Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL MISC. APPLICATION (FOR QUASHING & SET
ASIDE FIR/ORDER) NO. 10345 of 2017
With
R/SPECIAL CRIMINAL APPLICATION NO. 9928 of 2016
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. M. RAVAL
================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
√
================================================
SANJAY BALWANT NIKAM
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT & ANR.
================================================
Appearance:
MR ASHISH M DAGLI(2203) for the Applicant(s) No. 1
MR DAXESH T DAVE(248) for the Respondent(s) No. 2
MR YUVRAJ BRAHMBHATT, APP for the Respondent(s) No. 1
================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P. M. RAVAL
Date : 14/09/2026
ORAL JUDGMENT
1.
As both the matters are relating to the same FIR, the same
are heard and being decided by this common judgment.
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
2.
Criminal Misc. Application No. 10345 of 2017 is filed by the
applicant invoking Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code,
1973 (the Code) seeking to quash and set aside the FIR being C.R.
No. I-110 of 2008, registered with Sayajiganj Police Station, District:
Vadodara City for the offence punishable under Sections 406, 420,
467, 468, and 471 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) with
consequential proceedings. Whereas, Special Criminal Application
No. 9928 of 2016 is filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India r/w. Section 482 of the Code praying to quash and set aside
the Charge-sheet being Criminal Case No. 38896 of 2008,
alternatively praying for to quash and set aside the order dated
15.07.2016 passed by the learned 3rd Additional Civil Judge,
Vadodara below Exh. 9 in Criminal Case No. 38896 of 2008,
whereby, the application for discharge, filed by the petitioner,
came to be rejected and the order dated 09.09.2016 passed by the
learned 11th (Ad-hoc) Additional Sessions Judge, Vadodara
confirming the aforesaid order dated 15.07.2016 rejecting discharge
application.
3.
Filtered facts of the case are that accused namely Mukesh
Mahendrabhai Darji allegedly, by giving his identity as younger
brother of one Paresh Mahendrabhai Darji in the Branch No. 3,
Sayajiganj Branch of the Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC),
and by producing School Leaving Certificate of someone else as
well as other documents, got issued a policy with sum insured of
Rs.5 lakh and thereafter, by producing a fake Death Certificate
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
tried to encash the policy benefits and thereby, committed the
crime in question for which, FIR came to be registered against the
accused.
4.
Heard, learned advocate for the respective parties.
4.1
So far as Criminal Misc. Application No. 10345 of 2017 is
concerned, it is submitted that:
4.1.1 The applicant was a Development Officer having a long
tenure. It is submitted that the policy in question was availed by
the holder by submitting necessary documents viz. School Leaving
Certificate and necessary premium was also paid.
4.1.2 It is further submitted that papers were collected by the
authorized Agent of LIC and thus, the insurance policy was
issued. It is submitted that the applicant was not aware about the
document being false/forged. The learned advocate submitted
that many persons work under the applicant as LIC Agent and the
Agents submit the documents after verification and relying on the
documents that are supplied by the Agent for issuance of the LIC
Policy, he proceeds further.
Thus, it is submitted that the
applicant cannot be held responsible for the alleged act having no
intention whatsoever and having acted in good faith.
4.1.3 The learned advocate for the applicant would submit that
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
even the investigation in the matter is over and Charge-sheet is
also filed and from the papers of the Charge-sheet nothing adverse
is revealed against the present applicant.
4.1.4 It is further submitted that FIR reveals neither offence under
Section 120B of the IPC, nor Sections 34 or 114 of the IPC are added
and accordingly, the applicant cannot be held jointly liable for the
offence, if any, committed by other and so far, as other offences are
concerned, no ingredients are satisfied.
4.1.5 Making above submissions, it is urged to allow this
application.
5.
So far as Special Criminal Application No. 9928 of 2016 is
concerned, it is submitted that:
5.1.1 The petitioner is merely an Agent and has no role to play in
the crime in question. It is submitted that Charge-sheet in the
matter is already filed and if the Charge-sheet papers are taken in
entirety, then too, there is nothing to show prima facie case made
out against the present petitioner.
