Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Reserved on
: 25th September 2026
Pronounced on : 06th October2026
Uploaded on : 07th October 2026
#
CNR No. DLHC012561442014
+
MAC.APP. 13/2015 & CM APPL. 145/2015
RELIANCE GENERAL INSURANCE CO LTD
Through:
.....Appellant
Mr. Rajeev M. Roy, Advocate
(through VC)
versus
JYOTI DEVI & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Shrey Chathly, Adv. for
Respondent nos. 1 to 4
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANISH DAYAL
JUDGMENT
ANISH DAYAL, J.
1.
This appeal has been filed assailing the impugned award dated 12th
September 2014 in MACT No. 788/2014 passed by Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal (‘MACT/Tribunal’), Tis Hazari Courts, whereby compensation of
Rs. 63,10,000/- along with interest at 7.5% per annum was awarded.
2.
The accident in question occurred on 16th March 2013 at about 05:30
a.m., when the deceased, Dhyanendra Singh, was going towards Rajghat
from Sarai Kale Khan in a Tata 407 commercial vehicle. When he reached
IP Flyover, Ring Road, in front of Vikash Vihar, ITO, the offending vehicle,
a dumper bearing No. HR-69A-1911, was found parked in the middle of the
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
road, allegedly without any branch of a tree or any dipper light, parking light
or blinking headlight. As a result, the vehicle driven by the deceased rammed
into the dumper, and the deceased suffered grievous injuries to which he later
succumbed.
Submissions on behalf of Insurance Company
3.
Mr. Rajeev M. Roy, counsel for the Insurance Company, challenged
the award mainly on the following two aspects:
i.
Finding of negligence arrived at by the MACT in favour of the
claimant and against the driver/owner.
ii.
Quantum of compensation.
4.
On the aspect of negligence, Mr. Roy contends that the MACT did not
give any proper reasoning and merely based on the principle of the
preponderance of probabilities, decided that the negligence was indeed of
driver/owner of offending vehicle.
5.
He contended that, quite otherwise, offending vehicle was standing on
the road and deceased was driving Tata 407 and ought to have seen the
vehicle standing on the road.
6.
As per FIR, dumper was standing in the first line at an approximate
distance of 1 foot from the central verge. However, there was no reflector,
branch of a tree or brick, etc. placed behind the vehicle to indicate that it was
stationary to the vehicle approaching from behind.
7.
Mr. Roy further stated that there was no eyewitness to the accident.
Pursuant to the investigation, a statement was recorded of driver of offending
vehicle, Arjun Singh, who disclosed that a defect had developed in his
vehicle and that he was in search of a mechanic. He further stated that he did
not arrange any reflector, tree branch or brick at the backside of the vehicle.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
8.
Therefore, commission of offence under Section 304A of IPC and
Sections 104 and 177 of Motor Vehicles Act was pressed.
9.
As regards quantum of compensation, Mr. Roy contended that notional
income of Rs. 25,000/- per month was wrongly assessed solely based on the
testimony of Kotak Mahindra Bank official regarding the loan instalment of
Rs. 15,344/- per month and that 50% future prospects were wrongly added.
10.
He pointed out that in the loan statement provided by Kotak Mahindra
Bank, a number of cheques had bounced and, therefore, merely on this basis
it could not be concluded that deceased was earning Rs. 25,000/- per month,
as has been assessed by MACT.
Submissions on behalf of Claimants
11.
On the issue of negligence, Mr. Shrey Chathly, counsel for claimant,
pointed out to the chargesheet wherein a statement was recorded of driver of
offending vehicle, Arjun Singh, who disclosed that a defect had developed in
his vehicle and that he was in search of a mechanic. He further stated that he
did not arrange any reflector, tree branch or brick at the backside of the
vehicle.
12.
He further pointed out to the FIR, wherein it is noted that the blinkers
of the offending vehicle were not on.
13.
On the issue of income, he stated that the MACT has rightly assessed
the notional income as the deceased was paying an EMI of Rs 15,344/- per
month. Therefore, considering the same the MACT assessed that he would
have spent some money on family as well and assessed the notional income
at Rs. 25,000/-.
14.
