Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
121+122+127+247
Date of decision: 05.03.2026
1. CWP-1422-2026
Samarjit Singh
....Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab and others
....Respondents
2. CWP-1443-2026
Balbir Singh
....Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab and others
....Respondents
3. CWP-6003-2026
Surinder Singh
....Petitioner
Versus
The Registrar Cooperative Societies, Punjab and others
....Respondents
4. CWP-5392-2026
The Bir Rau Ke Multipurpose Cooperative Agriculture Service Society
Limited
....Petitioner
Versus
State of Punjab and others
....Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARPREET SINGH BRAR
Present:
Mr. Bachanpreet Singh, Advocate
for the petitioner in CWP-1422-2026.
Mr. Vishneet Singh Kathpal, Advocate (through V.C.)
for the petitioner in CWP-1443-2026.
Mr. Balraj Singh Sidhu, Advocate
for the petitioner in CWP-6003-2026.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
Mr. Surinder Garg, Advocate
for the petitioner in CWP-5392-2026.
Mr. Vikas Arora, DAG, Punjab in all the cases.
Mr. H.S. Bedi, Advocate
for respondent No.6 in CWP-5392-2026.
HARPREET SINGH BRAR J. (Oral)
1.
This common order shall dispose of all the aforementioned
four writ petitions filed under Articles 226/227 of the Constitution of
India, three of which i.e. CWP No.1422 of 2026, CWP No.6003 of 2026
and CWP No.1443 of 2026, have been filed by retired employees of
various Co-operative Societies in the State of Punjab, seeking the
release of their retiral benefits along with interest for the delayed
payment. However, CWP No.5392 of 2026 has been filed by a Cooperative Society itself i.e. The Bir Rau Ke Multipurpose Co-operative
Agriculture
Service
Society,
challenging
the
action
of
the
respondent/authorities in coercing it to release the retiral benefits of its
former Secretary, against whom recovery proceedings are pending. The
prayers in each of these petitions are as follows:1. CWP No. 1422 of 2026
The petitioner seeks the issuance of a writ in the nature of
mandamus directing the respondents to:a) Release the balance admitted retiral dues, being part of
his gratuity and leave encashment as the same has been
unlawfully withheld.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
b) Pay interest on the delayed payment of his retiral dues @
18% per annum, from the date the amount became due i.e.,
31.01.2020, till the date of actual payment.
2. CWP No. 1443 of 2026
The petitioner seeks:
a) Issuance of a writ in the nature of mandamus directing
respondent No.3 to grant interest on the admittedly delayed
payment of his retiral benefits.
b) Issuance of a writ in the nature of certiorari for quashing
of the inquiry report dated 25.04.2023 (Annexure P-5),
whereby his claim for interest was rejected.
3. CWP No. 6003 of 2026
The petitioner seeks the issuance of a writ in the nature of
mandamus directing the respondents to release his retiral benefits, i.e.
the balance amount of Gratuity, Leave Encashment, Provident Fund as
well as pending salary, along with interest on the delayed payment @
18% per annum from the date of its accrual till actual realization.
4. CWP No. 5392 of 2026
This petition has been filed by The Bir Rau Ke MultiPurpose Co-operative Agriculture Service Society Limited, seeking the
following reliefs:
a) Issuance of a writ in the nature of certiorari for settingaside the Show Cause Notice dated 24.12.2025 (Annexure
P-7) issued by the office of respondent No.5 (Assistant
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Nihal Singh Wala,
Moga), vide which the petitioner/Society was directed to
release the retiral benefits of respondent No.6/Gurjant
Singh.
b)
Issuance of a writ in the nature of mandamus directing
respondents
No.1
to
to
not
to
compel
the
petitioner/Society to release the benefits of respondent
No.6.
CONTENTIONS
1. CWP No. 1422 of 2026
2.
Learned counsel for the petitioner (in CWP No.1422 of
2026) has, inter alia, contended that the petitioner, retired as Secretary
of The Swaich Kamalu Multipurpose Co-operative Agriculture Service
Society Ltd., District Bathinda, on 31.01.2020, after rendering more
than four decades of unblemished service. His service conditions were
governed by the Punjab State Co-operative Agricultural Service
Societies Service Rules, 1997 (hereinafter referred to as “the 1997
Service Rules”), under which he was entitled to gratuity and leave
encashment at par with the employees of the Government of Punjab.
3.
Upon retirement, his retiral benefits were duly assessed
through a pre-audit conducted on 05.02.2020 (Annexure P-5 in CWP
No. 1422 of 2026), and a total sum of ₹11,95,156/- was found payable
towards gratuity and leave encashment. This entitlement was repeatedly
acknowledged by the respondents in audited balance sheets, official
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
records etc. However, the respondent-Society released only ₹3.50 lakhs
on 11.06.2020 and ₹1.30 lakhs on 17.12.2020, totaling ₹4.80 lakhs,
leaving a substantial balance unpaid. The petitioner made repeated
representations and served legal notices (Annexure P-6) for the release
of the balance amount, which yielded no effective result.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the
petitioner was constrained to approach this Court earlier by way of
CWP No. 26951 of 2021, which was disposed of vide order dated
05.01.2022 (Annexure P-8) with directions to decide his representation.
Due to non-compliance with the aforesaid order, the petitioner was
constrained to file COCP No.456 of 2022, during the pendency of
which, the respondents passed a speaking order dated 14.03.2022
(Annexure P-9). In the aforesaid speaking order (Annexure P-9), the
respondents unequivocally acknowledged that the petitioner is governed
by the 1997 Service Rules and that he is entitled to gratuity and retiral
benefits at par with employees of the Government of Punjab.
Furthermore, the Managing Committee of the respondent-Society was
directed to release the balance amount to the petitioner as per the said
Rules.
5.
It is argued that despite the crystallization and admission of
liability, the respondents only released the petitioner’s retiral dues
partially and in a piecemeal manner. As on 08.12.2025, a total amount
of ₹9,05,316/- stood paid, leaving a balance of ₹2,90,000/- unpaid,
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
which stands admitted by the respondents themselves in the balance
sheet (Annexure P-10) supplied to the petitioner.
2. CWP No. 1443 of 2026
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner (in CWP No.1443 of
2026) has submitted that the petitioner superannuated from service with
the respondent-Society on 31.12.2011 and was entitled to retiral benefits
amounting to ₹5,50,000/- towards leave encashment and gratuity.
Owing to the deliberate non-release of these dues, the petitioner was
constrained to approach this Court on multiple occasions. He initially
filed CWP No. 19781 of 2013, which was disposed of vide order dated
13.09.2013 (Annexure P-1 in CWP No. 1443 of 2026) with a direction
to the respondents to consider the petitioner’s representation. As the said
order was not complied with, the petitioner, thereafter, filed COCP No.
