Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
t 3488I
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE FIRST DAY OF SEPTEMBER
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WRIT PETITION Nos.27209 AND 29830 0F 2024
WP NO: 27209 OF 2024
Between:
D. Hanumantheshwar Rao, S/o D. Raja Rao (Late), Aged about 47 years, Occ
Administrative Officer, Olo Joint Transport Commissioner / SRTA,
Khairatabad, Hyderabad, Rl/o. H.No.6-3-1 1851 1 1 21 4, Begumpet, Hyderabad.
...PETITIONER
AND
'1
. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Transport, Roads
and Buildings Dept., Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, General
Administration Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
3. The Transport Commissioner, Telangana State, Hyderabad.
4. Gurram Vivekananda Reddy, Sio. G. Hanmanth Reddy, Aged about b7 years,
Present working station - Armoor, Nizamabad, Rl/o. H. No. 5-83/l, perkit,
Armoor, Nizamabad District - 503 224.
5. AIle Srinivas, S/o. A. Devarajam, Aged about 57 years, Present working
station - Adilabad, Fl/o. H. No. 9-209, Teachers Colony, Adilabad-S04 001
6. tVandadi Suresh Reddy, S/o. IV. Danareddy (Late), Aged about 56 years,
Present working station - RTA, Hyderabad, F/o. Villa No. 95, Ir/y Fair Villas,
Osman Nagar Road, Tellapur, R.C. Puram, Hyderabad - 502 032
7. Ravula Vijay Rao, S/o. R. Prakash (Late), Aged about 60 years, Present
working station - IVIVI - Patancheru, Sangareddy District, Fi/o. H.No. 1-93121E19, Plot No. 203 Street No. 6, Atchyuth Reddy Marg, Vidyanagar,
Hyderabad-500 042
(Respondent Nos.4 to 7 are impleaded as per Court Order dt 24-04-2025,
vide l.A. No. 1 of 2025, in W.P. No.272Og of 2024)
-l
8. Godas Ravi Kumar, S/o. G. Mallesham. Aged aboul 59 years Occupation
L4otor Vehicles lnspector O/o Present working MVl, RTA, Hyderabad-WestZone. R/o. 8-2-684114, Road No. '12, Anand Banjara, Banjarahills, Hyderabad.
9. Matam Yerri Swamy, S/o. Late M. Umapathaiah, Aged about 59 years,
Occupation Motor Vehicles lnspector O/o Presenl. working MVl, RTA,
Hyderabad-North Zone. Rl/o Flat G2, Anu Heights, Eenadu Colony,
Kukatpally, Hyderabad.
10.G. Ashwanth Kumar, S/o. G. Lakshami Narayana, Aged about 49 years.
Occupation Motor Vehicles lnspector O/o Present rvorking Motor Vehicle
lnspector R/o 14-1 12, Raghavendra Residency, Dilsukhnagar P and T
Colony, Hyderabad.
1 . J. Umamaheswar Rao, S/o. Late Seetharamaiah, r\ged about 59 years.
Occupation Motor Vehicles lnspector O/o District Transport Officer,
Nizamabad. Rl/o Flat No 216, Yendala Towers, opp Prudence Hospital,
Pragatr Nagar, Nizamabad.
(Respondent Nos.8 to 11 are impleaded as per Co. dt.11-11-2025 Vide lA
No.2 of 2025 in W.P.No.27209 of 2024)
l2.Dorbala Pradeep Ram Kdshna, S/o. D.Devidas Sharma, Aged about 49
years, Occ: Administrative Officer, Office at Road Transport Authority,
Hyderabad North Zone.
(Respondent No.12 is impleaded as per C.O. d1.05.08.2026 vide 1.A.2 of 2026
in WP.No.27209 of 2024)
.RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of
Writ of Mandamus, to declare the action of the 'l st Respondent in the issuing
amendments to Telangana Transport Service Rules,1993 vide Notification in
G.O.t\,4s.No.7, Transport, Roads and Buildings (TR. Ser) Dept., dt 28 01 .2021 , in
Annexure to Rule 5, to the extent of prescription of Technical Qualification i. e
Degree in [\/echanical Engineering or Automobile Engineering or equivalent
qualification, to the AO's working in District Offices (category- 8), for appointment by
transfer to the post of RTO (category- 3) is without any power and authority as
illegal, arbitrary, discrimrnatory and violative of Articles 14 and '16 of the Constitution
of lndia and contrary to Section 213 (4) of MV Act, 1988 and ,ronsequently, quash or
set aside the impugned rule and further declare that, the Petitioner and AOs working
in the District Offices are entitled to be considered for appointment to the post of
RTO based on the qualification prescribed in the Pre- amended Rules issued vide
G.O.Ms.No.1 80 dt 01.07.1995.
l.A. NO: 'l OF 2024
Petition under section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to grant stay
of all further proceedings, by suspending the operation of Annexure to Rule- 5 of
Telangana Transport Service Rules issued in G. o. Ivls. No. 7, Transport, Roads and
Buildings (TR. Ser) Dept., dt 28. 01 . 2021 , to the extent of prescription of Technical
Qualification i. e Degree in tt4echanical Engineering or Automobile Engineering or
equivalent qualification, to the AOs working in District Offices (category- 8), for
appointment by transfer to the post of RTO (category- 3) pending disposal of the
above writ petition.
l.A. NO: 3 OF 2026
Between:
Dorbala Pradeep Ram Krishna, S/o D.Devidas Sharma, Aged about 49
years, Occ: Administrative Officer, Office at Road Transport Authority,
Hyderabad North Zone.
...PETITIONER
AND
D. Hanumantheshwar Rao, Sio D. Raja Rao (Late), Aged about 47 years, Occ
SRTA'
Administrative Officer, Oio Joint Transport Commissioner
Khairatabad, Hyderabad, Rl/o. H.No.6-3-1 1 851 1 1 21 4, Begumpet, Hyderabad'
/
...RESPONDENT No.lM/R|T PETITIONER
2. The State of Telangana, Rep- by its Principal Secretary, Transport' Roads
and Buildings Dept., Secretariat, Hyderabad
3. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, General
Administration Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
4. The Transport Commissioner, Telangana State, Hyderabad.
5. Gurram Vivekananda Reddy, S/o. G. Hanmanth Reddy, Aged about 57 years,
Present working station - Armoor, Nizamabad, R/o. H No 5-83/1 , Perkit,
Armoor, Nizamabad District - 503 224.
6. Alle Srinivas, S/o. A. Devarajam, Aged about 57 years, Present working
station - Adilabad, Rl/o. H. No. 9-209, Teachers Colony, Adilabad-504 001
7. Mandadi Suresh Reddy, S/o. Ir,'1. Danareddy (Late), Aged about 56 yetrs'
Present working station - RTA, Hyderabad, R/o Villa No' 95, IVIy Fair Villas'
Osman Nagar Road, Tellapur, R.C. Puram, Hyderabad - 502 032
I
8. Ravula Vijay Rao, S/o. R. Prakash (Late), Aged abcut 60 years, Present
working station - MVI - Patancheru, Sangareddy District, Rl/o. H.No. 1-93121E19, Plot No. 203 Street No. 6, Atchyuth Reddy [\ilarg, Vidyanagar,
Hyderabad-500 042
9. Godas Ravi Kumar, S/o. G. Mallesham. Aged aboul 59 years Occupation
Motor Vehicles lnspector O/o Present working N/Vl, RTA, Hyderabad-West
Zone. R/o. 8-2-084114, Road No. 12, Anand Banjara, Banjarahills, Hyderabad.
'10.1\rlatam Yerrr Swamy, S/o. Late IVl. Umapathaiah. l\ged about 59 years,
Occupation Motor Vehicles lnspector O/o Presenl working MVl, RTA,
Hyderabad-North Zone. Rio Flat G2, Anu Heights, Eenadu Colony,
Kukatpally, Hyderabad.
'1
1.G. Ashwanth Kumar, Sio. G. Lakshami Narayana, Aged about 49 years.
Occupation lt4otor Vehicles lnspector O/o Present rvorking Motor Vehicle
lnspector No 14-112, Raghavendra Residency, Dilsukhnagar P and T
Colony, Hyderabad.
12.J. Umamaheswar Rao, S/o. Late Seetharamaiah. r\ged about 59 years.
Occupation Motor Vehicles lnspector O/o District Transport Officer,
Nizamabad. R/o Flat No 216, Yendala Towers, oprp Prudence Hospital,
Pragati Nagar, Nizamabad.
...RESPONDENTS 2.1 2/RESPONDENTS 1.1 1
Petltion under Section 15'1 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be; pleased to vacate the
interim orders passed by this Honorable Court on 24.O4.2O25 in WP No. 2983012024
and WP No 27209 of 2024 also direct the respondents to r'-.view the DPC Panels
2018-2019 and 2020-2021 and 2025-2026 (violation of presidential order) panels
and to include eligible administrative officers for promotion to the post of RTO and in
so far as the petitioner is concerned.
Counsel for the PetitioneT: SRI POODATTU AMARENDER
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 TO 3: SRI SANTHAPUFI SATYANARAYANA
RAO, GP FOFI SERVICES-I
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.4 TO 7: SRI G.VIDYA SAISAR, SENIOR
COUNSEL FOR SRI SAI PRASENI GUNDAVARAM
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.8 TO 11:SRl D.SUDHAR:SHAN
Counsel for the Respondent No.12: SRI VIJAY B PAROPAKARI
WP NO: 25830 OF 2024
Between:
1. Rayarao Hari Prasad Rao, S/o. Late Sri Narasimha Rao, Aged about 55
years, Occ. Administrative Officer, RTO, Hyderabad South Zone (Emp. l.D
1404954) F/o. 6-4-362, PIot No. 72, TV Colony, Vanasthalipuram, Hyderabad.
2. Afshan Anjum, W/o. Late Mohd l/ultani, Aged about 50 years, Occ.
Administrative Officer, RTO, Hyderabad East Zone (Emp.lD 2512132) No.23-421 Cl 34, Amberpet, Hyderabad
3. Vakkanthula Srinivasa Rao, S/o. V. Pullaiah, Aged about 54 Years, Occ.
Administrative Officer, RTO, Hyderabad, Central Zone R/o. H.No.11-10-28'
Vijaypuri colony, Kothapet, Ranga Reddy District.
4. Akki Padmavathi, W/o. Akki Dass, Aged about 44 years, Occ. Administrative
Officer, DTO, Ranga Reddy(Emp. lD No.2509836) Fl/o. F|.No.201, Santosh
Towers, West [Varredpally, Secunderabad.
(Dismissed as withdrawn as per C.O. dt: 05/08i2026 in lA.No.'1 of 2026)
5. Kasukurthi Rajani, W/o. M.Prem Chand Aged about 46 years Occ
Administrative Officer, DTO, Vikarabad (Empl lD- 2543564) Rio. Plot no 11,
Shankar Green Homes, Ameenpur, Sangareddy Dist
6. A.V.Ramesh, S/o. Late A.V.Ram Mohan Rao Aged about 45 years, Occ.
Administrative Officer, RTO, Hyderabad West Zone, (Emp lD 2509833) R/o.
F|.No.103, R.R.l\/eadows Radha Residency Dhobighat X Road, lvladannapet
colony, Saidabad, Hyderabad
7. B. Madhukar, S/o. Late B. Shekar, Aged about 46 years, Occ. Administrative
Officer, RTO, Hyderabad East Zone (Emp. l.D No. 2543585) F/o. G2,
Vinayaka Residency, Raghavendra Nagar, Nacharam, Hyderabad.
B. Kothapalli Benjamin, W/o. Balaiah, Aged about 57 years, Occ. Administrative
Officer, DTO, Suryapet (Emp. l.D 2543551) No. 8-3-22811209/2, Rahamath
Nagar, Yusufguda, Hyderabad, 500045.
...PETITIONERS
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Transport, Roads
and Buildings Department, Secretariat Building, Hyderabad.
