Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
SA No. 1 of 2019
Date of Order: 30.01.2023
Smti. Salima Begum & Ors.
Vs.
Smti. Hamida Sheikh & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. A.S. Siddiqui, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. A. Kharmyndai, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. K.S. Kynjing, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. A.D. Syiem, Adv.
:
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
This Second Appeal is directed against the judgment and order
dated 10.06.2019, passed in RFA No. 1(H) of 2016, wherein, a common
judgment and decree dated 19.02.2016, passed in Title Suit No. 20(H) of
2006 and Title Suit No. 15(H) of 2007, by the learned Assistant District
Judge, has been upheld.
2.
This Court on considering the matter for admission, on the
suggestions provided by the appellant, which were objected to by the
respondents had framed the following substantial questions of law;
i)
Whether a statement made in the written statement can be
construed as evidence against the Plaintiff without any evidence
being recorded to substantiate the same?
ii)
Whether an immovable property can be transferred from one
living person to another without any registered Deed of
Conveyance as mandated under Indian Registration Act and
Transfer of Property Act?
iii)
Whether mere mutation of immovable property would confer
any title and ownership on the person in whose name the
mutation is made and that too without following the procedure
as laid down under law?
iv)
Whether a government land can be transferred without prior
sanction and following the procedure as mandated under Assam
Land and Revenue Regulation, 1889 as adopted in Meghalaya?
3.
The main dispute in this case, concerns claim of ownership over
a plot of land measuring approximately 4000 sq. ft. with a three storied
RCC building standing thereon, which stood in the name of one (L) Tahirun
Nisa, the first wife of (L) Bashiruddin Sheikh. The plaintiff No. 1, in the
title suits, is the second wife and the widow of (L) Bashiruddin Sheikh, and
plaintiffs No. 2-4, are the children of plaintiff No. 1. The defendants No. 13, are the daughters of (L) Bashiruddin Sheikh, from his first wife (L)
Tahirun Nisa, who pre-deceased him. The main plank of the claim of the
plaintiffs in T.S No. 20(H) of 2006 is that, as (L) Bashiruddin Sheikh had
inherited about 1000 sq. ft. of the said plot, and had bequeathed verbally a
1/3 share to the plaintiff No. 1, which would be approximately 333 sq. ft.,
the remaining 666 sq. ft. which he had inherited from his first wife, should
devolve upon the plaintiffs and defendants as per Mohammedan Law.
However, when the respondents/defendants filed the written statement,
disclosing that the suit property had already been mutated in their name by
the Deputy Commissioner, East Khasi Hills, and that during the lifetime of
their mother (L) Tahirun Nisa itself, the names were already entered in the
Patta(Lease document), the appellants, instituted another suit, being Title
Suit No. 15(H) of 2007, for a declaration that, the inclusion of the names
was illegal and done without due process of law. These two suits, then came
to be tried together and the learned Trial Court, by a common judgment and
decree dated 19.02.2016, came to a finding that, the appellants are not
entitled to any share of the suit property, except for the income derived from
the Jackpot business of their late father, and it was further held that, there
was no illegality in the transfer for the suit property and inclusion of the
names of the respondents in the Patta, during the lifetime of their mother.
4.
As noted earlier, the judgment and decree dated 19.02.2016,
was then upheld by the Learned First Appellate Court by the judgment
dated 10.06.2019.
5.
Mr. A. S. Siddiqui, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. A.
Kharmyndai, learned counsel for the appellants on the substantial questions
of law raised, has argued that, both the learned Courts below had erred in
law, in deciding that, (L) Tahirun Nisa had bequeathed the entire suit
property in favour of the defendants No. 1, 2 and 3, without any
documentary evidence on record. It is also contended that, both the learned
Courts below had erred in law, in ignoring the fact that, no names can be
included in a Patta/Lease as co-lessees, unless the same was on an
application based on a registered instrument of conveyance. It has also been
argued that, the learned Courts below ignored the established legal position
that a mutation does not give title, but is merely a revenue record.
6.
In support of his arguments, the learned Senior counsel has
relied upon the following judgments;
i)
Balwant Singh and Anr vs Daulat Singh (1997) 7 SCC 137
ii)
Suraj Bhan and Ors vs Financial Commissioner and Ors
(2007) 6 SCC 186
iii)
Jitendra Singh vs The State of Madhya Pradesh (2021) SCC
OnLine SC 802
iv)
State Bank of India and Ors vs S.N. Goyal (2008) 8 SCC 92
v)
Banwarilal Sharma vs Kamala Devi Ajitsaria (2022) SCC
OnLine Gau 800.