986 of 2014, which too came to be disposed of vide order dated
16.10.2015 (Annexure P-2) in view of the fact that a speaking order had
eventually been passed. Subsequently, the petitioner approached this
Court again by filing CWP No. 3790 of 2016 seeking release of the
balance amount of ₹1,30,000/-. During the pendency of the said
petition, the respondent-Society cleared the outstanding amount, leading
to the withdrawal of the petition with liberty to approach the Registrar,
Co-operative Societies (Annexure P-3). Learned counsel submits that
the entire amount of ₹5,50,000/- was eventually paid to the petitioner in
installments between 04.04.2012 and 30.04.2016; however, no interest
was paid on the delayed release of the retiral benefits.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
7.
Thereafter, the petitioner submitted a representation dated
02.06.2022 (Annexure P-4) claiming interest on the delayed payment of
his retiral benefits. The Registrar forwarded the said representation to
the Assistant Registrar, Fazilka with directions to conduct an inquiry
into the delay in the release of the petitioner’s dues. As per the inquiry
report dated 25.04.2023 (Annexure P-5), the gratuity and other retiral
benefits of the petitioner were released in instalments owing to the poor
financial condition of the respondent-Society. The report further noted
that the delay in payment occurred due to the non-creation of a gratuity
fund by the then office-bearers of the Society and the continuous
financial losses suffered by it. In view of the financial health of the
respondent-Society, the inquiry report concluded that the petitioner’s
demand for interest does not appear to be reasonable and could not be
acceded to.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner argues that the aforesaid
rejection is illegal and arbitrary. It is contended that financial hardship
or losses suffered by the respondent-Society cannot constitute a valid
ground for withholding or delaying the payment of statutory retiral
benefits. Placing reliance on the judgment of this Court in A.S.
Randhawa v. State of Punjab, reported as 1997 (3) SCT 468, learned
counsel submits that it is settled law that delay in payment of retiral
benefits is impermissible in law and that the retiree shall be entitled to
interest in view of such delay.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
3. CWP No. 6003 of 2026
9.
Learned counsel for the petitioner (in CWP No. 6003 of
2026) has, inter alia, contended that the petitioner retired on 31.08.2023
as Manager from respondent No.4 - The Makhu Zamindara Cooperative
Marketing-cum-Processing
Society
Limited,
District
Ferozepur. After retirement, he submitted all necessary documents for
the release of his retiral benefits. His case was forwarded for pre-audit,
which verified his entitlement to ₹7,81,425.50/- for Gratuity and
₹5,29,780.00/- for Leave Encashment, totaling ₹13,11,205.50/-. The
petitioner is also entitled to ₹5,59,515.00/- towards salary and
₹7,46,794.00/- towards Provident Fund. As such, the petitioner deserves
to be paid a total of ₹26,53,514.50/-.
10.
He further contends that despite repeated visits and
requests, the respondent-department kept the matter pending on one
pretext or another and, to date, no amount towards the petitioner’s
retiral benefits has been paid. Aggrieved by this inaction, the petitioner
issued a legal notice dated 27.11.2025 (Annexure P-1 in CWP No. 6003
of 2026). In response thereto (Annexure P-3), the President of
respondent No. 4–Society acknowledged the petitioner’s entitlement to
the said amount but stated that the Society has been incurring
continuous financial losses and is not in a position to discharge all its
liabilities in a single instalment. It was further stated that, despite the
precarious financial condition of the Society, a sum of ₹4,39,120/- has
been released to the petitioner on various dates and that his case is being
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
accorded preference in view of his nearly 29 years of service with the
Society. The reply also stated that the outstanding dues would be cleared
at the earliest possible time, subject to the availability of funds. The
relevant portion of the reply (Annexure P-3) is reproduced hereunder:
“2. That it is pertinent to bring to your kind notice that the
Makhu
Zamindara
Cooperative
Marketing-cumProcessing Society is a cooperative society duly registered
under the provisions of the Punjab Cooperative Societies
Act, 1961. The day-to-day affairs of the Society are
managed by the Managing Committee, which is an elected
body chosen from among its members for a term of five
years from the date of election. All expenses of the Society,
including electricity bills, salaries of employees, telephone
charges, etc., are borne by the Society from its own funds
and not from the State exchequer. The Society does not
receive any grant, aid, or financial assistance from the
State Government; therefore, all its liabilities are met from
its own resources. The sources of income of the Society are
limited, and at present the Society is running under
continuous financial losses. As per the balance sheet
dated 31.03.2025, the Society has suffered an accumulated
loss of ₹75,81,264/-. It is admitted that the Manager of the
Society retired on 31.08.2023, and his retiral dues are
payable. However, it is also pertinent to apprise you that
the salaries of the employees have not been paid for the
last 40 months, and an amount of ₹6016900.90/- towards
employees' salaries is outstanding as on 31.03.2025. In
view of the severe financial constraints, the Society is not
in a position to clear all the liabilities of your client in a
single instalment. Your client, having served the Society
for a long period, is well aware of the income, liabilities,
and financial condition of the Society. As per the balance
sheet dated 31.03.2025, the total loss of the Society stands
at ₹69,58,055/-. Despite the weak corpus condition of
society Rs.4,39,120/- have already been paid to your client
on various dates, still preference is being given to your
client since he had served almost 29 years in the Society.
Therefore, the outstanding dues of your client shall be
cleared at the earliest possible time, subject to the
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
availability of funds. Your cooperation in the matter is
earnestly solicited in the interest of justice and the
members of the Society.”
4. CWP No. 5392 of 2026
11.
Learned counsel for the petitioner–Society (in CWP
No.5392 of 2026) has submitted that respondent No. 6 retired from the
post of Secretary of the petitioner–Society on 31.08.2019. Thereafter,
respondent No. 6 submitted representations dated 04.03.2020 and
14.07.2020 to the petitioner–Society as well as to the concerned official
respondents seeking release of his retiral benefits. As the said benefits
were not released, respondent No. 6 approached this Court by filing
CWP No. 13633 of 2020. The said petition was disposed of vide order
dated 04.09.2020 (Annexure P-2) with a direction to the respondents
therein to consider and decide the representations of the petitioner.
12.
It is submitted that the retiral benefits of respondent No. 6
were withheld in view of the allegations pertaining to financial
irregularities made in the accounts of the petitioner-Society during his
tenure of service. Further, two arbitral awards dated 23.06.2023
(Annexures P-3 and P-4) have been passed against him for recovery of
amounts of ₹55,467/- and ₹11,250/-, respectively, on account of his
failure to deposit certain dues.
