Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of Decision: 13th January, 2026
Uploaded on: 17th January, 2026
+
RC.REV. 708/2019 & CM APPL. 55332/2019
SANJAY GUPTA
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Rajat Aneja and Ms. Sonali
Chopra, Advocates.
versus
JAKKI MULL & SONS
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Sanjeev Sahay, Mr. Shagun
Saproo, Mr. Archit Rajput, Mr. Karan
Deep Singh and Mr. Nupur Singh,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT SHARMA
JUDGMENT
AMIT SHARMA, J.
1.
The hearing in the present case has been conducted through hybrid
mode.
2.
The present petition under Section 25B(8) of the Delhi Rent Control
Act, 1958, (for short, 8DRCA9), has been filed seeking the following prayers:
<In view of the facts and circumstances mentioned above it is
most respectfully prayed that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased
to:
i Call for the records of MISC SCJ No. 34/2019; Sanjay Gupta
Vs. Jakki Mull & Sons and RC ARC No. 29/2018; Sanjay Gupta
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
Vs. Jakki Mull & Sons from the Court of the Senior Civil Judgecum-Rent Controller, New Delhi District, Patiala House Court,
Delhi;
ii Allow the present Petition and set aside the Order dated
02.09.2019 passed in MISC SCJ No. 34/2019; Sanjay Gupta Vs.
Jakki Mull & Sons whereby while allowing the Review
Application filed by the Respondent herein, the Court of Shri
Bhupinder Singh, Senior Civil Judge-cum-Rent Controller, New
Delhi District, Patiala House Court, Delhi erroneously set aside
the Eviction Order dated 05.03.2019 passed by the Court of Ms.
Namrita Aggarwal, Senior Civil Judge-cum-Rent Controller,
New Delhi District, Patiala House Court, Delhi in RC ARC No.
29/2018; Sanjay Gupta Vs. Jakki Mull & Sons; and/or
iii. Pass any other or further order(s) as this Hon'ble Court may
deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the present
case.=
3.
The petitioner had filed an eviction petition, RC No.29/18, under
Section 14(1)(e) read with Section 25B of the DRCA against the respondent
with respect to Shop Nos.E-25; E-26; E-27, E Block, Connaught Place, New
Delhi (hereinafter referred to as 8demised premises9), on 17.04.2018 The
respondent filed application seeking leave to defend the said eviction petition
on 30.05.2018. Learned Rent Controller, vide judgment dated 05.03.2019,
while dismissing the said application, allowed the eviction petition in favour
of the petitioner. It was held that the respondent had failed to raise any triable
issue, which required evidence to be proved and the petitioner had clearly
established his bonafide requirement regarding the demised premises, and
therefore, the petitioner was entitled to recovery of the demised premises.
4.
Thereafter, a review application, MISC SCJ No.34/19, on behalf of the
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
respondent under Section 114 read with Order XLVII Rule 1 read with
Section 151 of the CPC seeking review of the judgment dated 05.03.2019 was
filed on 23.04.2019. By that time, the roster had changed. The newly
constituted learned Rent Controller vide the impugned order dated 02.09.2019
allowed the review application filed by the respondent and set aside the
judgment dated 05.03.2019.
5.
It is pertinent to note the history of litigation between the parties. There
were two other eviction petitions filed by the petitioner against the
respondent. The first eviction petition, E.No.87/09/1998, was filed by the
petitioner under Sections 14(1)(b) & (j) of the DRCA wherein, respondent
denied the title of the petitioner and the existence of landlord-tenant
relationship between the parties. Learned RC vide judgment dated 14.02.2014
dismissed the said petition as the petitioner had failed to prove his case of
eviction under Sections 14(1)(b) & (j) of the DRCA. The petitioner assailed
the said judgment dated 14.02.2014 by way of an appeal under Section 38 of
the DRCA and vide order dated 07.04.2021, learned Tribunal had adjourned
the said appeal sine die awaiting the judgment of this Court in the present
petition. The second petition, RC ARC No.5434/2010, was filed by the
petitioner on account of bonafide requirements of his wife, daughter, son, and
himself, under Section 14(1)(e) of the DRCA. In this petition as well, the
respondent denied the title of the petitioner and the existence of landlordtenant relationship. Learned RC vide order dated 29.11.2012 in this petition
granted leave to defend to the respondent. A challenge against the said order
by way of a revision petition, RC.REV.106/2013, by the petitioner was
disposed of by a consent order dated 14.10.2014 passed by learned Coordinate
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
Bench whereby, it was directed that both the parties will not get more than
two opportunities to complete their respective evidence and learned ARC was
directed to expedite the disposal of eviction petition by completing the hearing
of final arguments within three months of completion of evidence. Thereafter,
on an application of the respondent, learned RC adjourned the second petition
sine die vide order dated 16.05.2015 till the appeal against the judgment dated
14.02.2014 is decided by learned Appellate Court. Subsequently, in 2018, the
petitioner approached learned RC and vide order dated 16.04.20218, the
petitioner withdrew the second eviction petition on the ground that the
bonafide requirement as pleaded in the petition had since changed and the
same no longer existed.
6.
It is further pertinent to note that the petitioner is deriving title in the
subject property on the ground that initially the subject property was taken,
vide perpetual release dated 04.01.1926, by M/s L. Gopinath (HUF), which
was taken over by the former's father in 1948. In 1964, the father of the
petitioner filed a suit, Suit No.652/64, for partition of the joint family
properties owned by M/s L. Gopinath and the same was decreed vide decree
dated 02.11.1964. It is the case of the petitioner that all properties enumerated
in Schedule-8E9 of the report of the Court Commissioner to the said decree
were to the exclusive and absolute ownership of the petitioner and all the
members/coparceners of M/s L. Gopinath had duly accepted the said decree
and never challenged the same in any Court of law, and thus, the decree dated
02.11.1964 had attained finality.
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has firstly, submitted that the
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
respondent has grossly abused the process of the Court as it had remedy to
approach this Court by way of a revision petition under Section 25B(8) of the
DRCA, if it was aggrieved by the judgment dated 05.03.2019. He further
submitted that the review application was filed by the respondent after expiry
of two months of passing of the judgment dated 05.02.2019 and when the
learned Presiding Officer who had passed the said judgment was transferred.
It is further submitted that the ground taken in the review application was that
there was an error apparent on the face of the record. It is the case of the
petitioner that the respondent had waited for the transfer of the learned
Presiding Judge and had then filed the review application. Reliance has been
placed on the judgment of Hon9ble Supreme Court in Vedanta Limited v.
Goa Foundation & Ors.1, and it is contended that the Hon9ble Supreme
Court has disapproved the practice adopted by litigants of filing review
applications after the learned Presiding Judge who had passed the judgment
has retired or has been transferred.
8.
Secondly, he has submitted that the impugned order dated 02.09.2019
was passed by learned Successor RC by overriding the scope of powers of a
Court under Order XLVII Rule 1 of the CPC as vide the said order learned
RC had re-appreciated the entire material on record and had reversed the
findings contained in judgment dated 05.03.2019. Thirdly, it is submitted that
learned RC while passing the impugned order had erred in holding that a
patent error has been passed by overlooking the two findings of the respective
Courts in earlier eviction petitions regarding non-existence of landlord-tenant
(2021) 7 SCC 206
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
relationship and not giving due weightage to the concept of res-judicata. It is
the case of the petitioner that in the first eviction petition, E.No.87/09/1998,
filed in 1998, reliance was placed on certified copy of the partition decree
dated 02.11.1964, which was prepared and attested on 14.05.1968 and during
the course of final arguments, it was realised that an error has crept in the said
certified copy, and on closer examination of the same with report of Court
commissioner, it was noted that in paragraph 4, Schedule-8F9 was incorrectly
typed in place of Schedule-8E9 and Ajay Gupta was incorrectly typed in place
of petitioner – Sanjay Gupta. It is, however, pointed out that learned
Predecessor RC with respect to the said examination, held that due to lack of
clarity in respect of certain facts in question, the petitioner was not found to
be the landlord, or owner of the demised premises and accordingly, the said
eviction petition was dismissed vide judgment dated 14.02.2014. Attention of
the Court has been drawn towards paragraph (iii) under heading, 8Alleged
dispute qua the ownership of the Tenant Premises:9 in the subject eviction
petition filed by the petitioner as well as towards paragraph Nos.11 to 11.7 of
the judgment dated 05.03.2019 passed in the subject eviction petition and it is
contended that learned Predecessor RC had examined all the aforesaid issues
with respect to the ownership as well as existence of landlord–tenant
relationship amongst the parties and the same was not considered by learned
Successor RC while reviewing the aforesaid judgment in the impugned order.
