Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Reserved on:5thFebruary,2026
Pronounced on: 16th June, 2026
%
+
RFA 600/2024, CM APPL. 29628/2025
SANJAY VERMA
S/o Shri Mahendra Nath Verma,
R/o 50, E-SPACE, Nirvana Country,
Sector 50, Gurgaon-122018.
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. S.C. Anand Advocate.
versus
AITHENT TECHNOLOGIES PVT. LTD.
Through its Chief Executive Officer,
A-186, Okhla Industrial Area, Phase-I,
New Delhi-110020.
.....Respondent
Through: Ms. Venancio D'Costa and Ms. Gauri
Goel, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
JUDGEMENT
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
1.
The present Regular First Appeal under Section 96 read with Order XLI
of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 has been preferred by the
Appellant/Plaintiff, Sanjay Verma, assailing the Judgment and Decree dated
28.03.2024, whereby the Suit for Recovery of Rs.16,49,713/- filed by the
Appellant/Plaintiff came to be dismissed, by the learned District Judge.
2.
The Appellant/Plaintiff instituted the CS DJ No.13384/2016 seeking
recovery of Rs.16,49,713/- against the Respondent Company towards deferred
salary, compensation bonus, transfer allowance, gratuity and interest.
3.
Briefly stated, the case of the Appellant/Plaintiff was that he joined the
services of the Respondent Company on 28.07.1992 and resigned on 02.03.2005
Signed By:VIKAS
RFA 600/2024
ARORA
18:08:17
from the post of Vice President, Technology. At the time of his resignation, he
was drawing a gross monthly salary of Rs.1,42,333/-.
4.
During the financial year 2002-2003, the Respondent Company faced
financial difficulties on account of substantial investments in infrastructure and
delayed payments from its overseas affiliated entities. Consequently, in March
2002, the Defendant Company decided to defer a portion of the salaries
payable to employees, drawing salaries above Rs.12,000/- per month,for the
financial year 2002–2003 on a graded scale of 15%, 20%, 25% and 30%
depending upon the salary range. The employees were also promised one
month’s salary, as bonus compensation, to offset the financial hardship
occasioned by the deferment of salaries. The deferred salary was to be paid on
01.04.2003.
5.
Appellant/Plaintiff stated that during an Open-House Meeting held on
09.08.2002, Management announced restoration of salaries of employees in the
lowest salary group of Rs.12,000/- to Rs.20,000 per month, with effect from
01.10.2002, and assured that the case of other employees falling in other salary
groups including the Plaintiff, would also be reviewed and their deferred
salaries, would be released.
6.
As per the Appellant/Plaintiff, the said announcement had been made
with the approval of the CEO of the Defendant Company, who had sent an email dated 09.07.2002 Ex. PW2/1 to Mr. Raju Ahluwalia, with copies to Mr.
Ajay Malik and the Appellant/Plaintiff, regarding the preponement of the
decision to restore salaries to the earlier levels.
7.
The original salary of the Appellant/Plaintiff of Rs.1,42,333/-stood
restored w.e.f. 01.04.2003; however, the Respondent Company sought further
time to pay the arrears of deferred salary and compensation bonus. The
Signed By:VIKAS
RFA 600/2024
ARORA
18:08:17
Appellant/Plaintiff further stated that despite repeated demands, the Respondent
Company failed to release the said amounts.
8.
The Appellant/Plaintiff resigned from the Respondent Company on
02.03.2005 and claimed that he would not have continued with the Respondent
Company during the relevant period at a reduced salary, except on the assurance
that the reduced component would be paid later along with bonus.
9.
The Plaintiff has also relied upon a communication dated 01.04.2005,
issued by the CEO of the Respondent Company assuring clearance of his dues
by 31.05.2005. However, payment of the deferred salary and compensation
bonus, continued to be postponed, despite repeated requests.
10.
The Plaintiff on 20.03.2006 sent a letter demanding payment of his dues.
The Respondent Companypaid only a sum of Rs.1,00,003/- after deduction of
TDS towards salary for two days of March, 2005 and leave encashment, while
the other dues remained unpaid.
