Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on:12thMarch, 2026
Pronounced on: 09th July, 2026
+
RFA 21/2020, CM APPL.1198/2020
SH. SANJEEV KUMAR CHADHA
S/o Sh. Pishori Lai Chadha
R/o H.No. 160 (Old No. 17-A),
Old Gupta Colony,
Delhi – 110009
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Kshitiz Sharda, Advocate.
versus
1. ANIL KUMAR CHADHA
S/o Sh. Pishori Lai Chadha,
R/o 677, Bhai Premanand
Colony (West),
Delhi-110009
..Respondent No. 1
2. SH. RAMAN CHADHA
S/o Sh. Pishori Lai Chadha,
165-C, Pocket-B,
Mayur Vihar, Phase-II,
Delhi-110091
..Respondent No. 2
3. MS. SUNILA ANAND
W/o Sh. Suresh Anand,
R/o 301, Riddhi Tower,
Riddhi Garden, Film City Road
Malad (East)
Mumbai-400097
Maharashtra
..Respondent No. 3
4. MS. RATNA CHADHA
D/o Pishori Lai Chadha,
R/o H.No. 160 (Old No. 17-A),
Old Gupta Colony,
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
Delhi – 110009
..Respondent No. 4
5. SMT. RENU KANSAL
W/o Sh. Rajeev Kansal,
R/o 3/25, Roop Nagar,
Delhi
..Respondent No. 5
6. SMT. SHAKUNTALA RANI
W/o Sh. Kishan Gopal
R/o 3/25, Roop Nagar,
Delhi
..Respondent No.6
7. SMT. SHARDA DEVI
W/o Sh. Chetan Parkash Garg,
R/o 2, Gyan Lok Hapur,
Distt. Ghaziabad, (UP)
..Respondent No. 7
8. SMT. BABITA GARG
W/o Sh. Krishan Kumar Garg,
R/o 2, Gyan Lok Hapur,
Distt. Ghaziabad, (UP)
..Respondent No. 8
Through:
Mr. Ajay Jain, Mr. Krishna
Sharma,Mr. MN Mishra, Mr.
ManojGautam and Mr. Kashish
Gupta, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J
U D G M E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The present Regular First Appeal under Section 96 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as „CPC‟)read with Order
XLI CPC has been filed against the Judgment and Decree dated
09.09.2019passed by the Learned Additional District Judge-03,
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
Delhi,whereby the Suit of the Plaintiff/Appellant Sanjeev Kumar Chadha
has been dismissed.
2.
The Plaintiff/Appellant had instituted a Civil Suit bearing CS No.
59655/2016 (Old CS No.95/2008) seeking Declaration and Cancellation of
the two registered Sale Deeds dated 23.10.2007 executed by Defendant
No.1 in favour of Defendant Nos. 5 to 8, in respect of property bearing
Municipal No.160 (Old No.17-A), Old Gupta Colony, Delhi-110009,
(hereinafter referred to as suit property), as null and void.He had also
sought Permanent Injunction to restrain the Defendants from creating any
third-party interest in, transferring, alienating or otherwise dealing with the
suit property on the basis of the impugned Sale Deeds, also sought Damages
and mesne profits.
3.
The brief facts of the case are that the suit property originally
belonged to Late Shri Pishori Lal Chadha. Upon his demise, the suit
property devolved upon his legal heirs, namely the Plaintiff/Appellant,
Respondent No.1 Anil Kumar Chadha, Respondent Nos.2,3 and 4.
Admittedly, the case of the parties is that a registered Relinquishment
Deed dated 24.04.2003was executed by the Appellant, Mr Sanjeev Kumar
Chadha, brother on his behalf, as well as, on behalf of his sister Ms Sunila
Anand, Defendant No. 3 as her Power of Attorney and brother Sh. Raman
Chadha, Defendant No. 2, in favour of the Defendant No. 1, Sh. Anil
Kumar Chadha, brother and released their shares in his favour.
4.
Thereafter, Respondent No.1 Anil Kumar Chadha claimed exclusive
ownership over the suit property by virtue of the aforesaid Relinquishment
Deed, executedtwo registered Sale Deeds dated 23.10.2007 in favour of
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
Respondent Nos.5 to 8; one Sale Deed pertained to the ground floor and the
other pertained to the first-floor of the suit property.
