The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. As has been observed hereinabove and held by Hon'ble Apex, while considering the prayer made on behalf of the accused for parole, Courts are not to be swayed by the nature or gravity of offence committed by the convict, rather such prayer is required to be decided taking note of various judgments, as has been culled out in para 37 of the judgment, reproduced hereinabove. Moreover, in the case at hand, it cannot be laid down as a proposition of law that a person convicted for his having committee serious crime is not entitled to be considered for parole, rather in that situation, very purpose of taking ground repot from the District Magistrate and Superintendent of Police, is to ascertain whether in the event of release on parole, there exists a reasonable likelihood of the prisoner indulging in criminal activities again. In the present case, District Magistrate as well as Superintendent of Police, while objecting the parole of the petitioner, has failed to assign any cogent reason, which may justify their apprehension that in the event of grant of his release on parole, petitioner would again indulge in the illegal trade of narcotics. No doubt, petitioner has been convicted and sentenced to undergo ten years rigorous imprisonment on account of possessing narcotic substances, but that does not mean that in the event of his being enlarged on parole, he would again indulge in thes…
13. Consequently, in view of the above, present petition is allowed and impugned orders dated 07.02.2025, 28.02.2025 and
23. 07.2025 (Annexures P-2 to P-4) are quashed and set aside. The petitioner is ordered to be released on parole for 42 days subject to his furnishing personal bond in the sum of ₹ 1,00,000/- with two sureties in the like amount to the satisfaction of the Superintendent Jail with an undertaking to maintain good conduct during the period of parole and to surrender before the Superintendent Jail after the expiry of the period of parole. The Probation Officer is also directed to maintain a close watch on the activities of the petitioner and to report any deviation from the direction issued by the Court.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.625 of 2026
Date of Decision: 20.03.2026
_______________________________________________________
Ravi Kumar
…….Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh & others
… Respondents
_______________________________________________________
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sandeep Sharma, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting? 1 Yes.
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Somesh Sharma, Legal Aid Counsel.
For the Respondents: Mr. Rajan Kahol & Mr. Vishal Panwar,
Additional Advocate Generals with Mr. Ravi
Chauhan & Mr. Anish Banshtu, Deputy
Advocates General.
____________________________________________________
Sandeep Sharma, Judge(oral):
The petitioner, who is presently undergoing sentence for
his having committed offences punishable under Sections 20 & 29 of
the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985
(hereinafter referred to as the ‘Act’), has approached this Court in
the instant proceedings filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, for issuance of appropriate writ, order or direction to the
respondents to release him on parole.
2.
Precisely, the facts of the case, as emerge from the
pleadings as well as other material adduced on record by the
respective parties, are that FIR No.19 of 2023 came to be registered
Whether the reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
against the petitioner at Police Station, Palampur, District Kangra,
Himachal Pradesh under Sections 20 & 29 of the Act and Section 192
of MVD Act, on the allegations that commercial quantity of contraband
was recovered from the car of the petitioner, which was found parked
in front of his house. Learned Special Judge-II, Kangra at
Dharamshala, Himachal Pradesh held petitioner guilty of his having
committed offence punishable under the Act and vide judgment dated
07.12.2024, convicted and sentenced him to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for a period of ten years and pay fine to the tune of
Rs. 1, 00,000/- and in default of payment of fine, to further undergo
simple imprisonment for a period of three years under Section 20 of
the Act. After having undergone approximately three years sentence,
petitioner herein applied for grant of parole
before the competent
authority, but such prayer of him came to be rejected vide orders
dated 07.02.2025, 28.02.2025 and 23.07.2025 (Annexures P-2 to P4) on the ground that
petitioner stands convicted for a heinous
offence punishable under Sections 20 and 29 of the Act.
3.
