Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
+
Date of Decision: 28.01.2026
W.P.(C) 14997/2023 & CM.APPL. 59887/2023
REGIONAL PROVIDENT FUND COMMISSIONER GURGAON
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Braja Bandhu, Advocate.
versus
ARTEMIS MEDICARE SERVICES LTD
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Anirudh Bakhru, Mr. Ayush, Ms.
Urvija, Ms. Aayomi, and Mr. Kanav,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
1.
The present writ petition has been filed seeking setting aside of the order
dated 15.02.2023 passed by the Presiding Officer, Central Government
Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court-II, Rouse Avenue District Courts
Complex, Delhi in Appeal No. D-2/08/2021.
Vide the impugned order, the appeal preferred by the present respondent
was allowed and the order dated 12.01.2021 passed by the RPFC (Gurgaon
East) under Section 7A of The Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous
Provisions Act, 1952 (hereinafter “the EPF & MP Act”) directing the
respondent to deposit PF dues amounting to Rs.3,92,16,005/- was set aside.
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
W.P.(C) 14997/2023
2.
While the respondent has challenged the maintainability of the present
writ petition by contending that both the parties are located outside the
jurisdiction of this Court, learned counsel for the appellant has contested the
same by submitting that the appellate authority by which the impugned order
was passed is located in Delhi. In view of the preliminary objection raised, the
issue arising for consideration is whether the situs of the authority which
passed the impugned order being in Delhi would make this Court the forum
conveniens.
3.
Briefly, the facts necessary for consideration of the above issue are that
an inquiry under Section 7A of the EPF & MP Act was recommended by the
RPFC (Gurgaon East), Haryana against the respondent on the following
grounds:“It has been also noticed that establishment has deposited less PF dues after
the notification by Haryana Government on dated 15.11.2015 vide which
necessary notification issued by Haryana Government not to split the
minimum wages for the purpose of PF Wages. w.e.f. 01.11.2025. The
establishment is liable to deposit the following EPF dues Rs. 25726831/(Rupees Two Crore Fifty-Seven Lacs Twenty-Six Thousand Eight Hundred
Thirty-One only) on difference of salary in respect of employees deployed in
Haryana State.”
4.
The Enforcement Officer (EO) carried out the inquiry and submitted its
report to the assessing authority, i.e., the RPFC, against the respondent having
PF Code No. HR/GGN/0027995000. On receipt of the inquiry report, the
respondent was directed to submit the relevant records vide letter dated
18.06.2019. The respondent filed its reply, resulting in passing of the final
order dated 12.01.2021, whereby the respondent was directed to deposit a sum
of Rs.3,92,16,005/- as PF dues outstanding towards establishment and as
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
W.P.(C) 14997/2023
payable by the employer in respect of establishment for assessment of dues
from November 2018 to January 2019.
5.
The respondent challenged the aforesaid order before the appellate
authority of Central Government Industrial Tribunal (CGIT), Rouse Avenue
Courts Complex, New Delhi. A perusal of the circular dated 23.06.2017 (F.No.
Z-13025/32/2016-SS.1) issued under the signatures of the Director, Ministry of
Labour and Employment, Government of India, shows that after the merger of
The Employees’ Provident Fund Appellate Tribunal (EPFAT) with the CGIT
by the Finance Act, 2017, the matters relating to the EPF & MP Act were
brought under the jurisdiction of the CGIT. As per the list of CGIT benches and
their jurisdictions, while CGIT New Delhi-I has provident fund-related
jurisdiction over the Union Territory of Delhi, CGIT New Delhi-II pertains to
the Gurgaon and Faridabad districts of Haryana as well as the Ghaziabad and
Gautam Budha Nagar districts of Uttar Pradesh.
6.
