Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on:16.12.2025
Judgment pronounced on: 09.01.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 09.01.2026
+
RFA(OS) 5/2017, CM APPL. 6715/2019, CM APPL.
2105/2021, CM APPL. 54875/2024 & CM APPL. 30790/2025
SANDEEP SETHI & ANR
.....Appellants
Through: Mr. Anil Sapra, Sr. Adv. with Mr.
Amrit Pal S. Gambhir & Mr.
Dalip Mehra, Advs. with Mr.
Sandeep
Sethi/Appellant
in
person
versus
RAJINDER KUMAR SETHI DECEASED THROUGH LRS
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Ashish Mohan, Sr. Adv.
with Ms. Manisha Singh, Adv.
+
RFA(OS) 10/2017, CM APPL. 6808/2017 & CM APPL.
6721/2019
SANDEEP SETHI & ANR
.....Appellants
Through: Mr. Anil Sapra, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Amrit Pal S. Gambhir &
Mr. Dalip Mehra, Advs. with
Mr. Sandeep Sethi/Appellant in
person
versus
RAJINDER KUMAR SETHI DECEASED THROUGH LRS
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Ashish Mohan, Sr. Adv.
with Ms. Manisha Singh, Adv.
+
RFA(OS) 6/2017 & CM APPL. 6720/2019
RAJINDER KUMAR SETHI DECEASED THROUGH LRS
.....Appellant
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
Through:
versus
SANDEEP SETHI & ANR
Through:
Mr. Ashish Mohan, Sr. Adv.
with Ms. Manisha Singh, Adv.
.....Respondents
Mr. Anil Sapra, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. Amrit Pal S. Gambhir &
Mr. Dalip Mehra, Advs. along
with R-1 in person.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARISH VAIDYANATHAN
SHANKAR
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
1.
Through the present Appeals, the Appellants [Defendants
before the learned Single Judge] in RFA (OS) No. 05/2017 and in
RFA (OS) No. 10/2017, and the Appellant [Plaintiff before the learned
Single Judge] in RFA (OS) No. 06/2017, assail the correctness of the
common judgement dated 28.11.2016 [hereinafter referred to as
„Impugned Judgement‟] passed by the learned Single Judge
[hereinafter referred to as „LSJ‟] in CS(OS) 2134/2006 & CC No.
990/2017, wherein the Plaintiff‟s suit was decreed against the
Defendants in the said suit, directing the Defendants to handover the
possession of the entire first floor and two rooms along with one
bathroom on the second floor of the Property bearing No. A-8, Vishal
Enclave, New Delhi [hereinafter referred to as „Suit Property‟], as
shown in the site plan, within two months of receipt of this order. The
Counter Claim filed by the Defendant stood dismissed in view of the
Impugned Judgement passed in the suit.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
2.
Since the parties to the disputes are common, as is the
Impugned Judgement, and the appeals arise out of an identical factual
matrix involving overlapping parties and common questions of law,
this Court deems it appropriate to dispose of all the appeals by way of
a common judgement. The discussions, however, shall be bifurcated,
wherever necessary, while referring to the parties in the same manner.
3.
Nevertheless, for the ease of reference and with the consent of
the parties, RFA (OS) No.5/2017 is considered as a lead case. For the
sake of convenience, the parties before this court shall be referred to
in accordance with their respective status before the LSJ.
FACTUAL MATRIX
4.
For a comprehensive consideration of the issues involved, it is
apposite, at the outset, to delineate the attendant factual matrix, which
are set out in the ensuing paragraphs.
4.1
The Plaintiff is the registered owner of the Suit Property, which
was originally leased from the Municipal Corporation of Delhi
[hereinafter referred to as „MCD‟] pursuant to a perpetual lease dated
11.05.1971. It is stated that the Plaintiff thereafter constructed a threestorey building on the said plot from his own funds and resources.
4.2
It is further stated that the aforesaid property was subsequently
converted into free-hold in favour of the Plaintiff vide a conveyance
deed dated 05.01.2011. The Plaintiff bore all the expenses relating to
the conversion, and on that basis, asserts exclusive ownership over the
Suit Property as his self-acquired property.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
4.3
The Defendant, elder brother of the Plaintiff, was allowed to
use and occupy the first floor, and two rooms along with one
bathroom on the second floor of the Suit Property, purely out of
natural love and affection. No consideration was ever charged from
the Defendant for such use or occupation.
4.4
The Plaintiff states that the oral licence granted in favour of the
Defendant was revoked in September 2006. Upon revocation, the
Defendant sought 15 days‟ time to shift, remove his belongings, and
hand over the physical possession of the premises. However, despite
such assurance, the Defendant failed to vacate the Suit Property.
Consequently, a legal notice dated 26.10.2006 was issued to the
Defendant.
4.5
Despite due service of the aforesaid notice, the Defendant
neither replied thereto nor complied with its terms. In terms of the
notice, the licence to occupy the Suit Property stood revoked, and the
Defendant was granted seven days time to vacate the premises, and
handover vacant and peaceful possession to the Plaintiff.
4.6
Since the Defendant did not comply with the same, the present
suit was instituted, seeking the following reliefs:
“A. A decree of possession be passed in favour of the Plaintiff
and against the Defendant in respect of the entire first floor and
two rooms and one bathroom on the Second Floor, as shown
within red lines in the site plan attached with the plaint, of the
property bearing No. A-8, Vishal Enclave, New Delhi.
B. That a further decree of Rs. 2000/- on account of damages
and mene profits be also passed in favour of the Plaintiff and
against the Defendant, for the period of 04.11.2006 till the date
of filing of the Suit.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
C. That a further decree @Rs. 1,000/- per day on such rate at
which this Hon’ble Court may arrive at after holding enquiry
under Order XX Rule 12 of the CPC be also passed in favour of
the Plaintiff and against the Defendant as damages and mene
profits pendente lite and future till handing over of its physical
and vacant possession of the property in question. The Plaintiff
undertakes to pay deficient court fee at the time of decree.
D. Cost of the suit may also be awarded in favour of the Plaintiff
against the Defendant.
E. Any other or further order which this Hon’ble Court may
deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case
may also be passed in favour of the Plaintiff and against the
Defendant.”
5.
The Defendant filed a written statement and also raised a
counter- claim on the following grounds:
5.1
While the execution of the lease deed dated 11.5.1971 is not
disputed, the Defendant denies that the Plaintiff is the exclusive owner
of the Suit Property.
5.2
The ground floor of the Suit property was constructed out of the
joint funds of the Plaintiff and the Defendant, whereas the first and the
second floors were constructed solely by the Defendant using his own
resources, pursuant to a family arrangement under which those floors
were to belong exclusively to him.
5.3
The Defendant disputes the Plaintiff‟s assertion that the entire
expenditure for conversion of the property from leasehold to freehold
was borne exclusively by the Plaintiff.
