Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~2 (03.03.2026)
*
IN
THE
HIGH
OF
DELHI
AT
NEW
DELHI
Date of Decision: 25th April, 2026.
+
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
RAVI KUMAR TRIPATHI & ORS.
Through:
.....Petitioners
Ms. Amita Singh Kalkal and Ms.
Aditi Gupta, Advocates.
versus
PRINCIPAL
DISTRICT
AND
SESSIONS
JUDGE
HEADQUARTERS TIS HAZARI DISTRICT COURTS DELHI
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Nitesh Kumar Singh, Advocate.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
JUDGMENT
SANJEEV NARULA, J. (Oral):
[As per Notification No. 64/G-4/Gen1.-I/DHC dated 27th February, 2026,
matters listed on 3rd March, 2026 (on account of “Holi”), are to be taken up
on 25th April, 2026.”]
1.
The Petitioners are employees of the Delhi District Courts
establishment, having entered service as Junior Judicial Assistants (earlier
designated as LDCs/Ahlmads/Assistant Ahlmads). Their grievance arises
from a series of orders whereby promotions granted to them to the post of
Judicial Assistant were subsequently withdrawn. The challenge is not
premised on denial of initial consideration; rather, it is undisputed that the
Petitioners were duly promoted, discharged duties on the higher post for
varying periods, and were thereafter reverted on the ground that such
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
promotions were purely officiating in nature.
2.
The Petitioners seek quashing of the orders dated 20th September,
2017, 6th December, 2017 and 13th February, 2019, in so far as those orders
withdrew their promotions. They also seek a direction that no recovery be
made of the salary or arrears paid to them on account of their having worked
as Judicial Assistants pursuant to the promotion orders dated 23 rd August,
2017 and 20th September, 2017.
Factual background
3.
On 29th January, 2013, the Government of NCT of Delhi conveyed
approval for creation of 50 additional posts in the Delhi Higher Judicial
Service and 100 posts in the Delhi Judicial Service, along with ancillary
staff. The communication specifically recorded that the ancillary staff would
be filled as and when the posts of Judicial Officers were filled.
4.
On 2nd December, 2013, the Delhi District Courts Establishment
(Appointment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 20121 were notified. Under
the Rules, the post of Judicial Assistant is a promotion post from the cadre
of Junior Judicial Assistant. The method of recruitment is by promotion on
the basis of seniority-cum-suitability. The eligibility prescribed is five years’
service for graduates and ten years’ service for non-graduates in the post of
Junior Judicial Assistant. The Rules also provide that appointments by
promotion shall be made on officiating basis for a period of two years. The
period of officiation may be extended for reasons to be recorded, but not
beyond double the normal period.
5.
The impugned promotion exercise took place after an earlier round of
litigation concerning the District Courts establishment. By judgment dated
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
22nd March, 2010, this Court in Jagdish Rana & Ors. v. Govt. of NCT of
Delhi & Ors.,2 noticed the adverse effect of administrative delay on the
morale of employees, and directed GNCTD to sanction the upgradation of
posts of LDCs to UDC. Thereafter, in Contempt Case (Civil)
No. 1079/2016, an order dated 2nd May, 2017 came to be passed. The
promotion exercise undertaken in August, 2017 was in compliance with the
aforesaid directions.
6.
The Selection Committee met on 19th August, 2017. The minutes
record that, as on 31st March, 2017, there were 869 + 7 posts to be upgraded
from Junior Judicial Assistant to Judicial Assistant. It further records that 25
more posts of Judicial Assistant were also lying vacant. The total vacant
posts of Judicial Assistant were thus noted as 901.
7.
Pursuant to the recommendations of the Selection Committee, an
order dated 23rd August, 2017 was issued, granting promotion/upgradation
to Junior Judicial Assistants as Judicial Assistants. The Petitioners, except
Ravi Kumar Tripathi (Petitioner No. 1), figured in this order.
8.
On 8th September, 2017, the Selection Committee considered certain
officials, including Petitioner No. 1, who had earlier not been recommended.
By order dated 20th September, 2017, promotion of three officials, including
Sandeep (Petitioner No. 9), was withdrawn and three other officials,
including Petitioner No. 1, were promoted. Petitioner No. 1 was granted
promotion with effect from 16th February, 2014.
9.
On 6th December, 2017, two developments took place. First, the
earlier order dated 23rd August, 2017 was revised and notional dates of
“2012 Rules”
W.P.(C) No. 5686/1998.