In support of his contention, he relied upon the judgment of Supreme
Court in Gurpreet Kaur and Others v. United India Insurance Company
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
Ltd., decision dated 27th September 2022 of Supreme Court in Civil Appeal
No. 6981-82/2022, where the Court was dealing with a case in which
deceased in that case had purchased a tractor for which he had taken a loan
of Rs. 3,90,533/- from Kotak Mahindra Bank and was paying a monthly
instalment of Rs. 11,550/- and on this basis assessed the notional income of
deceased at Rs. 25,000/- per month.
15.
He further relied upon the judgment of this Court in National
Insurance Company v. Parvesh & Ors., 2023:DHC:6578, wherein this
Court dealt with the question of the loan amount for which deceased was
paying monthly instalments. The Court noted that his income certainly had
been more than what he would have spent on himself.
Analysis
16.
The MACT has relied upon the testimony of PW1, wife of deceased,
although she was not an eyewitness, particularly on the manner in which the
accident occurred. Moreover, Detailed Accident Report (‘DAR’) was filed
pertaining to FIR bearing No. 55/2013, PS IP Estate, including the charge
sheet.
17.
On the basis of the criminal record, the MACT proceeded on the basis
that these documents were sufficient proof to reach the conclusion that driver
was negligent.
18.
It is noted that there was no eyewitness to the accident and pursuant
to the investigations, a statement was recorded of the driver of the offending
vehicle, Arjun Singh, who disclosed that a defect developed in his vehicle
and he was in search of a mechanic, and he did not arrange any reflector,
tree, branch or brick at the backside of the vehicle.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
19.
Therefore, the commission of offence under Section 304A of IPC and
under Sections 104/177 of the Motor Vehicles Act was pressed.
20.
As per the site plan, the dumper was on the right side of the road going
towards Rajghat with only 1 foot distance from the central verge. Site plan
is extracted as under, for ease of reference:
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
21.
At 05:30 a.m., if there were no blinkers or any other indication that
dumper had stopped due to any defect in the vehicle, it would have been
difficult for any driver approaching on the right side of the road to have
noticed the stationary vehicle in time to avoid the accident.
22.
In this respect, reliance can be placed on the view taken by this Court
in United India Insurance Company v Lakshmi Kumari and others
2026:DHC:1946, wherein, after discussing the principle of last opportunity
and assessing the issue of contributory negligence, the court has noted that
the application of the principle of last opportunity having been discontinued
both in common law and by statutory reform, acceptable rule is that of
apportionment of damages for contributory negligence. The Courts have to
account for causation and the relevant blame-worthiness of the parties.
23.
For ready reference, the following paragraphs from the decision are
extracted as under:
“34…It is apposite to first consider the historical
underpinnings of contributory negligence, in order to
appreciate the relevance and purpose of principle of last
opportunity. A common law principle, contributory
negligence was a defence used by defendants in cases
where plaintiff was responsible for the harm caused to
them, by not exercising ordinary care even though, the
defendant was the tortfeasor. If proved, plaintiff’s claim
was wholly rejected and nothing could be recovered by
way of damages. One of the earliest decisions illustrating
this was Butterfield v. Forrester (1809) 11 East 60, where
Lord Ellenborough, C.J. observed, “one person being at
fault does not dispense with another’s using ordinary care
of himself.”
35…Principle of last opportunity is known to originate
from the English case of Davies v. Mann (1842) 10 M &
W 546 which, in brief, was a case of a donkey left by the
plaintiff on a public highway and the defendant who was
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
driving at an improper pace collided with the donkey
resulting in injuries to the donkey. Instead of applying
contributory negligence and holding the plaintiff entirely
liable, as per the tort law principles prevalent at that time,
an exception was carved out stating that, if the accident
could have been avoided by the exercise of ordinary care
by the defendant, plaintiff shall not be held liable for
contributory negligence. Therefore, to encapsulate, the
person who had the last opportunity to avoid an accident,
notwithstanding negligence of the other person, shall be
held liable for it.
36…The underlying premise of this principle then relates
to proximity of plaintiff’s act of negligence as a resultant
cause of the accident. Additionally, knowledge on the part
of defendant played a key role in determination of liability,
if the peril could have been prevented had the defendant
known or by adopting sufficient precaution.
***
41…Rule of last opportunity was mentioned in passing by
Supreme Court in Sushma (supra) in the context of the
circumstances in which the accident took place. Supreme
Court observed that, if the accident took place during the
day or when the place was well illuminated, perhaps, the
car driver would have been equally responsible by
applying rule of last opportunity. However, on the facts of
the case, all circumstances pointed to the negligence of the
truck driver who abandoned his truck in the middle of the
road. Supreme Court does not deliberate any further on
the rule of last opportunity.
