Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3302 ]
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(SPecial Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE TWENTIETH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K. SARATH
WRIT PETITION N O: 405 230F 2025
Betwee n:
s.Anil Kumar, s/o Krishna Aged about 41 years, Assistant Engineer operation,
Keesara Section, TGSPDCL' R/o. Keesaragutta
...PETITIONER
AND
1.
Southem Power Distribution company of Telangana Limited, Repre-sented by
it. cnJiirr" and tvlanaging Director, ivlint Com[ound, Hyderabad' T G'
TheChairmanandManagingDirector,SouthernPowerDistributionCompany
of Telangana Ltd. Mint Compound, Hyderabad' I G
J
TheDirector,HRDTGSPDCL'CorporateOffice'MintCompound,Hyderabad'
T.G.
4. The Chief General Manager (HRD), TGSPDCL, Corporate Office' Mint
Compound, HYderabad' T.G.
5. The Chief General Manager, (OandlU) Rural Zone, TGSPDCL' Corporate
Office, Mint ComPound, HYderabad.
6. The Chief General l\ilanager, Operation TGSPDCL' Medchal Zone'
Hyderabad.
7. The Superintending Engineer, Operation, TGSPDCL, Habsiguda' Hyderabad'
8. The Divisional Engineer, Elecl. OperatioJr. Keesara, TGSPDCL' Keesara'
Habsiguda
9. State of Telangana, Represented by i!9 Principal Secretary' Energy
Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad, T.G.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the
be
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may
pleased to issue writ or direction preferably Writ of Mandamus by declaring
the action of the Respondents in ordering recovery of an amount of Rupees
7,65,3431- vide Memo. No. DEE/OP/KEESARA/JAO(FI S)/D.No.5445 dated
19-12-2025 of the 8th Respondent by placing reliance orr ;ubsequent material,
which did not form part of enquiry proceedings, as be ng arbitrary, illegal,
opposed toprinciples of natural justice, erroneous, contre ry to the material on
record and in violation of Article 14 of the Constitutiorr of lndia and to setaside the same accordingly in interest of justice-
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that r the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, th: High Court may be
pleased to suspend the operation of impu; red Memo. No.
DEE/OP/KEESAIIA/JAO(PASI N. No.5445 dated 1 9-1 2-2C 1 5proceeding issued
by the Bth Respondent.
lA NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Section '1 51 CPC praying that i r the c ircu m sta n ces
slated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, thr: High Court may be
pleased to stay the recovery of an amount of Rupees 7,( 5,343/- vide Memo.
No. DEE/OP/KEESARA/JAO(PASyD 5445 No. dated 1() 12-2025 issued by
the 8th Respondent, pending Appea l/representation dat :d 06-01-2026 and
disciplinary proceedings on the analogy of orders issue,j in similar cases in
the inte rest of justice.
Counsel for the Petitioner : MS.CHEKURI JYOTSNA DEVI
counsel for Respondents No.1to8 , .Sts[?=rrr[tRREE I 'Y,
Counsel for Respondents No.9 : GP FOR ENERGY
The Court made the following: ORDER
I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SARATH
WRIT PETITION No.4O523 of 2025
THE 2OTH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2026
Between:
S.Anil Kumar
...Petitioner
AND
Southern Power Distribution Company oI Telangana Limited,
Represented by its Chairman & Managing Director and others
...Respondents
ORDER:
Heard Ms. Chekuri Jyotsna Devi, lcarned counsel for the
petitioner; Sri N.Sridhar Reddy, learned Standing Counsel
appearing for the respondent Nos. I to 8. Pcrused the material
available on record
2. Learned coun scl for the petitioner submits that the
pctitioner is filed this Writ Petition qucstioning thc action of the
rcspondents
Rs.7,6fi,3a3/-
1n
ordcring lor recovcry ol an amount of
uide Memo No.DEE/OP/ KBESALA/JAO(PAS)/
I
I
D.No.5445 dated 19.I2.2O25 issued by the respc ndent No.8, as
illegal and arbitrary
3.
