Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Reserved on: 16.12.2025
Pronounced on: 19.02.2026
Uploaded on: 19.02.2026
MAC.APP. 447/2017 & CM APPL. 2327/2019
RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD.
..... Appellant
Through: Ms. Prerna Mehta, Advocate.
versus
MOHD NAHID & ORS.
Through:
..... Respondents
Mr. S.N. Parashar & Mr. Ritik Singh,
Advocates for R-1.
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PRATEEK JALAN
JUDGMENT
1.
By way of this appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicle Act,
1988 [“MV Act”], the appellant-Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd. [“the
Insurance Company”] challenges an award dated 15.03.2017, passed by the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal [“the Tribunal”] in MAC No. 174/2014
[New No. 1399/2016], whereby the Tribunal awarded a sum of
Rs.30,02,139/-, alongwith interest at the rate of 10% per annum, in favour of
respondent No. 1, who was the claimant before the Tribunal.
A. FACTS
2.
The claim arose out of an accident which took place on 22.10.2013 at
11:30 AM, near Kasola Chowk on Delhi-Jaipur Road, National Highway-8.
The claimant was travelling in a goods vehicle, i.e. a Canter [bearing
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
registration No. HR-47B-2389] [“the offending vehicle”], which was being
driven by Mr. Ramesh Kumar [respondent No. 2 herein]. The claimant’s
allegation is that, due to the rash and negligent driving by respondent No. 2,
the vehicle hit against a trolla from the back, resulting in the claimant
sustaining severe injuries.
3.
The claimant was treated at the General Hospital, Rewari, Haryana,
and at the Jai Prakash Narayan Apex Trauma Centre, AIIMS, New Delhi. He
was hospitalised from 22.10.2013 to 06.11.2013. The claimant’s injury
included fracture of both bones in his left forearm, and extreme injuries in
his left leg, resulting in above-knee amputation. Before the Tribunal, he
placed on record a disability certificate dated 16.02.2015 [EX. PW 1/4],
issued by the Guru Teg Bahadur Hospital, Delhi, which assessed his
disability at 81% permanent locomotor disability in relation to his left upper
limb and left lower limb.
4.
The accident resulted in registration of an FIR bearing No. 245/13,
dated 22.10.2013 at Police Station Kasola, District Rewari, Haryana. A
chargesheet was also filed in the criminal proceedings against respondent
No. 2.
5.
The claimant filed a claim petition before the Tribunal, seeking
compensation. The driver, owner and insurer of the offending vehicle, were
arrayed as respondent Nos. 1 to 3 therein. The Tribunal found that the
accident had occurred as a result of rash and negligent driving by respondent
No. 2, and therefore awarded the sum of Rs.30,02,139/-, alongwith interest
at the rate of 10% per annum, in favour of the claimant, under the following
heads:
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
Sr.
No.
Head
towards
Amount awarded by
Tribunal
1.
Compensation
suffering
2.
Compensation towards medical bills
3.
Loss of earning capacity due to Rs.17,49,600/disability
4.
Loss of earning for a period of 6 Rs. 72,000/months
5.
Attendant charges for 5 months
Rs. 17,500/-
6.
Special diet and conveyance
Rs. 35,000/-
7.
Compensation towards loss
amenities and enjoyment of life
8.
Compensation towards disfigurement
9.
Compensation on account of artificial Rs. 6,12,050/limb
10.
Compensation
on
account
maintenance of artificial limb
Total
6.
pain
and Rs.1,50,000/Rs. 15,989/-
of Rs. 1,50,000/Rs. 1,50,000/-
of Rs. 50,000/Rs. 30,02,139/-
Finding no material to show any violation of policy conditions, the
Tribunal directed the Insurance Company to satisfy the claim.
7.
