Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:29171
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
Cri. Revision No. 1253 of 2024
Santosh Kumar @ Arjun, aged about 46 years, Son of Tilak Mochi, R/o
Flat No. A203, Arsh Apartment, Vikash Nagar Road No. 9, Singh More,
PO & PS Hatia, District Ranchi (Jharkhand)
…
…
Petitioner
Versus
The Central Bureau of Investigation
…
… Opp. Party
--CORAM: HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANUBHA RAWAT CHOUDHARY
--For the Petitioner
: Mr. Amit Kumar Das, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Saurav Kumar, Advocate
Ms. Muskan Jain, Advocate
For the Opp. Party-CBI
: Mr. Prashant Pallav, ASGI
--th
18/28 September 2026
1.
This Criminal Revision Application has been filed against the order
dated 11.09.2024 passed by the learned Special Judge, CBI-11 (Other than
ADHD Scam Cases), Ranchi in Misc. Criminal Application No.
1272/2024, whereby the application filed by the petitioner seeking
discharge has been rejected.
2.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the
discharge application of the petitioner has been mechanically rejected by
the learned court and the court has not considered the fact that there is
doubling while taking into consideration the asset/ expenditure of the
petitioner. The petitioner was working as Assistant Commandant in
Central Reserve Police Force and the check period involved in the present
case is for the period from 01.04.2013 to 21.12.2019.
3.
The learned senior counsel while referring to the charge-sheet has
submitted thatStatement-A is the assets at the beginning of check period, which
is amounting to Rs. 13,71,092.28 and there is no dispute so far as
this figure is concerned.
2026:JHHC:29171
Statement-B which is the assets at the end of check period, which
is to the tune of Rs. 75,45,820.07;
Statement-C is the income during the check period from which is
to the tune Rs. 1,15,07,360.00;
Statement -D is the expenditure during the check period which is
to the tune of Rs. 1,03,80,580.00.
4.
The learned senior counsel then refers to the computation of the
disproportionate assets which is as under:Sl.
No.
Amount (Rs.)
Assets at the beginning of Check
Period-A
13,71,092.00
Assets at the end of Check Period-B
75,45,820.00
Income during the Check Period - C
1,15,07,360.00
Expenditure during the Check Period D
1,03,80,580.00
Likely saving during the Check Period (Income Expenditure i.e. C-D)
11,26,780.00
Assets acquired during the check period
(B-A)
Disproportionate Assets = (B-A)-(C-D)
or (DA = 6-5)
61,74,728.00
DA Percentage = (B-A) -(C-D)/C X100
or (DA/Income x 100)
43.86%
5.
Description
50,47,948
He submits that as per Column-4 of the calculation of expenditure
during the check period has been shown as 1,03,80,580.00, which is lower
than the income during the check period mentioned in Column-3 and
therefore the amount available for expenses during the check period has
been shown as Rs. 11,26,780/-. The learned senior counsel submits that
the authority has calculated the assets acquired during the check period as
statement B-A i.e. 61,74,728.00 and this figure could not have been taken
2026:JHHC:29171
into consideration as the expenditure was already accounted for while
coming to the figure of Rs. 1,03,80,580.00.
6.
Further , in order to demonstrating the doubling of the various
figures, the learned senior counsel has referred to Serial No 6 of
Statement-C and submitted that a Car Loan (XUV 500) with specific
account number with SBI, Hatia Branch, Dhurwa, Ranchi was taken to the
extent of Rs. 10,00,000/- and the car loan was also shown to have been
closed. However, while recording the expenditure in Statement-D at Serial
No. 29, the authority has taken into account the repayment of the car loan
with respect to the XUV 500 to the extent of Rs. 11,10,500/- and there is
also another entry in Statement-D at Serial No. 30 relating to the purchase
of a Mahindra XUV 500 bearing Registration No. JH01 BX 6203 from
Nexgen Technology Solutions, which has been shown to the extent of Rs.
14,15,000/-. The learned senior counsel submits that, for the same XUV
car, the car loan has been shown, which has further been shown to have
been closed by repayment of the car loan and for the same XUV car,
another entry has been made to the extent of Rs. 14,15,000/-.
7.
The learned senior counsel submits that this has led to the
discrepancy, as the same car has been shown more than one time to inflate
the expenditure incurred by the petitioner.
8.
The learned senior counsel has further submitted that the inventory
with respect to kitchen items, bedroom items etc. has been taken in
Statement-B at serial No. 10 to the tune of Rs. 3,77,494.00 and those
items were not shown in the beginning of the check period as if the
petitioner did not have any household item. The learned senior counsel
submits that such entries, while calculating the assets, by itself reveal that
different items have been purposely included to inflate the expenditure.
The learned senior counsel submits that the most of the expenditure
mentioned in Statement-D has been paid either through credit card or
through bank transactions. The learned senior counsel submits that if the
2026:JHHC:29171
calculation is properly made, there would be no disproportionate assets
and the impugned order calls for interference.
9.
Learned senior counsel has relied upon the judgment passed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in (2022) 9 SCC 577 (Kanchan Kumar
vs. State of Bihar) and has referred to paragraph 16 onwards to submit
that the calculation made for the purposes of disproportionate asset can
certainly be looked into at the stage of discharge.
10.