5.
The Plaintiff asserted that the Relinquishment Deed was executed on
the assurance of Respondent No.1 that the Plaintiff/Appellant would receive
his legitimate share in the value of the suit property. However, Respondent
No.1, without honouring the said understanding, executed the impugned
Sale Deeds in favour of Respondent Nos.5 to 8.
6.
The Plaintiff claimed that the Defendants were liable to pay damages
and Mesne Profits of the Property for their illegal and unlawful occupation
since 25.04.2003 @Rs.5,000/- per month besides other charges from the
date of filing of the Suit, till the possession was handed over to the Plaintiff.
7.
It was further contended that the impugned Sale Deeds were collusive
transactions between Respondent No.1 and the purchasers, Defendant No.5
to 8, to deprive the Appellant of his lawful share. The Appellant also
asserted that the transactions were sham and not supported by valid
consideration, and questioned the genuineness as allegedly, no sale
consideration was paid by the purchasers.
8.
The Plaintiff served the Defendant No. 1 with a Legal Notice dated
01.04.2004, for vacating the Property and also claiming Rs.5,000/- per
month as Mesne Profits/Damages, despite which they failed to vacate the
Property. Hence, the Plaintiff/Appellant instituted the present Suit seeking a
decree of Declaration andCancellation of the said Sale Deeds dated
23.10.2007 as null and void and consequential relief of Permanent
Injunction.
9.
The Respondent No. 1, Sh. Anil Kumar Chadha in his Written
Statement, took the preliminary objection that the Sale Deed is duly and
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
properly registered and executed under Sections 17 and 58A of the
Registration Act and the Plaintiff was precluded from contradicting, varying,
adding, subtracting the terms and contracts of the Sale Deed, as per Section
91 and 92 of the Indian Evidence Act. The recitals of the Sale Deed
mentioned that the consideration had been given by the Defendants to the
Plaintiff in the manner set out in the contents of the Deed. The alleged
assertions made by the Plaintiff were false, frivolous and cooked up and
were not substantiated by any document.
10.
It is an admitted case that the Sale Deed was executed and registered,
in accordance with law, and the oral evidence in contradiction thereof is not
admissible. The Sale Deed had been executed in accordance with Section 54
of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 and cannot be declared as void or
setaside. The Plaintiff is estopped by his own conduct in contradicting the
terms of the Sale Deed under Section 115 of the Indian Evidence Act. He is
also bound by the Sale Deed.
11.
The Suit is also barred under Section 41(h) of the Specific Relief Act,
1963 as the alternate remedy is available to the Plaintiff, to seek the
recovery of money. The Plaintiff has further asserted that the market value
of the Suit Property is not less than Rs.16,00,000/- but the court fee has not
been paid on the said amount. The Plaintiff is seeking declaration and
cancellation of the Sale Deed wherein the sale consideration was mentioned
as 16,21,000/- dated 23.10.2007 but the court fee annexed is only Rs.200/-.
It was further claimed that the Plaintiff had not approached the Court with
clean hands and had concealed the material facts.
12.
On merits, it was denied that the Plaintiff and his unmarried sister,
Ms Ratna Chadha/Defendant No. 4, continued to reside in the property in
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
question and are in actual and physical possession, since the demise of Late
Sh. Pishori Lal Chadha, their father/erstwhile owner. It is denied that the
Plaintiff along with his wife and a child, were using two rooms, kitchen on
the Ground Floor or that Ms. Ratna Chadha, Defendant No. 4 was in
occupation of one kitchen and room on Ground Floor or that Front and back
verandah, bathroom, latrine, front and back court yards, were in common
use of the Plaintiff and the Defendant No. 4, Ms. Ratna Chadha.
13.
The Defendant No. 1, Sh. Anil Kumar Chadha, further asserted that
he was the absolute owner of the Property and was in actual possession, but
he had given the Property to the Plaintiff, Sh. Sanjeev Kumar Chadha and
the Defendant No. 4, Ms Ratna Chadha, out of love and affection on the
assurance that whenever the Defendants would want to sell the Property,
they can sell it and they would hand over the peaceful and vacant possession
of the Property to the Defendant No. 1.
14.