5.4
It is further pleaded that the suit is not maintainable, is not
properly valued, is barred by limitation, and is also barred by the law
of adverse possession.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
5.5
According to the Defendants, upon the demise of the father of
the parties, both the sons i.e. the Plaintiff and the Original Defendant,
inherited his estate and business, a substantial portion of which was
joint in nature. It is stated that the Plaintiff, Defendant, and their father
jointly participated in the auction, and upon being declared successful,
the property was purchased in the name of the Plaintiff, at the instance
of their father, in order to circumvent the terms and conditions of the
auction, which prohibited participation by a person already owning
property in Delhi. The initial amount of Rs.10,300/-, as well as the
subsequent instalments, are stated to have been paid out of joint funds.
5.6
The counter-claim further avers that the Plaintiff mortgaged the
Suit Property to obtain a loan, and thereafter in November 1976,
applied for sanction of building plans for construction of the ground
floor. Upon approval, a dwelling unit was built using joint funds, as
reflected in the occupancy certificate dated 16.05.1981. Both the
families are stated to have shifted to the newly constructed ground
floor on 04.11.1979. Prior thereto, the parties were residing together in
another property bearing No. B-1, Radhey Puri, Delhi, which
admittedly belongs to the Defendant, and whose ownership and
possession are not in dispute. Under the alleged family arrangement,
the Plaintiff was to assist the Defendant in securing sanction of
building plans, and in the installation of water and electricity meters in
the name of Defendant.
5.7
It is further stated that it was agreed between the parties that the
first and second floors of the Suit Property would be constructed by
the Defendant from his own funds, and that, in the event of sale of the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
Suit Property, the sale proceeds would be divided equally between the
two brothers. The Defendants claimed to have utilised the funds
received from the sale of Vivek Vihar Property, as well as the
drawings from his business, towards the construction of the first and
second floors, for which sanction was allegedly granted on
24.03.1988.
5.8
The Defendants plead that the records of the MCD reflected his
name and that of his son, i.e. the Sandeep Rathi, were got noted as
owners and occupants of the first and second floors of the Suit
Property, since they alone interacted with municipal authorities. The
reliance is placed on a notice dated 13.10.1989, which is stated to
confirm their use and occupation of the said portions. In mid- 2003, at
the request of the Plaintiff, the Plaintiff‟s son was permitted to use a
part of the second floor, for the purpose of storage.
5.9
The Defendants also provide a detailed narrative of the family‟s
movements, stating that after partition, the family initially stayed at
Jammu with their maternal uncle, thereafter, moved to Karnal and
subsequently settled in Delhi. During this period, several premises
were taken on rent, following which, the parties shifted to Radhey
Puri and throughout, the parties are said to have lived jointly as a
family.
6.
The following issues were framed on 04.07.2007 in the suit“1. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to a decree of possession in
respect of A-8, Vishal Enclave, New Delhi, as claimed?
2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to damages/mesne profits of
Rs.2000/-from the defendant till the period of filing of the suit
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
and @ Rs.l000/- per day for the period after filing of the suit
from the defendant as claimed or damages/mesne profits at any
other rate? OPD
3. Whether the suit is barred by limitation? OPD
4. Whether the suit has not been properly valued and liable to be
dismissed for want of court fee? OPD''
7.
The following issues were framed in the counter claim:
"1. Whether the defendant is entitled to decree of declaration
that he was the owner of 1st and 2nd floor and proposed owner
of land underneath A-8, Vishal Enclave, New Delhi?
2. CS(OS)No.2134/2006 Whether the defendant is entitled to
mandatory injunction as claimed in the counter claim for
removal of obstructions of plaintiff and his agents and servants
etc in use and occupation of 1st and 2nd Floor of the property by
the defendant?
3. Whether there was any family settlement as claimed by the
defendant dated 25.10.1970 and4.11.1979? OPD.
4. Whether the counter claims have not been properly valued
and are liable to be dismissed for want of proper court-fee?
5. Whether the counter claims of the defendant are barred under
Benami Transaction Act? OPD
6. Relief"
8.
The Plaintiff placed reliance on the partnership deed (Ex.
DW1/1) to demonstrate that the original parties were partners in a
firm, thereby seeking to negate the existence of any Joint Hindu
Family [hereinafter referred to as „JHF‟].
9.
During cross-examination, DW1 admitted that, on the date of
auction, no registered property stood in the name of Sh. Trilok Chand
Sethi. The Defendant also placed on record, a letter issued by MCD
concerning unauthorised construction [Ex. DW1/16]. DW1 further
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
acknowledged that the Vivek Vihar property had been sold by his
father, who thereafter purchased a flat in Mumbai. DW1 also admitted
that he was unable to produce any document to show that his father
had ever paid house tax in respect of the Suit Property or borne any
charges for converting the property from leasehold to freehold. The
only document produced by DW1 in support of construction, was an
invoice for 200 bags of cement, issued in his own name.
10.
DW1 deposed that the Suit Property was purchased in an
auction, conducted in the year 1970. According to him, the original
parties, their father, and an old friend of the Plaintiff, went for the
MCD auction. The father was allegedly made aware of the terms and
conditions of bidding, including the stipulation that a bidder should
not own any other property in Delhi. A copy of these terms and
conditions has been exhibited as Ex.DW1/2.
11.
DW1 further stated that the property bearing No. D-253 Vivek
Vihar, which was in the name of the original Defendant, was sold after
the parties shifted to the Suit Property on 04.11.1979. A copy of the
passbook, exhibited as Ex. DW1/3, was relied upon, to show that
funds from their joint account were used to pay household expenses
relating to the Suit Property. A copy of the ration card of the Plaintiff
has been exhibited as Ex. DW 1/8.
12.
DW1 further deposed that, pursuant to an alleged agreement of
1970, and subsequent family arrangements of 1974, and 04.11.1979,
the first and second floors of the Suit Property were always intended
to belong to the original Defendant.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
13.
The Plaintiff filed his evidence by way of an affidavit, exhibited
as Ex.PW1/A, wherein it was deposed that the Suit Property was
purchased by the Plaintiff in an auction conducted by the MCD for a
sum of Rs.41,200/-, which was paid entirely from his own earnings.
The original perpetual lease deed dated 11.05.1971, has been
exhibited as Ex. PW1/2, and the Conveyance Deed dated 05.01.2001,
executed in favour of the Plaintiff, has been exhibited as Ex.PW1/3.
The documents pertaining to house tax, assessment orders, and
various notices issued in the Plaintiff‟s name have been exhibited as
Ex.PW1/5 to Ex. PW1/12. The site plan marking the portion in
possession of the Defendant, in red, was exhibited as Ex.PW1/1. The
copy of legal notice dated 26.10.2006, has been exhibited as
Ex.PW1/15, postal documents such as UPC, have been exhibited as
Ex.PW1/16, and the postal receipts, have been exhibited as
Ex.PW1/17, respectively.