2. The Transport Commissioner, State of Telangana at Khairathabad,
Hyderabad.
3. Gurram Vivekananda Reddy, S/o. G. Hanmanth Reddy, Aged about 57 years,
Present working station - Armoor, Nizamabad, R/o. H. No. 5-83/1 , Perkit'
Armoor, Nizamabad District - 503 224.
4. Alle Srinivas, S/o. A. Devarajam, Aged about 57 years, Present working
station - Adilabad, Rl/o. H. No. 9-209, Teachers Colony, Adilabad-504 001
5. Ivlandadi Suresh Reddy, S/o. M. Danareddy (Late), Aged about 56 years,
Present working station - RTA, Hyderabad, R/o. Villa No. 95, lVy Fair Villas,
Osman Nagar Road, Tellapur, R.C. Puram, Hyderabad - 502032
6. Ravula Vijay Rao, S/o. R. Prakash (Late), Aged about 60 years, Present
working station - IVIV| - Patancheru, Sangareddy District, R/o. H'No 1-9-
3121E19, Plot No. 203 Street No. 6, Atchyuth RedCy Marg, Vidyanagar,
Hyderabad-500 042
(Respondent Nos.3 to 6 are impleaded as per Court Order dl 24-04-2025,
vide l.A. No. 2 of 2025, in W.P. No.29830 of 2024)
7. G.Sreenivasa Reddy, S/o. G.Peri Reddy (Late), Aged 57 years, Presently
working Station- MVI- lbrahimpatnam, Ranga Reddy )istrict, R/o. H.No.2-131 , Flat No.502, Vegetable Market, Nallakunta, Hydera rad - 500044.
8. Dorbala Pradeep Ram Krishna, S/o. D.Devidas Sh arma, Aged about 49
years, Occ: Administrative Officer, Office at Roac Transport Authority,
Hyderabad North Zone.
(Respondent Nos.7 and 8 are impleaded as per C O. dt.05.08.2026 vide
lA.No.2 and 3 of 2026 in WP.No.29830 of 2024)
..,RESPONDENTS
Petition under Arlicle 226 of the Constitution of lnd a praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased
to issue any writ order or direction one more particularly irr the nature of writ of
Itrlandamus, declaring the GO.Ms 7 Transport, Roads and bu ldings Department(TR-
SER) dt 2810112021 amending the Telangana Transport Service Rules, 1993 issued
in G.lt4s.No.180 T, R and B(Tr.1) department d|.0110711994, amending the
qualification required for promotion to the post of RTO from the post of
Administrative officers and post of RTO are filled in cycle of 1C by direct recruitment,
by promotion from [t4Vl and AO's, under the amended rules; in cycle of 10 only 2
vacancies are allocated to AO's, without considering the lvlemo dt 221912008,
wherein it was decided by the Government to allocate the 2 vacancies in the ratio of
.'l between the II4VS and AO's, without calling for object ons f rom the effected
candidates who have been appointed in the feeder categories of AOs as per the
service rules and rendered 25-37 yearc of service, ultra vir,:s to the service rules
unconstitutiona I depriving the petitioners right for promotion tl the post of RTO who
have put in long years of services as illegal, ultra-vires ard unconstitutional and
consequently set aside the G.O.lVs 7 Transport, Floads and buildings
Department(TR-SER) dt 2810112021 amending the Telangana Transport Service
Rules, 1993 issued in G.O.l\/s.No.180 T,R and B(Tr.1)department dt.01/07/1994
amending the qualification required for promotion to the post of RTO from the post of
Administrative officers and an allocation of the vacancies to the MVls and AO's in the
unit the unit of 10 as per the Government memo dt.221912008.
l.A. NO: 10F 2024
circumstances stated in the
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the
Court may be pleased to suspend
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High
(TR-SER) dt'
the G.O.lr/s. No.7 Transport, Roads and buildings Department
Service Rules, 1993, pending
2810112021 amending the Telangana Transport
writ petition
disposal of writ petition pending disposal of the above
t.A. NO :2OF 2024
PetitionUnderSectionl5lCPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesstatedinthe
Court may be pleased to for the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High
reasonsUrgedatthetimeofhearingitisprayedthattheHon.blecourtbepleasedto
in the DPC which is to constituted
stay the promotions to the posts of the RTOs
pending disposal of the writ petition'
l.A. NO:3 oF 2024
PetitionunderSectionl51CPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesstatedinthe
High Court may be pleased to stay the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the
promotionstothepostsoftheRTosinthevacanciesallocatedtotheAdministrative
as per the lvlemo No'
officers in the DPC which is proposed to be convened
1OOgtC3t2O24 dt.O2.12 24 pending disposal
of the writ petition'
FOR
Counsel for the Petitioners: Ms' P'K'KALYANI
SRI GOPALA RAO AMANCHARLA V
SANTHAPUR SATYANARAYANA
Counsel forthe ResponOent Nos'1 & 2: SRI
RAO, GP FOR SERVICES.I
Nos'3 TO 6: SRI G'VIDYA SAGAR' SENIOR
-C6uruiel
Counsel for the Respondent
FoR sRt sAl PRASEN GUNDAVARAM
A'V'A'SIVA KARTIKEYA
Counsel for the Respondent Nos'7 & 8: SRI
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
IN THEHIGH COURT FIORTHE STATEOFTELNTGANA
AT ITTDERABAI)
THE HON'RLF THE CHIEF'JUSTICE SRI APA.RESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
TIIE HONIBLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHII'DDIN
WRIT PETITION Nos.272O9 and 2983O of 20'24
DATE: Ol .O9.2U26
Writ Petition No.272O9 of 2o24
(CNR No.HBHCO lOS2a7 320241
Between:
D. Hanumantheshrvar Rao
,
...Petitioner
AND
The State of Telangana, rep., by its
Principal Secretary-, Tralsport, Roads &
Buildings Deparknent arrd 11 others
....Respondents
Writ Petition No.2983O of 2o24
(CNR No.HBHC0 lO57 2n2n%l:l
Between:
Rayarao Hari Prasad Rao and 7 others
.
..,Petitioners
AND
The State of Telangana, rep., by its
Principal Secretary, Trarlsport, Roads &
Buildings Departrnent and 7 others
..,.Respondents
COMMON ORDER
Since these Lwo writ petitions raise comm,tn questions
concerning the interpretation of Section 213 of the Votor Vehicles
Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as 'the MV Act, 1!:r88J and the
power cf the State Goverr-rment to prescribe technical qualifications
)
for appointment to the post of Regional Transport Officer (hereinafter
referred to as the 'RTOJ and challenge the vires of G.O.Ms.No.7,
Transport, Roads & Buildings (TR. Ser) Department, dated
24.01.2021 (hereinafter referred to as ,the Impugned G.O.) amending
the Telangana State Transport Service Rutes, 1993, they were heard
together and are being disposed of by this common order.
2.
W.P.No.272O9 of 2024, is liled under Article 226 of tkrc
Constitution of India, with the follou,ing prayer:"...1o rssue an appropiate LUit, order or direction tutre
parttcularlg one in the nature of Wnt of Mandomus, to declare the
action of the lst Respondent tn the issuing anLend.ments to
'Telangana Transport Serutce Rules, 1993' uid.e Notif.catton n
G.O.Ms.No.7, Transport, Roads & Buitdings (TR.Ser) Dept., dt:
28.01.2021, in ArLnexttre to Rule 5, to the extent oJ prescnption of
Technical Quali,fi.cation i.e., Degree in Mechanicctl Ertgineeing ir
Automobile Engineeing or equiualent qualtfi.cation, to the AO,s
working in District Offces (category,8), for appointrnent bg
transfer to the post of RTO (category 3) is Luithout atu.l potaer and
authoitA as illegal, arbitrary, dtscrimbrutory and uiolatiue of
ArticLes 14 & 16 oJ tlle Constitution of lndia ancl contrary to
Section 213 6) of MV Act, 1988 and consequen g, quash or set
aside the impugned rule and fufther declare thctt, the petitioner
and AO's working in the Distnct Offi.ces are entitled. to be
constdered for appointment to the post of RT() based on the
qualifiration prescrtbecl in the Pre amenclid Rules issued uid.e
G.O.IvIs.No.18O dt: 01.07.1995 ond lo pass sach other orcler or
orders as this Hon'ble (:ourt nreA deems fit lrtst Gtrcl proper in the
circums tances of the case.."
3.
W.P.No.2983O of 2024, is filed under Artlcle 226 of t]ne
Constitution of India, with the following prayer:"....to issue anA wit order or direction one more pqrticulartg in the
nature of urit ol Mandamus, declaing the GO.lvIs.7 Transport,
Roads and buildings Department(TR SER) dt 28.01.2021
amending the Tetangana Transport Seruice Rules, 1993 issued in
GO. Ms. No. 1 8 0 T, R&B (Tr. ) {lepaft ilent dt. 0 1. O 7. I 9 94 am ending
the qualiJication requtred for promotion to the post of RTO from the
post of Administratiue off.cers and post of RTO are fi.lled in cycle
of 10 by direct recruitment, bA promotion frorn MVI ctnd B0S,
under the amended rules at cgcle of 10 onlg 2 uacancies ttre
altocated to AOs, Loithout constdering tlLe IVenTo dt 22.9.2OO8,
-)
uhereit it uas decided bg the Gouernment to allocate the 2
uocancies tn the ratio of 1:1 betueen the MVS Gnd AOs, tuithout
calling for objections from the effected candidqtes who ltaue been
appolnted in the feeder categoies of AOs os per the service rules
qnd rendered 25 37 gears of service, ultra uires to tlrc seruice
nales unconstitutional depriung the petitioners ight for .oromotion
to the post of RTO tuho houe put in long gears of seruices 35
illegal, ultra-vires and unconstitutional and consequentlA set
aside the GO.Ms 7 Transport, Roads and buitdings
Department(TR-SER) dt 28.01.2021 amending ttle'1'elangana
Transport Seruice Rules, 1993 issued in G.Ms.No.180 T,ReB!'r.l)
department dt. 01.07.1994 amending the qualification requtred
for promotion to the post of RTO from the post of Admi,tistratiue,
officers and an qllocation of the uacancies to the MVI; and AOs in
the unit of 1O as pe,r the Gouernment memo dt.22.9.20o8 pcss
such other order or orders as this Hon'ble Court deet,.s fit and
proper."
4.
Heard Sri P.Amarender, learned counsel for the petitioner in
W.P.No.272O9 of
2024; Ms. P.K.Kalyani, learned counsel
representing Sri Amancharla V.Gopala Rao, learned counsel for the
petitioners in W.P.No.29830 of 2024; Sri Santhapur Satyanarayana
Rao, learned Government Pleader for Services-I appearing for
respondent Nos. 1 to 3 in W.P.No.272O9 of 2024 and respondent
Nos.l and 2 in W.P.No.29830 of 2024; Sri G.Vidyra Sagar, learned
Senior Counsel representing Sri Sai Prasen Gundavaram, learned
counsel for respondent Nos.4 to 7 in W.p.No.27209 of 2024 arld
respondent Nos.3 to 6 in W.P.No.2983O of 2024; Sri D.Sudharshan,
learned counsel for respondent Nos.8 to 11 in W.p.No 27209 of 2024;
Sri Vijay B Paropakari, learned counsel for respondent No. 12 in
W.P.No.272O9 of 2024; Sri A.V.A.Siva Kartikeya, lear-red counsel for
respondent Nos.7 and 8 in W.P.No.2983O of 2024 and, perused the
record.
Histo
5.
and evo lution of the Transport Serice Rules
The Transport Department of the erstwhile State of Andhra
Pradesh and, thereafter, the State of Telangana, has been governed
by successive service rules framed under the proviso to Article 3O9 of
the Constitution of India. The relevant changes in the service rules
governing the post of RTO are set out hereunder:
i)
G.O.Ms.No.375,
dated 01.03.1967 (A.P. Transl:qll!