I.earned counsel for the petitioner furtht: submits that
while the petitioner was working as Assistant I ngineer in the
respondent-Company, he was placed under sr rspension uide
proceedings d.rted O9.03 .2023 in connection .r ith an alleged
ACB case registered uide Cr.No.01/RST-RRR/21 23. Thereaflcr,
departmental proceedings were initiated agains,r the petitioner
uid-e charge sheet dated 05.12.2023, wherein i. is alleged that
on 30.01.2023, a theft had taken place due to .rcgligence and
dereliction of cluties on t.he part of the petition: -. Also, similar
charges wcre framed against three other Artisan: along with the
petitioner. But, no final orders in the departmetr al proceedings
is passed in respect of the petitioner, whereat in respect of
other three Artisans, the disciplinary proceed Lgs have bcen
concluded and punishment orders were issur:' I by imposing
penalty ol stoppage o[ two annual grade iri;rements with
cumulative effect.
\_
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the
impugned order of recovery was issued by the respondcnt No.B
rvithout issuing any notice or opportunit-y ol hearing to the
petitioner, pending disciplinary proceedings, which is contrary
to the principles of natural justice and requested to allow the
Writ Petition by setting aside the impugned memo dated
19.12.2025, issued by the respondent No.B
5. On the other hand, that learned Sternding Counsel
appearing for the respondent Nos.1 to B, basing on the counter
affrdavit, submits that while the petitioncr working as Assistant
Dngineer/ Operation in
the Keesara Division, due to his
negiigence and dereliction of duties along with tl-rree other
Artisans, theft ol material occurred from the Sub-station and
the petitioner being the supervising authority and the said three
Artisans were responsiblc for the s:r.icl loss. Thcreafter, an
enquiry was conducted against the said artisans and
punishment was imposed on them
6.
Learned Standing Counsel appearing lor the respondent
Nos.1 to 8 further submits that, sincc the pctitioncr is under
tl
suspensioil with regard to the case registerec by the AntiCorruption Burr:au, no separate action has beer taken against
him till date. I{orvcver, the Chief Engineer (Otr vl), uide Mcmo
d,ated 22.1O.2024, constituted a Committee (i('Inprising four
senior officers, including two Superintendinp Engineers, to
ascertain the quantum of loss arising out of the t left of material
lrom 5 MVA Porvcr 1'ransformers and to sL rmit a report'
Thereafter, the Committee, upon enquiry, subrl tted its report
recommending stringcnt action against the letitioner and
others for lapses in discharge of their drr ies and also
recommended lor rccovcry of the cost of stolen rr.; Lterial from thc
concerned Persons.
7.
Learncd Stanrling Counsel appearing for I hc rcspondent
Nos. I to 8 furt her submits that, based on the s aid report, the
impugned Mcmo dated 19.12.2025 was is sued by the
respondent No.8, directing recovery of Rs.7,65'l 43/- lrom thc
petitioner at 4Ool, of the total loss caused to 1l :e respondentCompany and. 2Onk each from the other three Ar :isans' As the
enquiry had already been conducted and a dec.' ion was taken
\
\
to recover the loss from the concerned employees, issuance of
any further notice to the petitioner is not required. Further, the
impugned proceedings were issued solely for rccovery of the loss
occasioned by the theft of material lrom the Sub-Station and
the petitioner being the supervising authority held liable to the
e
xtent of 4Ook of the loss, while the remaining 600/o has been
apportloned among the three Artisans aI 2Ooh each, which has
no itlegality or irregularity in the impugned action and in view o[
the same, requested to dismiss the Writ Pe tition
8.
