Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
UKHC010041592026
HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND AT NAINITAL
First Bail Application No. 417 of 2026
Shoaib
--Applicant
Versus
State Of Uttarakhand
--Respondent
With
First Bail Application No. 323 of 2026
Toseef Khan
--Applicant
Versus
State Of Uttarakhand
--Respondent
With
First Bail Application No. 816 of 2026
Rehan
--Applicant
Versus
State Of Uttarakhand
--Respondent
With
First Bail Application No. 2547 of 2025
Riyasat Kha
--Applicant
Versus
State Of Uttarakhand
--Respondent
UKHC010041592026
With
First Bail Application No. 354 of 2026
Sajid Khan
--Applicant
Versus
State Of Uttarakhand
--Respondent
---------------------------------------------------------------------Presence:Mr. D.K. Sharma, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. Lalit Sharma,
learned counsel for the applicant in BA1 No. 417 of 2026, BA1 No. 2547 of
2025.
Mr. Sanjay Bhatt, learned counsel for the applicant in BA1 Nos. 354 of
2026 and BA1 No. 323 of 2026, BA1 No. 816 of 2026.
Mr. Tumul Nainwal, learned A.G.A. for the State.
Mr. Pooran Singh Rawat and Mr. M.C. Upadhyay, learned counsel for the
complainant.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Order Reserved on: 04.08.2026
Order Delivered on: 19.08.2026
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Rakesh Thapliyal, J.
1.
All these bail applications are moved by the applicants
Shoaib, Toseef Khan, Rehan, Riyasat Kha and Sajid Khan, who
are facing the trial for the offences punishable under sections
103(1), 109(1), 190, 191(2), 191(3), 333, 351(2), 352, 61(2), 3(5) of
BNS, 2023 r/w section 3/25/30 of Arms Act arising out of First
Information Report dated 19.08.2025 bearing Case Crime No.
0263 of 2025 P.S. Kiccha, District Udham Singh Nagar.
2.
All these bail applications are clubbed and are being
decided together with the consent of learned counsel for the
parties since all the applicants herein are seeking regular bail in
connection with Case Crime No. 263 of 2025.
UKHC010041592026
3.
Brief facts of the case are that on 18.08.2025 at about 10:55
AM Rehan S/o Firashat, Sajid Khan S/o Litafat, Riyasat Kha
S/o Litafat and Akeel Khan S/o Mohd. Jaan entered in the
house of the informant Sami Khan @ Sameer S/o Akram khan
and they abuses and also threatened to kill since the candidate
of Hazi Sarvar Yaar Khan had lost the Gram Pradhan Election
and then they all opened fire due to which the informant’s
brother ‘Aalim’ (aged about 22 years) sustained a gunshot
injury on his chest and died at the spot.
The entire sequence of the incident wherein the deceased
“Aalim” was killed was actively being recorded by his sister
“Mrs. Meena” W/o of “Junaid Khan” from roof top of her
residential house located only at a distance of about 200 meter
from the place of incident and upon noticing her capturing
entire crime scene an aggressive mob of some persons rushed
towards her residence and opened gunfire with the intent to
eliminate her, but she escaped unhurt then members of the mob
trespassed into her house, snatched her mobile phone
containing the video of first incident and looted cash also.
Regarding this incident a separate First Information Report
bearing FIR No. 264 of 2025 was lodged by the witness of first
incident Mrs. Meena under sections 109(1), 115(2), 311 and
321(2) of BNS, 2023. This subsequent FIR was registered
specifically by giving reference of first incident establishing that
the assault, house trespass and robbery were committed solely
to suppress evidence and retaliate against the incident for
recording the incident of murder of her brother.
4.
Now, on completion of the investigation of FIR No. 263 of
2025 charge-sheet no. 256 of 2025 was submitted on 19.11.2025
wherein in total six persons namely (i) Akeel Khan S/o Mohd.