Service
Rules, 19671 The post of RTO was classified as Category 3.
The modes of appointment included direct recrurtment,
appointment from among Assistant Secretaries of State
Transport Authority (hereinafter referred to as the 'STA) and
recruitment by transfer from Motor Vehicle Inspectors
(hereinafter referred to as the 'MVIsJ, Superintendents of STA
and Section Ofhcers. Rule 3(d) prescribed a cycle of seven
vacancies with the vacancies being apportioned between MVIs
and Superintendents.
ii)
G.O.Ms.No.18, dated 01.02.1983 (A.P. Transpo rt Service Rules,
The
modes of
post of RTO was classilled as Category 4. The
appointment included
direct recruitment,
appointment by transfer to the post of RTO from MVIs and
recruitment by transfer from Superintendents of STA,
Superintendents of Subordinate Offices and Section Offrcers of
the Secretariat. Rule 3(d)(ii) prescribed a cycle of sever-t
)
vacancies, with vacancies being apportioned between MVIs and
Superintenden[s. The Superintenclents, w,]ro were nontechnical personnel, continued to have a legili;nate channel of
appointment by transfer to the post of R'lC, reflecting the
predominantly administrative character of thc RTO's functions.
iii)
G.O.Ms.No.180 , dated O1.O7.1994 (Telanqana State Transport
Service Rules, 1993) The A.P. Transport Service Rules, 1982
(hereinafter referred to as '1982 Rules') were superseded by the
said Rules. The post of RTO was classified as Category 4 and
the modes of appointment included diret.t recruitment,
appointment by transfer to the post of R'lO from MVIs
(Category 5), appointment by transfer of Administrative
Officers/Special Category Stenographers of STA, appointment
by transfer of Administrative Ofhcers (hereinaftcr referred to as
the 'AOsJ in the subordinate offices of the Transport
Department, and appointment by transfer of Se ;tion Ofhcers of
the Secretariat. Rule 3(b)(i) prescribed a cycle ol ten vacancies,
with vacancies carmarked for MVIs and AOs of the subordinate
olfices. Under the Annexure to Rule 5, the qualification
prescribed for the post of RTO, inter alio, was .tossession of a
degree of a University in India established or incorporated by
or under a Central Act or a State Act, or any equivalent
qualihcation.
iv)
G O.Ms.No.183
dated
08.09.1999: It is issued without
amending the statutory service rules. It altered the cycle of
vacancies by reducing the quota earmarked for
AOs/ Superintendents and correspondingly increasing the
quota for MVIs. Under the revised cycle of ten vacancies, five
vacancies were earmarked for MVIs and one vacancy for
AOs/ Superintendents. The said G.O. was challenged by the
Superintendents before the Andhra Pradesh Administrative
Tribunal (hereafter referred to as the APAT') in O A Nos'5584
and 5662 of 1999, inter alia, on the ground that an executive
instruction could not override the statutory service rules
framed under Article 309 of the Constitution of India'
v)
Order of the APAT dated 17.11.2O00: The APAT set aside
G.O.Ms.No.183, dated 08.09.1999, holding, inter alia, that an
executive instruction could not override the statutory service
rules framed under Article 309 of the Constitution of India'
The Tribunal further observed that the statutory rules would
continue to operate until duly amended'
6.
The record further indicates that under the pre-amended
Rules,AOsofthesubordinateofficesoftheTransportDepartment
had a channel of appointment by transfer to the post of RTO and no
technical qualification in Mechanical Engineering or Automobile
Engineering was prescribed for such AOs The petitioners contend
that this position continued for about 46 years, until the amendment
introduced by G.O.Ms.No.7, dated 2A.Ol.2O2t.
7.
On 28.O1.2O21, the State Government issued impugned
G.O.Ms.No.7, Transport, Roads & Buildings Departr-rent, amending
the Telangana State Transport Service Rules, 19!3. The salient
features of the Impugned G.O. are:
i)
Under the amended Rules, the post of RTO u,ar; re-categorized
as Category 3.
ii)
Rule 3(b) prescribed a cycle of ten vacancies for apporntment to
the said post, vrhich are as follows:
The amendment as per the impugned G.O. is as under
ln nie 3,
(i) irt sub-ntle (a), for the table thereunder, the follotling shall be substituted.,
namelA,-
Cate
(1)
(1)Joint transport
cotnmtsStoner
(2) Deputg Transport
Commissioner
(3) Regional Transport
Olficers
(4) Assistant Secretary tn the
ofrtce of the Transport
Co mmrs sto ner, H g de rab ad
(HoD)
(5) Motor VehrcLes Inspector.
Method of Appointment
Bg promotion from c egory
Deputy Transpo rt Comnissioner
2 i.e.,
t) Bg promotion from ccfiegory - 3 i.e.,
R e gtonal Transport Off.c e r
i) bg promotton Jiotn category 4
Assistant Secretanes u'trking tn the olfice
of the Transport Commi.;sioner in the ratio
of 24:1 i.e., in aunit of .25 uacancies 1n to
24tt, uacancies shetl be filled up bg
category - 3 qnd 25th uacancg shall be
flLed up bg category -1.
r) Bg direct recruitmetlt.
h) Bg promotion from category - S i.e.,
Motor Vehtctes Inspectot. and category - g
i.e., Admintstratiue offi.cer tuorking in the
Distict offces.
Bg promotion from the cqtegory 7 i.e.,
Admintstratiue Offi.cers uorking n the
O/ o the Transport Comnissioner (HoD)
BlJ Promotion from tlrc Category - 6 i.e.,
Assistanl Motor Vehicles Inspector(6,) Assrsrant Motor Vehicles
Inspector.
(
7) Admini stratiu e Olficer
uorking in HoD.
q BV Dtrect RecruitmenL
i bg appointment bll transkr from the
cintegory of Transport Head Constable of
Transport Department.
BA appointment b! lransfer from the
category oJ Sentor Assistcnt rn ?.S.
Mnisterial Seruice uorking in the O/ o
Transp ort Co mmi s sioner (H O D ).
Administratiue Olficer
uorking in Dstrict Olfces
( 8)
BA appointment bg transkr from the
category of Senior Assistcnf in TS'
Ministeriat Seruice uorking in subordinate
olfices of the resPectiue Zones.
Prouided that in the cose oJf Assistant Motor Vehicte Inspectors 95?'l' of the
bg direct
cc.d.re strength in the respectiue 2on s shatt be reserued to be ftled
bg
transkr
recruitmentLnd 5o/" of the-cadre strength shall be filled bg apPotntmen't
pottlt
20d'
point
euery
cAcle'
the category of Transport Head- Constables in 1OO
-from
shcrlt be eamdrked to Transporl Head Constables'
AJter sub-ruIe (a) the follotuing sub ntle shall be inserted' namelg'
(it
(b) Appointment bg direct recruitment cLtld bg promotion to tlle
category of Regional' Transport Officers sho.tt be mqde in a unit of (1O) uacancies
which shall be substituted as follorus:"
m the cat
romoton rom the cat
Direct Recruitment
B ro m o 10 n ro m t tle cq te
B
1! Vacan
2,d
4tt, VocAnC
Sth Vacancy
romotion
o Moto r Vehicles Ins
o Motor Vehlcles In
r.
ct or
o Mo o r Ve h c LeS I
of
calegory
the
trqnsJer
Bg appointment bg
from
of
Transport
ofJices
Distict
in
working
Administratiue Officer
De artment
m the cat
romotion
Direct Recruitment
ryof Motor VehicLes Inspector.
6th Vac
B
Vh Vaca
Bg appointment bg transkr from the category of
8t VacqncA
9tt, vac
10n' Vacancg
Ad.ministtatiue Officer utorking m Distict ofJices of TransPorl
artment
ector.
o o Motor Vehicles
romoton rom the c
made
against
hall
be
s
(Dtrect
recruitment
Recruitment
Direct
onl
ncies
vacq
subsldnttue
post of
Note: If no technicallg quaLirted person is found elig-ible for the saidofficer
in
iegionat Tronsfoi Ofice, irom the category of Admrnistrative
Di;tnd Office, ot on ilh. date of DPC, the uacant point shall be fitled frorn
the category of Motor Vehicle Inspector."
iii)TheAnnexuretoRule5prescribedthefollowingqualifications
for appointment by transfer from Category 8 (AOs working in
District Offices):
For ntLe 5, the foltowing shalt be substttuted, namelg, -
"5. Qualification: No person shql| be etigible for appotntment to the, categories
spectfied in column (1) bg the method speciied in column (2) untess he/ she
posse-sses the qua\rtcations spectfi.ed in the corresponding entru n column (3) to the
Annenlre to Rule 5 thereof."
ANNEXURE
(See RuLe 5)
Ito G.O.Ms.No.7, Trqnsoort. R&B [Tr. Serl Depqrtment, dt.28 01.2O21)
Name of the post
Method of
appotntment
(1)
(2)
Joint
QuaLificatlon
By promotion I{o person shall be eligible for
from category 2 appointment unLess he/ she has serued
for o mrnrmum peiocl c I lhree Vears in
RTA, Hgderabad
the category 2 i.e., DTC
Transport
Commissroner
(inctuding Secretory
and
Secretary,
STA, H derabad.
DeputA Transport Bg promotion
Commisstoner
from category 3
& 4 i.e., RTO &
Asst. Secy., ln
HoD.
Regtonat Tronsport BA
direct
OlJicer. (lncluding recrutlment
Assisrant Secretary
RTAs.)
BA
Promotion
No person shaLl bz eligibte fo,
appotntmenl unless i re,/ she hc.s serued
for o minimum penocl of three gears in
the categoies oJ 3 & I i e., RTO & Asst.,
Secret
in HoD
Must hotd a degree in Mechq.nical
Engineering or Automobi e Engtneeing or
quoLrfcalion (fa Uniuersilg in
"qutuolenl
Indaa
established or incorporated bg or
under a Central Act or a Prouincial Act or
a State Act or Institution recognized bg
the Untuersi Grants Co nmission UGC
No person sholL b,: etigible for
from category 5 appointment unless he/ she has serued
) i.e., I\IVI
for a minimum peiod or rhre" geors in
Br
the cat
qDDointment
bu
trclrsfer
from categortt
8 i.e. A.O.
toorkinq
Dlst.. Office
5 i.e., IvtVI.
l) No person sha,ll l,e eligible for
aBpolntment ualess he/she has
sen)ed fo" a minl'Irum period of three
uears ln the cateoor I i.e. A.O.
uorklno ln Dist., Office.
in lll No Derson shall lre elisible for
aDDolntment to the sqid post, unless
he/she Dossess c, d.eeree in
Mechanical
Ens tv-eerlnq
or
Automobile Ens tneeranq
or
qualificotion
eoulva.le,tt
of a.
Unluersltu ln lndia p.stablished. or
lncotDorated bg or ur.'.d.er a Cent"al
Act or a Provincial Act or a State Act
or Instltution recoan tZed bu the
Unluersltu Grants Comrnission.
OR
Dioloma I n Automobile Enqineeri nq
btt 4n1J l7-stitutio7.
auard.ed
l0
the
Centrdl
bu
fecog^ized
nt
Gouernment o" Stdte
appro led bu the AICTE, Neut Delhi.
(E'lLptlzsis supplied)
By
Promotion iVo persorl shall be eligibLe for
6 appointnrcnt utless lte/ she has serued
Category
from
i.e., AMVI
for a ntinimum period of three Aears itt
6 i.e., AMVI
the cat
dtrect (i) Must hold a degree in Mechanical
Assist0al Motor Bg
Automobile
Engineeing or
recruitmeftt
VehicLes Inspector
equiualent
or
Engiteeing
qtalification of o Uruuersitg itt Indla
established or incorporated bg or
under o Central Act or a Prouincial
Act or a State Act or Institution
recognized bg the Uniuersitg Grants
Commission (UGC).