It was denied that the other legal heirs of the deceased, Sh. Pishori Lal
Chadha, ever protested against the alleged fraudulent act of the Defendant
No. 1, who ultimately settled the matter with the purchaser and cancelled the
deal with the said purchaser. The Defendant No. 1 had cancelled the deal
with Sh. Ashok Puri, for certain reasons, which are not relevant to the
present Suit. He claimed that all the Defendants were well aware of the
absolute ownership of the Defendant No. 1, for which reason, they had
executed Relinquishment Deed dated 24.04.2003 in his favour, which was
duly registered in the Office of Sub-Registrar.
15.
The Defendant No. 1 further submitted that he had amicably settled
the matter in September with the Defendant No. 4 and she assured that
whenever the Defendant No. 1 would ask her to vacate the premises, she
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
would do so and not create any hindrance in the sale of Property to the third
party.
16.
The Defendant No. 1 sold the aforesaid Property to the Defendant
Nos. 5 to 8 vide Registered Sale Deed dated 23.10.2007. It is denied that on
24.12.2007, the Defendant No. 1 came to the Plaintiff and the Defendant No.
4 asking them to vacate the house, as he had already sold the same. It is
vehemently denied that on 24.12.2007, the Defendant No. 1 had agreed to
pay to the Plaintiff and the Defendant No. 4, their alleged respective share in
the sale consideration, even though the sale amount was not disclosed.
17.
The Defendant No. 1 asserted that it is only after amicably settling the
matter with the Plaintiff and the Defendant No. 4, that he had sold the
Property to the Defendant Nos. 5 to 8. Before selling the Property, the
Defendant No. 1 had duly informed the Plaintiff and the Defendant No. 4
and requested them to vacate the Property within seven days, to which they
had agreed, but subsequently, there was a change of mind and out of greed,
they refused to vacate the Property.
18.
The Defendant No. 1 had also informed the Defendant Nos. 5 to 8
about these facts, after which only they entered into the Agreement with the
Defendant No. 1 and executed the Sale Deed.
19.
It was denied that the Defendant No. 1 had got two Sale Deeds
registered maliciously and in collusion with the Defendant Nos. 5 to 8 or
that he had not received any consideration for the sale of the Property. He
also denied that there was any fraud played by the Defendant No. 1 even
though one issue to this effect was framed in earlier Suit No. CS(OS)
468/2007 (old No. 161/2004), titled Anil Kumar Chadha vs. Raman Kumar
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
Chadha & Others. The Defendant No.1 therefore, asserted that the Suit of
the Plaintiff, Sh. Sanjeev Kumar Chadha, was liable to be dismissed.
20.
Defendant No. 2, Mr Raman Chadha and Defendant No. 3, Ms
Sunila Anand, despite service, failed to appear and were proceeded exparte
on 13.07.2009. No Written Statement was filed on their behalf.
21.
The Defendant No. 4, Ms Ratna Chadha, in her Written Statement-
cum-Counter Claim, took the defence that the alleged Relinquishment Deed
had been obtained by coercion, threat and misrepresentation and was liable
to be declared as null and void. The earlier Suit bearing CS(OS) No.
468/2007 had been withdrawn fraudulently by the Defendant No. 1 in
collusion with others and illegally coerced and pressurised the Defendant to
sign various documents, which is on the face of it illegal.
22.
The Defendant No. 4 claimed that she is unmarried and has no other
place to live for which reason, the father had executed the Will dated
28.07.1993 in her favour, making her as absolute owner. It was denied that
she had a limited right of user as per the wish and desire of the Defendant
No. 1. She further submitted that she had been occupying the Suit Property
in her own exclusive right and Defendant No. 1 could not have executed the
Sale Deed. The Relinquishment Deed and the two Sale Deeds were claimed
to be void ab initio. She further submitted that a decree of Declaration be
passed in her favour declaring the Relinquishment Deed dated 24.04.2003
as null and void.
23.