14.
To facilitate better comprehension and enable ready reference
for all stakeholders, including the Appellate courts, the tabulated
charts are incorporated hereinafter, summarising the witnesses
examined and the documents exhibited.
List of Plaintiff Witnesses examined-
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
Plaintiff
Witness No.
Name of witness
Description
1.
Rajinder Kumar Sethi
Plaintiff
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
List of Exhibited Documents by PlaintiffExhibit
No.
Description of the Exhibit
Proved
by/Attested
by
P-1
Original letter dated 13.10.1989 by
MCD
Plaintiff
P-2
Original Perpetual Lease Deed dated
11.5.1971
Plaintiff
P-3
Original letter dated 04.11.1970 of
acceptance of the bid of the plot in
question written by the MCD
Plaintiff
List of exhibited documents by PW-1
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
Exhibit
No.
Description of the Exhibit
Proved
by/Attested
by
1.
Copy of Site plan showing the plot of
the Suit Property
PW-1
2.
Original perpetual Lease Deed dated
11.5.1971
PW-1
3.
Copy of a conveyance Deed dated
05.01.2001
PW-1
4.
Copy of Occupation Certificate obtained
by the Plaintiff from MCD
PW-1
5.
Assessment Order dated 02.09.97
PW-1
6.
House Tax paid by the Plaintiff
PW-1
7-12
A copy of proposals to make some
amendment in the assessment list by the
MCD, seeking objection from the
PW-1
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
claimant
14.
Reply to show cause notice dated
13.10.1989 against the Suit property by
the Plaintiff dated 23.10.1989
PW-1
15.
Copy of the notice dated 26.10.2006
sent by the Advocate to the Defendant,
asking to shift from the premises
PW-1
16.
Postal Documents
PW-1
A.
Affidavit of PW-1
PW-1
P-6
Photograph
PW-1
List of Defendant Witnesses examinedDefendant
Witness
No.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
Name of Witness
Description
1.
Sandeep Kumar Sethi
Defendant No.1(a)
2.
Deepak Yadav
LDC Land and
Estate Department
3.
Mahesh Nepali
Data Entry Operator
at Delhi Public
School
4.
Raj Kumar Rana
Dealing Assistant in
Lab (res.) DDA
5.
Ranbir Singh
Dealing Clerk,
Assessment &
Collection Deptt.,
MCD
6.
Pawan Kumar Tekriwal
Cement Stockist
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
7.
Gurbachan Singh Jaggi
Ex-civil contractor
8.
Vijay Handa
Ex-Electrician
9.
Babu Lal Gupta
Iron & Steel
Business
10.
Shree Ram Dandona
Architect
11.
Vijay Verma
Chartered
Accountant
12.
O.P. Maggon
Retd. Addl. Dy.
Commissioner
13.
Satish Kohli
Businessman
14.
Krishan Kumar Nagpal
Architect
15.
Abdul Malik
Accountant
16.
Ashok Kumar Sahani
Business
17.
Anand Kumar Chopra
Consultant
18.
Qayam Ali
ASI
19.
Ritu Suri
House-wife
20.
Surender Singh
Maura Clerk
List of exhibited documents by Defendants–
Defendant Witness-1
Exhibit
No.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
Description
Proved
by/Attested
by
P-2
Photograph
DW-1
P-3
Photograph of Marriage
DW-1
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
P-3
Photograph of Vandana Sethi
DW-1
P-5
A letter dated 04.11.1970 by MCD to the
Plaintiff, directing him to pay the
balance amount of Rs.30,900/-
DW-1
P-7
Photograph of cement bags
DW-1
P-I
A letter dated 18.02.97 written by
Sandeep Sethi to the Deputy Assessor &
Collector, requesting to fix next date of
hearing citing the reason that Sh.
Rajinder Kumar Sethi is not available at
that time i.e. on 19.02.97
DW-1
1.
A
partnership
deed
dated 06.04.1964 between Sh. Rajinder
Kumar Sethi and Sh. Sushil Kumar
Sethi, mutually agreeing that now the
business will be carried under the name
and style of M/S. Tara Rubber Industries
DW-1
2.
Terms & Conditions for the sale by
auction by the MCD of perpetual lease
hold rights in residential plots
DW-1
3.
Copy of the passbook enclosing the
details that a joint saving bank was
opened by the Plaintiff, in the names of
both the Plaintiff and Defendant
DW-1
4.
Copy of one bill of the cement purchased
DW-1
5.
Documents issued under the RTI
DW-1
6.
Copy of an affidavit of terms and
conditions that the party should not own
any other property in Delhi at the time of
auction.
DW-1
7.
Copies of the documents like Drafting
and Executing the relinquishment deed
DW-1
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
etc.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
8.
Ration card of the Plaintiff
Copy
of
letter
changed address
previous
DW-1
11.
Death certificate of Sh. Tilak Chand
Sethi, father of the parties.
DW-1
12.
Death certificate of the mother of the
parties
DW-1
13.
Indemnity
bond
of
Defendant dated 23.05.1978
original
DW-1
14.
Relinquishment Deed dated 20.05.1978,
whereby the property bearing No. B-1,
Radhey Puri, Delhi-51, was released by
the Plaintiff in favour of the Defendant
DW-1
15.
A copy of the documents, disclosing the
correspondence assisted by the Plaintiff
DW-1
16.
Copy
of
MCD
dated 13.10.1989 issued
the Defendant
notice
to
DW-1
17.
Conversion from Lease Hold to Free
hold of the Suit Property
DW-1
18.
Photograph of gymnasium
DW-1
19.
Copy of FIR dated 13.12.2000 u/s
323/365/511/34 IPC
DW-1
20.
Photographs of driveway leading up to
the stair as well as to be used for parking
of cars by the Defendants
DW-1
21 and 22
Photographs of main stair ways as well
as the alternate one, leading from
DW-1
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
with
DW-1
1st floor to second floor.
Photo
of
gymnasium
24.
Photograph
advertisement of
the
DW-1
DW-1
Defendant Witness-2
Exhibit
No.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
Description
Proved
by/Attested
by
1.
Application dated 25.10.70 by the
Highest Bider for the purchase of the
perpetual lease hold rights
DW-2
2.
A letter dated 04.11.1970 by MCD to the
Plaintiff, directing him to pay the
balance amount of Rs.30,900/-
DW-2
3.
No objection certificate to mortgage the
plot no.8, Sector B&C on Najaf Garh
Road near Tagore Garden, New Delhi27.
DW-2
4.
Request by the Plaintiff for grant of
mortgage in respect of the aforestated
plot.
DW-2
5.
Mutation of Plot No. D-203,
Jhilmil Tahirpur Residential Scheme
DW-2
6.
Regarding carrying the mentioned
development works in the construction
of the building.
DW-2
7.
Ration card of the Plaintiff
DW-2
8.