7.
On behalf of the respondents, Mr. K. S. Kynjing, learned Senior
counsel assisted by Ms. A.D. Syiem, has submitted that, there is no
substantial questions of law involved in the present Appeal. On the aspect of
the Pattas/Lease and entries of names therein, learned Senior counsel submits
that, from the facts on record, it is clearly seen that, (L) Tahirun Nisa died
on 21st January, 1998, and that on 27th May, 1998, applications had been
made by the defendants, for renewal of the Lease/Patta in respect of the suit
property, with a prayer to omit the name of their mother (L) Tahirun Nisa,
since she had expired, and in the said application, (L) Bashiruddin Sheikh,
was the witness. The learned Senior counsel then submits that this
application was allowed and necessary entries made and (L) Bashiruddin
Sheikh who died on 25.01.2005, had at no point of time before that, ever
claimed his share over the suit property. The mutation he argues, was taken
note of by the learned Courts below, who had taken full consideration of the
evidence on record that the suit property was in the name of (L) Tahirun Nisa
and the three daughters, since 22.08.1996. Learned Senior counsel has also
taken the Court to the relevant portions of the judgment wherein, this issue
has been conclusively decided.
8.
The learned Senior counsel has also highlighted the most
important issues that had been framed by the Trial Court and the findings
thereon, coupled with the evidence that had been led. On Issue No. 20, which
deals with; whether (L) Bashiruddin Sheikh had confirmed the right of
defendants as joint owners of the suit property; and whether the Lease Deed
was mutated in the name of the defendants, after observance of due
procedure, the learned Senior counsel submits that, from the evidence on
record, it is clearly reflected that, no objections were raised by (L)
Bashiruddin Sheikh, at the time when (L) Tahirun Nisa included her name
along with her daughters as joint owners. The same he submits, was
acknowledged by the plaintiffs, as also the fact that, the Lease Agreement
was based on the Sale Deed, in the name of (L) Tahirun Nisa. He submits
that, it is an admitted fact that, the suit property had been purchased by (L)
Tahirun Nisa and the said three storied RCC building was constructed
thereon. The learned Senior counsel has also placed the relevant portions of
the evidence to substantiate the case of the defendants and has submitted
that, besides the clear ownership of (L) Tahirun Nisa, over the suit property,
the Revenue Authorities that is, the Deputy Commissioner, had also issued
a Patta in her favour for the plot, which was numbered as Plot No. 118,
covered by Lease Agreement dated 01.04.1978, which had been exhibited as
Paper Mark III. It is further submitted that, it is only after the death of (L)
Tahirun Nisa and (L) Bashiruddin Sheikh, that the plaintiffs started laying
their claims over the suit property.
9.
The learned Senior counsel submits that from the evidence on
record, there is nothing to show that, (L) Bashiruddin Sheikh was entitled to
any share of the suit property, and at no point of time, were the Revenue
Authorities ever approached by the plaintiffs to make any claim for mutation
of their alleged share in the suit property. The learned Senior counsel submits
that, in view of the admitted facts and evidence on record, there has been no
error, or has settled law been ignored by the learned Courts below in passing
the impugned judgments. In support of his arguments on the scope of Second
Appeal, and on the right of step-children to inherit and on the point of
devolution and succession, the learned Senior counsel has placed the
following authorities;
i) B.R. Verma Mohammedan Law 11th Edition Page 399
ii) Mulla Principles of Mohammedan Law by Sir Dinshaw Fardunj
Mulla Page 109
iii) Mulla Mohammedan Law Digest with Basic Principles Page 558
Disqualification of Legal Heir
iv) Meghalaya Transfer of Land (Regulation) Act, 1971 Page 223
v) (2011) 12 SCC 220 Rangammal vs Kuppuswami and Another
vi) (2020) 3 SCC 786 Mangayakarasi vs M. Yuvaraj.
10.
Before embarking on discussing the matter on the substantial
questions of law that have been framed, it is to be kept in mind that, this
instant Second Appeal has been preferred against concurrent findings by
both the learned Courts below. The general settled position is that, the High
Court does not normally interfere with the concurrent findings of the Courts
below, but the same is subject to some exceptions, such as, material
evidence being ignored by the Courts below, or findings that have been
rendered on no evidence being present, or wrong inferences from proven
facts being drawn by applying the law erroneously.
11.