Attention of this Court has also been drawn towards paragraph Nos.21 to 23
in judgment dated 14.02.2014 passed in E.No.87/09/98, the first eviction
petition, to show the manner in which the issue of landlord-tenant relationship
was dealt in the said judgment. It is also the case of the petitioner that the
respondent had no locus standi to raise the dispute with respect to the title of
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
the petitioner qua him as the subject property was obtained from a partition
decree which had attained finality way back in 1964-65 and the title of the
petitioner has not been disputed by his other shareholders in the said HUFM/s L. Gopinath and the standard of the proof to make out a case under
Section 14(1)(e) of the DRCA was duly fulfilled. Thus, there cannot be resjudicata operating with respect to an issue to which the other party litigant
never had locus standi. It is further submitted that the aforesaid rectification
with respect to the name of the petitioner in the Schedule of the report of the
Court Commissioner was done by learned ASCJ vide order dated 21.12.2015
in M.No.17/15, on an application filed jointly by the petitioner, his fatherY.N. Gupta, his brother-Ajay Gupta, seeking correction of certain
typographical errors/mistakes in the certified copy of decree dated
02.11.1964, and accordingly, a fresh decree was directed to be drawn. It is
submitted that in view of these circumstances, the second eviction petition
filed by the petitioner was withdrawn as there was change in bonafide
requirement of the petitioner and thereafter, the subject petition was filed.
Reliance has been placed on the judgment passed by learned Coordinate
Bench of this Court in Mukesh Khanna v. Des Raj Jewellers2, to contend
that in similar circumstances, it was held that mere disagreement with the
view taken cannot be a ground to modify, or alter the findings passed by the
Predecessor Court and the impugned order therein was set aside.
9.
It is further the case of the petitioner that learned RC in the impugned
order has completely ignored the settled principle of law that, under Section
2025: DHC: 10773
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
14(1)(e) of the DRCA landlord is not supposed to prove absolute ownership
and is required to show that he holds the title better than a tenant. It is further
submitted that in the impugned order, learned Successor RC has taken into
account wholly irrelevant considerations and had given fact findings, which
were already given by his predecessor on merits. It is further submitted that
the observations made in paragraph 17 of the impugned order is totally
misconceived as there were no erstwhile fact findings on merits with respect
to the existence of landlord – tenant relationship between the petitioner and
the respondents. It is, therefore, submitted that the impugned order suffers
from illegalities, irregularities and perversity and the same is to be set aside.
10.
Reliance has been placed on following judgments by learned counsel
for the petitioner in support of his case: a) Haridas v. Usha Rani Bank (Smt) & Ors3,
b) Shri Ram Gopal v. Shri Purshottam Dass4;
c) Smt. Shanti Sharma & Ors v. Smt. Ved Prabha & ORs.5;
d) Meenakshi v. Ramesh Khanna And Anr.6;
e) Ramesh Chand v. Ugnati Devi7;
f) N.R. Narayan Swamy v. B. Francis Jagan8,
g) Baldev Singh Bajwa v. Monish Saini9,
(2006) 4 SCC 78
2014:DHC:3749
(1987) 4 SCC 193
1995 SCC OnLine Del 373
2008 LAWPACK (Del) 36791: 2009(157) DLT 450
(2001) 6 SCC 473
(2005) 12 SCC 778
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
h) Sarla Ahuja v. United India Insurance Company Ltd.10,
i) Harsh Kumar & Ors. v. Man Mohan & Ors11.
11.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondent has submitted that the
impugned order has been passed by learned Successor RC after taking into
account, the error apparent and patent illegality on the face of the record in
the judgment dated 05.03.2019 inasmuch as learned Predecessor RC had
failed to take into account that there was no landlord – tenant relationship
between the parties. It is submitted that the learned Predecessor had failed to
take into account that, in the first eviction petition, it was specifically held by
learned RC, after trial, that the petitioner cannot be treated as a landlord. It is
further submitted that the second eviction petition was withdrawn by the
petitioner citing changes in bonafide requirement; however, there was no
change with respect to the title of the parties. Therefore, since there were
findings given by two Courts with respect to the title of the parties and the
same amounted to res-judicata between the parties and it was incorrectly
recorded in judgment dated 05.03.2019 by learned RC that said findings given
in earlier eviction petitions are not binding. It is the case of the respondent
that since the petitioner was not able to obtain any favourable order in the two
erstwhile petitions, which were dismissed, after substantial hearing, he had
filed the subject petition. It is further submitted that by way of the subject
petition, the petitioner was trying to achieve indirectly what he could not do
directly.
(1998) 8 SCC 119
2012:DHC:1620
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
12.
He further submitted that learned Predecessor RC had not taken into
account the findings in the first eviction petition that the petitioner did not
have any pre-existing right in the demised premises and same was not subject
matter of the decree dated 02.11.1964 which was in the nature of compromise
decree, and therefore, in absence of any registered document in favour of the
petitioner pursuant to said decree, no title with respect to the demised
premises could have been said to be devolved on the petitioner. It is pointed
out that learned Predecessor RC had erred in holding that the petitioner was
landlord as rent was never paid to the petitioner and instead, all the rent
receipts were in the name of M/s L. Gopinath. It is pointed out that findings
in the judgment dated 14.02.2014 given in first eviction petition were also to
the effect that the petitioner was not the landlord and learned Predecessor RC
had erred in concluding in paragraph 11.2 of the judgment dated 05.03.2019
that the petitioner was the owner of the properties mentioned in Schedule-8E9
of the report of the Local Commissioner which included the demised
premises. It is submitted that the respondent was inducted as a tenant in the
demised premises by M/s L. Gopinath, HUF.
13.
It is the case of the respondent that the petitioner in order to wriggle out
the adverse findings against him had abused the process of the Court by filing
multiple petitions. With respect to subsequent events, it is submitted that the
demise of Y.N. Gupta, father of the petitioner, was rightly taken into account
by learned Successor RC as the same was an important event for devolvement
of the properties on the petitioner and other legal heirs. It is further submitted
that the second eviction petition, RC No.5434/10, was withdrawn by the
petitioner vide order dated 16.04.2018 by way of an application for
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
withdrawal under Order XXIII Rule 1 read with Section 151 of the CPC filed
by the petitioner and the same was also to be taken into account as conduct of
the petitioner.
14.
Reliance has been placed on paragraph Nos. 20 to 20.2 in the judgment
of Hon9ble Supreme Court in Kamlesh Verma v. Mayawati & Ors.12, with
respect to the principles and grounds of review and the circumstances in which
review will be or will not be maintainable. It is submitted that there were
concurrent findings with respect to the status/title of the parties and it was
held that the parties do not have any landlord-tenant relationship and the said
cogent findings cannot be brushed aside.
15.
Reliance has also been placed on the judgment of Bhoop Singh v. Ram
Singh Major and Others13, to contend that the petitioner did not have any
registered document to show how he was deriving title of landlord/owner in
the demised premises. It is the contention of respondent that the demised
premises were not subject matter of the decree dated 02.11.1964, and
therefore, no title could be stated to have transferred on the petitioner by the
said decree insofar as the subject property is concerned for the want of stamp
duty and registration.
16.