Ration card of the Defendant
DW-2
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
9.
Letter to the Defendant to deposit
Rs.156 for 78 documents in reference to
his application dated 30.11.2010 under
RTI Act, 2005
DW-2
10.
Auction sheet dated 25.10.1970
DW-2
11.
Letter by the Plaintiff in reference to the
direction of payment issued by
the Assistant Commissioner
DW-2
12.
Copy of site plan showing the plot of the
Suit Property
DW-2
13.
Letter dated 04.10.75, issued by
the MCD to the Plaintiff, with regards to
the possession of plot no. A-8, Sector B,
Najafgarh Road, Delhi
DW-2
14.
Acknowledgement by the Assistant
Commissioner in regard to the receiving
of an application from the Plaintiff along
with Lease Deed of the said plot.
DW-2
15.
Letter dated 21.11.1976, issued by the
MCD to the Plaintiff, with regards to the
possession of plot no. A-8, Sector B,
Najafgarh Road, Delhi
DW-2
16.
MCD confirms that the lease
agreement is registered in the name of
the Plaintiff with respect to Plot no. A8.
DW-2
17.
Letter dated 29.11.1975 affirming that
the possession letter is put up for the
signatures.
DW-2
18.
Certification that possession of 400 sq.
Yds of land bearing plot no. A-8, taken
by the Plaintiff.
DW-2
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
19.
Copy of Certificate issued by the Zonal
engineer that the building no. A-8 has
been inspected and declared that it is in
conformity with all the requirements and
is suitable for occupancy.
DW-2
20.
Copy of Perpetual Lease Deed dated
11.05.1971
DW-2
21.
The Plaintiff intends to transfer by way
of mortgage the urban land bearing No.
A-I, Radhey Puri, Delhi-51.
DW-2
22.
Copy of Grant of mortgage
permission in respect of plot no.8, Sector
B &C for which loan has been
sanctioned for construction of building
thereon.
DW-2
23.
Copy of No objection certificate to
mortgage the plot no.8, Sector B&C on
Najaf Garh Road
DW-2
24.
Copy of a Letter by the MCD to
the Plaintiff, for payment of the
outstanding amount of Rs.2064 against
the ground floor rent.
DW-2
25.
Assistant Commissioner received the
lease deed of the Plaintiff.
DW-2
26.
Copy of Application dated
16.12.1999, filed by the Plaintiff, for
conversion of leasehold property into
freehold property
DW-2
27.
Copy of Indemnity Bond executed on
13.12.1999.
DW-2
28.
Affidavit filed by the Plaintiff, asserting
that no unauthorised property is being
DW-2
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
used only for residential purpose.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
29.
An undertaking by the Plaintiff, to
pay the amount in respect of Suit
Property, on demand.
DW-2
30.
A letter by the MCD in regard to the
application for conversion of the
property, stating that it is under process.
DW-2
31.
Copy of Specimen signatures and
Passport Size photographs of the person
in whose favour conversion is sought
duly attested.
DW-2
32.
Copy of letter dated 18.08.97, Govt. Of
NCT of Delhi informed the Plaintiff
that the property has been free from loan
and the documents are returned.
DW-2
33.
Copy of Perpetual Lease Deed dated
11.05.1971
DW-2
34.
Copy of payment of rent amount of
ground floor, paid by the
Plaintiff [11.05.1996 to 10.05.1997]
DW-2
35.
Copy of payment of rent amount of
ground floor, paid by the
Plaintiff [11.05.1997 to 10.05.1998]
DW-2
36.
Copy of deficiencies marked by the
MCD, in the application of the Plaintiff
for the conversion of the property.
DW-2
37.
Copy of the sanctioned plan of the
Plaintiff‟s house submitted by the
Plaintiff to the Deputy Commissioner.
DW-2
38.
Copy of the Conveyance Deed
DW-2
39.
Copy of the execution of Conveyance
DW-2
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
Deed in respect of the Suit property.
40.
Copy of payment of rent amount of
ground floor, paid by the
Plaintiff [11.05.1998 to 10.05.1999] &
[11.05.1999 to 10.05.2000]
DW-2
41.
Copy of payment of rent amount of
ground floor, paid by the Plaintiff
[11.05.1999 to 10.05.2000]
DW-2
Defendant Witness-3
Exhibit
No.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
Description
Proved
by/Attest
ed by
1.
Copy certifying that daughter of Mr. Ajay
Sethi is a bonafide student of Delhi Public
School and copy of enrolment form of his
daughter
DW-3
2.
Copy of Birth Certificate of daughter of Ajay
Sethi.
DW-3
3.
Copy of Health Card of the daughter of Mr.
Ajay Sethi
DW-3
4.
Copy of ration card of Ajay Sethi
DW-3
5.
Copy of registration form of the daughter of
Mr. Ajay Sethi
DW-3
7.
Copy of enrolment form of the daughter of
Ajay Sethi
DW-3
8.
Copy of birth certificate of the daughter of
Ajay Sethi
DW-3
9.
Copy of health card of the daughter of Ajay
DW-3
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
Sethi
10.
Copy of Ration Card of Ajay Sethi
DW-3
11.
Copy of I-card of the daughter of Ajay Sethi
DW-3
12.
Copy certifying that daughter of Mr. Ajay
Sethi is a bonafide student of Delhi Public
School.
DW-3
13.
Copy of summons for producing the admission
documents of son and daughter of Mr. Ajay
Sethi
DW-3
Defendant Witness No.-5
Exhibit
No.
P-I
Description
Copy of property tax assessment
Proved
by/Attested
by
DW-5
Defendant Witness No.9
Exhibit
No.
A
Description
Certified copy of Rajasthan Iron Traders,
certifying that they had supplied Tor Steel
to the Defendant for construction of 1st and
2nd floor.
Proved
by/Attested
by
DW-3
Defendant Witness No. 10
Exhibit
No.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
Description
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
Proved
by/Attested
by
A.
Copy of the sanctioned plan of the suit
property
DW-10
Defendant Witness No. 18
Exhibit
No.
A.
Description
Proved
by/Attested
by
C Copy of the cancellation report of FIR sent DW-18
to concerned Mahila Court, Dwarka, New
Delhi
Defendant Witness No.19
Exhibit
No.
A.
Description
Copy of affidavit of the Defendant No.1(b)
i.e. Ritu Suri
Proved
by/Attested
by
DW-19
Defendant Witness No. 20
Exhibit
No.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
Description
Proved
by/Attested
by
A.
Copy of FIR dated 02.07.2001
DW-20
B.
Copy of in re-complaint by wife
Vandana Sethi with CAW cell, filed by
Ajay Sethi
DW-20
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
15.
