The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
28. We have perused the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court rendered in the case of Virender Chaudhary Vs. Bharat Petroleum Corporation and Others reported in (2009) 1 In the said case, the letter of intent was issued to the appellant on 06.05.2004, however, the respondent no.5 filed the writ petition only on or about 23.11.2004. The said writ petition was dismissed as withdrawn giving liberty to file fresh writ petition. The second writ petition filed by the respondent no. 5 was allowed by the High Court. In appeal, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that the High Court had failed to take into consideration the effect of delay and laches on the part of the respondent no.5 in approaching the High Court. It was further held that a remedy under writ jurisdiction is discretionary in nature and the court exercises the said jurisdiction only upon satisfying itself that it would be equitable to do so. It was further held that the equitable principles have been repeatedly applied for not granting a relief and/or a limited relief in favour of the applicant in a case of this nature.
29. For the reasons as discussed above, we do not find any infirmity in the order dated 22.08.2023 passed by the learned single Judge in W.P.C No. 3015 of 2021.
30. The present appeal is, accordingly, dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
L.P.A. No.631 of 2023
With
I.A. No.11282 of 2023
----Sanjay Kumar Dubey, son of Late Niranjan Kumar Dubey,
resident of village Tatrapas, P.O. & P.S. Rajpur, District Chatra
(Jharkhand)-825401.
.......... Appellant.
-Versus1. India Oil Corporation Limited, through its Chief Manager,
Indian Oil Bhawan, G-9, Ali Yavar, Jung Marg, Bandra (East),
P.O. & P.S. Bandra (East), Mumbai-400051.
2. Divisional Manager, Indian Oil Corporation Limited, Ranchi
Divisional Office, 2nd Floor, SPG Mart, Bahu Bazar Chauk, Old
Hazaribag Road, Ranchi-834001 (Old Address)
New Address- Indian Oil Corporation Ltd., Ranchi Depot,
Namkom, P.O. & P.S. Namkom, District Ranchi-834010.
3. Ajit Kumar Singh, S/o Brinda Singh, R/o Khap Lawani, P.O. &
P.S. Rajpur, District Chatra-825401.
.......... Respondents.
----CORAM :
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
----For the Appellant :
Mr. Sachin Kumar, Advocate
Ms. Aditi Raj, Advocate
For the Respondents:
Mr. Rahul Lamba, Advocate
Ms. Kanu Priya, Advocate
Mr. Anish Kamal, Advocate
----Reserved on 14.09.2026
Pronounced on 21.09.2026
Per: Rajesh Shankar, J.
1.
I.A. No.11282 of 2023 seeks condonation of delay of 62 days in
instituting the accompanying appeal.
2.
We have perused the averments in the I.A. and we are satisfied
that sufficient cause has been shown. Even otherwise, the delay
is not inordinate.
3.
Hench, the delay is condoned and I.A. No.11282 of 2023 is
disposed of.
4.
The present Letters Patent Appeal is directed against the
judgment/order dated 22.08.2023 passed by the learned Single
Judge, dismissing the writ petition being W.P.(C) No.3015 of 2021
filed by the petitioner/appellant.
5.
The learned counsel for the appellant submits that the Divisional
Manager, Indian Oil Corporation Limited, Ranchi Divisional Office
(respondent no.2) invited applications from the interested eligible
persons for appointment of Regular/Rural Retail Outlet (Petrol
Pump) Dealership at various locations in the State of Jharkhand,
including the location mentioned as “within 2 Kms. from
Kanhachatti block towards Untamore, Block - Kanhachatti,
District- Chatra” (hereinafter referred as ‘the said dealership’)
under open category vide notice published in daily newspaper
‘The Telegraph’ dated 25.11.2018.
6.
It is also submitted that pursuant to the notice dated 25.11.2018,
the appellant submitted duly filled application annexing the
required documents of the land appertaining to plot nos. 166 &
167, situated at Mouza – Tatra, P.S Rajpur, P.S No. 97, Anchal –
Kanhachatti, District – Chatra along with requisite fee of
Rs.8000/- on 23.12.2018 for allotment of the said dealership.
Subsequently, the draw of lots for selection of the retail outlet
(R.O.) dealership was conducted on 21.06.2019.
7.
It is further submitted that the respondent-Corporation informed
the appellant vide letter dated 22.6.2019 that he was declared as
successful applicant in the said draw of lots. The appellant was
further directed vide letter dated 27.06.2019 to remit Rs.40,000/Page 2 of 10
through online mode towards initial security deposit and to
submit the required documents as specified in the said letter
within 10 days.
8.
