The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. In the facts of the case, the order of permanent alimony monthly at Rs.12,000/- has not been seriously challenged by the appellant husband. Admittedly, the appellant husband is getting Rs. 45,000/a pension amount, against which, the wife respondent has no independent means for her livelihood and she is dependent on maintenance amount. Thus, considering the positive attitude of the appellant, giving consent in increasing the amount of permanent alimony to the extent of Rs.20,000/-, we are of the view that, the C/FA/1535/2015(GJHC240422462015) JUDGMENT DATED: 10/09/2026 amount of permanent alimony is required to be modified to the extent of Rs.20,000/- p.m. Thus, the appellant husband is directed to pay monthly permanent alimony of Rs.20,000/- from the date of this order instead of Rs.12,000/- p.m. The wife having a Saving Account with State Bank of India, Balasinor Branch (Account No. 30583903141). The appellant husband is directed to deposit the monthly alimony directly in the bank account of respondent wife. It is also agreed by the appellant that, the wife would be sole nominee in the service records and he will not change the said status and further assured that, despite of dissolution of marriage, the respondent wife will entitle for pensionary benefit and other retiral benefits.
13. For the reasons recorded, the appeal is partly allowed. The judgment and decree dated 07.07.2015, passed by the learned Family Court in Family Suit No. 878 of 2000, rejecting the prayer of divorce is hereby set aside. The marriage solemnized between the appellant and respondent wife dated 29.01.1989 is hereby dissolved by decree of divorce under Section 13(1)(ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act on the ground of desertion and so far as permanent alimony is concerned, the order of the Family Court granting Rs.12,000/- is modified and altered to the extent of Rs.20,000/- p.m. The appellant husband is directed to pay monthly Rs.20,000/- towards permanent alimony from the date of this order. The appellant husband shall directly give deposit monthly alimony in the saving account maintained by the wife with State Bank of India, Balasinor Branch (Account No. 30583903141). The C/FA/1535/2015(GJHC240422462015) JUDGMENT DATED: 10/09/2026 wife is entitled as a ‘nominee’ for retiral benefits including pension etc.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/FA/1535/2015(GJHC240422462015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 10/09/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 1535 of 2015
With
R/CROSS OBJECTION NO. 93 of 2015
In
R/FIRST APPEAL NO. 1535 of 2015
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
================================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
===============================================================
SANJIVKUMAR BHAGVATPRASAD INAMDAR (TRIVEDI)
Versus
JIGNABEN WIFE OF SANJIVKUMAR BHAGVATPRASAD
================================================================
Appearance:
MR CB DASTOOR(238) for the Appellant
MR HM PARIKH(574) for the Defendant
MR RASESH H PARIKH(3862) for the Defendant
===============================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
Date : 10/09/2026
COMMON ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA)
1.
The instant appeal under Section 19 of the Family Court Act,
1884, is directed against the judgment and decree dated 07.07.2015
passed by the Family Court, Ahmedabad in Family Suit No. 878 of
2000, whereby, the petition filed under Section 13(1)(ia)(ib) of the
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 for dissolution of marriage by decree of
C/FA/1535/2015(GJHC240422462015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 10/09/2026
divorce has been dismissed.
2.
The brief facts of the case need to be referred as under:
(1)
The appellant marriage of the husband with respondent wife
took place according to Hindu customary rights and ceremonies on
29.01.1989 at Ahmedabad. They lived together and blessed with 2
sons namely Vedant and Jay. The appellant husband did not want
the second child and on this issue, dispute arose between the
parties. It is the case of the appellant that, due to quarrelsome
nature of the respondent wife, the matrimonial dispute in a petty
issue arose and despite of so many attempts, she did not have
changed her conduct and attitude. It is further case of the appellant
that, on 03.08.1992, to attend the birthday of her brother, the wife
left the house and since then, she never returned back to the
matrimonial home to fulfill the marital obligation. Thus, after
period of 7 years from the date of leaving house by the wife, the
appellant husband instituted the suit for divorce mainly on the
ground that he was treated with cruelty by the wife and she
deserted his company for a continuous period of 2 years from the
date of filing of the suit.
