The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. In such view of the matter, the instant petition is allowed only to the extent of adverse remark against the petitioner in para- 28, 30 and 32. Rest of the order will be intact and to be dealt with on it’s own merit. The concerned Judicial Officer is advised to be very cautious in future while passing any serious UKHC010106972026 remark on the conduct of the counsel representing the litigant and should focus on the issue in hand.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
UKHC010106972026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND
AT NAINITAL
Criminal Misc. Application No. 1368 of 2026
Sanjeev Kaushik.
………………… Applicant.
Versus
State of Uttarakhand and Another.
……………Respondents.
Present:
Mr. Navneet Kaushik, learned counsel for the applicant.
Mr. Tumul Nainwal, learned A.G.A. for the State.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rakesh Thapliyal, J.
1.
The instant petition has been preferred by the petitioner
Sanjeev Kaushik, who is a practicing lawyer since last 27 years
in District and Session Court, Haridwar and Roorkee against the
judgment and order dated 08.04.2026 passed in Criminal
Revision No. 96 of 2025 ‘Rishab Saini vs. State of Uttarakhand
and Another’, wherein, the learned 1st Additional Sessions
judge, Roorkee make a serious remark on the integrity of the
petitioner by observing that conduct of the petitioner is against
the ethics of profession and liable for censor. The petitioner who
is the practicing lawyer though is not the party to the
proceeding of the matter, wherein, the impugned order was
passed as he was representing one of the party to the
proceeding but due to such a serious he is compeled to file this
petition.
2.
The brief facts of the issue, which was dealt with by the
learned 1st Additional Sessions Judge while deciding Criminal
Revision No. 96 of 2025 is that the respondent no. 2 herein Ms.
Amita Saini filed a complaint against her husband and in-laws
for the offence punishable under section 406 of IPC and the said
UKHC010106972026
complaint was registered as Complaint Case No. 3160 of 2023.
In this complaint case on 16.10.2024 the summons were issued
only against the husband Rishab Saini, who being aggrieved
with the summoning preferred Criminal Revision No. 93 of 2025
before the Session Court and the said revision was admitted but
the summoning order dated 16.10.2024 was not stayed.
Since, there was no stay in the order of summoning,
consequently, the concerned Trial Court proceeded with
Complaint
Case
No.
of
and
as
the
respondent/husband could not appear, a non-bailable warrant
(in short NBW) was issued on 27.02.2026 against Rishab Saini,
who being aggrieved with the order of non-bailable warrant
preferred another revision bearing Criminal Revision No. 25 of
2026, which was admitted on 07.03.2026 but the non-bailable
warrant was not stayed.
3.
Since, the non-bailable warrant was not stayed by the
Revisional Court in Criminal Revision No. 25 of 2026 Mr. Rishab
Saini preferred a petition before this court i.e. C528 No. 372 of
2026, wherein, the Coordinate Bench on 12.03.2026 disposed of
the petition by keeping non bailable warrant in abeyance with
the direction to the husband Rishab Saini to put appearance
before the Trial Court on the date fixed.
4.
The order of Coordinate Bench dated 12.03.2026 passed in
C528 No. 372 of 2026 was placed before the Trial Court dealing
with Complaint Case No. 3160 of 2023 on 18.03.2026 but since
the date was already fixed for 12.05.2026, therefore, the Trial
Court could not have take note of the order passed by the High
Court though it was already placed on record.
UKHC010106972026
5.
In the meantime, Original Revision No. 93 of 2025, which
was preferred against the original summoning order dated
06.10.2024 was came up before the Revisional Court on
08.04.2026 and the Revisional Court take serious note of the fact
that the order of High Court dated 12.03.2026 passed in C528
No. 372 of 2026 was suppressed and after taking serious note on
this the Revisional Court observed that during course of
argument learned counsel for the revisionist concealed the
above position from this court, which was brought to the
attention of Revisional Court by the learned counsel for
respondent no. 2, who is the complainant. In para-30 of the
order impugned it has been observed by the revisional court
that the order of High Court dated 12.03.2026 was well within
the knowledge of the revisionist and his counsel and
concealment of the order amount to misconduct on the part of
the revisionist and his counsel. Subsequently, in para-32 the
revisional court observed that the conduct of learned counsel in
this regard is against the ethics of profession and liable for
censor. Relevant extract of the order impugned, which is under
challenge, are being extracted herein as under:
28. During the course of arguments, the Learned Counsel for the
revisionist concealed the above position from this Court.