13.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further contended that
notwithstanding the aforesaid pending recoveries, respondent No.5-the
Assistant Registrar, Co-operative Societies, has been pressurizing the
petitioner–Society to release the retiral benefits of respondent No.6. It is
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
further submitted that on 05.03.2025, the petitioner-Society passed a
resolution (Annexure P-5) requesting the respondent No.5-Assistant
Registrar to adjudicate upon the issue of the financial imbalance caused
by respondent No.6. However, vide order dated 24.12.2025 (Annexure
P-6), the Assistant Registrar dismissed the imbalance case on the ground
that the petitioner-Society had failed to produce the requisite records.
On the very same day, respondent No. 5 issued a show-cause notice
(Annexure P-7) to the President, Vice-President, and all Committee
Members of the petitioner-Society, threatening action under Section
27(2) of the Punjab Co-operative Societies Act, 1961 in the event the
amount of ₹7,26,221/- along with interest is not paid to respondent No.
6.
14.
Additionally, learned counsel for the petitioner–Society
submits that the Punjab Co-operative Societies Act, 1961 (hereinafter
referred to as “the 1961 Act”) is the principal legislation governing the
registration, regulation, and functioning of Co-operative Societies in the
State of Punjab. Section 85 of the 1961 Act empowers the State
Government to frame rules for carrying out the mandate of the Act. In
exercise of the said statutory power, the State Government framed the
Punjab Co-operative Societies Rules, 1963 (hereinafter referred to as
“the 1963 Rules”). It is submitted that the 1963 Rules constitute
delegated legislation, framed under Section 85 of the 1961 Act.
15.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has further argued that the
Legislature, in its wisdom, has delegated the power to prescribe the
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
qualifications and conditions of service of the members and employees
of Co-operative Societies to the State Government under Section 85(2)
(xxxviii) of the 1961 Act. However, under Rule 28 of the 1963 Rules,
the State Government has further delegated this power to the Registrar,
Co-operative Societies and in exercise of such delegated authority, the
Registrar has framed the 1997 Service Rules.
16.
It is contended that sub-delegation is permissible only where
it is expressly authorized or can be necessarily implied from the parent
statute. In the present case, however, the 1961 Act does not confer any
power upon the State Government to further delegate its rule-making
power to the Registrar. Consequently, it is argued that the 1997 Service
Rules are invalid and ultra vires the parent enactment. Learned counsel
for the petitioner–Society further submits that, through the 1997 Service
Rules, the Registrar has effectively been vested with the powers of a
“super-employer”, mandating Co-operative Societies to make payments
of leave encashment, gratuity and other retiral benefits to their retired
employees at par with employees of the State Government, despite the
precarious financial condition of such Societies. It is submitted that the
implementation of these Rules reveals a manifest double standard in the
State’s employment policy. While the State Government has been
increasingly remunerating its own staff through meager consolidated
salaries or contractual engagements, the Co-operative Societies are
being saddled with the staggering financial burden of providing pay and
retiral benefits at par with regular government service. Learned counsel
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
argues that not even a single Society possesses the financial fortitude to
sustain such a mandate, particularly in the absence of any state-funded
budgetary support.
17.
It is argued that Co-operative Societies registered under the
1961 Act are autonomous bodies, and all expenses, including the
payment of salaries to their employees, are borne from their own funds
and not from the State exchequer. The Societies do not receive any
grant, aid, or financial assistance from the State Government, and
therefore all their liabilities must be met from their own resources. It
was brought to the notice of this Court that as per the admission of the
Finance Minister of the Government of Punjab in July 2025, nearly half
of the State’s 3,500 Primary Agricultural Co-operative Societies (PACS)
are in financial distress. Thus, a majority of Co-operative Societies in
Punjab are operating under continuous financial losses and, despite this,
they are being burdened with the liability of paying various retiral
benefits to their employees. Learned counsel further submits that several
Co-operative Societies, including the petitioner–Society in CWP No.
5392 of 2026, have neither adopted the 1997 Service Rules nor employ
ten or more persons so as to fall within the ambit of the Payment of
Gratuity Act, 1972 (hereinafter referred to as “the Gratuity Act”). On
this basis, learned counsel submits that such Societies cannot be
compelled to pay retiral benefits under the 1997 Service Rules or
gratuity under the Gratuity Act.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
18.
In rebuttal, learned counsel for the petitioner(s)-employees
and the respondent–State submit that the vires of Rule 28 of the 1963
Rules as well as the 1997 Service Rules have already been examined in
the judgment rendered by the Division Bench of this Court in Mohie
Janta Coop. Agri. Service Society Ltd., Mohie vs. State of Punjab,
2011(3) SCT 157. It is submitted that since the Division Bench has
upheld the validity of these provisions, the 1997 Service Rules remain
legally enforceable with respect to the employees of Co-operative
Societies in Punjab.
OBSERVATION & ANALYSIS
19.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and after
perusing the record with their able assistance, it appears that the
following seminal issue has arisen for consideration of this Court:Whether the 1997 Service Rules, framed by the Registrar,
Co-operative Societies under Rule 28 of the 1963 Rules,
are valid and statutory in nature, thereby creating a vested
and enforceable right in the employees to claim retiral
benefits from their respective Societies?
20.
This Court, vide order dated 21.01.2026 in CWP No.1422 of
2026, had passed the following order:
“2.
Learned counsel for the petitioner inter alia
contends that, in the year 1997, the Registrar Cooperative
Societies, framed Punjab State Cooperative Agricultural
Service Society Service Rules, 1997 (1997 Rules) and
provided that employees of agricultural cooperative
societies were to be treated at par with government
employees, conferring upon them the entitlement to
gratuity and other retirement benefits. As such the
respondent society is bound to pay the retiral dues of the
petitioner.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
3.
It appears that the duties of the petitioners
merely involved distribution of seeds, pesticides, and
fertilisers to farmers, performing services which are
neither perennial nor comparable to those rendered by
employees in government departments. Most of these
societies operate on a modest scale and may lack the
requisite financial resilience to discharge the accumulated
burden of gratuity, leave encashment, and other retirement
dues. This court is flooded with such petitions wherein such
societies due to financial constraints, are not able to
discharge its liability to pay retiral dues of its employees,
imposed upon the registrar through 1997 rules. Moreover
these societies do not receive any financial aid from the
government of Punjab and their earnings are generated
from sale of fertilizers and other farming commodities on a
commission basis of 1-2%, received from IFFCO,
MARKFED, etc. The scheme of the Punjab Cooperative
Societies Act, 1961 reveals that these societies are
autonomous bodies established with the aim to earn profit
and distribute it amongst its members.
