Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
KHOIROM
BIPINCHAN
DRA SINGH
KHOIROM
BIPINCHANDRA SINGH
Date: 2024.02.08
17:03:39 +05'30'
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 32 OF 2023
Salauddin, aged about 40 years, S/o Shri Jalaudin,
resident of Village-Madar Nagar, The-baheri, P.OBaheri, P.S- Baheri,
District-Bareilly, Uttar Pradesh-
243201.
…. Petitioner
- Versus -
The Union of India, represented by the Narcotics
Control Bureau (NCB), through its Intelligence Officer,
Narcotics Control Bureau, Imphal, CPWD Quarters,
Changangei, Kongba Uchekon, 795008, Imphal West,
Manipur.
…. Respondent
BEFORE
HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE GOLMEI GAIPHULSHILLU
For the petitioner
:
Mr. S. Worthing, Advocate
For the respondent
:
Mr. W. Darakishore, Senior PCCG
Date of hearing
:
19.01.2024
Date of order
:
08.02.2024
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 32 OF 2023
JUDGEMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
[1]
Heard Mr. S. Worthing, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner and Mr. W. Darakishore, learned senior PCCG appearing
for the respondent at length.
[2]
The present Bail Application has been filed under section
439 CrPC, r/w Section 167(2) CrPC & Section 37 ND&PS, Act with a
prayer inter-alia for releasing the accused/petitioner on bail.
The prayer of the application reads as follows:
“(i) consider this bail application and call for record/reports
from the court below; No. 8/NCB/IMPL/2022.
(ii) enlarge the accused/petitioner on bail with conditions.
(iii) pass any other appropriate order(s) as the Hon’ble
Court deems fit and proper for the ends of justice.”
[3]
Briefs of the case:
The accused/petitioner was arrested along with other co-
accused by a team of Narcotics Control Bureau (NCB) on 02.06.2022
on the strength of a complaint information dated 01.02.2022 with an
allegation of transporting banned contraband (ganja).
The accused/petitioner is a professional driver who is
engaged in transporting items such rice, carton scraps, plastic scraps
etc. And with his meager earnings, the accused/petitioner runs a
family consisting of 6(six) minor children and a wife who is a mere
housewife. Since, his arrest on 02.06.2022 till the filling of this
instant, petition, the accused/petitioner has been languishing in jail.
On 27.02.2023, an application under Section 439 CrPC r/w Section
167(2) was filed before the Hon’ble Court of the Special Judge,
ND&PS, Court, Senapati being Cril. Misc. (B) Case No. 26 of 2023
with a prayer to enlarge the accused/petitioner on bail. However, the
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 32 OF 2023
same was rejected by the Court of Special Judge (ND&PS), Senapati
vide its order dated 17.04.2023.
During the pendency of the Bail Application filed by the
accused/petitioner, the Special Public Prosecutor, Narcotics Control
Bureau filed an application dated 25.03.2023, praying for extension
of time so as to enable the investigation of the newly arrested
accused namely Shri M. Jayanta Singh and Shri Livingstone Ngakang
and the
same was allowed by the Court of the Special Judge
(ND&PS), Senapati vide order dated 27.03.2023, thereby vitiating
the bail application dated 27.02.2023 filed by the accused/petitioner
and rejected the same vide order dated 17.04.2023. Hence, the
present petition is filed praying for enlarging the accused/petitioner
on bail with conditions as the court may deem fit and proper.
[4]
In favour of his case, the petitioner filed the following
documents:
[5]
1.
True copy of the Complaint information dated
01.06.2022. (Annexure – A/1).
2.
True copy of the Bail Application dated 27.02.2023.
(Annexure – A/2).
3.
True copy of the order dated 17.04.2023 passed by
the Special Judge (ND & PS), Senapati, Manipur.
(Annexure – A/3).
4.
True copy of the application dated 25.03.2023 filed
by the Union of India for extension of time for
investigation (Annexure – A/4).
5.
True copy of the order dated 27.03.2023 passed by
the Special Judge (ND & PS), Senapati, Manipur
allowing extension of time for investigation.
(Annexure – A/5).
The learned senior PCCG appearing for the respondent
has filed objection to the present application as thus:
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 32 OF 2023
“1.
That, at the very outset, the Respondent herein
vehemently oppose and deny all the averments and
contentions in the instant application made by the petitioner.
Save and except those which are specifically admitted herein.
Anything that has not been specifically admitted is hereby
denied. Nothing shall be deemed to be admitted for want of
specific traverse. The Respondents reserve their right to file a
detailed reply and submissions at a subsequent stage.
2.
