Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on: 19thFebruary, 2026
Pronounced on: 12thMay, 2026
RFA 1093/2025, CM APPL.75612/2025, 75853/2025 & 11472/2026
+
SANJAY GARG
S/o Sh. Bashesar Dayal,
R/o H.No. D-4/47, Sector 15,
Rohini, New Delhi.
.....Appellant
Through:
Mr.Sanjay Kumar Mishra, Advocate.
versus
SANJAY KUMAR ALIAS SANJAY MITTAL ALIAS SANJAY
S/o Sh. Tekchand,
R/o B-52, Overseas Apartment,
Sector 09, Rohini, New Delhi.
Through:
....Respondent
Appearance not given.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA
J U D G M
E N T
NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA, J.
CM APPL. 11472/2026 (Condonation of Delay)
1.
The present Application has been filed by the Appellant seeking
Condonation of Delay of 241 days, in filing the present Appeal.
2.
For the reasons mentioned in the Application the same is allowed.
The delay of 241 days in filing the present Appeal is Condoned.
3.
The Application stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
RFA1093/2025
4.
Regular First Appeal under Section 96 read with Order XLI Rule 1 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 has been preferred on behalf of the
KUMAR BHATT
16:22:15
RFA 1093/2025
Page1of10
Appellant/Defendant, Sh. Sanjay Garg assailing the ex-parteJudgment and
Decree dated 29.08.2024 whereby the Suit of the Plaintiff/Respondent for
recovery of Rs.21,50,000/- along with interest @ 6% per annum from the
date of institution of the Suit till realization, along with costs, was decreed
under Order XXXVII Rule 2(3) CPC, on account of failure of the
Defendant/Appellant to enter appearance within the prescribed period.
5.
The Appellant has further assailed the Judgment dated 17.10.2025
passed in MISC DJ No. 69/2025, whereby the Application under Order
XXXVII Rule 4 CPC seeking setting aside of the ex-parte Judgment and
Decree dated 29.08.2024, came to be dismissed.
6.
The Plaintiff filed CS DJ No. 315/2024, under Order XXXVII CPC
for recovery of Rs.21,50,000/- along with interest @ 6% per annum from
the date of institution of the Suit till realization, along with costs.
7.
The facts, in brief, are that the parties to the Suit, were known to each
other for a long period and shared cordial relations. It is the case of the
Plaintiff/Respondent that in the second week of January, 2022, the
Defendant/Appellant approached the Plaintiff/Respondent seeking financial
assistance by way of a friendly loan of Rs.10,00,000/-on the representation
that the said amount was required to be deposited as security, for procuring
certain contracts from the Governments of Uttar Pradesh and Bihar.
8.
The Plaintiff, believing the said representation and upon the assurance
of the Defendant/Appellant that the amount would be returned within ten
months, he advanced a sum of Rs.10,00,000/- to the Defendant/Appellant.
9.
Again,in the month of June, 2022, the Defendant/Appellant
approached
KUMAR BHATT
16:22:15
RFA 1093/2025
the
Plaintiff/Respondent
and
sought
afriendlyloan
of
Page2of10
Rs.6,50,000/-, assuring that the said amount would be repaid along with the
earlier loan amount.
10.
The Plaintiff further claimed that during thesaidperiod, the
Defendant/Appellant met the Plaintiff/Respondent on several occasions and
repeatedly assured that the entire friendly loan amount would be repaid as
per the agreed schedule.
11.
In the first week of September, 2022, the Defendant/Appellant visited
the office of the Plaintiff/Respondent and again sought a friendly loan of
Rs.5,00,000/- on the ground that the said amount was required for the
treatment of his sister-in-law.
12.
The Plaintiff/Respondent accordingly advanced the said amount on
the condition that the total loan amount of Rs.21,50,000/- would be repaid
by October, 2022. Thereafter, the Defendant/Appellant sought an extension
of approximately 3-4 months for repayment of the entire loan amount of
Rs.21,50,000/-.
13.
As per the Plaintiff/Respondent, upon persistent demands for
repayment of the loan amount, the Defendant/Appellant issued a post-dated
cheque bearing No. 697350 dated 01.06.2023 for a sum of Rs.21,50,000/-.
14.
On 30.05.2023, when the Plaintiff/Respondent informed the
Defendant/Appellant about the proposed presentation of the aforesaid
cheque for encashment, the Defendant/Appellant allegedly came to the
office of the Plaintiff/Respondent, created a ruckus/disturbance, caused
damage to the office property and also assaulted the Plaintiff/Respondent,
pursuant to which a complaint was lodged vide DD No. 69A dated
31.05.2023 in localpolice station.
KUMAR BHATT
16:22:15
RFA 1093/2025
Page3of10
15.
When the Investigating Officer contacted the Defendant/Appellant, he
and his brother assured the Plaintiff/Respondent over telephone, that the
amount would be repaid within a day or two. The Defendant/Appellant also
asked the Plaintiff/Respondent to present the cheque for encashment.
