Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
"
!
% $
&
!
"
!
#
%#
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!
!
$
#
!
%!
&&
&
%%
'!
&&
!
"
(
#
'
#
!
&&*
%
%
% (
!
&&)
%
((
(!
$
(
!
!
%
!
" $
!
%
%
!
$ %
!
(
-2-
%
!
%
%
(
!
!
(!
(
+ ,
!
(
-
%
!
(
(
(
'
!
!
./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 9: 3.2 123/3/452; 022</5= 64; 3.2
64774>/5= ;27/260
!
"
"
&
2>
$
3 /0 3.2 ?453253/45 46 123/3/452; 3.@3 .2 /0 @
;20/8253 46
@3
!
#
44;@.@77/
@8.@;0.
/77@=2
4745:
@7A<
/8@; @58 54> ;20/8/5=
/8@;
2 ?4532580 3.@3 3.2
;201458253 147/?2 .@B2 6@7027: /5B47B28 3.2 123/3/452; @0
@??A028 /5 ?;/C/5@7 ?@020 /5
;/C2
& && 46 (@55@
<.27/ !47/?2
!47/?2
3@3/45
3@3/45
;/C2
& &
@58./
A5D
/8@;
;/C2
& && 46
@58./
A5D
-3-
!47/?2
3@3/45
A582;
3.2
/8@; 12;3@/5/5= 34 ! 9233/5= @58 ?.@;=28
#@;5@3@<@
!47/?2
?3
E)
6A;3.2;
?45325828 3.@3 /5 1A;0A@5?2 46 92/5= ?.@;=28 A582; 3.2
@94B2 0@/8 1;4B/0/450
45 2B2;: 4??@0/45 46 3.2 ?;/?<23
C@3?. 4;
02;/20
!
4;
&
3.2 123/3/452; /0 92/5=
0ACC4528 @58 823@/528 /5 3.2 147/?2 03@3/45 3.;4A=.4A3
3.2 8@:
2 6A;3.2; ?4532580 3.@3 A582; 3.2 =@;9 46
/5B203/=@3/45
3.2 147/?2 466/?2;0 0ACC45 3.2 123/3/452;
@58 /6 .2 /0 A5@B@/7@972 3.2: >4A78 ?@77 3.2 C2C92;0 46
./0 6@C/7: @58 C@<2 3.2C 0/3 /5 3.2 147/?2 03@3/45
3.;4A=.4A3 3.2 8@: @58 @632; 2F3;@524A0 82C@580 @58
6A76/7C253 46 3.402 82C@580 ;272@02 ./C @58 723 ./C =4
./0 @??4;8/5= 34 3.2 123/3/452; /0 C/0A02 46 3.2 14>2;
A582; 7@> @58 3.2;264;2 .@B/5= 9225 0ACC4528 64; C4;2
3.@5
4??@0/450 /5 3.2 1;2B/4A0 3>4 :2@;0 3.2 123/3/452;
/0 /5B4</5= 3.2 >;/3 DA;/08/?3/45 46 3./0
4A;3 64; 3.2 ;27/260
C253/4528 @94B2
3 /0 ?45325828 6A;3.2; 9: 72@;528 ?4A5027 64;
3.2 123/3/452; 3.@3 3.2 ;201458253 @A3.4;/3/20 84 543 .@B2
-4-
@5: 14>2; 34 0ACC45 3.2 123/3/452; >/3.4A3 3.2;2 92/5=
@5: ?4C17@/53 4; 64774>/5= 8A2 1;4?28A;2 @0 ?4532C17@328
A582;
2?3/45
;!
1;202537:
A;@<0.@
@5./3@
2?3/45
.@;@3/:@
@=@;/<
.2;264;2
.2 ?4532580 3.@3 3.2 ;201458253 147/?2 @;2
C/0A0/5=
3.2
1;4B/0/450
!;4?28A;2
3.2
& &
"
&
;/C/5@7
@58 0ACC45/5= 3.2 123/3/452; @58 ./0
6@C/7: C2C92;0 >/3.4A3 3.2;2 92/5= @5: ?@02 ;2=/032;28
@=@/503 ./C @58 >/3.4A3 2B25 /5B4</5= 3.2 1;4B/0/450
A582;
2?3/45
;!
