Constitutional
Sangappa B Mashalkar vs The State of Karnataka
Add to a compilation
Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index.
It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence.
Sign in · See the plans
Bench
Justice Pradeep Singh Yerur
Cite this judgment
Citation
Copy citation
Link for your website or blog
Copy link code
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0 ).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
"
!
%
!
!
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
"
#
%
# #$
#
"
#
#
%
#
# #$
!
$%
&
(
#
$ ' (
&
-2-
$ ' &%)
#
"
!
%%)
#
#
&*
!
(
!
#
!
#
#
"
!
&
%%+
#
(% %
%
$!
,#
#
!
"
#
-
#
#
./01 2./03.1 45637.2 850 9:. ;.9<9<53.0
11<9<53/2
5=.03>.39
/31
/2/22< 2./03.1 45637.2 850 0.7;531.39
0<
%
1=54/9. 850 0.7;531.39
2./03.1
95 &
5(
:<7 ;.9<9<53 <7 8<2.1 ?@ 9:. ;.9<9<53.0 7..A<3B 95
C6/7: 9:. <>;6B3.1 501.0 1/9.1
0.7;531.39
5 % =<1.
&
(% %
;/77.1 ?@
33.D60.$! /31 4537.C6.392@
1<0.49 9:. 0.7;531.397 95 /;;5<39 ;.9<9<53.0 95 9:. ;579 58
11<9<53/2
5=.03>.39
1=54/9. /9
.3<50
<=<2
61B.
-3-
/7/=/A/2@/3
;579 58
11<9<53/2
61B.
5609 /9
1/9.1
%
:. ;.9<9<53.0 <7 /3 /7;<0/39 95 9:.
5=.03>.39
/7/=/A/2@/3
1=54/9. 850
3 ;6076/34. 58
) % %( 4/22.1 ?@ 0.7;531.39
.3<50
<=<2
59<8<4/9<53
5 & :. /;;2<.1 95
9:. 7/<1 ;579
89.0 4531649<3B <39.0=<.E 58 9:. 4/31<1/9.7
9:. 2./03.1
<790<49 /31
.77<537
61B. 5;<3.1 9:/9 9:.
;.9<9<53.0 <7 / 76<9/?2. 4/31<1/9. 850 9:. 7/<1 ;579 =<1.
2.99.0 1/9.1 %
<790<49
(
61B.
%% %
;.9<9<53.0
% % %(
/7.1 53 9:. 7/<1 5;<3<53 58 9:.
0.7;531.39
5 & 7.39 / 2.99.0 1/9.1
95 0.7;531.39
5 % 850 /;;5<39>.39 58 9:.
:<7 ?.<3B 9:. 79/9. 58 /88/<07 0.7;531.39
<3 45>;2.9. =<52/9<53 /31 1<70.B/01 95 9:.
9:. 5;<3<53 58 9:. 2./03.1
62.7 /7 E.22 /7
<790<49 61B. /31 E<9:569 9:.0.
?.<3B /3@ 850E/01<3B 58 9:. 2.99.0 ?@ 0.7;531.39
<22.B/22@ /;;5<39.1 0.7;531.39
11<9<53/2
5=.03>.39
/7/=/A/2@/3
/9
5%
5 ( 95 9:. 7/<1 ;579 58
1=54/9. 850
/;;5<39>.39 58 0.7;531.39
5&
.3<50
BB0<.=.1
?@
<=<2
61B.
9:.
7/<1
5 ( 9:. ;.9<9<53.0 E:5 <7 9:.
.2<B<?2. 4/31<1/9. <7 ?.850. 9:<7
-4-
&
<7
9:.
=.:.>.39
4539.39<53
2./03.1
45637.2 850 9:. ;.9<9<53.0 9:/9 9:. <>;6B3.1 501.0 <7
;/77.1 E<9:569 85225E<3B 16. ;054.77 58 2/E /31 <3 ?2/9/39
=<52/9<53 58 9:.
531<9<537 58
G9:.
62.7 58
F))
/03/9/A/
.0=<4.
F))H
;05=<1.
/E
62.7
88<4.07
;;5<39>.39 /31
F)) 850 7:509 0.8.00.1 95 /7
9 <7 8609:.0 4539.31.1 9:/9 9:.
62.7
9:.
9:.
;054.160.
E:.0.?@
/;;2<4/9<537 /31 .2<B<?<2<9@ 58 9:. /;;2<4/39 /0. /77.77.1 ?@
9:. 2./03.1
<790<49 61B. E:5 9/A.7 <395 4537<1.0/9<53 9:.
;05;57/2 805> 0.7;531.39
5 & /31 9:.