4.
This Court is unable to comprehend whether,
prior to framing the 1997 Rules and extending the
entitlement of salary, gratuity, and other benefits to
employees at par with Government employees, the
financial capacity of each individual society was duly
considered.
5.
On the one hand, the Government of Punjab is
not paying even minimum wages to its own employees, and
essential services in the municipalities, health, and
education departments are being carried out through
contractual or ad hoc employees. The State's employment
practices indicate a consistent and systemic pattern of
extracting perennial work on an ad hoc or contractual
basis for prolonged periods. On the other hand, the
societies are saddled and burdened with obligation of
paying its employees, salaries and retiral benefits at par
with Government employees. Further, the Payment of
Gratuity Act, 1972 provides a minimum threshold of ten
employees for its applicability whereas the majority of
these societies have less than ten employees.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
6.
In view of the above, the Principal Secretary,
Department of Cooperation, Govt. of Punjab is directed to
deliberate on this issue and file his affidavit stating:a. On what rational basis were the employees of the
societies declared at par with government
employees? Whether the government is ready to
provide budgetary allocation to these
b. societies who are unable to discharge their
liabilities to pay retiral benefits to these employees?
c. Whether the rules imposed by the Registrar,
through the Punjab State Cooperative Agricultural
Service Society Service Rules, 1997 were notified in
the official gazette and whether the aforesaid rules
were placed before the state legislature?
d. Provide the notification issued in the official
gazette for the implementation of the Punjab
Cooperative Societies Rules, 1963 and Punjab State
Cooperative Agricultural Service Society Service
Rules, 1997.
e. Complete details of the total capital of the
respondent society along with its balance sheets
reflecting its profit or loss for the last five financial
years and the number of employees working in it.”
21.
In compliance with the order dated 21.01.2026 passed in
CWP No.1422 of 2026, a detailed affidavit dated 18.02.2026 of Ajit
Balaji Joshi, IAS, Administrative Secretary, Department of Cooperation, Punjab, was filed on behalf of respondent No.1. The contents
of the said affidavit have been crystallized in the following manner:
a. The 1963 Rules have been framed by the State
Government while exercising its powers under Section
85(3) of the 1961 Act and therefore, are a delegated
legislation. In compliance with Section 85(3) of the 1961
Act, the 1963 Rules were duly notified in the Official
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
Gazette (Annexure R-1) and laid before the Punjab State
Legislature (Annexure R-2).
b. The Registrar, Co-operative Societies, exercising its powers
under Rule 28 of the 1963 Rules, has framed the 1997
Service Rules to determine the qualifications, recruitment
process, conditions of service subject to which persons may
be employed by Co-operative Societies. The power under
Rule 28 of the 1963 Rules is an administrative-regulatory
power delegated to the Registrar to ensure uniformity and
discipline in service conditions across Co-operative
Societies.
c. The 1997 Service Rules were neither framed by the State
Government in exercise of powers under Section 85 of the
1961 Act, nor were they issued as statutory Rules under
the said Act. Rather, the 1997 Service Rules are regulatory
service-condition instruments framed by the Registrar, Cooperative Societies in exercise of the authority conferred
upon it under Rule 28 of the 1963 Service Rules. It was
further stated that the 1997 Service Rules do not bear the
character of delegated legislation under Section 85 of the
1961 Act and therefore, were not required to be laid before
the State Legislature. The requirement of laying of Rules
before the State Legislature under Section 85(3) of the
1961 Act is statutorily confined only to Rules framed by
the State Government under Section 85 of the 1961 Act.
d. The adoption of Government pay scales and service benefits
as a benchmark under the 1997 Service Rules was merely a
mechanism for standardization and uniformity across
various Co-operative Societies. Such adoption was made
only for the limited purpose of maintaining parity in scales
and benefits as a matter of policy guidance and did not, in
any manner:
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
i. Create
an
employer-employee
relationship
between the State Government and the employees of
the Co-operative Societies;
ii. Convert the employees of Co-operative Societies
into Government servants;
iii. Transfer or fasten any financial liability upon the
State exchequer for their salary or retiral benefits.
e. The Co-operative Societies registered under the 1961 Act
are independent legal entities with a distinct juristic
personality. The Society recruits its own employees who
are remunerated from its funds and are subject to the
administrative and disciplinary control of the Society itself.
Thus, the State Government neither acts as the appointing
authority nor as the salary-disbursing authority in respect of
such employees.
f. Neither the 1961 Act nor the 1963 Rules contain any
provision imposing financial liability upon the State
Government to discharge salary or retiral dues of
employees of such Societies. Therefore, in the absence of
any statutory mandate, the State Government is not in a
position to provide budgetary allocation for payment of
retiral benefits of employees of individual Co-operative
Societies. Any direction by this Court requiring the State
Government to assume the liabilities of such Societies
would amount to a judicially created financial obligation,
not contemplated by the statutory scheme of the 1961 Act.
g. With regards to the financial status of the respondent no.5Society in CWP No.1422 of 2026, the audited balance
sheets and financial statements for the last five financial
years were annexed as Annexure R-3. As per the aforesaid
records, the respondent no.5-Society operates primarily on
commission income (approximately 1-2%) from sale of
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
fertilizers and agricultural inputs and does not receive any
direct financial grants from the State Government.
Furthermore,
respondent
no.5-Society
has
incurred
financial losses in the recent years and presently, has only
one employee on its rolls.
● Nature and Validity of the 1997 Service Rules
22.
Admittedly, the 1961 Act is the principal legislation
governing the registration, regulation, and functioning of Co-operative
Societies in the State of Punjab. Section 85 of the 1961 Act delegates
the power to frame rules for carrying out the objectives of the Act to the
State Government. In exercise of the said delegated statutory power, the
State Government framed the 1963 Rules, which were duly notified in
the Official Gazette (Annexure R-1 in CWP No.1422 of 2026) and laid
before the Punjab State Legislature (Annexure R-2) in compliance with
Section 85(3). Relevant portion of Section 85 is reproduced hereunder:
“85. Rules
(1) The Government may, for any co-operative society or
class of such societies, make rules to carry out the
purposes of this Act.
(2) In particular, and without prejudice to the generality of
the foregoing power, such rules may provide for all or any
of the following matters, namely xx
xx
xx
(xxxviii) qualifications for members of the committee and
employees of a society or class of societies and the
conditions of service subject to which persons may be
employed by societies;
xx
xx
xx
(3) Every rule made under this section shall be laid as soon
as may be after it is made before the State Legislature
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
while it is in session for a total period of ten days which
may be comprised in one session or in two successive
sessions, and if before the expiry of the session in which it
is laid or the session immediately following [the
Legislature] agree in making any modification in the rule
or [the Legislature] agree that the rule should not be made,
the rule shall thereafter have effect only in such modified
form or be of no effect, as the case may be, so however, that
any such modification or annulment shall be without
prejudice to the validity of anything previously done under
that rule.”