The Insurance Company is in appeal. The claimant as well as the
driver and owner of the offending vehicle have been impleaded as
respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 3 respectively in this appeal. Although respondent
Nos. 2 and 3 were served with notice of this appeal, as recorded in order
dated 15.10.2018, and counsel filed vakalatnama on their behalf on
20.03.2018, the order sheets do not reveal any appearance on their behalf.
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
B. SUBMISSIONS BY LEARNED COUNSEL FOR THE PARTIES
8.
I have heard Ms. Prerna Mehta, learned counsel for the Insurance
Company, and Mr. S.N. Parashar, learned counsel for the claimant.
9.
Ms. Mehta’s principal contention was that the claimant was travelling
in a goods vehicle as a gratuitous passenger, and was not covered by the
terms of the insurance policy at all. She submitted that the Insurance
Company should therefore have been absolved of any liability. According to
Ms. Mehta, the evidence clearly revealed that the claimant was not travelling
as a representative of the owner of the goods, so as to qualify for coverage
under the insurance policy.
10.
Without prejudice to her contention on liability, Ms. Mehta also
submitted that the Tribunal had erroneously computed loss of income of the
claimant by assessing his functional disability at 81%, the same figure at
which his disability was assessed qua two limbs. In Ms. Mehta’s
submission, such an assessment was contrary to the judgment of the
Supreme Court in Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar & Anr.1. She also assailed the
Tribunal’s computation on the basis of the claimant’s wages of Rs. 12,000/per month, as it is entirely unsupported by evidence. She submitted that, at
best the Tribunal could have assessed loss of income on the basis of
minimum wages.
11.
On the first point, Mr. Parashar submitted that the claimant was
indeed the authorised representative of the owner of the goods, and would
therefore fall within the terms of the insurance policy. In any event, he
contended that, even assuming that the claimant was to be treated as a
gratuitous passenger, the consequence would be that the Insurance Company
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
would be entitled to recover the amount paid to the claimant, from the owner
and driver of the offending vehicle.
12.
Mr. Parashar also defended the Tribunal’s assessment of functional
disability, referring to the claimant’s profession as a painter (whitewashing),
which he can not perform anymore, as a result of the disabilities he has
suffered. He, in fact, submitted that the Tribunal has under-estimated the
compensation by omitting any enhancement of income on account of future
prospects.
13.
Learned counsel on both sides cited various judgments in support of
their contentions, to which I shall refer at the appropriate juncture.
C. QUESTIONS FOR DETERMINATION
14.
The aforesaid arguments give rise to the following questions for
determination.
a. Was the claimant covered by the insurance policy in question?
b. If not, what would be the consequence upon the liability of the
Insurance Company towards the claimant?
c. Does the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal require
interference in appeal?
D. COVERAGE UNDER THE INSURANCE POLICY
15.
The determination of this issue turns on an interpretation of the
conditions of the insurance policy issued by the appellant in respect of the
vehicle. A copy of the policy for the period 20.08.2013 to 19.08.2014 was
available before the Tribunal as part of the proceedings in the criminal case,
which were exhibited by the claimant as Ex.PW-1/6.
(2011) 1 SCC 343 [hereinafter, “Raj Kumar”].
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
16.
The following features of the policy are relevant for the present
dispute.
a) The policy specified “LCC including driver”2 as four.
b) The limitations as to use of the vehicle included “use for carrying
passengers in the vehicles; except employees (other than driver) not
exceeding the number permitted in the registration document and
coming under the purview of the Workmen’s Compensations Act,
1923”.
c) The premium calculation included components of “LLP to Paid
Driver/Cleaner/Conductor”, “LLP Paid Drivers”, and “Compulsory
PA cover to Owner Driver”.
17.
The registration certificate of the vehicle was also part of Ex.PW-1/6.
It included the provision as follows:
“13. Seating capacity + Driver
18.