Precisely, the case of the petitioner, as has been
highlighted in the petition and further canvassed by Mr. Somesh
Sharma, learned Legal Aid Counsel representing the petitioner,
is that the gravity of offence alleged to have been committed by
the petitioner cannot be a ground to reject the prayer made on
his behalf for grant of parole, especially when the petitioner
already stands convicted and is undergoing sentence on that
account. Learned counsel representing the petitioner further
submitted that since petitioner, for his having committed offence
punishable under Section 20 & 29 of the Act, has been already
convicted for ten years, coupled with the fact that he has already
undergone sentence of approximately three years, there was no
occasion, if any, for the respondents to reject his prayer for grant
of parole, which he is otherwise entitled to in terms of Rule 3 of
the Himachal Pradesh Good Conduct Prisoners (Temporary
Release) Act, 1968. While referring to orders dated 07.02.2025,
28.02.2025 and 23.07.2025 (Annexures P-2 to P-4), learned
counsel for the petitioner submitted that though conduct of the
petitioner during his stay in jail for approximately three years has
been found to be good and satisfactory, but yet benefit of parole
has been denied to him solely on the ground that he stands
convicted for a heinous crime punishable under Section 20 &29
of the Act and in the event of his being enlarged on parole, he
may again indulge in these activities, whereas in terms of the
Rule
3 of
the Himachal Pradesh Good Conduct Prisoners
(Temporary Release) Act, he is entitled to temporary release on
certain grounds. He submitted that since there is none in the
family to take care of land of the petitioner and petitioner wants
to make necessary arrangement for ploughing, sowing or
harvesting his crop, he is otherwise entitled to be given benefit of
parole for a period of 42 days. He states that since entire family
of the petitioner is residing in District Kangra, coupled with the
fact that genuine reason for parole exist, prayer made on behalf
of the petitioner for grant of parole deserves to be considered.
4.
Per contra, Mr. Rajan Kahol, learned Additional
Advocate General, while referring to the reply filed by the
respondents, submitted that since petitioner is a drug addict and
has been involved in the sale and purchase of narcotic
substances, it may not be in the interest of justice to enlarge him
on parole because in the event of his being enlarged on bail, he
may not only flee from justice, rather may again indulge in these
activities.
5.
Having heard learned counsel representing the
parties and perused the material adduced on record, this Court
finds that petitioner herein, pursuant to his conviction under
Section 20 & 29 of the Act, has been sentenced to undergo
rigorous imprisonment for a period of ten years and pay fine to
the tune of Rs. 1, 00,000/- in terms of judgment dated
07.12.2024. It is not in dispute that petitioner has already
undergone sentence for approximately three years. Rule 3 of
the Himachal Pradesh Good Conduct Prisoners (Temporary
Release) Act entitles a convict to seek temporary release on
parole, which can be granted for one of the reason as detailed in
Rule
3 of
the Himachal Pradesh Good Conduct Prisoners
(Temporary Release) Act, which reads as under:“3. Temporary release of prisoners on certain grounds
.(1) The Government may, in consultation with the
District Magistrate and subject to such conditions and
in such manner as may be prescribed, release
temporarily for a period specified in sub-section (2) any
prisoner if the Government is satisfied that,(a) a member of the prisoner's family has died or is
seriously ill; or
(b) the marriage of the prisoner's son or daughter is to
be celebrated ; or
(c) the temporary release of the prisoner is necessary
for ploughing, sowing or harvesting or carrying on any
other agricultural operation on his land and no friend of
the prisoner or a member of the prisoner's family is
prepared to help him in this behalf in his absence; or
(d) it is desirable so to do for any other sufficient
cause.
(2). The period for which a prisoner may be released
shall be determined by the Government so as not to
exceed,(a) Where the prisoner is to be released on the ground
specified in clause (a) of sub-section (1), two weeks;
(b) where the prisoner is to be released on the ground
specified in clause (b) or clause (d) of sub-section (1),
four weeks; and
(c) where the prisoner is to be released on the ground
specified in clause (c) of sub-section (1), six weeks.
(3) The period of release under this section shall not
count towards the total period of the sentence of a
prisoner.
(4) The Government may, by notification, authorize any
officer to exercise its power under this section in
respect of all or any of the grounds specified therein”.
6.
