Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
+
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 10.02.2026
W.P.(C) 19489/2025, CM APPL. 81374-81375/2025
RENU GOYAL
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Mohit Gupta, Ms. Seema
Ali, Ms. Pallavi, Mr. Adit
Sharma, Advs.
versus
EDELWEISS ASSET RECONSTRUCTION COMPANY LTD
AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through:
Appearance not given
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIVEK CHAUDHARY
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE RENU BHATNAGAR
RENU BHATNAGAR, J. (ORAL)
1.
The present writ petition has been instituted under Article 226
of Constitution of India by the petitioner seeking quashing of the
impugned order dated 25.03.2025 passed by the Debts Recovery
Appellate Tribunal, Delhi (hereinafter „DRAT‟) in M.A. No. 60/2025
in Appeal No. 63/2024, whereby the petitioner‟s appeal arising out of
S.A. No. 51/2020 was dismissed solely on the ground of noncompliance with the pre-deposit requirement under Section 18 of
Securitisation
and
Reconstruction
of
Financial
Assets
and
Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (hereinafter „SARFAESI
Act‟).
Signed By:PRERNA W.P.(C) 19489/2025
PATWAL
18:14:42
2.
The petitioner claims to be the absolute and lawful owner of
property bearing no. I-1612, Chittaranjan Park, New Delhi (hereinafter
„subject property‟), having acquired the same by virtue of a registered
Sale Deed dated 30.03.2007. The petitioner asserts that she is a
homemaker and has no independent source of income or financial
resources apart from the subject property.
3.
It is the case of the petitioner that respondent No. 2, namely M/s
Worlds Window Impex India Pvt. Ltd., allegedly availed certain credit
facilities from respondent No. 4, ECL Finance Ltd. The petitioner
states that she has no ownership, managerial role or financial
association with respondent No. 2.
4.
Respondent No. 3, Mr. Piyoosh Goyal, is stated to be the
husband of the petitioner. It is stated that he was shown as a coguarantor in connection with the credit facilities availed by respondent
No. 2. The subject property is stated to have been treated as secured
asset in respect of the said credit facilities on the basis of an alleged
mortgage purportedly created by respondent No.3.
5.
The petitioner further states that the loan account of respondent
No. 2 was assigned by respondent No. 4 to respondent No. 1,
Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd., on 28.06.2019. The
petitioner alleges that the said assignment was in violation of the
applicable guidelines of Reserve Bank of India governing acquisition
of non-performing assets by securitisation/reconstruction companies.
Signed By:PRERNA W.P.(C) 19489/2025
PATWAL
18:14:42
6.
Proceedings under SARFAESI Act were initiated in respect of
the subject property. Symbolic possession of the subject property was
taken on 21.11.2019, and physical possession of the subject property
was taken on 25.02.2020. Auction proceedings were initiated in
respect of the subject property by issuance of an e-auction notice dated
28.02.2020 scheduling auction of the property. The said auction did
not culminate in sale.
7.
A subsequent auction notice dated 22.06.2020 was issued
scheduling auction of the subject property. The petitioner filed
proceedings before the Debts Recovery Tribunal (hereinafter „DRT‟),
and by order dated 24.07.2020, the DRT stayed the auction
proceedings while granting liberty to initiate fresh auction proceedings
in accordance with law.
8.
Thereafter, a fresh auction notice dated 10.08.2020 was issued
and auction of the subject property was conducted on 16.09.2020. The
subject property was sold to respondent No. 6, Jeena Developers, for a
consideration of approximately Rs. 10.91 crores.
9.
A sale certificate in respect of the subject property was issued
on 28.12.2020 and possession of the subject property was handed over
to the auction purchaser.
10.
The petitioner instituted Securitisation Application No. 51/2020
before the DRT challenging the measures taken under the SARFAESI
Act. The same was dismissed vide order dated 24.11.2023.
Signed By:PRERNA W.P.(C) 19489/2025
PATWAL
18:14:42
11.
The petitioner, thereafter, preferred Appeal No. 63/2024 before
the DRAT challenging the order dated 24.11.2023 passed by the DRT.