It is also submitted that the appellant remitted the initial security
deposit of Rs. 40,000/ in favour of the respondent-Corporation
and thereafter vide letter dated 14.10.2019, the respondentCorporation informed the appellant that the Land Evaluation
Committee (L.E.C.) of the Corporation would visit the site offered
by him at the concerned location for inspection on 23.10.19 and
he was asked to be personally present at the site on the said date
along with photo identity card issued by any department of the
Government and the relevant documents relating to the land.
9.
Learned counsel for the appellant further submits that on
23.10.2019, the Land Evaluation Committee visited the site
offered by the appellant. The said Committee verified the
documents relating to the said land i.e. plot nos.166 & 167
including the map, ‘Jamabandi’ records and the rent receipts.
After inspecting the proposed site and verifying the documents,
the Land Evaluation Committee was quite satisfied with the land
at plot no.167 owned and possessed by the applicant as the said
plot was fulfilling the requirements mentioned in the Brochure for
selection
of
dealership
for
Regular/Rural
Retail
Outlets
(hereinafter referred as the Brochure).
10. It is also submitted that the appellant was shocked and surprised
to receive the letter dated 29.02.2020 issued by respondentCorporation, informing him that he was found ineligible for the
said dealership as the Land Evaluation Committee had found the
site offered by him not fulfilling the required norms for awarding
the dealership. The cause of ineligibility mentioned in the said
letter was that the applicant was not in possession of the offered
plot of required dimension and area.
11. Thereafter, the appellant made several representations including
the representations dated 13.3.2020, 4.11.2020 and 13.7.2021
to the Deputy General Manager/Manager (Retail Marketing),
Indian Oil Corporation Limited, Divisional Office, Namkum Depot,
Ranchi against the rejection of his candidature relating to
allotment of the said dealership, however the same were not
responded.
12. The appellant then filed a writ petition being W.P.(S) No.3015 of
2021, however, the said writ petition was dismissed by the
learned Single Judge vide order dated 22.08.2023 which has been
challenged in the present appeal.
13. According to the learned counsel for the appellant, the learned
single Judge failed to appreciate that if the uncles of the appellant
were not considered as the family members under Clause 4(v)(e)
of the said Brochure, they should have at least been treated as
“third persons” and in such a situation, the consent given by his
uncles in the form of an affidavit under Appendix IIIA was
required to be taken into consideration by the respondentCorporation.
14. It is further submitted that before issuing the letter dated
29.02.2020, the respondent-Corporation did not seek any
clarification from the appellant towards the objection with respect
to the dimension and area of plot no.167, which was 20 decimals.
15. It is contended that the appellant had presented all the required
documents of the said land before the Land Evaluation Committee
during its spot visit on 23.10.2019 which fulfilled all the eligibility
criteria for grant of the said dealership, however the respondentCorporation arbitrarily declared him ineligible.
16. On the contrary, the learned counsel for the respondents submits
that the said land was owned by the grandfather of the appellant
who had died leaving behind his three sons and the father of the
appellant had only 1/3rd share of the total area of 20 decimals i.e.
6.33 decimals of land (equivalent to 256 sq. mtr.) which was less
than the required dimension and area as specified in the Brochure
for Selection of Dealers for Regular & Rural Retail Outlets.
17. It is further submitted that the respondent-Corporation vide letter
dated 29.02.2020 informed the appellant that his application
under Group-1 category was found ineligible, since the land
required with the required dimension and area was not in his
possession. The said letter also mentioned that the application of
the appellant would be considered for selection along with Group3 applicants as per the guidelines.
18. It is also urged that the Letter of Intent for the said dealership
has already been issued by the respondent-Corporation in favour
of one Jitendra Kumar Dubey. The said fact was also stated in
the supplementary counter affidavit dated 21.08.2023 filed
before the writ court.
19. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the
materials placed on record.
20. Undisputably, as per the notice dated 25.11.2018 issued for
allotment of the said dealership, the minimum required area of
the land was 400 sq. meters with dimension of 20 meters x 20
meters. No doubt, the area of the land appertaining to plot no.167
offered by the appellant for allotment of the said dealership was
20 decimals and its dimension was 32 meters (front) and 20
meters (depth), which was more than the required dimension.
However, the said land was recorded in the name of the
grandfather of the appellant who died intestate. As such, the said
land got devolved in his three sons having equal share.
21. The appellant has claimed that the said land came to his father’s
share and he was in possession of the same. The basis of the said
claim was the land possession certificate of the said land issued
in his favour by the Circle Officer, Kanhachatti. He was, however,
not able to show any document suggesting ownership of the
entire 20 decimals of land either before the respondentCorporation or before the Writ Court which was mandatory for
allotment of said dealership.