Motor
Inspector
Vehicles
OR
Must hold a Diploma in Automobile
Engineering (3
gears course)
autqrded b1t qnA institution
recognized by the Central
Gouernment or State Gouemment
approued bU the AICTE Neu) Delht.
And
(ii) Must hotd a ualid Diuing License
authorized to driue HeavA Motor
Vetucles (Tra nsport Vehicles. )
BA appointment Must hold a degree itt Mechanical
bg transfer from Engineenng or Automobile Dngineeing or
the category oJ equiualent quatification of a Uniuersitg in
TransporT Head India estctblished or incorporated bg or
Constables of under a Centrol Act or a Prouincial Act or
a State Act or Institution recognized by
Transport
Depqrtment
the Uniuersity Granats Commission (UGC).
OR
Must hold a Diploma in Automobile
Dngineeing (3 gears course) awarded bg
ang institution recogntzed bg the Central
Gouemment or State Gouernment
approved lcg the AICTE New Dethi.
And
Must hold a ualid Driuing Ltcense
authorized to driue HequlJ Motor Vehicles
(Transport Vehicles.)
And
passed Transport
haue
t) Must
De atlment Te* Part t and Part II.
II
Administratiue
Bg appointment
olficer category - 7 bg transfer from
&8
the cqtegory or
Senior Assistant
oJ Ministenql
Serutces of the
respectiue HoD
and
district
offices
re ecttvel
ir)
ii) Accounts Test for )ixe cutiue Olficers or
Accounts Test for the Subordinate
o cers Part I and Palt ,1.
Must haue passed
i)
Transport Deparlrrt'nt Test Part - I
qnd Parl IL
it) it) Accounts Tesl for Executiue
Olfi.cers or Acc()Lr ts Test for the
Subordinate Offt'er; Part-l and Parl-
II
The albresaid amendment, insofar as it prescr.bes a technical
qualification for AOs, constitutes a departlrrr from the preamended Rules, under which no such technioal qualification
had been prescribed for the said feeder category for about 46
years.
Case of the petitioners
8.
The petitioner in W.P.No.27209 of 2024 \4'as inirially appoinred
as a Junior Assistant on 16.O3.1996, promoted as S,enior Assistant
in 2OO3 and thereafter as AO on 13.O5.2O13, and claims to be the
senior-most eligible AO for appointment to the post of RTO under the
pre-amended Rules. Petitioner claims that he is entitled to be
considered for promotion in Roster Point No.62 meant for Scheduled
Castes (SCs), in the vacancy that arose during the Pznel Year 20l92O2O, as per the Rules then in force.
9.
The petitioners in W.P.No.29830 of 2024 are lrOs working in
various offices of the Transport Department and c laim to have
rendered between 25 and 37 years of service. Tht: s;aid petitioners
t2
challenge the Impugned G.O. principally on the ground that the
prescription of a technical qualification has rendered them ineligible
for consideration for appointment to the post of RTO.
10. It is also the case of the petitioners that the Impugned G O is
arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India, inter alia, on the following grounds:
i) That the amendment was introduced without notice to, or an
opportunity of hearing being alforded to, the affected AOs;
ii) That the amended Rules altered the distribution of vacancies
in favour of MVIs and reduced the promotional opportunities
available to AOs;
iii) That a technical qualification was prescribed for AOs for the
first time, despite no such qualihcation having been prescribed
under the earlier Rules;
irr) That the prescription of sttch qualihcation by the State
Government is contrary to Section 213(a) of the MV Act, 1988,
under which the power to prescribe minimum qualihcations for
officers of the Motor Vehicles Department vests with the
Central Government;
v) That the amendment defeats their legitimate expectation of
being considered for appoin[ment to the post of RTO under the
pre amended Rules; and
ll
vi) That, in the absence of a technically qualified Administrative
Officer, the vacancy earmarked for the Admin jstrative Officer
category is liable to be filled by an MVI, thereby further
restrrcting the promotional avenue of AOs.
11. The petitioners also rely upon a subsequcn. letter of the
Transport Commissioner dated 02.O3.2024 addressed to the
Government, wherein restora[ion of the qualihcation prescribed
under the pre-amended Rules was recommended. A<'cordrng to the
petitioners, the Transport Commissioner observed thzrt the duties of
an RTO are predominantly administrative in nature and
recommended restoration of the qualification of a Bar:helor's Degree
in place of the technical qualihcation introduced by the Impugned
G.O. The relevant portion of the said letter is extracted hereunder:
The bqs[c educatrcn qualification for the post of RTO ettht'r by Direct
Recruitment or appointment bg transfer from the feeder cetegory in
Andhra Prqdesh and ltlaharashrra ts Degree from recognized
uniuersities. The post of RTO fatls under State Ciutl Seruic.:s qnd it is
equiuatent to the post of Deputg Cotlector dnd DeputA Supeintendent
of Police.form administratto\ point of uteu'.
It is furllrcr itformed llol bctsicallg the post of RTO Jurt:hons cts a
senior Admiristrator atld $ nore related to AdmtnistrqtiotL work and
on gairing expenence and senioritg, lheg can gai technical
knowLedge. Also, they cre cssisted bV executiue staff (Mo or Vehrcles
Inspector arrd Asslsta,ll Motor Vehicles Inspector) Luho are technicallA
quatified qnd there is no necessily for technical qualificc,tion to the
post of RegionaL Transport Officer in the Department.
Earlier, Ln the G.O.Ms.No.l8O. TR&B (Tr.l) Dept., dated O1.(t7.1994 the
basic quatificatton for lhe post of RTO bg Direct Rectuttntent is o
Degree/ Graduation in any discipline.
Bestdes direct recruitment, the post of INTO is flled up bg uta14 of
promotion front the feeder category of Administratiue OfJtcers of the
Departnrcnt LUho aLso do aot possess anA techrucal qualifcation. The
quallfi.cation as prescribed in G.O.Ms.No.180 TR&B [r.l) D,'_pt., dated:
01.07.1994 maq be restored.
ln uietu of tlle aboue, Gout. may take a decision or the request of
Groud I Aspirant and cornmunicate orders, tf ary1 in this ree,ud.
t4
12. Thereafter, the respondents have issued provisional seniority
lists of AOs, and objections submitted by some of the petitioners are
stated to be pending consideration. The petitioners apprehend that
the Departmental Promotion Commrttee (hereinafter referred to as
the 'DPC') may proceed \r"'ith the process of appointment to lhe post
of RTO under the Impugned Rules without finalisation of the
seniority list, which is arbitrary and contrary to the prescribed
procedure, as seniority is a relevant factor in determining eligibility
and consideration for appointment.
Submissio ns on behalf of the petitione'E
13. Learned counsel for the petitioners in both the writ petitions,
have advanced the following submissions:
i) That Section 213(41 of the MV Act, 1988 specihcally ernpowers
the Central Government, having regard to the objects of the
Act and, by notihcation in the Official Gazelte, to prescribe the
minimum qualifications to be possessed by oflicers of the
Motor Vehicles Department or any class thereof for being
appointed as such. According to learned counsel, no
corresponding power is conferred upon the State Government
under the said provision.
ii) That the power conferred upon the State Government under
Section 2 13( 1) to appoint such ofltcers 'as it thinks fit' cannot
be construed as including the power to prescribe their
qualifications. The pou,er of appointment anrl the power to
prescribe qualifications are drstinct, and I)arliament has
consciousl),vested the latter power in the Central Government
under Section 213(4). The State Government, r.herefore, could
not have prescribed an additional technical c ualification for
appointment to the post of RTO.
ii|
That the Central Government, by Notihcation S.O.No.443(E),
dated 12.06.1989, prescribed minimum qualifications for the
category ol MVI and AMVI. The said Notification was
subsequently amended by S.O.No.3O1(E), dat<:d 29.O4.7gg7,
which specifically provided that nothing con tained therein
would apply to an officer appointed to discharge functions of a
non-technical nature.
iv) That the Central Government, by Notification S.O.No.1215(tr),
dated 08.03.2019, again amended the 1989 Notification, but
even the amended Notification does not .trescribe any
qualifir;ation for the post of RTO and continues to prescribe
qualifications only for MVI and AMVI.
v) That the State (iovernment, by placing reliance on the orders
of the Ministry of Road Transport and Highr".ays (MoRTH)
dated 21.O7 .2023 is proposing to prescri te minimum
qualtfications for direct recruitment to the post of RTO. It
is
contended that the proposal of MoRTH has not been given
effect to and, in any event, relates only to direct recruitment
and does not prescribe an-v* qtralihcation for appointment by
transfer.
vi) That the Impugned G.O. creates an unreasonable classification
between MVIs and AOs. While MVIs, who are already required
to possess technical qualihcations, have been provided five
vacancies in a cycle of ten vacancies, AOs have been provided
only two vacancies. According to learned counsel, there is no
rational basis for such classification having regard to the
nature of the duties attached to the post of RTO.
vii) That the Impugned G.C)- substantially curtails the promotional
avenue available to AOs, which had existed under the pre-
amended Rules for about 46 years. According to learned
counsel, the amendment defeats the iegitinate expectation of
the petitioners to be considered for appointment to the post of
RTO in accordance with the pre-arnended Rules.
viii) That the petitioners have rendered between 25 and 37 years of
service and are now above 50 years of age. The prescription of
a new technical qualification at this stage effectively excludes
the existing AOs from consideration for appointment to the
post of RTO and results in stagnation in service.
t7
ix) That the State, as a model employer, is required to adopt a fair
and non discriminatory approach towards its employees.
According to learned counsel, the differential treatment
accorded to AOs uis-a-uis MVIs under the InLpugned G.O. is
unsupported by any reasonable justihcation.
x) That thc minutes of the meeting of the Supreme Court
Committee on Road Safet-v dated O2.O7.2O)9 relied upon by
the respondents in support of the Impugned G.O., do not
contain any direction to prescribe technical c ualillcations lor
AOs lor appointment to the post of RTO. According to learned
counsel, the minutes record the submission of MoRTH that
technical qualifications had already been prescribed at the
lower management level, namely, for MVIs, rrnd that at the
middle management level there was no di;'ect entry and,
therefore, no requirement to prescribe technic:Ll qualifications.
The Committee, according to iearned c tunsel, merellr
requested the Secretary, MoRTH, to examint, the matter in
greater detail.
xi) That neither the Supreme Court Committee on Road Safety nor
MoRTH had directed or advised the State Government to
prescribe a technical qualification for AOs for appointment to
the post of RTO. The reliance placed upon the said minutes to
justify thc Impugned G.O.is therefore misplacec.
l8
xii) That the functions discharged by RTOs under the MV Act,
1988 are predominantiy administratrve and do not require
specialised technical qualilications. In support of the
submission, Iearned counsel referred to the various Chapters
of the MV Act and contended as follou's:
a. Chapter II - Licensing: Except for the conduct of driving
tests, the functions under this Chapter are essentially
administrative. It was further submitted that the State
Government is establishing Automated Scientific Driving
Test Centres and that Learner's Licence tests have
already been made online.
b. Chapter IV - Registration: Except for lunctions involving
inspection of vehicles for registratiorr, renewal of
registration and issuance/ renewal of fitness certihcates,
the functions under this Chapter do not, according to
learned counsel, require specialised technical knowledge.
