Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48758
RSA No. 1099 of 2010
CNR: KAHC010916172010
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 8TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO. 1099 OF 2010 (PAR)
BETWEEN:
1.
S.V. VENKATASWAMY REDDY
S/O LATE VENKATARAMANAPPA
AGED 63 YEARS
R/A SULIKUNTE VILLAGE, VARTHUR HOBLI
BANGALORE EAST TALUK
BANGALORE URBAN DIST.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. GOUTHAM .M, SRI. SHASHANTHA NAIK AND
SRI. MANOHAR .M, ADVOCATES)
AND:
1.
RAMAKKA
W/O NARAYANA REDDY
D/O LATE VENKATARAMANAPPA
SINCE DEAD
1(A)
CHANDRA REDDY
S/O NARAYANA REDDY
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
ANEKAL TALUK, MUTTANAHALLY VILLAGE
BANGALORE-562 106.
BANGALORE RURAL.
1(B)
RAJU REDDY
S/O NARAYANA REDDY
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
ANEKAL TALUK, MUTTANAHALLY VILLAGE
BANGALORE-562 106.
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-2HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48758
RSA No. 1099 of 2010
CNR: KAHC010916172010
1(C)
INDIRAMMA
D/O NARAYANA REDDY
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
ANEKAL TALUK, MUTTANAHALLY VILLAGE
BANGALORE-562 106.
BANGALORE RURAL.
1(D)
SHYLA
D/O NARAYANA REDDY
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
ANEKAL TALUK, MUTTANAHALLY VILLAGE
BANGALORE-562 106.
BANGALORE RURAL.
2.
CHINNAMMA
D/O LATE VENKATARAMANAPPA
AGED ABOUT 47 YEARS
R/A VALEPURA VILLAGE
VARTHUR HOBLI, BANGALORE EAST TALUK
BANGALORE URBAN DIST.
3.
CHIKKAKULLAMMA
D/O LATE VENKATARAMANAPPA
AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS
R/A SULIKUNTE VILLAGE, VARTHUR HOBLI
BANGALORE EAST TALUK
BANGALORE URBAN DIST.
4.
SUNKAMMA
W/O RAMACHANDRA REDDY
AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS
D/O VENKATARAMANAPPA
R/A SULIKUNTE VILLAGE, VARTHUR HOBLI
BANGALORE EAST TALUK
BANGALORE URBAN DIST.
5.
SAVITRAMMA
W/O RAVINDRA REDDY
SICNE DEAD BY LRS
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-3HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48758
RSA No. 1099 of 2010
CNR: KAHC010916172010
5(A)
SRI. MANIKANTA .R
S/O SAVITRAMMA AND RAVINDRAREDDY
AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS
R/A DOMMASANDRA VILLAGE
ANEKAL TALUK, BANGALORE-560 125.
6.
RAMAKKA
W/O LATE VENKATARAMANAPPA
AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS
R/A SULIKUNTE VILLAGE, VARTHUR HOBLI
BANGALORE EAST TALUK-560 087.
BANGALORE URBAN DIST.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. V. ANAND, ADVOCATE FOR R3, R4, R5(A) AND R(6);
SRI. PRASANNA .B.R, ADVOCATE FOR R1(A TO D) AND R2;
SRI. M. ERAPPA REDDY, ADVOCATE FOR IMPLEADING R-7;
SRI.
V.B.
RAVISHANKAR,
ADVOCATE
FOR
IMPLEADING R-8)
THIS RSA IS FILED U/O 100 OF CPC AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT
AND
DECREE DATED
31.07.2009
PASSED
IN
RA.NO.42/2003 ON THE FILE OF THE PRESIDING OFFICER,
FAST
TRACK
COURT-III,
BANGALORE
RURAL
DISTRICT,
BANGALORE, DISMISSING THE APPEAL CONFIRMING THE
JUDGMENT
AND
DECREE DATED
30.05.2003
PASSED
IN
OS.NO.483/1997 ON THE FILE OF THE I ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE
(SR. DN.), BANGALORE RURAL DISTRICT, BANGALORE.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS
DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-4HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48758
RSA No. 1099 of 2010
CNR: KAHC010916172010
ORAL JUDGMENT
The captioned appeal is by the sole defendant who is
the
son
born
through
first
wife
Thimmakka
and
Venkataramanappa challenging the preliminary decree
drawn by the Court of first instance in OS.No.483/1995
affirmed by the appellate Court in RA.No. 42/2003.
2.
Heard the counsel on records. Perused the
substantial question of law framed by this Court vide order
dated 19.04.2012.
3.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are
referred to as per their rank before the trial Court in
O.S.No.483/1995.
4.
The family tree is as under:
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-5HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48758
RSA No. 1099 of 2010
CNR: KAHC010916172010
5.