3”
Section 147 of the MV Act provides for the requirements of an
insurance policy and limits of liability. It is reproduced hereinbelow:
“147. Requirements of policies and limits of liability.—(1) In order
to comply with the requirements of this Chapter, a policy of insurance must
be a policy which—
(a) insures the person or classes of persons specified in the policy
to the extent specified in sub-section (2)—
(i) against any liability which may be incurred by him in
respect of the death of or bodily [injury to any person,
including owner of the goods or his authorized representative
carried in the vehicle] or damage to any property of a third
party caused by or arising out of the use of the vehicle in a
public place;
Licensed carrying capacity, including driver.
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
(ii) against the death of or bodily injury to any passenger of a
public service vehicle caused by or arising out of the use of the
vehicle in a public place:
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
(2) Subject to the proviso to sub-section (1), a policy of insurance
referred to in sub-section (1), shall cover any liability incurred in respect of
any accident, up to the following limits, namely:—
(a) save as provided in clause (b), the amount of liability incurred;
(b) in respect of damage to any property of a third party, a limit of
rupees six thousand:
Provided that any policy of insurance issued with any limited liability and in
force, immediately before the commencement of this Act, shall continue to
be effective for a period of four months after such commencement or till the
date of expiry of such policy whichever is earlier.
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
(5) Notwithstanding anything contained in any law for the time
being in force, an insurer issuing a policy of insurance under this section
shall be liable to indemnify the person or classes of persons specified in the
policy in respect of any liability which the policy purports to cover in the
case of that person or those classes of persons.”3
The said section was amended in 1994, to require a policy of insurance to
cover liability towards the owner of goods carried in a vehicle, or his
authorised representative. It has been thus interpreted in several decision of
the Supreme Court, including inter alia in New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v.
Asha Rani & Ors.4 and National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Baljit Kaur & Ors.5.
19.
In the present case, the claimant claimed coverage on the basis that he
was the owner of the goods which were being carried in the vehicle, or the
authorised representative of the owner. In the claim petition, the claimant
asserted that he was going to HSIDC Balbal, Haryana, from Dharuhera in
the offending vehicle, which “was loaded with goods which belong with the
Emphasis supplied.
(2003) 2 SCC 223 [hereinafter, “Asha Rani”].
(2004) 2 SCC 1 [hereinafter, “Baljit Kaur”].
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
petitioner”. The claimant also filed an affidavit of evidence before the
Tribunal, which included the statement that the offending vehicle was loaded
with goods belonging to him. With regard to his vocation, he stated he was a
painter [whitewasher] in the area of East Delhi. The claimant was crossexamined by learned counsel for the Insurance Company, in which he stated
as follows:
“…I am a Painter by profession. The alleged offending vehicle in
which I was travelling was a Goods Carrying Canter. I along with
two other passenger was sitting with driver in front seat. I do not
know as to who are the other two persons who were also sitting with
driver. The Canter was carrying my painting goods in it. I was
going from Daruhera to Gharhi Bolani Chowk. I engaged the
Canter to carry my goods. I have not placed on record any
document pertaining to hiring of the said Canter. The other two
persons travelling in the Canter boarded the Canter later on and
the driver allowed them to travel after taking fare from them. The
driver of the Canter ran away from the accident site after causing
the accident. The driver did not sustain any injuries in the accident.
I was taking the goods to a place called Hans Resort for white wash
work. I had to white wash and paint the 20-25 rooms of the said
Resort. I had engaged two Labours with me for doing the said white
wash work. I do not have any document to show that I was assigned
this work from Hans Resort. I used to earn Rs. 20-25000/per month.
I have not placed on record any proof to this effect.
I have still not placed on record my complete medical bills.
It is wrong to suggest that I was travelling as a gratuitous
passenger in the offending vehicle after paying the fare along with
two other persons or that the goods in the Canter did not belong to
me. It is wrong to suggest that I am deposing falsely.” 6
20.
In the written statement filed by the Insurance Company, the
Insurance Company disputed this position, and contended that the claimant
was, in fact, travelling as a gratuitous passenger. Ms. Mehta submitted that
the aforesaid evidence of the claimant was inconsistent with his statement,
Emphasis supplied.