22. In view of the aforesaid fact, the respondent-Corporation
considered his ownership only over the land measuring an area
of 6.33 decimals (equivalent to 256 Sq. mtrs.) which was much
less than the dimension required for allotment of the said retail
outlet. The rest part of the land which was in the share of the
uncles of the appellant, was not treated by the respondentPage 6 of 10
Corporation as the land belonging to the family members as
defined in Clause 4 (V) (e) of the said Brochure.
23. Learned counsel for the appellant has also contended that at least
21 days’ time should have been given to the appellant by the
respondent-Corporation
before
issuing
the
letter
dated
29.02.2020 seeking clarification about the objection raised by the
IOC with respect to the said land. The appellant has, however,
failed to show before this Court as to what prejudice has been
caused to him due to not giving him such opportunity. It is trite
that not complying the principle of natural justice is not always
fatal unless any prejudice is caused to the aggrieved person by
such non-compliance.
24. Admittedly, the appellant along with his family members as
described under Clause 4(v)(e) of the said Brochure did not have
the exclusive ownership of the said land and thus he was not
holding the minimum required area of land for allotment of the
said dealership. The appellant could have been granted time only
if the defect in any document filed by him was of curable nature.
Since the appellant did not have the exclusive ownership of the
land, even if he was provided further time, the same would not
have changed the position. In such a situation, providing further
opportunity to him would have been a futile exercise. That
situation has rightly been avoided by the respondents by making
offer to the next eligible applicant.
25. Further contention of the learned counsel for the appellant is that
the case of the appellant should have been treated under Clause
4(v)(i) of the said Brochure by considering the affidavits of his
uncles in the form under Appendix IIIA submitted along with the
application. We do not find any substance in the said contention
as the appellant had applied for allotment of the dealership under
Group 1 for which the condition was that the applicant should
have possessed suitable piece of land at the advertised location
either by way of ownership or long-term lease for a period of
minimum 19 years and 11 months. Moreover, the said condition
should be read conjointly with the condition mentioned in Clause
4(v)(j) of the said Brochure. As per Clause 4(v)(j), if the
ownership of the land relied upon by the applicant is with others,
then the share of the applicant and/or his family members must
be more than or equal to the land required by the respondentCorporation. However, in the present case the appellant’s share
in the said land was only 6.33 decimals which was less than the
land required by the respondent-Corporation.
26. In any view of the matter, the said dealership has already been
awarded to one Jitendra Kumar Dubey and the retail outlet is
stated to be already functioning. The said fact was averred by the
respondent-Corporation by way of supplementary counter
affidavit dated 21.08.2023 filed before the writ court itself. Thus,
the appellant was having the knowledge of allotment of the said
dealership in favour of Jitendra Kumar Dubey. Despite that, the
appellant did not implead the said allottee as respondent before
the writ court.
27. At the time of filing of the present appeal also, the appellant did
not implead the allottee-Jitendra Kumar Dubey as respondent and
after more than six months, he filed I.A No. 5885 of 2024 seeking
deletion of the name of the respondent no.3 and impleadment of
the allottee- Jitendra Kumar Dubey in the present appeal. Thus,
due to the delay and latches on the part of the appellant, a third
party right has been created with respect to the said dealership.
28. We have perused the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
rendered in the case of Virender Chaudhary Vs. Bharat
Petroleum Corporation and Others reported in (2009) 1
SCC 297, which has been relied by the respondent-Corporation.
In the said case, the letter of intent was issued to the appellant
on 06.05.2004, however, the respondent no.5 filed the writ
petition only on or about 23.11.2004. The said writ petition was
dismissed as withdrawn giving liberty to file fresh writ petition.
The second writ petition filed by the respondent no. 5 was
allowed by the High Court. In appeal, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
held that the High Court had failed to take into consideration the
effect of delay and laches on the part of the respondent no.5 in
approaching the High Court. It was further held that a remedy
under writ jurisdiction is discretionary in nature and the court
exercises the said jurisdiction only upon satisfying itself that it
would be equitable to do so. It was further held that the equitable
principles have been repeatedly applied for not granting a relief
and/or a limited relief in favour of the applicant in a case of this
nature.
29. For the reasons as discussed above, we do not find any infirmity
in the order dated 22.08.2023 passed by the learned single Judge
in W.P.C No. 3015 of 2021.
30. The present appeal is, accordingly, dismissed.
31. Pending I.A., if any, is also dismissed
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
21st September, 2026
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
Sanjay/AFR
Uploaded on 23.09.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review