That before submitting a para-wise comment, the
answering respondent would like to highlight the factual matrix
of the case in brief for better appreciation of the case;
I. That, acting on specific information received from a
reliable source NCB team proceeded towards Tadubi
village of Senapati District on 01.06.2022 at about 1830
hrs. Upon reaching there the team of NCB Imphal in
assistance of B Coy 33 Bn. Assam Rifles intercepted a
Tata truck bearing registration number UK05CB5915.
The driver was the only occupant of the vehicle.
Thereafter the said truck was searched at the camp of
B Coy of 33 Bn. in presence of two independent
witnesses. The truck was loaded with scrap plastic
water bottles and scrap cartons card board. Thereafter
all the scrap was removed from the truck. While
removing the scrap from the truck 19 nos. of nylon sacs
were recovered concealed in the middle of the scrap
plastic bottles and carton papers. Upon opening all the
white color nylon sacs one by one found inside greenish
black dried flowering like substance believed to be
Ganja. A small amount of the substance was taken out
from all the 19 sacs/packets and tested with the Drug
Detection Kit available with the NCB team which tested
positive for Ganja in all the instances. All the sacs of
Ganja were seized subsequently. During search of the
truck one broken mobile phone, documents related to
the truck as mentioned above were also recovered and
seized.
II. That, thereafter, the sacs/packets containing
suspected Ganja were marked as P-1 to P-19.
Thereafter the weight of all the packets was measure
with the digital weighing machine brought by NCB
team. The gross weight of all the packets with packing
material found to be 1191.2 kg. ON reasonable believe
that an offence has been committed u/s 8(c) to be read
with section 20(b)(ii)(C) and 25 of the NDPS Act, 1985
(as amended), the recovered 19 packets of contrabands
believed to be Ganja were seized u/s 42 of the NDPS
Act, 1985 (as amended). ON spot interrogation
Salauddin revealed that one another person namely
Khan chacha was also accompanying with him and he
had all the knowledge of transportation of Ganja who
had procured the recovered drugs from Ukhrul. He
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 32 OF 2023
further revealed that he had loaded 7.1 ton of plastic
scrap and 7015 ton of carton paper scrap from M/s Dilip
Kr. Waste Management, Churachandpur, Manipur on
30.05.2022 and in the middle of the scrap he concealed
the 19 sacs of Ganja.
III. That, the search cum seizure procedure was
completed on 02.06.2022 without causing any damage
to any person or perperty in presence of the two
independent witnesses. A search cum seizure list was
prepared obtaining signatures of the owner of the
seized goods, seizing officer and the two independent
witnesses of Assam Rifles staff. Thereafter the accused
Salauddin was issued notices u/s 67 of NDPS Act, 1985
on the spot to appear before the NCB Officer for
recording his voluntary statement at NCB Imphal office
in connection with the seizure of 1191.2 kg of Ganja
from the truck bearing registration no. UK05CB5915.
Accordingly, Salauddin appeared before NCB officer on
02.06.2022 and tendered his voluntary statement u/s
67 of NDPS Act, 1985 on 02.06.2022 wherein he
confessed his involvement in the trafficking of the
seized Ganja.
IV. That on the basis of the recovery of contraband, his
confessional statements and on reasonable belief that
an offence had been committed in violation of
provisions of Section 8(c), which attracts penal
provisions u/s 20(b)(ii)(C) and 25 of NDPS Act, 1985;
Salauddin was arrested on 02.06.2022 & produced
before the Ld. Court of Duty Magistrate, Kangpokpi on
02.06.2022.
V. That, during the investigation, Khan chacha and Arun
Singha, the middleman who were found to be involved
in the present case were arrested and Final Complaint
was filed against them also on 28.11.2022 while
keeping investigation open for other suspects. In due
course, the supplier of the seized Ganja namely M.
Jayanta Singh, resident of Imphal and Livingstone
Nkagang of Ukhrul, Manipur were also arrested and
produced before the Court of Special Judge (ND&PS),
Senapati, Manipur on 14.03.2023 and 17.03.2023
respectively.
3.
That with regards to the averment made in para no. 1
to 2 of the bail application, the answering respondent has no
comments as it is a matter of record.
4.
That with regards to the averment made in para no. 3
of the bail application, the answering respondent has no
comment which are born out of record and that onus lies on
the Petitioner, the rest of the averment made in the paragraph
has to be established at the time of trial.
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 32 OF 2023
5.
That with regards to the averment made in para no. 4
of the bail application, it is humbly submitted that, Letter of
intimation of the arrest was sent to the Officer-in-Charge Police
Station – Baheri, District Bareily, Uttar Pradesh regarding the
accused Salauddin with request to furnish any criminal
antecedent available on record. A subsequent reminder was
also sent on 02.11.2022 to Officer-in-Charge Police Station
Baheri. However, reply is not yet received from Officer-inCharge Police Station. The same will be submitted before the
Ld. Judge as and when it is received.
6.