52/3.2;
1;48A?/5= @5: ?41: 54; 3.2;2 92/5= @5: ?4=253 ;2@045 64;
0ACC45/5= /5 B/47@3/45 46 3.2 6A58@C253@7 ;/=.30 46 3.2
4503/3A3/45 46 58/@ @58 ?@A0/5= 02B2;2 .@;@00C253 @58
A53478 .@;80./1 34 3.2 123/3/452;
.2 ?4A5027 6A;3.2; ?4532580 3.@3 3.2 ?@020
C253/4528
.2;2/5
@94B2
@0
@772=28
9:
;201458253 147/?2 .@B2 9225 03@:28 9: 3./0
;/C/5@7 !23/3/45
&
& &
40 &
)
B/82 4;82; 8@328
& &
3.2
4A;3 /5
&
* & &
@58
& &
.2;264;2 .2
-5-
?4532580 3.@3 3.2 ;2014582530 /5 ?72@; B/47@3/45 46 3.2
4503/3A3/45 46 58/@ @58 @=@/503 3.2 1;4B/0/450 A582; 3.2
;!
@;2 @?3/5= A145 3.2/; 4>5 >./C0 @58 6@5?/20
64; 3.2/; 4>5 92526/3 @58 @;2 A552?200@;/7: ?@77/5= 3.2
123/3/452; 34 3.2 147/?2 03@3/45 64; 2F3;@524A0 82C@580
@58 ?450/82;@3/450 >./?. /0 /772=@7 @58 3.2 0@C2 8202;B20
34 92 ?A;928 @58 ;203;@/528
5 3.202 =;4A580 .2 022<0
34 @774> 3.2 123/3/45
!2;
?453;@
72@;528
8B4?@32 ;21;20253/5= 3.2
88/3/45@7
4B2;5C253
3@32 ?4532580 3.@3 9@028 45
3.2 ?4C17@/53 @58 3.2 /564;C@3/45 ;2?2/B28 ?;/C/5@7 ?@020
@;2 ;2=/032;28 /5
& &&
;/C2
5 3.202 ?@020
& &&
& &
@58
3.2 147/?2 A145 /5GA/;: .@B2
02/H28 02B2;@7 /32C0 /5?7A8/5= C49/72 1.4520 @58 ?@0.
>.2;2 3.2 123/3/452; >@0 /5B47B28 /5 9233/5= 8A;/5= ?;/?<23
C@3?.20
!A;0A@53 34 0A?. 02/HA;2 @58 ;2?4B2;: 46 3.2
@C4A53 3.2 123/3/452; .@0 9225 ;272@028 /5 3.;22 ?@020
.2;264;2 @0 @58 >.25 3.2 ?;/?<23 C@3?.20 .@1125 3.2
123/3/452; =230 /5B47B28 /5 ?;/?<23 9233/5=
>./?. /0 @5
-6-
46625?2 @58 3.2 ;2014582530 @;2 @3 7/92;3: 34 /5/3/@32 @?3/45
@0 ?4532C17@328 A582; 3.2 #@;5@3@<@ !47/?2
?3
>./?.
3.2: @;2 84/5= /5 @??4;8@5?2 >/3. 7@>
)
3 /0 @704 ?45325828 9: 72@;528
4B2;5C253
1;4?28A;2
;!
88/3/45@7
8B4?@32 3.@3 >/3.4A3 /5B4</5= 3.2 8A2
@0
?4532C17@328
2?3/45
46 3.2
84/5= @5:3./5= /772=@7
A582;
2?3/45
3.2 ;2014582530 @;2 543
.2;264;2 .2 022<0 34 8/0C/00 3.2
123/3/45
*
@B/5= .2@;8 72@;528 ?4A5027 64; 943. 1@;3/20
3.2 14/53 3.@3 @;/020 64; ?450/82;@3/45 /0 I
.23.2; @5:
/532;62;25?2 /0 ?@7728 64; @3 3.2 .@580 46 3./0
4A;3 /5 3.2
1;20253 ?@02 45 .@58JK
11@;2537: /3 /0 0225 3.@3 3.2 123/3/452; @772=20
3.@3
.2
.@0
A552?200@;/7:
0ACC4528
9:
3.2
DA;/08/?3/45@7 147/?2 45 3.2 =;4A58 46 ./C 92/5= /5B47B28
/5 !