The learned senior counsel has also relied upon the judgment
passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Cr. Appeal No. 5009 of 2024
(Nirankar Nath Pandy vs. State of U.P. & Others) and has referred to
paragraph 10 thereof to submit that while considering long check period
for about 25 years, it has been held that it must be taken into account that
over such a long period of time, there is inflation and a natural progression
in the changing economy that affects the value of assets such as property
and there is bound to be some discrepancy in connection with the
valuation of the assets.
11.
Learned senior counsel for the opposite party-CBI has opposed
the prayer and submitted that the calculation and the arguments, which
have been advanced by the learned senior counsel for the petitioner,
cannot be appreciated at this stage. There is no overlapping between the
calculations in Statement-B and Statement-D. They are distinct and both
the amounts are required to be taken into consideration for the purposes of
determining the acquisition of assets during the check period. The learned
senior counsel has further submitted that at this stage, there is no glaring
discrepancy in the calculation as projected by the opposite party and this
Court may not meticulously examine each and every item so as to come to
a finding at this stage. These are essentially matters for trial and are
required to be considered at the appropriate stage.
12.
The learned senior counsel for the opposite party-CBI has relied
upon the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in
(2023) 6 SCC 768 (State of Tamil Nadu vs. R. Soundirarasu Others) and
2026:JHHC:29171
has referred to paragraph 75, 81 and 83 thereof to submit that the court
need not act as a charted accountant to come to a different computation
and onus is reverse upon the petitioner to explain the assets which he has
required during the check period.
13.
With respect to the judgment, as relied upon by the learned senior
counsel for the petitioner, reported in (2022) 9 SCC 577 (supra), the
learned senior counsel has submitted that in the said case, there was
glaring discrepancy, inasmuch as, the balance amount during the
beginning of the check period was itself recorded incorrectly and therefore
on account of such glaring error, there could have been some interference,
but in the present case, no such glaring error pointed out.
14.
The learned senior counsel has also submitted that the petitioner has
not annexed the copy of the petition seeking discharge and the impugned
order does not reveal as to what points were taken, but in absence of the
petition seeking discharge, the arguments advanced by the learned senior
counsel for the petitioner cannot be taken into consideration at this stage.
15.
After hearing the learned counsel for the parties, it is not in
dispute that at the beginning of the check period, the petitioner had asset
to the extent of Rs. 13,71,092.28 and assets at the end of the check period
has been mentioned in Statement-B which deals with various investments
and assets made by the petitioner which is to the tune of Rs. 75,45,820.07.
16.
Apart from this, the income during the check period has been
shown as Rs. 1,15,07,360.00. However, during the course of hearing, the
learned senior counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the income
during the check period would actually come to Rs. One Crore Forty-Five
Lakh and Odd and the figure shown in the charge-sheet is not correct.
Further, the Statement-D deals with the expenditure during the check
period which deals with various purchases made by the petitioner and his
family members.
17.
So far as one of the discrepancies, which the petitioner has pointed
out, is in connection with purchase of Mahindra XUV 500 Car, which is
2026:JHHC:29171
shown to have been purchased by taking loan, as is apparent from Serial
No. 6 of Statement-C, which was to the extent of Rs. 10,00,000/- and the
loan account has been shown to have been closed. Further, at Serial No.
29 of Statement-D, the repayment of the car loan has been shown to the
extent of Rs. 11,10,500/-, and another entry has been made at Serial No.
30 of Statement-D in connection with the purchase of a Mahindra XUV
500 car to the extent of Rs. 14,15,000/- along with a specific car
registration number.
18.
This Court is of the view that at this stage, it cannot be said that the
entry at serial no. 6 of Statement-C and entry in serial no. 29 and 30 at
Statement-D are relating to one and the same vehicle. There is nothing on
record to demonstrate this aspect of the matter.
19.
Further, there is no material to show that the income during the
check period has been wrongly computed by the opposite party in the
charge sheet and this aspect of the matter is also essentially a matter of
evidence to be considered during trial.
20.
Further, this Court does not agree with the argument of the learned
senior counsel for the petitioner that the entire expenditure was to be
subsumed in the expenditure during the check period which is mentioned
in Statement -D, rather it appears that expenditure in Statement -D is over
and above acquisition of assets mentioned in Statement -B.
21.
Accordingly, this Court is of the view that the learned senior
counsel for the petitioner has not been able to demonstrate satisfactorily
before this Court regarding the doubling of the entries made. These
aspects of the matter can be appreciated at the stage of evidence during
trial. On account of the arguments of the petitioner, no case has been
made out to interfere with the impugned order refusing to discharge the
petitioner.
22.
Learned senior counsel for the opposite party has rightly pointed
out that at this stage, there is no scope for meticulous examination of each
2026:JHHC:29171
and every entry and it is for the petitioner to demonstrate his due source of
income for the assets which he has acquired during the check period.
23.
In aforesaid circumstances, this Court is not inclined to interfere
with the impugned order refusing to discharge the petitioner.
24.
Accordingly, this criminal revision application is hereby dismissed.
25.
However, any observation made by this Court in this order is
primarily based to deal with the arguments advanced by the learned senior
counsel for the petitioner and any observation made by this Court in this
order will not prejudice the case of either party in any manner whatsoever.
26.
Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
27.
Pending interlocutory application, if any, are closed.
28.
Let a copy of this order be communicated to the court concerned
through ‘e-mail/FAX’.
(Anubha Rawat Choudhary, J.)
Dated: 28.09.2026
Uploaded On: 30.09.2026
Mukul/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review