Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Date of decision: 18th May 2026
+
MAC.APP. 825/2018 & CM APPL. 37714/2018 CM APPL.
62741/2023
ROYAL SUNDARAM GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Ms. Suman Bagga, Advocate with
Ms. Mouli Sharma, Advocate
versus
SUSHIL KUMAR SACHDEVA & ORS
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Sumit Dutt Dixit, Advocate
for R-1 to R-4.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGEMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J:(ORAL)
1.
Ms.
Suman
Bagga,
counsel
appearing
on
behalf
of
appellant/Insurance Company, challenges the award of the MACT dated
29th November 2017, on the following grounds:
(i)
The benchmark income of the deceased Sadhna Sachdeva
was taken as Rs.83,823/- per month, which was as per the
salary slip of July 2015, considering that the accident had
occurred on 06th July 2015; whereas counsel for appellant
contends that the salary of June 2015 ought to have been
taken into account, as per which the salary was Rs.81,563/-.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 825/2018
13:31:38
(ii)
For calculating the loss of dependency, a deduction of 1/3rd
was made towards personal and living expenses, as there
were two sons/dependants, who were 20½ years and 23½
years of age at the date of the accident, but were not
financially independent.
Ms. Bagga states that, even
otherwise, the husband of the deceased was also an earning
member and was drawing a salary of Rs.76,458/- at the time
of the accident as an employee of Indian Bank and,
therefore, the dependency of family cannot be restricted
solely on the income of the deceased wife. Ms. Suman
Bagga, counsel for appellant/Insurance Company, contends
that, as regards dependency, the two children were only
partially dependent on the deceased and, therefore, 1/2
ought to have been deducted, instead of 1/3rd.
(iii)
Transport allowance of Rs.6,816/- ought to have been
deducted from the gross salary. Further, she contends that
transport allowance would have to be excluded, since only
the income, which accrued to the personal benefit of
deceased, would have to be taken into account. Counsel
contends that transport allowance is a component which is
not personal to the deceased and, therefore, will not be
taken into account post his death.
2.
Mr. Sunil Dutt Dixit, counsel for respondents/claimants, in
response to the submissions made by Ms. Suman Bagga, counsel for
appellant/Insurance Company recorded in the order passed by this Court
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 825/2018
13:31:38
on 24th February 2026, has made the following submissions:
(i)
MACT had taken the benchmark income of deceased on the
basis of income on the date of accident, which was slated as
Rs.83,823/-, as per the salary slip given for July 2015. Even
though the deceased had only served for 6 days in the
month of July 2015 before the accident occurred, the salary
slip was enough proof to show that this said amount was
deceased’s gross pay.
(ii)
On the issue of dependency, he states that both children of
the deceased were not working at the time of accident; the
younger son, who was about 20 years, had completed his 1 st
year of Bachelors of Business Administration (‘BBA’)
Degree and the elder son, who was about 23 years of age,
was looking for a job, even though he had completed his
Bachelors of Technology (‘B.Tech.’) Degree. Therefore, he
contends that the husband and father-in-law of deceased
were not considered as dependants and only the two
children were considered as dependants.
(iii)
As regards transport allowance, Mr. Dixit, counsel for
respondents/claimants, has relied upon judgments in Vijay
Kumar Rastogi v. Uttar Pradesh State Roadways
Transport Corporation, 2018 SCC OnLine SC 193,
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nalini & Ors. 2024 SCC
OnLine SC 2252, Meenakshi v. Oriental Insurance Co.
Ltd., 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1872, Kavita Devi & Ors. v.
Sunil Kumar & Anr. 2025 INSC 938 and Manorma Sinha
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 825/2018
13:31:38
& Anr. v. The Divisional Manager, Oriental Insurance
Company Ltd & Anr. 2025 INSC 1237 to contend that
transport allowance forms part of the income of deceased,
which was taxable and was therefore, for benefit of the
family and should not be deducted from the salary.
(iv)
Mr. Dixit, counsel for respondents/claimants, further
contends that the MACT has already deducted 20% towards
Income Tax and, therefore, amounts which form part of the
transport allowance should also be considered as a part of
income for the purpose of computation of loss of
dependency.
