Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment Reserved on: 19th February, 2026
Judgment pronounced on: 12th March, 2026
%
RFA 701/2018
+
SANGITA MALLIK
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Pankaj Gupta, Mrs. Rimpy Gupta
and Mr. Ram Pawar, Advocates.
versus
GANDHI SMARAK
SANGRAHALAYA SAMITI & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Rahul Shukla and Mr. Bachita
Baruah Shukla, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT BANSAL
JUDGMENT
AMIT BANSAL, J.
1.
The present appeal has been filed seeking modification of judgment
and decree dated 21st April, 2018 passed ADJ-04 (Central), Tis Hazari
Courts Delhi (‘Trial Court’) in CS No. 614393/2016 titled as ‘Sangita
Mallik v. Gandhi Smarak Sangrahalaya Samiti and Another’ (‘impugned
judgment’).
2.
In terms of the impugned judgment, the suit filed by the
appellant/plaintiff was decreed for a sum of Rs. 90,000/- along with interest
at the rate of 9% per annum from the date of filing of the suit.
BRIEF FACTS
3.
The appellant was appointed as a Director of respondent no. 2 and ex-
officio member secretary of respondent no. 1 on 19th September, 2010 for a
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
12:14:32
RFA 701/2018
fixed term of five years. An honorarium of Rs. 30,000/- per month was to be
paid to the appellant as per the terms of the engagement. Prior to her
selection, the appellant was working as Deputy Director in Rajender
Bhawan Trust. At the time of her appointment, the appellant was around 57
years of age.
4.
The appellant joined as a Director on 21st September, 2010. The
appellant worked at the said post from 21st September, 2010 till 13th January,
2013.
5.
The appellant, who was suffering from a brain tumour had to undergo
an emergency surgery on 31st January, 2013. The surgery resulted in certain
complications and the appellant was hospitalised. On 18th February, 2013
the appellant applied for three months’ medical leave from 1st February,
2013 to 30th April, 2013. The same was sanctioned vide letter dated 5th
March, 2013 subject to the appellant receiving 50% of the ‘honorarium’.
6.
Since the medical treatment of the appellant continued, the appellant
was advised bed rest. Accordingly, the appellant applied for extension of her
medical leave from May, 2013 to July, 2013, which was acceded to by the
respondents vide letter dated 1st May, 2013, without any honorarium.
7.
On 10th July, 2013, the appellant applied for further extension of her
medical leave from August, 2013 till October, 2013.
8.
The request of the appellant for further extension of medical leave
was declined by the respondents vide letter dated 1st August, 2013 and the
appellant was relieved from her duties as Director.
9.
On 24th September, 2013, the appellant filed a suit before the Trial
Court seeking a declaration that the termination letter dated 1st August, 2013
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
12:14:32
RFA 701/2018
was illegal and arbitrary and also sought a sum of Rs.12,50,000/- towards
damages and compensation.
10.
Summons in the suit were issued on 23rd October, 2013. The
respondents contested the suit by filing a written statement. Evidence in the
suit was recorded from 17th March, 2015 to 15th March, 2017.
FINDINGS OF THE TRIAL COURT
11.
The Trial Court held that respondent/defendant is a registered society
under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 and not a statutory body.
Therefore, the employment of the plaintiff would be governed by the terms
of her appointment letter. Hence, Article 311 of the Constitution of India
would not be applicable in the present case.
12.
The Trial Court also noted that in terms of Rule 8 of the ‘Rules and
Regulations of Gandhi Smarak Sangrahalaya Samiti, Gandhi Memorial
Museum Society’ (‘Rules and Regulations’), the appointing authority in
respect of the appellant was the Chairman of respondent no. 2 and the
Chairman had relieved the appellant-plaintiff from her duties as a Director
vide communication dated 1st August, 2013.
13.
As regards the submission of the appellant that the employment of the
appellant was for a period of five years, which could not be terminated
earlier, the Trial Court has placed reliance on the judgment of the Division
Bench of this Court in Shriram Pistons and Rings Ltd. and Anr. v. T.S.