Rule 3(c) of the Himachal Pradesh Good Conduct
Prisoners (Temporary Release) Act, clearly provides that a
convict can be temporarily released on parole for the purpose of
ploughing, sowing and harvesting or carrying on any other
agriculture operations on his land and no friend of prisoner or a
member of the prisoner’s family is prepared to help him in this
behalf in his absence. In the present case, once petitioner has
been able to establish on record that there is none to plough,
sow or harvest or carry on agriculture operation on his land, he is
entitled to be granted benefit of parole. Prayer made on behalf of
the petitioner for grant of parole cannot be denied on the ground
of gravity of offence alleged to have been committed by him for
which otherwise he already stands convicted and sentenced for
ten years.
7.
By now, it is well settled that Court, while considering
the prayer for parole, is not to be swayed by the nature and
gravity of offence or the sentence which the convict is
undergoing, rather case for grant of parole is to be considered
keeping in view the object of granting parole. It is also to be kept
in mind that a convict despite being convicted is required to
make necessary arrangements for his family as well as his
property, be it moveable or immoveable.
8.
At this stage, it would be profitable to take note of Rule 3
of the Himachal Pradesh Good Conduct Prisoners (Temporary
Release) Act, which inter-alia provides that a convict can be
released on parole for the purpose of ploughing, sowing or
harvesting or carrying on any other agriculture operation on his
land, prayer made on behalf of the petitioner could not have
been rejected by the competent authority solely on the ground
that he stands convicted for a heinous crime and that in the
event of his being enlarged on parole, he may again indulge in
these activities.
9.
At this stage, it would be apt to take note of the
judgment passed by Hon'ble Apex Court in Asfaq versus State
of Rajasthan and other, passed in Civil Appeal No.10464 of
2017 arising out of SLP(C) No.16803 of 2017, wherein Hon'ble
Apex Court, while elaborating upon the object and purpose of
grant of parole, has also drawn a distinction between parole and
furlough.
It has been held that a parole can be defined as
conditional
release of prisoners i.e. an earlier release of
prisoner, conditional on good behaviour and regular reporting to
the authorities for a set period of time, whereas furlough can be
granted in long terms imprisonment. Relevant paras No. 7,9, 12,
16 and 37 of aforesaid judgment are reproduced herein blow:“7) We may state at the outset that the reason because of which
the High Court dismissed the writ petition filed by the appellant
herein is not an apposite one and does not meet the test of law.
The petition is dismissed only on the ground that the appellant is
convicted in a case of serious and heinous crime and, therefore,
parole cannot be claimed as a matter of right. As per the
discussion that would follow hereinafter, the conviction in a
serious and heinous crime cannot be the reason for denying the
parole per se. Another observation made by the High Court is
that since this Court had decided the appeal of the appellant
affirming the conviction, it would not be appropriate for the High
Court to exercise its discretion in favour of the appellant and if he
so desires he may approach this Court for the said purpose. This
again amounts to abdication of the power vested in the High
Court. Insofar as conviction for the offence for which he was
charged, i.e. under the provisions of TADA, is concerned, no
doubt that has been upheld till this Court. However, the issue
before the High Court was entirely different. It was as to whether
the appellant is entitled to the grant of parole for twenty days
which he was claiming. Merely because the matter of conviction
of the appellant had come up to this Court would not mean that
the appellant has to be relegated to this Court every time, even
when he is seeking the reliefs unconnected with the main
conviction. It is more so when in the first instance it is the High
Court which is supposed to decide such a prayer for parole made
by the appellant. With these remarks, we advert to the issue at
hand.
9) There is a subtle distinction between parole and furlough. A
parole can be defined as conditional release of prisoners i.e. an
early release of a prisoner, conditional on good behaviour and
regular reporting to the authorities for a set period of time. It can
also be defined as a form of conditional pardon by which the
convict is released before the expiration of his term. Thus, the
parole is granted for good behaviour on the condition that parolee
regularly reports to a supervising officer for a specified period.
Such a release of the prisoner on parole can also be temporarily
on some basic grounds. In that eventuality, it is to be treated as
mere suspension of the sentence for time being, keeping the
quantum of sentence intact. Release on parole is designed to
afford some relief to the prisoners in certain specified exigencies.
