Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 9th April, 2026
Pronounced on: 10th June, 2026
+
RSA No. 184/2024 & CM APPL. 62781/2024 (stay)
SANJEEV TIWARI
S/o Late Sh. P.R.Tiwari
R/o 201/A-3, Railway Quarters,
Basant Lane, Paharganj,
New Delhi.
Through:
......Appellant
Counsel for Appellant (appearance
not given)
versus
VIJAY KUMAR TIWARI
S/o Late Sh. Pyare Lal Tiwari
R/o 413, City Cooperative Housing Society Ltd.,
Sector-55, Gurugram, Haryana.
....Respondent
Through: None
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as „CPC‟) has been filed on behalf
of the Appellant against the Judgment dated 01.08.2024 whereby the learned
District Judge has upheld vide Order dated 19.04.2022 of the learned Civil
Judge, who has decreed the Suit of the Plaintiff/Respondent in the sum of
Rs.2,20,000/- along with the interest @ 8% p.a. on the sum of Rs.2,00,000/-,
from the date of filing of the Suit till the date of decree.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
15:39:36
RSA No. 184/2024
2.
The Civil Suit bearing CS No. 93596/2016 was filed by the
Plaintiff/Respondent, for Recovery of the loan of Rs.2,00,000/- along with
the interest.
3.
The facts in brief, the case of the Plaintiff is that he was carrying on
business as the sole proprietor of M/s Western Wear Inc. In May 2009, at
the request of the Defendant/Appellant, the Plaintiff advanced a friendly
loan of Rs.2,00,000/- to him through two cheques of Rs.1,00,000/- each
dated 04.05.2009 and 06.05.2009 respectively. The said cheques were duly
encashed by the Defendant on 22.05.2009. It was agreed between the parties
that the loan amount would be repaid within six months. However, despite
the expiry of the agreed period, repeated demands, and service of a legal
notice dated 21.02.2011, the Defendant failed to repay the loan amount.
Consequently, the Plaintiff instituted the present suit seeking recovery of
Rs.2,00,000/- along with interest.
4.
In the Written Statement, the Defendant contended that the Plaintiff
harboured a grudge against him. It was averred that the Defendant’s father,
Mr. Prithi Raj Tiwari, had instituted litigation concerning Property No.
4366, Near Vidya Mandir Wali Gali, Arya Samaj Chowk, Bhatinda, Punjab,
and had borne the entire litigation expenses, amounting to approximately
Rs.10,00,000/-. Upon the culmination of the proceedings, Mr. Prithi Raj
Tiwari distributed the respective shares of the legal heirs in the said
property. It was specifically pleaded that the Plaintiff, Mr. Vijay Kumar
Tiwari, being one of the legal heirs, received his share in the property on
06.10.2006. Likewise, the shares of Mr. Inderjeet Tiwari and the other legal
heirs were also disbursed on the same date.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
15:39:36
RSA No. 184/2024
5.
The Defendant further pleaded that his father, Mr. Prithi Raj Tiwari,
passed away on 10.03.2007. It was averred that during the lifetime of the
Defendant’s father, the Plaintiff had undertaken and assured that he would
contribute towards and reimburse his share of the litigation expenses, which
allegedly amounted to Rs.5,02,000/-. According to the Defendant, the two
cheques aggregating to Rs.2,00,000/- relied upon by the Plaintiff were not
issued as a loan but were issued in partial discharge of the Plaintiff’s liability
towards the said litigation expenses. It was further asserted that the Plaintiff
had also issued a cheque for Rs.63,300/- dated 25.05.2008 from his bank
account towards the said liability, and the amount was paid to Mr. Rohit
Tiwari at Mumbai. On the basis of these averments, the Defendant
contended that even after the aforesaid payments, a substantial amount
remained due and payable by the Plaintiff. The Defendant, therefore,
specifically denied that the sum of Rs.2,00,000/- constituted a loan advanced
by the Plaintiff.
6.
The Plaintiff in the Replication, denied the averments made in the
Written Statement and reiterated his assertions made in the Plaint.
7.
Issues on the pleadings were framed on 24.03.2012, which are as
under:(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
Whether the Plaintiff has no locus standi to file the
present suit? OPP
Whether the suit of the Plaintiff is without cause of
action? OPD
Whether the suit valued property for the purpose of
court fee and proper fee has been affixed thereof? OPP
Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to the suit amount?
OPP
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
15:39:36
RSA No. 184/2024
(v)
(vi)
8.
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to interest on the
amount claimed? OPP
Relief.
The Plaintiff, Mr. Vijay Kumar Tiwari as PW1 deposed in support of
his case.
9.
PW-2 Mr. Kanwal Krishan Garg deposed on similar lines as the
Plaintiff.
10.