UKHC010041592026
Jaan Khan, (ii) Rehan Khan S/o Firashat Khan, (iii) Sajid Khan
S/o Litafat Khan, (iv) Shoaib S/o Fariyad Khan, (v) Riyasat Kha
S/o Litafat Khan and (vi) Toseef Khan have been chargesheeted
and all these accused persons except Akeel Khan, who is
already granted bail by the Coordinate Bench now moved these
bail applications for seeking regular bail in connection with
Case Crime No. 263 of 2025. Now all these bail applications are
being discussed as follows:
(A) Bail Application No. 417 of 2026 ‘Shoaib vs. State of
Uttarakhand’
(i)
Mr. D.K. Sharma, learned senior counsel with Mr. Lalit
Sharma argued that the present applicant is innocent and has
been falsely implicated and the main role of hatching conspiracy
to commit the crime was attributed to “Mr. Hazi Sarvar Yaar
Khan” in the present FIR i.e. FIR No. 263 of 2025 but during
investigation he has been exonerated though there is a specific
allegation against him since the FIR alleges “gkth ljoj ;kj [kku us
vius leFkZdksa ds lkFk feydj ‘kM+;a= jpk”. They submits that entire
prosecution story is based upon false and concocted story,
which is evident from the fact that another co-accused Toseef
Khan though is not named in the FIR No. 263 of 2025 and even
both the eye witnesses of the incident namely Shami and Ikram
Khan did not disclose his name even then he has been
chargesheeted.
(ii)
Mr. D.K. Sharma further submits that all other witnesses
are interested witnesses except one Mr. Chand Miya, who is an
independent witness and has not corroborated the version of
the complainant or any of the alleged eye witnesses. He further
argued that charge-sheet has been filed in a hurried manner
without ballistic report and even otherwise no specific role is
UKHC010041592026
assigned to the present applicant and furthermore one of the coaccused Akeel Khan is already enlarged on bail by the
Coordinate Bench on 08.05.2026 in Bail Application No. 392 of
2026 and, as such, the present applicant Shoaib Khan deserves
for the benefit of parity since identical role is assigned to him.
(iii)
He further submits that the incident of both the FIRs i.e.
FIR No. 263 of 2025 and 264 of 2025 are in fact is in respect of the
same incident since the date and time of the incident is same i.e.
18.08.2025 at 10:55 hours lodged in the same police station but
were investigated by different I.O.s who in turn filed two
separate charge-sheets and now two Session Trials are going on,
however, the trial court proceeding arising out of FIR No. 264 of
2025 is stayed by the Coordinate Bench on 08.04.2026 in C528
No. 617 of 2026. Apart from this, he submits that the present
applicant “Shoaib” is languishing in jail since 30.08.2025 and
suffered incarceration of more than 11 months, therefore, he
may be released on bail .
(B)
Bail Application No. 323 of 2026 ‘Toseef Khan vs. State
of Uttarakhand’
(i)
Mr. Sanjay Bhatt, learned counsel for the present applicant
“Toseef Khan” submits that the present applicant is innocent
and has been falsely implicated and is languishing in jail since
23.08.2025 and the persons, who are implicated in both the FIRs
i.e. FIR No. 263 of 2025 and 264 of 2025 are different, therefore,
the very basis of prosecution is false and does not inspire
confidence. He submits that none of the accused persons in both
the FIRs are common though both the FIRs raised an allegation
with regard to murder of one Aalim, therefore, the prosecution
story is full of doubts from its very inception. He submits that
the main role of hatching conspiracy is attributed to one Mr.
UKHC010041592026
Hazi Sarvar Yaar Khan but surprisingly he has been exonerated
and further there is no factum of motive attributed to the
present applicant to commit the alleged crime.
(ii)
Mr. Bhatt further submits that the present applicant
Toseef Khan was not named in the FIR No. 263 of 2025 and even
the two eye witnesses namely Shami and Ikram Khan did not
disclose his name and it was only after 09.11.2025 the informant
to the FIR disclosed the name of the present applicant, which is
nothing but an afterthought. He submits that all other witnesses
are interested witnesses except one Chand Miya, who has not
corroborated the version of the informant as well as alleged eye
witnesses of the incident.
(iii)
He also submits that in absence of ballistic report the
charge-sheet has been filed without ascertaining whether the
weapon as shown to be recovered on his pointing out was used
in the commission of the crime and, as such, the entire
prosecution story is full of doubts and the investigation is also
faulty and there are chances of acquittal of the applicant. He
further submits that one of the co-accused has been granted bail
by the Coordinate Bench and, as such, since the applicant have
been assigned the same role as assigned to the co-accused, who
has been granted bail, therefore, the present applicant entitle the
benefit of parity.
(iv)
He further submits that in reference to the incident of FIR
No. 264 of 2025 14 persons were named but the charge-sheet is
submitted only against four persons and Trial Court proceeding
arising out of this FIR No. 264 of 2025 is already stayed by the
Coordinate Bench.