5.1.2 It is submitted that in fact the petitioner is a victim of the
crime inasmuch as main accused Mukesh Darji with whom the
petitioner had acquaintance, since was interested in availing an
LIC policy, the petitioner, out of acquaintance and trust, supplied
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
the duly stamped and signed policy form bearing Agency Code,
however, thereafter, said Mukesh Darji did not turn up, and
procured policy and paid premium directly, who submitted a false
claim alleging death of his brother Yagnesh Darji.
5.1.3 It is further submitted that on having found the claim
ingenuine, a detailed investigation was carried out by the LIC a
detailed Report was also submitted from which, it is revealed that
said Mukesh Darji has committed wrong.
5.1.4 It is further submitted that had there been any doubt with
regard to the involvement of the present petitioner in the so-called
act, the LIC would have suspended / cancelled the Agency of the
petitioner and taken disciplinary actions against the petitioner.
However, the Vigilance Department of LIC did not find any
material, worth the name, against the present petitioner.
5.1.5 It is vehemently submitted that in the case on hand, the main
accused namely Mukesh Darji has filed an Affidavit before the
concerned authority, which is on record, stating that all act of
lodging false claim by creating forged document was done by him.
Thus, while the learned trial Judge has manifestly erred in
rejecting the Discharge Application, the learned Revisional Court
has also erred in confirming the said rejection.
5.1.6 Thus, making above submissions, it is urged that this
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
petition may be allowed.
6.
Conversely, the learned advocate for the respondent No. 2 as
well as the learned Additional Public Prosecutor for the
respondent
–
State,
while
opposing
the
present
application/petition, have submitted that as per the settled law,
inherent powers under Section 482 of the Code /writ jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India should be used
sparingly and with a view to curb the abuse of process of law. It is
submitted that in the case on hand, a prima facie case is made out
against the applicant/petitioner and hence, they requested that it
is ultimately a matter of trial after which, the truth could be
churned out and hence, it is requested not to entertain these
applications.
6.1
It is further submitted that in the case on hand though there
is an affidavit of the main accused namely Mukesh Darji is on
record, however, what is material is, the endorsement made by the
present petitioner (in Special Criminal Application No. 9928 of
2016). As observed by the learned Revisional Court, the petitioner
has made categorical endorsement that he had fully explained the
questions in the proposal form to the proposer and recorded the
answers given by him. Further, if the statements of Talati-cumMantri and the Sarpanch of Khanpur Gram Panchayat are
referred, it is clear that no person namely Yagnesh Mahendrabhai
Darji was residing in the village. Thus, it is submitted that the
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
policy was taken in the name of a non-existent person qua whom,
such endorsement is made by the petitioner of Special Criminal
Application No. 9928 of 2016.
6.2
Making further submissions it is argued that, the applicant
in Criminal Misc. Application No. 10345 of 2017, who was the
Development Officer, also made an endorsement to the effect that
“I am Satisfied with the identity of the party and on the basis of my
independent inquiries, I hereby declare that the forgoing statements are
true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief”. Whereas,
petitioner in Special Criminal Application No. 9928 of 2016 who is
an agent makes endorsement in the Proposal Form that: “I hereby
declare that I have fully explained the above questions to the proposer and
I have truth fully recorded the answers given by the proposer”. Thus, the
applicants
were
conscious
enough
while
making
such
endorsements.
6.3
It is submitted that based on forged documents, policy was
availed by introducing fake details of a non-existent person and
present applicant/petitioner made their respective endorsement
endorsing the same a true and thus, only because Sections 34, 120B
or 114 of the IPC are not invoked, complicity of the present
applicant/petitioner in the alleged crime cannot be ruled out,
more particularly, when Charge can be altered at any stage.
6.4
Thus, making above submissions, it is urged that since prima
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
facie case is made out against the present applicant/petitioner,
interference of this Court is not required in the matter more
particularly when Charge-sheet in the case is already filed and
there is ample material to show involvement of present
applicant/petitioner. Eventually, it is urged to reject these
applications.
