Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010818542002
Sr.No:-20
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH Bench[3506]
AT AMARAVATI
WRIT PETITION NO: 13467 of 2002
S.Maheswara Rao
...Petitioner
Vs.
The Managing Director and Current-In-Charge, L.I.C., ...Respondent(s)
and another.
**********
Advocate for Petitioner:
Mr.J SUDHEER,
Ms.SHAIK NEHA HASSAN
Advocate for Respondent:
Mr.SINGAM SRINIVASA RAO
CORAM : SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 9th February 2026
ORDER:
Writ petitioner challenges disciplinary authority order, dated
31.12.2001, passed by the 2nd respondent as confirmed by the appellate
authority, vide order, dated 07.06.2002, to the extent of imposing
punishment of reduction of basic pay by one stage and recovery of
financial loss to the extent of Rs.34,334.75ps. purported to be in terms
of Regulation 39(1)(d) and Regulation 39(1)(c) respectively of Life
Insurance Corporation of India (Staff) Regulations, 1960, to be arbitrary,
illegal and in violation of principles of natural justice, besides being
unconstitutional.
CGR, J.
W.P.No.13467 of 2002
2.
(a) Petitioner was working with respondent Corporation as
Assistant Administrative Officer at one of its branches at Gurazala,
Guntur District. As part of duties, he was assigned with the duty of
accompanying officer for the purpose of ensuring the cash collected with
the branch to be deposited with its bank. On 13.4.1997, the collection of
premiums with the branch were stated to have been entered in daily
cash book and next day the amount was supposed to be deposited with
its banker. The job of collecting premiums by ay of cash though was not
that of the petitioner and rests on the senior cashier, in order to ensure
that the amounts so collected are safely and appropriately deposed with
the bank, the petitioner was entrusted with the assignment of
accompanying the cash. In the process, it was ultimately found that
there was shortage of cash than that recorded in daily cash register, for
which both criminal case as well as disciplinary proceedings came to be
instituted.
(b) The criminal case was foisted against the petitioner and also
the peon, who was entrusted with carrying of cash to the bank, on the
allegations of misappropriation. Eventually, the criminal trial ended in
acquittal insofar as petitioner was concerned, however, the other
accused got convicted. The petitioner was issued charge memo, dated
16.08.1997, alleging that he was responsible and negligent in
movement of the cash, which was supposed to be deposited with the
CGR, J.
W.P.No.13467 of 2002
bank. Petitioner submitted explanation, dated 09.09.1997, refuting the
charges.
The enquiry officer after conducting thorough enquiry,
submitted report, dated 25.02.1999, finding that though there was a
lapse on the part of petitioner as accompanying officer, it was on account
of his mis-judgment, therefore, the charge of negligence was not made
out and proved beyond doubt.
(c) However, the disciplinary authority dis-agreeing with the
opinion expressed by the enquiry officer, proceeded with the disciplinary
action by issuing show-cause notice, dated 12.11.2001 enclosing the
copy of enquiry report and called upon to submit explanation. The
show-cause notice proposed to impose penalty of reduction in basic pay
by three stages and recovery of financial loss to the extent of
Rs.34,334.75ps., being half of the loss incurred by the Corporation.
Petitioner submitted detailed explanation, dated 19.12.2001.
After
considering the evidence available on record and also the explanation
of the petitioner, the 2nd respondent disciplinary authority has passed
order, dated 31.12.2001, imposing penalty of reduction in basic pay by
three stages and also ordering recovery of the amount as stated above.
Petitioner has challenged the said order before the 1st respondent –
appellate authority. By order, dated 07.06.2002, the appellate authority
has modified the punishment to that of reduction in basic pay by one
CGR, J.
W.P.No.13467 of 2002
stage while retaining the recovery of the amount. Assailing the same,
present writ petition is filed.
3.
The respondent Corporation has filed detailed counter-affidavit
opposing the writ petition.
4.
Heard Ms.Shaik Neha Hassan, learned counsel, representing Sri
J. Sudheer, learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri Singam Srinivasa
Rao, learned counsel for the respondent.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner mainly contended that the order
of the disciplinary authority does not specifically render any finding as
such to drive home that the petitioner was negligent in discharging his
duty as accompanying officer, in the absence of reasons and findings,
the order is clearly unsustainable. She also contended that the role and
responsibility of accompanying officer would be merely to ensure that
the amount which is in box/suit case, is safely delivered and deposited
with the bank, as no specific role is attributed to the petitioner in such
process and pointing out anything against him for shortage of the
amount, particularly, having regard to the findings rendered by the
criminal court that the misappropriation was attributable to the other
accused, the disciplinary authority as well as appellate authority erred
in not considering such crucial part of evidence in deciding the
disciplinary proceedings which is, therefore, clearly perverse. In support
CGR, J.
W.P.No.13467 of 2002
of her submissions, reliance has been placed on the judgment of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in SBI v. Ajai Kumar Srivastava1.
