Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:UHC:66
Reserved On 12.12.2025
Delivered On 03.01.2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND
AT NAINITAL
Criminal Revision No. 626 of 2022
Dheeraj Kapoor
Versus
State Of Uttarakhand and Others
……………..Revisionist
….…….Respondents
With
Criminal Revision No. 629 of 2022
Ridhi Kapoor and Another
……………..Revisionists
Versus
Dheeraj Kapoor
….…….Respondent
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Presence:Mr. Tapan Singh, learned counsel for the revisionist in CRLR No.
626 of 2022.
Mr. Dinesh Chauhan, learned Brief Holder for the State.
Ms. Divya Jain, learned counsel for respondent nos.2 & 3 in CRLR
No. 626 of 2022.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Hon’ble Mr. Alok Mahra, J.
Both the criminal revisions arise out of the
same judgment and order dated 16.07.2022, passed by
the learned Judge, Family Court, Haridwar, District
Haridwar in O.S. No. 161 of 2017, whereby the
application filed by the minor children under Section
125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr.P.C.) was
partly allowed and the father was directed to pay
maintenance of ₹6,500/- per month to each of the two
minor children. Since both the revisions emanate from
the same impugned order, they are being decided by
this common judgment.
2.
Criminal Revision No. 626 of 2022 has been
preferred by the father, Dheeraj Kapoor, seeking setting
aside of the impugned order on the ground that the
learned Family Court has erred in law and on facts in
awarding maintenance beyond his financial capacity and
without properly considering the income of the mother.
Criminal Revision No. 629 of 2022 has been filed by the
minor
children
through
their
mother,
seeking
enhancement of the amount of maintenance awarded
by the Family Court.
3.
The brief facts of the case are that the
marriage between Dheeraj Kapoor and Poonam Kapoor
was solemnized on 17.04.2009 according to Hindu rites
and rituals. Out of the said wedlock, two children were
born, namely Ridhi Kapoor (daughter) and Shaurya
Kapoor (son). Owing to matrimonial discord, the parties
started living separately, and the minor children have
been residing with their mother. The minor children,
through their mother, filed an application under Section
125 Cr.P.C. alleging that the father was addicted to
alcohol and had subjected their mother to physical and
mental
cruelty.
occasions
she
It
was
alleged
was
assaulted,
that
her
on
multiple
character
was
maligned, and she was eventually forced to leave the
matrimonial home. It was further pleaded that the
father was earning about ₹90,000/- per month while
working in an insurance company and had sufficient
means
to
maintain
the
children.
Maintenance
of
₹30,000/- per month was sought.
4.
The father contested the application, denying
all allegations of cruelty and neglect. He claimed that
the mother was living separately without sufficient
cause and that he was unemployed due to multiple
litigations initiated against him. He relied upon various
judicial precedents, including Bhagwan Dutt v. Kamla
Devi, Koushik v. Sau Sangeeta Koushik, Ankit Saha v.
State of U.P., and Sanjeev Gupta v. Shalini Gupta, to
contend that maintenance must be commensurate with
actual income and cannot be granted mechanically.
5.
The mother of the minor children appeared as
PW-1 and reiterated the allegations made in the
application. She filed an affidavit of assets and liabilities
in compliance with the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Rajneesh v. Neha (2021) 2 SCC 324.
During cross-examination, she admitted that a salary of
₹93,991/- had been credited to her account and that
she had not filed income tax returns along with the
affidavit.
6.
The father, in his affidavit and oral evidence,
claimed that he was unemployed since 2017. However,
during cross-examination, he admitted that he had
joined IFFCO Tokio under an offer letter showing a
monthly CTC of ₹92,562/- and an annual CTC of
₹11,10,738/-,
with
a
net
in-hand
salary
of
approximately ₹64,000/- per month. Upon appreciation
of evidence, the learned Family Court observed that
although the mother attempted to conceal her income,
she admitted her monthly earnings. As regards the
father,
the
Court
disbelieved
the
plea
of
total
unemployment in view of his own admissions and
documentary material. Consequently, the Family Court
partly allowed the application and directed the father to
pay maintenance of ₹6,500/- per month to each minor
child.