42….The application of the rule of last opportunity having
been discontinued both in common law and by statutory
reform, the acceptable rule is of apportionment of
damages for contributory negligence. For this purpose, the
Courts must account for causation and the relative blameworthiness of the parties.”
(emphasis added)
24.
There is no evidence on record, though in the written statement the
driver/owner denied that the dumper was standing without any dipper light,
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
parking light or any other indication. Driver/owner did not testify in that
regard before the MACT.
25.
Besides, as noted above, in the statement as recorded, the driver had
stated that he did not arrange any reflector, tree branch or brick etc. at the
backside of the vehicle. There is no doubt that the truck was certainly parked
on the wrong side of the road. At best, there can be a dispute whether parking
lights or any other indication were used or not. The driver states in his written
statement that they were used. However, he gave a statement to the police
that they were not. There is no evidence or deposition by the driver before
the MACT in order to substantiate his assertion. Therefore, looking at the
overall circumstances of the matter, the MACT was right in not awarding
any contributory negligence to reduce the compensation.
26.
Therefore, applying the principle of preponderance of probabilities, it
would be apparent that the vehicle was left unattended and abandoned on the
fast lane of a major thoroughfare in early morning. The Tata 407 having
crashed into it, cannot be a case of contributory negligence.
27.
As regards the issue of quantum of compensation, finding of MACT
is required to be examined with respect to assessment of notional income. It
is noted that deceased was 23 years of age on the date of accident. He was a
professional driver and a graduate by qualification.
28.
PW2, Law Officer from Kotak Mahindra Bank, specifically stated that
deceased had taken a loan for a sum of Rs. 5,04,000/- in 2011, which he had
to repay in 45 instalments. The EMI per month was Rs. 15,344/-, and the last
instalment was paid for the month of March 2013.
29.
Mr. Roy pointed out from the loan statement that a number of cheques
had been dishonoured and, therefore, assessment made by MACT, on the
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
basis that deceased was capable of earning an income in that range, was not
correct.
30.
However, loan statement provided by Kotak Mahindra Bank does
show that EMI of Rs. 15,344/- was regularly debited every month, though
there were instances of dishonour of cheques; however, it is noted that the
instalments were received shortly thereafter, on average within 15 to 20 days.
Overall, the statement shows that deceased was largely meeting his loan
repayment obligations, though there were occasions when payment was not
made on time and was subsequently paid.
31.
Moreover, PW1, wife of the deceased, she had stated in her testimony
that the deceased was earning Rs. 32,000 – Rs. 35, 000/- per month as the
driver-cum-owner of Tata 407 and in the cross-examination also she gave the
copies of the educational certificate, the Driving Licence of the deceased and
the PAN Card. She further stated that she had not filed any ITR or any income
proof.
32.
It appears that, after purchasing the commercial vehicle, deceased was
plying it and earning through assignment jobs. His income, therefore, could
have been scattered as opposed to having a consistent amount coming in.
However, the fact that deceased was able to pay EMI of Rs. 15,344/- per
month is relevant while computing the notional income of the deceased.
Therefore, in the opinion of this Court, assessment made by the MACT by
taking benchmark income at Rs. 25,000/- per month, allowing approximately
Rs. 10,000/- per month towards his personal expenses, is appropriate and
acceptable.
33.
Reliance placed by counsel for claimant, Mr. Shrey Chathly, on
Gurpreet Kaur (supra), is also instructive. In that case, deceased had
purchased a tractor for which he had taken a loan of Rs. 3,90,533/- from
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
Kotak Mahindra Bank and was paying a monthly instalment of Rs. 11,550/.
34.
The Tribunal took into account the EMI being paid and assessed the
deceased’s income at Rs.25,000/- per month.
35.
The Supreme Court considered the challenge to the same and held that
the deceased was regularly making payment of Rs.11,550/- as an instalment
to discharge his loan liability towards the tractor, and the entire loan was paid
back within a year or so, which establishes the earning capacity of the
deceased.
36.
The approach adopted by the Tribunal was considered as balanced and
the assessment of the income at Rs. 25,000/- per month was appropriate and
justified. Notably, the Supreme Court stated as under:
37.
“In the summary proceedings where the approach of the
Tribunal's determination must be in conformity with the
object of the welfare legislation, it was rightly held that the
monthly income of the deceased could not be less than Rs.
