Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:556
Serial No. 03
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
AB No. 9 of 2024
Date of Decision: 19.06.2024
Shri. Samarjit Mohanty
S/o Sh. Rabi Mohanty,
R/o Near Town Hall, Spiti, Jagatsinghpura,
Odisha-754103
………Petitioner
versus
1. State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Represented by its Commissioner and
Secretary Home Police Department
2. The Superintendent of Police
East Khasi Hills, Meghalaya
3. The Investigating Officer, P.S.:
Sadar, Shillong
4. The Director, Distribution
Meghalaya Power Distribution
Corporation Limited
…..….Respondent
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S. Chanda, Adv.
Mr. R. Raj Jain, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Ms. T. Yangi. B, AAG with
Mr. J.N. Rynjah, GA (For R 1-3)
Mr. A.S. Pandey, Adv. (For R 4)
2024:MLHC:556
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
ORDER (ORAL)
1.
Heard Mr. K. Paul, learned Sr. counsel appearing for the petitioner
who has submitted that an FIR dated 26.05.2023 was lodged before the
Officer-in-Charge, Sadar Police Station, Shillong by the Director,
(Distribution) Meghalaya Power Distribution Corporation Limited
(MePDCL), Shillong on the allegation that M/s Feedback Energy
Distribution Company Ltd. (FEDCO) had defrauded the corporation by
withholding the money owed to the Corporation amounting to ₹
15,000,000/- (rupees fifteen crore) only which money relates to the
collection of bills etc. entrusted to M/s FEDCO for four areas that is,
Mawkyrwat, Mawsynram, Nagalbibra and Phulbari Revenue Sections for
which the proceeds is required to be handed over to the MePDCL and was
not done so. Hence the FIR.
2.
The FIR was registered as Sadar P.S. Case No. 130(05) of 2023
under Section 409 IPC and apparently investigation was launched.
3.
It is the submission of the learned Sr. counsel that unbeknownst to
the petitioner, the Investigating Officer (I/O) has filed an application under
Section 73 Cr.P.C before the Court of the learned Assistant to the Deputy
Commissioner (Judicial), Shillong with a prayer for issuance of a nonbailable warrant of arrest against the petitioner.
2024:MLHC:556
4.
It has also subsequently come to the knowledge of the petitioner
that the I/O had taken steps for issuance of notice under Section 91 Cr.P.C
and also one under Section 41A Cr.P.C directed against the petitioner to
compel him to appear before the said I/O. The petitioner on coming to
know of such proceedings had issued a letter dated 30.01.2024 to the I/O
to inform him that he had not receive any notice and that copy of such
notice may be issued to him. He has also expressed his willingness to
cooperate with the investigation.
5.
The petitioner being a resident of Orissa at the relevant point of
time, as soon as he came to know of the issuance of the said non-bailable
warrant of arrest had approached the Hon’ble High Court of Orissa with
an application seeking transit anticipatory bail which was granted to him
vide order dated 25.04.2024 in ABLAPL No. 15446 of 2023, by which
order he was directed to either appear before the concerned court within
six weeks from the date of the said order or that he should move for bail
which is done so by way of this petition.
6.
The learned Sr. counsel has submitted that in a nut shell the dispute
between the parties that is, between the complainant/MePDCL and M/s
FEDCO represented by the petitioner herein who is the then CEO arose
out of a contractual agreement between the parties wherein vide a
Distribution Franchisee Agreement (DFA) dated 18.03.2019, FEDCO was
authorised to sell and supply electricity as well as to collect the bills of
such sale from four areas that is, Mawkyrwat, Mawsynram, Nagalbibra
and Phulbari Revenue Sections respectively, proceeds of which is to be
handed over to the complainant/Company.
2024:MLHC:556
7.
In the course of business, the complainant had made several
allegations against FEDCO and had also demand payment of outstanding
amount of ₹ 15.37 crores. The demand was accompanied by a Preliminary
Notice of Termination of the said DFC. FEDCO had accordingly replied
to the said notice and has also requested the complainant to withdraw the
said Preliminary Notice of Termination. While correspondences were
exchanged between the parties in respect of the said dispute or
misunderstanding, the said FIR dated 26.05.2023 was filed.