11.
The Appellant/Plaintiff’s claimed that his salary was subjected to a
reduction of 30%
and accordingly, a sum of Rs.48,450/- per month was
reduced from his salary for the period from April 2002 to March 2003. He was
entitled to a total of Rs.5,81,400/-, as arrears of deducted salary. In addition, the
Appellant/Plaintiff claimed one month’s gross salary of Rs.1,42,333/- as
compensation bonus.
12.
Additionally, the Appellant/Plaintiff
claimed an amount of USD
4000(exchange rate $1 = ₹45), equivalent to Rs.1,80,000/-, towards transfer
allowance allegedly promised by the Respondent Company vide e-mails dated
05.10.2004 and 06.10.2004and payable on account of his transfer, from New
York, USA to New Delhi.
13.
He further claimed Rs.3,50,000/- towards gratuity,which become due on
03.03.2005.
Signed By:VIKAS
RFA 600/2024
ARORA
18:08:17
14.
The Appellant/Plaintiff instituted the Suit seeking recovery of
Rs.16,49,713/- along with interest @ 12% per annum.
15.
The Respondent Company filed the Written Statement and raised a
preliminary objection regarding territorial jurisdiction on the ground that the
employment of the Appellant/Plaintiff, pertained to Gurgaon.
16.
On merits, the Respondent Company denied that the salary had been
deferred. It was asserted that the salaries of employees were restructured, in
view of prevailing financial circumstances and that no agreement existed for
repayment of the reduced component of salary, at any later stage.
17.
The Respondent Company further asserted that the Appellant/Plaintiff,
along with other members of the Management team, was responsible for the
decision relating to restructuring of salaries. It was also contended that the
Appellant/Plaintiff did not raise any grievance during his employment and the
claim was raised only after his resignation.
18.
With respect to one month’s salary claimed as bonus, the Respondent
Company stated that it was contemplated only as a “loyalty bonus” after the
Company regained financial health; it was not a legal commitment, but merely a
moral incentive.
19.
The Respondent Company denied that any amount was due and payable
to the Appellant/Plaintiff at the time of his resignation, on 02.03.2005.
20.
On the basis of pleadings, the learned Trial Court framed the following
Issues on 01.06.2007:
“1. Whether this court has territorial jurisdiction to try
thissuit? OPP
2. Whether plaintiff was a party to the restructuring of
thesalary as alleged by the defendant? OPP
3. Whether plaintiff was a party to the restructuring of
thesalary and hence estopped from bringing this suit?
4.Whether a part of salary of plaintiff had been deferredwith
any assurance, as alleged? OPP
Signed By:VIKAS
RFA 600/2024
ARORA
18:08:17
5. Whether plaintiff was assured. any bonus? If so, to
whatextent?OPP
6. Whether plaintiff is entitled to any gratuity? If so, atwhat
rate and for which period? OPP
7. Whether plaintiff is entitled to the suit amount? OPP
8. Whether plaintiff is entitled to any interest on the
suitamount? If so at what rate and for what period? OPP
9. Relief ”
21.
In support of his case, the Appellant/Plaintiff examined himself as PW-1
and tendered his affidavit in evidence. He relied upon documents exhibited as
Appointment Letter dated 01.12.2001 Ex.P-1, Letter dated 01.11.2001 regarding
benefits and allowances Ex.P-2, relieving/experience letter Ex.P-3, salary slips
for March 2003 and April 2003 Ex.P-4, email dated 01.04.2005 and letter dated
21.03.2006 as Ex. PW-1/20, etc.
22.
The Appellant/Plaintiff also examined PW-2, Mr. Sunil Vadhera who
corroborated that during the Financial Year 2002-2003, salaries of certain
employees had been deferred on a graded scale due to temporary cash flow
issues faced by the Respondent Company.
23.