UKHC010041592026
(v)
Apart from this, Mr. Bhatt also pointed out that the
informant Mr. Shami Khan @ Sameer S/o Akram Khan and his
associate namely Ms. Nazia and her husband Gaffar Khan have a
long criminal history and they all are indulged in supply of
illegal arms and weapons.
(C)
Bail Application No. 2547 of 2025 ‘Riyasat Kha vs. State
of Uttarakhand’
(i)
Mr. D.K. Sharma, learned senior counsel and Mr. Lalit
Sharma submits that the present applicant Riyasat Kha is
innocent and has been falsely implicated and reiterate the same
argument, which they advanced in reference to the co-accused
Shoaib, who is seeking bail in Bail Application No. 417 of 2026,
however, only this much argument they further advanced that
the present applicant “Riyasat” having valid licence to possess
rifle, however, in absence of ballistic report he has been chargesheeted, therefore, it cannot be said that the incident was caused
by the rifle of the present applicant.
(ii)
They further submit that the present applicant is
languishing in jail since 15.09.2025 and as the chargesheet is
already filed and as such no further custodial interrogation of
the present applicant is required and since of the co-accused is
already enlarged on bail, therefore, he may also be released on
bail.
(D)
Bail Application No. 816 of 2026 ‘Rehan vs. State of
Uttarakhand’
(i)
In the instant bail application Mr. Sanjay Bhatt, learned
counsel, argued that the present applicant “Rehan” is
languishing in jail since 24.08.2025 and is a young boy of 30
years and no specific role has been assigned to him and the co7
UKHC010041592026
accused Akeel Khan is already enlarged on bail by the
Coordinate Bench and in fact the dispute is nothing but due to
political rivalry between two different political ideologies.
(ii)
He further submits that the informant to the FIR No. 263
of 2025 have a criminal antecedent and is languising in Bareilly
Jail in connection with FIR No. 122 of 2026 P.S. Bahedi District
Bareily, wherein, he is involved in supply of illegal fire arms
and he has also a long criminal history. Rest of the arguments he
has reiterated, which he advanced in Bail Application No. 323 of
2026 Toseef Khan vs. State of Uttarakhand.
(E)
Bail Application No. 354 of 2026 ‘Sajid Khan vs. State of
Uttarakhand’
(i)
The present applicant Sajid Khan is also praying for bail in
reference to FIR No. 263 of 2025 on whose behalf Mr. Sanjay
Bhatt argued that the present applicant Sajid Khan is the father
of co-accused “Toseef Khan” and is innocent and has been
falsely implicated and he has no criminal antecedents.
(ii)
He further submits that the present applicant is not named
in the FIR though during investigation involvement of the
present applicant came into light as the weapon was recovered
on his pointing out though he was not present at the time of
alleged incident.
(iii)
He further submits that the entire prosecution story is
based on false pretext and there is no evidence with regard to
any intention and motive of the applicant and is implicated only
due to political rivalry and rest of the argument he has
reiterated which he has advanced in respect of the other coaccused “Toseef Khan”.
UKHC010041592026
5.
Per contra, learned counsel for the informant Mr. Pooran
Singh Rawat and Mr. M.C. Upadhyaya vehemently opposed the
application of all the accused persons and submits that all the
persons who are chargesheeted committed the offence in
furtherance to their common intention and motive with
common object. He also submits that the arms and weapon used
in the crime were also recovered on their pointing out and as
per the CCTV footages and their mobile location they were
present at the place of occurrence. In reference to the accused
“Shoaib”, the applicant of Bail Application No. 417 of 2026 he
submits that this applicant is the main accused, who himself
admits that he fired gunshot at the deceased after taking
“Tamancha” from the co-accused Sajid Khan and the entire
incident was captured in the CCTV footages which clearly
establishes his involvement. He also submits that the weapon
used in the commission of crime was also recovered and the
mobile location of the present applicant was found at the place
of occurrence at the time of the incident. He further submits that
eye witnesses of the incident namely Sajid Khan, Junaid, Akram,
Ikram, Shami and cousin sister Meena have supported the case
of the prosecution. He also submits that the applicant Shoaib
have criminal antecedent in connection with FIR No. 227 of
2023.
6.
In reference to the co-accused “Toseef Khan”, the
applicant of Bail Application No. 323 of 2025 he submits that
this applicant though was not named in the FIR but he was seen
in the CCTV footages proceeding towards the complainant’s
house while carrying rifle and as per the statement of the eye
witness his active role was found in commission of the crime.