It was further submitted that Automated Testing
Stations are being established and the testing function is
being entrusted to such agencies.
c. Chapter V - Control of_Transport Vehicles: This Chapter
principally concerns the issuance of permits, which,
according to learned counsel, is administrative in
nature. The powers under this Chapter are vested in the
I9
Regional Transport Authority, chaired by the District
Collector
d. Chapter VII - Construction, Equipment and Maintenance
of Motor Vehicles: Learned counsel submitted that the
technical aspects covered by this Chapter are dealt with
by testing agencies such as The Autonrotive Research
Association of India (hereinafter referred _o as the ARAI,)
and Central Institute of Road Transprrt (hereinafter
referred to as the .CIRT,).
e. Chapter VIII - Control of Traffic: Learned counsel
submitted that traffic regulation and road safety are
dealt with by both the police and Transport Deparrments
at the lou'er levels, and that there is no re,luirement for a
technical qualihcation at the level of RTO for such
functions.
xiii) The learncd counsel also placed reliance on
the
recommendations of a Committee constituted br the Transport
Commissioner in 2O06 and submitted that rhe Committee had
concluded that, so far as the Transport Department was
concerned, technical work ended at the level of the AMVI
and
MVI cadres and that there was no need for ter:hnical cadres
beyond the MVI level.
xiv) That the Impugned G.O. was isstrecl rvithout
notlce to,
opportunity of hearing being afforclecl to, the
like1y to be prejudicially affected by
or an
AOs who were
the introduction of the new
qualifrcation. According to iearned counsel,
the amendment
substantially diminished their existing promotional
avenue
and, therefore, ought not to have been introduced
without
considering their interests.
xv) That the AOs had a legitimate expectation of being
for appointment to the post of RTO under the
Rules, under which such avenlte had been
considered
pre_amended
available for several
decades
xvi) In support of their case, learned counsel relied
upon the
following decisions:
a. Naujgoti Coop. Group Housing Societg u.
Union of
Indial (P aragraph s 15 and 16),
b' Food Corporation of India u. Karndherut cattre
Feecr
Industries2 (paragraphs 7 and g)
c. S. Pratap Singh u. State of punjab.3 (paragraphs 9 and
d. P.D.Agganual and others u. State ol U.^e and_ 10)
otherd
(Paragraphs 16 and 18)
Submissio n s on behalf of the resDo ndents
14.
Learned Government pleader for Services
respondents and learned Senior Counsel
respondents have advancecl the following
t(1992) 1 SCC 477
,(1993) 1 SCC 71
]AIR 1964 SC 72
,(1987t 3 SCC 622
appearing for official
appearing for private
submissrons
)l
of the
i) That the State Government is competent' in exercise
power under the proviso to Article 3O9 of the
Constitution of
and conditions of
India, to make ruies regulating recruitment
service of persons appointed to public services
connection with the affairs of the State
and posts in
such rule-making
power necessarily includes the power to
qualihcations for appointment to a particular
prescribe
post'
u'
ill That the Hon'ble Supreme Court in S' Satgapa'l Reddg
Goaernrnent of Andhra Pradeshs ' held that
the power of the
State Government to appoint suitable officers
includes the
po$,er to prescribe qualifications for such aPPo.ntment.
The
the
Central Government, under Section 213(4), Plescribes
ts
minimum qualifications, whereas the State Grlvernment
to prescribe qualifrcations which are higher than
competent
such minimum qualifications'
iii)
ThattheStateGovernmentbyprescribi;rgtechnical
qualifications for Aos, has merely presc ribed higher
qualihcations than the 'Degree of a Universi -y'
prescribed
earlier, which is clearly permissible in law'
iu) The Supreme Court Committee on Road Safetv' in
dated, O2.O7.2019, observed that 'if
'119941 4 SCC 391
its minutes
is importa nt that officers at
the middle monagement leuel like ARTOs artd RTOs should haue
technical qualifications' and requested the Secretary, MoRTH,
to examine the matter in greater detail. In furtherance of the
said policy consideration, the Government of Telangana
amended the qualification for appointment to the post of RTO
by replacing the earlier requirement of 'Degree of a University'
with the prescribed technical qualiflcatlon, having regard to
technical competence, road safety and efficient administration
of the Transport Department.
v) That the policy rationale for such technical qualification is
further supported by the MoRTH proposal dated 21.07.2023,
prescribing, for direct recruitment to the posts of
RTOi ARTO/District RTO, a degree in Automobile trngineerlng
or Mechanical Engineering. Though the said proposal relates to
direct recruitment, it reinforces the continuing policy emphasis
on technical qualihcations for officers at the middlemanagement level in Motor Vehicles Departments.
vi) That the classification made between MVI and AOs is founded
upon an intelligible differentia. MVIs constitute a technical and
enforcement-oriented feeder category in respect of which
technical qualifications are prescribed, whereas AOs constitute
a ministerial/ administrative feeder category in respect of which
the pre-amendment rules did not prescribe such technical
qualifications.
vii) That the MVIs are numerically more in number, and therefore,
they are given more slots in the cycle of 10 vztczrncies. The AOs
are given 2 s1ots, q'hich is a reasonable allocation based on the
cadre strength.
viii) That the note added to Rule 3(b) that n'here no technically
qualified person is available from the categ()ry of AO, the
concerned vacancy may be filled from the category of MVI, is a
pragmatic provision intended to ensure that a vacancy in the
higher post is not left unhlled and that the post is occupied by
a person possessing the requisite technical com-)etence.
i*) That the petitioners do not possess a vested or zLccrued right to
promotion to the post of RTO under the unarnended service
ru1es. At the highest, they possess a right to be considered for
promotion in accordance rvith the service rule:; applicable on
the date on which such consideration is undertaken.
x) That the rules having been amended, the petitioners must now
possess the technical qualifications prescribed tr be eligible for
promotion. The Doctrine of Legitimate Expectaiion cannot be
invoked to deleat a policy decisron taken in the public interest.
E-
xi) That the Central Government Notifications S.O.No.aa3(E),
dated 12.06. 1989, and S.O.No.1215(E), dated 08.03.2019,
prescribe minimum technica.l qualifications for the posts
MVIs
and AMVIs. The prescription of such technicai qualihcations
for officers in the Motor Vehicles Department supports the
policy rationale for requiring technical competence at higher
levels of the Department, including the post of RTO.
xii) That the note contained in S.O.No.3Ol(E), dated 29.O4.Iggt,
excluding an officer appointed to discharge functions of a ,non_
technical nature,, cannot be construed as prohibiting the Stare
Government fron-r prescribing technical qualifications for the
post of RTO
xiii) That the introduction of technical qualifications for
appointment to the post of RTO is in the larger public interest
and is intended to promote road safety and the efficient
implementation of the provisions of the MV Act, 19gg. It is
submitted that the Hon,ble Supreme Court has taken serious
note of the problem of road accidents and has issued various
directions and measures aimed at irnproving road safety.
xiv) That the State Government, in exercise o[ its constitutional
and statutory rule-making powers, is compe tent to amend the
recruitment rules and prescribe appropriate qualifications
for
the
public employment The petitioners cannot challenge
affected their
amendment merely on the ground that it ha;
promotional prospects, particularly when no vested right
to
promotion under the unamended rules is theretrv infringed'
ls.Wehavetakennoteoftherespectivesubmissionsurgedand
perused the material on record'
Considerati onb vt his Court
State Government's Power to Prescribe Higher Qualifications
under Section 21311f and Article 3O9
16. The statutory framework governing the ilp.)ointment and
regulation of officers provided in Section 213 of the
MV Act' 1988'
which is central to the present adjudication, is set out belor'r':
ofJicers" (1' The State
273. Appointment of motor aehicles inio
efkct lhe prouisions of
Gouernment mag, for the purPose of carrytng
,"it- ert,- "rr"ariti o Motor iehicte' DtpL't^"nt and appoi Lt as officers
thereof such persons as it thinks fit'
lhe
(2) Eue:ry srtch offtcer shall be deerned to be a pubhc' s€n\lnt Loiltlitl
meaning oflhe tndian Penal Code (45 of 1860)'
bg
(3) The Strltc Goventment mag make ntles to -regulate-the dtscharqe
officersoflheMotorV<:hrclesDepartmeltoftheirfunciiottsandin
poLuer to
to tie generatitg oJ the foreg)ing
\'"'ii*t"i ""i' ,"ithiut p,qud'crwhich theA
'pr""rnt
the uniform io i. *o'n bg tiem, the ou-thonties l)
t-hetn the powers
t,." suborclitate, the cluties to be perfonned bg
be
ih" po..r, exercisabte bg police officers u.ndet tlLis Act) tosuch
i;,;;i;;;rg
of
clse
exet
';;;;;;;e; bg in
"iitt
and tlrc condiliins goueming the
powefs.
^,
to.the obiects of the
(4) TlLe
' Cetttrol Goventmcnt mag, hawrtg regord
t\e muimum
prescibe
Aozette'
Act,"by ttotrfrcation in the Official
, possess
'i'otiri"tro,ri
shatl
thereof
any
clcss
o'
the soid o|ii"'"
'for
",ntch
being appointed as such.
the
(5) l odditiotL to the pou'ers that noll be conferred on anE offcer of
mag be
Vehtcles Deporlment under sub section (3)' such office r as
Motor
'."ipt-*"a
the
hcute
bg tl;e Stlte Gouernment in this behalf shqlL also
pouer to,
(a) make such exdmirTqtion and itquiry as he lhinks fit in order to
ascertann u)hether ttle prouisions of this Act and the rules made
thereunder are beirtg obserued;
(b) u,ith such assistance, if anA, as he thinks fit' enter, inspect and
search ang premises rt'thich is in the ocqtpation of a person uhq he
has reasoilo belieue, has comnLitted an offence under this Act or in
uhtch ct motor uehicle in respect of uhich srtch offence has been
committed is kept:
Proutded that,
(i) ang such search utithout o luarrant shall be made onlg bg an
officer of the ronk of a gazetted olficer;
(ri) where the offence is punishable uith fine onl!/ th"' search shatL not
be made after sunset and before sunise;
(iii) where the search is made u'ithout a Luarrarlt, the gazetted offi'cer
concemecl shall record in utiling the grounds for not obtaining o
warrant and report to his immecliate supeior that such search
hos been made;
(c) examine onlJ person and require the prcduction of anA register or
otlrcr d.ocuieit maittained it pursrtatrce oJ this Act, culd take on the
spot or otheru'ise st(ltetnents of ang persorL Luhtch he mag cortsider
necessary for carrying out the purposes of this Act;
(d) seize or take copies o.f ang registers or documents or portions thereof
as te mag coisider releuant in respect oJ an offence under thts Act
ll)hich he has reason to belieue h(].s been committed;
qnd to
(e) launch prosecutions in respect of ang offence wtder this Act
take a bond for ensuring the attendance of the offetder be-fore antg
Courl;
(fl exercise such other pouters as maU be prescibed:
Prouided that no Person shttll be compeLled utlder this sub-section to
answer anA question or moke anA statement tenditg to incriminate
himself.
(6) The prouisions of the Code of Crimrnal Procedure, 1973 (2 of
1974j shatt, so far as may be apply to qnA search or se'irue under this
section os they appty to ang searclT or seizure under the authoritg of ang
Luarrant issued under Section 94 of thqt Code'
17. A harmonious reading of the said Section 213 discloses that
the provision confers distinct pou'ers Llpon thc State Government
and the Central Government. Under sub section (1), the State
Government is empowered to establish the Motor Vehrcles
Department and appoint as officers thereof such persons 'as it thinks
fit'. rJnd.er sub-section (3), it is empowered to regulate the discharge
of functions by such officers. Under sub-section (:l), the Centrai
Government is empowered to prescribe the minimutn qualifications
which the officers or any class thereof sha11 possess fcr appointment.
18. The expression 'minimum quolifi.cation' employe<l in sub-section
(4) assumes signihcance. The provision cannot br. construed as
excluding the State Government's power to prescribe qualifications
higher than the minimum prescribed by the Centrirl Government.
The Hon'ble Supreme Court in S. Satgapal Red.dgis case (supra 5),
has held that the por,ver of appointment under Section 213(1)
includes the po.",,.er to prescribe qualifications for se lecting suitable
officers and that the State Government may prescribe higher
qualifications, provided that it does not prescribe qua. ifications lower
than those prescribed by the Central Government.
19.