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
recorded under Section 161 of the Code of the Criminal Procedure, 1973
[“CrPC”], in which he stated he was working as a supervisor in New
Paradise Company. Ms. Mehta submitted that this evidence was contrary to
the claim before the Tribunal, to the extent that the claimant did not mention
carrying any goods in the statement under Section 161 of the CrPC, and did
not mention his employment with any other entity before the Tribunal.
21.
While there is some dissimilarity in the two statements of the claimant
– one under Section 161, and the second before the Tribunal - I do not find it
sufficient to discredit the claimant’s testimony altogether. Even in his
statement under Section 161 of the CrPC, he mentioned that he was engaged
in carrying out painting and repair work at Hans Resort, although this was in
the capacity of a supervisor employed by New Paradise Company. Most
significantly, the claimant was not confronted with the alleged inconsistency
in the course of cross-examination at all. Although general crossexamination was carried out as to the purpose of his travel, there was no
cross-examination whatsoever, as to the alleged discrepancy between the
Section 161 of the CrPC statement and the claim petition, or evidence before
the Tribunal. The claimant maintained that he was carrying his goods in the
vehicle, and denied that he was travelling as a gratuitous passenger. Without
his testimony having been challenged in cross-examination at all, the
Tribunal committed no error in proceeding on the basis of the evidence
given by the claimant. Although the Tribunal has not elaborately discussed
this aspect, its conclusion is recorded in paragraph 28 of the impugned
award, to the effect that there was nothing on the record to show any
violation of policy conditions.
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
22.
In the course of her arguments, Ms. Mehta also submitted that two of
the other victims of the same accident [the legal representatives of one
passenger who died in the accident and another injured victim] had filed
claim proceedings before the Tribunal in Rewari, in which only the driver
and owner of the offending vehicle were held liable, and the Insurance
Company was exonerated from liability. A copy of the award of the Tribunal
in Rewari, dated 07.10.2016, has also been placed on record. It is clear
therefrom that, as far as the other two victims are concerned, there was no
suggestion that they were travelling as owners of the goods being carried in
the vehicle or authorised representatives of the owner. This is a question of
fact, which would differ from case to case, and I do not, therefore, find any
reason to interfere with the award in the present case, simply because a
different conclusion has been recorded with regard to other passengers.
23.
In view of the Section 147 of the MV Act, as interpretated in Baljit
Kaur, I am of the view that the present claimant was covered by the
insurance policy in question.
24.
It is therefore not necessary to enter into adjudication of question (b)
formulated above, and I proceed to examine the contentions with regard to
quantum of compensation
E. QUANTUM OF COMPENSATION
25.
The arguments of learned counsel on both sides centred around
compensation awarded under the head of loss of income – for the period of
treatment, as well as for loss of earning capacity in the future.
i) Quantum of Income
26.
The first element which requires determination is the quantum of the
claimant’s income at the time of the accident. In the claim petition, he
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
claimed an income of Rs. 20,000-22,000/- per month. The Tribunal assessed
his income at Rs.12,000/- per month, observing as follows:
“19.
The testimony of PW-1 shows that he is doing work of white
wash and earning Rs. 20-25,000/- per month. There is no income
proof on record. The petitioner is self employed. It is a matter of
common experience that a person engaged in a white wash work
can easily earn a sum of Rs. 12,000/- per month. This income is
taken by virtue of some guess work…..”
27.
I am unable to uphold this assessment of income in the absence of any
proof of income in the claimant’s case, or even any evidence with regard to
the income of a person engaged in whitewashing work. The Tribunal ought
to have based the assessment on the level of minimum wages, rather than
“common experience” or “guess work”. In the course of hearing, learned
counsel for the parties accepted that minimum wages for an unskilled
worker in Delhi at the relevant time was Rs. 8,086/- per month. It is
therefore not necessary to remand the matter to the Tribunal for reassessment, particularly having regard to the fact that the accident occurred
in the year 2013. I, therefore, hold that the loss of income payable to the
claimant for the period of treatment and thereafter, ought to have been
assessed on the basis that his income at the time of the accident was
Rs.8,086/- per month.
ii) Loss of Income during treatment
28.