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
promotion were granted to several Judicial Assistants; Petitioner Nos. 1-4
and 6 received notional promotion with effect from 11th February, 2014.
Secondly, the promotion of Petitioner No. 5, 7 and 8 was withdrawn.
10.
On 22nd March, 2018, a notification was issued under Rule 19(2) and
(4) of the 2012 Rules notifying 52 vacant posts of Judicial Assistant as on
17th March, 2018 and four likely vacancies due to retirement in 2018.
11.
On 14th January, 2019, the Selection Committee again considered
cases where certain officials had earlier not been promoted or whose cases
had remained under cloud. Pursuant to the minutes of this meeting, the
impugned order dated 13th February, 2019 was issued, whereby the
promotions of, inter alia, Petitioner Nos. 1-4 and 6 were withdrawn and
another set of officials was granted promotion to the post of Judicial
Assistant.
12.
Five days later, on 18th February, 2019, a notification was issued
notifying vacancies for the year 2019. This notification recorded 217 vacant
posts of Judicial Assistant as on 5th February, 2019 and two further
vacancies likely to arise due to retirement in 2019.
13.
Aggrieved by the withdrawal of their promotion, the Petitioners
submitted representations dated 5th March, 2019. The matter was placed
before the Grievances Redressal Committee. In its meeting dated 27 th
March, 2019, the Committee noted that sufficient vacancies existed at the
relevant time from the dates of actual promotion granted to the
“representationists”. It further noted that the “representationists” had worked
on officiating basis against those vacancies and, regular vacancies being in
existence, an effective hearing ought to have been granted before passing an
adverse order of reversion, as the decision was prejudicial to them. The
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
Committee recommended that the representations of Petitioner Nos. 1-6 and
8 be sent to the Selection Committee with a request to afford them a hearing
on their reversions.
On 4th June, 2019, notice was issued for a meeting of the Selection
14.
Committee to be held on 6th June, 2019. The aforesaid Petitioners were
called upon to attend the said meeting. It is the Petitioners’ case that they
appeared, but no speaking order dealing with their grievance was
communicated to them.
15.
The Petitioners thereafter submitted further reminders/representations.
On 25th September, 2021, the Respondent issued a fresh promotion order by
which a large number of Junior Judicial Assistants were promoted as
Judicial Assistants. Several Petitioners also came to be promoted in this
exercise. Petitioner No. 9, however, was found unfit for want of benchmark
in the 2021 exercise. For ease of reference, the relevant position may be
noted in one place:
Date
of Position in order Later
joining
dated 23rd August, revision/notional
District Court 2017
position
Withdrawal
order
S. No.
Name
Ravi Kumar 16th February, Promoted by order
dated
20th
Tripathi
September, 2017,
w.e.f.
16th
February, 2014
Serial No. 838 in 13th February,
order dated 6th 2019
December, 2017,
notional date 11th
February, 2014
and
actual/officiating
date
16th
February, 2014
Rakesh
12th February, Serial
No. 833,
w.e.f.
12th
Singh Rawat 2009
February, 2014,
officiating basis
Serial No. 840 in 13th February,
order dated 6th 2019
December, 2017,
notional
date
11th February,
and
actual/officiating
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
S. No.
Name
Date
of Position in order Later
joining
dated 23rd August, revision/notional
District Court 2017
position
Withdrawal
order
date
12th
February, 2014
Sarika
3rd
August, Serial
No. 834,
w.e.f. 3rd August,
2014, officiating
basis
Serial No. 841 in 13th February,
order dated 6th 2019
December, 2017,
notional date 11th
February, 2014
and
actual/officiating
date 3rd August,
Shobha
28th
April, Serial
No. 835,
th
w.e.f. 28 April,
2014, officiating
basis
Serial No. 842 in 13th February,
order dated 6th 2019
December, 2017,
notional date 11th
February, 2014
and
actual/officiating
date 28th April,
Kavita
Chugh
24th February, Serial
No. 842,
w.e.f.
24th
February, 2014,
officiating basis
Promotion
6th December,
withdrawn
by 2017
order dated 6th
December, 2017
Mohit
Anand
6th May, 2009
Ritu Tyagi
18th
April, Serial
No. 841,
w.e.f. 18th April,
2014, officiating
basis
Kanchan
Sachdeva
18th
May, Serial
No. 843, Promotion
6th December,
th
w.e.f. 18 May, withdrawn
by 2017
2014, officiating order dated 6th
Serial
w.e.f.
