Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:2741
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No. 18437 of 2025
Reserved on 07.01.2026.
Date of decision: 09.01.2026.
_____________________________________________________________________________
Richa Sharma
...Petitioner.
Versus
State of H.P. and others
…Respondents.
_____________________________________________________________________________
Coram
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Romesh Verma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? 1 Yes
_____________________________________________________________________________
For the Petitioner.
Mr. Prajwal Sharma & Aashima Vashishta,
Advocates.
For the Respondents:
Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General with
Mr.
Ramakant
Sharma,
Additional
Advocate General.
__________________________________________________________
Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge
Petitioner has approached this Court, seeking following
substantive reliefs:“i.
Issue an appropriate writ, order or direction thereby quashing
and setting aside the notification dated 27.03.2025 (Annexure
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:2741
CWP No. 18437 of 2025
P-1) as it has not been implemented at all by the respondents
in its letter and spirit.
(ii)
Issue an appropriate writ, order or direction thereby quashing
and setting aside the impugned order dated 13.11.2025
(Annexure P-10), the letter dated 29.08.2025 (Annexure P-9),
and consequential relieving order dated 02.05.2025 (Annexure
P-4), being arbitrary, illegal and violative of the rights of the
petitioner.
(iii)
Direct the respondents to consider the petitioner’s case afresh
for change/withdrawal of option and retention in Department of
Health & Family Welfare at Regional Hospital Una, strictly in
terms of Notification dated 27.03.2025 (Annexure P-1) and
Notification
dated
01.07.2025
(Annexure
P-6)
and
in
compliance with the directions of this Hon’ble Court dated
28.08.2025 (Annexure P-7).”
2.
Petitioner is serving as Staff Nurse in the Health Department
at Regional Hospital, Una, District Una, H.P.
3.
Government of Himachal Pradesh, decided to bifurcate the
cadre of Nursing Staff in two cadres, i.e., (1) Nursing Staff under Medical
Education Department and (2) Nursing Staff under Health and Family
Welfare Department.
4.
Regarding
bifurcation
of
posts
of
Nursing
Staff,
communication dated 15.10.2024, was circulated by the Director Health
Services, Himachal Pradesh, inviting option of Nursing Staff within a
week’s time.
2026:HHC:2741
CWP No. 18437 of 2025
5.
Admittedly, petitioner had opted for Department of Medical
Education and Research.
6.
Later on, Notification dated 27.03.2025 was issued by the
Government of Himachal Pradesh, Department of Health and Family
Welfare to bifurcate the existing cadre of Paramedical, Nursing,
Ministerial and other ancillary/supporting staff, which was under the
control of Department of Health and Family Welfare, H.P., into two
departments, i.e., (1) Department of Medical Education & Research, H.P.
and (2) Department of Health & Family Welfare, in the interest of Health
Care Delivery System and public interest.
7.
In aforesaid Notification dated 27.03.2025, it was further
notified that separate cadres of categories concerned shall be identified
and finalized on the basis of option exercised by respective categories for
both departments, on completion of all the necessary and codal
formalities, to be applicable in this behalf.
8.
In aforesaid Notification, there was Clause 9, permitting the
incumbents to file objections/representations/grievances, if any, to be
considered on merit, up to six months by the office of Director, Health
Services through Grievance Redressal Committee, to be constituted at
DHS. Clause 9 reads as under:-
2026:HHC:2741
CWP No. 18437 of 2025
“9.
Pursuant
to
issuance
of
this
notification,
the
objections/representation/grievances, if any, of the employees
will be considered on merit upto six months by the office of the
DHS. The representation shall be considered by a “Grievance
Redressal Committee” to be constituted at DHS consisting of
the officers of appropriate level from both the Directorates, i.e.
DME & DHS, and shall be decided by the Director Health
Services, HP on the recommendation of this Committee.”
9.
Vide Office Order dated 22.04.2025, on the basis of option
exercised by the petitioner, she was allotted Department of Medical
Education Cadre.
10.
Immediately after allocation of her posting/deployment,
petitioner submitted representation dated 23.04.2025, for cancellation of
her cadre bifurcation allotment to DME, due to unforeseen compelling
personal circumstances.
