Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:28344
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.B.SURESH KUMAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE JOBIN SEBASTIAN
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.A NO. 1317 OF 2019
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 07.11.2019 IN SC NO.826 OF
2013 ON THE FILES OF THE COURT OF THE ADDITIONAL SESSIONS
JUDGE-V, PALAKKAD
APPELLANT/ACCUSED NO.1:
SIVAMANI
AGED 30 YEARS
S/O. BALASUBRAMANIAN, PADINJARAI VEEDU,
KULUKKUPARA, KOZHINJAMBARA, CHITTUR.
BY ADVS.
P.K.VARGHESE
M.T.SAMEER(K/3346/1999)
P.S.ANISHAD(K/560/2010)
K.R.ARUN KRISHNAN(K/617/2011)
DHANESH V.MADHAVAN(K/298/2006)
JERRY MATHEW(K/658/2015)
BIJU KUMAR(K/1085/2018)
REGHU SREEDHARAN(K/653/2020)
RAMEEZ M. AZEEZ(K/001008/2022)
RESPONDENT/COMPLAINANT/STATE:
STATE OF KERALA REPRESENTED BY PUBLIC
PROSECUTOR, HIGH COURT OF KERALA, ERNAKULAM 682 031. (CRIME NO.534/2011 OF KOZHINJAMBARA
POLICE STATION, PALAKKAD DISTRICT)
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 2 :-
SRI.ALEX.M.THOMBRA SR.PP
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
25.03.2025,
ALONG
WITH
CRL.A.1382/2019,
03.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 3 :-
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.B.SURESH KUMAR
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE JOBIN SEBASTIAN
THURSDAY, THE 3RD DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 13TH CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.A NO. 1382 OF 2019
AGAINST THE JUDGMENT DATED 07.11.2019 IN SC NO.826 OF
2013 ON THE FILES OF THE COURT OF THE ADDITIONAL SESSIONS
JUDGE-V, PALAKKAD
APPELLANT/ACCUSED 2:
SAJITH
AGED 27 YEARS, S/O. SAKTHIVEL , KULUKKUPARA,
KOZHINJAMBARA, CHITTUR 678 555
BY ADVS.
SRI.VISHNUPRASAD NAIR
SRI.E.VIJIN KARTHIK
RESPONDENT/STATE & COMPLAINANT:
STATE OF KERALA
REP. BY PUBLIC PROSECUTOR, HIGH COURT OF KERALA,
ERNAKULAM 682 031
SRI.ALEX.M.THOMBRA SR.PP
THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
25.03.2025,
ALONG
WITH
CRL.A.1317/2019,
03.04.2025 DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
THE
COURT
ON
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 4 :-
P.B.SURESH KUMAR & JOBIN SEBASTIAN, JJ.
----------------------------------------------Crl.Appeal Nos.1317 and 1382 of 2019
----------------------------------------------Dated this the 3rd day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
P.B.Suresh Kumar, J.
The appellants are the accused in S.C.No.826 of 2013 on
the files of the Court of the Additional Sessions Judge-V, Palakkad.
They stand convicted and sentenced for the offence punishable
under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code
(IPC) for the murder of
one Pradeep. Among the appeals,
Crl.A.No.1317 of 2019 is preferred by the first accused and
Crl.A.No.1382 of 2019 is preferred by the second accused.
2.
At 6.30 p.m., on 14.11.2011, one Sunesh, a friend
of Pradeep informed Kozhinjampara Police that the former received
information from one Remani Kounder, a ward member that Pradeep
is lying wounded at a place called “Kulukkapara Puzhamedu” and
when Sunesh proceeded to that place, Pradeep was found lying
soaked in blood with cut wounds on his head, face, left hand and
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 5 :-
neck. It was also informed by Sunesh to the police that even though
he and his friends took Pradeep to Esaf Hospital, Kozhinjampara and
then to Paalana Hospital, Palakkad, Pradeep breathed his last by the
time they reached the latter hospital. A case was registered by
Kozhinjampara
Police
based
on
the
said
information.