That, with regards to the averment made in para no.5
to 7 of the bail application, the answering respondent has no
comment which are born out of record, the rest of the
submission are made in the forgoing para.
7.
That, with regards to the averment made in para no. 8
of the bail application, the answering respondent vehemently
denies to the averment made therein, it is submitted before the
Hon’ble High Court that, the petitioner/accused has
unequivocally stated in his voluntary statement recorded under
section 67 of NDPS Act that a Ganja will be load in his truck,
out of which he will be paid a good amount for consignment
and the accused has allowed to conceal the contraband
substance after an assurance was given to him not to worry as
the co-accused would be moving ahead of his truck to clear the
road as on when required. Therefore, the question of
unconscious possession is completely out of question.
8. That, with regards to the averment made in para no. 9 to 11
of the bail application, the answering respondent has no
comment to be made as it is a matter of record. Except to the
averment made therein that the petitioner is not aware of the
presence of contraband substance in his truck, the same
submission is made in the aforesaid para. Imperatively, the
engagement of accused in trafficking the contraband substance
was also affirmed by the co-accused Yasin Khan @ Khan
Chacha wherein Yasin confessed in his voluntary statement
stating that, he concealed the contraband substance after
informing the petitioner not to worry as he would be moving
ahead of his truck to clear the road as on when required and in
return the Petitioner will get a good amount. He also informed
that he and the Petitioner Salauddin were working for one
person namely Arun Singha resident of Hojai, Assam. Hence,
the submission made there are not a good/sufficient grounds in
the eyes of law for granting the relief sought for in the Bail
Application and as such the Hon’ble Court may be pleased to
reject the same.
9. That, with regards to the averment made in para no. 12 of
the bail application, it is submitted before the Hon’ble High
Court that, from the bare perusal of the factual matrix of the
case. It is manifestly clear that the accused was caught in
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 32 OF 2023
possession of 1191.2 Kgs of contraband Ganja packed in 19
sacks which was bought in his Tata Truck. Moreover, the
process of investigation is still underway in order to trace the
whereabout and chain of operation of all the accomplies of the
accused including those associates who have been instrumental
in trafficking of contraband substance, and as such, the
petitioner being the kingpin, releasing him on bail can temper
the evidence and witness, which will frustrate the whole
process of investigation.
10. That, with regards to the averment made in para no. 13 of
the bail application, the answering respondent has no
comments as it is a matter of record.
11. That, with regards to the averment made in para no. 14 of
the bail application, the answering respondent humbly submits
that, the accused was caught red-handed for a possession of
1191.2 Kgs of contraband Ganja packed in 19 sacks which was
bought in his Tata Truck, the same allegation is affirmed by the
2 (independent witness) namely Sh. Heman Rishanta Singh
Rfn/GD and Sh. Sougrakpam Chandra Kumar Meitei Rfn/GD of
‘B’ Coy Tadubi of 33rd Assam Rifle, and during investigation it
was discovered that the accused is a main member of the
syndicate in illicit trafficking and further investigation is still
going. Therefore, examining the prima facie evidence available
on record and considering that the amount of quantity
recovered from the accused is of commercial nature bared the
accused from acquiring bail under Section 37 of the NDPS Act.
Therefore, the Ld. Special Judge (ND&PS) Manipur has rightly
rejected the bail application of the accused.
12. That, with regards to the averment made in para no. 15 of
the bail application it is humbly submitted that, the I.O
submitted the Final Report/Charge-Sheet on 28.11.2022 and
the Petitioner filed the bail application on 27.02.2023 only after
the charge-sheet has been filed, which extinguished the right
of default bail. More so, the order dated 27.03.2023 passed by
the Hon’ble Court of Special Judge (ND&PS), Senapati had
rightly accepted the application filed by the Respondent, as the
Special Judge has unfettered rights under the provision of
Section 36-A (4) of NDPS Act, which give the power to grant
extension for a period upto 1(one) year.
13. That, with regards to the averment made in para no. 16 of
the bail application, it is humbly submitted that, the accused
was caught in possession of commercial quantity of contraband
substance, this prima facie case or the root of the case is
undisputed, and the investigation is still underway to further
trace the accused associate. It is imperative to mentioned that,
during investigation, besides the availability of complicity of all
the accused in voluntary statement, the connivance of all the
accused was revealed in analyzing the CDRs of all the
numbers, it has been established that there was in regular
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 32 OF 2023
contact with each other. There are several calls made among
them. Certified copies of the CDRs have been applied from the
concerned service providers and the same is yet to be
received, the answering respondent crave the leave of this
Hon’ble Court to refer the final complaint for detail of the CDRs
report as it is not reproduced herein for the sake of brevity.
Therefore, interference of this court on weighing the evidence
of going deep into the probative value of evidence at this
juncture is highly premature and hence, uncalled. All this prima
facie evidence available on record cannot be out rightly thrown
out and grant bail at this stage.