He also submits that his mobile location was also found at the
UKHC010041592026
place of occurrence and rifle with two empty 315 bore cartridges
were also recovered from his possession.
7.
In reference to the accused Rehan, the applicant of Bail
Application No. 816 of 2026 he submits that mobile location of
this applicant was found at the place of occurrence at the time of
incident and 315 bore tamancha and one live cartridge was also
recovered from his possession. He further submits that as per
the statement of witnesses namely Junaid, Rehan and Sajid the
present applicant Rehan take active role in causing fire from his
tamancha and he has criminal antecedent also.
8.
In reference to accused-applicant Riyasat Kha, the
applicant of Bail Application No. 2547 of 2025 Mr. Pooran Singh
Rawat submits this applicant is also named in the FIR and was
seen in the CCTV footages proceeding towards complainant’s
house while carrying a fire arm and his mobile location was also
found at the place of occurrence and 315 bore rifle was also
recovered from his possession and as per the statement of eye
witness the present applicant is also one of the main accused
and the issue of political rivalry is only developed to seek the
bail.
9.
In reference to the co-accused Sajid Khan, the applicant of
Bail Application No. 354 of 2026 Mr. Rawat argued that this
applicant also named in the FIR and was seen in the CCTV
footages proceeding towards the complainant’s house carrying
tamancha and he was also seen in the CCTV footages while
firing towards the complainant’s house and his mobile location
was also found at the place of occurrence and 315 bore
tamancha was also recovered and he is also having criminal
antecedent.
UKHC010041592026
10.
On the other side, Mr. Tumul Nainwal, learned A.G.A. for
the State submits that firstly the incident relating to FIR No. 263
of 2025 and FIR No. 264 of 2025 are relating to two distinct
incidents occurring at two separate locations and are at the
distance of 60 to 70 meter and the investigation reveals that both
the incidents was caused due the rivalry in reference to Gram
Panchayat Election of 2025 of Village Darau. He submits that
since both the FIRs relates to two distinct offences though on the
same date two different incidents were happened. In the first
incident a man was killed in his house and in the second
incident an attempt was made to kill the sister of deceased of
first incident by house trespass causing theft also and that is the
reason that both the incidents was investigated separately by
two different I.O.s. He also pointed out that there are two more
FIRs i.e. FIR No. 268 of 2025 and FIR No. 270 of 2025 which
relates to a police encounter dated 24.08.2025 in which two coaccused
persons
“Sajid
Khan”
and
“Gulnawaz”
were
apprehended and this separate incident are being investigated
by another I.O. of P.S. Pulbhatta.
11.
Mr. Nainwal argued that all these applicants have been
chargesheeted with the charge of killing one Aalim, a 22 years
boy, the brother of informant in an well organized and planned
manner, who died at the spot due to gunshot injury at his chest
and the post-mortem also confirmed cause of death as shock
due to ante-mortem fire arm injury, which is also corroborated
by Dr. Yadhuraj Bhatt, who conducted the post-mortem.
12.
Learned A.G.A. Mr. Tumul Nainwal further submits that
on completion of investigation the charge-sheet is filed on
19.11.2025 against six persons, who are applicants herein, and
one Akeel Khan, who have also actively involved in the
UKHC010041592026
commission of crime and also named in the FIR and was one of
the member of four armed assailants who entered into the
informant’s house and opened fire and after causing incident he
also absconded from the place of incident, subsequently, he was
also declared a proclaimed offender then he was arrested on
23.08.2025 along with co-accused Rehan Khan from Sharma
Dhaba located at Pulbhatta road District Bareilly and one pistol
(tamancha) 315 bore with one live cartridge was also recovered
from his personal possession at the time of arrest, consequently,
section 3/25 of Arms Act was also added against him. In
reference to this accused, learned A.G.A. submits that this
accused is enlarged on bail by the Coordinate Bench.
13.
Learned A.G.A. makes following submission in reference
to each of the accused:
i.
Shoaib S/o Fariyad Khan, the applicant of Bail
Application No. 417 of 2016. In reference to this person,
he submits that he is named in the FIR and surrendered
before the Trial Court and in his confessional statement
he admits that he caused fire from tamancha handed over
to him by co-accused Sajid Khan on the date of
occurrence and his presence is also corroborated by his
location as per CCTV footages from which it reveals that
this accused Shoaib firing towards the deceased with
tamancha taken from co-accused Sajid Khan and is now
chargesheeted.
ii.
