The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
22. in view of the above, and further, as there are no documents to support the case of the petitioner, the present writ petition is not maintainable, more particularly, when it involves mixed questions of fact, which have to be determined by way of evidence, requiring adjudication on factual aspects which cannot be undertaken in proceedings under Article 226 of the constitution of ') (200()) I SCC t(rS India, and therefore, the petitioner ought to have approached competent civil Court having jurisdiction for the reiief the claimed in the present writ petition. Thus, the Writ Petition is devoid of merits and is liable to be dismissed'
23. Accordingly, the present Writ Petition is dismissed' No order as to costs. As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, pending if any' shall stand closed. 'RIJI;',iHiHtE'EiRiI ,fTRUE COPY" i i I To, 'ilf":F:i'1"il1[',?"[:"J"'"[ffi ,$,f;pff "#i*:1;t;;[ili:'#:'"si;ir::"ff {i*"?ririri] ^5i:":i1;,i:.1::lxl'ffi : I : i ! t :l,8":":i:?rH:"1":g*:iTffi ',,1"i,'J',i1ffi i,'J.il"s'J[1ffi '1"'":?L' i.!lifiiflf,;s*lr"ry;,.:;41g*f$#,
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34851
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE TWENTY FOURTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT PETITION NO: 31083 OF 201s
Between:
The Hanmakonda Field Association of the Telugu Baptist Churches,
Represented by its Field Secretary, Sri Manda Surender Babu
...PETITIONER
AND
1. The State of Andhra Pradesh,, rep by its Principal Secretary, Department of
Municipal Administration and Urban Development, Secretariat Buildings,
Hyderabad.
2. Warangal Municipal Corporation, Warangal, Rep. by its Commissioner
3. The Property Committee of Field Association, of Telugu Baptist Churches,
Rep. by its Chairman, Sri K.M.Luther Christian Colony, Hanamkonda,
Warangal
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 ol the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue an appropriate direction, order or writ more in the nature of Writ of
Mandamus declaring the action of the 2nd respondent in not taking action on the
representations made by the petitioner in the matter of canceling the permission
granted in favour of the 3rd respondent for the construction of Commercial Complex
in the land belonging to the Mission Compound of Baptist Church, in Sy.No.1147 to
1150 in Hanumakonda, Warangal Dist., as being arbitrary, illegal and violating the
provisions of Article 14 and 29 of the Constitution of lndia and consequently direct
the 2nd respondent to cancel the permission granted vide R.O.P.No G4.97 312003
dated 22-07 -2004 in favour of the 3'd respondent
l.A. NO:1 OF 2013(WPMP. N O: 38600 OF 2013)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct lhe
2nd respondent to forthwith pass appropriate orders on the representation made by
the petitioner on 11-10-2013, pending disposal of the Writ Petition, in the interest of
justice
Counsel for the Petitioner: M/S CHILLAW ADVOCATES AND LEGAL
CONSULTANTS
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: GP FOR MUNCIPAL ADMN AND URBAN
DEVELOPMENT
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRI PASHAM MOHITH
(sc WARANGAL MUNtCtPAL CORP)
Counsel for the Respondent No.3: SRI BOMMINENI VIVEKANANOA
The Court made the following: ORDER
I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT
HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WP.No.31083 of 2013
Dt.24.04.2026
Between:
The Hanmakonda Field Association of the Telugu
Baptist Churches
.-.. Petitioner
and
The State of Andhra Pradesh, rep. by its
Principal SecretarSr, Department of
Municipal Administration & Urban
Development, Secretariat Buildings,
Hyderabad and two others.
...Respondents
ORDER
1.
The present Writ Petition has been filed to declare the action
of the 2nd respondent in not taking any action on the
representations made by the petitioner in cancelling the
permission granted in favour of the 3.d respondent for the
construction of commercial complex in the land belonging to the
Machine Compound of Baptist Church in survey No. 1147 to 1 150
in Hanumakonda, Waranga.l District, as arbitrary, illegal, and
violative of Articles 14 and 21 of the constitution of India and
consequently direct the 2"a respondent to cancel the permission
granted uide R O.P.No.G4.9T3l2OO3, dt.22.O7.2OO4, in favour of
the 3'd respondent and to issue such other order or orders or
direction as deemed fit and proper in the circumstances of the
case
2.