<790<49
61B.
>/A.7 /3 5;<3<53 E<9: 0.B/01 95 76<9/?<2<9@ 58 9:.
/;;5<39>.39 58 / ;.0753 95 9:. 7/<1 ;579 E:<4: :/7 359
?..3 153. <3 9:. ;0.7.39 4/7. 53 :/31
(
./03.1
0.7;531.39
45637.2
8609:.0
4539.317
9:/9
5 ( <7 ;52<9<4/22@ <3826.39</2 /31 .=.3 53 /3
./02<.0 544/7<53 /275 :<7 3/>. E/7 359<8<.1 ?@ /3 501.0
1/9.1
% %( E:<4: 4/>. 95 ?. 7.9 /7<1. ?@ 9:<7
5609 <3 "
62.7 58
5%
F) % %( 53 9:. B05631 9:/9 9:.
F)) E.0. 359 85225E.1 <3 9:. 790<49 7.37.
-5-
:.0.850. :. 4539.317 9:/9 <3 9:. ;0.7.39 4/7. /7 E.22
534.
/B/<3
9:.
4539.>;2/9.1
0.7;531.39
62.7
9:.0.<3
F))
/31
:/=.
?..3
9:.
;054.160.
82569.1
:.2;
5 ( 95 B.9 9:. /;;5<39>.39 E:<4: <7 1<0.492@
<3 45390/1<49<53 95 9:.
58 9:.
62.7
62.7 /31 9:. <39.39 58 9:. 80/>.07
:.0.850. 9:. 4531649 58 0.7;531.39
5 % <7
<3 =<52/9<53 58 9:. 1<0.49<537 58 9:<7
5609 <3 9:. ./02<.0
"
5%
F) % %(
;.9<9<53.0
E:5
/31
/275
<7 9:. >50.
<3
76<9/?2.
7.2.49<3B
9:.
4/31<1/9. 9:/3
0.7;531.39
5(
0.7;531.39
5 & /31 350 E/7 <9 9/A.3 <395 4537<1.0/9<53
?@ 9:.
<790<49
E:57. ;05;57/2 E/7 359 ;69 8509: ?@
61B. E:<2. 7.31<3B 9:. 5;<3<53 53 9:.
76<9/?<2<9@ 58 9:. 4/31<1/960. 58 0.7;531.39
5(
3 9:.7.
B056317 :. 7..A7 95 C6/7: 9:. 7/<1 <>;6B3.1 501.0 /31
4537.C6.392@
95 1<0.49 9:. 0.7;531.397 95 /;;5<39 9:.
;.9<9<53.0 E:5 <7 0.45>>.31.1 E<9: /3 5;<3<53 ?@ 9:.
2./03.1
<790<49 61B. 850 /;;5<39>.39 95 9:. 7/<1 ;579
.0
45390/
/;;./0<3B 850 0.7;531.39
0<
/2/22<
2./03.1
45637.2
5 ( =.:.>.392@ 4539.317 9:/9
-6-
9:56B: 9:. ;054.160. 4539.>;2/9.7 5?9/<3<3B /3 5;<3<53
0.B/01<3B 9:. 76<9/?<2<9@ 58 9:. 4/31<1/9. 805> 9:. 0<34<;/2
<790<49 61B. 9:. /;;5<39<3B /69:50<9@ <7 9:.
5=.03>.39
. 8609:.0 4539.317 9:/9 764: 0.45>>.31/9<53 <7 359
?<31<3B 53 9:.
0.7;531.39
5=.03>.39
/31 9:/9 >.0.2@ ?.4/67.
5 ( E/7 359 0.45>>.31.1 <9 4/3359 ?. :.21
9:/9 9:. /;;5<39>.39 >/1. ?@ 9:. /;;5<39<3B /69:50<9@
<.
9:.
5=.03>.39 <7 ?/1 <3 2/E 50 <22.B/2 4/22<3B 850 <97
C6/7:>.39
+
9 <7 /275 4539.31.1 ?@ 9:. 2./03.1 45637.2 850
0.7;531.39
F))
5 ( 9:/9 /29:56B:
79<;62/9.7
9:/9
9:.
62. %+ 58 9:.
5;<3<53
62.7 58
9:.
.;69@
5>><77<53.0 <7 95 ?. 5?9/<3.1 /31 9:/9 /22 /;;2<4/9<537
/0. 850E/01.1 /31 9:.0./89.0 4537<1.0.1 ?@ 9:.
61B. 850 /77.77<3B 76<9/?<2<9@
>/31/950@ 350 ?<31<3B 53 9:.
/;;5<39<3B /69:50<9@ ?.<3B 9:.