(Emphasis added)
23.
As previously noted, the 1961 Act specifically delegates the
power to frame Service Rules to the State Government. Crucially, the
said Act contains no provision authorizing the State Government to
further delegate this power. Notwithstanding this absence of authority,
the State Government, under Rule 28 of the 1963 Rules, has delegated
its power under Section 85(2)(xxxviii) to the Registrar, Co-operative
Societies. Consequently, acting as a sub-delegatee, the Registrar has
framed the 1997 Service Rules to govern the qualifications, recruitment
processes, and service conditions for employees of Co-operative
Societies in the State of Punjab. Rule 28 of the 1963 Rules is
reproduced below for ready reference:
“28. Qualifications and conditions of service of
employees [Section 85 (xxxviii)] (1) The qualifications and conditions of service subject to
which any person may be employed by a cooperative
society or a class of co-operative societies shall be such as
may be determined by the Registrar from time to time.
(2) Where the registrar is of the opinion that it is necessary
or expedient so to do, he may by order, for reasons to be
recorded in writing relax the provisions of this rule with
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
respect to any co- operative society or class of co-operative
societies to such extent as he may consider proper.”
(Emphasis added)
24.
The Administrative Secretary, Department of Co-operation,
Punjab, in his affidavit (supra), has categorically admitted that the 1997
Service Rules were neither framed by the State Government in the
exercise of its powers under Section 85 of the 1961 Act, nor were they
issued as statutory rules thereunder. It was further deposed that the
1997 Service Rules do not possess the character of delegated legislation
in terms of Section 85 of the 1961 Act, and consequently, there was no
requirement for them to be laid before the State Legislature. It is settled
law that where a statute confers a power on a named authority, it is
prima facie intended to be exercised only by that authority to the
exclusion of all others, unless the parent statute permits further
delegation expressly or by necessary implication. Reliance in this regard
can be placed on the judgment rendered by a three-Judge Bench of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in M/s Sahni Silk Mills (P) Ltd. vs. Employees
State Insurance Corp., 1994(4) SCT 277, wherein, speaking through
Justice N.P. Singh, the following was observed:
“5. The courts are normally rigorous in requiring the
power to be exercised by the persons or the bodies
authorised by the statutes. It is essential that the delegated
power should be exercised by the authority upon whom it
is conferred and by no one else. At the same time, in the
present administrative set-up extreme judicial aversion to
delegation cannot be carried to an extreme. A public
authority is at liberty to employ agents to exercise its
powers. That is why in many statutes, delegation is
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
authorised either expressly or impliedly. Due to the
enormous rise in the nature of the activities to be handled
by statutory authorities, the maxim delegatus non potest
delegare is not being applied specially when there is
question of exercise of administrative discretionary power.
6. By now it is almost settled that the legislature can
permit any statutory authority to delegate its power to an
other authority, of course, after the policy has been
indicated in the statute itself within the framework of
which such delegates is to exercise the power. The real
problem or the controversy arises when there is subdelegation. It is said that when Parliament has
specifically appointed authority to discharge a function, it
cannot be readily presumed that it had intended that its
delegate should be free to empower another person or
body to act in its place. In Barium Chemicals Ltd. v.
Company Law Board, AIR 1967 Supreme Court 295, this
Court said in respect of sub-delegation.
"Bearing in mind that the maxim delegatus non
potest delegare sets out what is merely a rule of
construction, sub-delegation can be sustained if
permitted by express provision or by necessary
implication."
7. Again in Mangulal Chunilal v. Manilal Maganlal, AIR
1968 Supreme Court 822, while considering the scope of
section 481 (1)(a) of the Bombay Provincial Municipal
Corporation Act (59 of 1949) this Court said that
Commissioner of the Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation
had delegated his power and function under the aforesaid
Section to a Municipal Officer to launch proceedings
against a person charged with offences under the Act or
the rules and that officer to whom such functions were
delegated could not further delegate the same to another.
8. In Halsbury's Laws of England, 4th edition, volume-I in
respect of sub- delegation of powers it has been said :
"In accordance with the maxim delegates non potest
delegare, a statutory power must be exercised only
by the body or officer in whom it has been confided.
(H. Lavender & Sons Ltd. v. Minister of Housing
and Local Government, 1970(3) All England
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
Reporter 871, unless sub-delegation of the power is
authorised by express words necessary implication
(Customs and Excise Comrs. v. Cure and Deelay
Ltd., 1962 (1) OQ 340, 1961(3) All England
Reporter 641 and Mungoni v. A.S.G. of Northern
Rhodesia, 1960(1) All England Reporter 446 PC
etc.). There is a strong presumption against
construing a grant of legislative, judicial or
disciplinary power as impliedly authorising subdelegation; and the same may be said of any power
to the exercise of which the designated body should
address its own mind. Allam & Co. v. Europa Poster
Service Ltd., 1968(1) All England Reporter 626...."
xx
xx
xx
10. So far as the present Section 94A is concerned, it says
that the Corporation subject to any regulation made by the
Corporation in that behalf, may direct that particular or
any of the powers and functions which may be exercised or
performed by the Corporation may, in relation to such
matters and subject to such conditions, if any, as may be
specified 'be also exercisable by any officer or authority
subordinate to the Corporation.' Section 94A does not
specifically provide that any officer or authority
subordinate to the Corporation to whom the power has
been delegated by the Corporation, may in his turn
authorise any other officer to exercise or perform that
power or function. But by the resolution dated 28.2.1976
the Corporation has not only delegated, its power under
Section 85B (i) of the Act to the Director General, but has
also empowered the Director General to authorise any
other officer to exercise the said power. Unless it is held
that Section 94A of the Act, enables the Corporation to
delegate its powers and functions to any officer or
authority subordinate to the Corporation and he in his
turn can sub-delegate the exercise of the said power to
any other officer, the last part of the resolution dated
28.2.1976 cannot be held to be within the framework of
Section 94A. According to us, the Parliament while
introducing Section 94A in the Act, only conceived direct
delegation by the Corporation to different officers or
authorities, subordinate to the Corporation, and there is
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
no scope for such delegate to sub-delegate that power, by
authorising any other officer to exercise or perform the
power so delegated.”
(Emphasis added)
25.