The issue of whether the situs of a Tribunal would be the determinative
factor for jurisdiction came up before this Court in Sterling Agro Industries
Limited Vs. Union of India and Ors.1, wherein a 5-Judge Bench of this Court,
while considering a reference, answered the same as under:“35. In view of the aforesaid analysis, we are inclined to modify the
findings and conclusions of the Full Bench in New India Assurance Co. Ltd.
v. Union of India, AIR 2010 Delhi 43; [2011] 166 C-C 87 (Delhi) and
proceed to state our conclusions in seriatim as follows :
(a) The finding recorded by the Full Bench that the sole cause of
action emerges at the place or location where the Tribunal/appellate
authority/revisional authority is situate and the said High Court (i.e.,
Delhi High Court) cannot decline to entertain the writ petition as that
2011 SCC OnLine Del 3162
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
W.P.(C) 14997/2023
would amount to failure of the duty of the court cannot be accepted
inasmuch as such a finding is totally based on the situs of the
Tribunal/appellate authority/revisional authority totally ignoring the
concept of forum conveniens.
(b) Even if a minuscule part of cause of action arises within the
jurisdiction of this court, a writ petition would be maintainable before
this court, however, the cause of action has to be understood as per the
ratio laid down in the case of Alchemist Ltd. v. State Bank of Sikkim
(2007) 136 C-C 665; (2007) 11 SCC 335.
(c) An order of the appellate authority constitutes a part of cause
of action to make the writ petition maintainable in the High Court within
whose jurisdiction the appellate authority is situated. Yet, the same may
not be the singular factor to compel the High Court to decide the matter
on merits. The High Court may refuse to exercise its discretionary
jurisdiction by invoking the doctrine of forum conveniens.
(d) The conclusion that where the appellate or revisional authority
is located constitutes the place of forum conveniens as stated in absolute
terms by the Full Bench is not correct as it will vary from case to case
and depend upon the lis in question.
(e) The finding that the court may refuse to exercise jurisdiction
under article 226 if only the jurisdiction is invoked in a mala fide manner
is too restricted/constricted as the exercise of the power under article
226 being discretionary cannot be limited or restricted to the ground of
mala fide alone.
(f) While entertaining a writ petition, the doctrine of forum
conveniens and the nature of cause of action are required to be
scrutinised by the High Court depending upon the factual matrix of each
case in view of what has been stated in Ambica Industries v. CCE (2007)
213 ELT 323; [2009] 20 VST 1 (S.C.) and Union of India v. Adani
Exports Ltd. (2002) 1 SCC 567.
(g) The conclusion of the earlier decision of the Full Bench in New
India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Union of India, AIR 2010 Delhi 43; (2011)
166 C-C 87 (Delhi) (page 115):"... that since the original order merges
into the appellate order, the place where the appellate authority is
located is also forum conveniens" is not correct.
(h) Any decision of this court contrary to the conclusions
enumerated hereinabove stands overruled.”
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has referred to a decision by the
Division Bench of this Court in Vishnu Security Services Vs. Regional
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
W.P.(C) 14997/2023
Provident Fund Commissioner and Anr.2 In the said case, the Division Bench,
while considering an appeal against an order of the learned Single Judge who
had dismissed a writ petition on jurisdictional grounds, concluded that no case
of forum non conveniens was made out in the specific facts of that case. The
Division Bench, in particular, noted the brevity of the learned Single Judge’s
decision and overturned it for lack of sufficient reasoning. The petitioner’s
reliance on Vishnu Security (supra), in the present facts, is misplaced.
8.
Rather, a Coordinate Bench of this Court, in M/s. Chinteshwar Steel Pvt.
Ltd. Vs. Union of India & Ors.3, was seized of the same issue as in the present
case and, after analysing the decisions in Sterling Agro (supra) and Vishnu
Security (supra), came to the conclusion that the decision in Vishnu Security
was more fact-specific and rendered primarily for the reason that the decision
of the learned Single Judge lacked reasons to support its conclusion. The Court
examined the issue in relation to the provisions under the Income Tax Act,
1961, the Customs Act, 1962, and the Companies Act, 1956, and came to the
conclusion that the situs of the Tribunal would not necessarily be the marker
for identifying the jurisdictional High Court. The Court, while declining to
entertain the writ petition, held that the High Court of Delhi would not be the
forum conveniens.
