Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010627322025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA
PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3460]
FRIDAY,THE THIRTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NYAPATHY VIJAY
WRIT PETITION NO: 32418/2025
Between:
1. RAYALASEEMA LAW COLLEGE, REP BY ITS
CORRESPONDENT SRI. YARRAPU REDDY ANAND
CHINTHAGUNTA
VILLAGE,
SANAMBATIA,
CHANDRAGIRI
MANDAL,
TIRUPATHI
DISTRICT,
ANDHRA PRADESH.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REP BY ITS
PRINCIPAL
SECRETARY
TO
GOVERNMENT
DEPARTMENT OF HIGHER EDUCATION, TULLURU,
SECRETARIAT BUILDINGS
VELAGAPUDI, GUNTUR
DISTRICT.
2. THE ANDHRA PRADESH STATE COUNCIL FOR HIGHER
EDUCATION, GOVERNMENT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
REP BY ITS SECRETARY NEELADRI TOWERS, 6TH
BATTALIAN ROAD MANGALAGIRI, ANDHRA PRADESH
522503
3. SRI VENKATESWARA UNIVERSITY, REP BY ITS
REGISTRAR PRAKASAM ROAD TIRUPATI DISTRICT,
ANDHRA PRADESH – 517502
4. SRI VENKATESWARA UNIVERSITY, REPRESENTED BY
ITS DEAN
COLLEGE DEVELOPMENT COUNCIL
PRAKASAM ROAD
TIRUPATI DISTRICT, ANDHRA
PRADESH 517502
5. UNIVERSITY STANDING COMMITTEE FOR AFFILIATION,
REPRESENTED
BY
ITS
CHAIRMAN
SRI
VENKATESWARA UNIVERSITY
PRAKASAM ROAD
TIRUPATI DISTRICT, ANDHRA PRADESH 517502
6. SRI BHUPATHI NAIDU MADHALA, IMPLEADED ALSO IN
HIS PERSONAL CAPACITY)
REGISTRAR
SRI
VENKATESWARA UNIVERSITY
PRAKASAM ROAD
TIRUPATI DISTRICT, ANDHRA PRADESH 517502
7. BAR COUNCIL OF INDIA, REP BY ITS MEMBER
SECRETARY
21, ROUSE AVENUE INSTITUTIONAL
AREA, NEAR BAL BHAWAN, NEW DELHI - 110 002
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying
that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the
High Court may be pleased tomay be pleased to issue an
appropriate writ more in the nature of Writ of Mandamus declaring
the impugned order No. C-111(4)/RLC/Affiliation/2025-26 dated
07-11-2025 as illegal, arbitrary, discriminatory and violative of
principles of natural Justice and set aside the impugned rejection
order and consequently direct the 3rd Respondent University to
grant affiliation for the academic year 2025-26 in accordance
with BCI Approval dated 10-06-2024 and further direct the
Respondents to permit the Petitioner to participate in
APLAWCET-2025 counselling and process admissions for AY
2025-26 and issue such
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC
praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the
petition, the High Court may be pleased may be pleased to
suspend the impugned rejection order vide No. C-111(4)/ RLC/
Affiliation/ 2025-26, dated : 07-11-2025 issued by the 3rd
Respondent, Sri Venkateswara University, and grant affiliation
forthwith the Petitioner institution so as to enable the Petitioner
institution to participate in APLAWCET-2025 counselling and
admit students for the academic year 2025-26, pending Writ
Petition, in the interest of justice and pass such
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. SRI VIJAY MATHUKUMILLI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR HIGHER EDUCATION
2. G VENKATA REDDY
3. K RADHIKA
4. THE ADVOCATE GENERAL
5. RAMESH BABU TALLURI SC For
S.V.UNIVERSITY,TIRUPATI
The Court made the following:
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE NYAPATHY VIJAY
W.P.No.32418 of 2025
O R DE R:
The present writ petition is filed questioning the action of
Respondent
No.3
in
issuing
the
order
No.C-111(4)
RLC/Affiliation/2025-26, dated 07.11.2025 as illegal and arbitrary.
2.
The facts leading to filing of the writ petition are as follows:
Petitioner
is
a
duly
established
Law
College
and
Respondent No. 2-A.P. State Council for Higher Education
(APSCHE) had issued NOC. For the academic year 2024-25,
Respondent No.3-University conducted physical inspection and
issued a temporary affiliation on 30.12.2023 for that academic
year. While so, the Petitioner-College was denied from
participating in A.P.LAWCET-2025 counselling process for
admission for the academic year 2025-26 on the ground of nongrant of digital affiliation by the Respondent-University.
3.
Questioning the same, Petitioner filed W.P.No.24436 of
2025 and an interim order was passed permitting the Petitioner to
participate in the counselling process on 11.09.2025.
In this
regard, W.A.No.1118 of 2025 was filed by the University, which
was disposed of by order dated 28.10.2025, setting aside the
interim order and further directing the University to conduct the
inspection and pass appropriate orders thereon. Pursuant to
orders of this Court in W.A.No.1118 of 2025, the RespondentUniversity inspected the Petitioner premises and resolved not to
recommend granting affiliation due to (04) deficiencies and
principal among them is the non-compliance of BCI norms for the
academic year 2025-26. Hence, the present writ petition is filed.