(2)
The suit was contested by the respondent wife inter-alia
denying the averments of the plaint. The allegation of cruelty and
the ground of desertion being specifically denied by the wife and
further alleged that, the husband appellant was not interested to live
with her and she was compelled to live with her parental home
because of harassment caused to her by the appellant husband.
C/FA/1535/2015(GJHC240422462015)
(3)
JUDGMENT DATED: 10/09/2026
The Family Court, on the basis of pleading framed the issued
at Exh. 30. Before the Family Court, the appellant husband and the
respondent wife themselves stepped into witness box at Exhs. 28
and 43. The Family Court, after hearing the parties and upon
appreciation of the evidence, held and observed that, the wife was
not guilty for the breakdown of the marriage on the ground of
cruelty, as the husband has miserably failed to prove the ground of
cruelty alleged to have been caused by the wife upon him. On the
issue of desertion, the Family Court has observed that the husband
has not shown his ready and willingness to bring back the wife
with him at her maternal home and therefore, the ground of
desertion as alleged being not accepted by the Court and
accordingly vide judgment and decree dated 07.07.2015, the suit
for divorce came to be dismissed.
3.
The appellant husband being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the
judgment and order of the Family Court, has preferred the present
Appeal, inter-alia, stating that, the trial Court has materially erred
in not properly appreciating the evidence and failed to appreciate
that the wife has deserted the appellant husband without any reason
and since long, both the parties have not stayed together and
marriage seems to be broken down completely without any fault.
4.
We have heard learned counsels Mr. C.B. Dastoor and Mr. Rasesh
Parikh, for the respective parties.
C/FA/1535/2015(GJHC240422462015)
5.
JUDGMENT DATED: 10/09/2026
Mr. Dastoor, learned advocate, while assailing the impugned
judgment and order, mainly seeks divorce on the ground of
desertion. The marriage took place in the year 1989, the since
1992, the husband – wife have not stayed together, as a result, the
appellant had filed present suit for divorce in the year 1999 and
after establishment of Family Court, the suit came to be transferred
and re-numbered with the Family Court, Ahmedabad. In the first
round of litigation, the decree of divorce in favour of the appellant
husband came to be passed on 28.09.2007. The respondent wife
challenged the decree by filing First Appeal No. 3021 of 2008. In
the First Appeal, after hearing the parties, the matter was remanded
to the Family Court and directed to decide a suit fresh on its own
merits by permitting the parties to lead additional evidence.
Thereafter, after hearing the parties, the Family Court, vide its
judgment dated 07.07.2015 was pleased to dismiss the suit. Since
1992, the parties are not living together and having regard to the
conduct of the wife, she was not at all interested to live with the
husband and no attempt was made by her to resume cohabitation
and as such there is no reasonable cause for her to leave the house
of the husband and as such there is no evidence led by the wife on
this issue. Thus, the appellant husband succeeded in establishing
the ingredients of desertion.
6.
Mr. Dastoor, learned advocate upon instructions, states that the
appellant husband is ready and willing to increase the monthly
amount of permanent alimony to the extent of Rs.20,000/- p.m.. At
present, as per the direction of the Family Court, the husband is
C/FA/1535/2015(GJHC240422462015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 10/09/2026
paying monthly permanently alimony at Rs.12,000/-. Thus, having
regard to the duration of the separation and conduct of the wife, the
Family Court, ought to have passed a decree of dissolution of
marriage.
7.
On the other hand, Mr. Rasesh Parikh, learned advocate has fairly
admitted that, since 1992, the parties are not staying together and
having regard to the age of the both – husband and wife, he
contended that the court may consider plea of divorce subject to
revision of the amount of permanent alimony. He would further
urge that, the wife is living in religious institution and having
regard to the age of the parties, her name shall be nominated as a
‘nominee’ for the pension and other retiral benefits.
8.