Upon consideration of the pleadings and evidence on record,
the Suit was decreed in favour of the Plaintiff on the following
grounds:
15.1 The Plaintiff successfully proved his ownership of the Suit
Property, by virtue of the perpetual lease deed dated 11.05.1971
(Ex.PW1/2), and conveyance deed dated 05.01.2001 (Ex.PW1/3). He
has also established that the sanctioned building plans, occupancy
certificate, house tax records, electricity and water meters stood in his
name. The Defendants failed to adduce any evidence to substantiate
the existence or implementation
of any family settlement.
Furthermore, the Defendant did not place on record any documentary
proof, to show that any expenditure was incurred by the original
Defendant towards the construction of the ground, 1st or 2nd floors.
Although reliance was placed on a bank passbook, the same did not
establish payment of electricity or water charges, as claimed.
Consequently, the Plaintiff was held to be the absolute owner of the
Suit Property, and entitled to its possession. Accordingly, the issue
no.1 in the suit and issue nos. 1 and 3 in the counter-claim were
decided in the Plaintiff‟s favour.
15.2 The LSJ observed that there was no cross-examination or
rebuttal by the Defendant with respect to the rate of damages/mesne
profits claimed by the Plaintiff. Considering the relationship between
the parties, damages/mesne profits @ Rs.30,000/- per month, were
granted in favour of the Plaintiff and against the Defendant.
15.3 On the point of limitation, the Defendants failed to establish
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
adverse possession over the Suit Property. No evidence or anything
was produced to show that the suit was barred by limitation. Since, the
license of the Defendant was revoked by a legal notice dated
25.10.2006, and the suit was filed on 06.11.2006, the Suit was held to
be well within the period of limitation.
15.4 The onus pertaining to the issue no 4 in the suit was on the
Defendant, however, the Defendant failed to discharge it. The suit had
been valued by the Plaintiff in accordance with the market value of the
Suit Property. The issue is, therefore, decided in favour of the Plaintiff
and against the Defendant.
15.5 With regard to the issue no.2 in the counter-claim, the
Defendant relied on photographs of the gym, allegedly run by Sh.
Ajay Sethi, son of the Plaintiff, at the Suit Property, to establish the
obstructions in the Defendant‟s use and occupation of the premises.
However, in view of the Plaintiff having established his ownership
and the Defendant having failed to prove any right, title, or interest in
the Suit property, the said contention was rejected.
15.6 Pertaining to valuation of the Court Fee, in respect of the
counter-claim, the LSJ held that the Counter Claims had been properly
valued in terms of para 25 thereof. Consequently, this issue was
decided in favour of the Defendant and against the Plaintiff.
15.7 Lastly, with regard to the issue no.5 in the counter-claim, in
view of the bar contained under Section 4(2) of the Prohibition of
Benami Property Transactions Act, 1988 [hereinafter referred to as
„the Benami Act‟], this issue was decided in favour of the Plaintiff and
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
against the Defendant.
16.
In light of these findings, the LSJ decreed the suit, in favour of
the Plaintiff, and the Counter Claim stood dismissed accordingly.
CONTENTION OF THE PARTIES
17.
The learned counsel for the Appellants/Defendants advanced
the following submissions:
RFA (OS) NO. 5/2017 & RFA (OS) NO. 10/2017
17.1 The Defendants aver that the Plaintiff could be said to be
holding the Suit Property in a fiduciary capacity only as a member of
the Hindu Family, and that the Suit Property was initially purchased,
and subsequently developed by construction of various floors, out of
common and joint family funds.
17.2 It is further averred that the LSJ has erred in failing to return
any findings on a crucial argument raised on behalf of the Defendants,
viz the averments of the Defendants in the counter-claim, having not
been specifically denied or challenged by the Plaintiff, stood admitted,
yet were completely ignored in the Impugned Judgement. In this
regard, the Appellants specifically rely upon the averments pertaining
to utilisation of joint funds, payments allegedly made for acquisition
of the Suit Property by Late Sh. T.C. Sethi, from joint funds,
expenditure incurred towards construction of the dwelling unit from
joint funds, the alleged common business agreement of 1970, and the
family arrangement dated 04.11.1979. According to the Defendants,
these averments go to the very root of the matter and establish the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
counter-claim in their favour.
17.3 The Defendants further submit that it is settled law that the
burden of proof to establish the quantum and justification of mesne
profits, lies upon the party claiming the same. The Impugned
Judgement, it is urged, has awarded mesne profits without any
evidence on record, and solely on the ground of suggestion being
made by the counsel of the Plaintiff.
17.4 It is also contended that the LSJ erred in awarding interest on an
alleged amount termed as mesne profits. It is pointed out that the suit
remained pending for several years, partly due to delays occasioned
during mediation proceedings, and also because the Impugned
Judgement remained reserved for a considerable period, for which the
Defendants cannot be faulted.
17.5 The Defendants contend that it was an admitted fact that the
land standing in the name of the father of the erstwhile parties stood
acquired shortly prior to the date of auction by MCD. This fact
assumes significance, in light of the terms of the auction, which
stipulated that ownership of any other property would render the bid
liable to rejection. It is for this reason, inter alia, that the bid was
recorded in the name of the younger son, i.e., the Plaintiff. According
to the Defendants, this crucial aspect has been completely overlooked
by the LSJ.
17.6 The LSJ is also stated to have erred in ignoring the fact that
everything
including
houses/residencies/businesses,
income
&
expenditure etc. were joint and derived from a common source of
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
funds namely, joint family business. This fact, it is contended, was not
denied in the pleadings and stood admitted in evidence.
17.7 The Defendants further contend that the provisions of the
Benami Act, and the settled law thereunder, have been ignored by the
LSJ. According to the Defendants, the Plaintiff could only be said to
be holding the Suit Property in a fiduciary capacity, as part of the
Hindu Family, and that the Suit Property was purchased and
developed out of common funds.
17.8 It is also argued that the LSJ inequitably noted the sale of the
Vivek Vihar property by the Defendant, and the purchase of an
alternative property at Dhanu Road, Maharashtra, while completely
ignoring the comparative monetary values involved in these
transactions.
17.9 The Defendants assert that joint bank account of the business
was used for making payment for all property tax, electricity, water,
repayments of loan, and construction related payments. This,
according to them, was consistent with the understanding that the Suit
Property was joint, and that steps would subsequently be taken to
record joint ownership in official records, pursuant to the family
arrangement.
17.10 It is further pertinent to note that that even the Plaintiff has
utterly failed to show any source of his funds for the construction,
which he claims to have undertaken from his own resources. It is
submitted that the Plaintiff had no known source of income at the
relevant time, whereas, the Defendants had demonstrated availability
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
of funds through sale of properties, constitute facts which were
allegedly ignored by the LSJ.
17.11 The Defendants also contend that the LSJ erred in relying upon
the judgement in Hemaji1, as the facts of that case were entirely
distinguishable and the law laid down therein was not applicable to
the present matter.