7.
Heard, the learned advocates for the respective parties and
perused the material on record, including the order passed by the
learned subordinate Courts rejecting the Discharge Application.
7.1
Prior to assessing the factual matrix on the touchstone of
criminal jurisprudence, it is apposite to reinforce the settled legal
position governing the scope, ambit, and limits of the inherent
jurisdiction vested under Section 482 of the Code. The
jurisprudential
parameters
regulating
the
exercise
of
this
extraordinary power have been authoritatively catalogued by
Hon’ble Supreme Court in a long line of precedents, chief among
them being the authoritative in the case of State of Haryana v.
Bhajan Lal [AIR 1992 SC 604]. Therein, Hon’ble Supreme Court
crystallized seven distinct, illustrative categories of cases where
judicial intervention under Section 482 of the Code or Article 226
of the Constitution is necessitated to secure the ends of justice and
clip any abuse of the process of Court. The relevant portion of
Paragraph 102 of the said judgment is extracted below:
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
“102. In the backdrop of the interpretation of the various relevant
provisions of the Code under Chapter XIV and of the principles of
law enunciated by this Court in a series of decisions relating to the
exercise of the extraordinary power under Article 226 or the
inherent powers under Section 482 of the Code which we have
extracted and reproduced above, we have given the following
categories of cases by way of illustration wherein such power could
be exercised either to prevent abuse of the process of any court or
otherwise to secure the ends of justice, though it may not be
possible to lay down any precise, clearly defined and sufficiently
channelised and inflexible guidelines or rigid formulae and to give
an exhaustive list of myriad kinds of cases wherein such power
should be exercised.
(1) Where the allegations made in the first information
report or the complaint, even if they are taken at their face
value and accepted in their entirety do not prima facie
constitute any offence or make out a case against the
accused.
(2) Where the allegations in the first information report
and other materials, if any, accompanying the FIR do not
disclose a cognizable offence, justifying an investigation by
police officers under Section 156(1) of the Code except under
an order of a Magistrate within the purview of Section
155(2) of the Code.
(3) Where the uncontroverted allegations made in the FIR
or complaint and the evidence collected in support of the
same do not disclose the commission of any offence and make
out a case against the accused.
(4) Where, the allegations in the FIR do not constitute a
cognizable offence but constitute only a non-cognizable
offence, no investigation is permitted by a police officer
without an order of a Magistrate as contemplated under
Section 155(2) of the Code.
(5)
Where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
are so absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of
which no prudent person can ever reach a just conclusion
that there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the
accused.
(6) Where there is an express legal bar engrafted in any of
the provisions of the Code or the concerned Act (under which
a criminal proceeding is instituted) to the institution and
continuance of the proceedings and/or where there is a
specific provision in the Code or the concerned Act,
providing efficacious redress for the grievance of the
aggrieved party.
(7) Where a criminal proceeding is manifestly attended
with mala fide and/or where the proceeding is maliciously
instituted with an ulterior motive for wreaking vengeance on
the accused and with a view to spite him due to private and
personal grudge.”
7.2
Evaluating the present applications on the anvil of the
principles enunciated in Bhajan Lal (supra), this Court has to
determine whether the allegations in the FIR, even when accepted
at face value, satisfy the essential statutory ingredients of Sections
406, 420, 465, 467, 468, and 471 of the IPC. This Court must ensure
that criminal machinery is not permitted to degenerate into an
engine of harassment where liability under criminal law is
completely absent.
7.3
The offences alleged under Sections 406, 420, 467, 468, and
471 IPC center on deception, forgery of valuable securities, and
using forged documents as genuine.
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
8.
Having regard to the arguments canvassed by the learned
advocates for the respective parties and having perused the
material on record, including the Charge-sheet papers and the
concurrent findings and orders passed by the subordinate Courts
rejecting the discharge application, this Court is called upon to
decide whether the proceedings against the present applicants
deserve to be quashed. It is a well-settled principle of criminal
jurisprudence that inherent powers under Section 482 of the Code
of Criminal Procedure, 1973, or the extraordinary writ jurisdiction
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, ought to be
exercised sparingly, cautiously, and only with a view to curb the
abuse of the process of any court or to secure the ends of justice.