Significantly, the vires of Rule 28 of the 1963 Rules and the
1997 Service Rules were previously challenged before a Division Bench
of this Court in Mohie Janta Coop. Agri. Service Society Ltd., (supra)
on two primary grounds: firstly, it was argued that the 1961 Act lacks
any specific provision authorizing the State Government to delegate its
rule-making power under Section 85 to the Registrar and therefore, the
1997 Service Rules suffer from excessive delegation; secondly, it was
contended that even assuming a valid delegation of power, the 1997
Service Rules are ultra vires as the Registrar failed to comply with the
mandatory procedure under Section 85(3), which requires the Rules to
be laid before the State Legislature.
26.
Although the Division Bench in Mohie Janta Coop. Agri.
Service Society Ltd. (supra) ultimately upheld the validity of the
aforementioned provisions and thus, the 1997 Service Rules, however, it
did not record any findings regarding the issue of excessive delegation
in framing of the 1997 Service Rules. The relevant extracts of the
judgment are reproduced below:
“3. The learned counsel for the petitioner has challenged
the vires of the Rule 28 of 1963 Rules on the ground that
as per sub-section (1) and (2) of Section 85 of the Punjab
Cooperative Societies Act, 1961, the State Government
could frame the rules with regard to the qualifications
and conditions of service and there is no specific power to
delegate its power to Registrar for the said purpose and
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
assuming for the sake of arguments if the Government
validly delegated the powers to the Registrar to frame the
Rules for laying down the qualifications and conditions
of the service of the employee of the Cooperative Society
then the rules are ultra vires for the reason that proper
procedure as provided under Section 85(3) of the Act has
not been followed by the Registrar, Cooperative Societies,
Punjab, Chandigarh for laying down these rules before
the State Legislature within 10 days of their formulation
but the needful was not done...
xx
xx
xx
5. With regard to the validity of the Rule 28 in context to
the provisions of Section 85 (XXXVIII) of the Act being
without jurisdiction, it was submitted that vide notification
No. GSR 79/P.A. 25/61/S 85/Ad. (5)/69 dated 14.10.1969,
the Governor of Punjab exercising its powers conferred
under Section 85 of the Punjab Cooperative Societies Act
1961 and rule 28 of Rules 1963, under which power to
frame the service rules of the employees of the society has
been conferred upon the Registrar, framed the rules. It was
also added that. The Division Bench of this Court in case
Bakshish Singh and others v. The Registrar, Co-operative
Societies Punjab, Chandigarh and others, 1985 R.R.R.
277 : AIR 1984 Punjab and Haryana 264, had upheld the
validity of Section 28 of the Rules and it was also observed
that non laying of rule before the legislature would not
invalidate such delegated legislation...
xx
xx
xx
7. As regards delegation of powers, Section 85 (1) and
(xxxviii) of the Act reads as under :xx
xx
xx
While exercising the powers under the aforesaid clause,
Rule 28 of 1963 Rules, Government conferred power upon
the Registrar to frame rules with regard to qualifications
and conditions of service of its employees. Rule 28 of the
1963 Rules reads as under :xx
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
xx
xx
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
8. The other question raised before us is that the laying of
the Rules before the Legislature for their proper
enforcement was mandatory, but this argument cannot hold
water, for the reason that no such material has been
brought on record that these rules were not laid before the
Legislature. In any case, no such Rule has been made
pointing towards the consequences of non-laying of the
Rules before the Legislature. Similar question arose before
the Full Bench of this High Court in case of M/s. Megha
Singh and Co. and others v. The State of Punjab and
others, AIR 1977 Punjab & Haryana 297, wherein, it was
observed as under :xx
xx
xx
9. In the instant case also, petitioner has not placed on
record any data to show that these rules were not placed
before the legislature. As such, while applying the obiter
dicta from the aforesaid judgment, it could safely be
determined that no fault could be found with the rules
when the same were circulated and adopted by the
societies through out the State of Punjab.”
(Emphasis added)
27.
Nonetheless, the question of excessive delegation under the
1963 Rules came up again before another Division Bench of this Court
in Harpreet Singh and another vs. State of Punjab and others, 2011
SCC OnLine P&H 11491. In this case, the petitioners-employees of a
Co-operative Marketing Society had challenged the validity of Rule
4(iv)(a) of the Punjab Co-operative Marketing-cum-Processing Service
Societies Employees Service Rules, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as “the
1996 Rules”), which imposed a restriction that total expenditure on staff
could not exceed 50% of the Society’s annual income. The 1996 Rules
were framed by the Registrar, Co-operative Societies while exercising
powers under Rule 28 of the 1963 Rules. Thus, the Division Bench was
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
called upon to answer the seminal legal question - whether the State
Government, having been delegated the power to frame rules under
Section 85 of the 1961 Act, could further sub-delegate that authority to
the Registrar through Rule 28 of the 1963 Rules.
28.
Upon examining the statutory framework, the Division
Bench in Harpreet Singh (supra) observed that Section 85(2)(xxxviii)
of the 1961 Act specifically delegates the power to prescribe
qualifications and service conditions to the State Government. The
Court noted that the parent Act does not contemplate any delegation of
power beyond the State Government. Since sub-delegation of legislative
power is invalid unless expressly or by necessary implication authorized
by the parent statute, the State Government could not have subdelegated its rule-making power to the Registrar. Consequently, it was
concluded that the 1996 Rules were unsustainable in the eyes of law as
they suffered from the vice of excessive delegation. The relevant
extracts of the judgment are reproduced hereunder:
“(8) It is, thus, evident that the Act has delegated the
power of framing the rules to the State Government with
regard to determining the conditions under which profit
may be distributed to a member of a cooperative society
with un-limited liability and the maximum rate of
dividend which may be paid by the co-operative society.
Likewise, under clause (xxxviii), the rules prescribing the
qualifications for employees of a society or a class of
societies and conditions of service, subject to which such
persons may be employed by such societies, can be
framed by the Government. The Act does not contemplate
delegation of power beyond the State Government. It was
in pursuance of the aforesaid power given under Section
85(2) of the Act that the State Government has framed the
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
1963 Rules. A perusal of Rule 28 of the 1963 Rules shows
that it has been framed in pursuance to the power
conferred under Section 85(2)(xxxviii) of the Act. Rule 28
of the 1963 Rules reads as under:—
xx
xx
xx
(9) It is in pursuance of sub-delegation given to the
Registrar by Rule 28 of the 1963 Rules that the impugned
1996 Rules/Instructions in respect of the employees
working in the respondent Societies have been framed.