9:. 7/>. <7 3.<9:.0
5=.03>.39
1=54/9.
/7 9:.
5=.03>.39 <9 0.9/<37 9:.
1<740.9<53 95 /;;5<39 /3@ ;.0753 95 9:. ;579 58
5=.03>.39
<790<49
11<9<53/2
9 <7 /275 4539.31.1 ?@ 2./03.1
-7-
45637.2 9:/9 0.7;531.39
5 ( :/7 /20./1@ 0.;509.1 95 9:.
169<.7 /31 :/7 ?..3 E50A<3B ?59: /9
/7/=/A/2/@/3 /31
6>/3/?/1 E:<4: <7 0.;509.1 95 9:.
5=.03>.39 9:056B:
/ 45>>63<4/9<53 1/9.1 %
(% %
:.0.850. :. 7..A7
0.I.49<53 58 9:<7 ;.9<9<53
)
./03.1
11<9<53/2
5=.03>.39
1=54/9.
/;;./0<3B 850 9:. 0.7;531.39$ 9/9. 4539.317 9:/9 9:.0. <7
35 1<7;69. E<9: 0.B/01 95 9:.
9:.
62.7 58
62.7 95 ?. 85225E.1 /7 ;.0
F)) 850 /;;5<39>.39 58
/E
88<4.07 58 9:.
9/9. 75 /275 9:. 4531<9<537 58 7.0=<4. /31 0.>63.0/9<53
. /275 15.7 359 1<7;69.
62. %+ % 58 9:.
/31 9:. ;054.160. 95 ?. 85225E.1 9:.0.<3
4539.39<53 58 2./03.1
11<9<53/2
62.7 58
F))
9 <7 /275 9:.
5=.03>.39
1=54/9.
9:/9 /3@ /;;5<39>.397 9:/9 <7 153. 850 9:. /E
88<4.07 58
9:.
9/9. 58
/03/9/A/ E<22 :/=. 95 ?. 790<492@ B5=.03.1 ?@
9:.
62.7 58
F))
4/31<1/9.7
?.850. 9:.
4/31<1/9. < .
9 <7 8609:.0 4539.31.1 9:/9 569 58
)
4/31<1/9.7 :/1 /;;./0.1 850 9:. <39.0=<.E
<790<49
61B. /31 569 58
4/31<1/9.7 53.
;.9<9<53.0-7 3/>. E/7 0.45>>.31.1 E<9:
-8-
:<7 5;<3<53 /31 0.>/0A7 0.B/01<3B 76<9/?<2<9@ 58 9:.
;.9<9<53.0 /31 9:. 7/>. E/7 7.39 95 0.7;531.39
:/7 850E/01.1 9:. 7/>. 95 0.7;531.39
'
5 & E:5
5%
:/=. :./01 9:. 2./03.1 45637.2 850 9:.
;.9<9<53.0
/31
9:.
2./03.1
11<9<53/2
5=.03>.39
:. 8/49 0.B/01<3B 4/22<3B 850 9:.
59<8<4/9<53 ?@
1=54/9.
F
0.7;531.39
11<9<53/2
5609 /9
5 & 850 9:. /;;5<39>.39 95 9:. ;579 58
5=.03>.39
1=54/9. 850 9:.
/7/=/A/2@/3 <7 359 1<7;69.1
.3<50
<=<2 61B.
:. ;.9<9<53.0 /31
59:.0 4/31<1/9.7 8<2.1 9:.<0 /;;2<4/9<537 95 9:. 7/<1 ;579
E:<4: <7 359 1<7;69.1
75 /275 <9 <7 359 <3 1<7;69. 9:/9
?/7.1 53 9:. /;;2<4/9<53 850E/01.1 ?@ 0.7;531.39
5&
9:.
61B.
.;69@
5>><77<53.0 95 9:. 2./03.1
0.B/01<3B 9:. 76<9/?<2<9@ 58 /;;5<39>.39 9:.
<790<49
<790<49 61B.
<3 9:. ;0.7.39 4/7. :/7 4537<1.0.1 9:. ;.9<9<53.0 95 ?.
76<9/?2. /31 :/7 /;;.31.1 :<7 0.>/0A7
3 9:. 76<9/?<2<9@
58 9:. ;.9<9<53.0 95 9:. ;579 58
11<9<53/2
1=54/9. 850 9:.
5609 /9
.3<50
<=<2 61B.
5=.03>.39
/7/=/A/2@/3
-9-
9:.