6.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent
Corporation supported the orders of disciplinary authority as confirmed
by the appellate authority. He contended that the enquiry officer has
clearly come to conclusion that there was negligence on the part of
petitioner, however, he opined that such negligence since not proved
beyond reasonable doubt, the disciplinary proceedings may not be
continued.
The said opinion, ipso facto, would not preclude the
disciplinary authority in taking forward the disciplinary proceedings
having regard to the gravity of the charge. He further contended that
inasmuch as the petitioner has signed the daily cash book (DCB), which
confirms that the amount that was to be deposited with the bank, it was
his responsibility to ensure the same amount is deposited with the bank
and as the amount fell shortage of the entry, as shown in DCB, clearly
petitioner was negligent in discharging his duty, therefore, rightly, the
disciplinary authority and as well as the appellate authority have
imposed punishment of penalty as specified therein.
7.
Perused the record and considered the rival submissions of both
the learned counsels.
(2021) 2 SCC 612
CGR, J.
W.P.No.13467 of 2002
8.
The petitioner did not dispute the fact of signing daily cash book
which suggested collection of premium amount by the branch on
13.02.1997. The amount as mentioned in DCB was supposed to be
deposited in the bank on next day i.e. 14.02.1997. It is not in dispute
that the next day when the amount was taken to bank, there was
shortage of Rs.68,669.50 ps. The Corporation having felt that the
amount that was falling short was on account of misappropriation, it has
initiated two sets of proceedings, one by instituting a criminal complaint
against the writ petitioner and the peon, who handled the cash, and the
other being disciplinary proceedings. Insofar as criminal proceedings
were concerned, the competent court has acquitted the petitioner
holding that he was not found to be involved in misappropriation of cash,
and the other accused came to be convicted. Insofar as the disciplinary
proceedings were concerned, the enquiry officer has thoroughly gone
into the aspect of negligence attributable to the petitioner, and
expressed opinion that the charge of gross negligence could not have
been said to be proved beyond reasonable doubt.
9.
The disciplinary authority, however, taking view that in disciplinary
proceedings, question of proving the charge on the touch stone of
beyond reasonable doubt does not arise and rather it was required to
be only seen on preponderance of probabilities, proceeded with the
disciplinary action. The disciplinary authority concurring with the opinion
CGR, J.
W.P.No.13467 of 2002
expressed by the enquiry officer, who also has come to the conclusion
that indeed there was negligence on the part of petitioner, ultimately,
also considering the fact that petitioner has signed the DCB, a specific
finding has been recorded that petitioner’s duties and responsibilities
would end only upon tendering of the cash in tact with the bank, which
was clearly lacking in the present case. On appreciation of evidence on
record, ultimately, the disciplinary authority for reasons recorded, has
come to conclusion that the charge against petitioner came to be proved
for which punishment of reduction in basic pay by three stages was
ordered, besides ordering recovery of 50% of the financial loss occurred
to the Corporation.
10.
The appellate authority equally has gone into the grounds of
appeal raised by the petitioner and has come to conclusion that the
reasoning and as well as conclusion drawn by the disciplinary authority
was sound enough and really do not warrant any interference, however,
taking a lenient view, the punishment has been modified to the extent of
reduction in basic pay by one stage, while retaining the recovery of
financial loss, so ordered.
11.
I have gone through both the orders of disciplinary authority and
as well as the appellate authority and of the opinion that both the orders
specifically deal with the evidence on record and rendered definitive
CGR, J.
W.P.No.13467 of 2002
findings with respect to the role played by the petitioner.
As
accompanying officer, since he did sign the DCB, which clearly admits
the position that the amount that was collected on 13.02.1997, varied
with the amount that was deposited on the next day, clearly petitioner’s
negligence had a prominent role in the process of it being
misappropriated by the peon.
12.
Though learned counsel for the petitioner has relied on the
judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Ajai Kumar Srivastava1 , in fact,
paras.26 to 28 of the said judgment, really go against the petitioner for
the reason that both the orders of disciplinary authority and as well as
appellate authority did render specific reasons and findings in coming to
the conclusion as to why punishment was being imposed and that it
was not a case of absolutely no evidence at all. It is now very well
settled in cases of disciplinary proceedings, the Courts, while exercising
Certiorari Jurisdiction under Article 226 of Constitution of India, would
only step in to see as to whether the order passed by the disciplinary
authority was within jurisdiction, the procedure in which the enquiry was
conducted has been in accordance with the statutory rules, does not
violate principles of natural justice and that the findings and decisions
arrived at by the disciplinary authority rests on possible reasons, unless
it is shown that the decision was arrived at sans any reasons, no
interference is called for. Further, the Court would not try to substitute
CGR, J.
W.P.No.13467 of 2002
its views by reappreciating the evidence and material on record
transposing it as an appellate authority. The case on hand clearly does
not fall under any of the above parameters, as observed above. The
orders by respective authorities did provide for reasons in coming to the
decision of imposing penalty.
13.
Accordingly, I find no reason to interfere with the orders of
disciplinary authorities and the writ petition stands dismissed. No order
as to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending consideration, if
any, in this case shall stand closed.
Date:09.02.2026.
cs
_____________________________
JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review