The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
27. Accordingly, the plaintiff would be entitled to pendente lite interest at the rate of 9% per annum from the date of filing of the suit i.e. 1st October, 2015 to 3rd September, 2019, the date the suit is decreed.
28. The plaintiff shall also be entitled to costs of the suit including the remuneration paid to the Local Commissioner.
29. In view of the discussion above, this Court does not find any merit in the present appeal and consequently, the same is dismissed. The cross objections filed by the plaintiff are allowed in the aforesaid terms.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment Reserved on: 7th January, 2026
Judgment pronounced on: 29th January, 2026
+
RFA 1003/2019, CM APPL. 50426/2019, CM APPL. 54558/2019
& CM APPL. 27979/2025
RENU MATHUR & ORS
Through:
.....Appellants
Mr. Jai Sahai Endlaw, Mr. Nitin
Kumar & Ms. Shruti Kapur,
Advocates.
versus
RAMESH CHANDER GUPTA
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Sachin Gupta and Ms. Mahima
Chanchalani, Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT BANSAL
JUDGMENT
AMIT BANSAL, J.
1.
The present appeal has been filed under Section 96 of the Civil
Procedure Code, 1908 (‘CPC’) read with Order XLI Rule 1 of the CPC
impugning the judgment and decree dated 3rd September, 2019 passed by the
Additional District Judge, Patiala House Courts, New Delhi in CS No.
59187/2016 (‘impugned judgment’).
2.
By the impugned judgment, the Trial Court has passed a decree of Rs.
50 lakhs in favour of the plaintiff along with future interest at the rate of
12% per annum.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
15:29:10
RFA 1003/2019
3.
The plaintiff has also filed cross objections to the extent that the Trial
Court has erred in not granting pendente lite interest as well as the costs of
the suit.
4.
This Court vide order dated 22nd November, 2019, directed the
appellants/defendants to deposit the 2/3rd of the decretal amount in the Court
which was to be kept in an interest-bearing FDR. Further, vide order dated
21st February, 2024, this Court directed release of 50% of the deposited
amount in favour of the respondent/plaintiff subject to respondent/plaintiff
furnishing a personal undertaking.
5.
Parties in the present appeal shall be hereinafter referred to as per the
nomenclature in the Trial Court. The appellants shall hereinafter be referred
to as ‘defendants’ and the respondent shall hereinafter be referred to as
‘plaintiff’.
PROCEEDINGS BEFORE THE TRIAL COURT
6.
The case set up by the plaintiff before the Trial Court was as under:
6.1
The defendants are the legal heirs of late Sh. Rakesh Bahadur Mathur
(hereinafter referred as ‘Sh. Rakesh Mathur’).
6.2
The plaintiff and Sh. Rakesh Mathur were neighbours and later
became friends. Sh. Rakesh Mathur had sold a portion of his property to the
plaintiff’s wife in 2012.
6.3
Sh. Rakesh Mathur was into property dealings and sought financial
help from the plaintiff.
6.4
The plaintiff extended an interest-free friendly loan of Rs.50 lakhs to
Sh. Rakesh Mathur over a period from July, 2013 to August, 2014 by way of
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
15:29:10
RFA 1003/2019
cheques as well as cash.
6.5
Sh. Rakesh Mathur executed two promissory notes totalling to Rs.50
lakh in favour of the plaintiff and also issued five undated cheques, totalling
Rs.50 lakhs.
6.6
Sh. Rakesh Mathur passed away on 26th July, 2015 and defendants,
who are the legal heirs of late Sh. Rakesh Mathur inherited movable and
immovable properties belonging to him.
6.7
Since the aforesaid loan amount was not returned to the plaintiff by
the defendants, a legal notice dated 11th September 2015 was served by the
plaintiff on the defendants. However, the defendants failed to make the due
payment. Accordingly, the present suit was filed by the plaintiff seeking
recovery of Rs.50 lakhs.
7.
The case set up by the defendants in the written statement is as under:
7.1
The defendants have admitted that Sh. Rakesh Mathur sold a portion
of the property bearing no. A-1, Vasant Kunj, New Delhi to the wife of the
plaintiff. It is also admitted that the plaintiff and Sh. Rakesh Mathur were
neighbours.
