The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
9. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, and having considered the concurrent findings arrived at by the Courts below, on the 2024:MLHC:991 hard facts of the case which are contained at issues No. 9, 10, 11, 13, 14 and 15, it is seen that the findings of the Trial Court setting aside the mortgage created by the appellant’s mother and also the Deed of Declaration, have been arrived at after a thorough examination of the facts while keeping the principles of Khasi customary law in mind and does not need further discussion. The eviction as decreed also was based on the peculiar facts of the case itself, and as such, in the considered view of this Court, no general question of law has arisen therefrom that requires any adjudication. Further, the substantial questions as framed, not being on the basis of the pleadings and issues of the suit, this Court finds that there are no substantial questions of law to be decided in the instant Appeal, and the same is dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:991
Serial No.
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
SA No. 2 of 2022
Date of Decision: 11.11.2024
Smti. Santimai Muthliang Bhoi
D/o (L) Atilma Muthliang Bhoi
of Mawiong Mawlai, Shillong
East Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya
:::Appellant
-VsSmti. Judy Muthliang Bhoi
D/o(L) Alma Muthliang Bhoi
of Damsite, Umiam P.S,
Ri-Bhoi District, Meghalaya
:::Respondent
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. A.S. Siddiqui, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. A. Kharmyndai, Adv.
Mr. D. Hynniewta, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. K. S. Kharshiing, Adv.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
2024:MLHC:991
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The instant Second Appeal has been preferred against an order of the
Lower Appellate Court dated 30.06.2021, whereby judgment and decree
passed by the Learned Trial Court dated 03.11.2015, passed in Title Suit No.
3 of 2004, has been upheld. The brief facts are that the appellant’s
grandmother one (L) Anaperial Bhoi (Muthliang), had purchased the suit
property at Mawiong Umjapung, Shillong, which on her demise became the
subject matter of dispute between the appellant’s mother (L) Atilma
Muthliang Bhoi and her siblings namely (L) Alma Muthliang, Martilda
Muthliang and Manly Muthliang. A suit was instituted in 2004, by Smti.
Alma Muthliang, against the mother of the appellant and the same was
decreed by judgment and decree dated 03.11.2015, in favour of the
plaintiffs, wherein amongst 18 other issues, the Trial Court held that the
mother of the appellant was liable to be evicted from the suit property.
While the suit was pending, the Plaintiffs No. 1 and 2 expired, and during
this period the Trial Court by judgment and decree dated 03.11.2015,
decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiffs. Against the judgment decree, the
appellant who is the daughter of (L) Atilma Muthliang Bhoi, preferred an
Appeal before the Court of the Judge, District Council Court, which was
numbered as Title Civil Appeal No. 10 of 2015. During the course of the
2024:MLHC:991
said appeal, the present respondent i.e. daughter of Judy Muthliang Bhoi,
substituted herself in place of her late mother. The Lower Appellate Court
then upheld the Trial Court judgment and findings, and dismissed the
appeal. The decree was ultimately executed on 25 th April, 2022, and the
appellant was evicted from the said property.
2.
When the matter had come up for admission and on the submissions
of the learned counsel, the following substantial questions of law were
framed on the inputs received from the parties.
1) Whether under the Khasi customary law a sister of the youngest
daughter and her daughter is entitled to use and occupy the
ancestral property?
2) Whether under the Khasi customary law a sister and/or her
daughter who are in use and occupation of the ancestral property
and have no other property can be evicted by the youngest
daughter?
3) Whether the youngest daughter is a mere custodian and not the
absolute owner of the ancestral property?
4) Whether the youngest daughter is entitled for a decree of eviction
of the other sister/and or their daughter, specialty when they are in
occupation of the ancestral property and not the youngest
daughter?
2024:MLHC:991
5) Whether an un-codified Custom is a question of fact which
requires to be proved by cogent evidence?
6) If not codified, whether the concurrent findings of the Learned
Trail Court and that of the First Appellate Court below on the
questions of fact can be interfered with in the second appeal?
3.
Before adverting to the submissions made by the learned counsel, the
Court is to examine whether issues had been framed, which would have
covered the grounds as sought to be made out in the Appeal before the
Lower Appellate Court and the instant Appeal before this Court. The Trial
Court as seen from the records, had framed 18 issues, which are reproduced
herein below.
1. Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form?
2. Whether the plaintiffs has any cause of action to file the instant
suit?
3. Whether the plaintiffs has any locus standi to file the instant suit?
4. Whether the suit is barred by the principles of estoppel, waiver
and acquiescence?
5. Whether the suit is bad for mis-joinder and non-joinder of
necessary parties?
6. Whether the suit is properly valued and requisite court fee has
been paid?
7. Who are the children of (L) Ka Anaperial Muthliang Bhoi?
8. Whether (L) Ka Anaperial Muthliang Bhoi was the owner of a
plot of land situated at? What are its boundaries?
2024:MLHC:991
9. To whom did (L) Ka Anaperial Muthliang Bhoi has handed over
the original sale deed dated 21.04.1984 and patta deed dated
24.03.1980 relating to the suit property to look after and manage
the same? Whether the same was done with the knowledge and
consent of all her children?
10.When and where did (L) Ka Anaperial Muthliang Bhoi died?