Reliance has also been placed on the judgment of Prem Kishore &
Ors. v. Brahm Prakash & Ors.14, to contend that in nearly similar
(2013) 8 SCC 320
(1995) 5 SCC 709: AIR 1996 SC 196
(2023) 19 SCC 244
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
circumstances, wherein, earlier eviction petition was dismissed as the
plaintiffs/appellants therein failed to appear before learned RC for the purpose
of establishing the relationship of landlord and tenant between the parties
despite several opportunities and subsequently, fresh eviction petition was
filed after demise of original plaintiff, the Hon9ble Supreme Court had
observed that where the issue of establishing landlord and tenant relationship
between the parties was decided on merits, the fresh suit/petition is not
maintainable on the principles of res-judicata. It is submitted that the case of
the respondent in the present case stands on better footing as there were two
concurrent findings in favour of the respondent which were not taken into
account by learned Predecessor RC in judgment dated 05.03.2019. In view of
the aforesaid submissions, it is prayed that the impugned order dated
02.09.2019 need no interference and the present petition be dismissed.
17.
In rejoinder, learned counsel for the petitioner has drawn attention of
this Court towards the following prayers in the suit, CS 58973/2016, filed
seeking declaration and permanent injunction instituted by the respondent
through its partner against the father of the petitioner, Y.N. Gupta, and other
coparceners in M/s L. Gopinath, HUF, wherein the petitioner was also arrayed
as Defendant No.2: <It is, therefore, most respectfully prayed that the Hon9ble Court
be pleased to pass a decree with costs in favour of the plaintiff
and against the defendants:
i.
Declaring the partition Decree partition decree and
certified copies of amended/corrected partition decree alleged to
have been passed in CS No. 124/2015 (Old CS No. 652/1694)
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
title Yatender Nath Gupta Vs. Smt. Meenaxi Gupta and others
illegal unlawful, void, non operative since the same has been
obtained by playing fraud on the Hon9ble Court by concealment
of facts as well as misrepresentation of facts in collusion with
each other who have been the partiers to the said partition decree
or amended/corrected partition and not binding on the plaintiffs.
ii.
Restraining defendant No. 2 from claiming as well as
representing himself as the owner/landlord of property No. E27/1-3 (E-25 to E-27), Connaught Place, New Delhi-11001 on
the basis of partition decree and certified copies of
amended/corrected partition decree alleged to have been passed
in CS No. 124/2015 (Old CS No. 652/1694) title Yatender Nath
Gupta Vs. Smt. Meenaxi Gupta and others since the same has
been obtained by playing fraud on the Hon9ble Court by
concealment of facts as well as misrepresentation of facts in
collusion with each other who have been the partiers to the said
partition decree or amended/corrected partition decree till the
disposal of the present suit.
iii. Any other relief which this Hon9ble Court may deem fit
and proper be also passed in favour of the plaintiff and against
the defendants.
iv.
Cost of the suit be also awarded in favour of the plaintiff
and against defendants.=
It is pointed out that plaint in the aforesaid suit was rejected by the
learned ACJ/CCJ vide order dated 21.03.2018 on the application moved on
behalf of the defendant Nos.1&3 under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that the learned ACJ/CCJ, in
the said order, had observed that the plaintiffs (respondent herein) cannot seek
declaration qua validity of the partition between the defendants (coparceners
of M/s L. Gopinath, HUF) as it does not infringe their rights as tenant in the
property in any manner, and further that, the respondent cannot seek
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
permanent injunction for restraining the petitioner herein from claiming and
representing himself to be the landlord/owner of the suit property concerned
as no cause of action was accrued in its favour.
18.
Thus, it is submitted that the learned Successor RC had erred in
reversing the findings given by learned Predecessor RC under review
jurisdiction and granting leave to defend to the respondent. It is therefore
prayed that the impugned order dated 02.09.2019 is to be set-aside.
19.
Heard learned counsels for the parties and perused the records.
20.
At the very outset, it is pertinent to note that learned RC in the
impugned order dated 02.09.2019 had referred to the judgment of Hon9ble
Supreme Court in Kamlesh Verma v. Mayawati (supra), on which reliance
has also been placed on by learned counsel for the respondent. In Kamlesh
Verma (supra), the Hon9ble Supreme Court had summarised the principles
when a review of judgment/order is or is not maintainable. The relevant
paragraphs of the said judgment read as under: <19. Review proceedings are not by way of an appeal and have to
be strictly confined to the scope and ambit of Order 47 Rule 1 CPC.
In review jurisdiction, mere disagreement with the view of the
judgment cannot be the ground for invoking the same. As long as
the point is already dealt with and answered, the parties are not
entitled to challenge the impugned judgment in the guise that an
alternative view is possible under the review jurisdiction.
Summary of the principles
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
20. Thus, in view of the above, the following grounds of review are
maintainable as stipulated by the statute:
20.1. When the review will be maintainable:
(i) Discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, after
the exercise of due diligence, was not within knowledge of the
petitioner or could not be produced by him;
(ii) Mistake or error apparent on the face of the record;
(iii) Any other sufficient reason.
The words <any other sufficient reason= have been interpreted
in Chhajju Ram v. Neki [(1921-22) 49 IA 144 : (1922) 16 LW 37 :
AIR 1922 PC 112] and approved by this Court in Moran Mar
Basselios Catholicos v. Most Rev. Mar Poulose Athanasius [AIR
1954 SC 526 : (1955) 1 SCR 520] to mean <a reason sufficient on
grounds at least analogous to those specified in the rule=. The same
principles have been reiterated in Union of India v. Sandur
Manganese & Iron Ores Ltd. [(2013) 8 SCC 337 : JT (2013) 8 SC
275]
20.2. When the review will not be maintainable:
(i) A repetition of old and overruled argument is not enough to
reopen concluded adjudications.
(ii) Minor mistakes of inconsequential import.
(iii) Review proceedings cannot be equated with the original
hearing of the case.
(iv) Review is not maintainable unless the material error, manifest
on the face of the order, undermines its soundness or results in
miscarriage of justice.
(v) A review is by no means an appeal in disguise whereby an
erroneous decision is reheard and corrected but lies only for patent
error.
(vi) The mere possibility of two views on the subject cannot be a
ground for review.
(vii) The error apparent on the face of the record should not be an
error which has to be fished out and searched.
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
(viii) The appreciation of evidence on record is fully within the
domain of the appellate court, it cannot be permitted to be advanced
in the review petition.
(ix) Review is not maintainable when the same relief sought at the
time of arguing the main matter had been negatived.=
21.
In the impugned order dated 02.09.2019, on the review application filed
on behalf of the respondent, learned Successor RC had proceeded to examine
the case by observing as under: <11. In the present matter, the applicant has highlighted that this court,
while passing order dated applicant 05/03/2019 failed to take into
account many issues that were raised before it, in particular that of
res-judicata and also the binding precedence/judgments. Also that the
court did not take in account the important facts/documents
(subsequent events) which were sought to be placed by the Applicant
through applications.=
22.
Perusal of the review application filed by the respondent shows that the
grounds taken therein, with respect to plea of res-judicata, additional
documents placed on record by way of subsequent application, question of
title and the relationship of landlord and tenant, different standards of proof
and conduct of the petitioner were duly dealt with by learned Predecessor RC.
The aforesaid grounds taken in the review application for the sake of
completeness are reproduced hereinunder: “A. BECAUSE the Learned Predecessor Court committed an error in
not appreciating and considering the averments as set out in the leave
to defend application, wherein the Applicant/ Respondent has been
able to raise prima facie, triable issue which seems to have been
overlooked by the Learned Predecessor Court, and which could not
be prematurely decided, without adjudication by way of evidence. As
such, the Applicant/Respondent cannot be thrown out of the tenanted
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
premises at the threshold at least till, the time, the Petitioner are able
to make out their case of bona fide requirement of the same. The
impugned order is thus liable to be recalled and set aside.