Separate Written Statements were filed by the Defendant Nos. 5 and
6, as well as by the Defendant Nos. 7 and 8. In both these Written
Statements filed on behalf of the Defendant Nos. 5 to 8, the preliminary
objections were taken that the Suit had been filed without locus standi as the
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
Plaintiff was neither the owner nor the landlord of the Suit Property. The
Suit was not valued for the purpose of court fees and jurisdiction. The
Ground Floor of the Suit Property in question was sold by one Sale Deed
registered on 12.12.2007. The Defendant Nos. 7 and 8 had purchased the
roof above the Ground Floor vide Sale Deed executed on 23.10.2007 and
registered on 12.12.2007. They had sent a Legal Notice dated 14.01.2008 to
Defendant No. 1 for handing over the possession of the Suit Property, who
then instigated the Plaintiff to file the present Suit, which is liable to be
dismissed. The Defendant Nos. 2 to 4 have already relinquished their shares
in favour of the Defendant No. 1, and they have no right, title and interest in
the Suit Property.
24.
On merits, all other averments made in the Plaint were denied.
25.
In the Replication, the Plaintiff/Appellant reiterated and reaffirmed
the contents of the Plaint and denied all the averments made in the Written
Statements.
26.
On the pleadingsof the parties, the learned Trial Court framed the
following Issues on 17.03.2010:
“(i) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of
declaration declaring that the Sale Deeds dated 23.10.2007
executed by Defendant No.1 in favour of Defendant Nos.5 to
8 in respect of the suit property are null and void? OPP.
(ii) Whether Defendant No.4 is entitled to a decree of
declaration declaring that the Relinquishment Deed dated
24.04.2003 relating to the suit property is null and void?
OPD
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
(iii) Whether the present suit is collusive, and if so, its effect?
OPD.
(iv) Whether the plaintiff has no locus standi to institute the
present suit? OPD.
(v) Relief.”
27.
The Plaintiff/Appellant, Sh. Sanjeev Kumar Chadha, examined
himself as PW-1 and tendered his evidence by way of affidavitEx. PW1/A.
He deposed on similar lines, as detailed in the plaint.PW-1 admitted during
his cross-examination the execution of the registered Relinquishment Deed
dated 24.04.2003. He further admitted that the said Relinquishment Deed
did not contain any stipulation regarding payment of shares or distribution of
sale proceeds amongst the legal heirs.
28.
Defendant No.1, Sh. Anil Kumar Chadha, examined himself as
DW-1 and tendered his evidence by way of affidavitEx.D1W1/X. He
supported the validity of the Relinquishment Deed dated 24.04.2003 Ex.D1
and deposed that the Plaintiff/Appellant and the other legal heirs had
voluntarily relinquished their rights in the suit property in his favour. He
asserted that by virtue of the said Relinquishment Deed, he became the
absolute owner of the suit property and was competent to execute the Sale
Deeds dated 23.10.2007 in favour of Defendant Nos.5 to 8.
29.
Defendant No.4, Ms Ratna Chadha, examined himself as DW-4 and
tendered her evidence Ex. D4/W-1 in support of the counterclaim. She relied
upon the Will dated 28.07.1993 allegedly executed by Late Shri Pishori Lal
Chadha in her favour and asserted that the Relinquishment Deed dated
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
24.04.2003 had been procured by fraud, coercion and misrepresentation and
was therefore liable to be declared null and void.
30.
Defendant No.5, Smt. Renu Kansal and Defendant No.8, Smt.
Babita Garg, who were purchasers under the impugned Sale Deeds dated
23.10.2007
Ex
D3,examined
themselves
as
DW-5
and
DW-8
respectivelyand tendered their affidavit of evidence Ex. DW5/A and Ex. D8/A respectively. They supported the validity of the Sale Deeds and denied
the allegations of collusion and sham transactions. During their crossexamination, both admitted that they were housewives and had not obtained
possession of the portions purchased by them. They were also unable to
furnish precise particulars regarding the source of funds and the cash
component of the sale consideration.
31.
DW6 Shakuntala Rani (Defendant No. 6),along with Defendant No.
5,wasthepurchaser of the suit property on the basis of Sale Deed dated
23.10.2007 Ex D3 and Relinquishment Deed dated 24.04.2003 Ex D1. She
claimed that the entire sale consideration of Rs. 16,21,000 was paid to
Defendant No. 1. She denied that Plaintiff was the landlord or owner of the
suit property. She also claimed that Defendant No. 4, Ms Ratna Chadha has
forged the Will dated 28.07.1993, allegedly executed by Late Shri Pishori
Lal Chadha in her favour.