Toseef Khan S/o Sajid Khan, the applicant of Bail
Application No. 323 of 2026. In reference to this applicant
Mr. Nainwal submits that he was arrested on 27.08.2025
initially in FIR No. 264 of 2025 but on interrogation he is
also found to be involved in the present FIR No. 263 of
UKHC010041592026
2025. He further submits that in his confessional
statement he admits his guilt that on 18.08.2025 he fired
from his father’s licensed rifle directly at the deceased
Aalim’s chest, which is also corroborated by an
independent eye witness Ashraf S/o Alam Khan, who
has specifically stated that the bullet fired by the present
applicant Toseef struck the deceased. He also submits
that on his pointing out the rifle (NPB Bore No.
AB0615648) the licence of which is in the name of his
father who is also chargesheeted and two empty
cartridges along with a cartridge belt was also recovered
on his pointing out from a cattle shed at his aunt’s house.
iii.
Rehan S/o Firashat Khan, the applicant of Bail
Application No. 816 of 2026. In reference to this accused,
Mr. Nainwal submits that this applicant is also named in
the FIR and is one of the four armed assailants and he
was absconded after causing the incident and was
arrested on 23.08.2025 along with Akeel Khan from
district Bareilly and one live cartridge of 315 bore was
also recovered from his possession. He further submits
that the CCTV footages obtained from the vicinity of the
spot shows that all the accused persons armed with stick
and rods moving towards and pelting stones at the
informant’s house at the time of occurrence and
subsequently this accused is also chargesheeted.
iv.
Riyasat Kha S/o Litafat Khan, the applicant of Bail
Application No. 2547 of 2025. In reference to this
applicant, Mr. Nainwal submits that this applicant is also
named in the FIR and he himself has surrendered before
the Trial Court along with the co-accused Shoaib and the
UKHC010041592026
CCTV footages shows that he was armed with gun
moving towards the informant’s house at the time of
occurrence and in his confessional statement he claimed
that his licensed rifle was lying at his house with his wife
“Ajmi”, however, on 16.11.2025 his licensed rifle (NPB
315 Bore No. AB0510569, Licence No. 485/GH/PSKCH/06)
was
recovered
from
his
own
house.
Consequently, section 30 of Arms Act was also added
against him and he is also chargesheeted.
v.
Sajid Khan S/o Litafat Khan, the applicant of Bail
Application No. 354 of 2026. In reference to this accused
person Mr. Nainwal submits that this applicant is also
named in the FIR and he was the member of the armed
group who entered into the informant’s house and he was
arrested on 24.08.2025 in a police encounter regarding
which a separate FIR No. 270 of 2025 was registered for
the offence punishable under section 109(1) of BNS, 2023,
r/w section 3/25 of Arms Act along with one Gulnawaz
(accused in FIR No. 264 of 2025) and one tamancha 315
bore with one empty and two live cartridges were also
recovered from his possession. He further submits that as
per the CCTV footages he is seen firing with his tamancha
towards the informant’s house. He further submits that
investigation reveals that his owned licence rifle was used
by his son the co-accused Toseef to fire a gunshot injury
at the deceased and the rifle with empty cartridges and
cartridge belt was also recovered from a cattle shed from
the house of Sajid’s sister and section 238 of BNS, 2023
was also added during investigation along with 30 Arms
Act against him and he is also chargesheeted.
UKHC010041592026
14.
In reference to one of the person, who according to the
learned counsel for the applicants is the main accused namely
Hazi Sarvar yaar Khan S/o Sarvar Yaar Khan Mr. Nainwal
submits that originally this person was named in the FIR as a
conspirator but during investigation no material was found
concocting him to any conspiracy and the allegation against him
were also not corroborated and he was exonerated and has not
been chargesheeted.
15.
At this juncture, Mr. Nainwal also make submissions in
reference to the incident of FIR No. 264 of 2025 and submits that
in this FIR 14 persons were named along with 10 unknown
persons and per this FIR Smt. Meena, the informant, the cousin
sister of the deceased “Aalim” was recording a video of entire
incident of murder from the roof top of her own house situated
approximately 60 to 70 meters from the place of incident of the
first incident and on being noticing the accused persons opened
fire at her with an intent to kill but she anyhow escape unhurt
and after this some of the accused persons entered into her
house, snatched her mobile and looted cash of Rs. 7,000/-. He
further submits that in reference to the incident of FIR No. 264
of 2025 the charge-sheet has been filed, however proceeding has
been stayed in C528 petition No. 617 of 2026 by the Coordinate
Bench.
