Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/CRIMINAL APPEAL (AGAINST ACQUITTAL) NO. 3132 of 2025
FOR APPROVAL AND SIGNATURE:
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
==========================================================
Approved for Reporting
Yes
No
==========================================================
SAMIMBANU BABUBHAI KHALIFA
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT & ANR.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR. JAY G THAKER(9944) for the Appellant(s) No. 1
PUBLIC PROSECUTOR for the Opponent(s)/Respondent(s) No. 1
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ILESH J. VORA
and
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI
Date : 24/09/2026
ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER : HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. T. VACHHANI)
1.
Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and order of
acquittal passed by the learned Principal Magistrate, Juvenile Justice
Board, Nadiad in Juvenile Criminal Case No.36 of 2018 dated
28.02.2025, acquitting the respondent No.2 (the Juvenile) for the offences
punishable under Sections 302 and 201 of the Indian Penal Code, the
victim-appellant has preferred the present appeal under Section 413 of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 read with Section 101 of the
Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015.
2.
The brief facts leading to the filing of the present appeal are as
under:
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
2.1
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
That on 12.12.2017, the complainant Mohmad Rafik Khalifah,
resident of Thasra, lodged a complaint before the Thasra Police Station,
District Kheda, alleging that his nephew Sahil had gone missing under
suspicious circumstances and was later found dead. According to the
complainant, on 10.12.2017, the deceased Sahil had gone to the shop of
one Sanjaybhai Valand in the morning and returned home for lunch in the
afternoon. After having lunch, he again went back to the shop and came
home in the evening at around 6:00 p.m. Thereafter, he visited his
grandmother's house and subsequently went out with respondent No.2,
who was later identified as the Child in Conflict with Law.
2.2
During the night, at about 3:00 a.m., the complainant's mother
Zubeda Bibi informed him that Sahil had not returned home. The
complainant, along with other persons, searched the surrounding area to
trace Sahil. In the course of the search, one Anvarhusen Zakirhusen
Malek informed the complainant that he had seen Sahil at around 11:30
p.m. near Zaika Hotel, in the company of respondent No.2 and one
Mustakim Gabbarmiya Malek. When the complainant inquired with the
respondent No.2 about Sahil's whereabouts, the respondent No.2 replied
that Sahil had sat with him at the underpass for some time and thereafter
they both went to their respective homes.
2.3
On the following day, the complainant continued searching for
Sahil at various nearby places, including Alina, Virpur, Balasinor,
Mahudha, Kathlal, Sarsa, Anand Railway Station and Khambholaj, but
Sahil could not be found. Subsequently, in the early hours of 12.12.2017,
at about 4:00 a.m., one Firojkhan telephonically informed the
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
complainant that a dead body was found floating in a canal situated at
Aurangpura Sim. The complainant immediately rushed to the spot and
identified the dead body as that of his nephew Sahil. The police were
informed and reached the scene to carry out further proceedings.
2.4
On the basis of the said complaint, FIR bearing C.R. No. 1-41/2017
came to be registered at Thasra Police Station initially against unknown
persons, though suspicion was expressed regarding the involvement of
the respondent No.2. Upon completion of investigation, the Investigating
Officer filed a charge-sheet against the respondent No.2 for the offences
punishable under Sections 302 and 201 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.
On conclusion of the evidence on the part of the prosecution, the learned
Juvenile Justice Board put various incriminating circumstances appearing
in the evidence to the respondent No.2 so as to obtain his
explanation/answer as provided under Section 313 of the Code. In his
further statement, the respondent No.2 denied all incriminating
circumstances appearing against him as false and further stated that he
was innocent and that a false case had been filed against him. After
examining the evidence, witness testimonies and submissions from both
sides, the learned Juvenile Justice Board recorded a finding acquitting the
respondent No.2.
3.
We have heard learned Advocate for the appellant and learned
Advocate appearing for the respondent No.2 and learned APP for the
respondent No.1-State and minutely examined the oral and documentary
evidence adduced and produced before the learned Juvenile Justice Board
concerned.
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
4.
