The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Upo a comprehensive consideratio Upon deration of the matter, this Court urt is of o the view that at the findings recorded by the learne learned Rent Controller and the learned learne Appellate Court are based on proper appreciati reciation of evidence and settled ed legal leg principles. No pe perversity, illegality, or material ial irregularity has been pointed nted out o which may y warrant war interference in revisional isional jurisdiction. Consequently, tly, the th present revision ision petition p is devoid of merit and is hereby dismissed.
16. How However, in the interest of justice, tice, th the petitioners are granted a perio riod of two months nths fr from today to vacate the demise emised premises, subject to their ir filing filin an undertaking king within w a period of three weeks in this regard and clearing ring all a arrears of rent. ent. In case of failure, respondent nt No. No.1 shall be at liberty to execute cute the th order in accordan cordance with law.
17. Pend Pending misc. application, if any, ny, als also stands disposed of. (AMARI
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CR-755-2026
-1-
IN THE HIGH
IGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND
ND H
HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH
GARH
C.R. No.755 of 2026 (O&M)
(O&M
Reserved on:23.03.2026
Pronounced on:27.03.2026
Uploaded on:30.03.2026
Ri Rani and another
Reeta Rani @ Rita
... Petitioners
Versus
Jatinder Singh
ngh and
an others
... Respondent
dents
CORAM : HON'BLE
HON
MR. JUSTICE AMAR
MARINDER SINGH GREWAL
Present:
Mr. Krishan Singh Dadwal, Advoca
dvocate
for the
t petitioners.
Mr. Deepak Verma, Advocate
for respondent
r
No.1.
****
***
AMARINDER
DER SINGH
S
GREWAL, J.
1.
The present civil revision petition
tition has been preferred under Article
Artic
227 of the Const
Constitution of India challengingg the order dated 19.04.2018 passed
ssed by
b
the learned Rent Controller, Garhshankar,, wher
whereby the eviction petition filed
d by
b
the respondent
dent N
No.1-landlord under Section
ion 13 of the East Punjab Urban
an Rent
Re
Restriction Act, 1949 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) has been allowed
ed and
an
the petitioners--tenants have been directed to ha
hand over vacant possession
n of the
th
demised premise
ises and the order dated 20.11.2025
1.2025 passed by the learned Appella
ppellate
Court vide which appeal filed by the petitioners
oners against the order of eviction
n dated
date
19.04.2018 passed
passe by the learned Rent Contro
Controller, Garhshankar has also
so been
bee
dismissed.
2.
The brief facts necessary for adjudi
adjudication of the present petition
ition are
a
that respondent
dent No.1
N claimed himself to be a co
co-owner and landlord of the shop in
dispute, which
hich w
was initially let out to Sarabjit
bjit Sin
Singh, predecessor-in-interest
st of the
th
PANKAJ KUMAR
2026.03.30 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab and Haryana High Court
Chandigarh
CR-755-2026
-2-
petitioners,, at a monthly
m
rent of ₹1000/-. After the demise of the originall tenant,
tenan
the petitioners stepped
st
into his shoes and contin
continued in possession of the demised
demise
premises ass tenants.
tenan Respondent No.1 sought
ght ev
eviction of the petitioners primari
rimarily
on the grounds
ounds that they had fallen into
nto ar
arrears of rent with effect
ct from
fro
01.06.2009,, that they were habitual defaulter
faulters in payment of rent and
nd that
th
respondentt No.1 required the premises forr his bona fide personal necessity
ty as he
h
intended to retur
urn to his native place and start his own business in the demised
demise
premises along
long with
w adjoining shops.
3.
Upo notice, the petitioners-tenan
Upon
tenants appeared and contested
ted the
th
petition by filin
filing a written statement raising
ising preliminary objections regardin
garding
maintainability,
ility, locus
l
standi of respondentt No.1 and applicability of the Act. On
O
merits, it was
as pleaded
ple
that the agreed rate of re
rent was ₹500/- per month and not
n
₹1000/- perr mon
month, that the property in dispute
ispute did not fall within the municip
unicipal
limits of Mahilp
ahilpur and, therefore, the provision
visions of the Act were not applicabl
plicable,
and that respond
espondent No.1 was not the owner
wner of the property, the samee being
bein
Shamlat Deh.
eh. The
Th bonafide necessity of respond
espondent No.1 was also denied
d on the
th
ground thatt he w
was well settled abroad.
