Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH
257+262+130(21cases)
Date of decision:08.04.2026
1.
CWP-24097-2025
JASWINDER SINGH AND OTHERS
.....PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
.....RESPONDENTS
2.
CWP-24885-2025
SURESH KUMAR AND OTHERS
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
…RESPONDENTS
3.
CWP-24886-2025
ANANT RAM AND OTHERS
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
…RESPONDENTS
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
4.
CWP-24891-2025
SANDEEP AND OTHERS
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
…RESPONDENTS
5.
CWP-24902-2025
DHARAMVEER SINGH AND OTHERS
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
…RESPONDENTS
6.
CWP-24904-2025
VINOD KUMAR AND OTHERS
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
…RESPONDENTS
7.
IMRAN KHAN AND OTHERS
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-27709-2025
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
…RESPONDENTS
8.
CWP-27711-2025
DHARMENDER SINGH AND ANOTHER
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
…RESPONDENTS
9.
CWP-27917-2025
DIVIJ MOHAN AND OTHERS
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA OTHERS
…RESPONDENTS
10.
CWP-30124-2025
PARAMJEET
….PETITIONER
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS
…RESPONDENTS
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
11.
CWP-36279-2025
DEEPAK AND OTHERS
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
…RESPONDENTS
12.
CWP-36162-2025
YASHVEER
….PETITIONER
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
…RESPONDENTS
13.
CWP-37350-2025
DAYANAND
….PETITIONER
VERSUS
THE STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS
…RESPONDENTS
14.
CWP-5510-2026
AJIT SINGH AND OTHERS
….PETITIONERS
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
…RESPONDENTS
15.
CWP-4126-2026
SURESH KUMAR AND OTHERS
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHER
…RESPONDENTS
16.
CWP-8679-2026
MANDEEP SINGH AND OTHERS
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHER
…RESPONDENTS
17.
CWP-9123-2026
URMILA AND OTHERS
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
…RESPONDENTS
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
18.
CWP-38377-2025
SANDEEP AND ANOTHER
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS
…RESPONDENTS
19.
CWP-38505-2025
SANDEEP KUMAR AND OTHERS
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHER
…RESPONDENTS
20.
CWP-9962-2026
ASHISH GODARA AND OTHERS
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF HARYANA AND OTHERS
…RESPONDENTS
21.
CWP-10657-2026
Vikash and others
….PETITIONERS
VERSUS
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS
…RESPONDENTS
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARPREET SINGH BRAR
Present :
Mr. Ravinder Singh Dhull with Mr. Navnit Sharma, Advocates
for the petitioners in CWP-24097-2025.
Mr. Rajesh Sethi, Mr. Krishan Kumar with Mr. Anshuman
Sethi, Advocate for the petitioner(s) in CWP-30124-2025 &
Mr. Ram Darshan Yadav, Advocate for the petitioner(s).
Mr. Amit Khatkar, Advocate for the petitioner in CWP-99622026.
Ms. Monika Jangra, Advocate for the petitioner(s) in CWP37350-2025.
Mr. Jasbir Mor, Advocate for the petitioner(s) in CWP-383772025.
Mr. B.K. Bagri, Advocate for the petitioner(s) in CWP-55102026.
Mr. I.P.S. Kohli, Advocate Mr. Sidharth Maini, Advocate Mr.
Dhruv Khanna, Advocate Mr. Sarabjeet Singh, Advocate for
the petitioner(s) in remaining cases.
Mr. Vikrant Pamboo, Advocate for respondent No.2 (in CWP24891-2025; CWP-24902-2025; CWP-24904-2025; CWP30124-2025 & CWP-24097-2025) and for respondents No.2 &
3 (in CWP-27709-2025, 36162 & 36279-2025, CWP-277112025, CWP-37350-2025, CWP-9962 & 9123 of 2026) for
respondents No.2 to 4 in CWP-5510-2026.
Mr. Prince Singh, Advocate for respondent No.3 (in CWP24097-2025).
Mr. Sukhdeep Singh Parmar, Advocate for respondents No.2 &
3 (in CWP-27917-2025) and for respondent-UHBVN in CWP24904, 29304 and 36279-2025 and for respondent NO.3 in
CWP-18675-2026.