The
investigation conducted in the case revealed that the first accused
who is a neighbour of Pradeep maintained enmity towards Pradeep
as Pradeep hacked his brother Sivaprakash in an earlier occasion;
that on account of the said enmity, accused 1 to 3 stopped Pradeep
at Kulukkapara Puzhamedu at about 4 p.m. on the relevant day and
accused 1 and 2 among them, hacked Pradeep throughout his body
with the choppers carried by them. The third accused being a
juvenile, the final report against him was submitted before the
Juvenile Court and the final report against accused 1 and 2 was
submitted before the jurisdictional Magistrate.
3.
On accused 1 and 2 being committed to trial, the
Court of Session framed charges against them in terms of the final
report, to which they pleaded not guilty. The evidence in the case
consists of the oral evidence of PWs 1 to 26 and Exts.P1 to P33
proved through them. MO1 to MO8 series are the material objects
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 6 :-
identified by the witnesses. Exts.D1 to D7 are the case diary
statements of the witnesses marked at the instance of the defence.
The accused were thereupon questioned under Section 313 of the
Code of Criminal Procedure (the Code) as regards the incriminating
evidence brought out by the prosecution. The accused denied the
same. As the Court of Session did not find the case to be one fit for
acquittal under Section 232 of the Code, the accused were called
upon to enter on their defence. The accused examined three
witnesses on their side at that stage as DW1 to DW3. Ext.X1 is a
document marked by the defence through DW1 and Ext.X2 is a
document marked by the defence through DW3.
Thereafter, on an
appreciation of the evidence, the Court of Session found the
accused guilty of the offences referred to above and sentenced
them, among others, to imprisonment for life. The accused are
deeply aggrieved by their conviction and sentence, hence these
appeals.
4.
Heard Adv.P.K.Varghese for the first accused and
Adv.Vishnu Prasad Nair for the second accused. Sri.Alex M.Thombra,
the learned Public Prosecutor addressed arguments on behalf of the
State.
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 7 :-
5.
The issue that arises for consideration in the
appeals is whether the conviction of the accused and the sentence
passed against them, are sustainable in law.
6.
The essence of the arguments advanced by the
learned counsel for the accused is that there is no evidence in the
case to connect the accused with the crime. It was pointed out that
even though the ocular witnesses cited by the prosecution to prove
the occurrence turned hostile, the accused were convicted by the
Court of Session based on circumstances relied on by the
prosecution. According to the learned counsel, the circumstances
proved in the case do not establish the guilt of the accused beyond
reasonable
doubt.
Per contra, the learned Public Prosecutor
supported the impugned decision of the Court of Session.
7.
In the light of the arguments advanced by the
learned counsel for the accused, it is necessary to delve into the
evidence let in by the prosecution. The witness who was examined
as PW1 is Sunesh, the friend of Pradeep at whose instance the case
was registered. PW1 affirmed that it was he who furnished the
information and identified his signature in Ext.P1 First Information
Statement. It was clarified by PW1 in his evidence that he had not
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 8 :-
seen the occurrence. It was also clarified by PW1 that his name is
Sunesh and that he is referred to as Suresh by mistake in Ext.P1. In
addition, it was deposed by PW1 that there was a case registered
against Pradeep in connection with an occurrence in which the latter
hacked the brother of the first accused. It was also deposed by PW1
that at about 1 p.m. on the relevant day, he saw the accused
standing by the side of a motorcycle near the scene of occurrence.
8.