3.
As regards, the deficiencies 1 and 2 in the impugned order,
it is stated that the Petitioner has built-up area of 4196.97
sq.mtrs., in block-B, situated within the boundaries of East-Road;
South – Block-A which forms part of larger extent of 20 acres, out
of which 4 acres have been duly earmarked and assigned for
establishment of the Law College as recorded in the resolution of
the managing committee. It is further stated that APSCHE, after
due consideration of the entire contiguous property, including the
demarcation and allocation of separate blocks, has granted No
Objection Certificate for running the Law College in the said
premises. It is stated that there is no statutory prohibition against
operating multiple educational institutions within a common
campus, provided that each institution satisfies the requisite land
and building norms with identifiable demarcation. It is stated that
the Petitioner-College possesses land and built-up area far in
excess of the minimum requirement and the facilities earmarked
for the Law College fully comply with the regulatory prescriptions.
4.
As regards deficiency No.3, it is stated that the Petitioner
paid staff approval fee on 25.07.2025 and the failure of the
University to act thereon cannot be to the disadvantage of the
Petitioner. As regards deficiency No.4, it is stated that on internal
verification, it was found that the individuals who were named
therein was erroneously mapped in the University portal as being
associated with another institution and avoid any ambiguity and to
ensure strict faculty norms, the faculty member has been
replaced with a duly qualified new faculty member and the
relevant documents are enclosed thereto. As regards the second
faculty member, it is stated that she is not working in any other
institution and her name appears to remain in the database of the
previous college due to non-deletion/non-updating of records by
that institution.
5.
In the counter affidavit filed by the Respondent-University, it
is stated that the Petitioner suffers from fundamental and fatal
difficulty of non-compliance of a mandatory requirement of
separate demarcation of land and building exclusively for the Law
College as mandated under Rule 16(1)(ii) r/w Schedule III of the
Bar Council of India Rules of Legal Education, 2008 and the
deficiency was first identified during the University inspection on
14.10.2023 for the academic year 2024-25 and again specifically
pointed out during the inspection on 04.11.2025. It is stated that
even though two years were granted to the Petitioner-College, the
deficiency pointed out was neglected.
6.
It is stated that the Petitioner‟s claim of a built-up area
admeasuring 4196.97 sq. mtrs., in Block-B forms part of 20 acres
of which 4 acres earmarked for Law College is a blatant
misrepresentation as the inspection revealed that the building
was used simultaneously for multiple educational institutions
without proper demarcation, boundaries or exclusive allocation of
Law College. It is stated that mere marking of certain rooms and
floors in the same building complex is based on a resolution of
the Managing Committee claiming to earmark certain areas is
insufficient as the mandatory requirement is the need of physical
separate demarcation of land and building exclusively for the Law
College with identifiable boundaries.
7.
It is stated that the requirement of exclusive demarcation of
land and building for Law College is not a mere technicality as it
goes to the root of ensuring that the Law College has dedicated
infrastructure and resources exclusively available for legal
education which cannot be diluted or compromised by sharing
premises with other colleges and compliance with the minimum
standards prescribed in Bar Council of India rules is mandatory
and not directory. It is further stated that the Petitioner cannot
have a vested right to continue affiliation in the absence of
compliance with the mandatory norms.
8.
Learned senior counsel Sri P.Veera Reddy would submit
that the campus of the College is in 20 acres and there is a builtup area of 4196.97 sq.mtrs., which is far in excess of the
minimum norms prescribed for running a Law College.
It is
submitted that the Petitioner-College has robust infrastructure
and contends that there is no specific requirement of a separate
building even as per the BCI norms nor there is a bar for running
a multi disciplinary college. As there is no possibility of denying
affiliation, the University has manufactured an objection of the
requirement of a separate building. Learned senior counsel had
pointed out the relevant BCI regulations to that effect which do
not mandate separate building and land to run a Law College. As
regards deficiency No.4, learned senior counsel submits that the
deficiency is rectified.
9.
Learned Advocate General appearing for the University
would submit that for establishing a Law College, independent
separate land and building is required to maintain the quality of
education and standards prescribed by the Bar Council of India.
It is contended that though the Petitioner was put on notice for
want of a separate building in the inspection conducted earlier,
the Petitioner-College did not rectify the said mistake and seeking
for affiliation with the University is impermissible.
10.
Heard Sri Vijay Mathukumilli, learned counsel for the
Petitioner and learned Government Pleader for Higher Education.
11.
The objections raised in the impugned proceedings against
the Petitioner-Law College are as under:
Deficiencies pointed out by the UIC as per Recommendations
University/BCI Guidelines
1. There is no separate demarked land
building for Law College. (as per the
BCI Law Guidelines – Land and
building should have properly
demarcated exclusively for Law
College).
Due to non-compliance
with
BCI
norms,
affiliation
cannot
be
given for the academic
year 2025-26.