11.
However, vide Office Order dated 02.05.2025 (Annexure P-
4), petitioner was relieved in absentia on 02.05.2025 (F.N.) from Regional
Hospital, Una to Directorate of Medical Education (DME), due to cadre
bifurcation, with direction to join duties in the office of DME, immediately.
12.
It is case of the petitioner
that she has 12 years old
daughter and 5 years old son, respectively and her son is suffering from
mild to moderate level of Autism and is under treatment from a private
2026:HHC:2741
CWP No. 18437 of 2025
clinic at Mohali and he requires constant and due care and therapy
continuously for his overall and healthy mental development, for which,
therapy sessions are held after 15 days consecutively. Moreover, the
husband of petitioner is working in private company at Bangalore. In such
adverse family situation, the petitioner is encumbered with all the
responsibility of ailing son and to manage family affairs, and also to look
after her daughter. It is submitted that the distance of Mohali from the
Regional Hospital is about 100 Kms., whereas from Dr. RKGMC & H,
Hamirpur, the distance of Mohali Hospital is more than 160 Kms. and it
would be quite difficult to the petitioner to take her son to Mohali for his
treatment. Moreover, the native place of petitioner is at Una and she is
being assisted by her in-laws there, but at Dr. RKGMC & H, Hamirpur, it
would be very difficult to the petitioner to look after her children. It is
further submitted that the petitioner herself has undergone surgery of
Uterus fibroid uterus Myomectomy surgery on 15th April, 2025. However,
request of the petitioner was not considered and she was ordered to be
relieved.
13.
In aforesaid backdrop, petitioner approached this Court by
filing CWP No. 13849 of 2025, titled as Richa Sharma vs. State of
Himachal Pradesh & others, which was disposed of, vide order dated
28.08.2025 (Annexure P-7) in following terms:-
2026:HHC:2741
CWP No. 18437 of 2025
“2. Though, having taken note of the pleadings adduced on record,
which are duly supported by affidavit, this Court finds that prior to
change of cadre, petitioner herein had given option, but since
Notification dated 27.03.2025, whereby existing cadre of Paramedical,
Nursing, Ministerial and other ancillary/supporting staff came to be
bifurcated, itself provides for representation to be considered by the
Grievance Redressal Committee, coupled with the fact that petitioner
has already filed representation to the competent authority, this Court
without going into the merits of the case, deems it fit to dispose of the
same with a direction to the petitioner to file fresh representation to the
Grievance Redressal Committee constituted by Director Health
Service, Himachal Pradesh, within a period of three days, which in turn
shall be decided by the Grievance Redressal within a period of two
weeks thereafter. Ordered accordingly. Needless to say, committee
concerned shall consider the case of the petitioner sympathetically
taking note of illness of son of the petitioner, who is required to be
taken to Mohali frequently after 15 days for treatment. Pending
applications, if any, also stand disposed of.”
14.
In furtherance to the aforesaid order dated 28.08.2025,
petitioner submitted a detailed representation. As the representation of
petitioner was not decided within the time granted by the Court, petitioner
had to file Execution Petition No. 2290 of 2025, for execution of the order.
15.
During pendency of the Execution Petition, representation of
the petitioner was considered and rejected by the Grievance Redressal
Committee, vide decision dated 13.11.2025 and the said decision was
communicated to the petitioner along with instructions dated 13.11.2025,
imparted by the Director Health Services to the learned Advocate
2026:HHC:2741
CWP No. 18437 of 2025
General, in the Court itself, through counsel, whereupon Execution
Petition was disposed of in following terms, vide order dated 14.11.2025
(Annexure P-11):“3. In view of the above, the present petition is disposed of reserving
liberty to the petitioner to seek appropriate remedy for the rederssal of
her surviving grievance including against the decision taken by the
respondents
in
accordance
with
law.
Pending
miscellaneous
application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.”
16.
The aforesaid facts compelled the petitioner to file present
writ petition. During pendency of the petition, counsel for the petitioner as
well as learned Advocate General, was requested to assist the Court with
respect to nature and type of the disease Autism and complications faced
by a patient on change of Doctor/Tutor, atmosphere, society and school.