7.2
The defendants have denied the fact that Sh. Rakesh Mathur had
sought any financial help from the plaintiff or that the plaintiff advanced a
loan of Rs.50 lakhs to him.
7.3
The defendants have denied issuance of promissory notes or undated
cheques by Sh. Rakesh Mathur to the plaintiff. It is stated that the
promissory notes and the cheques are forged and fabricated and have been
manipulated to make out a case of loan of Rs.50 lakhs allegedly advanced
by the plaintiff to Sh. Rakesh Mathur.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
15:29:10
RFA 1003/2019
7.4
In the first promissory note of Rs.45 lakhs, it is not mentioned
whether the sum of Rs.45 lakhs was paid in cash or by cheque. Further, the
cheque numbers are also not mentioned in the said promissory note. There is
no record of advancement of Rs.29.5 lakhs in cash to Rakesh Mathur.
7.5
The plaintiff has not explained as to why Sh. Rakesh Mathur issued
four cheques and not a single cheque and why the name of the payee has
been left blank.
8.
Replication was filed on behalf of the plaintiff to the aforesaid written
statement wherein it was explained that since the loan was advanced to Sh.
Rakesh Mathur from 23rd July, 2013 to 1st September, 2013, a promissory
note dated 1st September, 2013 was issued for the consolidated amount. It is
further stated that the amount of cash or cheques were not mentioned on the
promissory note as there were multiple transactions and it was a friendly
note.
9.
Based on the pleadings of the parties, the following issues were
framed:
“1.Whether plaintiff is entitled to recovery of Rs.50 Lacs along with
penalty and future interest @ 18% p.a.?
OPP
2.Relief.”
10.
Evidence was led on behalf of both sides. Four witnesses deposed on
behalf of the plaintiff whereas on behalf of the defendants, defendant
no.2/Sh. Ujjwal Mathur being the son of late Sh. Mathur appeared as the
only witness.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
15:29:10
RFA 1003/2019
FINDINGS OF THE TRIAL COURT
11.
The Trial Court decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiff for a sum of
Rs.50 lakhs along with future interest at rate of 12% per annum, holding
that:
i.
The five cheques handed over by late Sh. Rakesh Mathur to the
plaintiff being undated would not amount to bills of exchange, however,
would have corroborative value.
ii.
The defendants had not denied the signatures of late Sh. Rakesh
Mathur on these cheques. Nor have the defendants produced any evidence to
show that signatures of late Sh. Rakesh Mathur on these five cheques were
forged or that the handwriting on the five cheques was not his.
iii.
The plaintiff duly summoned a witness from the Bank of late Sh.
Rakesh Mathur to prove the signatures on the cheque. By comparing the
signatures produced by the Bank, the signatures on the cheques were held to
be authentic.
iv.
The defendants have failed to explain as to how the aforesaid cheques
came into the possession of the plaintiff if they were not handed over by Sh.
Rakesh Mathur to the plaintiff. It was not the case of the defendants that the
said cheques were stolen by the plaintiff.
v.
The defendants have failed to produce the counterfoils of these
cheques.
12.
In respect of the two promissory notes, the Trial Court held that:
i.
The promissory notes bear the signatures of Rakesh Mathur.
ii.
The discrepancies pointed out by the defendants on the promissory
notes are not material.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
15:29:10
RFA 1003/2019
iii.
Both the promissory notes are valid promissory notes in the eyes of
law.
iv.
There is no pleading in the written statement specifically stating that
handwriting of late Sh. Rakesh Mathur on the promissory notes was forged
or that the signatures were forged. Nor have the defendants made any efforts
to disprove the handwriting or the signatures of late Rakesh Mathur.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PARTIES
13.
Mr. Jai Sahai Endlaw, counsel appearing on behalf of the
appellants/defendants has made the following submissions:
13.1 The two promissory notes do not reflect the individual transactions
and are in respect of a consolidated amount of Rs.45 lakhs and Rs. 5 lakhs,
respectively.
13.2 There are no witnesses to the two promissory notes.
13.3 The five cheques allegedly issued by the late Sh. Rakesh Mathur to
the plaintiff are undated and do not mention the name of the payee.