2014,
basis
No. 837, Serial No. 844 in 13th February,
May, order dated 6th 2019
officiating December, 2017,
notional date 11th
February, 2014
and
actual/officiating
date 6th May,
th
Promotion
6th December,
withdrawn
by 2017
order dated 6th
December, 2017
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
S. No.
Name
Date
of Position in order Later
joining
dated 23rd August, revision/notional
District Court 2017
position
basis
27th February, Serial
No. 845,
w.e.f.
27th
February, 2014,
officiating basis
Withdrawal
order
December, 2017
Promotion
20th
withdrawn
by September,
order dated 20th 2017
September, 2017
Sandeep
16.
On 1st February, 2022, the Respondent communicated to Petitioner
No. 1 that his representations had been placed before the Selection
Committee in its meetings dated 23rd August, 2021 and 8th September, 2021.
The communication records the Selection Committee’s observed that, 30
cases had been kept in sealed cover and 12 officials were working as
Judicial Assistants purely on officiating basis. It further records that, since
eligible officials had already been promoted in earlier meetings, the officials
working as Judicial Assistants purely on officiating basis had been
considered for regular promotion according to their seniority in the zone of
consideration, and that regular promotion would be effective from the date
of assuming charge.
Petitioners’ Case
17.
Counsel for the Petitioners submits that the impugned withdrawal
orders are violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. It is contended
that the Petitioners were not merely aspirants awaiting consideration for
promotion; they had, in fact, been promoted, assumed charge, and
discharged duties on the higher post, before being reverted. In such
circumstances, the Respondent could not, by a mere recital that the
promotions were “purely officiating,” withdraw the same, particularly when
vacancies in the cadre were available.
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
18.
It is further submitted that the Respondent has failed to address the
central issue, namely, the existence of vacancies. The record, including the
proceedings of the Selection Committee and subsequent notifications,
reflects that substantial vacancies in the cadre of Judicial Assistant existed
during the relevant period. On this basis, it is contended that there was no
administrative necessity to revert the Petitioners. Counsel also contends that
the explanation founded on the “sealed cover” procedure does not justify the
impugned action. While the Petitioners do not dispute the authority of the
Respondent to consider eligible officials who may have been earlier
overlooked, the Respondent could have accommodated both the Petitioners
and subsequently considered officials against the available posts.
19.
It is further urged that the impugned orders are non-speaking,
inasmuch as they merely record withdrawal of promotions and substitution
by other officials, without disclosing any reasons as to why reversion was
unavoidable despite the existence of vacancies, or any consideration of
relevant factors such as service record, suitability, or the effect of continued
officiation. An order entailing civil consequences, it is submitted, must be
reasoned and demonstrably fair.
20.
On the aspect of natural justice, it is submitted that the Petitioners
were not afforded any opportunity of hearing prior to the issuance of the
withdrawal orders. Any subsequent hearing cannot cure the defect as the
orders had already been implemented and no reasoned decision was
thereafter communicated. Reliance is placed on the minutes of the
Grievances Redressal Committee, which records the existence of vacancies
and the necessity of granting an effective hearing prior to passing an adverse
order.
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
21.
Counsel further submits that the Petitioners were otherwise eligible
for promotion, as is evident from their inclusion in the promotion orders.
The withdrawal was not on account of any deficiency in eligibility, service
record, vigilance status, or suitability, but solely to accommodate other
officials at a later stage. It is urged that the Petitioners cannot be made to
suffer for any delay or omission attributable to the Respondent’s own
promotion exercise.
22.
It is further submitted that the District Court establishment is expected
to act as a model employer. Promotions in the establishment had already
suffered considerable delay. In this context, reliance is placed on the
observations of this Court in Jagdish Rana, wherein it was noted that
administrative delay in conferring service benefits has a demoralising effect
on employees. Reliance is also placed on the judgements of the Supreme
Court in Shankarsan Dash v. Union of India,3 and this Court in Sushma
Banga v. Delhi Administration and Ors.4
23.
On the issue of recovery, counsel relies upon State of Punjab v. Rafiq
Masih (White Washer).5 It is submitted that the Petitioners belong to the
lower rungs of the establishment, discharged duties on the higher post
pursuant to orders issued by the employer, and were not guilty of fraud,
misrepresentation or suppression. Any recovery of salary already paid for
work actually performed would be harsh and contrary to settled law.
Respondent’s Case
24.
Counsel for the Respondent submits that the writ petition proceeds on
an erroneous premise. The Petitioners were not granted regular promotions
(1991) 3 SCC 47.