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
Learned advocate appearing for the appellant has submitted that
since the entire case of the prosecution rests on circumstantial evidence,
the prosecution has proved its case beyond reasonable doubt, as also
proved the entire chain, and therefore, the learned Juvenile Justice Board
has erred in acquitting the respondent No.2. It is further submitted that if
the FIR in question is seen at the first instance, the complainant gave the
name of the respondent No.2 on the basis of the last seen together and, as
such, the specific role or description of the respondent No.2 having been
seen at the place of offence points out the role of the respondent No.2 in
the commission of the crime. It is therefore submitted that when the
prosecution witnesses had seen the respondent No.2 with the deceased,
the learned Juvenile Justice Board ought to have convicted the respondent
No.2, whereas it discarded the evidence by holding the same to be
hearsay, highly unnatural, improbable and inconsistent.
4.1
It is further submitted that the learned Juvenile Justice Board has
acquitted the respondent No.2 without considering the scientific evidence.
It is further submitted that the Juvenile Justice Board wrongly treated the
statements of important witnesses as "hearsay". Witnesses like PW-1
Mohmad Rafik Khalifah (Complainant) and PW-9 Mohmad Sajid
Khalifah (eye-witness) had direct knowledge. PW-9 clearly saw the
respondent No.2 calling the deceased and both walking away together.
PW-1 identified the respondent No.2 and filed the complaint. It is
submitted that the Juvenile Justice Board rejected these important facts
without properly considering which parts constituted direct evidence and
which parts were hearsay.
4.2
It is further submitted that the Juvenile Justice Board has ignored
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
the direct and important observations of PW-1 and PW-9, who saw the
deceased and the respondent No.2 together at night, and the said facts
were clear and directly connected to the incident. However, the said facts
were not considered. It is further submitted that the Juvenile Justice
Board has discarded the panchnamas only because the pancha witnesses
turned hostile. The recovery and panchnama documents (scene of
offence, seizure of articles, etc.) remain admissible and ought to have
been properly evaluated.
4.3
It is further submitted that the Juvenile Justice Board did not
separate statements based on personal knowledge from statements based
on hearsay. Several witnesses gave direct information; however, the same
has not been considered. It is further submitted that PW-13 (Doctor) has
clearly stated that the death was due to pressure on the neck and injuries
caused by a wooden object, which were sufficient to cause death.
However, the Juvenile Justice Board did not consider this medical
evidence with other facts, such as the respondent No.2 being last seen
with the deceased.
4.4
It is further submitted that the documentary evidence, such as
panchnamas, post-mortem report and FSL report (PW-11), does not lose
its evidentiary value since the witnesses were declared hostile, and the
said documents ought to have been evaluated independently. It is further
submitted that the medical cause of neck compression and chest injuries
match with the scene panchnama, clothes and recovered wooden object.
The Juvenile Justice Board did not connect these facts and failed to draw
a proper conclusion.
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
4.5
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
It is further submitted that the prosecution has completed the entire
chain of circumstances, viz.: (i) PW-9 saw the respondent No.2 with the
deceased at 11:30 p.m.; (ii) the deceased was later found dead with
injuries; and (iii) the panchnama thereby supported the recovery. It is
submitted that the motive and conduct of the respondent No.2 were not
considered, as the respondent No.2 used to sit with the deceased and was
seen with him late at night. However, the said fact was not properly
considered by the learned Juvenile Justice Board and, therefore, the
impugned judgment and order of acquittal deserves to be quashed and set
aside.
4.6
By making the above submissions, learned Advocate for the
appellant would submit to allow the present appeal and to quash and set
aside the judgment and order of acquittal recorded by the learned Juvenile
Justice Board.
5.
Per contra, learned Advocate appearing for the respondent No.2-
juvenile would support the impugned judgment and order of acquittal and
submit that the learned Juvenile Justice Board, after thorough evaluation
and examination of the evidence on record, has recorded the finding of
acquittal and, therefore, this Court may not interfere with the said finding
of acquittal. He would submit that the prosecution has failed to prove the
charges levelled against the respondent No.2, as the evidence of the
complainant is doubtful and no plausible reasons are shown by the
prosecution as to why their evidence ought to have been believed, since
they are interested witnesses and, thus, their evidence is not reliable and
believable. He has further submitted that there are omissions and
contradictions in the evidence of the prosecution witnesses and the same
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
cannot be ignored.