When a petition is preferred against concurrent orders of
subordinate Courts, specifically where a trial Court has refused
discharge and a revisional Court has affirmed that view, the scope
of interference by the High Court becomes exceedingly narrow.
At this preliminary stage, the Court cannot embark upon a
detailed mini-trial or weigh the probative value of the evidence,
but is strictly required to examine whether the lower Courts
committed any manifest perversity, illegality, or jurisdictional
error in holding that a prima facie case is made out.
8.1
The foundational facts reveal that the main accused, Mukesh
Mahendrabhai Darji, allegedly procured an LIC Policy for a sum
insured of Rs. 5 lakh by giving his identity as younger brother of
one Paresh Mahendrabhai Darji, producing a School Leaving
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
Certificate of someone else, and subsequently trying to encash the
policy benefits by producing a fake Death Certificate. During the
course of the investigation, statements recorded from the Talaticum-Mantri and the Sarpanch of Khanpur Gram Panchayat clearly
established that no person by the name ‘Yagnesh Mahendrabhai
Darji’ was ever residing in the village. Therefore, the Policy was
taken in the name of a non-existent, fictitious person.
9.
Now, coming first to Special Criminal Application No. 9928
of 2016, filed by the LIC Agent:
9.1
The petitioner-agent contends that he is merely a victim who
had an acquaintance with the main accused, arguing that out of
trust, he supplied a duly stamped and signed policy form bearing
his Agency Code to the main accused, who then independently
procured the policy and submitted the false claim.
9.2
The petitioner also heavily relies on the fact that the main
accused filed an affidavit taking sole responsibility for lodging the
false claim, and that the Vigilance Department of LIC did not find
any material against the petitioner.
9.3
However, this Court finds the petitioner's own admission of
handing over a pre-signed, blank Form highly detrimental at this
stage. The petitioner made a categorical written endorsement on
the Proposal Form stating: "I hereby declare that I have fully explained
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
the above questions to the proposer and I have truth fully recorded the
answers given by the proposer".
9.4
Certifying a face-to-face interaction and recording answers
from a proposer who did not even exist is a grave matter. A
departmental vigilance clearance or a co-accused's exculpatory
affidavit cannot automatically override documentary evidence (the
false endorsement) in criminal proceedings to warrant discharge.
The veracity of the agent's defense—whether he was innocently
duped or actively colluded—is entirely a disputed question of fact
that must be tested during trial. Furthermore, the Revisional Court
committed no legal error in confirming the trial Court's refusal to
discharge him, as the documentary material raises a strong
suspicion of complicity.
10.
Turning next to Criminal Misc. Application No. 10345 of
2017, filed by the Development Officer:
10.1 The applicant argues that as a Development Officer with a
long tenure, he merely proceeded on the verified documents
supplied by the authorized Agent in good faith. He contends that
he had no intention or knowledge of the forgery, and because
Sections 120B, 34, or 114 of the IPC are not invoked in the FIR, he
cannot be held jointly liable for offenses committed by others.
10.2 While this argument appears attractive at the first blush, it
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
falls
flat
upon
examining
the
documentary
record.
The
Development Officer also made a specific, personal endorsement
on the proposal form stating: "I am Satisfied with the identity of the
party and on the basis of my independent inquiries, I hereby declare that
the foregoing statements are true and correct to the best of my knowledge
and belief".
10.3 By explicitly declaring that he conducted "independent
inquiries" and was satisfied with the identity of a party who, as
per the village authorities, never existed, the Development Officer
has directly implicated himself in the chain of documentation.
10.4 Furthermore, this Court finds merit in the submission made
by the learned Additional Public Prosecutor. The mere fact that
Sections 34, 120B, or 114 of the IPC were not explicitly invoked in
the Charge-sheet does not rule out the complicity of the applicant.