4.
The learned Rent Controller, on the basis of pleadings of the parties,
partie
framed the necessary
neces
issues and after appreciatin
eciating the evidence led by both
th sides,
side
returned finding
indings in favour of respondent
nt No
No.1 and ordered eviction of the
th
petitioners vide o
order dated 19.04.2018 and
nd the appeal preferred against the said
sa
order by the
he petitioners
pe
has also been dismiss
ismissed vide order dated 20.11.202
11.2025
passed by the learned
lea
Appellate Court. Hence,
nce, th
the instant revision petition.
5.
Lear
Learned
counsel for the petitioners
oners had assailed the impugned
d orders
orde
by contending
ing th
that the findings recorded byy the learned Rent Controller as well as
a
PANKAJ KUMAR
2026.03.30 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab and Haryana High Court
Chandigarh
CR-755-2026
-3-
the learned Appellate
Appe
Court are erroneous,
s, con
contrary to evidence on record,
ord, and
an
suffer from material
mat
irregularity. It was argued that the rate of rent has
as been
bee
wrongly assessed
sessed and respondent No.1 had failed to establish bona fide necessit
ecessity.
The learned
d Rent
Ren Controller had not the jurisdic
urisdiction to entertain the rent petition,
petitio
as the disputed
uted premises does not fall within
hin the municipal limits so as to
o attract
attra
the provisions
ions o
of the Act. It was further argue
argued that respondent No.1 had not
n
pleaded thee nece
necessary ingredients of clauses
es (b) and (c) of Section 13(3)(a)
a) (i) of
o
the Act and
d thus,
thus the rent petition was liable
ble to be dismissed. In support
rt of his
h
contention,, he re
relied upon the judgment passed
assed a Division Bench of this Court in
Banke Ram Vs. Shrimati Sarasvati Devi 1977(1
77(1) RCR (Rent) 595 and judgmen
dgments
passed by Coordinate
Coord
Benches of this Court
urt in Thakar Dass Vs. Madan Moha
ohan
2018(2) RentLR
tLR 593; Joginder Singh Sawhney
hney Vs. Harbans Lal 2003(1)) RCR
RC
(Rent) 528 and Shankar Lal Vs. Madan Lall and others 2011 (1) RCR(Rent)
t) 139.
6.
It was
w further argued that both
th the learned Courts below havee failed
faile
to considerr the fact
f
that the tenancy included
ded th
the shop as well as the taur for a
consolidated
ed rent of ₹1000/- per month andd that the taur area was got vacated
ated by
b
the landlord
d forc
forcibly and illegally. The eviction
viction petition was filed by responde
pondent
No.1 through
gh a fforged and fabricated power
er of attorney. It was also argued
ued that
th
the application
ation filed by the petitioners under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC seeking
seekin
amendmentt of th
the written statement was dismiss
ismissed by learned Appellate Court in
an unjust and arbitrary
ar
manner, despite the
he fac
fact that there is settled law that a
liberal approach
roach ought to have been applied
lied bby the Courts while deciding
ing the
th
amendmentt appli
applications and there is no prohibit
rohibition to permit amendment even at
the appellate
ate stage.
sta
In support of his contenti
ntention, he relied upon the judgme
dgment
passed by the Hon’ble
Ho
Supreme Court in Ishwa
shwardas Vs. The State of M.P.. and
an
PANKAJ KUMAR
2026.03.30 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab and Haryana High Court
Chandigarh
CR-755-2026
-4-
others AIR 1979 SC 551 and the judgment
nt pass
passed by this Court in Daljit Singh
Sing
(deceased) throu
hrough LRs Vs. Sunita (deceased)
sed) through LRs and anotherr 2017
(2) PLR 438. Furthermore, the respondentt No.1
No.1-landlord had miserably failed to
prove bona fide need of starting a business,
ss, kee
keeping in view the fact thatt he had
ha
already gott vaca
vacated eight shops in the vicinity
icinity of the demised premises.
s. The
Th
respondentt No.1-landlord
No.1
is an NRI, beingg perm
permanently settled in Australiaa and
an
there is no evide
evidence available on record to dep
depict that he has any intention
ntion to
return to India
dia an
and run a business at his native
tive pla
place.