5.1
It is submitted that no such independent witness has been examined
by the prosecution to establish that the respondent No.2 committed the
murder. The evidence produced by the prosecution is not sufficient to
prove the charges levelled against the respondent No.2. He would
therefore submit to dismiss the present appeal while confirming the
judgment and order of acquittal passed by the learned Juvenile Justice
Board.
5.2
In support of his submissions, learned advocate for the respondent
No.2 has relied upon the decision in the case of Laxman Prasad Alias
Laxman Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh [(2023) 6 SCC 399] and
Munikrishna alias Krishna etc. Vs. State by Ulsoor PS [2022 SCC
OnLine SC 1449] and has submitted that, as per the ratio laid down by
the Hon'ble Apex Court, if one link in the chain of circumstances is
missing and not proved, the conviction based on circumstantial evidence
is required to be set aside.
6.
We have heard the learned Advocates appearing for the respective
parties and perused the deposition of witnesses as also the documentary
evidence placed on record as well as the conclusion arrived at by the
learned Juvenile Justice Board.
7.
At the outset, if the case of the prosecution is examined, the
prosecution has examined mainly five witnesses, viz., the complainant
and four other witnesses, in support of its case; however, from the
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
evidence of these witnesses, the prosecution has not proved the factum of
the respondent No.2 having committed the offence in question. However,
this Court would re-appreciate the evidence of the said five witnesses
upon which heavy reliance has been placed by the prosecution to prove
its case.
8.
Firstly, PW No.1 – Mohmad Rafik Khalifa, complainant, has been
examined at Exh.20, who has stated similar facts as narrated in the
complaint. He had stated that on that day Sahil came for lunch at her
mother's house in the afternoon, returned to the shop and again came to
the house at 6:00. He remained in the house and went with the respondent
No.2. Around 3:00 in the night, her mother came to him and informed
him that Sahil did not return. Upon inquiring about the surrounding area,
Sahil could not be found. The complainant tried to trace him along with
other persons, whereas one Anvarhusen Zakirhusen Malek informed him
that he had seen Sahil at 11:30 with respondent No.2 and Mustakim
Gabbarmiya Malek, who were returning from Zaika Hotel. He asked the
respondent No.2 about Sahil, in response to which he stated that Sahil sat
with him at the underpass for a short time and both returned to their
respective houses. Thereafter, on the next date in the morning, he
searched for Sahil in Alina, Virpur, Balasinor, Mahudha, Kathlal, Sarsa,
Anand Railway Station, Khambholaj, etc. area. On 12.12.2017, in the
morning at 4:00, one Firojkhan called him and informed him that the
body of Sahil was in the Canal near the bridge situated in Aurangpura
Sim. The complainant reached there, where he found Sahil dead. He
further stated that the body of Sahil was lying in the canal in a manner in
which the legs of the body were inside and the other part of the body was
outside the water. He further stated that the body of the deceased had
injuries. He further stated that the neck of the deceased was twisted. He
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
stated to have given a complaint with suspicion over the respondent No.2.
He identified the respondent No.2 before the Court. During crossexamination, he admitted that he was informed about the incident through
other persons.
From the evidence of this witness, it transpires that the deceased
was a friend of the respondent No.2 and the deceased was found dead,
and thereafter the complaint was given. Thus, no such direct involvement
of the respondent No.2 in the commission of the crime was proved from
the evidence of this witness.
9.
PW-9, Mohmad Sajid Khalifa, is examined at Exh.47, who has
deposed that on 10.12.2017 at around 10:00 in the night, his nephew
Sahil was eating at his house. The respondent No.2 came there, called the
deceased Sahil and both went outside. Around 5:00 in the morning, his
mother PW-11 Zubeda Bibi woke him up by stating that Sahil was not in
bed. Therefore, he, along with the other persons, went in search of his
nephew Sahil. He further stated that PW-10 Arif, his brother, called him
and informed him that the body of Sahil was found in the Canal at
Aurangpura. He, along with the other persons, went to the spot and saw
and identified the body of deceased Sahil. He narrated the injuries on the
body of the deceased. He stated that his brother PW-1 had given a
complaint to the police. He further stated that he had suspicion over the
respondent No.2 and another person named Habib Khan. He stated that
the police had recorded his statement.