PW-3 Mr. Prashant Tyagi, CCM, Kotak Mahindra Bank, West Patel
Nagar, New Delhi, brought the record pertaining to the Account of M/s
Western Wear In. Pertaining to the two cheques given to the Defendant. The
Statement of Account was Ex.PW-1/1 and the Certificate issued by the Bank
was Ex.PW-1/2.
11.
The Defendant, Mr. Sanjeev Tiwari as DW1 examined himself in
support of his case.
12.
DW-2, Mr. Manoj Kumar deposed on similar lines as the Defendant.
13.
The learned Civil Judge on appreciation of the evidence, found that
the two cheques of Rs.2,00,000/- were given to the Defendant by the
Plaintiff, which were duly encashed by him. This was proved not only by the
Statement of Account of the Plaintiff Firm, but was also admitted by the
Defendant.
14.
Furthermore, the Plaintiff had proved his ITR Verification Form for
the year 2010-2011, Ex.PW-1/D1 (colly) to which the Balance Sheet was
appended, wherein the entry of loan amounting to Rs.2,00,000/- advanced to
the Defendant, was clearly reflected in the Assets.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
15:39:36
RSA No. 184/2024
15.
Moreover, the Defendant in his cross-examination dated 29.01.2020
also admitted receiving the Cheque of sum of Rs.1,00,000/- each in his Bank
Account from the Plaintiff. The defence of the Defendant that the father of
the Defendant had undertaken litigation in respect of family property in
which he had incurred litigation expenses and the Plaintiff was to pay his
share of Rs.5,20,000/- and the amount of Rs.2,00,000/- towards the payment
of the said dues was held to be not proved and thus, the Suit of the Plaintiff
for Rs.2,20,000/- along with interest @ 8% per annum on the principal
amount of Rs.2,00,000/- till the date of decree was allowed.
16.
The Defendant Vijay Kumar Tiwari aggrieved by the said
Judgment filed RCA No.79/2022 before the learned District Judge who in
her Judgment dated 01.04.2024 found that the facts and the evidence had
been rightly appreciated by the learned District Judge and did not find any
illegality in the Judgment dated 19.04.2022. The Appeal was accordingly
dismissed.
17.
The present Regular Second Appeal has been filed by Defendant
Sanjeev Kumar Tiwari against the Judgment of the learned District Judge
dated 01.08.2024.
18.
The Substantial Question of Law posed by the Appellant are as
under:
“(i.)
Whether the First Appellate Court erred in law
by not adjudicating upon the application filed by the
appellant under order 41 rule 27 of CPC for bringing on
record certain documents without which the said appeal
could not be decided properly?
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
15:39:36
RSA No. 184/2024
(ii) Whether the Ld. Trial Court has erred in law under
bona fide mistake of closing the evidence of remaining
witnesses of the Appellant after examining DW2 because the
evidence of DW3 and DW4 were essential for proving the
fact that the payment of Rs. 02 lacs were not loan but
payment towards legal expenses and sale proceeds of
Bhatinda property sold by Respondent?
(iii) Whether the Ld. Trial Court and First Appellate Court
also erred in law in shifting the onus of proof regarding
issue no. 4 and 5 from OPP to OPD”
19.
The grounds of Appeal are that it was not appreciated that the
Appellant was a Government Officer in the pay scale of Rs. 9300-34800
with a Grade Pay of Rs.4600/- and had about Rs.5 lakhs in his PF Account.
He was a member of Northern Zonal Railway Employee Credit and Thrift
Society and could have easily got loan at cheaper rates from PF
Account/Society.
20.
The defence of the Appellant that Late Sh. Prithvi Raj Tiwari had
incurred litigation expenses in respect of ancestral property which the
Respondent/Plaintiff was not willing to share which led to strained
relationship between them. There was no probability of the Appellant taking
any loan from the Respondent.
21.
The onus for Issue No.4 and 5 was wrongly shifted to the Appellant
since the Respondent/Plaintiff failed to prove that he had advanced a
friendly loan of Rs.2 lakhs and that the said amount was not towards the
reimbursement of the litigation expenses. The evidence of the Appellant
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
15:39:36
RSA No. 184/2024
was closed under a bona fide mistake by the learned Trial Court after DW1
and DW2 out of five witnesses relied upon by the Appellant were examined.
These three witnesses were vital to prove that the alleged amount was given
on account of sale proceeds and litigations expenses for the ancestral
property at Bhatinda. DW3 and 4 were essential witnesses.
It was,
therefore, stated that the impugned Judgment be set aside.
22.