PW2 was a witness cited by the prosecution to
prove the occurrence, but he turned hostile. PW3 is a person who
was engaged in patching tyres at Kozhinjampara and he had
previous acquaintance with Pradeep as also the accused. It was
deposed by PW3 that he saw the occurrence in which Pradeep
sustained injuries. The version of PW3 as regards the occurrence
was that while he was proceeding to his house for lunch from his
shop located at Kozhinjampara, he saw the accused persons hacking
Pradeep with choppers near the cremation ground. It was his version
that there were a few ladies also at the scene at the relevant time
and all of them witnessed the occurrence and cried out. It was also
his version that the accused fled from the scene immediately
thereafter in a motorcycle and that they carried the weapons also
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 9 :-
with them. It was also his version that the wounds of Pradeep were
tied thereupon by a lady named Kamalam. PW3 identified MO1
series choppers as those used by the accused to inflict injuries on
Pradeep and MO2 as the iron rod found at the scene at the relevant
time. Likewise, PW3 identified MO3 as the shirt worn by the first
accused at the time of occurrence. In cross-examination, PW3
admitted that the lady named Kamalam referred to by him in his
evidence is none other than his mother. PW3 denied the suggestion
put to him during cross-examination that he is a person who is
undergoing treatment for mental illness. When it was put to PW3 in
cross-examination that he does not appear to have stated to the
police that he saw the occurrence, PW3 denied the same and
asserted that he stated to the police that he saw the occurrence.
Likewise, when it was put to PW3 in cross-examination that his
statement to the police was only that he had hearsay information
about the occurrence, he denied the same and asserted that he did
not give such a statement to the police. PW3 also denied the
suggestion made to him in cross-examination that he does not
appear to have stated to the police that he saw all the three
accused carrying choppers with them. Similarly, PW3 denied the
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 10 :-
suggestion put to him during cross-examination that he does not
appear to have stated to the police that accused 1 and 2 were
wearing MO3 and MO4 shirts respectively at the time of occurrence.
9.
PW4 is a cousin brother of Pradeep. His evidence
was that at about 1.30 p.m. on 14.11.2011, he saw the accused
together near the place of occurrence. PWs 5 and 9 are neighbours
of Pradeep. Even though PWs 5 and 9 turned hostile to the
prosecution, both of them affirmed in their evidence that there was
an occurrence in which Pradeep hacked the brother of the first
accused namely Sivaprakash. PW10 is Kamalam, the mother of PW3
referred to by him in his evidence. She deposed that on the relevant
day, she saw Pradeep soaked in blood on the side of the road near
the cremation ground. The version of PW10 was that it was she who
tied the wounds of Pradeep and gave water to him. It was deposed
by PW10 in her evidence that she had not seen the occurrence.
PW11 is the brother of the second accused. Even though he turned
hostile to the prosecution, it was deposed by him that he had a
motorcycle bearing Registration No.TN-45E-7238 and that Pradeep
obtained the said motorcycle from him at about 9 a.m. on the
relevant day to go to Kozhinjampara. PW12 is the sister of Pradeep.
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 11 :-
It was deposed by PW12 that when she went to the house of one of
her relatives on the morning of the relevant day at about 9 a.m. in
the pillion of the motorcycle owned by PW11 and ridden by Pradeep,
she saw the first accused near a petrol pump. It was also deposed
by PW11 that after sometime, she noticed that the first accused was
following them in a motorcycle accompanied by another person.
10.
PW13 is the elder brother of Pradeep. His evidence
was that when he went to the scene on getting to know of the
occurrence, he saw Pradeep soaked in blood and that those who
were present there at the relevant time told him that it was the
accused who hacked Pradeep and that they fled from the scene in a
motorcycle. PW13 affirmed in his evidence that there was a clash
between Pradeep and the brother of the first accused, in an earlier
occasion.
11.
PW15 was the doctor who conducted the post-
mortem examination on the body of the deceased and issued
Ext.P12 post-mortem certificate. The ante-mortem injuries found by
PW15 at the time of the post-mortem examination as deposed by
him are the following:
“1.
Incised wound 17x1x4.5cm, obliquely placed on top and right side
of head, curved with convexity upwards, backwards and to right.
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 12 :-
The right lower back end was 6 cm above top of root of right ear.
The left upper front end was at 15cm above root of nose in midline
top of head. Both-ends of the wound were sharp cut and edges
were contused. The wound cut the scalp underneath and further
cut the skull in full thickness, the cut involving the right frontal
parietal and temporal bones. The cut in skull measured 16 cm in
length. The wound further cut the dura and brain underneath. The
cut in brain measured 11x0.5x2cm in the right frontal parietal and
temporal bones. The wound was directed downwards to front and
to left. Subdural and subarachnoid bleeding was present over
brain. Brain was intensely pale.