7.
Per contra, learned counsell for respondent No.1-landlord has
supported the impugned
im
orders and submitted
ted tha
that the same are based upon
n proper
prop
appreciation
n of evidence and settled legal
al prin
principles. It is contended that the
th
petitioners have failed
f
to substantiate their pleas aas taken before the learned
d Courts
Cour
below and that no ground for interference is made out in revisional jurisdiction.
tion.
8.
I have
ha heard learned counsel
el for the parties at length and
d have
hav
carefully gone
one th
through the record of the case.
9.
The contention raised by the petitio
petitioners pertaining to the rate of rent
re
has no merit. The
Th learned Rent Controller has re
recorded a categorical finding
ing that
th
the rate of rent was
w ₹1000/- per month. This
his fin
finding is based on the factt that in
earlier rentt petitio
petitions filed between the parties,
ies, the respondents had tendered
d rent at
the rate of ₹1000/₹1000 per month and the said
id peti
petitions were withdrawn upon
on such
suc
tender. Significa
nificantly, the petitioners have not pplaced on record any material
terial to
show that they h
had ever sought recovery off any alleged excess rent paid by
y them.
them
In the absencee of
o any documentary evidence
nce su
supporting the plea that the agreed
agree
rent was ₹500/-- per month, the Rent Controller
oller w
was justified in drawing an adverse
advers
PANKAJ KUMAR
2026.03.30 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab and Haryana High Court
Chandigarh
CR-755-2026
-5-
inference against
gainst the respondents and the said ffinding was correctly affirmed
rmed by
b
the learned Appellate
Appe
Court.
10.
The further contention regarding
ing no
non-applicability of the Actt on the
th
ground thatt the p
premises does not fall within
hin mu
municipal limits also deserves
es to be
b
rejected. The
he pe
petitioner examined an official
ficial ffrom the Nagar Panchayat,
at, who
wh
categorically
lly deposed
dep
that the property in que
question falls within the municip
unicipal
limits of Mahilp
ahilpur and is assessed to house
use ta
tax. This testimony has remaine
emained
unshaken in cro
cross-examination. The responde
pondents have failed to produce
uce any
an
evidence to
o rebu
rebut the said official record. Thus, the finding recorded by the
he Rent
Re
Controller regarding
regard
applicability of the Act
ct is ba
based on cogent evidence and
nd calls
cal
for no interferen
erference. Furthermore, a Coordinat
rdinate Bench of this Court in Civil
Civ
Revision Petition
etition No.2985 of 2011 titled as Narinder Kumar and another
er Vs.
V
Narinder Singh
ngh Bains and other connected
ted ca
cases decided on 17.05.2011
011 has
ha
rejected thee cont
contention of petitioners therein
ein tha
that the demised premises does
oes not
n
fall within the m
municipal limits of Mahilpur
ur as tthe disputed khasra numbers
rs were
we
not mentioned
ned in the notification dated 11.01.199
.01.1993, while affirming the finding
nding of
o
the learned Rent Controller that the provisions
isions of the Act are applicablee to the
th
entire municipal
icipal area of Mahilpur and once
ce it is shown that a building is located
locate
within the municipal
mun
area, the provisions
ions oof the Act become applicab
plicable
automatically.
lly.
11.
This Court also does not find any merit in the contention raised
aised by
b
learned counsel
unsel for the petitioners thatt resp
respondent No.1-landlord had not
n
specifically
y pleaded
plead in his petition seekingg evic
eviction under Section 13 of the Act
A
that he wass not o
occupying another residential
tial bui
building in the urban area concerne
ncerned
and he has
as not vacated such a building
ng wi
without sufficient cause after
fter the
th
PANKAJ KUMAR
2026.03.30 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab and Haryana High Court
Chandigarh
CR-755-2026
-6-
commencement
ment o
of this Act, in the said urban
an are
area, thus, the petition itself was bad
ba
for non-complian
mpliance of clauses (b) and (c)) of S
Section 13(3)(a)(i) of the Act. A
careful perusal
rusal of
o the petition filed by responde
spondent No.1–landlord clearly reveals
revea
that he has specif
specifically averred that, being an NR
NRI, he intends to settle at his
is native
nativ
place in thee twil
twilight years of his life and,, for that purpose, requires thee shops,
shop
including the de
demised premises, to establish
lish a business for his livelihood,
ood, for
fo
which separate
arate eviction
e
petitions have been
en file
filed. It was further averred that he
h
had not vacated
cated any commercial building in the urban area of Mahilpur orr at any
an
other place in his life time. Thus, this Court
urt doe
does not find any non-compliance
iance of
o
clauses (b)) and (c) of Section 13(3)(a)(i)) of tthe Act as contended by learned
learne
counsel forr the p
petitioners. The absence off spec
specific pleadings or the non-framin
framing
of an issuee would
wou become material only wher
where it causes prejudice to a party.