13.4 The plaintiff has failed to produce any receipts in respect of the cash
amounts given by the plaintiff to late Sh. Rakesh Mathur. The plaintiff has
only placed proof in respect of a cheque of Rs.16.5 lakhs received by the
defendant.
13.5 The onus to show that the promissory notes and the cheques bore the
signatures of late Sh. Rakesh Mathur and also had his handwriting was on
the plaintiff and the onus could not have been shifted on the defendants.
13.6 A wrong finding has been returned on behalf of the Trial Court that
the defendants had not denied the signatures or the handwriting of late Sh.
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
15:29:10
RFA 1003/2019
Rakesh Mathur on the cheques/promissory notes.
14.
Per contra, Mr. Sachin Gupta, counsel appearing on behalf of the
respondent/plaintiff has submitted that there is no infirmity in the order
passed by the Trial Court. The Trial Court has carefully analysed the
evidence placed on record on behalf of the parties and came to the correct
conclusion and decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiff.
15.
In support of the cross objections filed on behalf of the plaintiff, it is
submitted that there is no justification for the Trial Court in not granting
pendente lite interest in favour of the plaintiff. Even though the plaintiff was
not seeking any interest under the promissory notes, it was entitled to
pendente lite interest from the date of institution of the suit till the suit was
decreed.
16.
Mr. Gupta also presses for costs of the suit including the amount paid
to the Local Commissioner for recording evidence in the suit. In this regard,
reliance is placed on the order passed in the suit on 26th July 2016.
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS
17.
I have heard the counsel for the parties and examined the Trial Court
record filed by the parties.
18.
In my view, the Trial Court has correctly come to the conclusion that
the two promissory notes dated 1st September, 2013 and 22nd August, 2014
are valid promissory notes as they bear the signatures of late Sh. Rakesh
Mathur and the names of both the parties, i.e. the lender (the promisee) and
the borrower (the promisor) are recorded therein. The Trial Court has
correctly held that the discrepancies pointed out by the defendants in the two
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
15:29:10
RFA 1003/2019
promissory notes are not material.
19.
The Trial Court has also correctly held that there was no pleading by
the defendants in the written statement that the handwriting and/or
signatures of late Sh. Rakesh Mathur on the promissory notes were forged.
Nor was any evidence laid on behalf of the defendants to disprove the
handwriting/ signatures of late Sh. Mathur on the said promissory notes.
20.
The Trial Court has also correctly come to the conclusion that even
though the five cheques in question would not amount to bills of exchange
since they were undated and the names of the payees were blank, the said
cheques would have corroborative value since the total amount of the five
cheques was Rs.50 lakhs which is also the total amount mentioned in the
two promissory notes.
21.
The Trial Court has rightly held that the plaintiff has duly proved the
signatures and/or handwriting of the plaintiff on the cheques by summoning
the record from late Sh. Rakesh Mathur’s bank. The defendants did not lead
any evidence to show that the signature/handwriting on the cheques was not
that of late Sh. Rakesh Mathur. In this regard, Mr. Gupta has drawn attention
of the Court to the evidence of the defendant’s witness (‘DW-1’) recorded
before the Local Commissioner wherein the DW-1 was asked to produce
documents which would contain the signatures of late Sh. Rakesh Mathur.
Relevant extracts from the cross-examination of the DW-1 is set out below:
“ Q 101. Can you produce the counterfoils of the earlier cheque books
other than the; one surrendered to the bank?
Ans. I cannot say with certainty without checking for those old cheque
books.
Q 102. Can you produce the income tax returns, statements of accounts
containing balance sheet and profit and loss account from the year 2012
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
15:29:10
RFA 1003/2019
till the demise of your father?
Ans. I will check with my CA.
Q 103. Can you produce documents in the handwriting of your father or
bearing signatures of your father?
Ans. I will check if available.”
22.
On the next date of hearing before the Local Commissioner on 7th
June 2017, DW-1 made a statement that the counterfoils of the chequebooks
are not available and that he could not trace any documents which bore the
signatures of late Sh. Rakesh Mathur.
“Q104. Have you brought the documents asked to you on the LDOH?