32.
DW-7 Sharda Devi(Defendant No. 7) deposed that she along with
Defendant No. 8 Smt. Babita Garg, had purchased the property from
Defendant No. 1 for a total sale consideration of Rs 16,00,000/-,vide Sale
Deed dated 23.10.2007. She claimed that the Plaintiff cannot claim
cancellation of the Sale Deed after having signed a Relinquishment Deed
dated 24.04.2003, Ex D1 in favour of Defendant No. 1. She further deposed
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
that Defendant No. 4 Ms Ratna Chadha has forged the Will dated
28.07.1993.
33.
The learned Additional District Judge, vide Judgment and Decree
dated 09.09.2019, upon appreciation of the pleadings, evidence and material
on record, held that the Plaintiff/Appellant had failed to establish that the
Relinquishment Deed dated 24.04.2003 had been executed subject to any
condition regarding distribution of the sale proceeds of the suit property
amongst the legal heirs, or that they were sham, collusive or liable to be
declared null and void. It was further held that the Plaintiff/Appellant had
admitted execution of the said Relinquishment Deed and had failed to
establish any ground for questioning its validity.
34.
The learned Additional District Judge further held that Defendant
No.1 had acquired valid title in the suit property by virtue of the
Relinquishment Deed dated 24.04.2003 and was therefore competent to
execute the Sale Deeds dated 23.10.2007 in favour of Defendant Nos.5 to 8.
35.
Accordingly, the learned Additional District Judge dismissed the suit
for Possession.
36.
Aggrieved by the Judgment and Decree dated 09.09.2019, the
Plaintiff/Appellant has preferred the present Appeal.
37.
The grounds of challenge are that the Learned Trial Court failed to
appreciate that the Sale Deeds dated 23.10.2007 executed by Defendant
No.1 in favour of Defendant Nos.5 to 8 were sham, collusive and makebelieve transactions, brought into existence solely to defeat the rights of the
Plaintiff/Appellant and Defendant No.4, in the suit property. It is contended
that Defendant No.1, in collusion with Defendant Nos.5 to 8, created a mere
façade of sale without any genuine transfer of ownership or possession.
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
38.
It is further contended that the learned ADJ failed to appreciate that
the claim of Defendant No.1 to ownership in the suit property rested solely
upon the Relinquishment Deed dated 24.04.2003, the validity whereof was
itself
under
challenge.
According
to
the
Plaintiff/Appellant,
the
Relinquishment Deed was executed only on the assurance of Defendant
No.1 that the suit property would be sold and the sale proceeds distributed
amongst all the legal heirs. There was no reason for the Plaintiff/Appellant,
who was admittedly residing in the suit property along with his family, to
relinquish his rights except on such understanding.
39.
It is further submitted that the learned Trial Court failed to appreciate
that the impugned Sale Deeds were executed on 23.10.2007 during the
pendency of CS(OS) No.468/2007 and that the said Suit was accordingly
withdrawn only on 24.10.2007. According to the Plaintiff/Appellant, the
execution of the Sale Deeds during the pendency of the proceedings and
immediately prior to withdrawal thereof, constitutes a significant
circumstance demonstrating the collusive nature of the transactions.
40.
It is further contended that despite the recitalcontained in Clause 2 of
the Sale Deeds regarding delivery of possession, the admitted fact is that
possession of the ground floor portion continued to remain with the
Plaintiff/Appellant and possession of the first-floor portion continued with
Defendant No.4. It is submitted that the continued possession of the
Plaintiff/Appellant and Defendant No.4, belies the recitals contained in the
Sale Deeds and casts serious doubt on the genuineness of the transactions.
41.
It is further submitted that the learned ADJ failed to properly
appreciate the evidence of Defendant Nos.5 and 8. It is contended that both
witnesses admitted in their cross-examination that they were housewives
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
with no independent source of income; had never inspected the suit property
from inside prior to the alleged purchase and were unable to furnish
satisfactory particulars regarding the source of funds and payment of sale
consideration. According to the Plaintiff/Appellant, these admissions clearly
establish that the impugned Sale Deeds were sham and collusive
transactions.
42.