3.
Having considered the submissions of counsels for the parties, in
the opinion of the Court, the benchmark income taken by the MACT
need not be displaced, considering that the salary slip for July 2015
categorically stated the salary to which the deceased was eligible.
4.
Ms. Bagga's submission that deceased had only worked for 13
days in the month of July 2015 may not be relevant, considering that the
salary slip issued by the Office of the District and Sessions Judge clearly
mentions the salary for July, which indicates that the deceased was
entitled to that salary starting from July 2015.
5.
On the issue of transport allowance, yet again, the Court is not in
agreement with Ms. Suman Bagga's assertion, since there are various
judgments, as noted above in paragraph 2 (iii), which categorically
provide that transport allowance forms part of the income of the
deceased.
6.
On the third issue of dependency, Ms. Bagga has drawn the
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 825/2018
13:31:38
attention of the Court to the cross-examination of PW1 recorded on 02nd
May 2016, which notes that her older son, Kunal Sachdeva, was working
in a private company in Bangalore and was earning Rs. 22,000/-, while
his younger son, Pulkit Sachdeva, was studying in second year of BBA.
7.
Though the accident took place on 06th July 2015, and, as per Mr.
Dixit, the elder son of the deceased was not working when the accident
took place, considering that this evidence has been placed on record a
year after the accident, the elder son ought to be considered as
contributing to family income.
8.
The Constitutional Bench of the Supreme Court in National
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680 emphasised that
“just compensation” under Section 168 of the Motor Vehicle Act 1988
must rest on fairness, reasonableness and equity, avoiding both windfall
gains and inadequate awards. The Court stressed pragmatic and uniform
computation, including future prospects, to ensure proximity to real loss.
Relevant paragraph is extracted as under:
“55. Section 168 of the Act deals with the concept of
“just compensation” and the same has to be
determined on the foundation of fairness,
reasonableness and equitability on acceptable legal
standard because such determination can never be
in arithmetical exactitude. It can never be perfect.
The aim is to achieve an acceptable degree of
proximity to arithmetical precision on the basis of
materials brought on record in an individual case.
The conception of “just compensation” has to be
viewed
through
the
prism
of
fairness,
reasonableness and non-violation of the principle of
equitability. In a case of death, the legal heirs of the
claimants cannot expect a windfall. Simultaneously,
the compensation granted cannot be an apology for
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 825/2018
13:31:38
compensation. It cannot be a pittance. Though the
discretion vested in the tribunal is quite wide, yet it
is obligatory on the part of the tribunal to be guided
by the expression, that is, “just compensation”. The
determination has to be on the foundation of
evidence brought on record as regards the age and
income of the deceased and thereafter the apposite
multiplier to be applied. The formula relating to
multiplier has been clearly stated in Sarla Verma
(2009) 6 SCC 121 and it has been approved in
Reshma Kumari (2013) 9 SCC 65 . The age and
income, as stated earlier, have to be established by
adducing evidence. The tribunal and the courts have
to bear in mind that the basic principle lies in
pragmatic computation which is in proximity to
reality. It is a well-accepted norm that money cannot
substitute a life lost but an effort has to be made for
grant of just compensation having uniformity of
approach. There has to be a balance between the
two extremes, that is, a windfall and the pittance, a
bonanza and the modicum. In such an adjudication,
the duty of the tribunal and the courts is difficult and
hence, an endeavour has been made by this Court
for standardisation which in its ambit includes
addition of future prospects on the proven income at
present. As far as future prospects are concerned,
there has been standardisation keeping in view the
principle of certainty, stability and consistency. We
approve the principle of “standardisation” so that a
specific and certain multiplicand is determined for
applying the multiplier on the basis of age.”
(emphasis added)
9.
Therefore, considering that the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 has been
enacted with the primary object of providing a statutory framework for
awarding just and reasonable compensation to victims of motor vehicle
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 825/2018
13:31:38
accidents, or to their dependents who are rendered helpless and
financially vulnerable due to the untimely death or injury of a family
member, the provisions of the Act cannot be permitted to be misused for
obtaining undue benefit or making a profit out of a claim.
10.