8.
It is also the submission of the learned Sr. counsel that even if there
is any dispute between the parties, the same is in the nature of a civil
dispute and no criminality can be imputed as far as the petitioner or
FEDCO is concerned. In fact, the complaint made under Section 409 IPC
has no credence as the complainant has not been able to show how an
offence under such section has been committed by the petitioner or
FEDCO. At most, it is just an issue of delay of making payment which has
accumulated to a huge sum of about ₹ 15 crores or so.
9.
At the hearing, the learned Sr. counsel has produced details of the
payment made to the complainant/Company starting from the financial
year 2019-2020 wherein a sum of ₹ 8,0992,254/- was paid. Even after the
said FIR was filed, on 02.06.2023 a sum of ₹ 1,18,36,022/- was paid for
the financial year 2023-2024 and another sum of ₹ 1,43,38,232/- was also
paid on the same day. Till 22.03.2024 a total sum of ₹ 19,36,83,409/- has
been paid. As for the month of April and May 2024, a sum of ₹
5,78,09,399/- has been paid. This will only prove that continuous
payments have been made by FEDCO.
2024:MLHC:556
10.
In view of the bona fide of the petitioner and FEDCO represented
by him, the substance of the complaint made and the intended course of
action to apprehend the petitioner will not stand the scrutiny of judicial
process. In this context, considering the fact that the threat of arrest looms
large, the petitioner may be given due protection by granting him
anticipatory bail.
11.
It is also the further submission of the learned Sr. counsel that
during the intervening period when this Court had granted interim bail to
the petitioner, he has appeared before the I/O and has also given his
statement on 11.06.2024. Therefore, there is no requirement of custodial
interrogation.
12.
It is therefore prayed that the prayer for grant of anticipatory bail
may be allowed with any conditions that this Court may deem fit to
impose.
13.
Ms. T. Yangi, B, learned AAG appearing on behalf of the State
respondent has submitted that on being directed the status report of the
case has been produced before this Court today and on perusal of the same
this Court may pass necessary orders.
14.
Mr.
A.S.
Pandey,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
respondent/MePDCL has admitted that since the filing of the FIR in May
2023 the MePDCL has received an amount of ₹ 9 crores or so, though the
exact amount received till date could not be ascertained, submits the
learned counsel. If the petitioner is cooperating with the investigation, this
respondent will have no objection to the prayer made herein.
2024:MLHC:556
15.
This Court has considered the submission made by the learned
counsels for the parties and has also perused the status report of the case
filed by the I/O. The I/O in his report has also confirmed that when
investigation began, FEDCO had remitted certain amount of money to the
complainant and to MePDCL and about ₹ 9,25,00,000/- (rupees nine
crores twenty-five lakh) only have been paid however, the I/O has also
noted that from the bank statement provided by the petitioner herein, till
May 2024 an amount of ₹ 12,53,18,554/- has been paid to MePDCL.
16.
Though this Court would not go into the merits of the allegations
made in the said FIR, suffice it to say that from the submission made by
the parties what can be understood is that there is dispute relating to
payment of dues by FEDCO represented by the petitioner herein as the
then CEO to the MePDCL which have not been cleared by FEDCO
following which the said FIR was filed.
17.
However, as far as the investigation is concerned, the assertion of
the petitioner that a substantial amount has been remitted in favour of the
MePDCL towards the demand made amounting to about 12,53,18,554/till the month of May 2024, the same also being agreed to by the
respondent/MePDCL would only prove that the dispute between the
parties is civil in nature which could have been solved amicably between
the parties. However, the criminal aspect of the case is a matter of trial.
18.