Reliance has been placed upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in
Kewal Krishan v. Rajesh Kumar & Ors., Civil Appeal Nos. 6989-6992 of
2021, to contend that a Sale Deed executed without consideration is void
and unenforceable. It is submitted that Defendant Nos.5 to 8 failed to
establish payment of the sale consideration and consequently the impugned
Sale Deeds are liable to be declared null and void.
43.
It is further contended that the learned Trial Court failed to appreciate
the cumulative effect of the surrounding circumstances, namely, execution
of the Sale Deeds during the pendency of litigation, non-delivery of
possession, alleged payment of substantial consideration in cash, absence of
any independent source of income of the purchasers and the inability of the
purchasers to explain the transactions in question. According to the
Plaintiff/Appellant, these circumstances unmistakably establish that the
impugned transactions were not bona fide.
44.
It is therefore submitted that the findings of the learned Trial Court
are contrary to the pleadings, evidence and material available on record and
have resulted in grave miscarriage of justice. Reliance has been placed upon
Tara Chand v. Ratan Bhai & Ors., (1992) 1 WLC 571 and Jaideep Bajaj v.
Shashi Bajaj, AIR 2006 Del 335.
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
45.
The Plaintiff/Appellant accordingly submitted that the impugned
Judgment and Decree dated 09.09.2019, be set aside and the Suit be decreed.
Submissions heardand record perused.
46.
At the outset, it is an admitted case that the suit property was
originally owned by Sh. Pishori Lal Chadha, father of Plaintiff and
Defendant Nos. 1-4. After his demise, Plaintiff Sanjeev Kumar Chadha
along with Defendant No. 2, 3 and 4 executed the registered Relinquishment
Deed dated 24.04.2003 Ex. D1, in favour of Defendant No.1 Anil Kumar
Chadha.
47.
Significantly, the challenge raised by the Plaintiff/Appellant proceeds
on the premise that Respondent No.1 was not entitled to deal with the suit
property. A registered document carries a presumption of validity unless
successfully impeached in accordance with law. The Relinquishment Deed
dated 24.04.2003 conferred title upon Respondent No.1, and the subsequent
Sale Deeds executed by him cannot be invalidated merely on the basis of
suspicion or conjecture.
48.
The contention of the Plaintiff/Appellant that Defendant No. 4, Smt.
Ratna Chadha, Respondent No. 4, had not personally executed the
Relinquishment Deed, is equally devoid of merit. The record reflects that
Respondent No. 4, Smt. Ratna Chadha had executed a Special Power of
Attorney in favour of the Plaintiff/Appellant, and the Relinquishment Deed
was executed by the Plaintiff/Appellant both in his individual capacity and
on behalf of Smt. Ratna Chadha,Respondent No.4. Furthermore, Defendant
No. 4, Smt. Ratna Chadha, Respondent No. 4, has never challenged either
the Relinquishment Deed or the subsequent Sale Deeds.
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
49.
The case of the Plaintiff/Appellant, Sh. Sanjeev Kumar Chadha is that
the Relinquishment Deed was executed on the assurance of Respondent
No.1 that the suit property would be sold and the sale proceeds distributed
amongst all the legal heirs. However, apart from his own oral assertion, no
independent evidence has been led to establish the existence of any such
arrangement. Significantly, no such stipulation finds mention in the
registered Relinquishment Deed dated 24.04.2003. As rightly contended on
behalf of the Respondents, the terms of a written and registered document
cannot be varied by oral assertions unsupported by cogent evidence, in terms
of Section 91 and Section 92 of Indian Evidence Act, 1872.
50.
PW-1 Sh. Sanjeev Kumar Chadha,during his cross-examination,
admitted execution of the
Relinquishment Deed Ex. D1 and further
admitted that the document did not contain any stipulation regarding
distribution of sale proceeds amongst the legal heirs. There exists no ground
for cancellation of the Relinquishment Deed, executed in favour of
Respondent No.1.
51.
The learned ADJ has rightly observed that the Plaintiff/Appellant is
an educated person and had admittedly executed the registered
Relinquishment Deed. The record does not disclose any material to establish
that the said document was executed under fraud, coercion or
misrepresentation. In these circumstances, the finding of the learned Trial
Court that the Plaintiff/Appellant failed to establish any infirmity in the
Relinquishment Deed does not warrant interference.
52.