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
Mr. Piyush Khanna, Advocate for respondent No.2 in CWP8675-2026.
Mr. Sanjeev Kaushik, Advocate, Ms. Manreet Kaur, Advocate
and Mr. Divyanshu Kaushik, Advocate for the respondent(s)UHBVN (in CWP-24885-2025; CWP-24886-2025; CWP24891-2025; CWP-24902-2025 & CWP-24904-2025).
Ms. Anupama Sharma, Advocate with Ms. Nikita Goel,
Advocates for respondents No.2 to 4.
Mr. Pravindra Singh Chauhan/AG Haryana/Sr. Advocate with
Mr. Prince Singh, Mr. Sanjeev Kaushik, Advocate and Mr.
Divyanshu Kaushik, Addl. AG Haryana. Ms. Amisha Rana,
Advocate in (in CWP-24885, 24886, 24902, 37350, 24891,
27711, 38377, 38505 of 2025).
HARPREET SINGH BRAR, J. (Oral)
1.
This order shall dispose of the above-mentioned writ petitions
as they arise from a similar factual matrix. However, for the sake of brevity,
the facts are taken from CWP-24097-2025.
2.
The petitioners have approached this Court by filing the present
writ petition under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of India for issuance
of a writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing the impugned speaking
order dated 08.07.2025 (Annexure P-3) whereby the request of inter utility
transfer of petitioners No.2 to 4 have been denied by the respondentNo.2.
Further, praying for issuance of a writ in the nature of mandamus directing
respondents No.2 and 3 to allow inter utility transfer of petitioners.
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
3.
Mr. Rajesh Sethi, Advocate has filed Power of Attorney on
behalf of the petitioner in CWP-30124-2025 in court today. The same is
ordered to be taken on record. Registry is directed to place the same at an
appropriate place in the paperbook.
4.
On 02.12.2025, the following order was passed:Learned counsel for the petitioner(s) inter alia
contends
that
the
petitioners
are
employees
of
DHBVNL/UHBVNL. There has been a past practice permitting
the inter-utility transfer in time of some executive instructions
issued time to time from the year 2006 onwards. Identically
circumstanced employees approached this Court seeking
quashing of the orders, whereby, the prayer for inter-utility
transfer of the petitioners, have been rejected and this Court
allowed the bunch of petitions along with CWP No.25668 of
2017 titled as ‘Kashmeer Singh and others Vs. State of
Haryana and others’. This Court while issuing directions to the
respondent-Corporations has observed that the employees who
are willing to forego their seniority and the fact that for the
recruits of 2019, a policy of inter-utility transfer dated
26.07.2019 has already been promulgated and certain other
employees selected in terms of advertisement No.08 of 2006
were also transferred. In light of the past practice, this Court
disposed of the writ petition in Kashmeer Singh’s case (supra)
with a direction to the Managing Director of UHBVNL and
DHBVNL to consider the case of the petitioner(s) therein
subject to terms and conditions of the instructions issued from
time to time.
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
The respondent-Corporations challenged the order
passed by the Coordinate Bench of this Court by filing LPA
No.58 of 2021 which was disposed of on 08.11.2023 by
modifying the judgment rendered by the Coordinate Bench to
the extent of directing the Managing Director of both the power
utilities to consider the case of the employees for grant of
benefit of inter-utility transfer as was given to the candidates
for the selection years of 2006, 2009, 2011 and subsequently, in
the year 2023 as well. In compliance thereof, UHBVNL passed
a speaking order rejecting the claim of the identically
circumstanced employees seeking inter-utility transfer. The
petitioner(s) in Kashmeer Singh’s case (supra) and petitioner in
other connected writ petitions filed COCP No.1887 of 2024
(Annexure P-15) and during the pendency of the contempt
petition on 27.09.2024, the request of Kashmeer Singh and 15
other employees, who were the petitioner(s) in the Kashmeer
Singh’s case (supra) and a bunch of petitions, were granted
inter-utility transfer.