25,000/-. The reason assigned by the High Court to reduce
the monthly income of the deceased is totally cryptic and
has no rationale. The Notification of Minimum Wages Act
can be a guiding factor only in a case where there is no
clue available to evaluate monthly income of the deceased.
Where positive evidence has been led, no reliance on the
Notification could be placed, particularly when it was
nobody’s case that the deceased was a labourer as
presumed by the High Court”
(emphasis added)
The Court also resonates with the view taken earlier by this Court in
Savita & Ors. v. National Insurance Company Ltd. 2026:DHC:3626, where
if no documentary evidence is available, some amount of guesswork is
necessary. This guesswork can be based on certain surrounding
circumstances. The relevant passages from Savita (supra) are as under:
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
“30. Principles which may be culled out from these cases
cited above, and be used as guidepost for assessment of
benchmark income, can be summarised as under:
A. Lack of documentary proof
i. In the informal sector, it may not always be possible to
produce documentary proof of employment and payment
of wages, which are usually paid in cash.
ii. Where there is lack of documentary proof to support that
the victim was working in Delhi, reliance may be placed
on facts and circumstances of the case to determine
whether, the victim was residing in Delhi on the date of
accident, in conjunction with documents such as driver’s
license, voter ID card, etc. Minimum wages of place of
work will be then considered.
iii. If documentary proof has not been filed, the Court can
use the minimum wage benchmark of an appropriate
category i.e., unskilled, skilled, matriculate, etc., as a
benchmark for assessment, but not be constrained to grant
the lowest tier.
B. Oral testimony of family members, employers
i. Assessment of income can also be done on the statement
of the immediate legal heir of deceased, i.e., wife, father,
or immediate family member, along with a statement of the
employer, if any. Testimonies of the above-mentioned
persons should be consistent and there should be an
unsuccessful rebuttal by the Insurance Company or the
contesting party.
ii. If the testimonies are not reliable, the Court can use the
minimum wage benchmark of an appropriate category i.e.,
unskilled, skilled, matriculate, etc., as a benchmark for
assessment, but not be constrained to grant the lowest tier.
C. Proof of employment
i. If documents in support of employment inter alia,
Salary/Wage Certificate, Income Tax Returns (‘ITRs’)
have been filed, same shall be considered.
ii. In the absence of such proof, assessment done by the
Court has to be based on some intelligent guesswork and
may not be restricted to the minimum wage parameter
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
after taking into account a holistic analysis of the evidence
on record. For example, place of employment, testimony of
co-workers, or any other person who testifies in favour of
the injured/deceased employee.
iii. The entire assessment is ultimately imbued with an
element of approximation and guesswork, as part of the
inquiry proceedings and not on exactitude.
iv. Reliance may be placed on State specific legislations,
as well as Minimum Wage Notifications to lean on for
support, in order to determine what qualifies as a skilled
worker and an unskilled worker, with respect to the
vocation of the victim.
D. Age, occupation and educational background of the
victim
i. In cases where the victim was a student and the evidence
on record suggests that the victim would have engaged in
employment after completing education, had the accident
not taken place; the Courts must consider the educational
background keeping in view the missed future
opportunities.
ii. Reliance to be placed on documents and testimonies
indicating the prior educational background of the victim,
if no proof has been placed with regards to the employment
details.
E. Standard of living of deceased persons
i. When a claim petition has been filed by the surviving
dependents of a deceased, where the deceased was the
breadwinner of the family, Courts must attempt to
ascertain the benchmark income keeping in view the void
left by the breadwinner’s death and income must be
determined keeping in view the standard of living enjoyed
by the family before the accident took place. While
monetary compensation is a means to filing the financial
hole left by the deceased, an estimate may be required to
be done in order to support the remaining family
members.”
(emphasis added)
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
38.
A Coordinate Bench of this Court in National Insurance Company v
Parvesh & Ors, 2023:DHC:6578 also dealt with a case where deceased was
paying monthly instalments towards a loan. Court noted that his income was
certainly higher than what he would have spent on himself. Court observed
as under:
“8. …Merely because the claimants were unable to
produce the income tax records or other cogent material in
support of their assertion of the income of the deceased,
their claim should not have been reduced on this
account….”
(emphasis added)
39.