@58
?;/?<23 9233/5= @58 C@82 34 0/3 /5 @ 147/?2 03@3/45
/6
.2
/0
1;20253
./0
6@C/7:
C2C92;0
@;2
-7-
0ACC4528
;!
3 /0 52287200 34 C253/45 3.@3
?4;;201458/5=
2?3/45
@;;203 46 3.2 12;0450
2?3/45
46 3.2
82@70 >/3.
;2@80 @0
2?3/45
64774>0
%
&
'
&
&
( !
)
!
!
!
&
*
!
!
( !
&
!
+
!
!
*
+
*
&
&
,'
!
!
&
*
&
)
'
*
,
!
*
)
*
*
*
)
*
&
-
-8-
#
&
&
*
#
!
&
-
&
,
*
&
#
*
!'
&
-
)
!
!
*
( !
!
+
*
!
*
!
)
!
!
. *
)
!
!
!
!
!
*
)
!
+
&
&
&
)
!
!
/
!
&
!
!
)
!
!
&
*
&
-9-
!
+
&
*
!
&
&
&
!
* !
&
&
!
)
&
+
&
!
& !
* &
!'
!
12 )
&
&
#
*
#
!
*
&
!
!
!
!
#
!3
*
12&
'
!
+
+
( !
!
*
*
!
!
!
&
%
1 5
&
#
!'
!
&
!
!
!
*
+
( !
&
!
!
&
!
0 6
&
!
!
&
- 10 -
&
!
&
!
&
&
&
&
*
!
!3
!
&
!
!
!
-
:
!
! *
+
;
<
E
$
3 /0 @ 6A58@C253@7 ;A72 46 7@> 3.@3 3.2
;201458253 147/?2
/6 @3 @77
/532580 34 /5/3/@32 @?3/45
@=@/503 @5: ?/3/H25 46 3.2 ?4A53;: 3.2: >/77 .@B2 34 /5B4<2
3.2 52?200@;: 1;4B/0/450 A582; 3.2
!;4?28A;2
482 46
;/C/5@7
@58 3@<2 @?3/45 /5 @??4;8@5?2 >/3. 7@>
;@3.2; 3.@5 ?@77/5= @ 12;045 C@</5= ./C 0/3 64; 3.2 >.472
8@:
>/3.4A3 3.2;2 92/5= @5: @772=@3/45 4; C@32;/@7
/564;C@3/45 @=@/503 3.2 0@/8 12;045
- 11 -
5 3.2 1;20253 ?@02 45 .@58
3.4A=. 3.2
123/3/452; .@0 03@328 3.@3 .2 .@0 9225 A552?200@;/7:
0ACC4528 9: 3.2 DA;/08/?3/45@7 147/?2 2B25 @??4;8/5= 34
3.2 172@8/5=0 /3 /0 03@328 3.@3 .2 .@0 9225 /5B47B28 /5
?;/C20
.2;2/5@94B2
3.;22
4??@0/450
>/3.
3.;22
8/662;253 ?;/C2 5AC92;0 >.2;2 ?2;3@/5 @;3/?720 @58 ?@0.