The said appeal was dismissed by order dated 24.09.2024 on account
of non-compliance with the pre-deposit requirement and nonprosecution.
12.
Applications seeking waiver of pre-deposit were thereafter filed
before the DRAT and were dismissed. A restoration application being
Miscellaneous Application No. 172/2024 was also dismissed by order
dated 21.02.2025.
13.
Subsequently, Miscellaneous Application No. 60/2025 seeking
recall of the order dated 21.02.2025 and restoration of the appeal was
filed before the DRAT. The said application was dismissed by order
dated 25.03.2025 on the ground of non-compliance with the predeposit requirement.
14.
The present writ petition has been filed challenging the order
dated 25.03.2025 passed by the DRAT.
15.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that the
petitioner is the absolute owner of the subject property and has no
involvement in the business or financial affairs of respondent No. 2. It
is submitted that the subject property was wrongfully subjected to
measures under the SARFAESI Act in connection with credit facilities
availed by respondent No.2, despite the petitioner not being a
borrower in relation to the said transaction.
Signed By:PRERNA W.P.(C) 19489/2025
PATWAL
18:14:42
16.
Learned counsel further submits that the Securitisation
Application filed by the petitioner before the DRT was dismissed
without adjudication of the principal issues raised by the petitioner,
including the validity of the mortgage, the legality of the assignment
of debt, and the legality of the auction proceedings.
17.
It is submitted that the statutory appeal preferred by the
petitioner before the DRAT was dismissed solely on the ground of
non-compliance with the pre-deposit requirement under Section 18 of
the SARFAESI Act and without consideration of the petitioner‟s
challenge on merits.
18.
Learned counsel submits that the petitioner sought waiver of the
pre-deposit requirement before the DRAT on the ground that she is a
homemaker without independent income and was unable to arrange
the amount required to be deposited. It is contended that the DRAT
failed to consider the petitioner‟s financial condition and mechanically
dismissed the applications seeking waiver and restoration of appeal.
19.
It is further submitted that respondent No. 1 had already
realised substantial amounts through the auction of the subject
property and that the insistence on pre-deposit without adjustment of
the sale proceeds has resulted in denial of the petitioner‟s statutory
remedy of appeal.
20.
On the aforesaid grounds, learned counsel for the petitioner
submits that the impugned orders passed by the DRT and DRAT are
Signed By:PRERNA W.P.(C) 19489/2025
PATWAL
18:14:42
liable to be set aside and the petitioner‟s appeal deserves to be restored
for adjudication on merits.
21.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and perused the
material on record.
22.
The principal controversy in the present petition relates to the
requirement of pre-deposit for maintaining an appeal before the
DRAT. It therefore becomes necessary to first examine the
requirement of pre-deposit in appeals arising under SARFAESI Act.
Section 18 of the SARFAESI Act is reproduced as under:
“18. Appeal to Appellate Tribunal.—(1) Any
person aggrieved, by any order made by the
Debts Recovery Tribunal1[under section 17,
may prefer an appeal along with such fee, as
may be prescribed] to the Appellate Tribunal
within thirty days from the date of receipt of
the order of Debts Recovery Tribunal.
[Provided that different fees may be
prescribed for filing an appeal by the
borrower or by the person other than the
borrower:]
[Provided further that no appeal shall be
entertained unless the borrower has deposited
with the Appellate Tribunal fifty per cent. of
the amount of debt due from him, as claimed
by the secured creditors or determined by the
Debts Recovery Tribunal, whichever is less:
Provided also that the Appellate Tribunal
may, for the reasons to be recorded in
writing, reduce the amount to not less than
twenty-five per cent. of debt referred to in the
second proviso.]
Signed By:PRERNA W.P.(C) 19489/2025
PATWAL
18:14:42
(2) Save as otherwise provided in this Act, the
Appellate Tribunal shall, as far as may be,
dispose of the appeal in accordance with the
provisions of the Recovery of Debts Due to
Banks and Financial Institutions Act, 1993 (51
of 1993) and rules made thereunder.”
(emphasis supplied)
23.