Who took care of her during of her lifetime and who performed
her last rites and ceremonies?
11.Whether (L) Ka Anaperial Muthliang Bhoi had during her
lifetime given the suit property to (L) Ka Atilma Muthliang
Bhoi?
12.When and where did (L) Ka Atilma Bhoi died?
13.Whether (L) U Manly Muthliang Bhoi died a sudden death?
Who looked after him during his lifetime and who performed his
last rites and ceremonies?
14.Whether the Defendant can mortgage the suit property without the
knowledge and consent of all the children of (L) Ka Anaperial
Bhoi? If not, whether the same is liable to be cancelled?
15.Whether the deed of Declaration dated 31/07/2002 is liable to be
cancelled and declared as null and void?
16.Who is entitled to inherit the suit property according to Khasi
Custom?
17.Whether the defendant is liable to be evicted from the suit
property?
18.To what relief/reliefs are parties entitle to?
2024:MLHC:991
4.
From a perusal of the above-mentioned issues, it can be seen that
with regard to inheritance and eviction from the suit property on which the
substantial questions appear to emanate from, the same are contained in
issues No. 16 and 17 thereof. Accordingly, these two issues set against the
questions as framed will have to be examined as to whether any substantial
question of law has arisen. At this juncture it is to be noted that while
adjudicating second appeals, it is important to keep in mind that for a
question of law to be substantial, the same must be debatable, not
previously settled by law or precedent, and must have a bearing on a
decision of the case and on the rights of the parties. Further, to be a question
of law, a foundation for the same must exist in the pleadings and the
question should emerge from the findings of fact arrived at by the Courts
below, and that the same be necessary to be decided for a just and proper
adjudication.
5.
The instant appeal has been preferred from the concurrent findings of
the Courts below, wherein on the findings of fact, both the Courts below had
decided the matter in favour of the respondent, first, in issue No. 16,
whereby it is held that as per Khasi custom, ancestral property should be
inherited by the youngest daughter of the family and inheritance be only
from the line of the youngest daughter, the same to which has also been
admitted by the defendant No. 3(mother of the appellant) in her cross-
2024:MLHC:991
examination. Secondly, on issue No. 17, the Lower Appellate Court had
upheld the findings of the learned Trial Court and had also digested issues
No. 7, 8, 9, 11, 14, 15 and 16 in coming to the said findings, wherein the
Trial Court while deciding this issue had come to a finding that the suit
property was neither gifted or alienated to the defendant No. 3(mother of
the appellant), and further, the suit property was entitled to be inherited only
by the direct descendants of the original deceased owner, who was the
plaintiff.
6.
From an examination of the issues as framed by the Trial Court, and
the findings which have been rendered on appreciation of facts and
evidence, without revisiting the same, inasmuch as, the jurisdiction of this
Court being confined only to substantial questions of law, wherein findings
of fact are not open to challenge in the second appeal, this Court will now
proceed to address the arguments and grounds raised by the appellant in the
Second Appeal.
7.
Mr. A. S. Siddiqui, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. A.
Kharmyndai, learned counsel on behalf of the appellant has submitted that
under the Khasi customary law, a sister of the youngest daughter and her
daughter is entitled to use and occupy ancestral property, and that under the
Khasi customary law, a sister and/or her daughter who are in use and
occupation of the ancestral property cannot be evicted by the youngest
2024:MLHC:991
daughter. The learned Senior counsel has submitted that the learned Courts
had erred in not considering the fact that a sister of the youngest daughter is
not liable to be evicted from the ancestral property, and that the daughter or
grand-daughter of the owner of the property is entitled to peaceful
enjoyment of the property especially when she is in possession of the same,
and the youngest daughter is not.
8.
Mr. K. S. Kharshiing, learned counsel for the respondent has
submitted that Khasi customary law especially on inheritance is already
cemented and the laws of inheritance governing the same are very clear, as
ancestral property goes to, is in the custody of, or inherited by the youngest
daughter of the family, or womb, or clan and by custom occupies the
ancestral house, and that generally it is the maternal uncles or brothers or
senior members of the family or clan who manage such property or
properties on behalf of the ‘Ka khadduh’. He further submits that being the
‘khadduh’ she cannot transfer or alienate such property without the consent
of the members of the family. He therefore submits the Courts below having
arrived at a correct decision as per Khasi customary law, no question of law
had arisen to be decided.
9.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, and having
considered the concurrent findings arrived at by the Courts below, on the
2024:MLHC:991
hard facts of the case which are contained at issues No. 9, 10, 11, 13, 14 and
15, it is seen that the findings of the Trial Court setting aside the mortgage
created by the appellant’s mother and also the Deed of Declaration, have
been arrived at after a thorough examination of the facts while keeping the
principles of Khasi customary law in mind and does not need further
discussion. The eviction as decreed also was based on the peculiar facts of
the case itself, and as such, in the considered view of this Court, no general
question of law has arisen therefrom that requires any adjudication. Further,
the substantial questions as framed, not being on the basis of the pleadings
and issues of the suit, this Court finds that there are no substantial questions
of law to be decided in the instant Appeal, and the same is dismissed.
10.
Lower Court records to be transmitted back.
Judge
Meghalaya
11.11.2024
“D.Thabah-PS”
THABAH
Date: 2024.11.11 16:56:50 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review