B. BECAUSE the Learned Predecessor Court erred in overlooking
the vital issue of Res Judicata raised by the Applicant/Respondent,
which the Learned Predecessor Court in its Order dated 07.01.2019
observed that the same shall be considered at the time of arguments
on leave to defend and not considering the same since as per law laid
down in Om Prakash Gupta Vs. Dr. Rattan Singh 1963 PLR 543. The
law laid down by Hon'ble Supreme Court is binding on all the Courts
in India as per Constitution of India and how the said decision of Om
Prakash Gupta was not binding on Learned Predecessor Court is in
itself is grave error of law.
C. BECAUSE the Learned Predecessor Court failed to appreciate that
the binding precedence/judgments, which in itself is sufficient to
'review the impugned order.
D. BECAUSE the Learned Predecessor Court while passing the
Impugned Order dated 05.03.2019, miserably failed to and infact
denied to consider the important facts/documents, sought to be placed
on record through different applications, which facts were subsequent
and documents, which came to knowledge of the Applicant late but
all having the immense impact on the merits of the case. But the
Learned Predecessor Court, adopting a strange procedure declined to
consider the same.
E. BECAUSE the Learned Predecessor Court while passing the
Impugned Order dated 05.03.2019 committed a grave errors in law by
ignoring well settled principles of law that in cases of eviction on the
ground of requirement of laid down by Hon'ble additional
accommodation as Supreme Court in Santosh Soni Vs. Chand Kiran
2000 JT (3) SC 397 and Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in numerous (1)
Ashok Kumar Gupta Vs. Rajesh judgments such as Kuman & Another
by Hon'ble Mr.Justice V.K. Shali, 2016 (154) DRJ 75, (2) Gulab
Singh Versus Sher Singh by Hon'ble Ms. Justice Mukta Gupta, 2015
(6) AD Delhi 137 on the point of subsequent events, (3) Sudershan
Kumar Versus Harish Chand Garg by Hon'ble Mr. Justice Manmohan
Singh, 2014 (143) DRJ 489 (4) Sanjay Chugh versus Opender Nath
Ahuja by Hon'ble Mr. Justice Manmohan Singh, 2014 (4) AD Delhi
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
83; (5) Depak Gupta Versus Sushma Aggarwal by Hon'ble Mr. Justice
Manmohan Singh, 2013 (202) DLT 121 (6) ritpal Singh Versus
Ramesh Kumar Dora by Hon'ble Mr. Justice Manmohan Singh, 2014
(143) DRJ 489 (7) Kishore Versus Prabodh Kumar by Hon'ble Mr.
Justice M. L. Mehta, 2012 (132) DRJ 562, (8) Sukh Dev Raj Sharma
Versus Kuljeet Singh by Hon'ble Mr. Justice M. L. Mehta, 2012 (195)
DLT 56, (9) S.K. Seth & Sons Versus Vijay Bhalla, by Hon'ble Mr.
Justice M. L. Mehta, 2012 (191) DLT 722, (10) Rajinder Singh Versus
Mange Lal by Hon'ble Mr. Justice Manmohan Şarin, 1998 (73), DLT
177, (11) Shrimani Arora Versus A.K. Garg, by Hon'ble Ms. Justice
Usha Mehra, 1997 (67) DLT 140 and subsequent judgments.
D. BECAUSE the Learned Predecessor Court erred in closing its eyes
to the Overseas Citizenship of India Scheme Card of the Petitioner
and his wife mentioning the profession of the Petitioner as "Airline
Staff= and that of his wife as "Transliterator". From the said
documents it is evident that the Petitioner and his wife are gainfully
employed in USA and therefore filing of the present. Petition is
nothing but manipulation and vexatious attempt to evict the
Applicant/Respondent.
E. BECAUSE the Learned Predecessor Court had erred in not
appreciating that under the Overseas Citizenship of India Scheme the
said person is permitted to practice only certain professions. The
proposed business sought to be carried on by the Petitioner cannot be
professed by him under the said scheme being a foreigner.
F. BECAUSE the Learned Predecessor Court committed an error of
law in not appreciating and failure to examine that the question of title
and the relationship of the landlord & tenant between the parties
regarding the premises in question, which was not only expressly
raised in an earlier Eviction Petition No. E-87/09/98 titled "Sanjay
Gupta Vs. M/ Jakki Mull & Sons & Others" under Section 14 (1) (b)
& M(j) but was also expressly decided between the parties by the
Learned Predecessor Court of Sh. Prashant Sharma (the then ARC,
New Delhi District, Patiala House Courts, New Delhi), vide
judgment/order dated 14.02.2014 after full trial, as such there was no
question for the Learned Predecessor Court herself, to hold that the
said earlier decision dated 14.02.2014 does not operate as Resjudicata. It is submitted that the Learned Counsel for the Respondent
neither filed any replies to the applications dismissed by the Learned
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
RC vide the impugned order, nor argued against the proposition of
law of Res-judicata at the time of arguments.
G. BECAUSE the Learned Predecessor Court also, miserably rather
overlooked, failed to. appreciate and the conspicuous and malafide
conduct of the Petitioner, of withdrawing the earlier eviction petition
(under Section 14 (1) (e) of DRC, Act) wherein not only the leave to
defend was granted by the court of Shri Manoj Kumar, the then (the
then RC, New Delhi District, Patiala House Courts, New Delhi) but
the said petition was also consigned as sine die vide order dated
16.05.2015 by Ms. Kiran Gupta (the then RC, New Delhi District,
Patiala House Courts, New. Delhi), after passing of the judgment
dated 14.02.2014. The entire exercise of withdrawing the earlier
similar petition and then filing of the present eviction petition In
question, was nothing but to somehow by-pass the orders of grant of
leave to defend as well as of consigning the said petition as sine die
which order otherwise had become final. It is submitted that the
Respondent has indulged himself in forum shopping and also
misusing the procedure of the law.
H. BECAUSE the Learned RC also miserably failed to appreciate and
apply the binding precedence of law passed by the Constitution bench
of Hon'ble Supreme Court in India in the case titled "Om Prakash
Gupta Vs. Dr. Rattan Singh" 1963, Punjab Law Reporter 543. The
relevant extract of the judgment is being reproduced herein below for
the convenience of this Hon'ble Court:
"If a person moves eviction of a person on the ground
that he is a tenant who had, by his acts and omissions,
made himself liable to be evicted on any one of the
grounds for eviction, and if the tenant denies that the
landlord, the Controller has to decide the question as
to whether there was a relationship of landlord and
tenant. If the Controller decides that there is no. such
relationship the proceedings has to be terminated,
without deciding the main question in controversy
namely, the question of eviction.”
It is, humbly submitted that since the decision dated 14.02.2014 by
the earlier competent court had already been taken, clearly holding
that the Respondent herein/petition in the eviction petition is neither
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
the legal owner and/or landlord of the property in question; the
Learned RC should have hold its hand and adjourned the eviction
petition sine-die, in view of the fact that appeal against the said
decision is pending adjudication before the RCT and there was soon
likelihood of passing the binding judgment by Learned RCT; instead
of dismissing the leave to defend application filed by the Petitioner
without any basis, on absurd grounds/reasons.
I. BECAUSE the Learned Predecessor Court also miserably failed to
appreciate that infact the judgment dated 14.02.2014 passed by Sh.
Prashant Sharma (the then ARC, New Delhi District, Patiala House
Courts, New Delhi), in an earlier Eviction Petition No. E-87/09/98
titled "Sanjay Gupta Vs. M/ Jakki Mull & Sons & Others" under
Section 14 (1) (b) & (j); has almost become final. It is so, as on
30.7.2018 the Petitioner had given up the grounds of eviction in the
said appeal filed /pending before the RCT, while seeking to press the
grounds of relationship of landlord and tenant. It is most humbly.
submitted that with the withdrawl of the eviction grounds nothing
survives in the said appeal since rent court in the absence of any
grounds the rent court have no jurisdiction to decide the relationship
of landlord and tenant/ownership etc. But the Learned RC did not
appreciate the same at all and passed the impugned order.