Firstly, most of the employees are working prior to 1996
and have been paid regular scales of pay. Secondly, the
provisions of Section 85(2)(xxxviii) of the Act has
delegated the power of framing the rules concerning
conditions of service to the State Government, which has
been further sub-delegated by Rule 28 of the 1963 Rules
to the Registrar. The provisions of sub-section (2) of
Section 85 of the Act would show that the rules framed by
the State Government are to be placed before the
Assembly. The instructions issued by the Registrar have
not been placed before the Assembly at all.
(10) Now the question that arises for consideration is
whether a delegatee of power could further delegate. The
aforesaid question came up for consideration before
Hon'ble the Supreme Court in the case of Life Insurance
Corporation of India v. Retired L.I.C. Officers
Association. It has been held that a delegatee cannot act
outside the scope of his power. There the power to
regulate the pay and allowances was delegated. But the
Chairman started regulating the gratuity of employees.
Hon'ble the Supreme Court held that a sub-delegate
cannot exercise any power which is not meant to be
conferred upon him by reason of statutory provisions.
Similar view has been expressed in the case of The Quarry
Owners Association v. State of Bihar, and Mahe Beach
Trading Company v. Union Territory of Pondicherry.
(11) The Rule making authority cannot delegate its power
unless the power of delegation emerges from the
provisions of the Act itself. Such authorisation may be
either express or by necessary intendment. If the
authority further delegates its lawmaking power to some
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
other authority and retains a general control of a
substantial nature over it, there is no delegation as to
attract the doctrine of ‘delegatus non potest delegare’,
which indicates that sub-delegation of power is normally
not allowable though the legislature can always provide
for it. It is well settled that sub-delegation is invalid
unless authorised by the parent Act. In that regard a
classical illustration is available in the cases of A.K. Roy v.
State of Punjab. In this case under the Prevention of Food
Adulteration Act, 1954, the power to initiate prosecution
for offences under Section 20(i) had been conferred on the
State Government. The said Act did not authorise subdelegation of power to Food Inspector. However, under
Rule 3 of the Prevention of Food Adulteration (Punjab)
Rules, 1958, the power to initiate prosecution was
delegated to the Food Inspector. Accordingly, Hon'ble the
Supreme Court held that sub-delegation was ultra vires the
parent Act.
(12) In the present case, Section 85(2)(xxxviii) of the Act
delegate the State Government the power of framing rules
which may provide for the qualifications for employees of
society or class of societies and the conditions of service
to which persons may be employed by the society.
However, by Rule 28 of the 1963 Rules, the power to
determine qualifications and conditions of service of such
employees have been left to the Registrar, who may
determine the same from time to time. Once the State
Legislature has delegated the power to the State
Government then it was impermissible for the State to
sub-delegate its power to the Registrar. Even on that score
the so called 1996 Rules would not be sustainable in the
eyes of law.
xx
xx
xx
(18) For the reasons stated above, these petitions are
allowed. The impugned 1996 Rules are held to be
inapplicable as they suffer from excessive delegation…”
(Emphasis added)
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
29.
In view of the foregoing discussion and adverting to the
facts of the present case, this Court is of the considered opinion that the
State Government could not have delegated its rule-making power
under Section 85(2)(xxxviii) of the 1961 Act to the Registrar, Cooperative Societies. Such sub-delegation is neither expressly authorized
nor permitted by necessary implication under the parent statute. Thus,
this Court holds that the 1997 Service Rules are ultra vires the 1961
Act. Accordingly, the claim of the petitioners for leave encashment,
gratuity, and other retiral benefits under the said Rules is rendered nonmaintainable.
30.
It is trite law that Rules or Regulations constituting
subordinate legislation are bound to be ignored by the Courts if they are
found to be ultra vires. When the enforcement of such provisions is at
issue, the Court is not precluded from declining to enforce them simply
because a specific prayer to strike them down or declare them invalid
was not made. Reliance in this regard can be placed on the judgment
rendered by a two-Judge Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Shree
Bhagwati Steel Rolling Mills (M/s.) v. Commissioner of Central
Excise, 2016(3) SCC 643 wherein, speaking through Justice R.F.
Nariman, the following was observed:
“28. Shri Aggarwal in order to buttress his submission that
he ought to be allowed to raise a pure question of law
going to the very jurisdiction to levy interest cited before us
the judgment in Bhartidasan University and Anr. v. AllIndia Council for Technical Education, 2001(4) S.C.T
704 : 2001 (8) SCC 676, and in particular paragraph 14
thereof which reads as follow:
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
The fact that the Regulations may have the force of
law or when made have to be laid down before the
legislature concerned do not confer any more
sanctity or immunity as though they are statutory
provisions themselves. Consequently, when the
power to make Regulations are confined to certain
limits and made to flow in a well defined canal
within stipulated banks, those actually made or
shown and found to be not made within its confines
but outside them, the Courts are bound to ignore
them when the question of their enforcement arise
and the mere fact that there was no specific relief
sought for to strike down or declare them ultra
vires, particularly when the party in sufferance is a
Respondent to the lis or proceedings cannot confer
any further sanctity or authority and validity which
it is shown and found to obviously and patently
lack. It would, therefore, be a myth to state that
Regulations made Under Section 23 of the Act have
"Constitutional" and legal status, even unmindful of
the fact that anyone or more of them are found to be
not consistent with specific provisions of the Act
itself. Thus, the Regulations in question, which the
AICTE could not have made so as to bind
universities/UGC within the confines of the powers
conferred upon it, cannot be enforced against or
bind an University in the matter of any necessity to
seek prior approval to commence a new department
or course and programme in technical education in
any university or any of its departments and
constituent institutions.
29. It would be seen that Shri Aggarwal is on firm ground
because this Court has specifically stated that rules or
Regulations which are in the nature of subordinate
legislation which are ultra vires are bound to be ignored
by the courts when the question of their enforcement
arises and the mere fact that there is no specific relief
sought for to strike down or declare them ultra vires
would not stand in the court's way of not enforcing them.
We also feel that since this is a question of the very
jurisdiction to levy interest and is otherwise covered by a
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
Constitution Bench decision of this Court, it would be a
travesty of justice if we would not to allow Shri Aggarwal
to make this submission.”
(Emphasis added)
31.
As a matter of fact, the Administrative Secretary,
Department of Co-operation, Punjab, in his affidavit (supra), has
categorically stated that Co-operative Societies registered under the
1961 Act are autonomous bodies, comprising of individuals who have
voluntarily entered into an association for mutual economic benefit.
These entities are managed by elected committees and are governed by
their respective bye-laws, within the broader statutory framework. Thus,
this Court holds that such Co-operative Societies are at liberty to frame
their own Service Rules and determine the pay scales and emoluments
of their employees, keeping in view their financial health and
operational viability.
32.