The Respondent Company examinedDW-1, Mr. Bunty Bisht, Manager,
who reiterated the stand taken in the Written Statement. He deposed that the
reduction in salary was a restructuring exercise and not deferment of salary. He
relied upon the photocopy of the Minute Book Ex.DW-1/A. The Respondent
Company also relied upon letter dated 28.03.2006 Ex.D-1and registered A.D.
cardEx.D-2, which had been admitted during admission and denial of
documents.
24.
The learned Trial Court after considering the rival contentions and the
evidence,held that the Appellant/Plaintiff had failed to prove that any part of his
salary was deferred with an assurance that it would be repaid on 01.04.2003 or
at any later stage. It was also held that the Appellant/Plaintiff had failed to
Signed By:VIKAS
RFA 600/2024
ARORA
18:08:17
prove any enforceable assurance regarding payment of one month’s salary as
bonus.
25.
The learned Trial Court further rejected the claim of Rs.1,80,000/-
towards transferallowance, holding that the e-mails relied dated 05.10.2004 and
06.10.2004 Mark PW-1/B upon had not been proved in accordance with section
65B of the Indian Evidence Act. moreover, the claim was, in any event, barred
by limitation since it pertained to the year 2001, while the present Suit had been
filed in 2006.
26.
The claim for gratuity was also rejected on the ground that the
Appellant/Plaintiff failed to prove continuous employment with the Respondent
Company from 28.07.1992, as alleged. The learned Trial Court noted that the
Appointment letter Ex.P-1 relied upon by the Appellant/Plaintiff showed his
appointment as Vice President, Technical with effect from 01.11.2001.
27.
Accordingly, the Suit of the Appellant/Plaintiff was dismissed vide
Judgment and Decree dated 28.03.2024.
28.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid Judgment and Decree dated 28.03.2024, the
present Appeal has been preferred.
29.
The grounds of challengeare that the learned Trial Court erred in treating
his service with the Respondent Company, as not continuous. It is contended
that the learned Trial Court failed to properly appreciate the admitted
Certificates/documents Ex.P-1 and Ex.P-2 and wrongly rejected the claim for
gratuity of Rs.3,50,000/-, which according to the Appellant/Plaintiff, became
due on 03.03.2005. The Appellant/Plaintiff has also claimed interest @ 12% per
annum on the said amount from the due date till realization.
30.
It is further contended that the learned Trial Court failed to consider the
claim for transfer allowance payable on account of the Appellant/Plaintiff’s
transfer from New York, USA to New Delhi. The Appellant/Plaintiff has relied
Signed By:VIKAS
RFA 600/2024
ARORA
18:08:17
upon Ex.P-1, Ex.P-2, Ex.P-3 and other documents to contend that an amount of
USD 4000 was payable to him, which, according to him, amounted to
Rs.1,80,000/- at the exchange rate of Rs.45/- per USD prevalent at the time of
filing of the Suit.
31.
It is contended that the Trial Court Judgment is self-contradictory,
inasmuch as while it relies upon decisions emphasizing the importance of Board
Resolutions, but it fails to notice that no Board Resolution was produced by the
Respondent to show restructuring of salary. The Appellant/Plaintiff has relied
upon the e-mail dated 09.07.2002 Ex. PW1/2and connected e-mails, to contend
that the salary was “deferred” and not restructured.
32.
It is further contended that the e-mails relied upon by the
Appellant/Plaintiff are admissible in terms of Section 88-A of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872. It is also submitted that the decisions relied upon by the
learned Trial Court pertains to internal shareholder disputes and lack of personal
liability of Directors and do not deal with the liability of a Company for
commitments made to its employees by its Directors. Reliance is also placed
upon the letter issued by the CEO/Director dated 01.04.2005, wherein interest
was allegedly promised, in case of delay in payment.
33.
The Respondent in his Written Submissions supported the impugned
Judgment and contended that the reduction in salary during the Financial Year
2002-2003, constituted a restructuring of remuneration necessitated by the
financial difficulties faced by the Company and not a deferment of salary. It was
submitted that no document existed evidencing any commitment to repay the
reduced component of salary and that the Appellant/Plaintiff had raised no
claim in this regard, during his employment.
34.