The Plaintiff/Appellant has also relied upon Clause 2 of the Sale
Deeds,which records delivery of possession to the purchasers, to contend
that the transactions were not genuine, since possession admittedly remained
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
with the Plaintiff/Appellant and Respondent No.4. It is not disputed that the
Plaintiff/Appellant continued to occupy the ground floor portion while
Respondent No.4 remained in occupation of the first-floor portion.
53.
However, the mere fact that possession was not immediately obtained
by the purchasers cannot by itself render the Sale Deeds void or nonexistent. The physical possession may have continued with Plaintiff and
Defendant No.4, but their legal ownership rights ceased on execution of the
Relinquishment Deed, and their continued possession was merely
permissive, after execution of the Relinquishment Deed.
54.
The next contention advanced on behalf of the Plaintiff/Appellant is
that the Sale Deeds dated 23.10.2007 were sham and collusive transactions
executed by Respondent No.1 in favour of Respondent Nos.5 to 8 solely to
defeat the rights of the legal heirs in the suit property. In support of this
contention, emphasis has been placed on the fact that the Sale Deeds were
executed during the pendency of CS(OS) No.468/2007, and that the said suit
was withdrawn only on 24.10.2007.
55.
Merely because the Sale Deeds were executed during the pendency of
the aforesaid proceedings cannot, by itself, lead to an inference that the
transactions were sham or collusive. Ld. ADJ rightly observed that the
defendant being the Dominus litus, had a right to withdraw the Suit
subsequent to the execution of the Sale Deed.
56.
Considerable reliance has been placed by the Plaintiff/Appellant upon
the cross-examination of Respondent No.5, Smt. Renu Kansal, and
Respondent No.8, Smt. Babita Garg, to contend that the Sale Deeds were a
sham document. It is correct that during their cross-examination both
admitted that they were housewives and had no independent source of
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
income. They also admitted that they had not inspected the suit property
from inside prior to the purchase and were unable to furnish precise
particulars regarding the source of funds utilised for the transactions.
57.
The Plaintiff/Appellant has argued that these admissions conclusively
establish that no consideration was paid and that the Sale Deeds were merely
paper transactions. Reliance has been placed upon Kewal Krishan v. Rajesh
Kumar & Ors., Civil Appeal Nos.6989-6992 of 2021, wherein it was
observed that a Sale Deed executed without consideration would not
constitute a valid transfer.
58.
However, the burden of establishing that the impugned Sale Deeds
were
executed
without
consideration
squarely
rested
upon
the
Plaintiff/Appellant. The Sale Deeds recorded payment of sale consideration
of Rs. 16,21,000/- and Rs. 16,00,000/-. Respondent No.1, in his testimony,
categorically asserted that the consideration mentioned therein had been
received by him. Except for highlighting certain inconsistencies in the
evidence of Respondent Nos.5 and 8, no independent evidence has been led
by the Plaintiff/Appellant to establish that the recitals regarding
consideration were false or that no consideration in fact passed between the
parties.
59.
The question before the Court is not whether the purchasers were able
to recall every detail of the transaction after several years, but whether the
Plaintiff/Appellant has succeeded in discharging the burden of proving that
the Sale Deeds were sham, collusive and unsupported by consideration. On
an overall appreciation of the evidence, it is difficult to conclude that such
burden has been discharged or to conclude that the sale Deeds were sham
documents.
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
60.
The
learned
ADJ
therefore,
rightly
concluded
that
the
Plaintiff/Appellant failed to establish that the Sale Deeds dated 23.10.2007
were sham, collusive or liable to be declared null and void. No infirmity is
found in the appreciation of evidence undertaken by the learned Trial Court
in this regard.
61.
Defendant No. 4, Smt. Ratna Chadha also challenged the
Relinquishment Deed, Ex. D1 by claiming firstly, that her signatures had
been obtained under fraud, threat and coercion by Defendant No. 1, who
took her signatures on the pretext of getting the property mutated, and the
Relinquishment Deed was a null and void document. She claimed that the
fraudulent act of execution of two Sale Deeds in favour of the Defendant
Nos. 5 to 8 came to her knowledge when he started harassing them. These
two Sale Deeds were never shown to her.
62.