As far as loss of income during the period of treatment is concerned,
the Tribunal awarded loss of income for the period of six months on the
basis of its assessment of income at Rs. 12,000/- per month.
29.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, the award under this head stands
reduced from Rs. 72,000/- to Rs. 48,516/- [Rs. 8,086/- x 6].
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
iii) Assessment of functional disability
30.
For computation of loss of earning capacity, two other contested
factors must first be determined – level of functional disability and future
prospects.
31.
The assessment of functional disability requires a three-step process,
as laid down by the Supreme Court in Raj Kumar:
“13. Ascertainment of the effect of the permanent disability on the actual
earning capacity involves three steps. The Tribunal has to first ascertain what
activities the claimant could carry on in spite of the permanent disability and
what he could not do as a result of the permanent disability (this is also
relevant for awarding compensation under the head of loss of amenities of
life). The second step is to ascertain his avocation, profession and nature of
work before the accident, as also his age. The third step is to find out whether
(i) the claimant is totally disabled from earning any kind of livelihood, or (ii)
whether in spite of the permanent disability, the claimant could still
effectively carry on the activities and functions, which he was earlier carrying
on, or (iii) whether he was prevented or restricted from discharging his
previous activities and functions, but could carry on some other or lesser
scale of activities and functions so that he continues to earn or can continue
to earn his livelihood..”
32.
In the present case, the claimant’s disability was assessed at 81%
permanent disability in both his left limbs. His vocation as a
painter/whitewasher was not disputed before the Tribunal. The Tribunal has
computed loss of income at 81%, i.e. the same level as his physical
disability in two limbs.
33.
Although Ms. Mehta submitted that the loss of earning capacity has
been over-estimated by the Tribunal, I find, to the contrary, that it has, in
fact, been under-estimated. One of the examples discussed by the Supreme
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
Court in Raj Kumar, was of amputation of the left hand. The Court observed
as follows:
“14. For example, if the left hand of a claimant is amputated, the
permanent physical or functional disablement may be assessed around
60%. If the claimant was a driver or a carpenter, the actual loss of
earning capacity may virtually be hundred percent, if he is neither
able to drive or do carpentry. On the other hand, if the claimant was a
clerk in government service, the loss of his left hand may not result in
loss of employment and he may still be continued as a clerk as he
could perform his clerical functions; and in that event the loss of
earning capacity will not be 100% as in the case of a driver or
carpenter, nor 60% which is the actual physical disability, but far less.
In fact, there may not be any need to award any compensation under
the head of "loss of future earnings", if the claimant continues in
government service, though he may be awarded compensation under
the head of loss of amenities as a consequence of losing his hand.
Sometimes the injured claimant may be continued in service, but may
not be found suitable for discharging the duties attached to the post or
job which he was earlier holding, on account of his disability, and may
therefore be shifted to some other suitable but lesser post with lesser
emoluments, in which case there should be a limited award under the
head of loss of future earning capacity, taking note of the reduced
earning capacity.”7
34.
The case of a painter like the claimant is, in my view, akin to the
Supreme Court’s example of a driver or a carpenter. In the present case,
although the amputation was of the claimant’s leg, his disability was also in
his left arm. To carry on the work of paintings/whitewashing of walls, the
use of both hands and both legs is imperative. I am therefore of the view that
an assessment of 100% functional disability/loss of earning capacity would
be appropriate in the present case.
iv) Future Prospects
35.
On the question of future prospects also, the claimant deserves some
further relief. The Constitution Bench of Supreme Court in National
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
Insurance Company Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi & Ors.8, clearly held that loss of
income must be enhanced for future prospects, at a level depending upon the
age and nature of the victim’s work. The same principle has also been
applied in personal injury cases9.