The Respondent stated that the Appellant was not entitled to gratuity
since, according to the Respondent, he had been appointed as Vice-President
Signed By:VIKAS
RFA 600/2024
ARORA
18:08:17
(Technology) w.e.f. 01.11.2001 and had resigned on 02.03.2005, thereby not
completing five years of continuous service as required under Section 4 of the
Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.
35.
In respect of the claim towards transfer allowance of USD 4,000, it was
submitted that the emails relied upon by the Appellant, had not been proved in
accordance with the provisions of the Indian Evidence Act. It was further
contended that the said claim pertained to the year 2001 and was therefore,
barred by limitation.
36.
The Respondent also relied upon the decision of this Court in Aithent
Technologies Pvt. Ltd. v. Archana Verma (RFA 608/2014, decided on
06.08.2018) to contend that the salary reduction undertaken during the Financial
Year 2002-03 constituted a restructuring of remuneration and not a deferment,
and that no agreement or document existed showing any enforceable obligation
to repay the reduced salary at a later stage.
Submissions heard and record perused.
37.
It is the case of the Appellant/Plaintiff, Mr. Sanjay Verma,that he joined
the Defendant Company on 28.07.1992 and continued in its employment till
02.03.2005. He stated that in 1995, he was sent to the U.S.A. and worked there
for about six years as Head of Technology. Thereafter, he returned to India and
joined as Vice President (Technology) with effect from 01.11.2001. The
Experience Certificate dated 02.03.2005 issued by the Defendant Company, Ex.
P-3, records that the Plaintiff had worked with the Defendant Company from
28.07.1992 to 02.03.2005, including six years in the New York office.
38.
The Plaintiff relied upon the letters dated 01.11.2001 Ex. P-1 and Ex. P-2
in respect of his salary and allowances. He also relied upon the salary slips for
March 2003 and April 2003, collectively exhibited as Ex. P-4. As per the
Plaintiff's case, his monthly salary prior to the reduction implemented during
Signed By:VIKAS
RFA 600/2024
ARORA
18:08:17
Financial Year 2002-03, was Rs.1,42,333/-. Indisputably, the salary was
reduced for one year and a sum of Rs.48,450/- per month was deducted
therefrom, towards deferred salary.
39.
The entire controversy, of reduced salary for one year during Financial
Year 2002-03s is whether it was deferred salary to be paid in the next year or
was it a part of restructuring of salary.
40.
The Plaintiff stated that despite the Defendant Company having ended
Financial Year 2001-2002 in profit, it was facing a cash-flow crunch mainly due
to outstanding receivables from affiliate companies, namely Velos and Canyon
Blue.According to the Plaintiff, towards the end of March 2002, a General
House Meeting was convened, which was addressed by the CEO, Mr. N. Venu
Gopal, and Mr. Sunil Vadhera, Director and Head of India Operations. It was
explained to the employees that the financial difficulty was temporary and their
cooperation was sought, to tide over the situation.The Plaintiff further stated
that the suggested measure involved deferment of part of the salaries of
employees on a graded scale, for a period of up to twelve months. It was also
stated that after the said period, the reduced salaries would be restored to predeferred levels. According to the Plaintiff, the employees were also promised
one month’s gross salary as compensation bonus.
41.
As per the Plaintiff, the deferment was implemented on a graded scale of
15%, 20%, 25% and 30% depending upon the salary bracket. Since the Plaintiff
fell in the highest salary bracket, Rs.48,450/- per month was reduced from his
salary for the period April 2002 to March 2003, amounting to Rs.5,81,400/-.
The Plaintiff further claimed one month’s gross salary of Rs.1,61,500/- as
compensation bonus. Thus, according to him, Rs.7,42,900/- became due
towards deferred salary and compensation bonus, as on 01.04.2003.
Signed By:VIKAS
RFA 600/2024
ARORA
18:08:17
42.
The Defendant Company, on the other hand, asserted that there was no
deferment of salary and that the salary structure had merely been restructured.