17.12 It is further submitted that the LSJ failed to apply the law laid
down by the Apex Court in, Marcel Martins v. M. Printers2. The
circumstances, in which the Suit Property was purchased in the name
of the Plaintiff, assumes great importance while determining whether
the Plaintiff held the property in a fiduciary capacity vis-à-vis the
Defendants. On this basis as well, the Defendants assert that the Suit
property was acquired and developed from common funds.
17.13 The LSJ is also stated to have erred in accepting the Plaintiff‟s
contention that the jewellery belonging to his wife was sold to finance
construction of the Suit Property. This claim, according to the
Defendants, stood completely demolished, during the Defendant‟s
cross-examination on 25.10.2010, wherein he admitted that no
documentary proof such as income tax returns or bank statements was
available, to establish the availability of funds or the existence of such
jewellery.
17.14 The Defendants further rely upon evidence led by the
Defendant No.2 to contend that the only gold in the household was
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
AIR 2009 SC 103
AIR 2012 SC 1987
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
either bought or inherited by the father of the erstwhile parties, and
that a portion thereof was sold to repay a loan taken by the father of
the parties from one Mr. K.C. Kapoor, at the time of auction bidding.
17.15 It is also highlighted that both the Plaintiff and his son admitted
that during matrimonial disputes between son and the daughter-in-law,
the daughter-in-law had taken away her entire jewellery/stridhan, as
well as the jewellery belonging to the wife of the Plaintiff, sometime
during 2007-2008. This fact, supported by police records, clearly
demonstrates that no jewellery was available for sale to finance
construction, and that any jewellery purchased thereafter, could only
have been acquired after completion of construction from funds,
allegedly provided by the Defendants.
17.16 The Defendants further contend that the LSJ failed to consider
the mandate of the statutory provisions, especially Section 2(15) read
with Section 35 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, regarding filing
of suit for partition and possession of an immovable property.
RFA (OS) NO 06/2017
17.17 The Appellants further submit that the LSJ ought to have taken
judicial notice of the fact that the matter was pending since 2006, and
that property prices had increased nearly fourfold during this period. It
is contended that damages and mesne profits ought to have been
awarded at least at the rate of Rs. 1 lakh per month. Alternatively,
reliance is placed on the Delhi Rent Control Act, which permits a 10%
increase every three years even for protected tenants, whereas no such
restriction applies to the Suit property, which ought to have been
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
governed by prevailing market rates.
18. Per contra, the learned counsel for the Respondent/Plaintiff has
made the following submissions:
18.1 It is averred that the Plaintiff has duly proved his ownership of
the Suit Property by placing on record the perpetual lease deed
[Ex.PW-1/2], Conveyance deed [Ex. PW1/3], Occupancy Certificate
[Ex. PW1/4], house tax receipts, assessment orders and various
notices [Ex. PW-1/5 to 12]. In contrast, the Defendants failed to
produce any document/record or prove the existence of any family
settlement qua the Suit Property or otherwise.
18.2 The Plaintiff contends that the Defendants failed to prove that
the first and second floors of the Suit Property were constructed by his
own funds or that the conversion from leasehold into freehold was not
funded solely by the Plaintiff.
18.3 The reliance placed by the Defendants on the Partnership Deed
dated 06.04.1964 [Ex. DW-1/1] is misconceive, as the said
Partnership Deed itself records that“AND whereas the party No.1 Sh. Rajendra Kumar Sethi was carrying
on the business under the sole proprietorship and with effect from
01.04.1964 the party no.2, i.e., Sushil Kumar Sethi has been taken as
a partner by Shri Rajendra Kumar in the firm under the name and
style of M/s Tara Rubber Industries”.
18.4 This makes it amply clear that the Plaintiff had an independent
source of income and did not require partnership funds to purchase the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
Suit Property. It has also been referred in para III (xviii) of the written
statement, that the Plaintiff was also involved in the sale and purchase
of properties, that further justify the generation of independent funds
by the Plaintiff.
18.5 The Plaintiff has also contended that the Appellant also called
for the voluminous records through RTI from the MCD [Ex. DW-2/1
Colly.] and a perusal of the same showed that the bid amount was paid
by and in the name of Plaintiff. Moreover, the Plaintiff has also been
given a no Objection Certificate [Ex. DW-2/3] for mortgaging the Suit
Property to Delhi Administration for loan etc.
18.6 With regard to the existence of the family arrangement dated
25.10.1970 and 04.11.1979, neither did the Appellant produce any
supporting document nor were the 20 witnesses produced were able to
prove any sort of family settlement.
18.7 Furthermore, Sh. Trilok Chand Sethi in his lifetime executed a
Will and property bearing no. D-253, Vivek Vihar, Delhi was
bequeathed to the original Defendant. Further, in line with the said
Will, a release Deed dated 20.05.1978 [Ex. DW-1/4], was executed by
the Plaintiff in favour of the Defendant, since at that point of time a
Will could not be given any effect, without grant of probate, and
hence a relinquishment/ release deed ought to have been executed.
This itself negates the existence of any family settlement.
18.8 It is also contended that the Defendant owns multiple properties
such as B-1 and 2, Radhey Puri from where it is deriving rent, a plot
of land at Vivek Vihar, a flat at Dhanu Road, Mumbai and Appellant
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
is a member of Varun Co-op. House Building Society, whereas the
Plaintiff has in his name only one property i.e. the Suit property,
thereby rendering the plea of family settlement improbable.
18.9 Moreover, even prior to the setting up of M/s Tara Rubber
Industries vide Partnership Deed dated 01.04.1964 [Ex. DW-1/1], the
Plaintiff was having his sole proprietorship and even after that he was
engaged in the business of buying and selling of properties thereby
generating sufficient income and revenue to purchase the Suit
Property in auction, through his own funds. The Defendants even
though contend, that he along with his father had invested his monies
for the said purchase, but the same has not even been proved through
any account statements, passbooks or record.
18.10 It is also contended that the Defendants sought to place reliance
on the judgement of Marcel Martins (supra), but relying on the said
judgements this Hon‟ble Court in Promila Gulati v Anil Gulati3,
Ramesh Advani v Hiro Advani & Anr, has held that for a party to
successfully fall under the exception of Section 4 of the Benami Act, a
specific pleading coupled with evidence proving the same ought to be
present. It is imperative that a pleading of relationship of trust in a
fiduciary capacity is taken and further the Court shall have to take into
consideration the factual context in which the question arises for it is
only in factual backdrop that the existence or otherwise of a fiduciary
relationship can be deduced in a given case.
18.11 Lastly, it is contended that the Defendants have never initiated
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
2015 (149) DRJ 195
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
any proceedings i.e., suit for implementation of an oral family
settlement or any other claim raise by the Defendants in the written
statement/counter-claim in spite of lapse of over three decades, clearly
indicating that the defence raised is an afterthought, lacking bona
fides, and intended merely to cloud the real issues in the matter.
FINDINGS AND ANALYSIS
19.