Such an interpretation gives harmonious effect [o sub-sections
(1) and (4) of Section 213. The Central Government prescntres the
minimum qualification having regard to the objects of the Act,
whereas the State Government, in exercise of its power to appoint
officers and its rule-making power under the proviso tt Article 309 of
the Constitution, may prescribe higher qualifications having regard
to the requirements of its service and the nature of the post
concerned.
20.
Reddgls
The respondents have placed reliance on S' Satgapal
(supra 5) contending that the State Government is competent
prescribe qualifications higher than those prescribed by the
Government under Section 213(4\ of the MV Act, 1988' and
Central
has held
as under:
or
e-ld
has
to
the
to
t
het
-s
t
that motter" Repugnqncg a"ises when both the
u)o
e and u,hen it
larus are fullg inconsistent or are ab sotutelg ire concilabl
to obelt one wit hout disobeAing the other. The
l-s impossible
uhett
repugnancg uould aise tuhen conflicting results are Produced
gtuen
set oJ
a
to
both the statutes couenng ihe same fietd are applied
th'e
reconcile
to
attempt
euery
fqcts. Bltt the court hc.s to make
would
court
and
Iews
provisions of the app\rentlA cortfltcting
to detemine
endeauottr to Eue hannonious co nstmcto n. The purpose
would
uhich
Parliament
of
intention
inconsistency is to ascertain the
the
bg
occupied
entire
of
the
field
be gathered from d consideratiotl
the
to
giuen
be
co.ft
elfect
uthether
be
law. The proPer test uould
stand
prouisions of both the laws or whether both the laus can
powers
together. Section 213 itself macle the distinction of the
tn
Gouernment
exercisable bg the State Gouefltment and the Central
thqt
ment
Gouern
utorking the Prouisiotts of the Act. It is the Stote
h it s officers The refore.
ns oft he Act
S
op
to
to he
AS
o
ond
Bu nece
the Do
n t4) t
to
nt
ral
nt. Whctt utas do ne bu the
NS
Gouernment was onl the rescn trcn o mtnlnilqL
med t rescibe i
to the State Go t)ernment co
o
leavi tlrc
uen
NS The Gouemo r has been
hi her
neces
it
to
an
ect
sub
he
Constitutio
otuer und.er rouso to Anicle 309 o t
the
tature to make rules
the Stote
ktu.t
ons
for
oualificati
pre
of
on
scnpli
recntitment whic h inctude s
rl
Trans
the
Since
State.
the
ost
under
or
ointment to an o
and
rnment
Goue
he
State
b
ted
Dep drtment under t hr. Act is constitu
to the State seruice, uhile
he officers opDointed to tho se oosts beLo
a nece SSAru
app ointinq its ou) n officers he State Gouentment o,s
itment or
recru
ifications fo r
adnt nct rs entitled, to Dre
Gouernmettt
condihon s of se rulce. But while so n rescribin o. the State
the Motor
n but in no
mo accep t the qu alifictttio ns or prescribe h10 her a Iifrcatio
rescnbed
qu
nsp
alificatto
case DTCS cibe anu qu ctLification less than the
o the
r
Sectio
o
he Cen trol Gouernmen t under sub-section
b
the
both
ns,
quattficatio
prescibing
lesser
i.e.,
Act. In the latter euent,
l9
rules catuTot operate without colliding with each other. WLen the rules
mqde bA the Central Gouernment undet Section 2134) and the
statutory rules made under prouiso b Article 3O9 of the C:onstitutton
are constnled lutmroniouslA, there is no incompatibititlJ or
inconsistencg tn the operation of both the rules to appoint ,1t persons to
the posts or class of officers of the State Gouernment uis-a-uis the
qualifications prescribed bg the Central Government unde" sub-section
(4) of Sectiort 2 13 of the Act.
(Emphasis supplied)
21. It is pertinent to note that the aforesaid decision must be
considered in the context in which it was rendered. In S.SctyapaI
Reddg's case (supra 5), the challenge concerned the prescription ofa
Degree in Mechanical trngineering by the State (iovernment for
appointment as AMVI, whereas the Central Government had
prescribed a Diploma in Mechanical Engineering ar; the minimum
qualification for that ciass of officers. The Hon'b1e Supreme Court
upheld the State Government's prescription of the higher
quahhcation and held that the power of appointmen. under Section
213(i) includes the power to prescribe qualifications for selecting
suitable officers, subject to the minimum qualificatio-r prescnbed by
the Central Government. However, the position in the present case
is materially different. The Central Government Notrfications relied
upon by the respondents, namely S.O.No.443(tr), dated 12.06.1989,
S.O.No.301(tr), dated 29.O4.1991, and S.O.No.121S(tr), dated
08.03.2019, prescribe qualifications in respect of the category of
MVI/AMVI and does not prescribe any qualihcation lbr the RTOs.
Therefore, the present case, does not involve the enhirncement of an
existing minimum qualification prescribed by the Central
l0
Government applicable to the post of RTO. The similar situation did
not exi.st in the case of S. S,o:tgc,Pal Red.dg's case (supra 5). The
State Government in the case of S. Satgapal Reddg (supra 5)
prescribed a higher qualification of Degree in Mechanical
Engineering in the place oI the Diploma in Mechanical Engineering
prescribed as the minimum qualification by the Central Government.
22. The distinction is material because the validiq- of the
impugned qualiltcation must be examined having regard to the
nature and functions of the post of RTO, the statutory scheme
governing the Motor Vehicles Department, and the basis on which
the State Government has considered a Degree in engineering as
qualification necessary for AOs seeking appointment by transfer. The
decrsion in S. Sctyop al Reddgls case (supra 5) establishes the State
Government's power to prescribe a higher qualification; it does not
dispense with the requirement that the particular qualification
prescribed must bear a rational nexus with the post and withstand
scrutiny under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
23.. Further, the respondents have also relied upon S.O.No.3O1(tr),
dated 29.O4.199 1, which provides that "nothing contoined in this
notification sho,ll apply to an officer oppointed to discharge functions of
a non-technical nature." While the said provision reflects the
distinction draivn by the Central Government between technical and
non-technical functions, its appiicability to the post of RTO cannot
3l
be determined merely by reference to the desiSlnation or the
notihcation itself. The nature of activities performed br the RTO must
be examined with reference to the statutory and administrative
functions attached to the post. The said notihcation is, therefore,
relevant only as a supporting circumstance and cannot. by itself,
establish the nature of functions discharged by the RTO. The issue
must ultimately be determined on the basis of the actual functions
and responsibilities of RTOs and the justificatior advanced for
prescribing an engineering qualification for AOs seeki.-rg appointment
by transfer to the post.
24. It is also Lo be noted that the principal questior: is not whether
the State Government possesses any general power under Article 309
to prescribe qualifications for public employment. 'l'he question is
whether, having regard to the specific statutory scheme of Section
273 of the MV Act, 1988 and the Central notifications issued
thereunder, that power can validly be exercrsed _o introduce a
technical qualification for the post of RTO u'hen no minimum
qualilication is prescribed by the Central Government for the said
post.
25. The proviso to Article 309 empowers the Stare Government to
make rules regulating recruitment and conditions cf service, but
such power is expressly subject to the provisions of the Constitution
and to any lau, made by the appropriate Legislaturr.. The MV Act,
ll
I988, being a Parliamentaly enactment, must consequently be given
effect to while examining the scope of the State Government's rule
making power. Section 213 rnust, therefore, be construed
harmoniouslywiththeprovisotoArticle3ogoftheConstitution.The
fact that the State Government possesses rule making power under
Article 309 of the Constitution does not, by itself, conclude the
question of the extent to which that power may be exercised in the
held speciltcally regulated by Section 213 of the MV Act, 1988'
26. It is pertinent to note that the respondents have sought to
justify the impugned G.O. bi' placing reliance upon the minutes of
the meeting of the Supreme Court Committee on Road Safety dated
O2.O7.2O7g. However, the said minutes require to be considered in
their entireff and in the context in u'hich the observations were
made. The relevant portion of the sard minutes of the meeting is
extracted hereunder:
The Committee pointed. out that Sectrcn 213 fi) of MV Act, 1988 requires
the Central Gout. to prescribe technicol cpali.li.cation of the ofilcers
posted. in the Motor Vehicle Depctrtment of the States The MoR1'H stated
inot tn"y haue alreadg prescribed the technical qualiJicalton ot Lower
management leuel uz. MV Inspectors. Diploma is the mimmum
quatiftcation for tllem. At middte manogement leuel, there' is no direct
intry and tierefore there is no requiremertt for prescnbitg tecluical
qtairficotion for them. Theg also stated that Central Institute of Road
iraisport, Pune imparts training to the State Transport Offcers from
time to time.
The Committee said that it is imPortqnt that olfrcers at the' middle
management Leuel like ARTOs qnd R?Os should haue' technicaL
qualifications and the approoch suggested bg the MoRTH uill take a
[ong time to make this loppen. The Commiltee requested lhe Secretary'
MoRTH to examine this tnatter in greater detoil.
27. Further, the said minutes disclose three material aspects,
which are as under:
i) The statement of the MoRTH reflected the position then
obtaining that no separate technical quahfication had been
prescribed for officers at the middle-management level on the
ground that there was no direct entry at that le.rel.
ii) The Committee expressed a policy vierv that technical
qualifications u,ere desirable for officers u t the middlemanagement level, including ARTOs and RTOs.
iii) The Committee requested the Secretary, MoRTH to examine
the matter in greater detail. The minutes do not record any
direction requiring the State Government to prescribe technical
qualifications for RTOs, nor do they themselves prescribe any
such qualification.
The aforesaid minutes, therefore, cannot br- themselves be
construed as conferring authority upon the State Government to
introduce a technical qualification for the post ol- RTO. At the
highest, they' disclose a recommendation or policy cc nsideration for
examination by the MoRTH. The dislinction is mater:al, particularly
when the validity of the impugned G.O. is required to be tested with
reference to the statutory scheme governing tht: trescription of
qualification s.
i4
2a. It is relevant to note that the subsequeut MoRTH proposal
d,ated 21.O7 .2023 prescribed minimum qualifications for direct
recruitment to the post of RTO, irrcluding a degree in Automobile or
Mechanical Engineering. However, being a subsequent proposal
relating to direct recruitment, it does not establish the State
Government's authority to prescribe technical qualiltcations for
appointment by transfer under the impugned G.O. Nor can it, by
itself, validate the impugned G.O.
29. The respondents' contentiorr that RTOs disctrarge technical
functions and that, therefore, technical qualifications are necessary
for appointment to the post, mus1. be examined with re1'erence to the
statutory functions assigned to RTOs under the MV Act, 1988, and
the actual distribution of technical and administrative functions
within the Transport Department.
30.
Chapter II of the MV Act deals rvith licensing of drivers The
functions of the Licensing Authority, which mav include the
RTO/ARTO/DTO, include the issuance, renerval and endorsement of
driving licences and other matters relating to licensing. While certain
functions, such as conducting driving tests, may involve technical
assessment, the licensing functions as a whole are substantially
regulatory and administrative in nature.
i5
31. It is also relevant that the State Government has proposed the
establishment of Automated Scientific Driving Test C'--ntres and the
entrustment of such functions to specialised agerLcies' Further,
learner's licence tests have been made online. These developments
indicate that certain functions involving technical a ssessment are
increasingly being performed through automated or specialised
mechanisms rather than by the RTO personally.
32. Chapter IV of the MV Act, 1988 deals rvith registration of motor
vehicles. The functions of the Registering Authorily, which may
include the RTO/ARTO/DTO, include registratioll of vehicles,
assignment of registration marks, issuance of certilicates of
registration and related matters, as well as functions relating to
fitness certificates under Section 56.
33.
While vehicle inspection and the determination of htness may
involve technical expertrse, the material placed belore the Court
indicates that such technical functions are perfolmed with the
assistance of technically qualified officers like the I'MVI's and the
MVI's. The existence of such technical components in the functions
of the Department does not establish that the post of RTO is
technical in character.