Learned counsel for the petitioner(s) relied upon
yet another bunch decided on 19.02.2025 titled as ‘Vinod
Kumar and others Vs. State of Haryana and others’ and
petitioner(s) again approached this Court by filing CWP
No.2311 of 2025 along with another 11 bunch of cases which
was disposed of on 19.02.2025 with a direction to consider the
case of the petitioner(s) within a period of three months from
the date of filing of the application subject to certain
conditions.
In
purported
compliance,
the
respondent-
Corporation passed a speaking order dated 08.07.2025
(Annexure P-23). The petitioner(s) also preferred a COCP
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
No.3037 of 2025 which was disposed of 28.07.2025 (Annexure
P-24).
Learned counsel for the petitioner(s) further
emphasized that the case of the petitioner(s) is identical to that
of the petitioner(s) in Kashmeer Singh’s case (supra) and the
respondent-Corporation has granted the inter-utility transfer to
the petitioner(s) therein in terms of the order passed by the
Division Bench of this Court in 08.11.2023 in LPA No.58 of
2021. As such, the applicability of the judgment of the Division
Bench dated 08.11.2023 with the facts of the present case is not
in question.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondentCorporation submits that in the earlier round of litigation when
the petitioner(s) approached this Court by filing CWP No.2311
of 2025 (Annexures P-17 to P-22) which was disposed of by
filing on 19.02.2025, the order which is available at Page
No.189 of the paper book, and submits that the aforementioned
writ petitions were filed by the petitioner(s) earlier were
disposed of with the consent of both the parties. A direction was
issued to consider the case of the petitioner(s) for transfer to
another power utility to three conditions:(i) subject to availability of posts.
(ii) their consent to be tagged at the bottom of the seniority and
(iii) availability of the similar post in order to comply with the
minimum qualification of the posts.
and learned counsel for the petitioner(s) has given his
consent for transfer subject to availability of post and
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
compliance
of
prescribed
minimum
qualification
and
adjustment at the bottom of the seniority list. In terms of the
directions issued by this Court on 19.02.2025 in CWP No.2311
of 2025 and other connected matter, a speaking order dated
08.07.2025 was passed.
At this stage, Mr. Vikrant Pamboo, Advocate seeks a
short accommodation to have complete instructions in order to
resolve this controversy with regard to inter-utility transfers.
List on 08.12.2025.”
5.
On 08.12.2025, the following order was passed:At the outset, learned counsel for the respondent(s)UHBVNL submits that the present bunch of cases may be
referred to an appropriate State-level or District-level
Grievance Redressal Committee.
However, this submission cannot be accepted as the
simmering issue necessarily requires a policy decision. The
controversy in the abovementioned bunch of writ petitions
pertains to inter-utility transfer of personnel. Evidently, the
stand of the respondent-Corporation has been inconsistent
since the creation of UHBVNL and DHBVNL. For nearly two
decades, inter-utility transfers have been effected at the whims
and fancies of the officers in charge, dehors any uniform or
codified policy, as noted in order dated 02.12.2025. However, a
transfer policy dated 26.07.2019 (Annexure P-6) was
subsequently promulgated, the benefits of which were made
available to Group C recruits of the year 2019. While it is
settled law that transfer is not a vested right, it is equally
imperative that once a policy is framed to regulate transfers, it
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
must be transparent, fair and reasonable. After its formulation,
such a policy must be implemented in its entirety, leaving no
scope for selective application as any deviation would fall foul
of the mandate of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
The arbitrary approach adopted by the respondentCorporation regarding transfer of personnel has resulted in
this Court being faced with an ever-increasing inflow of
transfer-related matters, thereby contributing substantially to
the existing pendency. A fair, reasonable and comprehensive
policy to govern such transfers would not only reduce
avoidable
litigation
unwarranted
but
harassment.
also
As
shield
a
public
employees
from
employer,
the
respondent-Corporation is duty-bound to function in a manner
that upholds public interest and adheres to our constitutional
values. However, the pattern that emerges reveals persistent
administrative shortcomings which have remained unaddressed
for a considerable period. It is also noteworthy that the
petitioners have already undertaken to forgo their seniority for
the purposes of inter-utility movement, yet their proposed
transfers continue to face resistance.