Heard learned counsel representing the parties at length and,
with their able assistance, perused the paper book, along with the
record, and their written submissions.
20.
The primary contention of the Defendants that the Plaintiff is
not the exclusive owner of the Suit Property is wholly untenable. The
Plaintiff has conclusively proved his title, by placing on record the
documents like Perpetual Lease Deed dated 11.05.1971 [Ex. PW1/2],
Conveyance Deed dated 05.01.2001 converting the property from
leasehold into freehold [Ex. PW1/3], Occupancy Certificate [Ex.
PW1/4], No Objection Certification, house tax records, assessment
orders and statutory notices issued exclusively in his name [Ex.PW1/5
to 12].
These documents constitute unimpeachable evidence of
ownership. In contrast, the Defendants have not produced a single title
document, conveyance, sanction letter, or statutory record evidencing
any ownership rights in their favour, over any portion of the Suit
Property.
21.
The Defendants assertion that the Suit Property was purchased
from joint family or joint business funds, is equally devoid of merit.
Significantly, the Defendant after having taken a stand in his written
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
statement, that property was not purchased in name of their father,
T.C. Sethi, because he was already owner of some other property in
Delhi, admitted during cross-examination that no registered property
stood in the name of the father of the parties on the date of auction. No
bank statements, account books, vouchers, or payment receipts
evidencing contribution by the Defendants or their father towards the
auction price were produced. Even the passbook relied upon by the
Defendant does not reflect any payment towards the auction
consideration or construction costs. Mere oral assertions of “joint
funds”, unsupported by contemporaneous documentary records,
cannot displace registered title documents.
22.
It is pertinent to note that the Defendants themselves placed
reliance on the Partnership Deed dated 06.04.1964 [Ex. DW1/1].
Ironically, the said document completely undermines their own
averment, as it categorically records that the Plaintiff was carrying on
business as a sole proprietor prior to the constitution of the partnership
and that the Defendant was inducted subsequently as a partner. This
clearly establishes that the Plaintiff had an independent source of
income even prior to the partnership and negates the existence of any
JHF or any joint family nucleus. Joint Hindu Family and Joint Hindu
Family property are distinct and separate. The mere existence of a JHF
does not necessarily lead to existence of a JHF property. Once the
existence of a JHF is not established, the presumption of a Joint Hindu
Family Property does not arise.
23.
It is well settled that even if there is an existence of JHF, it does
not ipso facto render all the properties as joint family properties.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
Instead, the claimant must establish that the property in question was
acquired with the aid of the joint family funds, particularly by
demonstrating the existence of a sufficient nucleus capable of
supporting such acquisitions. It reinforces the importance of
substantiating claims, regarding the nature of property within joint
Hindu families. It is clear that without concrete evidence of a joint
family nucleus, any presumption of a property as joint family-owned
is legally impermissible.
24.
The Defendants‟ case hinges substantially on alleged oral
family settlements dated 25.10.1970 and 04.11.1979. However, no
written memorandum, contemporaneous document, or corroborative
evidence was produced to prove the existence of an oral family
settlement. None of the witnesses examined were able to establish
either the precise terms, the manner of implementation, or even the
very existence of such alleged family settlements. Additionally, the
Defendants have failed to produce any documents to prove that they
ever asserted themselves as co-owner in the Suit Property, unlike the
Plaintiff. Significantly, no suit or proceedings were ever instituted for
enforcement of the purported settlements, for more than three decades,
which conduct is wholly inconsistent with the existence of any
concluded or acted-upon family arrangement.
25.
It is a settled principle of law that although a family settlement
may be oral, its existence must be proved by cogent, reliable and
convincing evidence demonstrating not only consensus ad idem but
also acceptance and implementation by the parties. The Defendants,
however, have failed on all counts. Moreover, the long and
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
uninterrupted conduct of the parties, coupled with the absence of any
mutation, change in possession, or assertion of rights in consonance
with the alleged settlement, clearly negates the plea raised. An
unsubstantiated oral family settlement cannot be permitted to defeat or
override duly executed and subsisting title documents. Accordingly,
the plea of family settlement remains a mere bald assertion,
unsupported by evidence, and having remained unsubstantiated, was
rightly rejected by the LSJ.
26.
The assertion that the ground floor was constructed from joint
funds, whereas the first and second floors were allegedly constructed
exclusively by the Defendants, is wholly unsupported by cogent and
credible evidence. Apart from a solitary receipt pertaining to purchase
of 200 bags of cement, the Defendants failed to produce any material
substantiating the alleged expenditure, such as construction bills,
contractor agreements, labour payments records, sanctioned building
plans in the Defendant‟s name, or bank statements evidencing
withdrawals for construction purposes. Even the examination of DW7 does not advance the Defendants‟ case, as it falls short of
establishing either the source of funds or exclusive contribution
towards construction.
27.
It is trite law that the burden of proving financial contribution
towards construction squarely lies upon the party asserting such a
claim. Mere assertions, uncorroborated by documentary evidence, do
not discharge this burden. Conversely, the sanctioned building plans,
electricity and water connections, as well as the municipal records,
stand exclusively in the name of the Plaintiff, thereby clearly
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
indicating both ownership and control over the property. Further, it is
well settled that mere occupation, supervision of construction, or
participation in management does not, in law, confer any proprietary
or ownership rights in immovable property. In the absence of proof of
title or demonstrable financial contribution leading to the creation of
an enforceable interest, the Defendants‟ claim is legally untenable.
The LSJ, therefore, rightly rejected the said plea, holding that
possession or supervision, without more, cannot be elevated to a claim
of ownership.
28.
With respect to the contention that the Plaintiff did not
exclusively bear the expenses of conversion, the Defendants led no
evidence to show any contribution on their part. On the contrary, DW1 categorically admitted in cross-examination that no proof of
payment towards conversion charges was available or could be
produced by the Defendants, thereby amounting to failure to
substantiate their stand. The conveyance deed stands solely in the
name of the Plaintiff, and in law, once the conveyance deed stands
duly executed and registered solely in the name of the Plaintiff, a
strong presumption of legality, title and exclusive financial
contribution, arises in favour of the Plaintiff. Mere denial or
speculative assertions are insufficient to discharge such onus,
particularly, in the absence of documentary evidence. Thus, the
Defendants plea remains unsupported and legally untenable.
29. The reliance placed by the Defendants on Marcel Martins (supra)
is misplaced and clearly distinguishable. The decision therein was
rendered in the peculiar factual matrix of that case, resting upon
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
inferences
drawn
from
admitted
conduct
and
surrounding
circumstances, none of which are present in the instant case. The ratio
of the said judgement, therefore, cannot be mechanically transplanted
to the present facts, which are dissimilar and devoid of any
foundational evidence warranting such interference. On the contrary,
the judgements in Promila Gulati and Ramesh Advani (supra),
unequivocally mandate strict and specific pleadings, coupled with
cogent proof, particularly where exceptions to statutory prohibitions
are invoked. These authorities underscore that vague assertions or
omnibus pleas are insufficient to displace statutory presumptions or to
bring a case within the narrow exceptions carved out by law. In the
present case, there is a conspicuous absence of any specific pleading
or evidence establishing the existence of a fiduciary relationship,
circumstances giving rise to trust or confidence, and the legal
obligation on the Plaintiff to hold the property for the benefit of the
Defendants.