34. Chapter V of the MV Act deals with the contr-ol of transport
vehicles. The functions of the Regional Transport Authority' which is
chaired by the District Collector and has the RTO as its Secretary,
include functions relatrng to the issuance of permits, variation and
transfer of permits, which are purely administrative in nature and do
not require the exercise of speciaiised engineering expertise
35. The material further indicates that technical aspects relating to
vehicle inspection and roadworthiness are substantially performed
by technically qualified officers in the AMVI/MVI cadres, whereas the
RTO occupies
_a
supervisory and administrative position in the
departmentai hierarchy. This allocation of technical functions is
consistent with the statutory scheme under Section 213(a) of the MV
Act, 1988, pursuant to which the Central Government has, by
Notifications S.O.No.443(E), dated 12.06.1989, and S.O.No. 1215(E),
dated O8.03.20 19, prescribed minimum qualifications specihcally for
the posts of MVI and AMVI.
36. Significantly, in 2006 the A.P. Transport Deparlment Technical
Ofl-rcers Association represented to provide Techrrical pattern cadres
in the Department, wherein a Committee was constituted by the
Department and categorically decided as foliows:
"As far as Trqnsport Department ts concerned, technical uork ends up
qt the leuel of AMVI and MVI cadres. S"-ction 56 of MV Act prouides for
the prescibed authoritg tuho does not hold technical qualificatton to
take decision-s on the report of an officer haung technical
qualifi,cotons. The qboue prouision clearlg detnarcates the distinction
between technical and non technical authoities in the Deportment,
such being the case, demarcotion is bound to be there. Begond the
cadre of MVI, there is no need for creation of techttical cadres. If at alt
department feels to create techrical cadres begortd the cadre of MVI, it
shouldbeurithinthetechnicalpersonnelpromotedtothcltcadfe,not
touching personrtel drautn from other channels."
The aforesaicl internal decision of the TransporL
treated the AMVITMVI cadres as the 1eve1 at
Department
which the technical work
of the Department substantially ends and found no
necessity for
creation of further technical cadres'
g7.
The Transport Commissioner, bv letter dated
recommended restoration of the eclucational
02 O3'2O24 ' also
qualification for the post
technical
of RTO to 'Ang Bachelor's Degree' in place of the
qualiiication. The Transport Commissioner observed
RTO functions as a senior administrati"'e post
necessity for a technical qualification for the
38.
that the post of
and that there v!'as no
post'
On a consideration of the statutory functions and
placed before the Court, it appears that the functions
the material
of an RTO are
predominantly supervisory, regulatory and administrltive'
although
the post is connected with certain functions invoiving technical
inspection and
aspects. The technical functions relating to vehicle
assessment of roadworthiness are substantially
per formed by the
AMVI/ MVI cadres, u'ho possess the requisite technica
qualifications'
39. In S. Satyap al Reddgls case (supra 5)' the Hrn'b1e Supreme
Court recognised the distinction betu'een technical
and non-technical
functions and noticed the exclusion of prescription of
minimum
qualihcation b1- the Central Government in respect of officers
appointed to discharge functions of a non-technicai nature. The
applicability of that exclusion ilr the present case turns on the nature
of the functions assigned to and discharged by RTOs. Since the
Central Government has not prescribed a minimum technical
qualihcation for RTOs except in cases by direct recruitment and its
notifications exempt officers in non-technical roles, the State's
introduction of a technrcal qualification for AOs shot s that it had
prescribed minimum qualification for AOs lor being appointed as
RTOs, where it could have prescribed a higher qualification after the
Central Government had prescribed a minimum qualihcation.
40. The existence of the technical MVI/AMVI cadres, whose
qualifications are prescribed by the Central Government, is
specifically to discharge functions requiring specialised technical
expertise. In this statutory scheme, the RTO functions primarily in a
regulatory and managerial capacity. The effective functioning of the
Department relies on the complementary contribution of the
technicai cadre and the administrative cadre, each performing
distinct roles defined by the Act. The State s a ttempt to prescribe a
technical qualification for the administratir.e feeder category (AOs) for
promotion to RTO is inconsrstent with this established statutory
framework and appears to be an attempt to mandate a qualification
where the Central Government has not chosen to prescribe any
qualification to such appointment by transfers.
ls
4L. It is in this context that the introduction of the technical
qualification for AOs must be considered. The impugned G O' not
only prescribes a Degree in engineering qualihcation f<ir appointment
by transfer to the post of RTO, but also provides that, where no
technically qualified Administrative Officer is available. the vacancy
earmarked for that category may be filled from the MVI category' The
combined elfect of these provisions is to substantially restrict the
established avenue of appointment try transfer ar-ailab e to AOs'
42. In ?.R. Kapur a. State of Haryana6, the Hcn'b1e Supreme
Court held that while the competent authoriT may alter
qualihcations for promotion, such alteration, affecting the right to be
considered for promotion, must satisfy Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution. The relevant para of the said decisicn is extracted
hereunder:
16. ....1t is equollA welt'settled that ang tate uthich affects the ight of
o person to be considered for prontotion is a condttiot' of seruice
although ntere cltances of Protnotion tnoA not be lt nlall frtfther be
stated thc,t an authoitA competent to lag down quoh.)ica'tiotts .for
prornotion, is also contpetent to change the quQltfication::. The ruLes
defuing quali.f.cottons arld suitabilitg.for prontotiott are- conditions of
seruice antd theg cotl be changed retrospectiueLl1 . Tl Lis tu[< is howeuer
subject to a well-recognised pinciple that the benefits acguired under
the efisting tuLes ca ttot be taken owag bg an amendment utth
retrospectiue effect, that is fo s@y, there is no poluer to nLake such a
rule under tle prouiso to ArTicle 3O9 which affects or imPairs uested
ights. Therefore, unless it is specificallg proutded in the rules, the
emplogees tuho are alreadg promoted before the amenclnrctt of the
rules, cannot be reuerted and their promotnns connot be recalled ln
other words, such rules layirtg doutn qualiftcations Jbr prot'totion rnade
uith retrospectiue elfect must necessary so]tisfg the tests 'tJ Article 14
and 16(l) oJ'the Cotlstitution: State of Mgsore u. LLN. Kr shna Mufig
" AtR t987 sc -l l5
and Ors. MANU/ SC/ 0600/ 1972 : (1973)ILLI42SC B.S. yad(lu and.
Ors. u. State of Haryana and Ors. MANU/SC/04O9/ 1980 :
(1981)lLlJ280SC State of Gujarat and Anr. u. Ramc.nlal Keshaulal
Soni and Ors. MANU/SC/0346/ 1983 : (1983)\LLI2B4SC and. Ex
Captain K.C. Arora and AnL u. State of Haryana and Ors.
MANU/ SC/ O271/ 1984 : (1984)l1Lu362SC.
(Etnphasis supptied)
43. It is well settled that a government servant has no vested right
to promotion to a particular post. However, a right to be considered
for promotion in accordance .","'ith the rules applicable at the relevant
time is distinct from a right to promotion itself. In the present case,
the AOs had, under the pre-amended service rules, an avenue for
conslderation for appointment by transfer to the post of RTO, subject
to fulfilment of the prescribed qualifications and other conditions.
The impugned G.O. has altered the eligibility conditions by
introducing a technical qualification, thereby excluding the
petitioners from consideration notwithstanding their eligibility under
the earlier ru les.
44. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in P.D. Aggarual's case (supra 4),
has recognised that although the Government possesses the power to
amend service rules, such porver is subject to constitutional
limitations and cannot be exercised in an artritrary or unreasonable
manner. The fact that the petitioners were appointed under the pre-
amended rules does not confer upon them a vested right to
promotion under those ru1es. But, where an amendment alters the
eligibility conditions governing an existing promotional avenue, its
4l
validity must be tested against the applicable statutory and
constitutional limitations,
including the Principles of non-
arbitrariness and fairness. The impugned G.O., by introducing a
technical qualification for appointment by transfer to the Post of
RTO, thereby excludes the petitioners from consid':ration despite
their eligibility under the pre-amended rules and is, to that extent'
arbitrary and unreasonable.
45. Further, the petitioners have invoked the Doctrine of
Legitimate Expectation on the basis of the long-standrng promotional
avenue available to AOs for appointment to the 1lo;t of RTO The
doctrine does not confer an absolute right to the cor Linuation of an
existing policy or service rule; hou'ever, \'!'here a (lonsistent past
practice has created a reasonable expectation, sucL expectation is
required to be duly considered before the establis
-red position is
altered, particularly lr,'here the alteration adversr:ly affects the
persons who have relied upon the existing arrangenlellt.'
46. In Naaigoti Coop. Group Housing Society's case (supra 1),
the Hon'ble Supreme Court recognised that legitim ale expectation
may arise from consistent past practice and that srrch expectation
ought not to be defeated without an overriding rcason of public
policy. Similarly, in Kamdhenu Cattle Feed 'lnrlustries's case
(supra 2), the Hon'ble Supreme Court held that altt ough legitimate
expectation may not, by itself, constitute an enforceable right, failure
to consider and give due weight to such expectation may render the
decision arbitrary and thereby offend the principle of nonarbitrariness.
47. In the present case, the material placed before the Court
indicates that AOs had a promotional avenue to the post of RTO for
severai decades under the successive service rules, and that the
qualification prescribed for the post was a 'Degree of a Uniuersitg',
which the petitioners possess. Therefore, the petitioners could
reasonably expect to be considered for appointment by transfer to
the post of RTO in accordance with the qualification and promotional
structure that had prevailed over the preceding years. The impugned
G.O. has materially altered that established position by introducing a
technical qualihcation for appointment by transfer to the post of
RTO, thereby excluding AOs who otherwise satisfied the qualihcation
prescribed under the earlier rules, The responderrts have not been
able to demonstrate any compelling public interest that warrants the
sudden and drastic change in the qualification for AOs to be
promoted as RTO.
Arbitrariness, Discrimination and Violation of Articles 14 and 16
48, Article 14 of the Constitution of India guarantees equalily
before the law and equal protection of the laws, while Article 16
guarantees equality of opportunity in matters of public employment
A classification made by the State must be founded ot an intelligible
differentia and must bear a rational nexus rT'ith the object sought to
be achieved.
49. The impugned G.O. provides for allocation of vacancies
between the feeder categories of MVIs and AOs, with 5 out of every
10 vacancies being allocated to MVIs and 2 lo AOs. Tre respondents
seek to justify this distinction on the basis of the technical
qualifications possessed by MVIs and the respective :adre strength'
The classification, however, cannot be sustained merely by referring
to the technical qualifications of MVIs, for the followin { reasons:
i)
MVIs and AOs constitute feeder categories for appointment by
transfer to the post of RTO and, under the pre-amended rules,
both categories were eligible for consideration for such
appointment. The mere difference in their educational
qualifications does not establish a rational nexus between the
classification and the nature of duties attacherl to the post of
RTO, particularly in light of the Central Government's
notifications. By prescribing specific technicai qualifications for
MVIs/AMVIs, the Central Government has effectiveiy
designated them as the technical cadre. Cent-al Government
did not prescribe any minimum technical qualilication to the
post of RTO by transfer; this regulatory structLlre is a relevant
circumstance shou'ing that technical expertise is concentrated
in the MVI/AMVI cadre. Thus, the State failed to demonstrate
as to why an engineering qualification is nevertheless
necessary for appointment by transfer to the RTO post.
ii) The AOs have acquired substantial experience in the
administration and functioning of the Transport Department
over several years.
iii)
The allocation of 5 vacancies to MVIs and only 2 vacancies to
AOs requires a rational basis having regard to the object
sought to be achieved. The numerical strength of the respective
cadres may be a relevant consideration for determining the
quota, but it cannot justify differential treatment if the
resulting classification bears no reasonable relationship to the
functions and responsibilities of the promotional post.
ir) The further stipulation that, in'here no technically qualified
person is available from the AO category, the vacancy shall be
fi1led from the MVI category has a direct bearing upon the
promotional avenue of AOs. If the technical qualihcation is not
otherwise necessary for the discharge of the principal functions
of the RTO, such a condition would substantially rmpair the
promotional opportunity of AOs and requires a rational
justification.
v)
Moreover, the Cadre strength may legitimately be considered in
determining the distribution of promotional vacancies.