part
However, in a sit
situation where the materiall facts are evident on the record and the
th
parties havee proc
proceeded to trial with full awaren
awareness of each other’s claims,
s, it is
difficult to comprehend
comp
how any deficiency
cy in pleadings could be said to have
hav
caused prejudice
judice. The petitioners have utterly failed to demonstrate that
hat any
an
prejudice was ca
caused to them, or that they
ey wer
were prevented from producing
ing any
an
evidence materia
aterial to the outcome of the case. The Hon’ble Supreme Court
ourt in
Ram Narain Aro
Arora versus Asha Rani (1999)) 1 S
SCC 141 has held as under:“11 There cannot be a pedantic
“11.
ntic or a dogmatic approach in the
th
matt of analysis of pleadings or oof the evidence adduced thereto.
matter
eto. It
is no doubt true that if the pleading
dings are clearly set out, it would
uld be
b
easy for the court to decide the m
matter. But if the pleadingss are
a
lack
lacking
or vague and if both partie
arties have understood what was
as the
th
case pleaded and put forth with ref
reference to requirement of law
w and
an
plac such material before thee cou
placed
court, neither party is prejudiced.
ced. If
we analyse
a
from this angle, we do nnot think that the High Court
rt was
wa
PANKAJ KUMAR
2026.03.30 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab and Haryana High Court
Chandigarh
CR-755-2026
-7-
not justified in interfering with
ith the order made by the Rent
Re
Con
Controller.”
12.
The learned Appellate Court has rig
rightly dismissed the application
ation of
o
the petitioners
ners filed
fi
under Order 6 Rule 17 CP
CPC for amendment of the written
writte
statement on the ground that the facts, which
hich ppetitioners wanted to incorpora
orporate
pertained to
o the year
y 2011 whereas they had
ad file
filed the written statement before
fore the
th
learned Rent
nt Con
Controller on 02.02.2012, thus,
us, no plausible explanation camee forth
for
that they could not incorporate the said infor
information in the written stateme
atement
despite duee diligence.
dilig
Further, there is no expla
explanation as to what prevented
ed them
the
to seek amendme
endment of the written statement
nt dur
during the course of trial before
fore the
th
learned Rent
nt Controller.
Con
Likewise, petitioners
ners ha
have miserably failed to prove
ove that
th
the power of attorney
atto
was a forged and fabricated
ricated document.
13.
The most crucial issue in the present
resent case is that of bona fide personal
person
necessity. The respondent No.1-landlord has ple
pleaded that he intends to return
eturn to
his native place and start a business for hi
his livelihood. The learned
d Rent
Re
Controller,, upon appreciation of evidence,, has aaccepted the said plea as genuine.
genuin
The law relating
lating to bona fide necessity is well ssettled. In Sarla Ahuja v. United
Unite
India Insurance
ance Co. Ltd. (1998) 8 SCC 119,, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
ourt has
ha
held that when a landlord asserts that he req
requires his building for his
is own
ow
occupation,, the Rent Controller shall nott proc
proceed on the presumption that the
th
requirementt is not
no bona fide. When other conditi
onditions of the clause are satisfied
fied and
an
when the landlord
landlor shows a prima facie case,
se, it is open to the Rent Controller
roller to
draw a presumpt
sumption that the requirement of the landlord is bona fide. It is often
ofte
said by courts
ts that
tha it is not for the tenant too dicta
dictate terms to the landlord as to how
ho
else he can
n adju
adjust himself without gettingg poss
possession of the tenanted premise
remises.
