Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
#
+
Judgment reserved on: 07.09.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 10.09.2026
CNR No. DLHC010555102023
O.M.P. (COMM) 533/2023
RELIGARE FINVEST LIMITED
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Sanjeev Singh, Ms.
Sandipa Bhattacharjee, Ms.
Sneha Mondal & Mr. Kartik
Sharma, Advs.
versus
ATELIER AUTOMOBILES PVT. LTD.
& ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Tarun Gupta & Mr. Hirday
Virdi, Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AVNEESH JHINGAN
JUDGMENT
1.
This petition is filed under Section 34 of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short ‘the Act’) challenging the arbitral
award dated 02.08.2023 and the order dated 20.09.2023.
2.
The petitioner is a non-banking financial company engaged in
providing financial and credit facilities. The respondent availed a loan
facility of Rs.11,50,00,000/- from the petitioner pursuant to the loan
agreement dated 14.03.2016. The loan carried floating interest initially
at 13% per annum subsequently revised to 14% per annum w.e.f.
20.02.2021. The loan was secured inter alia by mortgage of
immovable property situated at Megh Chhaper Pargana Tehsil and
District Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh.
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 533/2023
15:26:49
2.1
On account of defaults in payment of instalments the petitioner
invoked arbitration and recalled the loan vide notice dated 14.10.2019
claiming Rs.10,13,79,085/- as outstanding as on 09.10.2019. Upon
failure of the respondents to liquidate the dues, on 08.11.2019 the
petitioner appointed the sole arbitrator.
2.2
During the pendency of the proceedings the respondent filed a
petition under Sections 14 and 15 of the Act seeking termination of
the mandate of the unilaterally appointed arbitrator and appointment
of a substitute arbitrator. By order dated 07.12.2022 this court
appointed the sole arbitrator.
2.3
By the impugned award the arbitrator allowed the claims of the
petitioner and awarded Rs.9,98,32,582/- towards principal with
pendente lite interest @10% per annum, post-award interest @10%
per annum and proportionate arbitration costs to the petitioner. The
respondents were further permitted to discharge the award amount in
thirty-six equated in monthly instalments commencing from
10.09.2023. The entire amount shall become recoverable upon default
in payment of any two instalments.
2.4
Both parties thereafter preferred applications under Section 33
of the Act. The respondent sought adjustment of payments made after
09.10.2019 whereas the petitioner sought rectification of the
computation of the awarded amount. By order dated 20.09.2023 the
arbitrator modified the award by providing for 10% interest from
14.10.2019 till the date of award and permitting adjustments of
payment made during the relevant period. Aggrieved by the award and
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 533/2023
15:26:49
the modification, the present petition has been filed.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the arbitrator
erred in awarding interest @10% per annum instead of the contractual
rate of 13% per annum and failed to assign any reason for awarding
the pendente lite interest and the post award interest both @10% per
annum.
4.
Per contra learned counsel submits that the petitioner after
having accepted the payments pursuant to the repayment schedule
furnished vide e-mail dated 01.09.2023, is estopped from assailing the
rate of interest awarded by the arbitrator. Reliance to support
acceptance of amount by the petitioner is on the similar pleadings
made in application under Section 33 of the Act filed by the petitioner
and the reply of the petitioner to the application under Section 33 of
the Act filed by the respondent.
4.1
Reliance is placed upon the decision of the Supreme Court in
Rajasthan
State
Industrial
Development
and
Investment
Corporation and Anr. v. Diamond & Gem Development Corporation
Limited & Anr. (2013) 5 SCC 470 to contend that a party cannot be
permitted approbate and re-probate or blow hot and cold
simultaneously and that a party having accepted the benefits of a
contract subsequently cannot repudiate the obligations arising
therefrom.
4.2
Reliance is on the decision of this court in Sporty Solutionz Pvt.
Ltd. v. Badminton Association of India 2020:DHC:897 and MS K S
Jain
Builders
v.
Indian
Railway
Welfare
Organisation
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 533/2023
15:26:49
2024:DHC:2943 to contend that having accepted the awarded amount
and acted upon the repayment arrangement, the petitioner is estopped
from the challenging the award.
5.
The arbitrator framed the following issues:
“I. 1 Whether the loan recall notice dated 14.10.2019
was not acted upon and/ or is deemed to have been
withdrawn, as alleged in the Statement of Defense?
OPR
II. 2 Whether the claimant is entitled to the amount of
Rs. 10,80,02,230/claimed by it? OPC
III. 3 Whether the Claimant is entitled to interest and if
so at what rate and for which period? OPC
IV. 4 Whether the Claimant is entitled to the coast of
Arbitration and if so, to what amount? OPC
V. 5 Whether the Respondents are entitled in law, to
set off the amount of Rs.89,45,945/- out of the amount
if any found payable by the Respondents to the
Claimant? OPR.