30.
It is well settled that in the absence of material pleadings in the
written statement, a plea of either an oral family settlement or of the
case falling within the exception to Section 4 of the Benami Act is not
legally tenable. Mere incantation of the words “trustee” or “fiduciary”
cannot, by itself, attract the statutory exception. Notably, despite
examining as many as twenty witnesses, the Defendants failed to elicit
any credible evidence to substantiate the alleged family settlement,
which forms the very bedrock of their defence. The entire defence,
therefore, rests on conjecture and unsubstantiated assertions.
31.
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
It is apparent that the said defence taken by the Defendants is
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
barred by Section 4 of the Benami Act. The operative part of the law
reads as under:
“4. Prohibition of the right to recover property held benami(1)…
(2) No defence based on any right in respect of any property
held as benami, whether against the person in whose name the
property is held or against any other person, shall be allowed in
any suit, claim or action by or on behalf of a person claiming to
be the real owner of such property.”
In the present case, the Plaintiff cannot, by any stretch of
imagination, be said to have been standing in a fiduciary capacity visa-vis the Defendant, nor can the Plaintiff be construed as a trustee.
Even assuming such a plea is raised, the same is required to be
established through specific and unambiguous pleadings and proof,
both of which are conspicuously absent. However, the bar/prohibition
under the Benami Act, cannot be circumvented merely by paying lip
service to the concept of fiduciary capacity, as such an approach
would defeat the very object and legislative intent of the statute.
Permitting such defences, on the basis of bald and unsubstantiated
pleas would amount to allowing statutory prohibitions to be rendered
illusory, thereby subjecting the ostensible owner to prolonged and
vexatious litigation at the instance of a person claiming to be the socalled “real owner”. Such an outcome would not only undermine the
sanctity of registered title but would also run counter to the express
mandate of section 4 of the Benami Act.
32.
In the present case, the Defendants have themselves admitted
permissive occupation of the Suit Property. Such permissive
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
possession, being referrals to a license, can never mature into adverse
possession, unless there is clear, cogent and unequivocal evidence of
hostile possession brought to the knowledge of the true owner. The
licence admittedly stood revoked by notice dated 26.10.2006, and the
suit for recovery of possession was instituted on 06.11.2006, well
within the prescribed period of limitation. In the absence of any
foundational proof, the plea of adverse possession is legally untenable
and has rightly been rejected by the LSJ.
33.
The Defendant was a licensee, and he must be deemed to be
always a licensee. It is not open to him, during the subsistence of the
license or in the suit for recovery of possession of the property
instituted after the revocation of the license to set up a title to the
property in himself or anyone else. The licensee‟s obligation is to
surrender possession upon termination of the license and, if so
advised, to pursue any independent remedy for declaration of title
through appropriate proceedings. In the present case, despite
termination of the license though notice issued [Ex. PW1/15], and
institution of the suit, the Defendants failed to surrender possession of
the Suit property. The Plaintiff, therefore, became entitled, as a matter
of law, to recover possession.
34.
Furthermore, the Defendants have relied upon various
documents, including a copy of the pass-book [Ex.DW-1/3], which
purportedly reflects a joint saving bank account held by the Plaintiff
and the Defendant, and seeks to suggest that the common funds were
utilised for payment of all the expenses relating to the Suit Property.
However, although the said document indicates that the account was
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
jointly held, but it does not show, nor does it establish, that the funds
from the said account were utilised either for the purchase of the Suit
property or for the construction carried out thereon.
35.
Additionally, the terms and conditions of auction [Ex. DW-1/2],
filed along with amended written statement, in fact operate in favour
of the Plaintiff. The said document categorically stipulates that, under
no circumstances, would a change in the name of the intending
purchaser be permitted. This condition clearly negates the Defendant‟s
plea and reinforces the Plaintiff‟s case. The relinquishment deed
executed by the Plaintiff [Ex. DW-1/14], further fortifies the
Plaintiff‟s stand, as the same is executed only to give effect to a Will,
under which another property stood bequeathed in favour of the
original Defendant. This circumstance, clearly demonstrates that there
was no pre-existing family settlement, as alleged by the Defendants.
The remaining documents relied upon by the Defendants, such as the
ration card of the Plaintiff [Ex. DW-1/8], the death certificates of the
father and mother of the parties [Ex. DW-1/11 and 1/12], and other
allied documents, are not in dispute, and therefore do not warrant any
further consideration. In the considered view of the Court, the
remaining documents exhibited by the Defendants, as well as the
examination of as many as twenty witnesses, bear no relevance to the
core controversy involved in the present dispute and do not carry any
persuasive or probative value.
36.
The challenge raised by the Defendants to the award of mesne
profits, is equally devoid of merit. Once, the Defendants were held to
be unauthorised occupants post revocation of licence, the liability to
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
pay mesne profits followed as a necessary legal consequence. The LSJ
exercised judicial discretion in determining the quantum of mesne
profits, considering the location of the property, the nature of
occupation, and the relationship between the parties. The rate so
awarded cannot be characterised as arbitrary, perverse or excessive.
Conversely, the Plaintiff‟s appeal seeking enhancement of mesne
profits was also rightly rejected in the absence of evidence to justify a
higher rate.
37.
There is likewise no infirmity in the findings of the LSJ with
respect to the valuation of the suit, the payment of court-fees, and the
valuation of counter-claim. These findings are supported by the
pleadings and the evidence on record and call for no interference.
38.
The defence set up by the Defendants is founded on
conjectures, afterthoughts, and unsubstantiated allegations. In sharp
contrast, the Plaintiff has established his case through registered title
documents, statutory and municipal records, and consistent oral and
documentary evidence.
CONCLUSION
39.
In light of the foregoing discussion, this Court finds no
illegality, perversity or incorrect view arrived at or that an incorrect
approach was adopted by the LSJ in the Impugned Judgement, so as to
justify appellate interference.
40.
The Defendants have failed to establish any right, title or
interest therein. The counter-claims were rightly dismissed, and the
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
decree of possession and mesne profits warrants no interference. The
findings of the LSJ are based on a proper appreciation of evidence and
a correct application of law.
41.
Hence, having found no merit, all the present Appeals along
with the pending applications, stands dismissed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
HARISH VAIDYANATHAN SHANKAR, J.
JANUARY 09, 2026/sp/ra
Signed By:SAVITA
PASRICHA
16:51:13
RFA (OS) 05/2017 and connected matters
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review