2.
Avulsed incised wound 11x 1 x 4 cm on top of head, more to left,
lower front end 8 cm above left eyebrow and 2 cm outer to midline.
The right back end was seen merging with the left end of previous
injury. The left back end was 11 cm above top of left ear. The
wound avulsed scalp and outer table of skull over an area of
6x4cm, backwards and to left. Ends of the wound were - sharp cut
and edges contused.
3.
Incised wound 3x0.2x0.3 cm on the avulsed flap of scalp obliquely
placed with lower right end at 10 cm above root of nose.
4.
Incised wound 3x1x3 cm on left side of face obliquely placed with
upper back round cut end at 4 cm in front of root of top of left ear.
The lower inner sharp cut end was 6 cm outer to left nostril. The
wound cut the skin and soft tissues underneath and penetrated the
left maxilla bone to enter the sinus cavity. The wound was directed
downwards to left and backwards.
5.
Incised wound 14x3x5.5 cm obliquely placed on right side of face
and head front lower round cut end at just above root of right
nostril and 2.5 cm outer-to midline nose. The upper back sharp cut
end was at 1.5 cm above top of root of right ear. The wound was
deeper at front end and cut the skin and soft tissues underneath
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 13 :-
and cut the maxilla bone in full thickness and penetrated the soft
palate. At its back end the wound cut the scalp. The wound was
directed downwards to left and backwards.
6.
Incised wound 11x5x4.5 cm obliquely placed on right side of neck
upper back end at 4 cm above root of neck and 2.5 cm outer to
midline back of neck. The lower front end was 6 cm below jaw
margin and 1.4 cm outer to midline. Both ends of the wound were
sharp cut and edges contused. The wound had a side cut with
sharp cut end of size 1.5x0.5 cm along its upper border at 4 cm
behind lower front end. The wound cut the skin subcutaneous
tissues and muscles underneath. Two separate cuts could be
identified
in
the
depth
of
the
wound
one
of
which
was
corresponding to the side cut. Blood vessels including the common
carotid artery on right side were cut. The wound cut the cervical
spinal column between 1 and second cervical vertebrae and also
through the body of 3rd cervical vertebra, up to half thickness of
the spinal column. The spinal cord underneath was partially cut.
The wound was directed downwards to left and backwards.
7.
Incised wound 1.2 x 0.3x 2 cm on right half of front of neck
obliquely placed with upper inner round cut end at 4 cm outer to
midline and 0.5 cm below jaw margin. The wound was in line with
the side cut of previous injury.
8.
Incised wound 1x0.4x0.5 cm on right half of front of neck
transversely oblique with inner end at 6 cm below jaw margin and
2 cm outer to midline. The wound was in line with lower front end
of injury No. 6. Both ends of the wound were sharp cut.
9.
Incised wound 2.2x0.36x1cm, transversely oblique on front of neck
in midline, 6.5 cm below chin. The wound cut the skin and
subcutaneous tissues underneath and cut the thyroid cartilage in
full thickness. The wound was in line with previous injury.
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 14 :-
10.
Incised wound 10x6x4cm, vertically oblique on upper and outer
aspects of right shoulder upper inner end at 7cm outer to root of
neck in transverse midline top of shoulder. The lower outer end
was at 20cm above elbow at just outer to midline outer aspect of
arm. The wound continued downwards and to front as a contused
abrasion 8x0.3cm with its lower end at 12cm above elbow and 1cm
in front of midline outer aspect of upper arm. The wound cut the
skin subcutaneous and ligaments underneath and cut opened the
joint capsule of right shoulder. The head of right humerus was cut
in full thickness. The ends of the wound were sharp cut and edges
contused. The wound was directed downwards, to left and to front.
11.
Superficial incised wound 3x0.3cm on outer aspect of right
forearm, vertically oblique, upper front end at 6cm below elbow.
12.
Superficial incised wound 4x0.3cm on back of right wrist and
forearm lower outer end at outer end of wrist.
13.