9.
The decision in M/s. Chinteshwar Steel Pvt. Ltd. (supra) was assailed
before the Division Bench of this Court by way of LPA 801/2012. The
Division Bench, while upholding the decision of the learned Single Judge, held
2012 SCC OnLine Del 1024
2012 SCC OnLine Del 5264
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
W.P.(C) 14997/2023
as under:
“10. In fact, the two decisions in Vishnu Security Services and Jan Chetna
(supra) elucidate when and in what circumstances judicial discretion should
not be exercised on the ground of forum conveniens. In Vishnu Security
Services (supra), the Division Bench observed that though the writ petition
may be maintainable in two High Courts, but when the High Court finds
that it is inconvenient to entertain the writ petition as other High Court is
better equipped to deal with the case, doctrine of forum conveniens would
be attracted. Thereafter, reference was made to English authorities wherein
it has been held that in judging the comparative convenience or nonconvenience of the forum, the test to be applied is which Court out of the
two is more suitable in the interest of the parties as well as ends of justice.
Reference was also made to a U.S. decision wherein it has been observed
that courts have open doors to those who seek justice, but when justice is
blended with some harassment, it needs to be checked. Undoubtedly, the
petitioner is dominus litis, but when the choice is motivated by
temptation/strategy to force the petition at an inconvenient place, the Court
has the power to step in. We are also in agreement with the view of learned
Single Judge in the impugned order that the Division Bench in Vishnu
Security Services (supra) overruled the judgment of learned Single Judge
only on the ground that no reason had been given by the learned Single
Judge in that case to come to the conclusion that this Court was not the
convenient forum. Similarly, in Jan Chetna (supra), the Division Bench
observed that though the issue raised was purely legal relating to an object
in another State, yet as the issue raised had no local flavour at all, the said
doctrine need not be invoked. Consequently, in our opinion the judgments of
Vishnu Security Services (supra) and Jan Chetna (supra) have neither
deviated nor could have deviated from the judgment of five Judges of this
Court in Sterling Agro Industries Ltd. (supra).”
10.
The present issue again cropped up in Satish Ahuja Vs. Union of India &
Ors.4 wherein, while taking note of the decision in Jagdambay Auto Station &
Anr. Vs. Union of India & Ors.5 and the decision of the Division Bench in
Chinteshwar Steel Pvt. Ltd. (supra) wherein the decision in Sterling Agro
2016 SCC OnLine Del 2503
2012 SCC OnLine Del 5597
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
W.P.(C) 14997/2023
(supra) has been discussed, the Coordinate Bench of this Court reached the
same conclusion and dismissed the writ petition on the ground of territorial
jurisdiction.
11.
Recently, in Regional Provident Fund Commissioner Vs. BSC-C and C
JV6, the Coordinate Bench of this Court, in identical facts to the present case,
refused to entertain the writ petition.
12.
In the present case, both the parties are situated in Gurgaon. The only
basis for invoking the jurisdiction of this Court is that since the impugned order
has been passed by the appellate authority situated in Delhi, indeed as held in
Sterling Agro (supra), a part of the cause of action has arisen in Delhi.
However, that would not make this Court the forum conveniens. In Sterling
Agro, the Court, while canvassing the law on the subject, took note of various
decisions of the Supreme Court and explained the concept of forum conveniens
as under:
“30. In Musaraf Hossain Khan v. Bhagheeratha Engg. Ltd. (2006) 130
Comp Cas 390; (2006) 3 SCC 658, the apex court referred to the decision in
Kusum Ingots and Alloys Ltd. v. Union of India (2004) 120 C-C 672; (2004)
6 SCC 254 and observed as follows (page 401 of 130 C-C) :
‘... with a view to determine the jurisdiction of one High Court vis-a-vis
the other the facts pleaded in the writ petition must have a nexus on the
basis whereof a prayer can be made and the facts which have nothing to
do therewith cannot give rise to a cause of action to invoke the jurisdiction
of a court. In that case it was clearly held that only because the High
Court within whose jurisdiction a legislation is passed, it would not have
the sole territorial jurisdiction but all the High Courts where cause of
action arises, will have jurisdiction.. .’