In these circumstances, it is imperative that the
respondent-Corporation
formulates
a
coherent
and
comprehensive policy, which either prohibits inter-utility
transfers altogether or one that clearly defines the objectives,
parameters
and
conditions
governing
such
transfers.
Accordingly, the concerned Additional Chief Secretary to the
State of Haryana is directed to file an affidavit before this
Court,
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
specifically
addressing
the
issues
highlighted
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
hereinabove and setting out the steps proposed for resolving
the same.
List on 22.12.2025.”
6.
On 22.12.2025, the following order was passed:In compliance with the order dated 08.12.2025 passed by
this Court, the affidavit of Sh. Shyamal Misra, the Principal
Secretary, Energy Department, Government of Haryana, has
been filed in the Court today, which is ordered to be taken on
record. Registry is directed to place the same at an appropriate
place. Copy thereof has been supplied to the learned counsel
for the petitioners.
Learned State Counsel refers to the said affidavit and
submits that in consultation with respective stakes holders of
power utilities. It has been decided that a policy will be
formulated prohibiting inter-utility transfers between UHBVNL
and DHBVNL. The Boards of Directors of the respective power
utilities i.e. UHBVNL & DHBVNL being autonomous entities
are competent to frame such regulations/policies for their
proper functioning. However, after a thorough examination of
the issue in question, a draft policy on prohibition of interutility transfers has been framed and submitted to the State
Government for concurrence. Once the concurrence of State
Government is received, the approval of the respective Boards
of Directors will be sought for its due implementation.
Learned State counsel has assured this Court that, while
framing the policy, an exception would only be created for
deputation of employees on administrative grounds.
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
List for further consideration on 02.04.2026.
In the meantime, status report be filed with the Registry
before the next date of hearing.
The needful regarding implementation of the said policy
be done within a period of three months of receipt of a certified
copy of this order.
7.
On 02.04.2026, the following order was passed:Two separate short replies have been filed on behalf of
respondents No.1 and 2 in CWP-30124-2025 & CWP-55102026 respectively in Court today. The same are taken on
record. Copies thereof have been supplied to the learned
opposite counsel.
Neither any status report has been filed nor the decision
taken by the State Government has been placed on record
regarding approval of the draft policy on prohibition of interutility transfers. A copy of the order was supplied to the learned
State counsel.
Learned State counsel seeks last opportunity to do the
needful.
List on 08.04.2026.
In case, the order dated 22.12.2025 is not complied with,
the Principal Secretary, Energy Department, Government of
Haryana, shall remain present in Court on the next date of
hearing to explain the reasons for non-compliance of the order.
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
8.
of
In compliance of order dated 22.12.2025, a status report by way
an
affidavit
dated
08.04.2026
of
Mukesh
Chauhan,
Chief
Engineer/Administration, UHBVN, Panchkula has been filed in Court today.
The same is ordered to be taken on record. Registry is directed to place the
same at an appropriate place in the paperbook.
9.
Learned counsel for respondent No.2-UHBVN submits that
respondent No.2-UHBVN has formulated and notified a comprehensive
policy dated 07.04.2026 (Annexure R-2/1) whereby inter-utility transfers
have been prohibited. The said policy (Annexure R-2/1) stands issued
subject to the ex-post facto approval from the respective Board of Directors
in terms of Article 67 of the Articles of Association of respondent-UHBVN,
which is similar to DHBVN. As such, the request of the petitioners for interutility transfer cannot be acceded to.
10.