7.
Learned counsel for the father contended that
the impugned order suffers from serious illegality and
arbitrariness, as the learned Family Court failed to
consider his actual financial capacity and wrongly
ignored the substantial income of the mother. It was
argued that liability ought to have been apportioned,
and the father could not be saddled with the entire
burden. He further contended that the Family Court
erred in directing payment of maintenance from the
date of application without recording reasons, contrary
to the law laid down in Jaiminiben Hirenbhai Vyas v.
Hirenbhai Rameshchandra Vyas and Shail Kumari Devi
v. Krishan Bhagwan Pathak.
8.
Learned counsel further submitted that due to
several litigations, the father was unable to secure
employment and was wholly dependent on his parents.
It was also argued that the mother, who earns a
substantial income and has been granted monetary
relief under the Domestic Violence Act, deliberately
suppressed material facts and obtained the impugned
order by misrepresentation, attracting the principle that
fraud
vitiates
all
judicial
acts
as
held
in
S.P.
Chengalvaraya Naidu v. Jagannath and Dalip Singh v.
State of U.P.
9.
Learned
counsel
for
respondent
nos.2
&
3/minor children supported the impugned order and
sought enhancement of maintenance. It was contended
that the father is a well-qualified and able-bodied
person with substantial earning capacity, who has
deliberately
concealed
his
true
income
to
evade
responsibility. It was argued that the learned Family
Court grossly underestimated the actual expenses of
the children, ignoring rising educational costs, tuition
fees, transportation, healthcare, and other necessities
consistent with the status of the parties.
10.
Learned counsel submitted that mere earning
of the mother does not absolve the father of his
statutory and moral obligation to maintain his children.
Reliance was placed upon Urvashi Aggarwal v. Inderpaul
Aggarwal, Raghubar Singh v. State of Jharkhand, and
other
judgments
to
contend that
concealment
of
income warrants drawing adverse inference against the
father. It was further argued that the father has not
complied with even interim maintenance orders passed
under the Domestic Violence Act, demonstrating willful
neglect. The plea of unemployment was stated to be
false and unsupported by credible evidence.
11.
In
rejoinder,
learned
counsel
for
the
revisionist/father reiterated that he never neglected his
children and that it was the mother who was unwilling
to cohabit. It was contended that the mother, being
financially independent, is capable of maintaining the
children, and the impugned order deserves to be set
aside.
12.
Having heard learned counsel for both sides
at length and after carefully examining the entire
record, this Court is required to consider whether the
impugned order dated 16.07.2022 passed by the
learned Judge, Family Court, Haridwar suffers from any
illegality, perversity or jurisdictional error so as to call
for interference under revisional jurisdiction provided
under Sections 397/401 Cr.P.C.
13.
At
the
outset,
it
is
well
settled
that
proceedings under Section 125 Cr.P.C. are summary in
nature. Their object is not to punish a party but to
prevent destitution and vagrancy of wives and minor
children. The jurisdiction exercised is protective and
welfare-oriented. The scope of interference in revision
is limited, and unless the order of the court below
suffers from patent illegality, arbitrariness or perversity,
the revisional court should not interfere merely because
another view is possible.
14.
In the present case, there is no dispute
regarding the entitlement of minor children, to receive
maintenance from their father. The only issue raised
before
this
Court
relates
to
the
quantum
of
maintenance awarded and the allegation that the
Family Court failed to properly consider the income of
the mother and the plea of unemployment taken by the
father.
15.
The revisionist/father has claimed that he is
unemployed and has no source of income. However, the
learned Family Court has rightly examined this plea in
the light of documentary evidence and the admissions
made by the revisionist during cross-examination. The
revisionist admitted that he was employed with IFFCO
Tokio and that the offer letter issued to him reflected a
monthly CTC of ₹92,562/- and an annual CTC of
₹11,10,738/-. He further admitted that his take-home
salary was around ₹64,000/- per month.
16.
