The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. For the reasons recorded, we are of the considered opinion that the material on record are not sufficient for holding that the alleged activities of the detenu have either affected adversely or likely to affect adversely the maintenance of public order and therefore, the subjective satisfaction arrived at by the detaining authority cannot be said to be legal, valid and in accordance with law.
11. Accordingly, this petition stands allowed. The order impugned dated 13.08.2026 passed by the respondent authority is hereby quashed. We direct the detenu to be set at liberty forthwith, if he is not required in any other case. Rule is made absolute accordingly. Direct service permitted. (GITA GOPI,J) (L. S. PIRZADA, J) Hitesh Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/SCR.A/12458/2026(GJHC240640162026)
ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/SPECIAL CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO. 12458 of 2026
==========================================================
SANJAY JAYANTBHAI CHHANABHAI RATHO THROUGH ANITABEN
MAHESHBHAI RATHOD
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT & ORS.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR PRITESHKUMAR A VAGHELA(10078) for the Applicant(s) No. 1
MS KRISHNABEN A VAGHELA(12885) for the Applicant(s) No. 1
MR HARDIK SONI APP for the Respondent(s) No. 1
RULE NOT RECD BACK for the Respondent(s) No. 2
RULE SERVED for the Respondent(s) No. 3
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MS. JUSTICE GITA GOPI
and
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE L. S. PIRZADA
Date : 14/09/2026
ORDER
(PER : HONOURABLE MS. JUSTICE GITA GOPI)
1.
The petitioner herein came to be preventively detained vide
the detention order dated 13.08.2026 passed by the respondent
authority as a “dangerous person” as defined under Section 2(c) of
the Gujarat Prevention of Anti-social Activities Act, 1985 (hereinafter
referred as ‘the Act of 1985’).
2.
By way of this petition, the petitioner has challenged the
legality and validity of the aforesaid order.
3.
This Court has heard learned the advocates appearing for the
respective parties.
4.
Learned advocate for the detenu submits that the grounds of
R/SCR.A/12458/2026(GJHC240640162026)
ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
detention has no nexus to the “public order”, but is a purely a
matter of law and order, as registration of the offence cannot be
said to have either affected adversely or likely to affect adverse the
maintenance of public order as contemplated under the explanation
sub-section (4) of Section 3 of the Act, 1985 and therefore, where
the offences alleged to have been committed by the detenu have no
bearing on the question of maintenance of public order and his
activities could be said to be a prejudicial only to the maintenance
of law and order and not prejudicial to the maintenance of public
order.
5.
On the other hand, learned APP opposing the application
contended that the detenu is habitual offender and his activities
affected the society at large. In such set of circumstances, the
detaining authority, considering the antecedents and past activities
of the detenu, has passed the impugned order with a view to
preventing him from acting in any manner prejudicial to the
maintenance of public order in the area of Ahmedabad City.
6.
Having considered the facts as well as the submissions made
by the respective parties, the issue arises as to whether the order of
detention passed by the detaining authority in exercise of the
powers under the provisions of the Act of 1985 is sustainable in law?
7.
The order impugned was executed upon the detenu. In the
grounds of detention, a reference of criminal cases i.e. (i) for the
offence under Sections 118, 296B, 115, 54 of BNS and 135(1) of the
G.P. Act with Shaherkotda Police Station and (ii) Sections 189(2),
190, 191(1), 125, 324(4), 118(1), 115(2) and 351(3) of BNS with
Shaherkotda Police Station were made and further it is alleged that
the activities of the detenu as a “dangerous person” affects
adversely or are likely to affect adversely the maintenance of public
R/SCR.A/12458/2026(GJHC240640162026)
ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
order as explained under Section 3 of the Act of 1985.
8.
After careful consideration of the material, we are of the
considered view that on the basis of the criminal cases, the
authority has wrongly arrived at the subjective satisfaction that the
activities of the detenu could be termed to be acting in a manner
‘prejudicial to the maintenance of public order’. In our opinion, the
said offences do not have any bearing on the maintenance of public
order.
9.