Superficial incised would 1.5x0.2cm on outer aspect of right index
finger obliquely placed at 1cm below root of finger.
14.
Incised amputation of left hand obliquely except for a flap of skin
4cm broad on the inner aspect of forearm the wound measuring
11x4cm, with its lower inner end at 1cm above wrist at midline
inner aspect of wrist. The upper back end was 5cm above wrist on
border between back and inner aspect of forearm. The upper
frontend was 5cm above wrist at 1cm outer to midline front of
forearm. The wound cut skin all soft tissues including fascia
tendons and blood vessels and both bones of forearm in full
thickness. The wound was directed upwards and to left.
15.
Incised wound 1.4x0.8x0.5cm on back of left hand just above root
of ring finger with avulsion of skin downwards and to right.
16.
Superficial incised wound 2.8x0.2cm obliquely placed on back of
left forearm upper back end at 6cm above wrist.
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 15 :-
17.
Superficial incised wound 2x0.2cm on back of left forearm obliquely
placed with upper back end at 14cm below elbow.
18.
Incised wound 2.8x0.8x1.2cm transversely oblique on front and
inner aspects of left forearm upper inner end at 6cm below elbow.”
It was opined by PW15 in his evidence that the deceased died due
to cut injuries to head and neck. It was also opined by PW15 that
MO1 series choppers could produce the incised wounds including
the fatal injuries to the head and neck.
12.
PW16 was the Scientific Assistant attached to the
Regional Forensic Laboratory, Thrissur who examined the scene of
occurrence on 15.11.2011 and collected the various objects from
the scene for forensic examination, and later issued Ext.P13 report
in respect of the same. Item 6 in Ext.P13 report is MO3 shirt, items
12 and 13 therein are MO1 series choppers, item 14 therein is MO2
metallic pipe and item 15 therein is MO5 plastic sack. It was
deposed by PW16 that Item 6 contained human blood and although
items 14 and 15 contained blood, its origin could not be determined.
It was also deposed by PW16 that items 12 and 13 did not contain
blood.
13.
PW26 was the police officer who conducted the
investigation in the case. It was PW26 who arrested the accused on
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 16 :-
16.11.2011. It was deposed by PW26 that during the interrogation
pursuant to the arrest, it was disclosed to him by the first accused
that he has concealed two choppers and an iron rod in a plastic sack
by submerging the said sack in a mossy pond at a place called
Eruthempathy and when he was taken to that place as guided by
the first accused, he took out MO1 series choppers and MO2 iron rod
kept in MO5 plastic sack from the water near the ghat on the
eastern side of the pond and he seized the same as per Ext.P7
mahazar. Ext.P7(a) is the disclosure of the first accused which led to
the recovery of MO1 series choppers, MO2 iron rod and MO5 plastic
sack. It was clarified by PW26 in cross-examination that PW3 had
not disclosed to him that he saw the occurrence and what was
stated by him was that he only heard about the occurrence.
Similarly, it was clarified by PW26 in cross-examination that PW3
had not stated to him that all the three accused had choppers in
their hands at the relevant time nor had he furnished the particulars
of the clothes worn by the accused at the relevant time.
14.
Among the witnesses examined on the side of the
defence, DW1 was the Medical Superintendent of the Government
Mental Health Hospital, Thrissur. She deposed that PW3 had
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 17 :-
undergone
psychiatric
treatment
from
the
said
hospital
on
15.02.2016, 22.02.2016, 02.03.2016 and 21.03.2016. Ext.X1 is the
case sheet maintained at the hospital pertaining to the treatment
given to PW3. The witness who was examined as DW2 was the
Medical
Superintendent
of
the
Community
Health
Centre,
Kozhinjampara. He deposed that the records kept in the said
hospital reveal that PW3 had undergone psychiatric treatment from
the said hospital also during the period from 27.04.2017 to
23.05.2019.
15.
It is on an evaluation of the evidence discussed
above that the Court of Session came to the conclusion that the
accused are guilty of the offence punishable under Section 302 read
with Section 34 IPC. The pointed question is whether the Court of
Session is justified in arriving at the said conclusion on the basis of
the evidence discussed above.