Thus, from the evidence of this witness, the only factum proved is
that on 10.12.2017, the respondent No.2 went out with Sahil, and that
Sahil was found dead, and thereafter the complaint was given. No such
direct involvement of the respondent No.2 was proved from the evidence
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
of this witness.
10.
PW-10-Mohmad Arif Khalifa is examined at Exh.48, who has
deposed that he was informed about the disappearance of his nephew
Sahil. They all went to search for him, but he came to know that one body
was found near the Canal. Upon reaching that spot, he came to know that
the body was of his nephew Sahil. He stated that he did not know who
had killed him. He stated that the respondent No.2 had been roaming with
the deceased Sahil for 2 months. He further stated that he came to know
about the murder of the deceased by the respondent No.2 through other
persons. He further stated that he was informed by PW-12 Anvar Husain
Malek that the deceased was seen returning from Zaika Hotel around
11:00 with the respondent No.2 and Mustakim Gabbar.
Thus, the evidence of this witness appears to be hearsay evidence
and, therefore, does not inspire any confidence to link the respondent
No.2 with the offence in question.
11.
PW-11-Zubedabibi has been examined at Exh.51, who is the
grandmother of the deceased and has deposed that she had four sons and
one daughter. Out of them, her daughter Shamim Banu had one son
named Sahil. After the divorce, Shamim Banu lived with the present
witness for 8-9 years until her re-marriage to one Babubhai Kasim at
Virpur. After that, Shamim Baru went to her matrimonial home by
leaving her son Sahil. It was stated that her grandson Sahil failed in the
10th standard and was doing hair-cutting work at a shop in Sanjaybhai
Valand. It was stated that in the night time, Sahil used to sit with the
respondent No.2. She stated that on the day of Sahil's disappearance, she
went to the complainant, who, along with other persons, went in search of
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
Sahil. In the morning at 9:00 on the third day of Sahil's disappearance,
PW-1 informed him that the body of Sahil was found in Navrang Sim.
She stated having gone there and narrated the injuries on the body of the
deceased. She stated that, as per her belief, the murder of the deceased
was caused by the respondent No.2, Habibkhan, Banu and Muskan.
During cross-examination, she admitted that she had not seen the
incident and came to know about the incident from another person. Thus,
the overall facts stated in the deposition of this witness are hearsay and,
therefore, her evidence does not inspire any confidence. Furthermore, it is
stated by her that she had suspicion over three other persons other than
the respondent No.2. But, except for a bare statement of suspicion, no
other credible evidence has been adduced by the said witness. Therefore,
the deposition of the said witness is not wholly reliable so as to bring
home the charge against the respondent.
12.
PW-12 Anvar Malek had initially not supported the version of the
prosecution, but after declaring him hostile, he admitted the leading
questions raised by the learned APP. He supported the statement given
before the police. However, during cross-examination, he admitted that
he had not seen the incident and had no personal knowledge about the
incident. He further admitted that he had merely given his name and
address to the police. Thus, considering the overall deposition of the said
witness, it appears that the nature of the evidence of this witness is
hearsay and, therefore, does not inspire any confidence.
13.
Thus, from the aforesaid evidence of the five main witnesses, the
prosecution has failed to prove the case against the respondent No.2 of
having committed murder with the intention and knowledge and by
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
causing bodily injuries which were sufficient in the ordinary course of
nature to cause the death of a person. None of the witnesses has, in clear
terms, stated to have seen the respondent No.2 committing the murder of
the deceased and, therefore, their evidence does not inspire any
confidence. The evidence of most of these witnesses is hearsay evidence,
who had stated in their deposition before the Court that the respondent
No.2 was last seen with the deceased before his dead body was found, but
apart from the respondent No.2, another person, Habibkhan, was also
seen with the deceased, and there is also a gap of almost more than a day
between the period when the respondent No.2 was last seen with the
deceased and when the dead body of the deceased was found.