31. Thereafter, their Lordships reproduced paragraphs 27 and 28 of the
said decision and a passage from Union of India v. Adani Exports Ltd.
(2002) 1 SCC 567, and proceeded to state as follows (page 403 of 130 C-C)
2023 SCC OnLine Del 6380
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
W.P.(C) 14997/2023
:
‘We have referred to the scope of jurisdiction under articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution only to highlight that the High Courts should not
ordinarily interfere with an order taking cognizance passed by a
competent court of law except in a proper case. Furthermore only such
High Court within whose jurisdiction the order of the subordinate court
has been passed, would have the jurisdiction to entertain an application
under article 227 of the Constitution of India unless it is established that
the earlier cause of action arose within the jurisdiction thereof.
The High Court, however, must remind themselves about the doctrine of
forum non conveniens also (see Mayar (H. K.) Ltd. v. Owners and Parties,
Vessel M. V. Fortune Express (2006) 3 SCC 100; (2006) 2 Scale 30).’
(underlining is by us)
32. From the aforesaid pronouncements, the concept of forum conveniens
gains signification. In Black's Law Dictionary, forum conveniens has been
defined as follows:
‘The court in which an action is most appropriately brought,
considering the best interests and convenience of the parties and
witnesses.’
33. The concept of forum conveniens fundamentally means that it is
obligatory on the part of the court to see the convenience of all the parties
before it. The convenience in its ambit and sweep would include the
existence of more appropriate forum, expenses involved, the law relating to
the lis, verification of certain facts which are necessitous for just
adjudication of the controversy and such other ancillary aspects. The
balance of convenience is also to be taken note of. Be it noted, the apex
court has clearly stated in the cases of Kusum Ingots and Alloys Ltd. v.
Union of India (2004) 120 C-C 672; (2004) 6 SCC 254, Musaraf Hossain
Khan v. Bhagheeratha Engg. Ltd. (2006) 130 C-C 390; (2006) 3 SCC 658
and Ambica Industries v. CCE (2007) 213 ELT 323; [2009] 20 VST 1 (S.C.),
about the applicability of the doctrine of forum conveniens while opining
that arising of a part of cause of action would entitle the High Court to
entertain the writ petition as maintainable.
34. The principle of forum conveniens in its ambit and sweep encapsulates
the concept that a cause of action arising within the jurisdiction of the court
would not itself constitute to be the determining factor compelling the court
to entertain the matter. While exercising jurisdiction under articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution of India, the court cannot be totally oblivious of the
concept of forum conveniens. The Full Bench in New India Assurance Co.
Ltd. v. Union of India, AIR 2010 Delhi 43; (2011) 166 Comp Cas 87
(Delhi), has not kept in view the concept of forum conveniens and has
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
W.P.(C) 14997/2023
expressed the view that if the appellate authority who has passed the order
is situated in Delhi, then the Delhi High Court should be treated as the
forum conveniens. We are unable to subscribe to the said view.”
13.
In the aforesaid backdrop of facts and the settled legal position, this
Court is not inclined to entertain the present writ petition; the same is
accordingly dismissed, along with all pending applications. However, the
petitioner is given liberty to seek its remedy in accordance with law.
MANOJ KUMAR OHRI
(JUDGE)
JANUARY 28, 2026
sn
Digitally Signed
By:NIJAMUDDEEN ANSARI
19:44:33
W.P.(C) 14997/2023
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review