J. BECAUSE the Learned Predecessor Court cannot ignore the fact
that after passing of the judgment dated 14.02.2014 passed by Sh.
Prashant Sharma (as mentioned aforesaid), the Respondent
herein/Petitioner has no cause of action to claim himself as owner/
landlord of the premises till he is able to prove the same in appeal
pending before Learned RCT or by filing the suit for declaration
before the Civil Court so that the decision of Learned ARC Sh.
Prashant Sharma could be quashed and set-aside.
K. BECAUSE the Learned Predecessor Court miserably failed to
appreciate that the standard of proof of the petition under Section 14
(1) (e) and petition under Section 14 (1) (b) & (j) has nothing to do,
with the issue of relationship of landlord and tenant as well as the
ownership of the premises. The learned RC also miserably failed to
appreciate that basis of conclusion of the judgment dated/order dated
14.02.2014 was the evidence (both oral and documentary), which was
led by the parties to prove their respective stands i.e. after full fledged
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
trial and not that the then RC decided the said questions incidentally
or collaterally.
L. BECAUSE the Learned Predecessor Court wrongly relied upon
the judgment dated Ramesh Chander Vs. Uganti Devi 157, (2009)
DLT 450, to hold that the absolute ownership is not required to be
proved by the landlord which judgment is never applicable to the facts
of the present case. Learned Predecessor Court miserably failed to
appreciate the contents/facts/ratio of said complete judgment on the
one hand and the acts of the present case on the order hand are
different, while applying the said judgment in the present case. It is
submitted that the correct ratio of the said judgment is as under:
"It is. settled preposition of law that in the concept of
order to consider ownership under Delhi Rent Control
Act, the court has to see the title and right of the
landlord qua the tenant. The only thing to be seen by
the Court is that the landlord had been receiving rent
for his own benefit and not for and on behalf of
someone else. If the landlord receiving rent for himself
and not on behalf of someone else, he is to be
considered as the owner howsoever imperfect his title
over the premises may be. The imperfectness of the
title of the premises cannot stand in the way of an
eviction petition under Section 14 (1) (e) of the DRC
Act, neither the tenant can be allowed to raise the plea
of imperfect title or title not vesting in the landlord and
that too when the tenant has been paying rent to the
landlord. Section 116 of the Evidence Act creates
estoppels against such a tenant. A tenant can
challenge the title of landlord only after vacating the
premises and not when he is occupying the premises.
In fact, such a tenant who denies the title of the
landlord, qua the premises, to whom he is paying rent,
acts dishonestly"
M. BECAUSE the Learned Predecessor Court had apparently passed
the impugned Order dated 05.03.2019 without the application of
equity and good conscience and also without any caution and
circumspect.
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
O. BECAUSE the Learned Predecessor Court has not only failed to
apply the ratio of law settled by the judicial pronouncements under
the said provisions of law by High Court and the Apex Court but has
allowed himself to be guided by irrelevant considerations while
applying law to the facts of the case.
P. BECAUSE the impugned order on the face of the record is patent
and latent violation of provisions of law and the binding precedents
as the same has been passed in gross disregard to the same.=
23.
Perusal of the aforesaid grounds would show that the purpose of the
review application was to challenge the findings of learned Predecessor RC.
The observations made by learned Successor RC in the impugned order were
without any cogent or satisfactory reasons in respect of the grounds of review
provided under Order XLVII Rule 1 of the CPC.
24.
With respect to the contention raised on behalf of the respondent
regarding the non-consideration of submission of plea of res-judicata in
respect of non-existence of landlord-tenant relationship between the parties,
and non-consideration of subsequent event, it will be apposite to refer to the
relevant observations given by learned Predecessor RC vide judgment dated
05.03.2019 and learned Successor RC vide impugned order dated 02.09.2019,
which have been reproduced in tabulation form as under: Issues
Referred
Judgment dated 05.03.2019 Judgment dated 02.09.2019
passed
by
learned passed by learned Successor
Predecessor RC
RC
Ownership
11 The respondent has 13 There is no denial that
as well as disputed the ownership of initially, on 13/04/1998 a
existence of
petitioner over the tenanted petition u/s 14(1)(b) and (j) of
landlord-
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
tenant
relationship
premises as well as the
existence of landlord tenant
relationship between the
petitioner and respondent. It is
the case of respondent that
M/s. L Gopi Nath was the
owner / landlord of the
tenanted premises and as such
the property belonging to it
could not be partitioned. That
the partition decree of 1964 is
no decree in the eyes of law
being obtained by fraud
wherein the respondent was
not even a party and even
otherwise being unregistered
and unstamped. Per contra, it
is submitted by the petitioner
that he is the owner / landlord
of the tenanted premises and
that the respondent has also
paid rent to petitioner on
various occasions.
11.1 I have heard the
contentions of both the parties
and perused the records.
Perusal of the records shows
that in the petition the
petitioner
has
clearly
mentioned in para 19 the
entire history by virtue of
which the suit property
devolved upon the petitioner
from M/s. L Gopi Nath. It is
an admitted fact between the
the DRC Act,1958 was filed by
the Non -Applicant which was
dismissed vide order dated
14/02/2014. Also in the
petition u/s 14(l)(e) of the
DRC Act filed on 20/11/2010,
leave to defend was granted to
the Applicant,vide order dated
29/11/2012. The said order,
was challenged before Hon'ble
High Court which was
disposed off vide order dt. 14th
October 2014 on joint consent
of the parties that evidences
shall be led, meaning thereby
that the appellant (Non Applicant herein) admitted
that evidences has to be led to
prove the issue of landlordtenant between the parties.
14 The said petition u/s
14(1)(e) of the DRC Act was
adjourned sine die awaiting
outcome of the Appeal
preferred by the Non Applicant
against the order dated
14/02/2014 whereby petition
u/s 14(1)(b) &(j) of the DRC
Act was disposed off as
dismissed. The said Appeal
bearing No. RCT 12/2014
(renumbered as RCT No.
157/16) is stated to be still
pending before Ld. RCT.
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
petitioner and respondent that
the
tenanted
premises
belonged to the firm of M/s. L
Gopi Nath Further, it has
nowhere been disputed that
the petitioner is one of the
family member of L Gopi
Nath who was earlier the
proprietor of M/s. L Gopi
Nath. The respondent tried to
dispute the ownership of M/s.
L Gopi Nath stating that M/s.
L Gopi Nath has claimed its
ownership only on the basis of
a perpetual lease deed dt.
04.01.1926.
However,
respondent
himself
has
admitted at various places in
its leave to defend application
that it was inducted as a tenant
by M/s. L Gopi Nath and till
date continues to pay rent in
the name of M/s. L Gopi Nath.
That being the case, the
respondent cannot dispute the
title of M/s. L Gopi Nathi over
the premises in question.
Further, it is also not in
dispute that Sh. Y N Gupta ,
father of petitioner was the
successor in interest of M/s. L
Gopi Nath who was the
proprietor of M/s. L Gopi
Nath. Now being the eldest
member of family, after Sh.
Gopi Nath, Mr. Y N Gupta
15 As such the Applicant on
the aspect of landlord-tenant
issue, succeeded in full fledged
trial in petition u/s 14(l)(b) and
(j) of the DRC Act as well as in
Petition u/sl4(l)(e) DRC Act
filed in 2010 which when
challenged before Hon'bie
High Court was not set aside
and matter has sent back for
trial.
16 In the meantime petition u/s
14(l)(e) of the DRC Act which
was filed on 20/11/2010 RC
ARC No.5434/2010 was
withdrawn on 16/04/2018 and
the present petition was filed
citing change in the bonafide
requirements. However no
change was averred in the issue
of landlord -tenant relationship
between the parties.
17 This court is of the view that
a patent error has been
committed by overlooking the
two findings of the courts in
respective petitions E No.
87/09/98 ( under section 14(1)
(b) &(j) of DRC Act) and E.