Such paroles are normally granted in certain situations some of
which may be as follows:
(i) a member of the prisoner's family has died or is seriously ill or
the prisoner himself is seriously ill; or
(ii) the marriage of the prisoner himself, his son, daughter,
grandson, grand daughter, brother, sister, sister's son or
daughter is to be celebrated; or
(iii) the temporary release of the prisoner is necessary for
ploughing, sowing or harvesting or carrying on any other
agricultural operation of his land or his father's undivided land
actually in possession of the prisoner; or
(iv) it is desirable to do so for any other sufficient cause;
(v) parole can be granted only after a portion of sentence is
already served;
(vi) if conditions of parole are not abided by the parolee he may
be returned to serve his sentence in prison, such conditions may
be such as those of committing a new offence; and
(vii) parole may also be granted on the basis of aspects related to
health of convict himself.
12) A convict, literally speaking, must remain in jail for the period
of sentence or for rest of his life in case he is a life convict. It is in
this context that his release from jail for a short period has to be
considered as an opportunity afforded to him not only to solve his
personal and family problems but also to maintain his links with
society. Convicts too must breathe fresh air for at least some
time provided they maintain good conduct consistently during
incarceration and show a tendency to reform themselves and
become good citizens. Thus, redemption and rehabilitation of
such prisoners for good of societies must receive due weightage
while they are undergoing sentence of imprisonment.
16) Having noted the aforesaid public purpose in granting parole
or furlough, ingrained in the reformation theory of sentencing,
other competing public interest has also to be kept in mind while
deciding as to whether in a particular case parole or furlough is to
be granted or not. This public interest also demands that those
who are habitual offenders and may have the tendency to commit
the crime again after their release on parole or have the tendency
to become threat to the law and order of the society, should not
be released on parole. This aspect takes care of other objectives
of sentencing, namely, deterrence and prevention. This side of
the coin is the experience that great number of crimes are
committed by the offenders who have been put back in the street
after conviction. Therefore, while deciding as to whether a
particular prisoner deserves to be released on parole or not, the
aforesaid aspects have also to be kept in mind. To put it tersely,
the authorities are supposed to address the question as to
whether the convict is such a person who has the tendency to
commit such a crime or he is showing tendency to reform himself
to become a good citizen.
37) There is a subtle distinction between parole and furlough. A
parole can be defined as conditional release of prisoners i.e. an
early release of a prisoner, conditional on good behaviour and
regular reporting to the authorities for a set period of time. It can
also be defined as a form of conditional pardon by which the
convict is released before the expiration of his term. Thus, the
parole is granted for good behaviour on the condition that parolee
regularly reports to a supervising officer for a specified period.
Such a release of the prisoner on parole can also be temporarily
on some basic grounds. In that eventuality, it is to be treated as
mere suspension of the sentence for time being, keeping the
quantum of sentence intact. Release on parole is designed to
afford some relief to the prisoners in certain specified exigencies.
Such paroles are normally granted in certain situations some of
which may be as follows:
(viii) a member of the prisoner's family has died or is seriously ill
or the prisoner himself is seriously ill; or
(ix) the marriage of the prisoner himself, his son, daughter,
grandson, grand daughter, brother, sister, sister's son or
daughter is to be celebrated; or
(x) the temporary release of the prisoner is necessary for
ploughing, sowing or harvesting or carrying on any other
agricultural operation of his land or his father's undivided land
actually in possession of the prisoner; or
(xi) it is desirable to do so for any other sufficient cause;
(xii) parole can be granted only after a portion of sentence is
already served;
(xiii) if conditions of parole are not abided by the parolee he may
be returned to serve his sentence in prison, such conditions may
be such as those of committing a new offence; and
(xiv) parole may also be granted on the basis of aspects related
to health of convict himself.”
10.
Most importantly, in afore judgment, Hon'ble Apex
Court has held that amongst the various grounds on which
parole can be granted, the most important ground, which stands
out, is that a prisoner should be allowed to maintain family and
social ties and for this purpose, he has to come out for some
time so that he is able to maintain his family and social contact.