A plain reading of Section 18 of the SARFAESI Act indicates
that the statute confers a right of appeal against an order passed by the
DRT under Section 17 of the Act. However, the said right is not
absolute. The second proviso to Section 18 expressly stipulates that no
appeal shall be entertained unless the borrower deposits fifty percent
of the amount of debt due from him, either as claimed by the secured
creditor or as determined by the DRT, whichever is less.
24.
The third proviso vests a very limited discretion in the DRAT to
reduce the amount to be deposited, but such reduction cannot be
below twenty-five percent of the debt so due. The legislative language
in the provision, particularly “no appeal shall be entertained” makes
the
requirement
of
pre-deposit
a
condition
precedent
for
maintainability of an appeal before the DRAT.
25.
The said proviso therefore indicates that the discretion available
to the DRAT is not an unchained one. While the DRAT may reduce
the deposit requirement from fifty percent to twenty five percent for
reasons to be recorded in writing, the provision does not talk about
complete waiver of the pre-deposit requirement.
Signed By:PRERNA W.P.(C) 19489/2025
PATWAL
18:14:42
26.
In the present case, the impugned order dated 25.03.2025
passed by the DRAT records that the petitioner‟s appeal and
subsequent restoration application were dismissed on account of noncompliance with the pre-deposit requirement as per SARFAESI.
DRAT, while considering the petitioner‟s applications seeking waiver
of complete pre-deposit amount, held that compliance with the
statutory requirement was mandatory for maintainability of the appeal
and declined to grant complete waiver of the deposit condition. The
relevant part of the impugned order is reproduced herein below:
“This appeal under Section 18 of the
SARFAESI Act was filed against the order
dated 24.11.2023 passed by the Ld. DRT. For
the entertainment of the appeal, appellant had
to make at least minimum pre-deposit of
25%as envisaged under second proviso to
Section 18 of the Act. Despite several
opportunity afforded to the appellant, she
failed to comply with the mandatory
requirement of pre-deposit. True, the appellant
had an also filed application (1.A.
No.688/2024) for complete waiver of the
condition of pre deposit along with the appeal,
urging that she has a meritorious case and the
property which she alleged to have been
mortgaged has been illegally old by the bank,
but all these contentions on merit can be
considered only once the appeal is entertained
after due compliance of the condition of
predeposit and this Tribunal is not empowered
to order Complete waiver of the pre-deposit.
What to speak of this Tribunal, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court has in Kotak Mahindra Bank
Pvt. Ltd vs. Ambuj A Kasliwal & Ors., Civil
Appeal No. 538/2021, decided on 16.02.2021,
has observed that even the Hon'ble High Court
Signed By:PRERNA W.P.(C) 19489/2025
PATWAL
18:14:42
does not have the power to waive the predeposit in its entirety, nor can it exercise
discretion, which is against the mandatory
requirements of the statutory provisions.
***
It may be mentioned that in the application
filed by the appellant no prayer has been made
by the appellant for time to comply with the
condition of pre-deposit or undertaken to
comply with the same.
In view of the above discussion, since the
appellant has not made any pre-deposit
despite opportunities given, no more time can
be given to the appellant for compliance of the
condition of pre-deposit.
The present
dismissed.”
27.
application
is,
therefore,
DRAT, while passing the impugned order, has also placed
reliance upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in Kotak Mahindra
Bank (P) Ltd. v. Ambuj A. Kasliwal, (2021) 3 SCC 549, wherein the
Supreme Court examined the statutory requirement of pre-deposit in
recovery proceedings. DRAT noted that the Supreme Court has held
that where the statute provides that an appeal shall not be entertained
without deposit of a specified portion of the debt, such requirement
constitutes a mandatory statutory condition governing the exercise of
the appellate remedy. The relevant part of the aforesaid judgment is
reproduced herein below:
“17. …In all cases fifty per cent of the decretal
amount i.e. the debt due is to be deposited
before the DRAT as a mandatory requirement,
but in appropriate cases for reasons to be
Signed By:PRERNA W.P.(C) 19489/2025
PATWAL
18:14:42
recorded the deposit of at least twenty-five per
cent of the debt due would be permissible, but
not entire waiver. Therefore, any waiver of
pre-deposit to the entire extent would be
against the statutory provisions and, therefore,
not sustainable in law.