16.
Apart from this, he submits that in reference to the present
FIR No. 263 of 2025 the CDR report of the accused persons were
also analyzed and as per the CDR location of all accused
persons, who have been chargesheeted are also confirmed at the
place of occurrence. In addition to this, Mr. Nainwal also
apprised about antecedents of all the applicants, which are as
follows:
UKHC010041592026
i.
Rehan S/o Firashat Khan-criminal antecedents of three
cases i.e. FIR No. 192 of 2022, FIR No. 265 of 2022 and FIR
No. 40 of 2024; all cases are registered at P.S. Kiccha.
ii.
Shoaib S/o Fariyad Khan-FIR No. 227 of 2023 of P.S.
Kiccha.
iii.
Akeel Khan S/o Mohd. Jaan Khan (already enlarged on
bail) have no prior antecedent.
iv.
Sajid Khan S/o Litafat Khan- no prior antecedent.
v.
Toseef Khan S/o Sajid Khan-no criminal antecedent but
the accused in both the FIRs i.e. FIR No. 263 of 2025 and
FIR No. 264 of 2025.
vi.
Riyasat Kha S/o Litafat Khan-no criminal antecedent.
17.
At this juncture, Mr. Nainwal also give the details of the
criminal antecedent of the informant of FIR No. 263 of 2025 and
submits that this informant have a long criminal history in
district Nainital, Udham Singh Nagar and Bareilly of State of
U.P. and at present this person is in judicial custody in relation
to Case Crime No. 122 of 2026 though he is one of the
prosecution witness in FIR No. 263 of 2025.
18.
Learned A.G.A. by giving the aforesaid details finally
concluded his argument by submitting that after collecting all
material evidences including CCTV footages, mobile video
recording of the informant and the statement of independent
eye witness, recovery of Fire arms including licensed weapon
recovered from one of the applicant’s own house and on the
basis of their confessional statement there are the evidences of
common object and intention resulting into the murder of Aalim
(deceased). He submits that taking into consideration the
UKHC010041592026
gravity of the offences and the specific role attributed to each of
the applicants and the recovery of the licensed weapon after the
incident and the fact that there are all possibility that if the
applicants have been enlarged on bail, they may either influence
the witnesses or tamper with the evidences and there are
possibility that they may flee from justice, therefore, all these
applicants does not deserve for bail.
19.
After hearing the rival submissions of learned counsel for
all the parties including learned counsel for the complainant
and after perusing the entire record including the objection of
the State as well as complainant and the fact that on a single day
two incidents were happened in two houses located in the same
area by group of people what this court has observed that the
entire incident was caused by a mob of persons is nothing but in
a well planned and organized manner crime was committed for
brutal murder of the deceased ‘Aalim’ the brother of the
informant of FIR No. 264 of 2025. The record reveals that the
entire incident of Case Crime No. 263 of 2025, wherein, all the
applicants have been chargesheeted was visually captured on a
mobile phone by the sister of deceased Mrs. Meena from the
roof top of her house and the material on record indicates that
upon realizing their heinious act was being recorded an
aggressive mob consisting of more than 14 persons, who are
named in the subsequent FIR No. 264 of 2025 rushed to the
residence of the informant Meena, the informant of FIR No. 264
of 2025 and the said mob opened direct gunfire upon her from
which she narrowly escaped unhurt. Following this, the
assailants forcibly trespassed into her dwelling house, violently
snatched mobile device containing the critical video evidence of
the incident of FIR No. 263 of 2025 and by looted cash also
clearly reveals the gravity of the offence.
UKHC010041592026
The incident of FIR No. 264 of 2025 though independently
registered under section 109(1), 115(2), 311 and 321(2) of BNS,
2023, with explicit refer to the first incident and the accused
Toseef, who is the applicant herein, and is also an accused in
FIR No. 263 of 2025 is also common to both the incidents
establishing of his nexus with both the offences, the first one
relates to murder and the second relates to violent assault on the
eye wetness of the first incident since the informant of FIR No.
264 of 2025, who was recording the incident of the first incident.