We have heard learned counsel for the respective parties and
perused the records and proceedings along with the impugned
judgment.
9.
Having regard to the facts of the present case and evidence on
record, the issue falls for our consideration as whether the Family
Court was justified in rejecting the prayer for divorce on the
ground of ‘desertion’ under Section (13)(1)(ib) of the Hindu
Marriage Act ?
10.
We are conscious about the fact that, the suit for divorce was
originally filed on two grounds i.e. cruelty and desertion. It is fairly
conceded by the counsel appearing for the appellant that the
ground of cruelty is not established and therefor, only on the
C/FA/1535/2015(GJHC240422462015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 10/09/2026
ground of desertion, he is seeking a relief for dissolution of
marriage. In the facts of the present cased, since 1992, the parties
are living separately. Upon careful examination of the oral
evidence of the parties, it appears that the decision of the
separation on the part of the wife was without any reasonable cause
and therefore, there has been no resumption of matrimonial
cohabitation for approximately 40 years and more. The age of the
appellant husband is about 67 yrs and wife is running about 65 yrs.
The reasons offered by the wife for living separately are not
satisfactory to hold that due to the atmosphere created by the
husband appellant she has reason to refuse to live with the
husband. In such circumstances, we are of the view that the
findings recorded by the Family Court, that the appellant failed to
establish desertion is not born out from the evidence on record and
has committed an error while coming to conclusion that the ground
of desertion has not been established.
11.
Consequently, the appellant has established the ground of desertion
and is entitled to decree of dissolution of marriage.
12.
In the facts of the case, the order of permanent alimony monthly at
Rs.12,000/- has not been seriously challenged by the appellant
husband. Admittedly, the appellant husband is getting Rs. 45,000/a pension amount, against which, the wife respondent has no
independent means for her livelihood and she is dependent on
maintenance amount. Thus, considering the positive attitude of the
appellant, giving consent in increasing the amount of permanent
alimony to the extent of Rs.20,000/-, we are of the view that, the
C/FA/1535/2015(GJHC240422462015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 10/09/2026
amount of permanent alimony is required to be modified to the
extent of Rs.20,000/- p.m. Thus, the appellant husband is directed
to pay monthly permanent alimony of Rs.20,000/- from the date of
this order instead of Rs.12,000/- p.m. The wife having a Saving
Account with State Bank of India, Balasinor Branch (Account No.
30583903141). The appellant husband is directed to deposit the
monthly alimony directly in the bank account of respondent wife.
It is also agreed by the appellant that, the wife would be sole
nominee in the service records and he will not change the said
status and further assured that, despite of dissolution of marriage,
the respondent wife will entitle for pensionary benefit and other
retiral benefits.
13.
For the reasons recorded, the appeal is partly allowed. The
judgment and decree dated 07.07.2015, passed by the learned
Family Court in Family Suit No. 878 of 2000, rejecting the prayer
of divorce is hereby set aside. The marriage solemnized between
the appellant and respondent wife dated 29.01.1989 is hereby
dissolved by decree of divorce under Section 13(1)(ib) of the
Hindu Marriage Act on the ground of desertion and so far as
permanent alimony is concerned, the order of the Family Court
granting Rs.12,000/- is modified and altered to the extent of
Rs.20,000/- p.m. The appellant husband is directed to pay monthly
Rs.20,000/- towards permanent alimony from the date of this
order. The appellant husband shall directly give deposit monthly
alimony in the saving account maintained by the wife with State
Bank of India, Balasinor Branch (Account No. 30583903141). The
C/FA/1535/2015(GJHC240422462015)
JUDGMENT DATED: 10/09/2026
wife is entitled as a ‘nominee’ for retiral benefits including pension
etc.
14.
Accordingly, the Cross Objection No. 93 of 2015 is partly allowed.
15.
There shall be no order as to costs. Registry is directed to transmit
the records and proceedings, if any, to the trial Court.
(ILESH J. VORA,J)
(R. T. VACHHANI, J)
P.S. JOSHI
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review