Ans. I have brought certain documents i.e. ITR of Late Rakesh Bahadur
Mathur in respect of assessment year 2:013-14, 2014-15, 2015-16 along
with computation sheets, income and expenditure accounts and balance
sheets for the respective assessment years. However the counterfoils of the
cheque books are not available and missing from my records, I could not
trace any documents in the handwriting of my father or any documents
bearing the signature of ray father. Also there are no other statements of
accounts available except the annexure already brought to the court….
Q105. I put to you that you are deliberately not producing the counterfoils
of the previous cheque books due to the reason that it has been specifically
mentioned in the counterfoils that the cheques in question of the present
matter are mentioned by Late Rakesh Mathur in said counterfoils that the
cheques were issued to the Plaintiffs.
Ans. It is wrong
Q106. I put to you that you have deliberately not brought any documents in
respect of handwriting of your father and signature of your father Late
Rakesh Mathur as you are well aware that the Ex. PW-1/1 to Ex. PW-l/6
and Ex. PW-1/20 and also. Ex. PW-3/7 are signed by your father and even
on some documents the handwriting of your father is available and
therefore you do not want to allow the Plaintiff or the court to have any
document available for comparison.
Ans. It is wrong.”
[emphasis supplied]
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
15:29:10
RFA 1003/2019
23.
No doubt, the onus to prove that the promissory notes as well as the
cheques contained the handwriting/signatures of late Sh. Rakesh Mathur was
on the plaintiff. The plaintiff has duly fulfilled the onus by summoning the
official record from late Sh. Rakesh Mathur’s bank. However, the
defendants did not lead any evidence to disprove the evidence led on behalf
of the plaintiff. The Trial Court has also correctly held that there was no
explanation given by the defendant as to how the official cheques came to
the possession of the plaintiff if they were not handed over by late Sh.
Rakesh Mathur to him. It was not the case of the defendants that the said
cheques were stolen by the plaintiff.
24.
It is a settled position of law that a civil suit has to be decided on the
basis of preponderance of probabilities. In the present case, the Trial Court
has analysed the evidence on record and come to the conclusion that the
promissory notes as well as the cheques duly bore the signatures as well as
the handwriting of late Sh. Rakesh Mathur. Hence, the plaintiff was entitled
to the amounts in terms of the promissory notes issued by late Sh. Rakesh
Mathur.
25.
Insofar as the cross objection filed by the respondent/plaintiff is
concerned, there is no justification given by the Trial Court in not awarding
pendente lite interest. While there is no infirmity in the finding of the Trial
Court that the plaintiff was not entitled to any interest in terms of the
promissory notes, the plaintiff would be entitled to seek pendente lite
interest from the date of filing of the suit till the time the suit is decreed. A
successful party in the suit cannot be deprived of pendente lite interest.
26.
Similarly, no reasons have been given by the Trial Court for not
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
15:29:10
RFA 1003/2019
awarding costs in the favour of the plaintiff. It is a settled principle of law
that costs ordinarily are required to be awarded in favour of the successful
party. The Trial Court seems to have overlooked the order passed in the suit
on 26th July 2016, in terms of which it was recorded that payments made to
the Local Commissioner shall be recovered as cost of litigation at the end of
the suit.
27.
Accordingly, the plaintiff would be entitled to pendente lite interest at
the rate of 9% per annum from the date of filing of the suit i.e. 1st October,
2015 to 3rd September, 2019, the date the suit is decreed.
28.
The plaintiff shall also be entitled to costs of the suit including the
remuneration paid to the Local Commissioner.
29.
In view of the discussion above, this Court does not find any merit in
the present appeal and consequently, the same is dismissed. The cross
objections filed by the plaintiff are allowed in the aforesaid terms.
30.
The Registry is directed to release the balance amount out of the sums
deposited by the appellant/defendant, in favour of the respondent/plaintiff,
along with the accrued interest.
30.1 The amount so released shall be adjusted from the total amount due to
the respondent/plaintiff.
31.
All pending applications stand disposed of.
AMIT BANSAL
(JUDGE)
JANUARY 29, 2026
Rzu
Signed By:VIVEK
MISHRA
15:29:10
RFA 1003/2019
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review