16.
As noted, even though the case is one attempted
to be proved by the prosecution through direct evidence, all the
witnesses cited by the prosecution to prove the occurrence except
PW3, turned hostile. As fas as PW3 is concerned, it has been
established in the case through the evidence of PW26, the
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 18 :-
investigating officer that PW3 had not stated to him that he saw the
occurrence, and his version in the statement recorded under Section
161 of the Code was that he had only hearsay information about the
occurrence. It is seen that, in the circumstances, even the Court of
Session did not accept PW3 as an ocular witness. We do not find any
infirmity in the view taken by the Court of Session in this regard,
especially when it has come out in evidence that PW3 was a person
who was undergoing treatment for mental illness on several
occasions after the occurrence and also due to his unusual
behaviour of addressing his mother by her name as if she were
unknown to him, while giving evidence. We take this view also for
the reason that PW3 had not stated to PW26 while recording his
statement under Section 161 of the Code that all the three accused
had choppers in their hands at the relevant time nor had he
furnished to PW26, the particulars of the clothes worn by the
accused at the relevant time. In other words, the evidence tendered
by PW3 on the above aspects are not consistent with his previous
statement. There is yet another reason also for us to hold so, as
PW10 who had tied the wounds of the deceased immediately after
the occurrence has admitted in her evidence that she had not seen
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 19 :-
the wounds, whereas the version of PW3 was that PW10 and other
ladies saw the occurrence.
17.
Be that as it may, the Court of Session, in the
circumstances, is seen to have found the accused guilty based on
the circumstances established in the case. The pointed question in
the above background is whether the circumstances proved in the
case would establish the guilt of accused 1 and 2 beyond reasonable
doubt.
18.
One of the arguments advanced by the learned
counsel for the accused is as regards the motive alleged by the
prosecution for the accused to commit the crime. The motive
alleged is that Pradeep had hacked the brother of the first accused
during October 2010 and the accused thereby caused the death of
Pradeep on account of that enmity. The argument advanced by the
learned counsel for the accused in this regard is that the particulars
of the case, if any, registered in connection with that occurrence
were not brought on record, and in the absence of any material in
that regard, it cannot be said that the motive has been established
beyond reasonable doubt. We are not impressed by this argument.
No doubt, the prosecution is expected in cases of this nature to
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 20 :-
produce the particulars of the case registered when it alleges that
the motive for the crime is a previous crime. But, merely on account
of the said omission on the part of the prosecution to do so, it
cannot be held straight away that the prosecution failed to establish
the motive, if there is other satisfactory evidence before the court to
hold in terms of Section 3 of the Indian Evidence Act, that such an
occurrence took place. In the case on hand, there is satisfactory
evidence to hold that there was a previous clash between the
deceased and the brother of the first accused and that the latter
sustained serious injuries in that clash, even though there are no
materials to establish the nature and manner in which the injuries
were inflicted. As such, it cannot be said that the prosecution has
failed to prove the motive of the accused to commit the crime.
19.
Another argument seriously pressed into service
by the learned counsel for the accused is as regards the evidence
given by PW26 that MO1 series choppers and MO2 iron rod were
recovered based on the information furnished by the first accused
which is relevant under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act. The
argument is that the evidence tendered by PW26 is too artificial and
cannot be believed. It is seen that the recovery of MO1 series
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 21 :-
choppers and MO2 iron rod was effected on 17.11.2011 and the
same are seen produced before the court only on 24.11.2011. There
is not even formal evidence from the side of the investigating officer
as to the cause for the said delay. Be that as it may, Ext.P13 report
of the Forensic Science Laboratory, Thrissur shows that MO1 series
choppers did not contain traces of blood. True, PW15, the doctor
who conducted the post-mortem examination on the body of the
deceased, deposed in his evidence that the injuries sustained by the
deceased are possible with choppers in the nature of MO1 series,
even though there was no evidence on the side of the doctor that
any of the injuries sustained by the deceased is possible with MO2
iron rod. In the circumstances, in the absence of blood on MO1
series choppers, it is doubtful as to whether the same were weapons
that were used by the assailants to inflict injuries on the deceased
and if that be so, the recovery of MO1 series choppers and MO2 iron
rod may not be of any relevance in the case.