16.
The Plaintiff/Respondent accordingly, presented the aforesaid cheque
for encashment on 01.06.2023; however, it was dishonoured and returned
unpaid vide Return Memo dated 02.06.2023 with the remarks “PPS NOT
CONFIRMED”.
Thereafter,
the
Plaintiff/Respondent
contacted
the
Defendant/Appellant, who allegedly admitted his liability, but failed to
discharge the same.
17.
Thereafter, within seven days from receipt of information regarding
dishonour of the cheque, the Plaintiff/Respondent issued a Legal Notice
dated 09.06.2023 through speed post to the Defendant/Appellant calling
upon him to make payment of the cheque amount within a period of 15 days
from the date of receipt of the said notice. However, despite service of the
aforesaid notice on 09.06.2023, the Defendant/Appellant failed to make
payment of the cheque amount.
18.
Consequently, the Plaintiff/Respondent filed a Complaint under
Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act bearing CC No. 1817/2023,
which is pending trial.
19.
The Plaintiff/Respondent thereafter, filed the present Suit under
Order XXXVII Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as
“CPC”)for recovery of Rs.21,50,000/- along with pendente lite and future
interest @ 18% per annum.
20.
After institution of the Suit, summons for Appearance were issued to
the Defendant/Appellant,vide Order dated 24.04.2024. As per the report of
KUMAR BHATT
16:22:15
RFA 1093/2025
Page4of10
the Assistant Ahlmad dated 28.08.2024, the Defendant/Appellant was
served on 23.07.2024, however, no appearance was filed within the statutory
period of ten days, as prescribed under Order XXXVII Rule 2(3) CPC.
21.
Consequently, the learned Trial Court, vide ex-parte Judgment and
Decree dated 29.08.2024, decreed the Suit for a sum of Rs.21,50,000/- along
with interest @ 6% per annum from the date of institution of the Suit till the
date of Decree, along with costs.
22.
Thereafter, the Appellant filed MISC DJ No. 69/2025 under Order
XXXVII Rule 4 read with Section 151 CPC, seeking setting aside of the exparte Judgment and Decree dated 29.08.2024. It was asserted that summons
of the Suit had never been served upon the Appellant and that he became
aware of the ex-parte Judgment and Decree only upon receipt of Notice in
the execution proceedings. The Appellant further denied the signatures
appearing on the service reports dated 29.05.2024 and 23.07.2024 and relied
upon the opinion of a handwriting expert, to contend that the said signatures
were not his signatures.
23.
The Plaintiff/Respondent contested the said Application and
contended that the handwriting Expert, Sh. Deepak Jain, had rendered his
opinion merely on the basis of comparison of the admitted signatures with
the certified copies of the summons and not the original documents. It was
further asserted that neither were the original summons examined nor was
any permission obtained by the handwriting expert, for taking photographs
of the original record.
24.
The Appellant further contended that a blank signed cheque had been
handed over to one Supreet, who allegedly passed on the said cheque to the
Plaintiff/Respondent, and that the same had been misused. It was further
KUMAR BHATT
16:22:15
RFA 1093/2025
Page5of10
asserted that there existed no legally enforceable debt or liability against the
Appellant and, therefore, sufficient grounds existed for grant of leave to
defend.
25.
The Plaintiff/Respondent, however, took the stand that the said
Supreet was an imaginary person and no relationship, either between
Supreet and the Defendant/Appellant, or between Supreet and the
Plaintiff/Respondent, had been established. It was further pointed out that
the Defendant/Appellant had never lodged any Complaint regarding the
alleged misuse of the cheque and, therefore, the defence raised by the
Defendant/Appellant was sham and devoid of merit.
26.
The Appellant further argued that the ex-parte Judgment and Decree
had been obtained by fraud and concealment of material facts and, therefore,
the same was non-est in the eyes of law, and liable to be set aside.
27.
In support of the aforesaid contention, reliance was placed upon the
Judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in A. V. Papayya Sastry and
Others vs. Government of A.P &ors.,(2007) 4 SCC 221 wherein it was
observed that a Judgment obtained by fraud is a nullity in the eyes of law.
28.
The aforesaid contention was disputed by the Plaintiff/Respondent,
who maintained that while the proposition of law laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court was not in dispute, the same had no application to the facts
of the present case as no prima facie fraud had been shown to have been
committed.
29.
The learned District Judge, upon consideration of the rival
contentions, held that the report of the Process Server was reliable and that
the opinion of the Handwriting Expert could not be relied upon since the
KUMAR BHATT
16:22:15
RFA 1093/2025
Page6of10
comparison of signatures had been undertaken on the basis of certified
copies of the summons and not the original record.
30.