VI. 6 Relief”
6.
The only grievance pressed by learned counsel for the petitioner
in the petition pertains to the rate of interest (hereinafter ‘ROI’)
awarded for the period commencing from the filing of the statement of
claim till passing of the award and the post-award period. There is no
dispute between the parties that under the the loan agreement, the
agreed floating ROI was 13% per annum which was subsequently
amended to 14% per annum.
6.1
Before proceeding further it would be relevant to quote Section
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 533/2023
15:26:49
31(7)(a) and (b) of the Act:
“31. Form and contents of arbitral award.—
***
(7) (a) Unless otherwise agreed by the parties, where and
in so far as an arbitral award is for the payment of money,
the arbitral tribunal may include in the sum for which the
award is made interest, at such rate as it deems
reasonable, on the whole or any part of the money, for the
whole or any part of the period between the date on
which the cause of action arose and the date on which the
award is made.
(b) A sum directed to be paid by an arbitral award shall,
unless the award otherwise directs, carry interest at the
rate of two per cent. higher than the current rate of
interest prevalent on the date of award, from the date of
award to the date of payment.
Explanation.—The expression “current rate of interest”
shall have the same meaning as assigned to it under
clause (b) of section 2 of the Interest Act, 1978 (14 of
1978).”
7.
Under Section 31(7)(a) of the Act, the arbitrator can award
interest at a reasonable rate on the whole or any part of the amount
awarded for the whole or any part of the period arising from the cause
of action till date of the award, unless the parties have otherwise
agreed. In the case in hand, the parties had agreed for a floating ROI
@14%. No evidence was led before the arbitrator to establish the
prevailing ROI yet without recording any basis or reasoning, simple
interest @10% per annum was awarded from date of filing of the
statement of claim till passing of the award.
8.
The award of pendente lite interest being unsupported by any
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 533/2023
15:26:49
reasons or discernible basis for determination of the ROI is contrary to
Section 31(7)(a) of the Act and falls foul of Section 31(3) of the Act.
9.
Under Section 31(7)(b) of the Act, in case of the post-award
interest unless otherwise directed by the award, the sum awarded
carries an interest of 2% higher than the current rate prevalent on the
date of the award. The explanation to Section 31(7)(b) provides that
the expression ‘current rate of interest’ shall have same meaning
assigned to it under Section 2(b) of the Interest Act, 1978. Section
2(b) of the Interest Act, 1978 is reproduced below:
“Section 2. Definitions.
***
(b) "current rate of interest" means the highest of
the maximum rates at which interest may be paid
on different classes of deposits (other than those
maintained in savings account or those
maintained by charitable or religious institutions)
by different classes of scheduled banks in
accordance with the directions given or issued to
banking companies generally by the Reserve
Bank of India under the Banking Regulation Act,
1949 (10 of 1949).
Explanation.--In this clause, "scheduled bank"
means a bank, not being a co-operative bank,
transacting any business authorised by the
Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (10 of 1949);”
10.
The arbitrator without determining the prevailing ROI or
disclosing any basis awarded simple interest @10% per annum for
post-award period. The granting of post-award interest is bereft of
discernible basis, non-speaking, in violation of Section 31(3) of the
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 533/2023
15:26:49
Act, and suffers from patent illegality and is liable to be set aside.
11.
The reliance of the learned counsel for the respondent on
decision of this Court in Sporty Solutions Pvt. Ltd. (supra) to contend
that having accepted the awarded amount the petitioner is precluded
from challenging the award via filing a petition under Section 34 of
the Act, lacks merit. In that case, an amount of Rs.2.50 crores was
awarded to the petitioner as compensation for the failure of the
respondent to give the contractually stipulated three months’ notice
prior to termination, to be paid within three months from the date of
award. The petitioner filed a petition under Section 34 of the Act but
withdrew it and accepted the release of the awarded amount of Rs.2.5
crores. The petitioner accepted the compensation unconditionally. In
that background, this Court held that having accepted the benefit
under the award, the petitioner was estopped from subsequently
challenging the award or claiming interest thereon by filing a second
petition under Section 34 of the Act.
12.
The reliance on the decision of this Court in MS K S Jain
Builders (supra) is misconceived. The question whether acceptance of
principal amount awarded operates as an estoppel against challenging
the ROI was neither an issue before the Court nor was any finding
rendered on this issue.
13.