The brii:f lacts of the case are that the Samaveshan of
Telugu Baptist Churches is having vast properties in the States of
Andhra Pradesh (Telangana), Tamil Nadu, West Bengal and
Nagaland, and the saicl properties are being looked after by the
Property Association of Baptist Churches purporting to act in
terms of the orders passed by the Madras High Court in
C.P.Nos. 1O9 and I l0
of lg73, and for the purpose of
administration, the org:inization is divided into fields, and one
such field is the Field Association of Hanumakonda.
3.
It is stated thar an extenr of Ac.g.O0 guntas in Survey
Nos.1147 to 1 150 of Hanamkonda, knou,n as Machine Compound,
situated on the main road from Warangal to Kazipet, belongs
to
?
the said organization, and it does not provide for any property
association at the field level, however, certain Persons styling
themselves as Property Association of Hanumakonda Field have
made an application to the 2"d respondent for permission to
construct a commercial complex uide Application No'973/2003 in
an extent of Ac. 1.OO guntas, and thereafter entered into a
development agreement with M/ s. Orugallu Constructions and
commenced construction.
4.
It is further stated that the petitioners approached the
Hon,bleHighCourtofJudicatureatMadras,whichinitially
granted injunction, and thereafter in Contempt Application
Nos.89, 269, 441 and 444 to 459 of 2O03, the persons who
obtained permission were arrayed as respondents, and they have
given an undertaking on 27.O7.2OO4 that they will not interfere
with the property, and the said contempt cases were finally
disposed of on 02.08.2006 holding that all alienations such as
sale, Iease, gift or any other transactions are bad in law'
5.
It is stated that the alleged possession of the 3'd respondent
over the subject properties by virtue of development agreement
with M / s. Orugallu Constructions is invalid and therefore the
permlssion granted by the 2"a respondent has no legal effect,
and
when these facts were brought to the notice of the District
collector, waralgal, he directed the District Revenue officer,
Warangal, to stop the construction by taking appropriate action.
6.
It is further stated that despite the same, the 3.a respondent
continued the construction, and filed o.S. No.17/20og on the file
of the III Additional District Judge, Warangal, which was
dismissed on 26.O2.2OOg, and thereafter the petitioners have
been
making representations to the 2"d respondent for calcellation
the permission granted to the 3rd respondent, but no action
of
has
been taken.
'
It is stated that though the 2nd respondent was aware of the
orders passed by the Hon'ble High court of Judicature at Madras
as u,ell as the Civil Court, and initially responded to the
representations and assured cancellation, but, due to the pressure
of vested interested persons, no steps were taken thereafter, and
in a similar matter, the Honble High Court in W.p. No.19l5O of
2OO7 set aside the permission gralted by the Municipal
Corporation of Hyderabad, and therefore the petitioners requested
the 2"d responden t to cancel the permission granted vide
R.O.P.No.G4.973/2OO3, dt.27.O7.2004, but the 2.d respondent
failed to take action in accordance with law.
8.
Therefore, questioning the inaction of the respondents,
particularly, of the 2"a respondent in not carcelling the permission
and having failed to discharge their duty in spite of the orders of
the competent Courts, the present writ petition is filed seeking
cancellation of the permission granted in favour of the 3.d
respondent for construction of a commercial complex in the land
belonging to the Mission Compound of Baptist Church in Survey
Nos.1147 to 1150.
9.
Heard. Sri Rdmesh Chitla, Iearned counsel Jor the
petltioner, Sri Pcshcm Mohith, learned. Standlng Counsel for
respond.ent No.2 o'nd Srl Bomrnineni Viueka;nanda, learned.
counsel for respondent No.3.
10.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner,
reiterating the writ averments, would contend that the orders
passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Madras is binding on the 2nd
respondent, and the said authority being duty bound to give effect
to the said orders, cannot act in disregard of the same, and thus,
the 2"d respondent ought to have considered the representation
made b],the petitioner and ought to have taken proper decision by
duly examining the material placed and the orders of the
competent Courts, and accordingly prayed to allow the present
writ petition by cancelling the permission granted in favour of the
3.d respondent.