Under the criminal jurisprudence governing criminal trials,
charges can be altered or added by the trial Court at any stage
(under Section 216 of the Code) if the underlying material
demonstrates a common intention or meeting of minds.
Consequently, the omission of the strategic sections in the FIR or
Charge-sheet raised by the accused, but to no avail.
10.5 Most importantly, the learned Revisional Court thoroughly
evaluated these concurrent aspects and rightly upheld the trial
Court's rejection of discharge. In the absence of any patent
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
perversity or grave miscarriage of justice in the concurrent
findings of the Courts below, this Court finds no legal justification
to interfere under Section 482 of the Code or Article 226 of the
Constitution.
10.6 Where an insurance policy is obtained in the name of a nonexistent person, the affirmative endorsements made by internal
institutional
officials
(accused
herein)
certifying
personal
verification constitute vital evidentiary links. Whether these
representations were the result of innocent administrative
negligence (lacking mens rea) or constituted active facilitation or
collusion in the fraud, is a question of fact that can only be
adjudicated during trial through cross-examination. Furthermore,
the argument advanced by the learned advocates for the
applicant/petitioner that the institution (LIC) has not named them
either in its internal investigation or in the FIR, cannot serve as a
ground to discharge or quash the proceedings at this stage when
sufficient prima facie material is otherwise available on record.
10.7 Further, investigation in the offence is completed and the
Charge-sheet is already filed. From the charge-sheet papers, a
prima facie case appears to have been made out against the
applicant/petitioner. As per the settled law laid down by the
Apex Court in Central Bureau of Investigation v. Aryan Singh etc.
reported in 2023 (0) AIJEL-SC 70780, at the stage of discharge
and/or quashing of criminal proceedings while exercising powers
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
under Section 482 of the Code, the Court is not required to conduct
a mini-trial, as charges are required to be proved during trial on
the basis of evidence led by the prosecution or investigating
agency.
10.8 In this context, it is also apposite to refer to the decision in
Kanchan Kumar v. State of Bihar reported in (2022) 9 SCC 577,
wherein the Apex Court, while considering the judgment in
Dipakbhai Jagdishchandra Patel v. State of Gujarat, summarized
the principles governing discharge under Section 227 of the Code.
The Apex Court reiterated that at the stage of framing charges, the
court must sift the material produced and relied upon by the
prosecution to see if a case is made out for the accused to stand
trial. A strong suspicion suffices, provided it is founded on
material that can be translated into evidence at the trial, rather
than pure subjective satisfaction or moral notions. In the present
case, the specific written endorsements made by both applicants
validating a non-existent person furnish the requisite material to
ground such strong suspicion.
10.9 Therefore, having assessed the factual matrix on the
touchstone of the settled legal position governing the scope, ambit,
and limits of inherent under section 482 of the CRPC and writ
powers under 226/227 of the Constitution of India against
concurrent orders of subordinate Courts, this Court concludes that
there is ample material in the Charge-sheet to show the
R/CR.MA/10345/2017(GJHC240618892017)
JUDGMENT DATED:
14/09/2026
involvement of both the applicant/petitioner. Both accused made
specific written endorsements validating a non-existent person,
and the concurrent decisions of the Courts below refusing
discharge suffer from no legal infirmity. Consequently, these
applications deserve to be rejected.
11.
In the result, both Criminal Misc. Application no. 10345 of
2017 and special criminal application no. 9928 of 2016 fail and are
hereby REJECTED.
The order dated 15.07.2016 passed by the
learned 3rd Additional Civil Judge, Vadodara, below Exh. 9, as well
as the confirming revisional order dated 09.09.2016 passed by the
learned 11th (Ad-hoc) Additional Sessions Judge, Vadodara, are
hereby UPHELD. Rule is discharged. Interim relief, if any, shall
stand vacated forthwith.
11.1 The trial Court shall proceed with Criminal Case No. 38896
of 2008 in accordance with the law without being influenced by
any observations made in this order. Notice is discharged in both
matters.
[ P. M. Raval, J. ]
hiren/SB-2/14926+
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review