Furthermore, none of these witnesses has stated about any previous
animosity between the respondent No.2 and the deceased, and thus the
prosecution has failed to establish its case beyond reasonable doubt. The
learned Juvenile Justice Board, after thorough analysis, has come to the
conclusion and this Court does not find any infirmity in recording the
acquittal of the respondent No.2.
14.
If the evidence examined by the prosecution is examined, nothing
indicates the involvement of the respondent surfaced from the evidence of
this witness, in spite of the fact that the witness has deposed to have seen
the respondent No.2 with the deceased prior to commission of the
offence, and thus the evidence of this witness does not indicate the fact of
the respondent No.2 having been last seen together with the deceased. No
direct evidence to link the respondent No.2 with the crime in question has
emerged and merely naming the respondent No.2 as having accompanied
the deceased prior to commission of the offence, the complaint came to
be lodged.
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
15.
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
Now, insofar as the argument of the learned Advocate for the
appellant that the case on hand is based on circumstantial evidence and
the prosecution has completed the entire chain to connect the respondent
No.2 with the crime is concerned, it would be apt to note that, while
leading the case, the prosecution is required to establish mainly three
links of the chain, namely: (i) motive; (ii) last seen; and (iii) recovery of
weapon of assault, showing involvement of the respondent No.2. Thus,
while dealing with the evidence on record, the Court concerned is
required to appreciate whether the aforesaid three aspects are established
to prove the case of the prosecution or not, and if not, the benefit thereof
would go to the respondent No.2, as the prosecution has failed to prove
its case beyond reasonable doubt by failing to complete the entire chain
of circumstances.
16.
In a case of circumstantial evidence, the chain is required to be
completed as mandated under the law so as to indicate the guilt of the
respondent No.2 while discarding any other theory of the crime. If one of
the link goes missing and not proved, in view of the settled law on the
point, the conviction is required to be interfered with. At this stage, with
profit, we may refer to the decision in case of Laxman Prasad Alias
Laxman (supra) where the Hon’ble Apex Court after referring to Sharad
Birdhichand Sarda vs. State of Maharashtra [(1984) 4 SCC 116] and
Shailendra Rajdev Pasvan vs. State of Gujarat [(2020) 14 SCC 750] has
quashed the conviction by making observations in paragraph 2 to 4 as
under:
“2.
The present one is a case of circumstantial evidence. The
prosecution led evidence to establish three links of the chain: (i) motive,
(ii) last seen, and (iii) recovery of weapon of assault, at the pointing out of
the appellant. The High Court, while dealing with the evidence on record,
agreed with the finding of motive and the last seen, however, insofar as the
recovery of the weapon of assault and bloodstained clothes were
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
concerned, the High Court in para 18 of the judgment held the same to be
invalid and also goes to the extent to say that the recovery which has been
made does not indicate that the appellant has committed the offence. Still,
it observed that looking to the entire gamut and other clinching evidence
against the appellant of last seen and motive, affirmed the conviction.
3.
We do not find such conclusion of the High Court to be strictly in
accordance with law. In a case of circumstantial evidence, the chain has to
be complete in all respects so as to indicate the guilt of the accused and
also exclude any other theory of the crime. The law is well settled on the
above point. Reference may be had to the following cases:
(1) Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra,
(ii) Shailendra Rajdev Pasvan v. State of Gujarat.
4.
Thus, if the High Court found one of the links to be missing and not
proved in view of the settled law on the point, the conviction ought to have
been interfered with.”
17.
In view of the settled law that one must look for a complete chain
of circumstances and not at snapped and scattered links which do not
make a complete sequence, the circumstances from which the conclusion
of guilt is drawn should be fully proved, and such circumstances must be
conclusive in nature. Moreover, all the circumstances should be complete,
and there should be no gap left in the chain of evidence; in the present
case, the chain is not completed.
18.