Most importantly, Hon'ble Apex Court in aforesaid judgment held
that theory of criminology underlines that the main objectives
which a State intends to achieve by punishing the culprit are:
deterrence, prevention, retribution and reformation. When we
recognize reformation as one of the objectives, it provides
justification for letting of even the life convicts for short periods,
on parole, in order to afford opportunities to such convicts not
only to solve their personal and family problems but also to
maintain their links with the society. Another objective which this
theory underlines is that even such convicts have right to breathe
fresh air, albeit for periods. Most importantly, Hon'ble Apex Court
in aforesaid judgment held that there cannot be any presumption
that a person, who is convicted for serious or heinous crime is to be,
ipso- facto, treated as a hardened criminal, rather hardened criminal
would be a person for whom it has become a habit or way of life and
such a person would necessarily tend to commit crimes again and
again. If a person has committed a serious offence for which he is
convicted, but at the same time it is also found that it is the only crime
he has committed, he cannot be categorized as a hardened criminal.
Hon'ble Apex Court in afore judgment held that release on parole is
designed to afford some relief to the prisoners in certain specified
exigencies, which shall also include temporary release of the prisoner
for ploughing, sowing or harvesting or carrying on any other
agriculture operation on his land or his father’s undivided land actually
in possession of the prisoner.
11.
Careful perusal of the orders laid challenge in the instant
proceedings clearly reveals that behaviour of the petitioner during his
stay in jail for approximately three years was found good and
satisfactory and there was no complaint, if any, against him, but
prayer made on behalf of the petitioner for grant of parole has been
merely rejected on the ground that District Magistrate
as well as
Superintendent of Police area concerned had not recommended his
case on the ground that petitioner is accused of heinous crime and in
the event of his being enlarged on parole, he may again indulge in
these activities.
12.
As has been observed hereinabove and held by Hon'ble
Apex, while considering the prayer made on behalf of the accused for
parole, Courts are not to be swayed by the nature or gravity of offence
committed by the convict, rather such prayer is required to be decided
taking note of various judgments, as has been culled out in para 37 of
the judgment, reproduced hereinabove.
Moreover, in the case at
hand, it cannot be laid down as a proposition of law that a person
convicted for his having committee serious crime is not entitled to be
considered for parole, rather in that situation, very purpose of taking
ground repot from the District Magistrate and Superintendent of
Police, is to ascertain whether in the event of release on parole, there
exists a reasonable likelihood of the prisoner indulging in criminal
activities again. In the present case, District Magistrate as well as
Superintendent of Police, while objecting the parole of the petitioner,
has failed to assign any cogent reason, which may justify their
apprehension that in the event of grant of his release on parole,
petitioner would again indulge in the illegal trade of narcotics. No
doubt, petitioner has been convicted and sentenced to undergo ten
years rigorous imprisonment on account of possessing narcotic
substances, but that does not mean that in the event of his being
enlarged on parole, he would again indulge in these activities,
especially when there is nothing to suggests that prior to registration
of present case, petitioner was involved in any such offences.
Once
for his having done illegal activity, petitioner has been convicted by
the competent court of law, coupled with the fact that there is no other
case against him under the act, prayer made on his behalf for parole
could not have been rejected on the ground that in the event of his
being enlarged on parole, he will again indulge in these activities
again. There is every possibility that after being convicted under
NDPS Act, petitioner would mend his ways and after his having
completed period of sentence, he would come back to mainstream,
but in case aforesaid grounds sought to be raised at the behest of
District Magistrate and Superintendent of Police are accepted and
petitioner is not granted benefit of parole, there is every likelihood of
his becoming harden criminal because in that situation, he will have
no chance to return back to the mainstream.
13.
Consequently, in view of the above, present petition is
allowed and impugned orders dated 07.02.2025, 28.02.2025 and
23.07.2025
(Annexures P-2 to P-4)
are quashed and set
aside. The petitioner is ordered to be released on parole for 42 days
subject to his furnishing personal bond in the sum of ₹ 1,00,000/- with
two sureties in the like amount to the satisfaction of the
Superintendent Jail with an undertaking to maintain good conduct
during
the
period
of
parole
and
to
surrender
before
the
Superintendent Jail after the expiry of the period of parole. The
Probation Officer is also directed to maintain a close watch on the
activities of the petitioner and to report any deviation from the
direction issued by the Court.
14.
The Superintendent Jail is free to impose any other
suitable condition at the time of the release of the petitioner.
March 20,2026
(shankar)
(Sandeep Sharma),
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review