It is a settled principle of law that a bald plea
of unemployment cannot be accepted at face value,
particularly when the person concerned is able-bodied,
qualified and experienced. The revisionist is admittedly
an MCA graduate with substantial work experience. In
such circumstances, the plea that he is unable to earn
on account of pending litigations is not acceptable. An
able-bodied person is presumed to have the capacity to
earn,
and
intentional
or
voluntary
unemployment
cannot be used as an excuse to avoid statutory
responsibility. The learned Family Court has therefore
rightly
drawn
an
adverse
inference
against
the
revisionist for not making a full and truthful disclosure
of his income and employment details, in line with the
principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Rajneesh
v. Neha (2021) 2 SCC 324.
17.
With regard to the income of the mother of
minor children, the learned Family Court has duly
considered the material on record and has recorded a
clear finding that her monthly income is approximately
₹93,991/-. The court has also noted that though there
was initially some lack of disclosure, the income stood
clarified through her admission. However, the mere fact
that the mother is earning does not absolve the father
of his statutory and moral duty to maintain his minor
children. The obligation of a father to maintain his
children is independent and continues so long as the
children are minors. Judicial precedents consistently
hold that even where both parents are earning, the
father cannot escape his responsibility, particularly
when the children are residing with the mother and she
is bearing the primary responsibility of their day-to-day
care and upbringing.
18.
The Family Court has not placed the entire
financial burden upon the father. It has awarded a
reasonable and moderate amount after considering the
income of both parents and the needs of the children.
The contention that the liability ought to have been
mathematically
divided
between
the
parents
is
misconceived. Section 125 Cr.P.C. does not require
arithmetical
apportionment.
The
maintenance
of
₹6,500/- per month to each child, totalling ₹13,000/per
month,
cannot
be
said
to
be
excessive
or
disproportionate. Considering the rising cost of living,
educational expenses and other daily needs of growing
children, the amount appears reasonable and, in fact,
on the lower side when seen in the light of the earning
capacity of the revisionist.
19.
The
submission
regarding
adjustment
of
interim maintenance awarded in other proceedings is
also devoid of merit. Any amount already paid under
orders passed in parallel proceedings can always be
adjusted at the stage of execution. This, by itself, does
not render the impugned order illegal. Similarly, the
direction
to
pay
maintenance
from
the
date
of
application is within the discretion of the court. It is
settled law that maintenance may be awarded either
from the date of application or from the date of the
order. The learned Family Court has exercised this
discretion judiciously, and no perversity or arbitrariness
has been shown.
20.
In so far as Criminal Revision No. 629 of 2022
filed by the minor children seeking enhancement of
maintenance
is
concerned,
this
Court
finds
that
revisional jurisdiction is not an appellate jurisdiction.
Unless the maintenance awarded is shockingly low or
manifestly unjust, enhancement cannot be granted
merely on re-evaluation of facts. The Family Court has
exercised its discretion after proper appreciation of the
evidence on record, and no exceptional circumstances
have been shown to warrant enhancement at this
stage.
21.
In view of the above discussion, this Court is
of the view that the impugned judgment and order
dated 16.07.2022 passed by the learned Judge, Family
Court, Haridwar does not suffer from any illegality,
perversity or jurisdictional error. The maintenance
awarded is reasonable and proportionate. The plea of
unemployment taken by the revisionist/father is not
bona fide, and the earning of the mother does not
absolve the father of his obligation to maintain his
minor children.
22.
Accordingly, Criminal Revision No. 626 of
2022 filed by the father is dismissed.
23.
Criminal Revision No. 629 of 2022 filed by the
minor children seeking enhancement of maintenance is
also dismissed.
24.
Accordingly, The judgment and order dated
16.07.2022 passed by the learned Judge, Family Court,
Haridwar is affirmed. Any amount already paid shall be
duly adjusted in accordance with law. The arrears, if
any, shall be cleared by the revisionist/father within a
period of three months from today.
25.
There shall be no order as to costs.
(ALOK MAHRA, J.)
Dated: 03.01.2026
Mamta
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review