14. That, with regards to the averment made in para no. 17 of
the bail application, it is humbly submitted that, the further
investigation of the case is still going on to trace the criminal
antecedent of the accused and more so, the release of an
accused in NDPS Act cases on bail will send a negative signal
to the society. It will be detrimental to the interest of society.
The bail cannot be granted merely on the ground that there
was no past criminal history at this stage. Pertinently, the letter
of intimation of his arrest was sent to the Officer-in-Charge
Police Station-Baheri, District Bareily, Uttar Pradesh in regards
to the accused Salauddin with a request to furnish on any
available antecedent criminal record. On 02.11.2022 reminder
was also sent to Officer-in-Charge Police Station-Baheri. Reply
is not yet received from Officer-in-Charge Police Station. The
same will be submitted before your Honour as on when receipt.
15. That, with regards to the averment made in para no. 18 to
20 of the bail application, it is humbly submitted that, from the
bare perusal of the material available on record, it is evidently
clear that, the accused being a part of drug cartel having its
operation in different part of India, who have been involved in
trafficking of contraband substance, releasing the accused on
bail without bearing in mind the gravity of the offence, and
without considering the fact that, the Respondent is trying hard
to further trace the network of all his associates will frustrate
the whole process of pending investigation and adversely affect
the entire society and the objective of making a stringent
provision for control of illicit traffic in ND&PS Act will ultimately
be defeated.
It is pertinent to mentioned herein that, the Petitioner
was found in possession of commercial quantity, his case is hit
by bar under section 37 of the NDPS Act which sets a stringent
condition on grant of bail to accused found with commercial
quantity of drugs, hence, bearing in mind the seriousness of
the offences merely one is poor or sole breadwinner of the
family cannot be the factor to grant bail. Interest of society
must be the prime consideration in the case of offence
committed under NDPS Act. Quantity of the substance with
which accused was charged shall also be a relevant factor to
consider while granting bail.
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 32 OF 2023
[6]
Perused the application with the affidavit-in-opposition
filed by the respondent with documents filed by both the parties also
perused the order passed by the Ld. Special Judge (ND & PS),
Senapati, Manipur.
[7]
During the course of the hearing, the learned counsel for
the petitioner fervently submitted that the charge sheet was filed
without the expert report of the seizure contraband Ganja. As such,
Charge sheet is deemed to be incomplete, because of this the accused
is liable to be released on bail.
[8]
The learned counsel appearing for the respondent
submitted that the Final Report/Charge-Sheet on 28.11.2022 and the
Petitioner filed the bail application on 27.02.2023 only after the chargesheet has been filed, which extinguished the right of default bail. More
so, the order dated 27.03.2023 passed by the Hon’ble Court of Special
Judge (ND&PS), Senapati had rightly accepted the application filed by
the Respondent, as the Special Judge has unfettered rights under the
provision of Section 36-A (4) of NDPS Act, which give the power to
grant extension for a period upto 1(one) year
[9]
The learned counsel for the respondent submitted that
the Bail Application of the present petitioner was filed before the Ld.
Special Judge (ND & PS), Senapati, Manipur after charge sheet/final
report was filed in connection with the case. On perusal of the record,
the submission made by the learned counsel found positive. The
learned counsel, further, submitted that bunch of the matter relating to
ND & PS case which was filed without the expert report of the seizure
contraband and the same is still pending before the Hon’ble Apex Court
for disposal.
[10]
In support of his case, the learned counsel for the
respondent handed down the following cases:
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 32 OF 2023
1.
Special Leave Petition (Criminal) Diary No.(s).
43791/2023 – Pabitra Narayan Pradhan Vs. The State
(NCT) of Delhi, Supreme Court of India.
2.
Petition(s) for Special Leave to Appeal (Crl.) No(s).
8164 – 8166/2021-Mohd. Arbaz & Ors. Vs. State of NCT
of Delhi, Supreme Court of India.
Perused both the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
[11]
On perusal of the order of the Ld. Special Judge (ND &
PS), Senapati, Manipur, it is evident that the Ld. Special Judge passed
the order after hearing both sides with application of mind and also
after going through the relevant sections of ND & PS with the series of
cases rendered by the Apex Court and rightly rejected the Bail
Application filed by the present petitioner.
[12]
In view of the facts and circumstances, I find no ground
for allowing the petition in the foregoing and hence, the present Bail
Application filed by the petitioner is rejected.
[13]
Accordingly, the present Bail Application No. 32 of 2023 is
dismissed and disposed of. However, the petitioner is given liberty to
file fresh bail application on fresh grounds.
[14]
Send an extract copy of this order to the Court of Special
Judge (ND & PS), Senapati, Manipur.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
Lucy
BAIL APPLICATION NO. 32 OF 2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review