The Respondent in his response had reiterated that the friendly loan of
Rs.2 lakhs along with interest @ 10% per annum had been duly given to the
Appellant. It was further explained that the entire expenses in regard to the
litigation and settlement of property at Bhatinda was borne by the Plaintiff
Vijay Kumar Tiwari and the Appellant’s father did not spent even a single
penny in this transaction. PW2 Kanwal Krishan Garg who was the counsel
in the disputed property of Bhatinda had clearly stated that he had taken
Rs.25,000/- for contesting the Suit and that the entire amount was paid by
the Plaintiff.
23.
It was further contended that all the litigation therein, had no
relevance with the Suit amount claimed by the Plaintiff in the Recovery Suit.
The Appellant was unnecessarily confusing the loan transaction by claiming
that it was the amount returned towards the litigation expenses. It is stated
that the Suit was filed in the year 2002 in respect of Bhatinda property and
almost all litigation expenses were paid, except the Counsel’s fee and the
final Settlement was arrived at on 21.05.2005.
subsequently in the month of May, 2009.
The loan was taken
Therefore, by no stretch of
imagination can it be termed as partial return of the litigation expenses.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
15:39:36
RSA No. 184/2024
24.
The Plaintiff had also given a sum of Rs.50,000/- through cheque in
November, 2006 to the father of the Appellant which was returned through
the cheque by the mother of the Appellant in the year 2008. Therefore, if
any adjustment was to be made, it would have been done at that time. It was
denied that the due opportunity had not been given to the Defendant to
examine his three witnesses. The onus of Issue No.4 and 5 had also been
decided correctly. It was further submitted that the Appellant had not locus
to file the Application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC at a belated stage.
25.
It was further stated that all the proposed issues by the Appellant were
challenged to the facts and was not tenable. It was thus submitted that the
Appeal was without any merit and was liable to be dismissed.
Submissions heard and record perused.
26.
The case of the Plaintiff was that a loan of Rs.2 lakhs had been given
to the Appellant/Defendant in May, 2009 as an interest free loan keeping the
relationship of the parties. The two cheques of Rs.1 lakh each dated
04.05.2009 and 20.5.2009 were duly handed over to the Defendant who
encashed the same. The money was utilized by the Defendant/Appellant for
business purposes, as he was carrying on the business of a catering club in
partnership with one Mr. Manoj, as the Defendant was the Govt. employee.
The Defendant had admitted receiving this Rs.2 lakhs in his Account. This is
further corroborated by the independent evidence by way of ITR
Verification Form for the year 2010-11 Ex.PW1/D1. In the Balance Sheet
appended to the ITR Verification Form, the entry of the loan amount of Rs.2
lakhs as advanced to the Defendant has been clearly reflected in the Assets.
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
15:39:36
RSA No. 184/2024
The Plaintiff had been cross-examined at length, but his testimony could not
be shaken.
27.
His only defence was that this was towards reimbursement of
Rs.5,02,000/- which was the litigation expenses to be borne by the Plaintiff.
To support his averment, the Appellant had relied upon family Settlement
Ex.PW1/2 which allegedly had the signatures of the Plaintiff at point A as
well as Sale Deed of the property Ex.DW1/1.
28.
However, as was observed by the learned Civil Judge, the Defendant
had failed to furnish any particulars of the legal proceedings in respect of
which the said amount was allegedly due. The alleged Family Settlement
was dated 21.05.2008 was made between Smt. Ranjana, Smt. Raj Rai
Tiwari, the Plaintiff and the successors of Late Sh. Bal Kishan Tiwari
Ex.DW1/1, wherein it was reflected that litigation expenses of Rs.10 lakhs
were incurred and also mentioned about the distribution of shares. The
learned Civil Judge noted that the defence taken by the Defendant was
mutually contradicted and was not corroborated by the evidence produced
by the Defendant.
Firstly, the Family Settlement dated 21.05.2008
Ex.DW1/1 in fact was a Sale Deed between legal heirs of Late Pyare Lal
Tiwari and Sh. Harjeet Singh in regard to the shop forming part of property
No.4366, Vidya Mandir Gali, Arya Samaj Chowk, Bhatinda (Punjab) and
was not a family settlement. Secondly, the breakup of litigation expenses
qua property bearing No.4366, Arya Samaj Chowk, Bhatinda (Punjab) was
provided in the Sale Deed Ex.DW1/1, but it was not in regard to the
residential property but in respect of one shop in the said property. Thirdly,
it was claimed that the father of Defendant had paid all the litigation
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
15:39:36
RSA No. 184/2024
expenses but bare perusal of Ex.DW1/1 reflected that the father of the
Appellant was not a party to the document. In fact, the father of Defendant
had died on 10.03.2007, as per the written statement, while the Sale Deed
was executed on 21.05.2008. Furthermore, Ex.DW1/1 clearly stated that all
kinds of expenses regarding the registration of Sale Deed was paid by the
buyers. The Defendant was, therefore, unable to establish that the amount of
Rs.2 lakhs was towards the share of litigation expenses.