Furthermore, there is no eyewitness to the incident. Based on
suspicion, the complainant lodged an FIR against the present respondent
No.2, and the arrest was made based on suspicion; there was no concrete
material against the respondent No.2 to prove his involvement in the
commission of the crime and merely on suspicion, his involvement was
tried to be shown, which cannot take the place of evidence. From the
evidence so produced by the prosecution and as examined by the learned
Juvenile Justice Board, the prosecution, as rightly held by the respondent
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
No.2 Board has failed to prove its case. Though the prosecution has
heavily relied upon the theory of last seen together, along with the
respondent No.2, another person was also found with the deceased, which
also casts doubt on the credence of such evidence. The conduct of the
witnesses identifying only the deceased who was accompanied by the
respondent No.2 prior to his murder also comes under the cloud of doubt.
19.
At this juncture, it is apt to refer the judgment of the Supreme
Court, in the case of Tulasareddi @ Mudakappa & Anr. v. The State of
Karnataka & Ors., 2026 INSC 67, the relevant paragraphs of which read
as under:
“26. At this stage, we would like to refer the decisions rendered by this
Court on the aspect of interference of Appellate Court in the appeal filed
by the State challenging the acquittal of the accused recorded by the Trial
Court.
27. In the case of Babu Sahebagouda Rudragoudar v. State of Karnataka
this Court held in paragraphs 39 to 42 as under:
39. This Court in Rajesh Prasad v. State of Bihar [Rajesh Prasad v.
State of Bihar,(2022) 3 SCC 471 : (2022) 2 SCC (Cri) 31]
encapsulated the legal position covering the field after considering
various earlier judgments and held as below : (SCC pp.482-83, para
29)
“29. After referring to a catena of judgments, this Court culled
out the following general principles regarding the powers of the
appellate court while dealing with an appeal against an order of
acquittal in the following words: (Chandrappacase [Chandrappa
v. State of Karnataka, (2007) 4 SCC 415 : (2007) 2 SCC
(Cri)325], SCC p. 432, para 42)
‘42. From the above decisions, in our considered view, the
following general principles regarding powers of the appellate
court while dealing with an appeal against an order of acquittal
emerge:
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
(1)
An appellate court has full power to review, reappreciate and
reconsider the evidence upon which the order of acquittal is
founded.
(2)
The Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 puts no limitation,
restriction or condition on exercise of such power and an
appellate court on the evidence before it may reach its own
conclusion, both on questions of fact and of law.
(3)
Various expressions, such as, “substantial and compelling
reasons”, “good and sufficient grounds”, “very strong”
circumstances”, “distorted conclusions”, “glaring mistakes”,
etc. are not intended to curtail extensive powers of an appellate
court in an appeal against acquittal. Such phraseologies are
more in the nature of “flourishes of language” to emphasise the
reluctance of an appellate court to interfere with acquittal than
to curtail the power of the court to review the evidence and to
come to its own conclusion.
(4)
An appellate court, however, must bear in mind that in case of
acquittal, there is double presumption in favour of the accused.
Firstly, the presumption of innocence is available to him under
the fundamental principle of criminal jurisprudence that every
person shall be presumed to be innocent unless he is proved
guilty by a competent court of law. Secondly, the accused having
secured his acquittal, the presumption of his innocence is
further reinforced, reaffirmed and strengthened by the trial
court.
(5)
If two reasonable conclusions are possible on the basis of the
evidence on record, the appellate court should not disturb the
finding of acquittal recorded by the trial court.’
40. Further, in H.D. Sundara v. State of Karnataka [H.D. Sundara
v. State of Karnataka, (2023) 9 SCC 581 : (2023) 3 SCC (Cri) 748] this
Court summarised the principles governing the exercise of appellate
jurisdiction while dealing with an appeal against acquittal under
Section 378 CrPC as follows : (SCC p. 584, para 8)
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
“8..… 8.1.
The acquittal of the accused further strengthens the
presumption of innocence,
8.2. The appellate court, while hearing an appeal against acquittal,
is entitled to reappreciate the oral and documentary evidence,
8.3. The appellate court, while deciding an appeal against acquittal,
after reappreciating the evidence, is required to consider whether the
view taken by the trial court is a possible view which could have been
taken on the basis of the evidence on record,
8.4. If the view taken is a possible view, the appellate court cannot
overturn the order of acquittal on the ground that another view was
also possible, and
8.5. The appellate court can interfere with the order of acquittal only if
it comes to a finding that the only conclusion which can be recorded on
the basis of the evidence on record was that the guilt of the accused
was proved beyond a reasonable doubt and no other conclusion was
possible.”