L
The learned Standing Counsel appearing for 2"d respondent,
Sri Pasham Mohit, while denying the nrit averments and placing
reliance on the counter affidavit liled , contended that the
petitioner relied upon the suits and proceedings, to which the
respondent-Corporation is not a party, and there are no restraint
orders against the respondent Corporation in issuing permission
to respondent No.3 l.rerein. It is also stated that the building
permission, which the petitioner herein seeks cancellation, by way
of present Writ Petition, was issued on 22.07 .2004 in favour of the
3.d respondent and the said construction was already completed
way back in the year 2008 and the property was also assessed by
giving house No.6 l-2'25 11,2,3,4 & 6 in the name of individuals.
He further contended that after a period of 9 years from the date
of issuance of the szud building permission, the present writ
petition is fited seeking cancellation of the said permission and
thus, no relief can be granted in the present writ petition' on this
ground alone.
L2. Sri Bommineni Vivekanalda, learned counsel appearing for
the 3,a respondent, placing reliance on the colrnter affidavit
frled,
contended stated that the writ petition has been filed challenging
the permission granted in favour of the 3'a respondent in
the land
belonging to the Mission Compound of Baptist Church
and the
present writ petition is a vexatious litigation launched
by the
petitioner and is in no way concerned with the said property
the petitioner without there being a substaltial proof or
records, to establish its right over the said property' has
and
proper
flrled the
instant writ Petition and thus the locus of the petitioner is also
challenged.
13. It is further contended by the learned counsel that though it
is stated by the petitioner that injunction has been
granted by the
Hon'ble High Court of Madras against the construction
undertaken in the subject property, in fact' no such
injunction is
granted by the Hon'ble High Court at Madras and there are
no
subsisting injunction orders hled before this Court to substantiate
B
such claim and that the petitioner by making vague allegations
that the 3.,1 rcspondent has no right over the property, has sought
the cancellal ion of permission.
14. It is further contended that the subject permission was
granted to the 3rd respondent way back in 2OO4 and the present
writ petition has been filed in 2O 13, almost around 9 years later,
by rvhrch time, the construction of the building was completed in
a1l respects way back in the year 2oog and the same is also
recorded by this court in cMA.No.4O1 of 2oor wherein the
court
at pa,ra 28, recorded that " It is settled latu that the court while
disposing an application for grant of temporary injunction, shoutd.
not go to the ertent of deciding the main case of the parties
but the
order should be a speaking ord.er, shotuing that the Court has
taken
a decision afi.er applging its mind.. While d.etermining the question
as to grant of injunction, the Court should refrain
from giuing a
finding on merits of the case......", and at para 29, recorded that
"To sum up, ex facie the Madras High Courl bg uirtue
dated O3.O5.1975, passed in Compang petition Nos.109
1974, upheld tLLe execution of Exs.p6 and. p7 tn
and_ 110 of
fauour of pABC,
uthich in turn executed- Deuelopment Agreement_cum_GpA
-"
of ord.ers,
in fauour
l
of th.e appellant. Equallg, the amalgamation of ABFMS & PABC was
sanctioned. It utas categoically held that there was no uiolation of
order of injunction in this regard. Importantlg, tlrc appelLant has
cortstntcted three floors euident from 3 plntograph"s marked as
Ex.P5......"
15. It is further contended that the Honble High Court by
preliminary findings in the said appeal noted that the construction
is completed till 3'a floor in the year 2007 and the petitioner has
not been able to produce any document to show that the 3.d
respondent is not authorized to construct a building in the said
premises and thus, the 3.a respondent while denying other
contentions in the writ affidavit, contended that the writ petition is
not maintainable by the petitioner, as the petitioner having hled
the instant writ petition, has not filed any supporting documents
of title along with the orders of the High Courts and Civil Courts
and thus, the writ petition is devoid of merit and is liable to be
dismissed.
16. Ha ulng gfircn eantest consideratlon to the submisslons
ma.d.e bg the leolned. counsel appearlng Jor the respectlve
parties, perused the material on record.