The facts, in brief, are as follows:
One Venkataramanappa was the propositus. He had
two wives, namely, Thimmakka and Ramakka. The present
suit was instituted by Ramakka, the second wife of
Venkataramanappa, who is arrayed as plaintiff No.6, along
with her children and the children born through the first
wife, Thimmakka, except the present appellant/defendant,
Venkataswamy Reddy.
6.
The
case
Venkataramanappa
of
married
the
plaintiffs
Thimmakka
is
that
and
that
Venkataramanappa and Thimmakka jointly acquired the
property covered under the registered gift deed dated
12.05.1939. Under the said gift deed, the property was
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-6HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48758
RSA No. 1099 of 2010
CNR: KAHC010916172010
gifted
jointly
Thimmakka.
in
favour
After
the
of
Venkataramanappa
demise
of
and
Thimmakka,
Venkataramanappa married plaintiff No.6-Ramakka.
7.
It
is
further
Venkataramanappa
and
case
of
Ramakka
the
plaintiffs
received
that
another
property under a registered gift deed dated 21.04.1955.
Under the said gift deed, Ramakka was conferred a limited
right of enjoyment. The recitals in the said gift deed
contemplated that, upon the demise of Ramakka, the
property would devolve upon the male children born to
Venkataramanappa and Ramakka.
8.
The plaintiffs asserted that the suit schedule
properties constituted joint family ancestral properties
and, on such assertion, plaintiff
No.6-Ramakka, her
children and the children born through the first wife
Thimmakka, except the present defendant, instituted the
suit seeking partition and separate possession.
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-7HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48758
RSA No. 1099 of 2010
CNR: KAHC010916172010
9.
It is relevant to note that O.S.No.171/1994,
which was also a suit for partition and separate possession
instituted
by
the
present
defendant,
and
O.S.No.283/1991, a suit for bare injunction instituted by
the second wife of Venkataramanappa, namely, Ramakka,
were clubbed with the present suit and common evidence
was
recorded.
dismissed.
The
suit
However,
for
injunction
the
partition
came
to
suits
be
in
O.S.Nos.171/1994 and 483/1995 came to be decreed. The
Trial Court, while drawing the preliminary decree, allotted
1/21st share to plaintiffs 1 to 5 out of the father’s 1/3rd
share, whereas plaintiff No.6, the widow, was awarded
1/3rd share together with 1/21st share.
10.
The
said
preliminary
decree
O.S.No.483/1995
was
carried
No.42/2003.
First
Appellate
The
in
passed
Regular
Court,
in
Appeal
upon
re-
appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence on
record,
dismissed
the
appeal
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
preferred
by
the
-8HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48758
RSA No. 1099 of 2010
CNR: KAHC010916172010
defendant/Venkataswamy Reddy and affirmed the decree
passed by the Trial Court.
11.
This
Court,
by
order
dated
admitted
the
appeal
and
formulated
19.04.2012,
the
following
substantial question of law:
“The daughter of late Venkataramanappa, having instituted
O.S.483/97,
for
declaration,
partition
and
separate
possession of Joint family properties, whether the trial court
was justified in reckoning a notional partition entitling the
son and widow to 1/3rd share and the son and daughters
each to 1/7th share in the 1/3rd share of the deceased father
i.e., 1/21st share, of the suit schedule properties, as
confirmed by the Lower Appellate Court, more so in the
light of the amendment to Sec.6 of the Hindu Succession
Act, 1956, entitling the daughters to an equal share in the
properties of the coparcenary?”
Finding on the substantial question of law:
12.
Learned counsel for the appellant/defendant
has urged several grounds questioning the determination
and quantification of the shares by the Courts below.
However, on a careful consideration of the pleadings, oral
and documentary evidence and the findings recorded by
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
-9HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48758
RSA No. 1099 of 2010
CNR: KAHC010916172010
the Courts below, this Court finds that the primary issue
requiring consideration is not merely the quantification of
shares, but the very source and manner of acquisition of
the
respective
properties
by
Venkataramanappa,
Thimmakka and Ramakka.
13.
The
Courts
below,
while
determining
the
shares, have proceeded on the premise that the properties
constituted joint family properties, without adverting to
the specific source of title under which the properties came
to be acquired. The rights of the parties, therefore, have
to be determined with reference to the respective gift
deeds under which the properties were acquired.
14.
Insofar as the property covered under the
registered gift deed dated 12.05.1939, marked as Ex.P1,
is
concerned,
the
recitals
clearly
establish
that
Venkataramanappa and his first wife Thimmakka became
joint owners of the said property. Consequently, upon the
demise of Thimmakka, her share in the property has to
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 10 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48758
RSA No. 1099 of 2010
CNR: KAHC010916172010
devolve in accordance with Section 15 of the Hindu
Succession Act.
15.
The children born through Thimmakka, namely,
Ramakka, Chinnamma and Venkataswamy Reddy, are
therefore entitled to succeed to Thimmakka’s half share,
each taking 1/6th share therein. The remaining half share
belonging to Venkataramanappa under the gift deed dated
12.05.1939
would,
upon
his
demise,
devolve
under
Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act upon his widow,
plaintiff No.6-Ramakka, and his six children, namely, the
three children born through Ramakka and the three
children born through Thimmakka. Thus, the remaining
half share of Venkataramanappa is required to be divided
among seven sharers, each consequently taking 1/14th
share in the entire property.