<790<49 61B. :/7 850E/01.1 9:. 7/>. 95 0.7;531.39
5&
E:5 :/7 <3 9603 850E/01.1 <9 850 /;;5<39>.39 95
0.7;531.39
5%
34. 9:<7 ;054.160. <7 85225E.1
9:.
5=.03>.39 <7 2.89 E<9: 35 59:.0 5;9<53 ?69 95 >/A. 9:.
/;;5<39>.39 ?/7.1 53 9:. 0.>/0A7 58 9:.
<790<49
61B.
/31 9:. 850E/01<3B 58 9:. /;;2<4/9<53 E<9: 9:. 5;<3<53 ?@
9:.
.;69@
5=.03>.39
5>><77<53.0
7:/22
:. E5017 67.1 :.0. /0. J9:.
9:.0./89.0
>/A.
:/=<3B 0.B/01 95 9:. 0.>/0A7 58
.;69@
5>><77<53.0K
>/31/9. 95 9:.
:.0.850.
9:.
/;;5<39>.397
<790<49
61B. /31 9:.
9:.0.
5=.03>.39 0.7;531.39
<7
/
42./0
5 % 95 ;054..1
8609:.0 /31 9:.0./89.0 95 >/A. /;;5<39>.39 53 9:. ?/7<7
58 9:. 0.>/0A7 58 9:. 2./03.1
.;69@
<790<49
61B. /31 9:.
5>><77<53.0 E:<4: :/7 /20./1@ ?..3 153. <3 9:.
;0.7.39 4/7. <3 8/=560 58 9:. ;.9<9<53.0 E:<4: <7 ;05164.1
/9
33.D60.7 $
/31
3 9:. 45390/0@ 9:.0. <7 35 764:
0.45>>.31/9<53 >/1. E<9: 0.B/01 95 76<9/?<2<9@ 58 9:.
4/31<1/960.
0.7;531.39
11<9<53/2
5=.03>.39
5(
/;;5<39>.39
1=54/9. 3.<9:.0 ?@ 9:.
.;69@
- 10 -
5>><77<53.0 0.7;531.39
61B.
?69
:5E.=.0
790/3B.2@
/;;5<39.1 0.7;531.39
5=.03>.39
5 & 350 ?@ 9:. 2./03.1
0.7;531.39
<790<49
5%
5 ( 95 9:. ;579 58
:/7
11<9<53/2
1=54/9. E:<4: 0637 <3 959/2 =<52/9<53 /31
82/B0/39 45390/1<49<53 95 9:.
62.7 58
F))
<7 >50. 1<7/1=/39/B.567 95 0.7;531.39
./02<.0 544/7<53 <3 "0<9
7/>. 0.7;531.39
.9<9<53
5%
5 ( 9:/9 53 9:.
F) % %( 9:. =.0@
5 ( :.0.<3 E/7 /;;5<39.1 160<3B 9:.
9.360. 58 9:. ;.9<9<53.0 9:.0.<3 3/>.2@
4/>. 95 ?. C6/7:.1 /31 9:.
/1:.0. 790<492@ 95
22 9:. >50. <9
62.
0/A/7: E:<4:
5=.03>.39 E/7 1<0.49.1 95
5 %+ & 58 9:.
>/A. 80.7: /;;5<39>.39
0<
:.0.850.
62.7 58
F)) /31
/> 58 9:. =<.E 9:/9
9:. ;0.7.39 ;.9<9<53 E5621 7644..1 /31 9:. /;;5<39>.39 58
0.7;531.39
5 ( ?.<3B 45390/0@ 95 9:.
>50. 7;.4<8<4/22@
62. %+ % 58 9:.
:/=. 95 ?. C6/7:.1
44501<3B2@
85225E<3B
/
:. "0<9 .9<9<53 <7
62.7 58
62.7 58
F))
F)) E5621
;054..1 95 ;/77 9:.
- 11 -
?
:. <>;6B3.1 501.0 1/9.1
&
?@
?./0<3B
0.7;531.39
% ' % %(
5%
<1.
(% %
;/77.1
33.D60. $ ! <7 :.0.?@
C6/7:.1
:. 0.7;531.397 /0. :.0.?@ 1<0.49.1 95 /;;5<39
9:.
;.9<9<53.0
5=.03>.39
5609 /9
9:.
;579
1=54/9. 850 9:.
/7/=/A/2@/3 E<9:<3
11<9<53/2
.3<50
<=<2 61B.
1/@7 805> 9:.
1/9. 58 0.4.<;9 58 / 45;@ 58 9:<7 501.0
01.0.1 /44501<3B2@
.
.31<3B
<39.02546950@
/;;2<4/9<537
;/2.
<37<B3<8<4/34.
'(
%
&
!
<79
%
<395
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review