The distinction between "public order" and "law and order"
has been carefully defined in a Constitution Bench judgment of the
Supreme Court in the case of Dr. Ram Manohar Lohia v. State of
Bihar and Others, (1966) 1 SCR 709. In this judgment, His
Lordship Hidayatullah, J. by giving various illustrations clearly
defined the "public order" and "law and order". Relevant portion of
the judgment reads thus:
"....Does the expression "public order" take in every
kind of disorder or only some? The answer to this
serves to distinguish "public order" from "law and
order" because the latter undoubtedly takes in all
of them. Public order if disturbed, must lead to
public disorder. Every breach of the peace does not
lead to public disorder. When two drunkards
quarrel and fight there is disorder but not public
disorder. They can be dealt with under the powers
to maintain law and order but cannot be detained
on the ground that they were disturbing public
order. Suppose that the two fighters were of rival
communities and one of them tried to raise
communal passions. The problem is still one of law
and order but it raises the apprehension of public
disorder. Other examples can be imagined. The
contravention of law always affects order but
before it can be said to affect public order, it must
affect the community or the public at large. A mere
disturbance of law and order leading to disorder is
thus not necessarily sufficient for action under the
R/SCR.A/12458/2026(GJHC240640162026)
ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
Defence of India Act but disturbances which
subvert the public order are. A District Magistrate is
entitled to take action under Rule 30(l)(b) to
prevent subversion of public order but not in aid of
maintenance of law and order under ordinary
circumstances.
It will thus appear that just as "public order" in the
rulings of this Court (earlier cited) was said to
comprehend disorders of less gravity than those
affecting "security of State", "law and order" also
comprehends disorders of less gravity than those
affecting "public order". One has to imagine three
concentric circles. Law and order represents the
largest circle within which is the next circle
representing public order and the smallest circle
represents security of State. It is then easy to see
that an act may affect law and order but not public
order just as an act may affect public order but not
security of the State...."
9.1
The concept of `public order' and `law and order' has been
dealt with in the case of Pushkar Mukherjee & Others v. The
State of West Bengal, AIR 1970 SC 852. In this case, the
Hon'ble Supreme Court had relied on the important work of Dr. Allen
on `Legal Duties' and spelled out the distinction between `public'
and `private' crimes in the realm of jurisprudence. In considering
the material elements of crime, the historic tests which each
community applies are intrinsic wrongfulness and social expediency
which are the two most important factors which have led to the
designation
of
certain
conduct
as
criminal.
Dr.
Allen
has
distinguished `public' and `private' crimes in the sense that some
offences primarily injure specific persons and only secondarily the
public interest, while others directly injure the public interest and
affect individuals only remotely. There is a broad distinction along
these lines, but differences naturally arise in the application of any
such test.
R/SCR.A/12458/2026(GJHC240640162026)
9.2
ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Babul Mitra alias
Anil Mitra v. State of West Bengal & Others, (1973) 1 SCC
393 had an occasion to deal with the question of "public order" and
"law and order". The Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed that the
true distinction between the areas of "law and order" and "public
order" is one of degree and extent of the reach of the act in
question upon society. The Court pointed out that the act by itself is
not determinant of its own gravity. In its quality it may not differ but
in its potentiality it may be very different.
9.3
In Commissioner of Police & Others, v. C. Anita (Smt.),
(2004) 7 SCC 467, the Hon’ble Supreme Court again examined the
issue of "public order" and "law and order" and observed thus:
"7. ....The crucial issue is whether the activities of
the detenu were prejudicial to public order. While
the expression "law and order" is wider in scope
inasmuch as contravention of law always affects
order, "public order" has a narrower ambit, and
public order could be affected by only such
contravention which affects the community or the
public at large. Public order is the even tempo of
life of the community taking the country as a whole
or even a specified locality. The distinction
between the areas of "law and order" and "public
order" is one of the degree and extent of the reach
of the act in question on society. It is the
potentiality of the act to disturb the even tempo of
life of the community which makes it prejudicial to
the maintenance of the public order. If a
contravention in its effect is confined only to a few
individuals directly involved as distinct from a wide
spectrum of the public, it could raise problem of
law and order only. It is the length, magnitude and
intensity of the terror wave unleashed by a
particular eruption of disorder that helps to
distinguish it as an act affecting "public order" from
that concerning "law and order". The question to
ask is:
R/SCR.A/12458/2026(GJHC240640162026)
ORDER DATED: 14/09/2026
"Does it lead to disturbance of the current life of the
community so as to amount to a disturbance of the
public order or does it affect merely an individual
leaving the tranquility of the society undisturbed?"
This question has to be faced in every case on its facts."
10.
For the reasons recorded, we are of the considered opinion
that the material on record are not sufficient for holding that the
alleged activities of the detenu have either affected adversely or
likely to affect adversely the maintenance of public order and
therefore, the subjective satisfaction arrived at by the detaining
authority cannot be said to be legal, valid and in accordance with
law.
11.
Accordingly, this petition stands allowed. The order impugned
dated 13.08.2026 passed by the respondent authority is hereby
quashed. We direct the detenu to be set at liberty forthwith, if he is
not required in any other case. Rule is made absolute accordingly.
Direct service permitted.
(GITA GOPI,J)
(L. S. PIRZADA, J)
Hitesh
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review