36.
In the present case, the victim had admittedly crossed the age of 40
years as on the date of the accident. He would therefore be entitled to 25%
enhancement of future income10.
v) Assessment of loss of future income
37.
As a result of the above discussion, the compensation for loss of
future income is recomputed as follows:
Heads
Monthly Income [A]
Annual income [A x 12 = B]
Addition of future prospects [25% of B = C]
Annual income (including future prospects)
[B + C = D]
Loss of future earnings after accounting for
functional disability (per annum)
[100% of D = E]
Loss of future income (after applying the
applicable multiplier) [D x 15]
38.
Amount
Rs. 8,086/Rs. 97,032
Rs. 24,258/Rs. 1,21,290/Rs. 1,21,290/-
Rs. 18,19,350/-
Loss of future income is therefore enhanced from Rs.17,49,600/- to
Rs. 18,19,350/-.
F. CONCLUSION
Emphasis supplied.
(2017) 16 SCC 680 [hereinafter, “Pranay Sethi”].
Sidram v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd., [(2023) 3 SCC 439], paragraph 31.
Pranay Sethi, paragraph 59.4.
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
39.
As the result of the above discussion, the impugned award is modified
to the following extent:
S.
No.
40.
Heads
Amount
awarded by the
Tribunal
Amount
awarded by
the Court
Difference (+/-)
1. Loss of earning
capacity due to
disability
Rs.17,49,600/-
Rs.18,19,350/- (+) Rs. 69,750/-
2. Loss of earning
for a period of
6 months
Rs. 72,000/-
Rs. 48,516/-
(-) Rs. 23,484/-
TOTAL
Rs. 18,21,600/-
Rs.18,67,866/-
(+) Rs.46,266/-
The impugned award, in the present case, thus stands enhanced by Rs.
46,266/- from Rs. 30,02,139/- to Rs. 30,48,405/-.
41.
It may be noted that this judgment results in an enhancement of the
awarded amount, even in the absence of a cross-objection or cross-appeal by
the claimant. Such a course, is in my view, permitted, particularly having
regard to the judgment of the Supreme Court in Surekha & Ors. v. Santosh
& Ors.11. I have had occasion to consider this issue in detail in Oriental
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Shanti & Ors.12.
42.
By order dated 12.05.2017, the Insurance Company was granted stay
of execution of the impugned award, subject to deposit of the awarded
amount in this Court. The interest on the deposit was released to the
claimant, pursuant to order dated 20.03.2018. The Tribunal’s order directed
(2021) 16 SCC 467.
MAC.APP. 891/2013, decided on 11.12.2025 [hereinafter, “Shanti”].
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
disbursement of the awarded amount over a period of 11 years, which have
not yet lapsed.
43.
As the proceedings have resulted in enhancement of the award, the
following directions are passed:
a) The amount of the award be deposited by the Insurance Company
with the Tribunal, within a period of 8 weeks, alongwith interest at the
rate of 9% per annum from the date of filing of the petition until
deposit.
b) The deposited amount lying in this Court, alongwith accrued interest
therein, be transferred to the Tribunal forthwith.
c) The amounts which would already have been released to the
claimants, under the impugned award of the Tribunal, be released to
him forthwith.
d) The amount which is to be deposited pursuant to paragraph 43(a)
above, may also be released to the claimant forthwith.
e) The amount which was to be kept in further fixed deposits under the
impugned award shall be disbursed in terms of the directions
contained therein.
44.
The appeal, alongwith the pending application, stands disposed of
with the aforesaid directions.
45.
Statutory deposit be refunded to the Insurance Company.
PRATEEK JALAN, J
FEBRUARY 19, 2026
‘PV/Ainesh’/
Signed By:BHUPENDER
20:07
MAC.APP. 447/2017
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review