2. Multiple Colleges are running in the
same building (as per the BCI Law
Guidelines - Law College should
have
exclusively
demarcated
building and Land).
3. Faculty not appointed as per the
norms of University/BCI (vide
reference 1st cited - in Staff selection
there must be formed Five Men
Selection Committee in that one
Nominee of the concerned University
is must.
4. On verification 02 Aadhaar Number
of Two Faculty (1.N.Pavithra –JNTU,
Ananthapuramu
and
2.
Dr.
M.Purushothama Reddy – Rukmini
Devi Arundale College of Education,
(RACE), Madanapalle) are working
in other colleges. (as per the BCI
Law Guideline – faculty should not
work in another College and as per
the provision given in the APCFSS
Affiliation web portal one can be
check with Aadhaar whether working
in other College or not.)
13.
The controversy in the case revolves around objections
pointed out in Sl.Nos.1 and 2 in the above tabulated statement
i.e. requirement of a separate demarcated land and building for
Law College and that multiple colleges are running in the same
building. The BCI Regulations for Establishment of Law Colleges
were framed under the provisions of the Advocates Act, 1961 and
were named as Rules of Legal Education, 2008 (for short „the
Rules). Rule 16 thereof specifies conditions for a University to
affiliate a Centre of Legal Education and sub-rule 16(ii) is relevant
for this case. As per this Rule 16(ii), the institution should have in
its name adequate land and buildings either on lease or freehold
to provide a Centre of Legal Education building and sufficient
floor space area is devoted in entirety for a Centre of Legal
Education based on size of students population, faculty
requirement and for infrastructure facilities.
14. Rule 16(ii) of the Rules reads as under:
16. Conditions for a University to affiliate a Centre of
Legal Education
(ii) the institution has in its name either in freehold or
leasehold, adequate land and buildings, to provide for
Centre of Legal Education building, library, halls of
residences separately for male and female and sports
complex both indoor and outdoor, so that it can effectively
run professional law courses provided that in case of
leasehold the lease is not less than ten years,
Provided that sufficient and adequate floor space area
specially and completely devoted for a Centre of Legal
Education, based on the size of its student population,
faculty
requirement,
infrastructure
facilities
adequate
space
can
considered
be
required
for
sufficient
accommodation for the purpose in a multi-faculty building on
land possessed by the Management of a Society/ Trust
running multi-faculty institutions.
14.
The above Rule does not specifically contemplate a
separate building as mentioned in the impugned letter. What all
required under the above Rule is that the Law College should
have exclusive, sufficient and adequate floor space based on
student strength so as to effectively run the professional law
courses even in a multi faculty building on land possessed by
management running multi faculty institutions.
15.
Apart from the above mentioned Rule, Schedule III of the
Rules prescribes minimum infrastructure facilities required in a
Centre of Legal Education. The Rules 3 and 4 thereof would be
relevant for the purpose of this case.
3. Freehold or Leasehold Property: Each Centre of Legal
Education
providing
education
in
law
either
in
the
Department of law of a University or its constituent or
affiliated college must have either on freehold or on long
leasehold land adequate to provide academic buildings,
library, indoor and outdoor sports facilities, halls of
residences for male and female students separately, as the
case may be, in the name of the Centre of Legal Education
or organization running the Centre of Legal Education.
However, lease in the name of the Centre of Legal
Education shall be for a period of not less than ten years.
What is the adequate space for the said purpose shall
be decided by the respective authority of the University
under its affiliation regulation and as guided by the
UGC.
Provided that sufficient land and adequate floor space area
completely and exclusively devoted for a Centre of Legal
Education, based on the size of its student population,
faculty requirement infrastructure facilities, Library space
requirement, indoor and outdoor games facilities and other
requirements can be considered sufficient accommodation
in compliance with this clause, for the purpose in a multifaculty Institution on land possessed by the Management of
a Society/ Trust/ Non Profit Company running multi-faculty
institutions in a metropolitan or in a class 1 city.
16.
The proviso to Rule 3 of Schedule III is a reiteration of Rule
16(ii) of the main Rules and both the Rules in tandem speak of
adequacy of floor space area devoted for a Centre of Legal
Education in a multi-faculty institution on land possessed by the
Management of a Society. The Rules only speak of adequacy,
but not exclusivity as is urged by the University. The words
“exclusive or separate building” is consciously not referred to in
the Rules and this Court is not inclined to read exclusivity into the
Rules as that would amount to legislation.
17.
The discretion to determine adequacy is given to the
University as highlighted above and it is quite apparent that a Law
College in the premises of a multi faculty institution is permissible.
As the objections Nos.3 and 4 in the impugned order are trivial in
nature, the University can re-examine the same in the light of the
explanation given by the Petitioner.
18.
Therefore, the impugned order is set aside and the writ
petition is allowed. The 3rd Respondent-University is directed to
re-consider affiliation to the Petitioner-College forthwith taking
note of the adequacy of space as observed above. No order as
to costs.
As a sequel, pending applications, if any, shall stand
closed.
__________________
NYAPATHY VIJAY, J
Date:13.02.2026
KLP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review