The first incident clearly establishes that all the assailants came
with common object and intention to commit the crime and the
subsequent event arising out of Case Crime No. 264 of 2025
itself demonstrate a calculated cold blooded attempt to
systematically terrorize eye witness, destroy vital electronic
evidence and causing threat to the witness, disentitle each of
them to be enlarged on bail.
20.
At this juncture, it is also relevant to mention here that in
FIR No. 263 of 2025 no doubt “Toseef” was not named, who is
the son of the co-accused “Sajid Khan”, but the investigation
reveals that in the subsequent incident arising out of Case
Crime No. 264 of 2025 he was named and thereafter his
involvement was found in the present case also which is also
corroborated by an independent eye witness Ashraf S/o Alam
Khan, who specifically stated that the bullet fired by the accused
Toseef struck the deceased and on his pointing out the rifle with
two empty cartridges and a cartridge belt was also recovered,
which was registered in the name of his father, the co-accused
Sajid Khan and the same was recovered from a cattle shed at his
aunt’s house.
UKHC010041592026
So far as co-accused Sajid Khan is concerned the father of
co-accused Toseef he is already named in the FIR and CCTV
footages shows that he was firing from tamancha in the
direction of the informant’s house and his licenced rifle was
used by his son the co-accused Toseef.
So far as the co-accused “Rehan Khan” is concerned,
admittedly he is named in the FIR and was the member of four
assailants and after the incident he was absconded and then
arrested after 3-4 days on 23.08.2025 along with the co-accused
Akeel Khan from District Bareilly and one live cartridge of 315
bore was also recovered from his possession and the CCTV
footages reveals that this applicant along with other assailants
were armed with sticks and rods moving towards and pelting
stones at the informant’s house at the time of occurrence,
therefore, this applicant is also actively involved in the
commission of crime.
21.
So far the applicant “Shoaib” is concerned he is also
named in the FIR though he has surrendered and as per the
record he was firing towards the deceased with a tamancha
taken from the co-accused Sajid Khan.
22.
So far as the applicant “Riyasat Kha” is concerned, he is
also named and surrendered and the CCTV footages of the
incident shows that he was armed with a gun moving towards
the informant’s house at the time of occurrence and his licence
rifle was also recovered from his own house. Consequently,
section 30 of Arms Act was also added against him and it
cannot be ruled out that he was not involved in the incident.
23.
At this juncture, while considering bail application the
role of each of the applicants cannot be analyzed independently,
UKHC010041592026
which completely the subject matter of the trial but prima-facie
the record reveals that they all in a well planned and organized
manner with common object and intention commit the offence,
which appears to be serious and it became more serious after
second incident.
24.
The accused Toseef is admittedly chargesheeted in both
the offences i.e. Case Crime No. 263 of 2025 as well as in Case
Crime No. 264 of 2025 and as per the prosecution case in the
second incident 14 persons were named in the FIR, however, as
apprised only four of them have been chargesheeted and so far
as FIR No. 263 of 2025 is concerned, in total 6 persons have been
chargesheeted and one person namely Hazi Sarvar Yaar Khan
was exonerated and furthermore there is no major time
difference in between both the incidents but the manner in
which both the incidents were caused are more serious.
25.
Thus, this court is of the view that the second incident
arising out of Case Crime No. 264 of 2025 disentitle the
applicants to get bail since the second incident was caused to
terrorize the witnesses and to destroy the electronic evidence of
the first incident, therefore, at this juncture if the applicants are
enlarged on bail then there are all possibilities that they can
terrorize the witnesses or to tamper with the evidence and
therefore there are all possibilities that they all may frustrate the
Trial Court proceedings.
26.
Finally, what this court has observed that both the
incidents demonstrate a calculated, cold blooded attempt by the
accused persons and while considering the bail applications of
each of the accused gravity of the primary offence that too with
regard to brutal murder of deceased “Aalim”, this court cannot
overlooked that the subsequent incident is nothing but an
UKHC010041592026
attempt to destroy the electronic evidence and to eliminate the
eye witness, therefore, this court review that if at this stage the
applicants are enlarged on bail certainly it will affect the
ongoing trial.
27.
Accordingly, without expressing any opinion on the merit
of the case, all the bail applications are hereby rejected.
28.
It is made clear that the trial Court may proceed and
conclude the trial on it’s own merit without being influenced
with the observation as above.
29.
The copy of this order be kept in the record of each of the
bail applications.
(Rakesh Thapliyal, J.)
PR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review