In the instant appeal, the issues framed revolve around the
contention that, the learned Courts below have ignored the settled position
of law in rendering the judgments. This Court therefore, is to examine
whether the same has been occasioned and the impact, if any on the
outcome of the matter, and whether though there is a clear enunciation of
law, the Lower Courts had misinterpreted or misapplied the same. Heavy
emphasis has been made on the point of transfer of an immovable property
and whether mutation would confer title and ownership on the person, on
whose name the mutation is made. The other, ancillary issues are whether
statements made in the written statements can be construed as evidence and
whether transfer of government land can be affected without prior sanction
of Revenue Authorities under the relevant Regulation.
12.
On the issues concerning the transfer and mutation of the suit
property, it is correct as put up by the appellant that mutation, that is, entries
in the government records do not confer title on a person, but are for the
purpose of records with the Revenue Authorities, especially with regard to,
payment of land revenue. It is necessary therefore, to consider the materials
and evidence on record, as to whether the claim of title of the defendants
stem from the mutation as alleged by the plaintiffs/appellants. The facts as
narrated and evidence recorded, reflect that, (L) Tahirun Nisa had
purchased the said suit property measuring about 4000 sq. ft. in 1962, and
a Lease Agreement/Patta of the said plot was granted by the Deputy
Commissioner (Revenue) in her favour on 01.04.1978. It is relevant to note
herein that, the appellant No. 1, in her cross examination in T.S. No. 20(H)
of 2006, had deposed that, the suit property was in the name of (L) Tahirun
Nisa right from the beginning and in T.S. No. 15(H) of 2007, had stated
that, it is a fact that, the suit property was purchased in the year 1962, in
the name of (L) Tahirun Nisa and she had gone further on to state that, it is
a fact that I know very well, that the name of the suit property stands in the
name of (L) Tahirun Nisa since 1962. Further, the statements of the
appellant No. 1 (PW 2) were corroborated by PW 4 and PW 1, were it was
stated that ……..it is a fact, that my father told me that the suit property
was in the name of my step-mother……. She further stated, I agree that
ownership stands in the name of the person in whose name the property is
recorded.
13.
Though mutation does not confer title, the fact that, the
appellants/plaintiffs never raised any objections to the mutation during the
life time of (L) Tahirun Nisa and (L) Bashiruddin Sheikh, is a clear pointer
that, the plaintiffs acknowledged that, (L) Tahirun Nisa was the owner of
the suit property. The Trial Court on this aspect, has also gone into the
written statement filed by the Revenue Authorities that, apart from
admitting that, (L) Tahirun Nisa was the original owner of the suit property
being Plot No. 118, had also added therein that, the said plot had been
mutated in the name of her three daughters on her application dated
22.08.1996, which on her demise was followed by an application dated
27.05.1998, by the said daughters together with their father, (L)
Bashiruddin Sheikh. It has also been noted by the Trial Court that, no
interest was created in favour of the plaintiffs, during the life time of (L)
Bashiruddin Sheikh, as per Mohammedan Law, and that no evidence had
been adduced by the plaintiffs, with regard to, non-compliance of the
provisions of the Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, 1889, at the time
of effecting mutation.
14.
From the discussions above, it can be concluded that, the
learned Courts below on the facts and materials as presented, cannot be said
to have ignored the settled position of law, as the mutation was never
objected to during the life time of (L) Bashiruddin Sheikh and no evidence
has been led in this regard, to counter this position. Further, no evidence
has been adduced by the plaintiffs/appellants to establish that, the mutation
of the suit property was not as per laid down procedure. The fact that, the
property was purchased in the name of (L) Tahirun Nisa in 1962, was itself
established and corroborated by the evidence which has been tendered by
the parties. The entire sequence of facts and evidence recorded, therefore
clearly reveal that, the title of (L) Tahirun Nisa being clear, the succession
to the same by the defendants cannot be said to be a transfer without a Deed
of Conveyance, as the same was by devolution, as per Mohammedan Law,
and further, the mutation was but, an entry of their names in the Lease
Agreement, and not that the title has been derived from the said mutation.
The other question of law, that is, whether a statement made in the
statement can be construed as evidence, in view of the discussions above,
has no relevance, as the main issue and questions have been considered by
looking into the entire materials and evidence on record.
15.
In view of the above, there arising no substantial questions of
law in this Appeal, the same is accordingly dismissed and no interference
is called for with the concurrent findings and judgments of the Lower
Courts.
16.
Lower Court records to be transmitted back immediately.
17.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
30.01.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review