In rebuttal, learned counsel for petitioner submits that the
policy dated 07.04.2026 (Annexure R-2/1) has been made applicable to only
Group C and D employees working for UHBVN and DHBVN. A perusal of
the policy dated 07.04.2026 (Annexure R-2/1) would indicate that the
objective behind proscribing inter-utility transfers was to “avoid
administrative complexities, potential misuse of discretionary powers,
disruptions in service delivery, and challenges in maintaining balanced
workforce distribution.” However, by limiting its scope to only Group C and
D employees, the respondent-UHBVN has made an arbitrary and
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
unreasonable classification sans any intelligible differentia to justify the
same. It is clear that the convenience of higher ranking officers has been
prioritised while remaining unconcerned with the plight of employees of
Group C and D. As such, the policy dated 07.04.2026 (Annexure R-2/1) is
violative of fundamental rights of the petitioners, as enshrined in Articles 14
and 21 of the Constitution of India. Further still, the petitioners had
requested for inter-utility transfer prior to the notification of the policy dated
07.04.2026 (Annexure R-2/1). Thus, the said policy cannot be applied
retrospectively to deny the benefit of inter-utility transfer to the petitioners,
in view of the judgment rendered by this Court in Kashmeer Singh and
others vs. State of Haryana in CWP No.25688 of 2017.
OBSERVATIONS AND ANALYSIS
11.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and after perusing
the record with their able assistance, it transpires that the present
controversy pertains to inter-utility transfer of personnel between UHBVN
and DHBVN.
SCOPE OF JUDICIAL INTERVENTION IN TRANSFERS
12.
Tritely, transfer is an incident of service. As such, the decisions
in this regard must also be taken by the relevant departments based on
considerations like administrative exigencies, organizational needs as well
as the cause of efficiency. Since the employer has comprehensive
knowledge regarding all aspects of the organisation’s functioning, it alone is
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
best suited to assess where the services of an employee are most needed and
process transfers accordingly. Further, while accepting appointment, an
employee inherently agrees to the service conditions thereof as well and
therefore, in a transferrable job, an employee cannot seek or deny transfer as
a matter of right. A two-Judge bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Union of India vs. S.L. Abbas (1993) 4 SCC 357, speaking through Justice
B.P. Jeevan Reddy made the following observations in this regard:
“7. Who should be transferred where, is a matter for the appropriate
authority to decide. Unless the order of transfer is vitiated by mala
fides or is made in violation of any statutory provisions, the Court
cannot interfere with it. While ordering the transfer, there is no doubt,
the authority must keep in mind the guidelines issued by the
Government on the subject. Similarly if a person makes any
representation with respect to this transfer, the appropriate authority
must consider the same having regard to the exigencies of
administration. The guidelines say that as far as possible, husband
and wife must be posted at the same place. The said guideline
however does not confer upon the Government employee a legally
enforceable right.”
13.
Since such matters involve internal management and policy
decisions particular to the employer, the scope of judicial review in this
respect is fairly limited. Substituting the decision of the relevant authority
with its own when the former is better placed to assess the requirements of
the department would be manifestly unjust. Reliance in this regard can also
be placed on the judgments rendered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Union of India vs. N.P. Thomas (1993) 6 Supp (1) SCC 704, N.K. Singh
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
vs. Union of India (1994) 6 SCC 98 and Pubi Lombi vs. State of Arunachal
Pradesh and others 2024 SCC OnLine SC 279.
14.
In that vein, this Court is of the considered opinion that where
the scope of judicial intervention in transfers within the same organisation is
rather limited, it would be out of question to interfere in matters pertaining
to inter-utility transfers. While UHBVN and DHBVN perform similar
functions, they are in fact distinct entities with separate Boards of Directors
managing their respective affairs. Therefore, the petitioners have no vested
right of inter-utility transfer between UHBVN and DHBVN and thus, this
Court cannot exercise its writ jurisdiction in the present case.
SCOPE OF POLICY DATED 07.04.2026
15.