16.
Accordingly, in respect of the property covered
under Ex.P1, the children of Thimmakka, namely, plaintiffs
1 and 2 and the defendant/Venkataswamy Reddy, would
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 11 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48758
RSA No. 1099 of 2010
CNR: KAHC010916172010
each take 1/6th share through Thimmakka together with
1/14th share through Venkataramanappa. Plaintiff No.6
and plaintiffs 3 to 5 would each be entitled to 1/14th share
through Venkataramanappa.
17.
Insofar as the property covered under the
second registered gift deed dated 21.04.1955, marked as
Ex.P2, is concerned, it is not in dispute that the property
was gifted by the brother of plaintiff No.6-Ramakka. The
source of acquisition, therefore, is the maternal side of
Ramakka.
18.
Though the gift deed created a limited right of
enjoyment in favour of Ramakka, such limited estate stood
enlarged into an absolute estate by virtue of Section 14 of
the Hindu Succession Act. Consequently, Ramakka became
the absolute owner of the property to the extent of the
share covered by the gift deed in her favour. Thus, in
respect of the property covered under Ex.P2, plaintiff
No.6-Ramakka is independently entitled to one-half share.
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 12 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48758
RSA No. 1099 of 2010
CNR: KAHC010916172010
19.
The remaining one-half share attributable to
Venkataramanappa would devolve, upon his demise, upon
his widow and six children under Section 8 of the Hindu
Succession Act. Accordingly, the said remaining half share
has to be divided equally amongst the seven heirs, each
taking 1/14th share in the entirety of the property.
20.
Consequently, plaintiff No.6-Ramakka would be
entitled to one-half share under the gift deed dated
21.04.1955
and
an
1/14th
additional
share
in
the
remaining half share of Venkataramanappa. Her three
children,
namely,
Chikkakullamma,
Savithramma,
and
the
Thimmakka,
namely,
three
Sunkamma
children
Ramakka,
born
and
through
Chinnamma
and
Venkataswamy Reddy, would each be entitled to 1/14th
share.
21.
From the foregoing discussion, it is evident that
the concurrent findings recorded by the Courts below,
insofar as they hold that the plaintiffs are entitled to
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 13 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48758
RSA No. 1099 of 2010
CNR: KAHC010916172010
succeed to a share in the properties left behind by
Thimmakka
and
Venkataramanappa,
do
not
call
for
interference. However, the determination of shares made
by the Courts below proceeds without examining the
source of acquisition and the nature of the title created
under the respective gift deeds dated 12.05.1939 and
21.04.1955.
22.
Once the source of title is examined, the shares
have necessarily to be re-determined in accordance with
the statutory scheme governing succession. The shares
determined by the Courts below, therefore, cannot be
sustained and require modification to the extent indicated
hereinabove.
Accordingly,
the
substantial
question
of
law
is
answered in the negative.
23.
For the foregoing reasons, the appeal succeeds
in part and this Court proceeds to pass the following:
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 14 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48758
RSA No. 1099 of 2010
CNR: KAHC010916172010
ORDER
(i) The Regular Second Appeal is allowed in part.
(ii) In respect of the properties covered under the
registered gift deed dated 12.05.1939, plaintiffs 1
and 2 and the defendant/Venkataswamy Reddy are
each entitled to 1/6th share plus 1/14th share,
whereas plaintiffs 3 to 6 are each entitled to 1/14th
share.
(iii)
In respect of the properties covered under the
registered gift deed dated 21.04.1955, plaintiff No.6Ramakka is entitled to one-half share plus 1/14th
share,
whereas
plaintiffs
to
and
the
defendant/Venkataswamy Reddy are each entitled to
1/14th share.
(iii)
Any
alienations
defendant/Venkataswamy
made
Reddy
by
the
sole
during
the
pendency of the proceedings shall remain subject to
the shares re-determined by this Court. Needless to
state, the purchasers, if any, are at liberty to work
out their equitable remedies in the final decree
proceedings.
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
- 15 HC-KAR
NC: 2026:KHC:48758
RSA No. 1099 of 2010
CNR: KAHC010916172010
(iv)
The
impleading
applications
filed
in
I.A.Nos.1/2026 and 3/2024 are disposed of without
expressing any opinion on the rights claimed by the
respective impleading applicants. The said applicants
are relegated to work out their remedies in the
pending suit in O.S.No.200/2010.
(v) The decree passed by the Trial Court and
affirmed by the First Appellate Court shall stand
modified to the aforesaid extent.
(vi) The Registry shall draw the modified preliminary
decree accordingly.
SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
Verified
(SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM)
JUDGE
ALB
List No.: 2 Sl No.: 1
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review