29.
Further in Ex.DW1/5, there is not a whisper about Rs.10 lakhs being
the legal expenses. In fact, all the legal heirs of Late Sh. Pyare Lal Tiwari
including the Plaintiff and the mother of the Defendant collectively received
Rs.14 lakhs as the consideration amount.
30.
The Defendant also referred to Family Settlement dated 19.08.1996
Ex.PW1/D2 which, however, also remained unproved. The learned Civil
Judge observed that firstly the Family Settlement was only to the effect that
Party 1 and Party 2 had already cancelled their General Power of Attorney
executed in favour of Party 3 and it was mutually agreed to dispose of the
Bhatinda property and distribute the sale consideration amongst themselves
to the extent of their respective share. It did not mention anything about the
litigation expenses or that the Plaintiff had to pay Rs.5,02,000/- as his share
of litigation.
31.
Moreover, the Family Settlement was dated 19.08.1986, whereas in
the Written Statement it was stated that the shares were disbursed by Late
father of Defendant in 2006 to Inderjeet Tiwari and others.
The
Defendant/Appellant was thus, unable to show the relevant date of the trial
or when the said litigation charges became due and outstanding. There were
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
15:39:36
RSA No. 184/2024
no other documents placed on record by the Appellant. The testimony of
DW2 Sh. Manoj Kumar who had supported the testimony of Defendant also
could not work in his favour. This witness admitted that he used to work as
a Caterer in Railway Officer’s Club in 2011. Moreover, he was not able to
give the details about where he was called by the Plaintiff several times or
Defendant was also taken on conference.
32.
Most importantly, DW2 stated that there was no loan liability between
the parties as no amount was given or received in his presence.
This
reflected that DW2 was not a competent witness to prove or disprove the
loan of Rs.2 lakhs as no such transaction had transpired in his presence.
33.
In the end it is pertinent to refer to the testimony of PW2 Kanwal
Krishan Garg, the Counsel who had represented Late Prithvi Raj Tiwari
father of Defendant as well as Vijay Tiwari in the litigation. This witness
duly proved his Bar Council Identity Card Ex.PW2/D1. No suggestion was
put to him that he was not the counsel of Late Shri Prithvi Raj Tiwari and
the Plaintiff in the proceedings. Furthermore, this witness explained that his
professional fee was Rs.20,000/- which was paid entirely by the Plaintiff.
He also stated that the entire litigation expenses in the Trial Court as well as
the Appellate Court did not exceed Rs.15,000/- in all. This PW2 withstood
to the test of cross-examination and his testimony was not shaken.
34.
Learned Civil Judge also noted that during the final arguments before
the learned Civil Judge, it was argued that the Plaintiff had deposited the
said cheques in the account of the Defendant in his own volition to set off
the claim due against the Plaintiff to claim that no loan was taken by the
Appellant. However, in paragraph 4 of the Written Statement the Defendant
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
15:39:36
RSA No. 184/2024
had mentioned that the cheques had been issued by the Plaintiff and were
encashed by the Defendant which again reflects that the cheques had not
been deposited by the Plaintiff but by the Defendant/Appellant himself in his
Account.
35.
The Appellant had contended that he had moved an Application under
Order 41 Rule 27 CPC for examination of his three witnesses, who
inadvertently could not be examined by him before the learned Trial Court.
However, when the Defendant/Appellant himself had chosen not to examine
the three witnesses and had closed his evidence after recording the testimony
of himself and DW2, he cannot now claim any inadvertence. Clearly, it is an
attempt by the Appellant to fill the lacunae in the evidence. As already
discussed above, the Plaintiff through cogent evidence has established his
case for recovery of Rs.2 lakhs given by him as loan. There is no merit in
this contention of the Appellant seeking an opportunity for examining
additional evidence which in fact is only to fill in the lacunae in the
evidence.
36.
From the aforesaid appreciation of evidence by the learned Civil
Judge and its re-appreciation by the learned District Judge in appeal, it is
evident that both Courts concluded that the amount in question was a loan
taken by the Appellant which he failed to repay.
37.
Both the Courts have cogently appreciated the facts to arrive at the
conclusion to decree the Suit.
38.
Though the Appellant has sought to project certain substantial
questions of law, the grounds urged are purely factual in nature and do not
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
15:39:36
RSA No. 184/2024
give rise to any substantial question of law. Henceforth, there is no
substantial Question of Law raised in the present Second Appeal.
39.
The Appeal is without merit and is hereby, dismissed and
disposed of accordingly. The pending Application(s), also stands
disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JUNE 10, 2026
RS/VA
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
15:39:36
RSA No. 184/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review