Aftcr hearing both sides and perusing the materiai on
record, this Court is of the considered view that thc petitioner is
questioning the impugned Memo No.DEE/OP/KtrESARA/
JAO(PAS)/D.No.5445 dated 79.12.2025 issued by the
respondent No.8. The petitioner and other three Artisans were
subjccted to disciplinary proceedings lor the theft of material
occurred from the Sub-station. 1'he respondent authorities
have initiated disciplinary proceedings against the petitioner
and other Artisans separately. The disciplinary proceedings with
regard to the petitioner as on this date have not been
concluded. The disciplinary proceedings ag: I est the three
Artisans were concluded and imposed punishrr, trt of stoppage
of two annual incrcment s rvith cumulative efft:r" and the same
is pending before the appellate authority. While it being so, the
respondent authorities, without concluding rJ Le disciplinary
proceedings agarnst the petitioner and also withc ut disposing of
the appeal hled by the Artisans, issued di:l:rent recovcry
proceedings.
9. In the instant case, the respondent autll lrities without
fixing the liability on thc petitioner and without :oncluding the
disciplinary procccdings against him, issucd the impugned
recovery proccedings ttide Memo dated 19.l).2025. The
respondent authorities have constituted a ( )ommittee for
recovery of loss causcd due to theft of tht: material and
conducted parallel procccdings in spite of pendi rg disciplinary
proceedings by enquiry without issuing notice t,r the petitioner,
which is arbitrary and illegal. If the respondent; want to take
appropriate action for recovery of amounts besi-:s disciplinary
proceedings, they have to wait for conclusion of t-re disciplinary
\
a\
proceedings and should also give an opportunity to the
petitioner for submissions of an explanation and without doing
the same, the respondents have issued the impugnecl recovery
proceedings and the same are liable to be set aside'
10. In view of the above hndings, this Writ Petition is disposed
ol by setting aside the impugned Memo No.DEE/OP/KEESARA/
JAO(PAS)/D.No.5445 dated 19-12.2025 issued by the
respondent No.8. Howcver, this order does not preclude the
respondents to take appropriate action after conclusion of the
disciplinary proccedings and if any causc survives, they can
issue recovery proceedings by following due process of law'
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in this Writ
Petition shall stand closed. There shall be no order as to costs'
U
/-K.V.O.NARSl
TRAR
STANT
//TRUE COPY//
ECTION OFFICER
To,
The Chairman and Managing Director, Southern Power istribution CompanY
of Telangana Limited, Mint Compound, Hyderabad' I Q
2. The chairman and Managing Director, southern Power Distribution company
of Telangana Ltd. Mint Compound, Hyderabad' I 'G
3. The Director, HRD TGSPDCL, Corporate office, Mint Compound, Hyderabad,
T.G.
4. The Chief General Manager (HRD), TGSPDCL, Corporate Office' Mint
Compound, HYderabad, T.G
5. The Chief General Manager, (OandM) Rural Zone, TGSPDCL' Corporate
Office, Mint ComPound, HYderabad.
6. The Chief General Manager, Operation TGSPDCL, Medchal Zone'
Hyderabad.
7. The Superintending Engineer, Operation, TGSPDCL, Habsiguda' Hyderabad
8. The Divisional Engineer, Elecl. Operation Keesara, TGSPDCL' Keesara'
Hal-lsiguda
i
9. The Principal Secretarv. Energy Department, Secretarl I Tetangana
Hyderabad, T.G.
\
10.One CC to Ms.CHEKUR| JYOTSNA DEVI, Advocate.
,
State,
[(] rUCl
11. One CC to SRt N.SREEDHAR REDDY, SC
FOR TGSF t ,CL. tOpUCI
12.Two CCs to GP FOR ENERGY, High Court for
the Statr; :f Tetangana at
Hyderabad. [OUT]
13. Two CD Copies.
d BSK
I
HIGH COURT
DATED:2010212026
CC TODAY
!
I
I
) ;\' c OF
(J rtB
)
rt
lut
-'.>
l)
,;
.7
ORDER
WP.No.40523 ot 2025
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
2?
9l,.
c
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review