>2;2 02/H28 @58 .2 /0 ;272@028
.2;264;2
3.2;2 >@0
?2;3@/5 C@32;/@7 >/3. 3.2 147/?2 34 0ACC45 3.2 123/3/452;
A3 52B2;3.27200 3.2 0@C2 >4A78 .@B2 34 92 9@028 45
?2;3@/5 C@32;/@70 @58 ?4=253 ;2@0450 @58 ;2=/032;/5= 3.2
%
4; @5: C@32;/@7 3.@3 /0 2F/03/5= @=@/503 3.2 123/3/452;
>./?. =/B20 3.2 14>2; 34 3.2 DA;/08/?3/45@7 147/?2 34
0ACC45 3.2 123/3/452; 64; /5GA/;: @58 82@7 /5 @??4;8@5?2
>/3. 7@>
>/3.4A3 84/5= 04
3.2 ;2014582530 ?@5543
A552?200@;/7: 0ACC45 3.2 123/3/452; @58 C@<2 ./C 0/3 /5
3.2 147/?2 03@3/45 /5 67@=;@53 B/47@3/45 46 3.2 1;4B/0/450 46
7@> @58 3.2 6A58@C253@7 ;/=.30 B20328 /5 3.2
4503/3A3/45
46 58/@ >./?. /0 /5 6@B4A; 46 3.2 123/3/452; 64; 6;2284C 46
6;22
C4B2C253
@58
7/92;3:
.2;264;2
/3
>4A78
- 12 -
52?200@;: 64; 3./0
4A;3 34 0.4> /58A7=25?2 /5 3.2 C@332;
6 3.2 ;201458253 147/?2 >2;2 34 0ACC45 3.2 123/3/452; 34
3.2 147/?2 03@3/45 64; /5GA/;: 4; @5: /5B203/=@3/45
3.2:
0.@77 6/;03 ?@A02 @ 543/?2 34 ./C 0.4> ?@A02 ;2@0450 @58
C@32;/@70 3.@3 @;2 @=@/503 ./C @58 /5B4<2 3.2 1;4B/0/450 46
2?3/45
;!
2?3/45
3.2
3.2
?4;;201458/5=
64774>
3.2
1;4B/0/45
1;4?28A;2
/5
@??4;8@5?2 >/3. 7@> @58 82@7 >/3. 3.2 0@C2 03;/?37: /5
?4C17/@5?2 >/3. 3.2 0@C2
3.@3
>/3.4A3
3 /0 @704 52287200 34 C253/45
64774>/5=
3.202
1;4B/0/450
3.2
;201458253 147/?2 0.@77 543 A552?200@;/7: 0ACC45 3.2
123/3/452; 4; ./0 ;27@3/B20 @58 C@<2 3.2C 0/3 /5 3.2 147/?2
03@3/45 >/3.4A3 64774>/5= 8A2 1;4?200 46 7@>
4;8/5@32
25?. 46 3./0
3.2 ?@02 46
'(
4A;3 /5
! " #
$
.2
$
/5
%
&
%
.@0 27@94;@327: 82@73 >/3. 3.202 1;4?28A;20
@58 =A/827/520 34 92 64774>28 >./72 0ACC45/5= @ 12;045
34 3.2 147/?2 03@3/45 64; /5GA/;: 4; /5B203/=@3/45
.2
=A/827/520 @58 3.2 1;4?28A;2 7@/8 84>5 /5 3.2 'A8=C253 46
- 13 -
3.2
44;8/5@32
25?. 46 3./0
4A;3 /5 3.2 @64;2C253/4528
82?/0/45 0.@77 92 03;/?37: 64774>28 9: 3.2 DA;/08/?3/45@7
147/?2 >./72 0ACC45/5= 3.2 123/3/452; 4; 0A?. 12;045 64;
/5B203/=@3/45 4; /5GA/;:
3 /0 52287200 34 C253/45 3.@3 3.2 123/3/452;
0.@77 92 12;C/3328 34 3@<2 @58 @??4C1@5: @745= >/3. ./C
@5: 12;045 92 /3 @5 7@>:2; 4; @ 545 7@>:2; /6 3.2 ;A720
@58
;2=A7@3/450
1;4B/82
64;
8A;/5=
/5GA/;:
4;
/5B203/=@3/45 4; /532;;4=@3/45
&
/
//
??4;8/5=7:
1@00 3.2 64774>/5=
./0 123/3/45 /0 &
>;/3
&
'
C@58@CA0
/0
/00A28
3.2
;201458253 @A3.4;/3/20 34 64774> 3.2 8A2 1;4?200 46 7@> @0
?4532C17@328 A582;
1;4B/0/45 46
2?3/45
2?3/45
46 3.2
;!
?4;;201458/5=
03;/?37: /5 3.2 72332;
@58 01/;/3 @58 64774> 3.2 52?200@;: =A/827/520 @58 8;/77
- 14 -
03/1A7@328 9:
4 4;8/5@32
! " #
$
25?. 46 3./0
%
4A;3 /5 3.2 ?@02
& "0A1;@$
'(
%
&
!
'
&
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review