17.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has placed on record
downloaded material in this regard, wherefrom relevant information is
extracted as under:“Autism spectrum disorder is a neurodevelopmental condition that
affects how a person communicates, interacts socially, and processes
sensory information. Interestingly, autism is a spectrum disorder. It
doesn’t show up in just one way. One child might talk nonstop; another
might not use words at all. Some find deep comfort in routine, while
others need room to explore and improvise.
….
….
….
….
2026:HHC:2741
CWP No. 18437 of 2025
Dr. Sumantra Chattarji, Director of CHINTA (Centre for High Impact
Neuroscience and Translational Applications) at TCG CREST (The
Chatterjee Group Centres for Research and Education in Science and
Technology is a research driven, private, deemed to be university in
Kolkata, India) once gave his view on autism; ‘As the brain develops in
its early days, the connections between neurons don’t form in the
typical fashion. As a result, the brain is wired differently over time and
reaches a point where all the pieces are there. Nothing is lost. They’re
just wired slightly differently’.
In school-aged children and teens, challenges often shift from
developmental delays to social struggles, emotional regulation issues,
and the effort to blend in.
Social Communication and Interaction Challenges
Navigating friendships and social expectations can become more
challenging in school settings.
At this stage, autistic individuals may experience:
•
Difficulty reading social cues like facial expressions, body
language, or tone of voice
•
Struggles
with
initiating
or
maintaining
back-and-forth
conversations
•
Preference for playing alone or spending time with younger
children or adults
•
Literal interpretation of language and missing sarcasm, jokes, or
implied meaning
•
Limited or avoidant eye contact during conversations
Restricted Interests and Repetitive Behaviors
Autistic children and teens often develop focused interests that may
dominate their time and conversations.
Common autism symptoms and signs are:
2026:HHC:2741
CWP No. 18437 of 2025
•
Intense fixation on specific topics, activities, or objects
•
Repetitive behaviors like spinning objects, hand-flapping, or
rocking
•
Insistence on routine or predictability and distress when routines
are disrupted
•
Difficulty transitioning between classes, tasks, or social
environments
Sensory Sensitivities
Sensory differences often become more pronounced in high-stimulus
environments like schools or social gatherings.
Look for:
•
Overreaction to sounds, lights, or textures (e.g., buzzing lights,
scratchy uniforms)
•
Seeking or avoiding sensory input (e.g., covering ears, refusing
certain foods)
•
Overwhelm or shutdowns in crowded or chaotic spaces
Emotional Regulation and Daily Living
As expectations increase with age, autistic teens may face unique
internal struggles, such as:
•
Heightened anxiety, especially in social settings
•
Mood changes, emotional shutdowns, or meltdowns
•
Difficulty managing transitions or unexpected changes
•
Trouble with daily tasks like organizing schoolwork, hygiene, or
managing time”
18.
Learned Advocate General has also placed on record
information in this regard, contained in instructions dated 01.01.2026,
2026:HHC:2741
CWP No. 18437 of 2025
received from Director Health Services, relevant extract whereof is as
under:
“Autism is also known as autism spectrum disorder (ASD). It
is a condition related to brain development by birth.
Children suffering autism usually have difficulty while talking
or understanding speech, maintaining eye contact and having trouble
while conversation or literal interpretation of language. So such children
usually prefer to be alone and find it hard to mix with other children.
Some children show repetitive body movement like hand flapping or
rocking etc. usually they have an intense focus on specific topics and a
strong preference for routines. They are very sensitive to sound, touch
light etc.
….
….
….
….
….
….
….
….
With early identification, therapy, family support and social
acceptance such children can learn, grow and live meaningful life.
Child may need therapy as per individual requirements.
Various
specialist
generally
after
initial
phase
train
the
parents/caregivers for day to day intervention. Follow-up of such
children is taken care by various specialist as per individual needs.”
19.
Considering the information placed on record by both sides,
we have arrived at a conclusion that there may be difficulty in cure and
development of the child suffering from Autism on facing changes for
shifting from one place to other, one doctor/tutor to another and such
struggles may hamper improvement in the development of brain of the
child suffering from Autism.