Mokha1(‘Shriram Pistons’), to the effect that even if there is a wrongful
RFA (OS) No. 3/1999.
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
12:14:32
RFA 701/2018
repudiation of the contract of employment by the employer, the employee
can only claim damages in lieu of the notice period.
14.
The Trial Court has also held that in the absence of a written contract,
the engagement of the appellant would be governed by the Memorandum of
Association and the Rules framed thereunder. In terms of Rule X(2) of the
‘Service Rules, Gandhi Smarak Sangrahalaya Samiti’ (‘Service Rules’), any
employee could be terminated by giving a three (3) months’ notice.
Accordingly, the Trial Court awarded damages for a period of three (3)
months from the date of termination of employment, amounting to Rs.
90,000/- along with interest at rate of 9% per annum.
15.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment, the present appeal has been
filed.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PARTIES
16.
Mr. Pankaj Gupta, counsel for the appellant has made the following
submissions:i.
Since the appointment of the appellant was for a fixed term of 5 years
and there was no stipulation for prior termination, the termination of
the appellant vide letter dated 1st August, 2013 was illegal. Hence, the
appellant is entitled for compensation for the remaining period of her
engagement. In this regard reliance is placed on the judgment of the
Division Bench of this Court in India International Centre v. SN
Pandit2(‘India International Centre’).
RFA No. 93-D/1965.
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
12:14:32
RFA 701/2018
ii.
Since the engagement of appellant was in the nature of post-retiral
engagement, the general principle of mitigation of loss would not be
applicable.
iii.
The leave of the appellant had already been sanctioned till 15th
September, 2013 by the then Chairman on 17th July, 2013. Therefore,
the termination of the engagement during the subsistence of the said
period is bad in law.
17.
Mr. Rahul Shukla, counsel appearing for the respondents has made
the following submissions:i.
The appointing authority in respect of the appellant was the Chairman
and the relieving letter has also been issued by the Chairman.
ii.
The Trial Court in the impugned judgment and decree has correctly
applied the Service Rules in terms of which the respondent-society is
required to give three months’ notice to the appellant before terminating her
services. Accordingly, the Trial Court has awarded compensation to the
appellant in lieu of three months’ notice period, which has been accepted by
the respondents.
iii.
It is wrong to content that a fixed-term employment cannot be
terminated earlier. If sufficient cause is shown, the aforesaid employment
can be terminated and the said termination would not be unlawful.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
18.
I have heard counsel for the parties and examined the material placed
on record.
19.
It is an undisputed fact that the employment of the appellant was in
the nature of a private employment. The appellant worked at the said
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
12:14:32
RFA 701/2018
position from 21st September, 2010 till 13th January, 2013.Thereafter, the
appellant had to take medical leave on account of health issues faced by her.
Initially, medical leave was sought and granted for a period of three months
from February, 2013 to April, 2013 with 50% of the honorarium and
subsequently for a period of another three months from May, 2013 to July,
2013, without any honorarium.
20.
In the meeting of the Governing Body held on 18th May, 2013
(Exhibit DW-1/5), it was noted that the medical certificate submitted by the
appellant for extension of medical leave was inadequate and the Governing
Body requested the Chairman to ask the appellant to submit her resignation.
In the Meeting of the Governing Body dated 26th July, 2013, the decision of
the Chairman to extend the appellant’s leave till 31st July, 2013 was
accepted. However, it was made clear by the respondents that any further
extension of leave beyond 31st July, 2013 shall not be approved. Relevant
extracts from the Minutes of Meeting dated 26th July, 2013 (Exhibit DW1/6) are set out below:
“(b) Resolution No. 7 – Decision (a) – Regarding Smt. Sangita Mallik’s
Resignation:
The Chairman, Prof. Bimal Prasad, informed the Governing Body that
Smt. Sangita Mallik is not ready to resign from the Directorship of the
National Gandhi Museum. She has asked for another three months
leave on medical ground. Thus, it was clear that she is not going to join
her duty on 1.8.2013.