As far as the prayer for grant of anticipatory bail is concerned, this
Court under the facts and circumstances of the case and looking into the
complicity of the petitioner in the same, would agree that the petitioner
has reason to believe that he may be arrested in connection with the case
registered on the basis of the said FIR dated 26.05.2023. In the case of
2024:MLHC:556
Shri. Gurbaksh Singh Sibbia & Ors. v. State of Punjab, (1980) 2 SCC 565,
at para 35, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed as follows:
“35. Section 438(1) of the Code lays down a condition which has to
be satisfied before anticipatory bail can be granted. The applicant
must show that he has "reason to believe" that he may be arrested
for a non-bailable offence. The use of the expression "reason to
believe" shows that the belief that the applicant may be so arrested
must be founded on reasonable grounds. Mere 'fear' is not 'belief',
for which reason it is not enough for the applicant to show that he
has some sort of a vague apprehension that some one is going to
make an accusation against him, in pursuance of which he may be
arrested. The grounds on which the belief of the applicant is based
that he may be arrested for a non-bailable offence, must be capable
of being examined by the court objectively, because it is then alone
that the court can determine whether the applicant has reason to
believe that he may be so arrested. Section 438(1), therefore, cannot
be invoked on the basis of vague and general allegations, as if to
arm oneself in perpetuity against a possible arrest. Otherwise, the
number of applications for anticipatory bail will be as large as, at
any rate, the adult populace. Anticipatory bail is a device to secure
the individual's liberty; it is neither a passport to the commission of
crimes nor a shield against any and all kinds of accusations, likely
or unlikely.”
19.
It is also well settled that a competent court while dealing with a
case wherein prayer for grant of anticipatory bail is concerned certain
factors and parameters can be taken into consideration. Such factors have
also been illustrated in the case of Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State
of Maharashtra & Ors., (2011) 1 SCC 694, at para 112 wherein the
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as follows: “112. The following factors and parameters can be taken into
consideration while dealing with the anticipatory bail:
(i)
The nature and gravity of the accusation and the exact role of
the accused must be properly comprehended before arrest is
made;
2024:MLHC:556
(ii)
The antecedents of the applicant including the fact as to
whether the accused has previously undergone imprisonment
on conviction by a court in respect of any cognizable offence;
(iii) The possibility of the applicant to flee from justice;
(iv) The possibility of the accused's likelihood to repeat similar or
other offences;
(v) Where the accusations have been made only with the object
of injuring or humiliating the applicant by arresting him or
her;
(vi) Impact of grant of anticipatory bail particularly in cases of
large magnitude affecting a very large number of people;
(vii) The courts must evaluate the entire available material against
the accused very carefully. The court must also clearly
comprehend the exact role of the accused in the case. The
cases in which the accused is implicated with the help of
Sections 34 and 149 of Penal Code, 1860 the court should
consider with even greater care and caution because over
implication in the cases is a matter of common knowledge
and concern;
(viii) While considering the prayer for grant of anticipatory bail, a
balance has to be struck between two factors, namely, no
prejudice should be caused to the free, fair and full
investigation and there should be prevention of harassment,
humiliation and unjustified detention of the accused;
(ix) The court to consider reasonable apprehension of tampering
of the witness or apprehension of threat to the complainant;
(x) Frivolity in prosecution should always be considered and it is
only the element of genuineness that shall have to be
considered in the matter of grant of bail and in the event of
there being some doubt as to the genuineness of the
prosecution, in the normal course of events, the accused is
entitled to an order of bail.”
20.
Looking into the facts and circumstances of this case, this Court is
of the considered opinion that the petitioner be granted anticipatory bail.
2024:MLHC:556
21.
This petition is therefore allowed and the petitioner is directed to be
enlarged on bail, in the event of his arrest, if he is not wanted in any other
case on the following conditions: i. That he shall not abscond or tamper with the evidence and
witnesses;
ii. That he shall appear before the Investigating Officer as and
when required;
iii. That he shall not leave the jurisdiction of India without prior
permission of the court; and
iv. That he shall furnish a personal bond of ₹ 50,000/- (rupees fifty
thousand) only with two solvent sureties of like amount to the
satisfaction of the concerned I/O.
22.
The interim bail granted is hereby made absolute.
23.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
19.06.2024
TIPRILYNTI
TIPRILYNTI KHARKONGOR
2024.06.19 20:01:19
KHARKONGOR Date:
-07'00'
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review