Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 20th May 2026
+
MAC.APP. 835/2014
RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Rajeev M. Roy, Advocate
(through VC)
versus
SMT. SIMMY & ORS
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Shrey Chathly, Advocate for
respondent Nos. 1 to 3.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
%
ANISH DAYAL, J (ORAL)
1.
This appeal has been filed by appellant/Insurance Company,
seeking reduction of the compensation awarded by the Motor Accidents
Claims Tribunal , Karkardooma Courts, Delhi [‘MACT/Tribunal’], vide
Award dated 31st May 2014 in M.A.C Petition No. 174/2012 [‘impugned
award’], whereby compensation of Rs. 41,65,276/- along with interest @
9% was awarded.
2.
The accident occurred on 01st September 2012, when Mr. Rajesh
Khattolia [hereinafter, ‘deceased’] was travelling to Uttarakhand along
with his friends in an Alto Car. Said car fell into a ditch, allegedly due to
the rash and negligent driving of its driver [respondent no.4 herein], as a
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 835/2014
16:10:55
result of which, deceased died on the spot.
3.
The deceased was in the employment of Tech books International
Pvt. Ltd. as a “Senior Executive” and was earning Rs. 26,621/- per month
at time of the accident.
4.
Mr. Rajeev M. Roy, counsel for appellant/Insurance Company,
submits that components of compensation need to be re-aligned with the
decision of the Supreme Court in National Insurance Company v.
Pranay Sethi & Ors. (2017) 16 SCC 680.
5.
Considering that the appeal is a continuation of the claim
proceedings, the right of appellant/Insurance Company to seek alignment
of compensation subsists in this regard, particularly in view of the
judgement passed by this Court in IFFCO Tokio Gen. Ins. Co. Ltd. v.
Anil Kumar Kaushik, 2026 SCC OnLine Del 1378, wherein this Court
held that the principles laid down in Pranay Sethi (supra) would apply
to all pending matters, irrespective of the stage of pendency, including
those which are a continuation of or arise out of claim petition . For ease
of reference, relevant paragraphs of the aforesaid judgement are
extracted as under:
“10. An issue came up for deliberation whether the decision
in Pranay Sethi (supra) would have retrospective
application to an award which was given prior to 2018. In
this regard, reference was made to a decision of Supreme
Court in New India Assurance Company v. Sonigra Juhi
Uttamchand, 2025 INSC 15, where the Supreme Court
stated that the High Court could not be faulted in fixing
amounts in excess of the amounts fixed in Pranay
Sethi (supra), since the judgment was passed prior to the
pronouncement of the judgment in Pranay Sethi (Supra) and
stated as under:
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 835/2014
16:10:55
“9… we are of the view that the Tribunal and the High
Court cannot be found at fault with fixing the amounts
in excess of the aforesaid amounts fixed by this Court
as the award and the judgment of the High Courts
were passed prior to the pronouncement of the
judgment of this Court in Pranay Sethi's case. But at
the same time, it is to be noted that in the decision
in M.A. Murthy v. State of Karnataka, this Court held
that when in a decision this Court enunciates a
principle of law, it is applicable to all cases
irrespective of the stage of pendency thereof because it
is to be assumed that what is enunciated by this Court
is, in fact, the law from inception. We may hasten to
add that we shall not be understood to have held that
pursuant to enunciation of a principle of law, matters
that attained finality shall be reopened solely for the
purpose of applying the law thus laid. But at the same
time, if the matter is pending, then, irrespective of the
stage, the principle cannot be ignored.”
(emphasis added)
11. Further reliance was placed upon MM Murthy v. State
of Karnataka, (2003) 7 SCC 517, where the Supreme Court
held as under:
“8. The learned counsel for the appellant submitted
that the approach of the High Court is erroneous as
the law declared by this Court is presumed to be the
law at all times. Normally, the decision of this Court
enunciating a principle of law is applicable to all cases
irrespective its stage of pendency because it is assumed
that what is enunciated by the Supreme Court is, in
fact, the law from inception. The doctrine of
prospective over-ruling which is a feature of American
jurisprudence is an exception to the normal principle
of law, was imported and applied for the first time
in L.C. Golak Nath v. State of Punjab (1967 SCC
OnLine SC 14 : AIR 1967 SC 1643). In Managing
Director, ECIL, Hyderabad v. B. Karunakar ((1993) 4
SCC 727) the view was adopted. Prospective overruling is a part of the principles of constitutional canon
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 835/2014
16:10:55
of interpretation and can be resorted to by this Court
while superseding law declared by it earlier. It is a
device innovated to avoid reopening of settled issues,
to prevent multiplicity of proceedings, and to avoid
uncertainty and avoidable litigation. In other words,
actions taken contrary to the law declared prior to the
date of declaration are validated in larger public
interest. The law as declared applies to future cases.
(See Ashok Kumar Gupta v. State of U.P. (1997) 5 SCC
201, Baburam v. C.C. Jacob (1999) 3 SCC 362 : 1999
SCC (Cri) 433). It is for this Court to indicate as to
whether the decision in question will operate
prospectively. In other words, there shall be no
prospective over-ruling, unless it is so indicated in the
particular decision. It is not open to be held that the
decision in a particular case will be prospective in its
application by application of the doctrine of
prospective over-ruling. The doctrine of binding
precedent helps in promoting certainty and consistency
in judicial decisions and enables an organic
development of the law besides providing assurance to
the individual as to the consequences of transactions
forming part of the daily affairs. That being the
position, the High Court was in error by holding that
the judgment which operated on the date of selection
was operative and not the review judgment in Ashok
Kumar Sharma's case No. II. All the more so when the
subsequent judgment is by way of Review of the first
judgment in which case there are no judgments at all
and the subsequent judgment rendered on review
petitions is the one and only judgment rendered,
effectively and for all purposes, the earlier decision
having been erased by countenancing the review
applications. The impugned judgments of the High
Court are, therefore, set aside.”