No. 5434/2010 (under section
14(l)(e) of DRC Act) regarding
non existence of the landlord
and tenant relationship and not
giving due weightage to the
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
decided to partition the
property of the firm M/s. L
Gopi Nath between all the
family members for which a
partition suit bearing no.
652/64 titled as Sh Yatinder
Nath Vs. Minaxi Gupta & Ors
was filed . In fact the said suit
was decreed on 02.11.1964 by
which all the properties of
M/s. L Gopi Nath was
partitioned by metes and
bounds among the family
members. The objection
raised by the respondent that
the said partition decree is
forged and fabricated since
the respondent was not made
a party to it is without any
substance,
since
the
respondent is merely a tenant
in the premises in question
and a tenant who has no right,
title or interest over the
property by any stretch of
imagination can not be made
party to a partition suit which
is filed between the owners i.e
the family members to divide
the
properties
amongst
themselves. Further, the
respondent has also disputed
that the said partition deed dt.
02.11. 1964 stating that it is
no decree in the eye of law
since it is unstamped and
concept of res-judicata.
18 In Om Prakash vs Rattan
Singh(Supra), it was held that
"DRC act postulates the
relationship of landlord and
tenant which must be a
preexisting relationship. The
act is directed to control some
of the terms and Incidents of
the relationship. Hence, there
is no express provision In the
act empowering the controller,
or the tribunal, to determine
whether or not there is a
relationship of landlord and
tenant. In most cases such a
question would not arise for
determination
by
the
authorities under the act. The
act
proceeds
on
the
assumption that there is such a
relationship. However. If the
relationship is denied . the
authorities under the act have
to determine the questions
also, because a simple denial
of the relationship cannot oust
the jurisdiction of the tribunals
under the act. It is true that the
act does not in terms authorize
the authorities under the act to
determine finally the questions
of the landlord and tenant. The
act
proceeds
on
the
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
unregistered. The documents
on which the registration is
compulsory are given in
clauses A to E Sub clause (1)
of Section 17 of the
Registration Act. The decree
dt. 02.11.1964 effects the
partition of the immovable
property and therefore, it falls
under section 14(1)(b) of
Registration Act. However,
by virtue of the provisions
contained in Section 17(2)
(vi) of the Registration Act,
clause (b) of Sub Clause (1) of
Section 17 of the Registration
Act does not apply to any
decree or order of a court
except a decree or a order
expressed to be made on a
compromise and comprising
of immovable property other
than that which are subject
matter of suit or proceedings.
The decree dt. 02.11.1964 is
made on a compromise.
However, it does not
comprise of immovable
property other than that which
is subject matter of the suit
and therefore, the said decree
does not come within the
provisions of Section 17 of
the Registration Act and thus
does not require compulsory
registration. Moreover none
presumption that there is such
a
relationship.
If
the
relationship is denied, the
authorities under the act have
to determine the questions
also, because a simple denial
of the relationship cannot oust
the jurisdiction of the tribunals
under the act.
"If a person moves a controller
for eviction of a person on the
ground that he is a tenant who
had, by his acts and
omissions,made himself liable
to be evicted on any one of the
grounds for eviction,and if the
tenant denies that the plaintiff
is the landlord, the controller
has to decide the question as to
weather
there
was
a
relationship of landlord and
tenant. If the controller decides
that there is no such
relationship the proceedings
has to be terminated,without
deciding the main question in
controversy
namely
,the
question of eviction."
19 There is no gainsaying the
tribunals within the provision
of the Act, are tribunals of
exclusive jurisdiction and their
orders are finals and not liable
to be questioned by way of
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
of the family members of L
Gopi Nath who are effected
by the said partition deed had
ever challenged the said
decree
dt.
02.11.1964,
meaning thereby that the said
decree has become final and
binding upon all.
subsequent
petitions.
However, the findings of the
tribunals can be questioned by
way of separate suit or appeal.
An error apparent on the face
of the record seems to have
been
committed
by
overlooking the findings of the
court in eviction petitions no E
11.2 It is also averred by the 87/09/98 and 5434/2010.
respondent that in an earlier
eviction petition filed by the 20 In Brahm Prakash vs
petitioner
against
the Chando Devi C.R.P No.
respondent under section 1332/2002 , DoD 04/05/2010,
14(1)(b)& 14(1)(j) of DRC of Hon'ble Delhi High Court,
Act bearing no. E 87/09/98 it it was observed as under
was held by the Ld. ARC,
Patiala House Courts, New "12. The conditions necessary
Delhi vide judgment dt. for applying the principles of
14.02.2014 that there was a res- judicata are also fulfilled
doubt as to the status of Sh. Y in the present case, the matter
N Gupta qua the tenanted at hand in the second case,
premises due to his actions subject matter of the present
and depositions and that Sh. Y petition, was directly and
N Gupta is not the owner of substantially in issue in the
the
premises.
However, earlier petition. The earlier
perusal of the record shows petition as aiso the second
that the certified copy of the petition are between the same
partition decree filed before parties, as the respondents
the said court was the one claim under Sh. Samey Singh,
which was obtained on petitioner in the first eviction
14.05.1968 in which there petition. Both petitions related
was a typographical error. to the same premises. The
However, today the petitioner Court, which had decided the
has placed on record the former petition, was a Court
to
try
the
certified copy of the partition competent
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
decree which was obtained by
him on 20.01.1965. The said
certified copy of the partition
decree clearly mentioned that
all the properties mentioned in
schedule E of the report of the
Local Commissioner were
under the ownership of the
petitioner ie Sh. Sanjay
Gupta. Further Ld. ASCJ, Tis
Hazari Court was pleased to
hold that even in the certified
copy of the partition decree
which was obtained on
14.05.1968,
there
was
typographical error. Thus, the
filing of the correct partition
decree
having
no
typographical error and with
all the parties to the partition
suit approaching the court that
passed the decree and getting
error
rectified,
the
controversy can be put to rest
and it can be safely concluded
that Sh. Sanjay Gupta was
held to be the owner of the
properties mentioned in
schedule E of the report of the
Local Commissioner which
includes
the
tenanted
premises. Even otherwise the
respondent is trying to create
a confusion regarding the
status of petitioner over the
tenanted premises knowing
subsequent petition as well.
The matter, directly and
substantially in issue in the
second petition, was heard by
the Rent Controller in the
earlier petition and was finally
decided by dismissing the
eviction petition in view of
failure on the part of Shri
Samey Singh to establish the
relationship of landlord and
tenant between the parties.
18. By filing a subsequent
eviction
petition,
the
respondents
cannot
be
permitted to do directly,
what they could not do
indirectly. Failure to ad(duce
evidence,
resulting
in
dismissal of the claim of the
respondents for want of proof,
is in reality, a decision on
merits. Just as if the petitioner
therein had produced evidence,
which
the
Court
had
considered as inadequate proof
and had dismissed it upon the
said ground. Applicable to
such a situation is the legal
maxim. 'De non apparentibus
et non existentibus eadem est
ratio'. It is a rule which applies
to those things, which do not
appear, and to things which do
not exist. So, for maintaining
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
very well that the respondent
is nothing more than a tenant
in the premises in question
and was inducted in that
capacity by the predecessor in
interest of the petitioner L
Gopi Nath who at that time
was proprietor of M/s. L Gopi
Nath. In all the petitions under
Section
14(1)(e),
the
petitioner is not required to
prove his absolute ownership
over the tenanted premises but
he is only required to show
that he is something more
than a tenant in the premises
in question. Reliance in this
regard is placed upon the
judgment tiled as Ramesh
Chander Vs. Uganti Devi.
157 (2009) DLT 450 wherein
it has been held that
“In petition under section
14(1)(e) of the DRC Act the
absolute ownership is not
required to be proved by the
landlord. The landlord is just
required to show that he is
something more than a tenant.