Be that as it may, being autonomous entities, duly registered
under Companies Act, 1956, UHBVN and DHBVN are fully competent to
make policy decisions regulating its internal affairs. In exercise of this
power, the respondent-UHBVN has formulated a comprehensive policy
dated 07.04.2026 (Annexure R-2/1) on Prohibition of Inter-Utility Transfers
between UHBVN and DHBVN. The relevant part thereof is reproduced
below:
“
Whereas, UHBVN and DHBVN are separate and independent
distribution utilities established under the Haryana Electricity Reform
Act, 1997, to manage power distribution in the northern and southern
regions of Haryana, respectively;
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
Whereas, the primary objective of maintaining distinct utilities
is to ensure operational efficiency, accountability, regional focus, and
equitable resource allocation tailored to the specific needs of each
geographic area;
Whereas, inter-utility transfers of employees have historically
led to administrative complexities, potential misuse of discretionary
powers, disruptions in service delivery, and challenges in maintaining
balanced workforce distribution, as observed in various judicial
observations and administrative reviews;
Whereas, the Hon'ble Punjab and Haryana High Court has
emphasized the need for a coherent policy to address arbitrary
transfers, recommending either strict regulation or outright
prohibition to uphold transparency and fairness;
And whereas, it is deemed necessary to reconsider the policy of
inter- utility transfers to preserve the integrity, independence, and
operational autonomy of UHBVN and DHBVN;
Therefore, in exercise of the powers conferred by section 179 of
Companies Act, 2013 and Article 67 of the Articles of Association of
Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited (hereinafter the Nigam)
and all other enabling powers in this behalf, Uttar Haryana Bijli
Vitran Nigam hereby notifies the comprehensive Policy on
Prohibition of Inter-Utility Transfers between Uttar Haryana Bijli
Vitran Nigam (UHBVN) and Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam
(DHBVN):
Section 1: Definitions
For the purposes of this policy, unless the context otherwise
requires:
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
i Inter-Utility Transfer means any transfer, movement,
reassignment, absorption, or exchange of Employees from one
utility to the other on a permanent basis.
ii UHBVN refers to Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited.
iii DHBVN refers to Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam
Limited.
iv Employee includes all Groups C & D categories of
personnel, whether permanent, temporary, contractual,
employed by either utility.
v Competent Authority means the Managing Director of the
concerned utility, or any officer designated by the Government
of Haryana for enforcement of this policy.
vi Exceptional Circumstances shall be limited to those defined
in Section 4 of this policy.
Section 2: Scope and Applicability
This policy applies to all Group C & D employees under the
control of UHBVN and DHBVN.
Section 3: Prohibition of Inter-Utility Transfers
No inter-utility transfer of employees shall be permitted
between UHBVN and DHBVN under any circumstances, except as
explicitly provided in Section 4.
All pending applications or requests for inter-utility transfers
as of effective date of this policy stand rejected forthwith.
Any attempt to initiate, process of execute an inter-utility
transfer shall be deemed a violation of this policy and subject to
disciplinary action.
The utilities shall not entertain or forward any requests for
inter-utility
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
transfers
to
higher
authorities,
including
the
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
Government of Haryana, unless falling under the exceptions
outlined in Section 4.
Section 4: Exceptions
To ensure the policy's strict enforcement while addressing
unavoidable scenarios, exceptions shall be limited to the following,
subject to approval by a high- level committee:
National Emergencies or Force Majeure: Transfers may be
allowed temporarily (not exceeding 6 months) in cases of natural
disasters, pandemics, or other emergencies requiring cross-utility
support, upon recommendation by the State Disaster Management
Authority and approval by the Government of Haryana.
Court Orders: Compliance with specific directions from a court
of competent jurisdiction, provided such orders are not appealable or
have been upheld on appeal.
Deputation on foreign service terms on the basis of mutual
request of employees holding the same posts. Such deputation shall be
on a vice-versa basis and strictly governed by the provisions of
deputation/foreign service as laid down in Haryana Civil Services
(General) Rules, 2016.
Regulatory Directives: Directives from HERC or the Central
Electricity Authority (CEA) for operational necessities, such as grid
stability or infrastructure projects spanning both utilities.
All exceptions must be approved by a High Level
Committee comprising representatives from UHBVN, DHBVN, and
the Department of Power, Government of Haryana. The committee
shall document reasons in writing, ensuring transparency and
preventing arbitrariness in implementation.
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
Employees who are on probation shall not be eligible for
deputation.”
(Emphasis supplied)
16.
A perusal of Section 3 of the policy (supra) makes it
abundantly clear that not only are inter-utility transfers prohibited, but the
pending applications for the same, as on the date of implementation of this
policy, shall also stand rejected. As such, the petitioners cannot claim that
the policy was only supposed to have prospective application.
17.