As held by the Supreme Court in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport
Corporation (2009) 6 SCC 121, compensation under the Act is intended
to be fair, equitable, and not a bonanza. The relevant paragraphs from
Sarla Verma (supra) in this regard are extracted as under:
“16. Compensation awarded does not become “just
compensation” merely because the Tribunal considers
it to be just. For example, if on the same or similar
facts (say the deceased aged 40 years having annual
income of Rs 45,000 leaving his surviving wife and
child), one Tribunal awards Rs 10,00,000 another
awards Rs 5,00,000, and yet another awards Rs
1,00,000, all believing that the amount is just, it cannot
be said that what is awarded in the first case and the
last case is just compensation. “Just compensation” is
adequate compensation which is fair and equitable, on
the facts and circumstances of the case, to make good
the loss suffered as a result of the wrong, as far as
money can do so, by applying the well-settled
principles relating to award of compensation. It is not
intended to be a bonanza, largesse or source of profit.
(emphasis added)
11.
Moreover, since the father was also earning and was not
considered a dependent, the question of partial dependency would also
arise. However, no legal substantiation has been provided by Ms. Bagga
in this regard. Nevertheless, the Court is of the view that the deduction
towards personal expenses from the benchmark income shall be taken as
1/2 instead of 1/3rd .
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 825/2018
13:31:38
12.
On the basis of principles enunciated in National Insurance Co.
Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi and Ors. (2017) 16 SCC 680, the following will be
altered:
i.
Loss of love and affection awarded st Rs. 1,00,000/- ought not to
be granted on the basis of the principles enunciated in United
India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satinder Kaur @ Satwinder Kaur
and Ors. (2021) 11 SCC 780;
ii.
Loss of consortium will be Rs. 40,000/- x 4 = 1,60,000/- instead of
Rs. 40,000/-;
13.
Revised compensation, therefore, is as under:
Sr. No. Heads
1.
Monthly income of the
deceased (A)
2.
Add-Future Prospects (B)
3.
Less-personal expenses of the
deceased (C)
Awarded by the
Tribunal
Rs.83,823/-
Awarded by the
Court
Rs.83,823/-
30% of Rs.83,823/= 25,146.90/1/3 of Rs.
1,08,969.90/- = Rs.
36,323.30/-
30% of Rs.83,823/= 25,146.90/1/2 of
1,08,969.90/- =
54,484.95/Rs. 6,53,819.40/(rounded of to Rs.
6,53,820/-)
Rs. 84,99,660/-
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
Annual loss of dependency
[(A+B) - C ] x 12= D]
Multiplier (E)
Total loss of dependency (D x
E) = (F)
Compensation for loss of love
and affection (G)
Compensation for loss of
consortium (H)
Compensation for loss of estate
(I)
Compensation towards funeral
expenses (J)
Total Compensation
(F+G+H+I+J = K)
Interest Awarded
Reduced Compensation
Rs.8,71,764/13
Rs,90,66,343/-
Nil
Rs. 1,00,000/Rs. 40,000/-
Rs. 1,60,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 92,36,343/-
Rs. 86,89,660/-
9% per annum
Rs. 5,46,683/-
9% per annum
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 825/2018
13:31:38
14.
Accordingly, the compensation is reduced by Rs. 5,46,683/-.
15.
Vide order dated 14th September 2018, this Court directed the
appellant to deposit 90% of awarded amount, along with accrued
interest, with the Registrar General of this Court within four weeks from
today.
16.
On 18th September 2023, this Court directed release of 60% of the
amount deposited by the appellant.
17.
Accordingly, the balance amount of the revised compensation, if
any, be deposited by the appellant within 4 weeks with the Registrar
General of this Court, along with accrued interest. Upon such deposit,
this balance amount be released as a lump sum to the claimants in
accordance with the apportionment directed by MACT in the impugned
award.
18.
Appeal is disposed of. Pending applications (if any) are rendered
infructuous.
19.
Statutory deposit shall be refunded to appellant/Insurance
Company only upon deposit of the enhanced amount along with the
accrued interest.
20.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
MAY 18, 2026/RK/bp
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 825/2018
13:31:38
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review