It was further observed that summons had been served upon the
Defendant/Appellant on two occasions, i.e., on 24.04.2024 and 01.07.2024,
yet no appearance was entered on his behalf. The learned District Judge also
noted that the Defendant/Appellant had not disputed the signatures
appearing on the cheque issued in favour of the Plaintiff/Respondent and,
accordingly, rejected the plea that summons had not been served upon the
Defendant/Appellant.
31.
Insofar as the plea regarding misuse of the blank cheque was
concerned, the learned District Judge observed that despite dishonour of the
cheque with the remarks “PPS NOT CONFIRMED”, no Complaint
regarding alleged misuse of the cheque had ever been lodged by the
Appellant. It was accordingly, held that no substantial defence or genuine
triable issue had been raised by the Appellant so as to warrant grant of leave
to defend, in terms of the Judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in IDBI
Trusteeship Services Ltd. vs. Hubtown Ltd.,2017 (1) SCC 568 wherein it
was held that where no substantial defence is disclosed, leave to defend is
liable to be refused.
32.
The Suit of the Plaintiff was accordingly, decreed.
33.
Insofar as the plea of fraudin service was concerned, the learned
District Judge held that no prima facie case of fraud, had been made out on
the facts of the present case and, accordingly, the Application under Order
XXXVII Rule 4 CPC was dismissed.
KUMAR BHATT
16:22:15
RFA 1093/2025
Page7of10
34.
Aggrieved by the ex-parte Judgment and Decree dated 29.08.2024
and the subsequent dismissal of the Application under Order XXXVII Rule
4 CPC, the Appellant has preferred the present Appeal.
35.
The grounds of challenge are that the material placed on record and
the submissions advanced on behalf of the Appellant, have not been
appreciated in the correct perspective.
36.
It has further been contended that the Suit could not have been
decreed without proof of the assertions made in the Plaint and that the report
of the Handwriting Expert has been rejected, without due consideration. It
has also been contended that the medical condition of the Appellant has not
been taken into account, by the learned Trial Court.
37.
Further, the learned Trial Court lacked jurisdiction to pass the
impugned Judgments and that material irregularities have been committed,
resulting in grave miscarriage of justice.
38.
It has, therefore, been prayed that the ex-parte Judgment and Decree
dated 29.08.2024 passed in CS DJ No. 315/2024 as well as the Judgment
dated 17.10.2025 passed in MISC DJ No. 69/2025 be set aside.
Submissions heard and record perused.
39.
The ex-parte Judgment and Decree dated 29.08.2024 passed in CS DJ
No. 315/2024 has primarily been assailed on the ground that the Reports
regarding service of summons upon the Defendant/Appellant, on 24.04.2024
and 01.07.2024, are incorrect and that summons had never been received by
him.
40.
A challenge has also been made to the Judgment dated 17.10.2025
passed in MISC DJ No. 69/2025 whereby the Application under Order
XXXVII Rule 4 CPC was also dismissed.
KUMAR BHATT
16:22:15
RFA 1093/2025
Page8of10
41.
The learned District Judge has rightly observed that summons had
been served upon the Defendant/Appellant on two occasions and, therefore,
the plea of the Defendant/Appellant that he had never been served with the
summons, was rightly rejected.
42.
Insofar as the report of the Handwriting Expert is concerned, the same
has also been rightly discarded by the learned District Judge on the ground
that the opinion of the expert was based upon certified copies and not upon
examination of the original record.
43.
The learned District Judge has rightly concluded that the Appellant
had neither disclosed sufficient cause for setting aside the ex-parte Judgment
and Decree dated 29.08.2024 nor disclosed such facts as would entitle him
to grant of leave to defend, in terms of the principles laid down in B. L.
Gupta vs. Sunita Khanna, 1994 DLT 56 (585) and Prabhat vs. Dharmapal,
2011 SCC OnLine Del 1566.
44.
Furthermore, Defendant/Appellant had not denied his signatures on
the Cheque, but merely taken a defence that a blank cheque handed over
through one Supreet, had been misused. This pleawas duly considered and it
was observed that neither the identity of the said Supreet nor his
relationship
with
either
the
Plaintiff/Respondent
or
the
Defendant/Appellant, was explained. Accordingly, the allegation of misuse
of cheque as raised by the Defendant/Appellant, was rightly rejected.
45.
The Appellant had also sought to raise a plea of fraud; however, the
same was found to be a bald assertion unsupported by any particulars or
explanation regarding the alleged fraud in the transaction in question.
46.
There is no infirmity in the ex-parte Judgment and Decree dated
29.08.2024 whereby the Suit under Order XXXVII CPC has been decreed
KUMAR BHATT
16:22:15
RFA 1093/2025
Page9of10
on account of failure of the Defendant/Appellant to enter appearance, within
the prescribed period.
47.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, the present Appeal is devoid of
merit and is hereby, dismissed.
48.
Pending Applications, if any, are disposed of accordingly.
(NEENA BANSAL KRISHNA)
JUDGE
MAY 12, 2026/R
KUMAR BHATT
16:22:15
RFA 1093/2025
Page10of10
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review