PANKAJ KUMAR
2026.03.30 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab and Haryana High Court
Chandigarh
CR-755-2026
-8-
While deciding
iding tthe question of bona fides of the requirement of the landlord,
ord, it is
quite unnecessar
cessary to make an endeavour as to hhow else the landlord could
ld have
hav
adjusted himself.
imself. Thus, the contention of the petitioners that respondent No.1 is
settled abroad
oad an
and, therefore, has no bona fide need is misconceived. Further,
ther, the
t
Hon’ble Supreme
upreme Court in Baldev Singh Bajwa
ajwa v. Monish Saini (2005) 12
2 SCC
SC
778 has held as under:u
“19 …….In our view, there are
“19.
re in
inbuilt protections in the releva
levant
prov
provisions
for the tenants that when
henever the landlord would approac
roach
the court
c
he would approach when
hen hhis need is genuine and bona
a fide.
fid
It is,
is of course, subject to the tenant
nant's right to rebut it but with strong
stron
and cogent evidence. In our view,
ew, iin the proceeding taken up under
und
Sect
Section
13-B by the NRI landlords
rds ffor the ejectment of the tenant,
nt, the
th
cour shall presume that the landlor
court
dlord's need pleaded in the petition
tion is
genu
genuine
and bona fide. But thiss wo
would not disentitle the tenantt from
fro
prov
proving
that in fact and in law the rrequirement of the landlord is not
n
genu
genuine.
A heavy burden wouldd lie on the tenant to prove that
at the
t
requ
requirement
of the landlord is not genuine. To prove this fact
ct the
th
tena will be called upon too gi
tenant
give all the necessary factss and
an
part
particulars
supported by docume
umentary evidence, if available,
le, to
supp his plea in the affidavit itse
support
itself so that the Controller willl be in
a position
po
to adjudicate and decide
cide the question of genuine or bona
bon
fide requirement of the landlord.
d. A mere assertion on the part of the
th
tena would not be sufficient too re
tenant
rebut the strong presumption in the
th
land
landlord's
favour that his requirem
rement of occupation of the premis
emises
is real
re and genuine.”
14.
It is a settled principle of law
w that the requirement of the landlord
landlor
must be assessed
sessed from the landlord’s perspectiv
pective and not from that of the tenant.
tenan
Even if, during
ring the
th pendency of the proceedings,
dings, another adjoining shop off similar
simil
size and with
ith co
comparable access comes into th
the possession of the landlord,
ord, the
th
PANKAJ KUMAR
2026.03.30 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab and Haryana High Court
Chandigarh
-9-
CR-755-2026
tenant cannot
not insist
in
that the landlord should
ould uutilize that premises instead.
ad. The
Th
choice of suitabi
uitability of the accommodationn rests solely with the landlord, and the
th
tenant cannot
not dictate
dic
terms in this regard. What is essential is that the landlord
ndlord’s
need must be genuine,
gen
bona fide, and not a mere pretext. The landlord remains
ains the
th
best judge of his own requirements.
15.
Upo a comprehensive consideratio
Upon
deration of the matter, this Court
urt is of
o
the view that
at the findings recorded by the learne
learned Rent Controller and the learned
learne
Appellate Court are based on proper appreciati
reciation of evidence and settled
ed legal
leg
principles. No pe
perversity, illegality, or material
ial irregularity has been pointed
nted out
o
which may
y warrant
war
interference in revisional
isional jurisdiction. Consequently,
tly, the
th
present revision
ision petition
p
is devoid of merit and is hereby dismissed.
16.
How
However,
in the interest of justice,
tice, th
the petitioners are granted a perio
riod
of two months
nths fr
from today to vacate the demise
emised premises, subject to their
ir filing
filin
an undertaking
king within
w
a period of three weeks in this regard and clearing
ring all
a
arrears of rent.
ent. In case of failure, respondent
nt No.
No.1 shall be at liberty to execute
cute the
th
order in accordan
cordance with law.
17.
Pend
Pending
misc. application, if any,
ny, als
also stands disposed of.
(AMARI
ARINDER SINGH GREWAL)
JUDGE
March 27,, 2026
Pankaj*
PANKAJ KUMAR
2026.03.30 11:01
I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of
this document
Punjab and Haryana High Court
Chandigarh
Whether speaking/reasoned
ned
:
Yes/No
Whether reportable
:
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review