DW-1, Mr. Bunty Bisht, in his cross-examination, also stated that the salary of
employees earning above Rs.12,000/- per month was restructured and not
deferred. He admitted that the salary of the Plaintiff was reduced by Rs.48,450/per month, but stated that the Plaintiff accepted such reduction/restructuring, as
he was part of the decision-making from the Indian management side. He also
admitted that he had accepted the letter given by the Company regarding the
deferred salary. He further admitted that his salary was restored with effect from
01.04.2003.
43.
The Plaintiff also admitted that he had not given any objection at the time
of deferment and that he had no written document regarding demand of deferred
salary during his employment with the Defendant.He further admitted in his
cross-examination that no written letter was given to him by the Company
stating that his deferred salary would be paid in future. He also admitted that he
had no record or document regarding deferred salary having been paid by the
Defendant to other employees.
44.
Though the Plaintiff has sought to characterize the arrangement as
deferment of salary, but admittedly, there is no written agreement, board
resolution, policy document or contemporaneous record produced by him to
establish that the reduced salary component, was agreed to be paid to him on
01.04.2003 or at any future date.
45.
The Plaintiff has also placed reliance upon the e-mail chain dated
09.07.2002 Ex. PW-2/1 and the connected correspondence. The said
correspondence shows that the management was discussing the impact of the
decision announced in April, 2002 regarding reduction of salaries and, in that
context, the expression “deferred salaries” was used. The CEO, in his response
Signed By:VIKAS
RFA 600/2024
ARORA
18:08:17
dated 09.07.2002, also expressed agreement with partially reversing the
decision for a category of employees with effect from 01.10.2002. However,
neither the said e-mail nor the connected correspondence records any decision
that the reduced component of the Plaintiff's salary would be accumulated and
repaid to him on 01.04.2003 or on any other specified date. There is likewise no
reference therein to payment of one month's gross salary as compensation
bonus. At best, the correspondence indicates that the management was
reviewing the salary reduction measures and considering restoration of salaries.
It does not establish the specific pleaded case of the Plaintiff that a sum of
Rs.5,81,400/- towards reduced salary and compensation bonus became due and
payable to him as a matter of contractual obligation.
46.
Another significant aspect is the conduct of the Plaintiff. According to
him, the deferred salary became payable on 01.04.2003. However, he continued
in the employment of the Defendant Company till 02.03.2005. During his crossexamination, he admitted that he had no written document regarding any
demand for deferred salary during his employment with the Defendant. If the
reduced salary had in fact crystallized into an admitted liability from
01.04.2003, there is no explanation as to why no written demand was ever
raised by the Plaintiff during the period of almost two years thereafter, while he
continued in service.
47.
This conduct of the Plaintiff, in not insisting upon payment of the alleged
deferred salary during his employment and raising the claim only thereafter,
also supports the conclusion that there was no formal agreed policy of the
Defendant Company, to repay the reduced salary as deferred salary.
48.
The Plaintiff has also placed reliance upon the letter dated 01.04.2005Ex.
PW-1/20, wherein the Defendant allegedly stated that if payment was not made
by 31.05.2005, interest would be paid. The same is reproduced as under:
Signed By:VIKAS
RFA 600/2024
ARORA
18:08:17
49.
However, the said communication neither quantifies the alleged dues nor
identifies their nature. There is no specific reference to the reduced salary for
Financial Year 2002-03, no mention of compensation bonus and no recital that
the salary reduction was merely a deferment to be repaid at a future date.
50.
The Plaintiff also sent his Demand Letter dated 20.03.2006,wherein he
demanded his dues. However, the said letter is only a demand raised by the
Plaintiff himself. It does not establish that the Defendant Company had accepted
any liability towards deferred salary or compensation bonus.
51.
It is not disputed that there were discussions regarding payment of one
month's salary bonus to employees.However, the Plaintiff has failed to place on
record any material to establish that the said bonus crystallized, into a binding
contractual obligation. The consistent stand of the Defendant has been that the
same was contemplated only as a loyalty incentive or moral commitment and
not as a legal obligation. In the absence of any document or other cogent
evidence showing that the bonus became payable as a matter of right, the claim
towards compensation bonus cannot be sustained.