2026:HHC:2741
CWP No. 18437 of 2025
20.
For adjudication of the issue, it is also relevant to record
here the reason assigned by the Redressal Grievance Committee for
rejecting representation of the petitioner, which reads as under:“Decision:
It was noted by the committee that the request of the
petitioner Smt. Richa Sharma with respect to change of cadre option
has already been decided vide letter dated 04.10.2025. However, in
view of the petition filed by the said official and the orders passed by
Hon’ble High Court of H.P. dated 28.08.2025 in CWP No. 13849/2025,
the fresh representation dated 29.08.2025 made by the petitioner Mrs.
Richa Sharma has been considered afresh. It was noted by the
committee that vide orders dated 29.08.2025, the Government has
clarified that the consideration of change of cadre is not under the
scope of the committee.”
21.
It is also apt to record that vide communication dated
02.09.2025, sent from Secretary (Health) to Government of Himachal
Pradesh to Director Health Services, H.P. (Annexure P-9), regarding
proceedings of Grievance Redressal Committee, communicated that
change of option may not be considered.
22.
From aforesaid facts and circumstances, it is apparent that
grievance of the petitioner has not been considered by the Committee at
all, rather it has rejected the representation of the petitioner, in view of
instructions dated 29.08.2025 (Annexure P-9), circulated by Secretary
(Health), Government of Himachal Pradesh.
2026:HHC:2741
CWP No. 18437 of 2025
23.
Even during pendency of the petition, under instructions of
the concerned authority, learned Advocate General, on behalf of
respondents, submits that the representation of the petitioner has been
rightly rejected, in view of option exercised by her, but there is no
instruction imparted on behalf of respondents with regard to consideration
of grounds of representation, including disease of her son and impact of
change of station, doctor and tutor, on the child of the petitioner.
24.
It is also noteworthy that in Clause 9 (supra) of notification
dated 27.03.2025, there was provision for reconsideration of option within
six months for genuine reasons, whereas instead of going through or
addressing the grievance of the petitioner, Committee has rejected the
claim of the petitioner on the basis of instructions issued by the Secretary
(Health), Government of H.P., which is completely in disregard to Clause
9.
25.
From the aforesaid, it is apparent that representation of the
petitioner has been rejected without passing reasoned or speaking order,
but only following the instructions of the superior, however without going
into actual grievance put-forth by the petitioner before the authorities and
Grievance Redressal Committee.
2026:HHC:2741
CWP No. 18437 of 2025
26.
We would have relegated the petitioner again to concerned
authority/Committee for afresh decision, however, petitioner is running
from pillar to post since April 2025, and till date her grievance has not
been redressed. Perusal of the material placed on record by the petitioner
as well as the respondents with respect to the Autism, also indicate
genuineness of the request of the petitioner to withdraw her option.
Therefore, instead of referring the case of the petitioner to respondents to
take decision afresh, we are of the considered opinion that in given
peculiar facts and circumstances of present case, the petition deserves to
be allowed by quashing the impugned office orders and notifications,
whereby petitioner has not been allowed to withdraw her option and has
been kept in cadre of Department of Medical Education and has been
relieved to join accordingly, in the office of Director Medical Education,
and directing to retain her at present place of posting in Department of
Health and Family Welfare.
27.
Accordingly, office order dated 22.04.2025 (Annexure P-2)
w.r.t. Serial No. 54, i.e., petitioner, Office Order dated 02.05.2025
(Annexure P-4), Communication dated 13.11.2025, including decision of
the Committee and letter issued by Director to the petitioner dated
13.11.2025 [Annexure P-10 (Colly)], are quashed and set-aside, only to
the extent of the petitioner, and petitioner is directed to be retained in
2026:HHC:2741
CWP No. 18437 of 2025
Department of Health & Family Welfare at Regional Hospital Una, District
Una, Himachal Pradesh.
28.
Accordingly, petition is allowed and disposed of in the
aforesaid terms. Pending applications, if any, also stands disposed of.
(Vivek Singh Thakur),
Judge.
(Romesh Verma),
Judge.
9th January, 2026
(Susheel)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review