However, Section 2 of the policy (supra) limits its application
to employees of Group C and D. In doing so, the respondents have denied
them a benefit which has been kept open to higher ranking officers i.e.
employees falling under Group A and B. Prima facie, respondent-UHBVN
has created two classes within the same set of employees. However, it is
unclear what purpose is served by this status-based discrimination,
especially considering that the objective of the policy (supra) has essentially
been to promote administrative efficiency and accountability. Thus, this
Court is of the considered opinion that denying the opportunity of interutility transfer, in such strict terms, only to the Group C and D is arbitrary
and unreasonable as it bears no rational nexus to the objective of the policy
(supra).
18.
The State and its instrumentalities, being model employers, are
held up to higher standards and therefore, bear an additional responsibility to
ensure that their actions are not perceived as arbitrary or violative of the
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
constitutional philosophy. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in Maneka Gandhi
vs. Union of India and another 1978(1) SCC 248 has held that Article 21
confers a fundamental right on every citizen to not be deprived of his life or
liberty except in accordance with the procedure established by law and that
such procedure must be ‘just, reasonable and fair’. Further, in L.I.C. of
India vs. Consumer Education & Research Centre 1995(4) SCT 678, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court further clarified that the duty to act fairly is a part of
the procedure envisaged under Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of
India. As such, any approach, especially that of a public employer, that
exhibits any signs of arbitrariness would necessarily be in conflict with
Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution of India.
19.
Reliance may also be placed on the judgment rendered by a
Constitution Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ajay Hasia vs. Khalid
Mujib Sehravardi (1981) 1 SCC 722, wherein speaking through Justice P.N.
Bhagwati, the following observations were made:
“16. ...This vital and dynamic aspect which was till then lying latent
and submerged in the few simple but pregnant words of Article 14 was
explored and brought to light in Royappa's case and it was reaffirmed
and elaborated by this Court in Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India,
(1978) 2 SCR 621, where this Court again speaking through one of us
(Bhagwati, J.) observed :"Now the question immediately arises as to what is the
requirement of Article 14 : what is the content and reach of the
great equalising principle enunciated in this article, There can
be no doubt that it is a founding faith of the Constitution. It is
indeed the pillar on which rests securely the foundation of our
democratic republic. And, therefore, it must not be subjected to
a narrow, pedantic or lexicographic approach. No attempt
should be made to truncate its all-embracing scope and
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
meaning for, to do so would be to violate its activist magnitude.
Equality is a dynamic concept with many aspects and
dimensions and it cannot be imprisoned within traditional and
doctrinaire limits ..................Article 14 strikes at arbitrariness
in State action and ensures fairness and equality of treatment.
The principle of reasonableness, which legally as well as
philosophically, is an essential element of equality or nonarbitrariness
pervades
Article 14 like
a
brooding
omnipresence”
CONCLUSION
20.
In view of the discussion above, the aforementioned writ
petitions are disposed of in the following manner:
i.
In view of policy dated 07.04.2026 (Annexure R-2/1), no interutility transfers shall be permitted between UHBVN and
DHBVN, except those covered by Section 4 of the policy
(supra).
ii.
Section 2 of the policy dated 07.04.2026 (Annexure R-2/1) is
held to be violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India as
it creates an unreasonable classification between employees
that bears no reasonable nexus to the objective of the policy.
iii.
The policy dated 07.04.2026 (Annexure R-2/1) shall apply
uniformly to all employees of UHBVN and DHBVN and, not
exclusively to employees falling under the ambit of Group C
and D.
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
CWP-24097-2025 and connected matters
21.
In the event UHBVN or DHBVN are found to be entertaining
transfer requests by any employee, irrespective of their group or category,
the petitioners shall retain the liberty to initiate contempt proceedings
against erring Nigam under Article 215 of the Constitution of India.
22.
Registry is directed to place a photocopy of this order on the
paper-books of the connected matters.
23.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
(HARPREET SINGH BRAR)
JUDGE
08.04.2026
Puneet Chawla
Whether speaking/reasoned. : Yes/No
Whether Reportable. :
Yes/No
PUNEET CHAWLA
2026.04.10 18:29
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review