20.
It is seen that one of the circumstances relied on
by the prosecution to prove the guilt of the accused is that MO3 shirt
of the first accused contained human blood. It is seen from the
materials that it was PW3 who gave evidence that the first accused
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 22 :-
was wearing MO3 shirt at the time of occurrence. Inasmuch as it is
found that the presence of PW3 at the scene at the relevant time, is
doubtful, we are of the view that it is not safe to place reliance on
the said circumstance while evaluating the circumstances for
considering the question as to whether the prosecution has
established the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt.
21.
It is now trite that the circumstances to be proved
to establish the guilt of the accused in a given case, shall be of a
conclusive nature and tendency and the same shall be fully
established,
which
means
that
the
circumstances
shall
unequivocally establish the truth of the facts, leaving no reasonable
doubt, or alternative explanation and the same should have a
definite tendency of implicating the accused in the crime. If one
examines the evidence let in by the prosecution in the case on hand
keeping in mind the principles aforesaid, the following are the
circumstances that could be taken as proved :
(i)
that the accused and deceased were persons
residing in the same neighbourhood and were persons
known to each other;
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 23 :-
(ii)
that the deceased caused serious injuries to the
brother of the first accused in an earlier occasion, on
account of which, the deceased and the first accused were
not in cordial terms thereafter;
(iii)
that the death of the victim was a homicide and
that he died on account of the cut injuries sustained to his
head and neck at the place called Kulukkapara Puzhamedu;
(iv)
that the cut injuries sustained by the deceased
on his head and neck were in the nature of injuries that
could be inflicted with weapons in the nature of MO1 series
choppers;
(v)
that PW1, the friend of the deceased who gave
Ext.P1 First Information Statement, saw the accused
standing by the side of a motorcycle near the scene of
occurrence at about 1 p.m. on the relevant day;
(vi)
that PW4, the cousin brother of the deceased
saw the accused together near the place of occurrence at
about 1.30 p.m. on the relevant day;
(vii)
that PW12, the sister of the deceased saw the
first accused following the motorcycle in which she was
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 24 :-
riding pillion with the deceased at about 9 a.m. on the
relevant day, while they were proceeding to the house of
one of their relatives;
The question that remains to be considered is whether the
circumstances mentioned above are sufficient to hold beyond
reasonable doubt that it was accused 1 and 2 who committed the
murder of the deceased. Before examining the said question, it is
necessary to keep in mind the principles to be followed in this
regard. The principles are:
(1)
that the circumstances from which the conclusion of
guilt is drawn are fully established,
(2)
that the facts so established are consistent only with
the hypothesis of the guilt of the accused, that is to
say, they should not be explainable on any other
hypothesis except that the accused is guilty,
(3)
that the circumstances are of a conclusive nature and
tendency,
(4)
that they should exclude every possible hypothesis
except that the accused is guilty, and
(5)
that there must be a chain of evidence so complete as
not to leave any reasonable ground for the conclusion
consistent with the innocence of the accused and must
show that in all human probability, the act must have
been done by the accused.
Crl.A.No.1317 & 1382 of 2019
2025:KER:28344
-: 25 :-
We are of the view that the above mentioned circumstances would
not form a chain of evidence so complete as not to leave any
reasonable ground for the conclusion consistent with the innocence
of the accused and would not show that in all human probability, it
was accused 1 and 2 who caused the death of Pradeep. Needles to
say, the appellants are entitled to the benefit of doubt.
In the result, the appeals are allowed. The conviction of
the appellants for the offences charged against them is set aside
and they are acquitted. They shall be set at liberty forthwith and
released from custody, if their continued detention is not required in
connection with any other case. Registry is directed to communicate
the above order forthwith to the concerned prison, where
the
appellants are undergoing incarceration.
Sd/P.B.SURESH KUMAR, JUDGE.
Sd/JOBIN SEBASTIAN, JUDGE.
YKB
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review