In Chandra alias Chanda alias Chandraram & Anr. v Mukesh
Kumar Yadav & Ors., (2022) 1 SCC 198, the Supreme Court has held that
in absence of documentary evidence on record for the income of the
deceased, some amount of guesswork is required to be done. Though the
minimum wages notification can be a yardstick but, at the same time, it
cannot be an absolute one to fix the income of the deceased.
40.
Therefore, where there is no documentary indication of earning
capacity, but there is sufficient evidence of consistent payment towards a
substantial loan, such circumstance can constitute evidence of deceased
having sufficient earning capacity. In such circumstances, minimum wage
notifications would not necessarily be brought into play, particularly when
there is no evidence that deceased was simply working as a labourer or in
any unskilled job.
41.
In present case, ownership of vehicle under hypothecation is not
disputed by Kotak Mahindra Bank. Therefore, in view of circumstances
discussed above, adoption of minimum wages would not be warranted.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
42.
Since entire family, including parents of deceased, was financially
dependent upon the deceased and there was no cross-examination by
driver/owner or Insurance Company on this aspect, deduction of 1/4 th
towards personal and living expenses is acceptable. Application of multiplier
of ‘18’ is also appropriate.
43. As regards the other components of compensation, the same are liable
to be realigned in view of the principles laid down in National Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi and Ors. (2017) 16 SCC 680 as under:
a. Compensation towards loss of love and affection shall not be awarded
in view of the decision in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satinder
Kaur @ Satwinder Kaur and Ors. (2021) 11 SCC 780;
b. Funeral expenses shall be reduced to Rs.15,000/-, instead of
Rs.25,000/-;
c. Compensation towards loss of estate shall be enhanced to Rs.15,000/-,
instead of Rs.10,000/-; and
d. Loss of consortium shall be awarded at Rs. 1,60,000/-, i.e. Rs. 40,000/each to the four claimants, namely, parents of the deceased, spouse and
minor daughter.
e. Future prospects, which were awarded at 50%, ought to be at 40% in
view of the standardised principles.
44.
Sr.
No.
1.
Accordingly, the revised compensation will be as under:
Heads
Monthly income of the
deceased (A)
Awarded by
the Tribunal
Rs. 25,000/-
Awarded by the
Court
Rs. 25,000/-
50%
40% of Rs.
25,000/- = Rs.
2.
Add-Future Prospects (B)
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
1/4th
10,000/1/4th of Rs.
35,000/- = Rs.
8,750/-
Rs. 3,37,500/18
Rs. 3,15,000/18
3.
Less-personal expenses of
the deceased (C)
Annual loss of dependency
[(A+B) - C ] x 12= D]
Multiplier (E)
Total loss of dependency
(D x E) = (F)
Compensation for loss of
love and affection (G)
Compensation for loss of
consortium (H)
Compensation for loss of
estate (I)
Compensation towards
funeral expenses (J)
Total Compensation
(F+G+H+I+J = K)
Interest Awarded
Reduced Compensation
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
Rs. 60,75,000/- Rs. 56,70,000/Rs. 1,00,000/Rs. 1,00,000/-
NIL
Rs. 1,60,000/-
Rs. 10,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 25,000/-
Rs. 15,000/-
Rs. 63,10,000/- Rs. 58,60,000/7.5%
Rs. 4,50,000/-
7.5%
45.
Accordingly, the compensation is reduced by Rs. 4,50,000/-.
46.
Vide order dated 7th January 2015, this Court directed the Insurance
Company to deposit 40% of the award amount along with accrued interest
with the Tribunal and further directed release of monthly interest accrued on
the fixed deposit to respondents no. 1 and 3 in the ratio of 70% and 30%,
respectively.
47.
Accordingly, the balance compensation, i.e. the revised compensation
minus the amount already deposited, along with accrued interest thereon,
shall be deposited within a period of four weeks. Upon such deposit, the said
amount shall be released in terms of the directions contained in the impugned
award.
48.
Accordingly, the appeal stands disposed of with above directions.
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
49.
Pending applications, if any, are rendered infructuous.
50.
Copy of this judgement be sent to concerned MACT.
51.
Copy of this judgement shall also be sent to concerned bank.
52.
Statutory deposit, if any, shall be refunded to Insurance Company,
only if the order of deposit has been complied with.
53.
Judgment be uploaded on the website of this Court.
(ANISH DAYAL)
JUDGE
OCTOBER 06, 2026/rk/bp
KUMAR CHOUDHARY
MAC.APP 13/2015
17:15:04
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review