Further if the landlord was
receiving the rent for himself
and not on behalf of someone
else, he is to be considered as
the owner, however imperfect
is title over the premises may
his right to claim arrears of
rent, if Sh.Samey Singh was
required to prove that he was
the landlord of the petitioner,
but he failed to do so, the Rent
Controller had no option but to
decide the issue against him on
account of non-production of
evidence. In other words, what
does not appear, must be
regarded as non-existent.
19. In these circumstances, the
decision of the Rent Controller
dated 27.01.1998, has to be
taken as a decision on the
merits of the matter. Merely
because a subsequent cause of
action has been pleaded by the
respondents in the second
eviction petition by claiming
arrears of rent not only for the
period for which the first
eviction petition was filed, but
also for the subsequent period
upto 18.05.2001, cannot be a
ground to hold that the second
eviction
petition
was
maintainable. The relationship
of landlord and tenant between
the parties was not established
in the earlier proceedings and
the same point is directly and
substantially in issue in the
second petition wherein the
foundation to claim the arrears
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
be."
11.3 In the present case as
well, the petitioner has
successfully proved that his
title qua the tenanted premises
is more than that of the
respondent being successor in
interest and a family member
of M/s. L Gopi Nath, having a
partition decree in his favour
and above all considering the
fact that the respondent till
date is depositing rent qua the
tenanted premises in favour of
M/s. L Gopi Nath which was
earlier a proprietorship firm of
the grandfather of the
petitioner and later the father
of petitioner. Thus the title of
the petitioner over the
tenanted premises definitely
better than that of respondent
which is the only requirement
which is required to be proved
in a petition under section
14(1)(e) of DRC Act.
of rent is the stand of the
respondents
(petitioners
therein) that they are the
landlords of the petitioner
herein. The findings returned
bv the Rent Controller in his
order dated 27.01.1998 passed
in the first petition have to be
held to be findings on merits
and having been adjudicated
conclusively, are final in
nature and act as a bar of res
judicata on the second eviction
petition preferred by the
respondents."
21 Reliance on the judgment
titled :"Shri Ram Gopal v.
Sh.
Purshottam
Dass
(Supra), by Ld. Counsel for
the Non- Applicant is
misconceived,
being
distinguishable on facts. Here
no such sale deed has been
filed to have no doubt about
the ownership of the Non
Applicant. The issue of
ownership can always be
agitated in subsequent judicial
proceedings but at the same
time it has to be proved. Sale
deed would have put an end to
the controversy but that is not
in the present case.
11.4 Further, it is clear that
under a Hindu law the
moment a son is born, he gets
share in his father's property
and became part of the
coparcenary. His right accrues
to him not on the death of the
father or inheritance from the 22
In
the
said
the
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
father but with the very fact of
his birth. That whatever be the
source of the property of the
father, his son must have a
share in that and the said
property becomes the part of
joint family property of his
son and grandson and other
members who forms joint
Hindu Family with him. In the
same way, premises in
question was joint Hindu
Family property of M/s. L
Gopi Nath of which the father
of petitioner Sh. Y N Gupta
was the first coparcener and a
Karta. The existence of this
fact is not disputed by the
respondent and thus the
respondent cannot dispute the
title of the petitioner. Further,
the respondent had also filed a
suit for declaration of the
partition decree 02.11.1964 as
null and void bearing no.
58973/16. However, the said
suit was dismissed as rejected
by the court under Order 7
Rule 11 CPC on the ground
that the respondent has no
locus to challenge the said
partition
decree
entered
between the family members
of L Gopi Nath.
backdrop/admitted facts , this
court is of the the view that
there appears to an error
apparent on the face in holding
that standards of proof of
ownership in petition u/s
14(l)(b) &{j) of the DRC Act
and that of petition u/s 14(l)(e)
of the DRC Act are different.
23 There also seems to be
wrong interpretation of the
ratio of judgment titled
Ramesh Chandler v. Uganti
Devi 157(2009)DLT 450 by
observing that the absolute
ownership is not required to be
proved by the landlord. As per
the said judgment, the person
receiving rent for himself was
to be considered as the owner
irrespective
of
the
imperfectness of his title, but
the same is not so in the present
case. Though averred in the
petition . no rent receipts in his
favor were produced bv the
Non Applicant.
24 Applicant's application dt
18/12/2018 for staying of the
proceedings was dismissed by
this court vide order dt.
09/01/2019. The said order
was changed before Hon'ble
11.5 Further, the observations High court and vide order
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
made by d. ARC in a petition
under section 14(1)(b) & (j) of
DRC Act regarding the
existence of landlord tenant
relationship between the
petitioner and the respondent
has no relevance to the
present petition since the
standard of proof required to
be proved by the petitioner in
petition
under
section
14(1)(e) of DRC Act is
entirely different from the
standard of proof required in a
petition
under
section
14(1)(b) & (j) of DRC Act.
Thus, from the totality of the
facts and circumstances and
the fact that the petitioner
today has brought to light the
correct certified copy of the
partition
decree
dt.
02.11.1964, wherein it has
been clearly held by the court
that the petitioner is exclusive
owner of the property in
question, it is held that for the
purpose of present petition,
petitioner is the owner/
landlord of the tenanted
premises and thus his very
well entitled to file the present
petition for his bonafide
requirement
against
the
respondent.
dt.04/02/2019 the said petition
was disposed off by observing
as under:
"In view thereof, the present
petition is disposed of to the
effect that the submissions that
are sought to be made by the
petitioner as prayed in its
application in relation to the
contentions
that
the
proceedings under sections
14(l)(e),14(l) (b) & 14(l)(j) of
the DRC Act ,1958 as
amended in relation to the
aspect of the relationship of
landlord and the tenant would
be on a similar footing and thus
the consequential aspect of the
principles of res-iudicata being
applicable.
would
be
considered bv the learned Rent
Controller.New Delhi without
being uninfluenced bv the
observations made in the
impugned
order
dated
07.01.2019."
25 However the said aspect of
applicability of res judicata
seems to have been got
overlooked in the order dated
05/03/2019 and no reasons of
applicability
of
different
standards of proof in petition
u/s 14(l)(e) and u/s 14(l)(b) and
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
11.6 It has also been averred
by the respondent that earlier
also the petitioner had filed an
eviction petition against the
respondent under section
14(1)(e) of DRC Act which
was withdrawn and now the
petitioner has again filed a
petition under the same
provision without pleading
any changed circumstances.
However, as per the petitioner
the cause of action to file the
present eviction petition is
different from that of the
earlier eviction. The cause of
action for filing a petition
under section 14(1)(e) of
DRC Act is a continuous
cause of action and merely
because the petitioner had
earlier filed an eviction
petition
for
bonafide
requirement
against
the
respondent does not disentitle the petitioner from
again filing a petition for his
own bonafide requirement
against
the
respondent
specially in the light of the
fact that after withdrawing the
earlier eviction petition, the
wife of petitioner had
obtained an order in her
favour for her bonafide
requirement qua property
(j) of the DRC Act was
discussed..
26 There seems to be an error
in deciding the issue of
landlord-tenant between the
parties just on the basis of
arguments, which is still
pending adjudication before
Ld. RCT. Detailed orders on
this issue has been passed by
Ld. ARC while disposing
petition u/s 14(l)(b) S((j) of the
DRC Act vide order dt.
14/02/2014, after full fledged
trial and Ld. RC while
allowing leave to defend in
petition u/s 14(l)(e) of the
DRC Act vide order dt.
29/11/2012.
Arguments /Affidavits could
not have taken place of trial.
27 The non applicant could
not have been allowed to abuse
the process of the court by
filing subsequent petitions
with the malafide intention of
overturning
the previous
findings of Ld. Rent Controller
in petition bearing E No.
87/09/98
and
E
No.
5434/2010. It is clear that the
petitioners tried to wriggle out
of the adverse finding against
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
bearing no. E 27/4. Even them by means of subsequent
otherwise the earlier eviction petitions.
petition filed by the petitioner
against the respondent under
section 14(1)(e) of DRC Act
was for the composite use of
himself, his wife and his
children whereas a lot has
changed over the span of so
many years and now the
bonafide requirement of the
petitioner in the present
petition is for his use only and
not for his other family
members.