Furthermore, regarding the applicability of the Gratuity Act,
Section 1 thereof stipulates that the Act applies to every shop or
establishment wherein ten or more persons are employed, or were
employed, on any day of the preceding twelve months. Section 1 of the
Gratuity Act is reproduced below for ready reference:
“1. Short title, extent, application and commencement.—
(1) This Act may be called the Payment of Gratuity
Act, 1972.
(2) It extends to the whole of India:
Provided that in so far as it relates to
plantations or ports, it shall not extend to the State of
Jammu and Kashmir.
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
(3) It shall apply to—
(a) every factory, mine, oilfield, plantation,
port and railway company;
(b) every shop or establishment within the
meaning of any law for the time being in
force in relation to shops and establishments
in a State, in which ten or more persons are
employed, or were employed, on any day of
the preceding twelve months;
(c) such other establishments or class of
establishments, in which ten or more
employees are employed, or were employed,
on any day of the preceding twelve months,
as the Central Government may, by
notification, specify in this behalf.
(3A) A shop or establishment to which this Act has
become applicable shall continue to be governed by
this Act notwithstanding that the number of
persons employed therein at any time after it has
become so applicable falls below ten.
(4) It shall come into force on such date as the
Central Government may, by notification, appoint.”
(Emphasis added)
33.
Learned counsel for the petitioner(s)-employees and the
respondent-State were unable to controvert the fact that a majority of
Co-operative Societies in the State of Punjab employ less than ten
persons. Furthermore, learned counsel failed to demonstrate the
existence of any of the aforementioned circumstances that would bring
the specific Co-operative Societies involved in the present writ
petitions, within the ambit of the Gratuity Act. Moreover, the
Administrative Secretary, in his affidavit (supra), has specifically
brought to the notice of this Court that the respondent-Society in CWP
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
No.1422 of 2026 currently has only a single employee on its rolls.
Consequently, this Court is of the considered view that the provisions of
the Gratuity Act are also inapplicable to the present cases.
● Precarious Financial Condition of Co-operative Societies in Punjab
34.
Admittedly, Co-operative Societies registered under the
1961 Act are independent legal entities, possessing a distinct juristic
personality. The employees of a Co-operative Society are directly
appointed by the concerned Society itself. The Society pays their
remunerations from its own funds and exercises administrative and
disciplinary control over them. All operational expenses, including
salaries, are borne by the societies from their internal resources rather
than the State exchequer. It is worth noting that, admittedly, these
Societies do not receive any direct grant, aid, or financial assistance
from the State Government.
35.
The diminishing financial health of these Co-operative
Societies is no longer a matter of conjecture but a documented fiscal
reality. The Administrative Secretary in his affidavit (supra) has
highlighted that the respondent-Society in CWP No.1422 of 2026
operates primarily on a meager commission income of approximately 12%, derived from the sale of fertilizers and agricultural inputs. This
Society has incurred significant financial losses in recent years and, as
mentioned above, is currently operating with only a single employee.
Similarly, a perusal of the record in CWP No.6003 of 2026 reveals a
systemic crisis as the respondent-Society therein has suffered an
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
accumulated loss of ₹75,81,264/- as of 31.03.2025 (Annexure P-3). The
financial distress is so acute that employees’ salaries have remained
unpaid for 40 months, with outstanding liabilities towards staff pay
amounting to over ₹60 lakhs as on 31.03.2025.
36.
Pertinently, the financial distress of these Societies is
compounded by the lack of any financial aid from the State Government
and an operating model that merely relies on a negligible 1–2%
commission. To saddle such fragile, autonomous entities with the
staggering financial liability of retiral benefits at par with the State
Government, without any corresponding budgetary support, is a recipe
for institutional insolvency. Furthermore, as observed by this Court in
its order dated 21.01.2026, the duties of the petitioner-employees in
these Societies merely involve distribution of seeds, pesticides, and
fertilisers to farmers. Thus, they are performing services which are
neither perennial nor comparable to those rendered by regular
employees in government departments.
37.
Moreover, through the implementation of the 1997 Service
Rules, the Registrar has effectively assumed the role of a “superemployer,”
mandating
that
Co-operative
Societies,
which
are
independent legal entities with a distinct juristic personality, provide
retiral benefits to their employees at par with the employees of the
Government of Punjab. This mandate has been imposed despite the fact
that the State Government neither acts as the appointing authority nor as
the salary-disbursing agency for employees of these Co-operative
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
Societies. Crucially, while the Registrar seeks to enforce these heavy
financial obligations, the State Government has categorically deposed
thatit bears no financial liability towards employees of Co-operative
Societies and that it is not in a position to provide any budgetary
allocation or financial assistance to individual Societies to discharge
retiral liabilities of its employees. This creates a situation where
Societies are saddled with massive retiral liabilities while the State
exchequer remains entirely insulated from any corresponding financial
obligation.
38.
Therefore, this Court finds that the attempt to mandate
payment of retiral benefits to employees of Co-operative Societies in the
State of Punjab at par with State Government employees, particularly
through the ultra vires 1997 Service Rules, is both legally unsustainable
and practically unworkable.
CONCLUSION
39.
In view of the above discussions, this Court is of the
considered opinion that the 1997 Service Rules, framed by the
Registrar, Co-operative Societies under Rule 28 of the 1963 Rules, are
ultra vires the 1961 Act. Thus, the petitioner(s)-employees do not
possess any vested or enforceable right to claim retiral benefits from
their respective employer-Societies on the strength of the 1997 Service
Rules. Further, once the 1997 Service Rules are held to be
unenforceable and are categorically admitted to be non-statutory in
nature, a writ petition seeking their enforcement would not be
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
CWP-1422-2026 and connected cases
considered maintainable. Accordingly, CWP No.1422 of 2026, CWP
No.6003 of 2026 and CWP No.1443 of 2026 are hereby disposed of as
being non-maintainable.
40.
Furthermore, CWP No.5392 of 2026 is allowed. The Show
Cause Notice dated 24.12.2025 (Annexure P-7), issued by the office of
respondent No. 5-Assistant Registrar therein, is hereby quashed and set
aside. Respondents No.1 to 5 are directed not to compel the petitionerSociety to release the retiral benefits of respondent No.6 in terms of the
1997 Service Rules.
41.
Moreover, it is clarified that no recovery shall be effected
from any retired employee on the basis of this judgment in respect of
retiral benefits already disbursed.
42.
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall also stand
disposed of.
43.
A photocopy of this order be placed on the file of other
connected cases.
(HARPREET SINGH BRAR)
JUDGE
05.03.2026
yakub
MOHD YAKUB
2026.03.20 11:37
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab & Haryana High Court,
Chandigarh.
Whether speaking/reasoned:
Yes/No
Whether reportable:
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review