However, the respondents have not placed sufhcient
material
before the Court to demonstrate how the particrriar allocation
of hve vacancies to MVIs and tn'o vacancies to AOs was arrived
at,orhowthatallocationbealsarationalrelationshiptothe
functions and responsibiiities of the post of RTO
50. The classification between MVIs and AOs llso warrants
examination in the light of the length of service anc departmental
experience possessed by the AOs, as also the statutory scheme
under
Section 2'13(4) of the MV Act, 1988, q'hereunder the Central
Government has confined the prescription of technical qualifications
to the MVI/AMVI cadres and has not extended any su':h requirement
to the appointment by transfer to the post of RTO
'Ihe petitioners
have rendered several years of service in the Transport Department
and have acquired experience in its administrative and regulatory
functioning. Such experlence cannot be disregarded zLltogether
while
determining their suitability for appointment to a adrrLinistrative
post
merely because they do not possess an engineering qu alihcation'
51. In the present case, the distinction between MVIs and AOs
mustthereforebetestedwithreferencetothenaturerfthefunctions
attached to the post of RTO, the respective roles of the two feeder
categories, their experiencq and qualifications, and tfLe object sought
to be achieved b1' the impugned G.O Where the principal functions
of the RTO are administrative and superuisory, the rnere possession
of a technical qualification by one feeder category cannot justify
curtailing the promotional opportunity of the other category.
52. The differential treatment accorded to AOs under the
impugned G.O. is no[ supported by a sufficient rational basis and is
violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
Conclusion
53. For the foregoing reasons, this Court is of the considered view
that the State Government possesses the power, in exercise of its
rule-making authority, to prescribe qualifications for appointment to
posts in the Transport Department, including qualifications higher
than the minimum qualification prescriLred by the Central
Government. However, such power is subject to the constitutional
requirement of non arbitrariness and must bear a rational nexus
with the nature and responsibilrties of the post concerned. In the
present case, the respondents have not demonstrated a sufficient
rational connection between the engineering qualification prescribed
by the impugned G.O. for Administrative Officers for appointment by
transfer to the post of RTO. The impugned qualification, coupled
with the altered allocation of vacancies, substantially curtails the
established avenue of appointment by transfer availatrle to
Administrative Ofhcers and is not supported by a sufficient rational
basis. The impugned provisions are therefore arbitrary and
discriminatory and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.
4l
the
54. Accordingly, both the Writ Petitrons are a11ou,ed, rvith
following directions
i) G.O.Ms.No.7, TransPort, Roads & Buildings (TR. Ser)
a
Department, dated 28.O 1.202 1, insofar as it prescribes
technical qualification of a Degree in Mechanical Engineertng
or Automobile Engineering or equivalent qu llihcation for
Admrnistratir,e officers working in District ofltces (Category
8)
for appoinlment by transfer to the post of Regicnal Transport
Officer (Category 3), ls declared illegal, zrrbitrary and
discriminatory, violative
of Articles 14 anc 16 of the
Constitution of India and contrary to the star'utorJ' scheme
under Section 213 ol the Motor Vehicles Act' 1988' and is
accordingly quashed to that extent'
ii)
The amendment to Rule 3(b) of the Telangana State
Transport
Service Rules. 1993, introduced by G O \ls No 7 dated
2a.O1.2021, insofar as it alters the c1rcle of vacancies
allocated
to Administrative Ofhcers for appointment to th e post of
RTO'
is quashed and set aside The vacancies shall accordingly be
dealt with 1n accordance with the pre-arnended Rules
containedinG.O.MsNol8O,Transport'Roacs&Buildings
(Tr.I) Department, dated O1 07 1994'
iii) The petitioners and other similarly situated Administrattve
Officers shall be considered for appointment b1 transfer to the
post of RTO in accordance with the qualification prescribed
under the pre-amended Rules, without insisting upon the
technical qualification introduced by G.O.Ms.No.7 dat€d
28.O1.202r.
ir)
The respondents shall undertake the process of consideration
for appointment to the post of RTO in accordance with the preamended Rules and the directions contained in this judgment,
without giving effect to the technical quaiihcation or the altered
vacancy cycle introduced by G.O.Ms.No.7 dated 28.O)..2021.
v) Any appointments already made pursuant to G.C).Ms.No.7
dated 28.O1.202 1 shall not, solely on account of this common
order, be disturbed without notice to the affected persons and
an order passed in accordance with law.
As a sequel, the miscellaneous petition s, il any, shall stand
closed. No costs.
SD/- MOHD. ISMAIL
DEPUTY REGIS
//TRUE COPY//
S CTION OFFICER
To
1. The Principal Secretary, Transport, Roads and Buildings Dept-, Secretariat'
Hyderabad, State of Telangana.
2. The Principal secretary, General Administration Department, secretariat,
Hyderabad, State of Telangana.
The
Transport Commissioner, Telangana State, Hyderabad'
3.
4. The Transport Commissioner. State of Telangarta at Khairathabad,
Hyderabad.
5. Sri D. Hanumantheshwar Rao, S/o D. Raja Rao (Late), Aged about 47 yeats'
Occ Administrative Officer, O/o Joint Transport Cc mmissioner / SRTA,
Khairatabad, Hyderabad, PJo. H.No.6-3-1 185 I 1 1 21 4, Be Sumpet, Hyderabad
6. Sri Gurram Vivekananda Reddy, S/o. G. Hanmanth Fleddy, Aged about 57
years, Present working station - Armoor, Nizamabad. R/o. H. No. 5-83/1 ,
Perkit, Armoor, Nizamabad District - 503 224.
7. Sri Alle Srinivas, S/o. A. Devarajam, Aged about 57 years, Present working
station - Adilabad, R/o. H. No. 9-209, Teachers Colony, Adilabad-504 001
8. Sri lr,4andadi Suresh Reddy, S/o. [\rl. Danareddy (Late), Aged about 56 years,
Present working station - RTA, Hyderabad, R/o. Villa t'Jo. 95, I\/y Fair Villas,
Osman Nagar Road, Tellapur, R.C. Puram, Hyderabad ' 502 032
9. Sri Ravula Vijay Rao, S/o. R. Prakash (Late), Aged at,out 60 years, Present
working station - MVI - Patancheru, Sangareddy Dir;trict, R/o H.No. 1-93121E19, Plot No. 203 Street No. 6, Atchyuth Redriy Marg, Vidyanagar,
Hyderabad-500 042.
'10. Sri Godas Ravi Kumar, S/o. G. Mallesham. Aged about 59 years Occupation
Motor Vehicles lnspector O/o Present working lvlvl, ItTA, Hyderabad-West
Zone, R/o. 8-2-684114, Road No. 12, Anand Banjara, Banjarahills, Hyderabad.
11. Sri tr/atam Yerri Swamy, S/o. Late [t4. Umapathaiah, Aged about 59 years,
Occupation t\,4otor Vehicles lnspector O/o Present working lVVl, RTA,
Hyderabad-North Zone. Fl/o Flat G2, Anu Heiglrts, Eenadu Colony,
Kukatpally, Hyderabad.
'12.Sri G. Ashwanth Kumar, S/o. G. Lakshami Narayana, Aged about 49 years.
Occupation l\,4otor Vehicles lnspector O/o Present vrorking lt4otor Vehicle
lnspector No 14-112, Raghavendra Residency, D lsukhnagar P and T
Colony, Hyderabad.
13.Sri J. Umamaheswar Rao, S/o. Late Seetharamaiah, Aged about 59 years.
Occupation IVIotor Vehicles lnspector O/o Distrl,;t Transport Officer.
Nizamabad. Rlio Flat No 216, Yendala Towers, opp Prudence Hospital,
Pragati Nagar, Nizamabad.
14.Sri Rayarao Hari Prasad Rao, S/o. Late Sri Narasimha Rao, Aged about 55
years, Occ. Administrative Officer, RTO, Hyderabad South Zone (Emp. l.D
1404954) F/o. 6-4-362, Plot No. 72, TV Colony, Vanasthalipuram, Hyderabad.
15. Sri Afshan Anjum, Wo. Late Mohd lt4ultani, Aged about 50 years' Occ.
Administrative Officer, RTO, Hyderabad East Zone (Emp.lD 2512132) Rlo.23-421 C134, Amberpet, Hyderabad
16. Sri Vakkanthula Srinivasa Rao, S/o. V. Pullaiah, Aged about 54 Years, Occ.
Administrative Officer, RTO, Hyderabad, Central Zone R/o. H.No.11-10-28,
Vijaypuri colony, Kothapet, Ranga Reddy District.
17. tt/s. Akki Padmavathi, W/o. Akki Dass, Aged about 44 years, Occ.
Administrative Officer, DTO, Ranga Reddy (Emp. lD No. 2509836) PJo. Fl.No.
201, Santosh Towers, West l,4arredpally, Secunderabad.
1B.l\,4s. Kasukurthi Rajani, Wio. M.Prem Chand Aged about 46 years Occ.
Administrative Officer, DTO, Vikarabad (Empl lD- 2543564) Rio. Plot no 11,
Shankar Green Homes, Ameenpur, Sangareddy Dist
19.Sri A.V.Ramesh, S/o. Late A.V.Ram fvlohan Rao Aged about 45 years, Occ.
Administrative Officer, RTO, Hyderabad West Zone, (Emp lD 2509833) R/o.
F|.No.103, R.R.Meadows Radha Residency Dhobighat X Road, Madannapet
colony, Saidabad, Hyderabad
20.Sri B. Madhukar, S/o. Late B. Shekar, Aged about 46 years, Occ.
Administrative Officer, RTO, Hyderabad East Zone (Emp. l.D No. 2543585)
Fl/o. G2, Vinayaka Residency, Raghavendra Nagar, Nacharam, Hyderabad.
21.
Sri Kothapalli Benjamin, W/o, Balaiah, Aged about 57 years, Occ.
Administrative Officer, DTO, Suryapet (Emp. l.D 2543551) R/o. 8-3-
22Bl 1209 12, Rahamath Nagar, Yusufguda, Hyderabad, 500045.
22. Sri G.sreenivasa Reddy, S/o. G.Peri Reddy (Late), Aged 57 years, Presently
working Station- MVI- lbrahimpatnam, Ranga Reddy District' Fli o. H.No.2-131, Flat No.502, Vegetable Market, Nallakunta, Hyderabad - 500044.
23. Sri Dorbala Pradeep Ram Krishna, S/o. D.Devidas Sharma' Aged about 49
years, Occ: Administrative Officer, Office at Road Transport Authority,
Hyderabad North Zone.
24.One CC to SRI POODATTU AIVARENDER, Advocate [OPUC]
25.One CC to SRI ATVANCHARLA V.GOPALA RAO, Advocate IOPUC]
26. One CC to SRI SAI PRASEN GUNDAVARATV, Advocate [OPUC]
27.One CC to SRI D.SUDHARSHAN, Advocate IOPUC]
28.One CC to SRI VIJAY B PAROPAKARI, Advocate IOPUC]
29.One CC to SRI A V.A.SIVA KARTIKEYA, Advocate [OPUC]
30.Two CCs to GP FOR SERVICES-|, High Court for the State of Telangana, at
Hyderabad [OUT]
31 . Two CD Copies
PSK
GJP
l0
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0110912026
COMMON ORDER
WP.Nos.27209 AND 29830 OF 2024
1t\ E SIArt:
q
)
)
0 7 sFp
,nrr
t
L
,,tl
* c
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITIONS
WITHOUT COSTS
AL
.^ .t'
a'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review