11.7 It is also the case of the
respondent that the present
petition is not maintainable
since all the tenants being the
other partners of M/s. Jakki
Mull and Sons have not been
impleaded as a party to the
present
case.
However,
perusal of the record shows
that a single tenancy was
created in the name of firm
M/s. Jakki Mull & Sons which
has duly been arrayed as a
respondent in the present
petition. Even otherwise the
partnership firm and each of
its partners are mutual agents
of each other as per the
principle of mutual agency
and therefore, the partnership
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
firm or any of its partner
represents all others. Thus the
present petition against the
respondent
is
perfectly
maintainable.
Subsequent
Event(s)
13.4 Further, at the stage of
arguments, the respondent has
filed an application to place
on record the additional
documents in the form of
copy of the lease deed dt.
25.09.2017 and 20.03.2014
entered into between the
petitioner and other tenants
qua the other properties. The
respondent cannot be allowed
to place these documents at
this stage since these lease
deeds were executed way
back and the respondent had
all the opportunity to place
these documents alongwith
the
leave
to
defend
application or immediately
thereafter when the said
documents were executed . At
this stage, when the matter is
at the stage of arguments on
leave to defend application,
no new document which was
executed way back can be
filed by the respondent. Even
otherwise, these documents
are sought to be placed on
record only to show that the
28 While relying upon the
judgment titled Gulab Singh
Vs. Sher Singh (supra), it was
also urged by the applicant that
this court failed to consider the
important facts and documents
which were sought to be placed
on record through different
applications which came to the
knowledge of the applicant late
but all were having immense
impact on the merits of the
case. This court failed to
consider the fact that the
petitioner had inherited certain
more properties during the
pendency of the petition after
the death of his father. The
same fact was brought to the
notice of the court, however
the same was left without
considering. It was mentioned
in the application that in the
alleged partition decree of
the
petitioner(Non
Applicant herein) have shown
shop No.(s) 5490(E- 15),
5491(E-16),
5492{E-17),
5493(E-18),
5494{E19),5495(E-20), 8251(E-21),
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
petitioner is earning huge
amount of rent from various
other premises. However, as it
has been already mentioned
above, mere earning of rental
income by the petitioner is of
no consequence to a petition
for bonafide requirement of
petitioner since petitioner
being the landlord is well
within his right to start
independent business from
the premises in question when
he is admittedly presently not
running any other business
nor is engaged in other
employment in India. Hence,
the respondent has failed to
prove the availability of any
suitable accommodation with
the petitioner which can be
used by petitioner for his
bonafide requirement.
Flat No.5496,5497,5498 and
5499 situated in Connaught
Place ,New Delhi to have been
owned by Late Sh.Y. N Gupta
and as such after his death
devolved upon the petitioner
and other legal heirs of Late
Sh.Y.N Gupta. Order dt.
05/03/2019 of this court which
was passed subsequent to the
death of Late Sh.Y. N Gupta
and placing these facts before
the court does not reflect if
status of these properties was
considered.
29 It is settled law that an error
which is not self evident and
has to be dictated by a process
of reasoning can hardly be said
to be an error apparent on the
face of the record. However in
the present case, there exist an
error in overlooking the fact
that the said issue of landlord tenant has not been put to rest
in litigation between the
parties in other judicial
proceedings. There seems to
be an error in holding that the
standard of proof required to
be proved in petition u/s
14(l)(e) of DRC Act . By
withdrawing earlier petition
u/s 14(l)(e) DRC Act and filing
the present one just on the
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
basis of change in bonafide
requirement , the issue of
landlord-tenant did not got
settle. Earlier petition was
adjourned sine die for that very
reason. Before Ld. RCT, the
non
applicant
(appellant
therein) gave up the appeal on
the ground of unauthorized
construction and subletting
and only pressed the ground of
ownership and landlord-tenant
relationship, as is reflected in
the order sheet dt. 30.07.2018
of RCT No. 157/16. Thus the
issue of ownership and
landlord-tenant relationship
was admittedly in dispute.
Error seems to be apparent by
ignoring the said fact which
was evident and highlighted.
25.
A perusal of the aforesaid tabulation demonstrates that all the grounds
taken by the respondent in its review application before the learned Successor
RC were thoroughly dealt with on merits and decided by the learned
Predecessor RC. The plea of res judicata as taken by the respondent herein
with regard to the findings in earlier two eviction petitions was dealt with in
detail and it was concluded by the learned Predecessor RC vide judgment
dated 05.03.2019, that in view of the correct certified copy of the partition
decree dated 02.11.1964, a fresh cause of action had accrued in favour of the
petitioner herein. It was further observed by the learned Predecessor RC that
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
the standard of proof required to be proved by the petitioner in a petition under
Section 14(1)(e) of the DRCA is entirely different from the standard of proof
required in a petition under Sections 14(1)(b) & (j) of the DRCA. With respect
to the aforesaid, learned Successor RC in the impugned order has given
findings to the effect that the view taken by the learned Predecessor RC
appears to be an error apparent on the face of the record as standards of proof
of ownership required in a petition under Section 14(l)(e) and Sections
14(l)(b) and (j) of the DRCA are different and has also observed that the
learned Predecessor RC had wrongly interpreted the ratio of judgment
Ramesh Chandler v. Uganti Devi15, observing that absolute ownership is
not required to be proved by the landlord. Learned Successor RC has also
observed that the aspect of applicability of res judicata seems to have been
overlooked in the judgment dated 05.03.2019 and no reasons of applicability
of different standards of proof in a petition under Section 14(l)(e) and Sections
14(l)(b) and (j) of the DRCA was discussed.
26.
Similarly, the issue of subsequent events was considered by learned
Predecessor RC by observing that the same were of no consequence as no new
document which was executed way back can be filed by the respondent.
Sufficient reasons were also given for the same by the learned Predecessor
RC that such documents merely tend to show that the petitioner was then
earning a huge amount of rent. The said issue was again considered by the
learned Successor RC by observing that non-consideration of the said
subsequent events, i.e., death of the father of the petitioner-Y.N. Gupta and
157 (2009) DLT 450
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
devolvement of his properties on legal heirs including the petitioner, which
were brought on record by the respondent by way of an application was again
an error apparent by the learned Predecessor RC.
27.
In these circumstances, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
review application preferred on behalf of the respondent was an appeal in
disguise whereby the same arguments, which had been rejected by learned
Predecessor, were re-heard and decided in the impugned order. In Kamlesh
Verma (supra), the Hon9ble Supreme Court has already held that mere
possibility of two views on the subject cannot be a ground for review, and
also, the review is not maintainable when the same relief sought at the time
of arguing the main matter had been negatived. The respondent always had
an option to exercise its legal remedy of filing revision under Section 25B(8)
of the DRCA challenging the findings given by learned Predecessor RC vide
judgment dated 05.03.2019 both, factually and legally. However, by way of
the impugned order learned Successor RC has effectively exercised powers
of an appellate Court in review jurisdiction and proceeded to re-open the case
between the parties.
28.
Thus, there is manifest error in the impugned order dated 02.09.2019
passed by learned Successor RC and the same is set aside.
29.
Consequently, the original eviction judgment dated 05.03.2019 passed
by learned Predecessor RC is restored. The parties shall remain bound by the
terms/directions of the said original eviction judgment and will act in
consonance thereof.
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
30.
Interim order dated 10.01.2020 stands vacated.
31.
Copy of the judgment be sent to the concerned learned Senior Civil
Judge-cum-Rent Controller, New Delhi District, Patiala House Courts, Delhi,
for necessary information and compliance.
32.
The present petition is allowed and disposed of.
33.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of accordingly.
34.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court, forthwith.
AMIT SHARMA
(JUDGE)
JANUARY 13, 2026/sn/ns
SINGH RAWAT
16:48:36
RC.REV. 708/2019
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review