However the above position was brought on record to the
attention of this Court by the Learned Counsel for the Respondent
no.2.
30. The order dated 12/03/2026 being well within the
knowledge of Revisionist and his Learned Counsel,
concealment of
the order and the proceedings as above from
this
court
is
misconduct on part of the Revisionist and his Learned Counsel.
32. The conduct of the Learned Counsel in this regard is against
the ethics of profession and liable for censor.”
6.
Now, being aggrieved with the serious remark as
observed by the revisional court in the order dated 08.04.2026
the petitioner who is the counsel for one of the party to the
UKHC010106972026
revision, which has been decided by the order impugned
preferred this petition under section 528 of BNSS, 2023. Learned
counsel for the petitioner.
7.
Mr. Navneet Kaushik, learned counsel for the applicant,
submits the adverse remark of the revisional court is wholly
unjustified and unwarranted since in the original proceeding i.e.
Complaint No. 3160 of 2023 the order of High Court was
already placed on record on 18.03.2026 and since the order of
High Court relates to the non bailable warrant, which has
nothing to do with the subject matter of Revision No. 93 of 2025,
therefore, the Revisional Court exceeded his power and
jurisdiction while passing serious remark on the applicant, who
is a practicing lawyer. He submits that the petitioner being and
advocate is practicing since 27 years with an unblemished
record and in any of the proceeding in which he has appeared
for the litigant since last 27 years not a single remark has been
made on his conduct and integrity by any court and the issue in
hand was wrongly dealt with by the revisional court while
passing serious remark against the petitioner. He submits that
even the Revisional Court have not dealt with this aspect that
the issue of NBW was not the subject matter of Revision No. 93
of 2025 even then on the instance of learned counsel for the
complainant the revisional court take serious view on the
conduct of the petitioner, which was not at all warranted.
8.
Mr. Tumul Nainwal, learned A.G.A. in order to assist this
court also submits that the revisional court should apply his
judicial mind before passing any remark whether there was any
necessity to put a serious remark on the conduct of the lawyer
particularly when the subject matter of the revision was entirely
different to the subject matter of C528 No. 372 of 2026. He fairly
UKHC010106972026
submits that C528 No. 372 of 2026 decided by the Coordinate
Bench was only confined to issuance of non bailable warrant
and it has nothing to do with the subject matter of Revision No.
93 of 2025, since the issue was only with regard to the issuance
of order of summoning dated 16.10.2024.
9.
I found force on the submission of learned counsel for the
applicant as well as the learned A.G.A. I have gone through
with the entire order as well as the order passed by the
Coordinate Bench of this court in C528 No. 372 of 2026 as well
as the subject matter of Criminal Revision No. 25 of 2026 as well
as the subject matter of Criminal Revision No. 93 of 2025.
Admittedly, the issue of Criminal Revision No. 25 of 2026 was
only confined to non bailable warrant, therefore, there was no
any occasion on the part of the revisional court to take
cognizance on the order of the High Court which relates to non
bailable warrant and the learned Revisional Court should deal
with the issue in hand, therefore, this court is of the view that
the learned 1st Additional Sessions judge, Roorkee, while
passing the order impugned dated 08.04.2026 have exceeded his
power and jurisdiction while passing serious remark on the
conduct of the counsel, who was representing one of the party
in that proceeding. This is really very surprising that the
concerned court instead of focusing on the issue in hand take
the cognizance of the issue which has no relevance.
10.
In such view of the matter, the instant petition is allowed
only to the extent of adverse remark against the petitioner in
para- 28, 30 and 32. Rest of the order will be intact and to be
dealt with on it’s own merit. The concerned Judicial Officer is
advised to be very cautious in future while passing any serious
UKHC010106972026
remark on the conduct of the counsel representing the litigant
and should focus on the issue in hand.
11.
Registry is directed to send the copy of this order to the
concerned court.
(Rakesh Thapliyal, J.)
19.06.2026
PR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review