17. Evidently, though the Writ petition is filed challenging the
building permission granted in favour of the 3'a respondent
stating that despite the orders of the Hontrle High Court of
Madras, the said buitding permission has been granted and is
therefore, liable to be cancelled, however, except a bare
representation, dt. 11.10.2013, the petitioner has not hled any
documents to show that the petitioner has got right, title and
interest over the said property, which is a sine qua non to
maintain the present writ petition.
18. Further, the petitioner has chosen to hle only the copy of the
orders in Applications No.l8l and Lg2 of 2006 on the file of
Hontrle High Court of Madras, wherein the petitioner was one Mr.
D.Jayaraju and the 1st defendant is the property Association of
Baptist church Pvt. Ltd., represented by its Executive Director Sri
G.G.D. Divakar. When admittedly, the main grievance of the
petitioner is against the sanctif,n of the building permission to the
a
3d respondent, the purport and relevance of the said orders
to the
subject matter, is not stated, nor any materia-l is placed
establish a direct nexus betvv,een the said proceedings and
present lis, and in that view of the matter, the present writ
to
the
petition
filed by the petitioner is misconceived'
lg.Itisfurtherobservedthatthepetitionerhasagrievance
against the grant of permission in favour of the 3'd
and if there are any violations of the orders passed
respondent'
by the Hon'ble
High Court of Madras or any of the jurisdictional Courts'
it is for
the petitioner to approach the very sarne Courts which had
by
granted such orders complaining of the alleged breach'
invoking appropriate proceedings in accordance with
law'
Moreso, the permission was granted in 2OO4 and completed
2008 and a-lmost 9 years thereafter, the present Writ
in
Petition has
been instituted.
20. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in State oJ M'P' rt' Nandlal
Jaisutolt hetd that "if there is inordinate delay on the
part of the
petitioner in filirLg a writ petition and such delag is not satisfactoilA
r (198614 SCC 566
l2
explained, the High Court mag d ecline to interuene and. grant
relief
tn exercise of its writ prisdiction,,.
2l ' The aforesaid view is fortified by the Honble Supreme court
in Citg & Industrtat Devt.Corp us Dosu Aardeshir
Bhluandiutala & Ors.z wherein it was held as under:
"lt is tuell settled and needs no restatement at our
hands that under Article 226 of the Constitution, the
luisdiction of a High Court to issue appropriate writs
particularLg a uit of Mandamus is highly discretionary.
The reLieJ' can.not be claimed. as of right. One of
the
grounds fo, refusing relief is that the person
approaching the High Court is guiltg of unexplained.
delaq and the laches. Inordinate delag in mouing the
court for a Writ is an adequate ground
wit.
for refusing a
22. in view of the above, and further, as there are no documents
to support the case of the petitioner, the present writ petition
is
not maintainable, more particularly, when it involves mixed
questions of fact, which have to be determined
by way of evidence,
requiring adjudication on factual aspects which cannot
be
undertaken in proceedings under Article 226 of the constitution
of
')
(200()) I SCC t(rS
India, and therefore, the petitioner ought to have approached
competent civil Court having jurisdiction for the reiief
the
claimed in
the present writ petition. Thus, the Writ Petition is
devoid of
merits and is liable to be dismissed'
23.
Accordingly, the present Writ Petition is dismissed'
No order
as to costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, pending if any'
shall stand closed.
'RIJI;',iHiHtE'EiRiI
,fTRUE COPY"
SECTION OFFICER
i
i
I
To,
'ilf":F:i'1"il1[',?"[:"J"'"[ffi
,$,f;pff
"#i*:1;t;;[ili:'#:'"si;ir::"ff {i*"?ririri]
^5i:":i1;,i:.1::lxl'ffi
:
I
:
i
!
t
:l,8":":i:?rH:"1":g*:iTffi
',,1"i,'J',i1ffi i,'J.il"s'J[1ffi '1"'":?L'
i.!lifiiflf,;s*lr"ry;,.:;41g*f$#,
8. Two CD CoPtes
N TJ
PSK
lL:l
rban Deve'Pmen'i
HIGH COURT CC TODAY
DATED: 2410412026
ORDER
WP.No.31083 of 2013
)
'!'("
l' 3 Rp,i li
;
a-
,L
-',,/
.-:t
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
\\ ,l
I
,1
?A
)L
i ..
-'.i'l-'
\
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review