41. Thus, it is beyond the pale of doubt that the scope of
interference by an appellate court for reversing the judgment of
acquittal recorded by the trial court in favour of the accused has to be
exercised within the four corners of the following principles:
41.1. That the judgment of acquittal suffers from patent perversity,
41.2. That the same is based on a misreading/omission to consider
material evidence on record, and
41.3. That no two reasonable views are possible and only the view
consistent with the guilt of the accused is possible from the evidence
available on record.
42. The appellate court, in order to interfere with the judgment of
acquittal would have to record pertinent findings on the above factors
if it is inclined to reverse the judgment of acquittal rendered by the
trial court.
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
28. In the case of Ramesh v. State of Uttarakhand, this Court has
observed and held in para 19 & 20 as under:
“19. In a case like this when the trial court acquitted the accused
persons of their charges, the High Court could not have reversed the
finding merely on the basis that other view, as recorded by the High
Court, appeared to it to be a plausible view. Such an approach by the
High Court, against the judgment of the acquittal, is impermissible. In
this context, we may usefully refer to Kalyan v. State of U.P. [Kalyan v.
State of U.P., (2001) 9 SCC 632 : 2002 SCC (Cri) 780] wherein it was
held : (SCC pp. 640-41, paras 15, 18 & 20)
“15. … The view taken by the trial court could have been
disturbed only if there were compelling reasons. We do not find
any compelling reason noticed [State of U.P. v. Hari Lal, 1998
SCC OnLine All 1216 : 1999 All LJ 142] by the High Court
while setting aside the order of acquittal.
18. Even if another view regarding the occurrence was possible,
as taken by the High Court, the same could not be made a basis
for setting aside the order of the trial court in view of the settled
position of law on the point.
20. Under the circumstances, the appeal is allowed by setting
aside the judgment of the High Court convicting the accused
persons and sentencing them to various imprisonments including
life imprisonment. We uphold the order of acquittal passed by
the trial court in favour of the appellants.”
29. From the aforesaid decisions rendered by this Court, it can be said
that if two reasonable conclusions are possible on the basis of the evidence
on record, the Appellate Court should not disturb the findings of acquittal
recorded by the Trial Court. Further, if the view taken is a possible view,
the Appellate Court cannot overturn the order of acquittal on the ground
that another view was also possible. The following principles have to be
kept in mind by the Appellate Court while dealing with the appeals against
an order of acquittal:
(a)
whether the judgment of acquittal suffers from patent perversity,
(b)
whether the judgment is based on misreading/omission to
consider the material evidence on record,
(c)
an order of acquittal is to be interfered with only when there are
“compelling and substantial reasons” for doing so. If the order is
“clearly unreasonable”, it is a compelling reason for
R/CR.A/3132/2025(GJHC240824892025)
JUDGMENT DATED: 24/09/2026
interference.’
20.
(d)
the appellate court, while deciding an appeal against acquittal,
after reappreciating the evidence, is required to consider whether
the view taken by the trial court is a possible view which could
have been taken on the basis of the evidence on record,
(e)
if the view taken is a possible view, the appellate court cannot
overturn the order of acquittal on the ground that another view
was also possible, and
(f)
the appellate court can interfere with the order of acquittal only
if it comes to a finding that the only conclusion which can be
recorded on the basis of the evidence on record was that the guilt
of the accused was proved beyond a reasonable doubt and no
other conclusion was possible.
In light of the above legal position and for the reasons recorded in
the foregoing paragraphs, coupled with the fact that the case of the
prosecution does not get support from the evidence recorded by the
learned Juvenile Justice Board, the present appeal deserves to be
dismissed and is accordingly dismissed while confirming the impugned
judgment and order of acquittal.
(ILESH J. VORA,J)
(R. T. VACHHANI, J)
MVP/sompura
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review