(emphasis added)
12. In Kanishk Sinha v. The State of West Bengal, 2025
INSC 278, the Supreme Court has further reviewed the issue
as under:
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 835/2014
16:10:55
“3. …Now the law of prospective and retrospective
operation is absolutely clear. Whereas a law made by
the legislature is always prospective in nature unless it
has been specifically stated in the statute itself about
its retrospective operation, the reverse is true for the
law which is laid down by a Constitutional Court, or
law as it is interpretated by the Court. The judgment of
the Court will always be retrospective in nature unless
the judgment itself specifically states that the judgment
will operate prospectively. The prospective operation
of a judgment is normally done to avoid any
unnecessary burden to persons or to avoid undue
hardships to those who had bona fidely done
something with the understanding of the law as it
existed at the relevant point of time. Further, it is done
not to unsettle something which has long been settled,
as that would cause injustice to many.”
(emphasis added)
13. Considering that the appeal is a continuation of the
claim proceedings, these principles enunciated by the
Supreme Court would squarely apply.
14. MV Act is a beneficial legislation. Courts have
consistently applied the principles of Pranay Sethi (supra)
to align the elements of compensation in order to provide
standardization which has been the bulwark of the decision
in Pranay Sethi (supra).”
(emphasis added)
6.
Accordingly, considering that the deceased was 41 years of age,
future prospects awarded at 30% by the Tribunal shall be taken as 25%
in terms of the decision of the Supreme Court in Pranay Sethi (supra).
Relevant paragraphs in this regard are extracted hereinbelow:
“59.3. While determining the income, an addition of 50% of
actual salary to the income of the deceased towards future
prospects, where the deceased had a permanent job and was
below the age of 40 years, should be made. The addition
should be 30%, if the age of the deceased was between 40 to
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 835/2014
16:10:55
50 years. In case the deceased was between the age of 50 to
60 years, the addition should be 15%. Actual salary should
be read as actual salary less tax.
59.4. In case the deceased was self-employed or on a fixed
salary, an addition of 40% of the established income should
be the warrant where the deceased was below the age of 40
years. An addition of 25% where the deceased was between
the age of 40 to 50 years and 10% where the deceased was
between the age of 50 to 60 years should be regarded as the
necessary method of computation. The established income
means the income minus the tax component.”
(emphasis added)
7.
Similarly, the amount awarded towards loss of love and affection
shall stand deleted in view of the decision of the Supreme Court in
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satinder Kaur (2021) 11 SCC 780.
Loss of consortium, for three family members shall be taken at Rs.
40,000/- per family member, which totals up to Rs.1,20,000/-. Loss of
estate and funeral expenses, shall both be taken at Rs. 15,000/- each.
Multiplier adopted at ‘14’ is in consonnance with the decision of the
Supreme Court in Sarla Verma v DTC (2009) 6 SCC 121.
8.
Accordingly, the compensation shall be re-computed as under:
S. NO.
HEADS
AWARDED BY
THE TRIBUNAL
AWARDED BY
THIS COURT
Annual Income of deceased
(A) (less Income Tax)
Rs. 3,23,934/-
Rs. 3,23,934/-
(Monthly income
@ Rs. 26,993.6)
(Monthly income
@ Rs. 26,993.6)
30%
25%
Add Future Prospects (B)
Less Personal expenses of the
deceased (C)
Rs. 1,40,367/-
Rs. 1,34,968/-
Annual loss of dependency
Rs. 2,80,734/-
Rs. 2,69,937/-
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 835/2014
16:10:55
(D)
Multiplier (E)
Total loss of dependency
(Dx12xE = F)
Rs. 39,30,276/-
Rs. 37,79,118/-
Medical expenses (G)
Nil
Nil
Compensation for loss of
consortium (H)
Rs. 1,00,000/-
Rs. 1,20,000/-
Compensation for loss of love
and affection (I)
Rs. 1,00,000/-
Nil
Compensation for loss of
estate (J)
Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Compensation towards
funeral expenses (K)
Rs. 25,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs.41,65,276
Rs.39,29,118
9%
9%
Total compensation
(F+G+H+I+J+K = L)
Interest
9.
Accordingly, the compensation is reduced by Rs.2,36,158/-.
10.
Vide order dated 15th September 2014, this Court had directed
appellant/Insurance Company to deposit the compensation amount
before the Registrar General of this Court and release 75% of the same in
favour of the claimants. The balance amount was directed to be kept in a
fixed deposit returns [FDRs] with UCO Bank, Delhi High Court Branch,
initially for one year along with a provision for renewal.
11.
The balance compensation, in terms of the revised computation,
be released to the claimants in accordance with the scheme stipulated in
the impugned award, and the reduced amount be refunded to the
Insurance Company, along with accrued interest.
12.
Mr.
Shrey Chathly, counsel appears on behalf of claimants;
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 835/2014
16:10:55
counsel for respondent nos. 4 and 5, the driver and the owner
respectively, were sought to be served through substituted service but
have not appeared and have, therefore, been proceeded ex-parte.
13.
It is noted that the recovery rights granted to the Insurance
Company, against respondent no.4 and 5/driver and owner respectively,
as provided in paragraph 29 of the Tribunal award, shall subsist.
14.
Accordingly, the appeal has been disposed of.
15.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
16.
Statutory deposit, if any, shall be refunded to appellant/Insurance
Company.
17.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
MAY 20, 2026/RK/ya+tk
KUMAR CHOUDHARY MAC. APP. 835/2014
16:10:55
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review