The Supreme Court in Rajasthan State Industrial Development
and Investment Corporation (supra) considered the maintainability
of a writ petition in a contractual matter. There is no quarrel with the
proposition enunciated that a party cannot be allowed to approbate and
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 533/2023
15:26:49
re-probate simultaneously. This principle is based on equity and
fairness and is intended to prevent a party from accepting and
rejecting the same transaction to its advantage. This principle cannot
be applied mechanically or in a manner contrary to the principles of
right and good conscience.
14.
In the present case the claiming of the awarded amount
specially when not disputed by the respondent shall not debar the
petitioner to pray for interest at an enhanced rate. Moreso, when
principal amount awarded is not disputed by either of the party.
15.
The reliance on the pleadings in the application under Section
33 of the Act filed by the petitioner and the reply of the petitioner to
the application under Section 33 of the Act filed by the respondent
does not tantamount to acceptance of the award by the petitioner. The
pleadings were confined to opposing the correction sought by the
respondent and for that purpose reference to the awarded amount and
interest granted thereupon was made. Relevant paragraph of the
application under Section 33 of the Act filed by the petitioner is
reproduced below:
“13. That the Respondents have mischievously filed
the application to create confusion and have blatantly
without any basis submitted that an amount of
Rs.2,07,09,851 /- stands outstanding to evade their
entire outstanding liability. However, this Hon'ble
Arbitral Tribunal may be pleased to reject incorrect
representation of the Respondents and pass appropriate
directions under this Application filed by the Claimant
to the Respondents to pay an amount of Rs.
10,80,02,230/- (Rupees Ten Crore Eighty Lakh Two
Thousand Two Hundred Thirty only) with effect from
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 533/2023
15:26:49
20.02.2021 at simple interest of 10% p.a. till payment
of the entire amount.”
16.
Similarly, the e-mail dated 01.09.2023 whereby the petitioner
had sought the recovery of the awarded amount, does not record
waiver or relinquishment of the right by the petitioner to avail the
remedies against the award. The demand for payment of the awarded
amount in absence of any express or unequivocal abandonment of the
statutory remedies cannot be construed as acceptance of the award in
its entirety.
17.
The Supreme Court in Gayatri Balasamy v. ISG Novasoft
Technologies Ltd.,(2025) 7 SCC 1 held that while an arbitral award
cannot be modified under Section 34 of the Act, a severable part of the
award may be set aside. The relevant paragraphs are quoted below:
“32. In the present controversy, the proviso to Section
34(2)(a)(iv) is particularly relevant. It states that if the
decisions on matters submitted to arbitration can be
separated from those not submitted, only that part of the
arbitral award which contains decisions on matters nonsubmitted may be set aside. The proviso, therefore,
permits courts to sever the non-arbitrable portions of an
award from arbitrable ones. This serves a twofold
purpose. First, it aligns with Section 16 of the 1996 Act,
which affirms the principle of kompetenz- kompetenz,
that is, the arbitrators' competence to determine their
own jurisdiction. Secondly, it enables the Court to sever
and preserve the “valid” part(s) of the award while
setting aside the “invalid” ones.27 Indeed, before us,
none of the parties have argued that the Court is not
empowered to undertake such a segregation.
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 533/2023
15:26:49
33. We hold that the power conferred under the proviso
to Section 34(2)(a)(iv) is clarificatory in nature. The
authority to sever the “invalid” portion of an arbitral
award from the “valid” portion, while remaining within
the narrow confines of Section 34, is inherent in the
Court's jurisdiction when setting aside an award.
34. To this extent, the doctrine of omne majus continet
in se minus—the greater power includes the lesser—
applies squarely. The authority to set aside an arbitral
award necessarily encompasses the power to set it aside
in part, rather than in its entirety. This interpretation is
practical and pragmatic.It would be incongruous to hold
that power to set aside would only mean power to set
aside the award in its entirety and not in part. A contrary
interpretation would not only be inconsistent with the
statutory framework but may also result in valid
determinations being unnecessarily nullified.”
(emphasis supplied)
18.
The issue no.3 awarding pendente lite interest unsupported by
reasons for determination of the ROI and the grant of post-award
interest are contrary to Section 31(7)(a) and (b) of the Act and is
patently illegal.
19.
The issue no. 3 is severable not intricately connected to the
other claims adjudicated by the arbitrator. Consequently, the petition
is allowed and the award to the extent of grant of interest is set aside.
AVNEESH JHINGAN, J
SEPTEMBER 10, 2026/‘JK’
Reportable:- Yes
Signed By:CHANCHAL
O.M.P. (COMM) 533/2023
15:26:49
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review