2003 SCC OnLine Del 263.
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
conferring any vested right; rather, their promotions were purely officiating
in nature, made to ensure continuity of work while certain cases remained
under sealed cover or otherwise pending consideration. Upon clearance of
such cases, the officials temporarily promoted were required to yield place.
The withdrawal was therefore a natural consequence of the temporary nature
of the promotion.
25.
It is submitted that the Selection Committee met on 19 th August, 2017
in compliance with the directions passed in Jagdish Rana and the related
contempt proceedings. Out of the total candidates considered, 868 Junior
Judicial Assistants were promoted/upgraded as Judicial Assistants by order
dated 23rd August, 2017. Only a limited number of officials were placed on
officiating basis against posts corresponding to sealed cover cases or in
substitution of officials who could not then be considered due to lack of
eligibility or requisite clearance.
26.
Counsel submits that the Committee was entitled to adopt a procedure
for sealed-cover cases. Officials facing departmental enquiry, criminal
proceedings, fact-finding enquiry or vigilance issues could not be promoted
immediately. To avoid disruption in functioning, temporary officiating
arrangements were made. Such arrangements, by their very nature, were
liable to cessation upon resolution of the claims of the concerned officials.
27.
It is further submitted that the case of Petitioner No. 1 illustrates that
the Respondent acted to rectify errors in the promotion process. Upon
finding that he had been wrongly treated as ineligible, the order dated 20 th
September, 2017 was passed, reverting certain officiating promotes, thus
accommodating him and others.
(2015) 4 SCC 334.
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
28.
With regard to the order dated 6th December, 2017, it is submitted that
the Selection Committee, in its meeting dated 8 th November, 2017, noticed
that certain officials had been described as promoted on a regular basis due
to a typographical error, whereas their promotions were in fact officiating.
The subsequent order merely corrected this clerical mistake, and no vested
right could arise from such an inadvertent description. Further, the order
dated 13th February, 2019, was issued in pursuance of the minutes dated 14 th
January, 2019, wherein certain officials were found fit for promotion after
removal of earlier impediments or upon opening of sealed covers. The
Petitioners, having been promoted only on an officiating basis, were
accordingly reverted in consonance with the terms of their appointment.
29.
The Respondent disputes the allegation that the Petitioners’
representations were not considered. It is submitted that the Grievances
Redressal Committee recommended that they be heard by the Selection
Committee. Thereafter, notice was issued for the meeting dated 6 th June,
2019. Later, their representations were placed before the Selection
Committee in its meetings dated 23rd August, 2021 and 8th September, 2021.
By communication dated 1st February, 2022, the Petitioners were informed
that their representations had been disposed of and that their regular
promotion would be effective from the date of assuming charge pursuant to
the later promotion exercise.
30.
Counsel submits that the Petitioners cannot claim regular promotion
merely because vacancies existed. Promotion to a post depends not only on
vacancy but also on seniority, zone of consideration, suitability, vigilance
status, benchmark, availability of records and the recommendation of the
competent Committee. Reliance is placed on Union of India v. K.K.
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
Vadera,6 to submit that promotion takes effect from the date it is granted
and not from the date on which the vacancy arises. Reliance is also placed
on Union of India & Anr. v. Manpreet Singh Poonam,7 where the Supreme
Court reiterated that an employee has no vested right to promotion and that
delay in consideration does not itself create a right to retrospective
promotion.
31.
On the issue of recovery, it is submitted that no recovery has been
effected from the Petitioners thus far. Counsel for the Respondent states that
any decision in that regard, if required, would be taken in accordance with
the governing rules, applicable judgements, and directions of this Court.
Points for determination
32.
Having heard counsel and examined the record, the following
questions arise for consideration:
Whether the impugned withdrawal orders dated 20 th September, 2017,
(i)
6th December, 2017 and 13th February, 2019 suffer from arbitrariness or
procedural unfairness in so far as they reverted the Petitioners from the post
of Judicial Assistant despite the recorded vacancy position in that cadre.
Whether the Respondent’s justification that the Petitioners were
(ii)
promoted only on officiating basis, against sealed-cover or temporarily
unavailable cases, is sufficient in law to sustain the withdrawals without a
recorded consideration of available vacancies.
(iii)
Whether the Petitioners are entitled to restoration, continuity, notional
benefits or any other consequential relief in the cadre of Judicial Assistant.
(iv)
Whether the Respondent can recover salary or arrears paid to the
Union of India v. K.K. Vadera, 1989 Supp (2) SCC 625.