Signed By:VIKAS
RFA 600/2024
ARORA
18:08:17
52.
This conclusion also finds support from the judgment of a Coordinate
Bench of this Court in M/s Aithent Technologies Pvt. Ltd. v. Archana Verma
(RFA 608/2014 decided on 06.08.2018), arising out of the same salary
restructuring exercise undertaken by the Respondent Company, during the
Financial Year 2002-03. The Coordinate Bench, while examining a similar
claim of deferred salary, observed that there was no material on record to
establish any arrangement of deferment and consequently, set aside the decree
granted by the Trial Court.
53.
Thus, the learned Trial Court has correctly appreciated the evidence in so
far as the claim towards deferred salary and compensation bonus is concerned.
54.
The Plaintiff has further claimed USD 4,000, equivalent to
Rs.1,80,000/-, towards transfer allowance on account of his transfer from
the U.S.A. to India. He has relied upon e-mails dated 05.10.2004 and
06.10.2004, Mark PW-1/B. However, the learned Trial Court has rightly held
that the said e-mails were not proved in accordance with law, as no certificate
under Section 65B of the Indian Evidence Act was filed and proved. Moreover,
the claim pertained to the year 2001, whereas the Suit was instituted in the year
2006. The claim towards transfer allowance was, therefore, rightly rejected
and also rightly held to be time barred.
55.
The Plaintiff has also claimed gratuity of Rs.3,50,000/-.In this regard,
Ex. P-3 assumes significance, which has been admitted by the Defendant. The
said Experience Certificate, issued by the Defendant Company itself, records
that the Plaintiff worked with the Defendant Company from 28.07.1992 till
02.03.2005, including a period of six years in the New York office and records
that during his tenure, he served the Company in various capacities including
Project Manager, Senior Project Manager, Group Leader and Vice President
(Technology).
Signed By:VIKAS
RFA 600/2024
ARORA
18:08:17
56.
Furthermore, DW-1, in his cross-examination, stated that the Plaintiff
joined the Defendant Company in India in November, 2001 and prior thereto,
was working with the Defendant Company in New York, U.S.A. He also
admitted that he had no document to show that the Plaintiff had resigned from
the Defendant Company, before shifting to U.S.A.
57.
In view of Ex. P-3 and the admission of DW-1 that he had no document
to show that the Plaintiff had resigned before shifting to the U.S.A., the finding
of the learned Trial Court that the Plaintiff failed to establish continuous
service, cannot be sustained. The material on record prima facie indicates that
the Plaintiff remained in the service of the Defendant Company from
28.07.1992 till 02.03.2005.
58.
However, the claim raised by the Plaintiff is essentially one for gratuity
payable under the provisions of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The
determination of entitlement, computation of the amount payable and all
incidental questions arising therefrom, fall within the statutory framework
provided under the said Act. The Act provides a complete mechanism for
adjudication of such claims before the competent Authority.
59.
In these circumstances, while the reasoning adopted by the learned Trial
Court for rejecting the claim for gratuity cannot be sustained, this Court does
not consider it appropriate to adjudicate the claim for gratuity in the present
proceedings. The Appellant/Plaintiff is accordingly granted liberty to avail of
such remedies as may be available to him in law under the Payment of Gratuity
Act, 1972 before the competent forum.
60.
All questions relating to entitlement, computation, limitation and other
objections are left open to be considered by the competent authority in
accordance with law.
Signed By:VIKAS
RFA 600/2024
ARORA
18:08:17
Conclusion:
61.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, the Appeal is dismissed in so far as
the claims towards deferred salary, compensation bonus and transfer allowance
are concerned.
62.
In respect of the claim for gratuity, the Appellant/Plaintiff is granted
liberty to avail of such remedies as may be available to him in law before the
competent Authority/forum under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972.
63.
Pending application (s), if any, stand disposed of.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
JUNE 16, 2026/R
Signed By:VIKAS
RFA 600/2024
ARORA
18:08:17
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review