18. It is noticed that this Court while
considering an analogous provision contained
in Section 18 of the Securitisation and
Reconstruction of Financial Assets and
Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002
(“Sarfaesi” for short) relating to pre-deposit
in order to avail the remedy of appeal has
expressed a similar opinion in Narayan
Chandra Ghosh v. UCO Bank [Narayan
Chandra Ghosh v. UCO Bank, (2011) 4 SCC
548 : (2011) 2 SCC (Civ) 362] , which reads
as hereunder:
“7. Section 18(1) of the Act confers a statutory
right on a person aggrieved by any order
made by the Debts Recovery Tribunal under
Section 17 of the Act to prefer an appeal to the
Appellate Tribunal. However, the right
conferred under Section 18(1) is subject to the
condition laid down in the second proviso
thereto. The second proviso postulates that no
appeal shall be entertained unless the
borrower has deposited with the Appellate
Tribunal fifty per cent of the amount of debt
due from him, as claimed by the secured
creditors or determined by the Debts Recovery
Tribunal, whichever is less. However, under
the third proviso to the sub-section, the
Appellate Tribunal has the power to reduce
the amount, for the reasons to be recorded in
writing, to not less than twenty-five per cent of
the debt, referred to in the second proviso.
Thus, there is an absolute bar to the
entertainment of an appeal under Section 18 of
the Act unless the condition precedent, as
stipulated, is fulfilled. Unless the borrower
Signed By:PRERNA W.P.(C) 19489/2025
PATWAL
18:14:42
makes, with the Appellate Tribunal, a predeposit of fifty per cent of the debt due from
him or determined, an appeal under the said
provision cannot be entertained by the
Appellate Tribunal. The language of the said
proviso is clear and admits of no ambiguity.
8. It is well settled that when a statute confers
a right of appeal, while granting the right, the
legislature can impose conditions for the
exercise of such right, so long as the
conditions are not so onerous as to amount to
unreasonable restrictions, rendering the right
almost illusory. Bearing in mind the object of
the Act, the conditions hedged in the said
proviso cannot be said to be onerous. Thus,
we hold that the requirement of pre-deposit
under sub-section (1) of Section 18 of the Act
is mandatory and there is no reason
whatsoever for not giving full effect to the
provisions contained in Section 18 of the Act.
In that view of the matter, no court, much less
the Appellate Tribunal, a creature of the Act
itself, can refuse to give full effect to the
provisions of the statute. We have no
hesitation in holding that deposit under the
second proviso to Section 18(1) of the Act
being a condition precedent for preferring an
appeal under the said section, the Appellate
Tribunal had erred in law in entertaining the
appeal without directing the appellant to
comply with the said mandatory requirement.”
(emphasis supplied)
28.
The Supreme Court, inter alia, observed that the legislative
scheme permits only a limited discretion in the Appellate Tribunal to
reduce the pre-deposit requirement, but such reduction cannot be
below twenty-five per cent of the debt due. It categorically held that
the statutory discretion operates only between fifty percent and twenty
Signed By:PRERNA W.P.(C) 19489/2025
PATWAL
18:14:42
five percent of the debt and does not extend to complete waiver of the
deposit requirement.
29.
Examined in the light of the aforesaid legal position, the
impugned order passed by the DRAT cannot be said to suffer from
any error. In our opinion, the DRAT has merely enforced the statutory
mandate contained in Section 18 of the SARFAESI Act while
declining to entertain the petitioner‟s appeal in absence of compliance
with the pre-deposit requirement. The order reflects application of the
statutory framework and cannot be said to be arbitrary or contrary to
law.
30.
In view of the above, this Court finds no ground to interfere
with the impugned order dated 25.03.2025 passed by the DRAT.
31.
Consequently, the present writ petition stands dismissed along
with pending applications, if any.
VIVEK CHAUDHARY, J
RENU BHATNAGAR, J
FEBRUARY 10, 2026/ka/neha
Signed By:PRERNA W.P.(C) 19489/2025
PATWAL
18:14:42
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review