Ld. ADJ rightly observed that this Relinquishment Deed was not
challenged by any legal heirs since the date of its execution. Smt. Ratna
Chadha had also challenged it for the first time by filing a Counter-Claim
in the Suit. However, no evidence whatsoever was led in her counter-Claim,
which got dismissed and has not been challenged by her.
63.
She explained that she was the unmarried daughter and had no other
place to live except the suit premises. Her father, Sh. Pishori Lal Chadha had
executed a Will dated 28.07.1993, Ex. D4W1/2 in her favour, by virtue of
which she became the owner of the Suit Property.
64.
The perusal of the Will shows that it is a single-page Will, which was
witnessed by Sh. Ravinder Kumar and Sh. Jagmohan Singh. The execution
of the Will was required to be proved by DW-4 and mandatorily, at least one
attesting witness was required to be examined. However, no evidence
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
whatsoever has been led by her. Though she filed her Affidavit of Evidence,
she never stepped into the Witness box to prove her evidence.has been led to
prove the Will, in accordance with law. Smt. Ratna Chadha, therefore,
miserably failed to establish any right under the Will.
65.
The learned ADJ, thus, rightly concluded that Respondent No.4 had
failed to establish either the validity of the alleged Will or the plea of fraud,
coercion and misrepresentation in execution of the Relinquishment Deed, or
the cancellation.
66.
The challenge raised by Respondent No.4,Smt. Ratna Chadha to the
Relinquishment Deed dated 24.04.2003, also does not merit acceptance.
Significantly, allegations of fraud, coercion and misrepresentation are
required to be specifically pleaded and strictly proved. Except for bald
assertions, no cogent evidence was led by Respondent No.4 to substantiate
the allegations levelled against Respondent No.1. The findings of the
learned ADJ are based upon proper appreciation of the evidence on record
and do not call for interference.
67.
Defendant No. 4, Smt. Ratna Chadhafurther deposed in her affidavit
of evidence that on 06.04.2004, she cancelled the GPA executed in favour of
Defendant No.1 Anil Kumar Chadha as well as the Relinquishment
Deed,vide Cancellation Deed, Ex. D4W1/3, which curtailed her right in the
Property and she never intended to relinquish her share in the Property. She
also gave a public Notice dated 08.05.2004, Ex. D4W1/5 and a Public
Notice dated 07.01.2003, Ex. D4W1/6 in the Newspaper in regard to the
annulment of the Relinquishment Deed. The Defendant No. 4 thus deposed
that because the Relinquishment Deed was revoked, the Defendant No. 1
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
had no right or title to sell the Property by virtue of the two Sale Deeds,
which were also liable to be declared null and void.
68.
While the Defendant No.4 Radha Chaddha had set up a claim of
cancellation of GPA and Relinquishment Deed, as stated by her in her
Affidavit of Evidence, but the record reflects that though the Affidavit of
Evidence was filed and there was some proxy counsel who had been
appearing on her behalf throughout the trial, but she herself never stepped
into the witness box to prove these documents of cancellation, Public Notice
or Publication in newspaper in regard to the annulment of Relinquishment
Deed.
69.
Pertinently, her Counter-claim No.CC 209/08, which had been
separately registered, also got dismissed on account of want of evidence. In
this case as well, no evidence whatsoever has been led by her in support of
her assertions and, therefore, the defence taken by her has not been proved.
70.
The conclusions reached by the learned ADJ are based on correct
appreciation of evidence, which do not suffer from any illegality, perversity
or infirmity, warranting interference in Appeal.
71.
The Plaintiff/Appellant has failed to establish that the Relinquishment
Deed dated 24.04.2003 was invalid or that the Sale Deeds dated 23.10.2007
executed by Respondent No.1 in favour of Respondent Nos.5 to 8 were
sham, collusive or unsupported by consideration. The findings recorded by
the learned Additional District Judgeare based on proper appreciation of the
evidence and call for no interference.
Conclusion:
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
72.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court finds no infirmity in the
Judgment and Decree dated 09.09.2019 passed by the learned Additional
District Judge-03, Rohini Court, Delhi.
73.
There is no merit in the present Appeal, which is hereby
dismissed. Pending Applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JULY 9, 2026/R/RS
RFA 21/2020
Signed By:VIKAS
ARORA
17:26:21
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review