Governing Body members discussed this issue in detail. The members
were firmly of the view, considering all details about her performance,
her health, and her absence from the duty because of her ill-health, that
it is not possible to allow her to continue as the Director of the National
Gandhi Museum now. At this point, Chairman, Prof. Bimal Prasad
intervened and suggested that Rs. 1 Lac should be given to her as
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
12:14:32
RFA 701/2018
medical expenses assistance. He also assured that he will persuade her
to resign from the Directorship and it hoped she will resign. Members of
Governing Body after considering the proposal decided that after
receiving the resignation letter from Smt. Sangita Mallik, Rs. 1 Lac will
be given to her on a compassionate ground.
In any case, if she does not resign, the Chairman, National Gandhi
Museum, has been authorised by the Governing Body to relieve her
from the responsibilities of the Director of the National Gandhi
Museum.”
[emphasis supplied]
21.
Since the appellant did not submit her resignation, the Chairman
terminated her engagement vide letter dated 1st August, 2013 (Exhibit PW1/9).
22.
In my considered view, there is no infirmity in the decision of the
respondents to not extend the appellant’s medical leave beyond 31st July,
2013. It is a matter of record that the appellant had been taking medical
leaves since January, 2013. Earlier, the medical leave was granted from 1st
February, 2013 to 30th April, 2013 and subsequently from May, 2013 to
July, 2013. It has to be borne in mind that the appellant was holding the post
of a Director and her prolonged absence would have affected the functioning
of the respondent-society. Since the contract was for a fixed term of 5 years,
the respondents could not be reasonably expected to continue sanctioning
medical leave to the appellant.
23.
Even in terms of Rule VI(10) of the Service Rules, an employee is
only entitled to a maximum 90 days’ medical leave in case of a serious
illness, upon production of a certificate from a medical practitioner. Clearly,
the appellant had exceeded this limit.
24.
The reliance placed by the appellant on Rule VI(15A) of the Service
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
12:14:32
RFA 701/2018
Rules to submit that an employee can be granted a leave up to a continuous
period of three (3) years is also completely misplaced. No employee can, as
a matter of right claim leave for a period of three (3) years. The appellant,
who was employed for a fixed term of five (5) years, surely cannot be
entitled to claim leave for three (3) years.
25.
I am unable to accept the submission of the appellant that a fixed term
employment cannot be terminated by the employer. Even in the judgment of
India International Centre (supra) relied upon by the appellant, it has been
held that a fixed duration contract can be terminated prior to the expiry of
duration on just causes.
26.
In the present case, as noted above, sufficient justification has been
provided by the respondents for terminating the contract of the appellant.
27.
The appellant has contended that her leave was extended by the
Chairman till 15th September, 2013. Reliance has been placed on the
endorsement of the Chairman in her leave application dated 10th July, 2013
(Exhibit PW-1/7). However, the said plea was not taken by the appellant
before the Trial Court and hence has not been considered in the impugned
judgment. The said plea has been raised for the first time in the present
appeal. In any event, in light of the resolution passed by the respondents on
26th July, 2013 (Exhibit DW-1/6), the said endorsement holds no relevance.
28.
In Shriram Pistons (supra), it has been held that even if the
termination of employment is wrongful, damages that can be awarded are
limited to the notice-period pay/salary and the employee cannot claim
damages till retirement. Accordingly, the Trial Court has rightly awarded
damages of Rs. 90,000/- to the appellant in lieu of the three months’ notice
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
12:14:32
RFA 701/2018
period which was required to be given in terms of Rule X(2) of Service
Rules.
29.
In view of the discussion above, this Court finds no infirmity in the
judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court.
30.
There is no merit in the present appeal and the same is dismissed.
AMIT BANSAL
(JUDGE)
MARCH 12, 2026
at
Digitally Signed
By:AANCHAL TAGGAR
12:14:32
RFA 701/2018
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review