Civil Appeal Nos. 517-518 of 2018, decided on 8th March, 2022.
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
Petitioners for the period during which they actually worked as Judicial
Assistants.
Analysis
33.
The present case calls for a limited yet careful inquiry. It is not
necessary to lay down, as an absolute proposition, that every officiating
promotion confers a vested right; it plainly does not. Equally, it cannot be
accepted that the mere description of a promotion as “officiating” confers an
unfettered power on the employer to withdraw it without reasons, without
affording an opportunity of hearing, and without examining whether such
reversion is administratively warranted.
34.
The Respondent’s position is, to a limited extent, justified. In the 2017
exercise, certain officials could not be considered owing to sealed cover
proceedings, vigilance issues, or erroneous assessment of eligibility. Upon
subsequent clearance, the administration was entitled to consider such
officials in accordance with their seniority and eligibility, and a junior
employee cannot ordinarily claim precedence over a senior who was earlier
excluded for valid reasons.
35.
However, this does not conclude the issue before the Court. The
Petitioners do not dispute the entitlement of such officials to promotion;
their contention is that their own reversion was unwarranted in view of the
availability of vacancies. While the Respondent has explained the basis for
promoting other officials, it has not satisfactorily addressed the necessity of
reverting the Petitioners despite the existence of vacant posts.
36.
The record reflects that vacancies persisted throughout the relevant
period. The minutes dated 19th August, 2017 record 901 vacant posts of
Judicial Assistant, of which 868 were filled. Subsequent notifications dated
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
22nd March, 2018 and 18th February, 2019 indicate continuing vacancies,
including 217 posts shortly prior to the order dated 13 th February, 2019. This
position is further corroborated by the RTI material placed on record.
37.
The Respondent has not placed on record any reasoned decision
demonstrating why the available vacancies could not be utilised to
accommodate the Petitioners, at least until a regular promotion exercise was
undertaken. The impugned orders proceed on the assumption that the only
permissible course was to substitute one set of employees with another.
Such an assumption is not self-evident. Where vacancies exist within the
cadre, and an employee has already been promoted and discharged duties on
the higher post, the administration is required to justify why reversion is
unavoidable; however, no such consideration is borne from the record.
38.
This deficiency is accentuated by the findings of the Grievances
Redressal Committee in its minutes dated 27 th March, 2019, recording that
adequate vacancies existed at the relevant time, that the Petitioners had
worked on an officiating basis against such vacancies, and that an effective
opportunity of hearing ought to have preceded an adverse order of reversion.
This observation emanates not from the Petitioners, but from an internal
committee of the Respondent itself. While the Selection Committee was not
bound to accept this view, it was incumbent upon them to address the same
by a reasoned determination. The record does not indicate that such
consideration was undertaken.
39.
The subsequent hearing does not cure this defect. Although notices
were issued for a meeting of the Selection Committee, and the Petitioners
are stated to have participated, no reasoned or speaking order has been
placed on record addressing their specific grievance. The communication
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
dated 1st February, 2022 merely states that their representations were
considered and that regular promotions would operate prospectively in
accordance with seniority. This does not address the prior question as to why
their reversion in 2017 and 2019 was warranted despite the existence of
vacancies.
40.
The distinction is material. The Petitioners’ claim comprises two
aspects: first, a claim for retrospective regular promotion; and second, a
challenge to the withdrawal of promotions already granted and acted upon.
The Respondent’s reliance on K.K. Vadera and Manpreet Singh Poonam
pertains primarily to the former. Those decisions affirm that promotion does
not ordinarily relate back to the date of vacancy and that no vested right
arises merely from the existence of a vacancy. That principle is well settled.
However, the present case is not one of a mere claim to retrospective
promotion. The Petitioners were promoted by the employer, discharged
duties on the higher post, and were subsequently reverted despite the
availability of vacancies.
41.
In this context, the principle in Shankarsan Dash assumes relevance.
While inclusion in a select list does not confer an indefeasible right to
appointment, the State is equally precluded from acting arbitrarily or
refusing appointment without valid reason. This principle operates both
ways: it prevents a claim to promotion solely on the basis of vacancy, but
equally obliges the Respondent to demonstrate a rational basis for not
accommodating employees who had already been promoted, particularly
where vacancies were available.
42.
The 2012 Rules also merit careful consideration. Rule 21 stipulates
that promotions shall be on an officiating basis for a period of two years.
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
This does not imply that a promotee acquires automatic regularisation upon
completion of such period, irrespective of seniority, suitability, or cadre
position. To that extent, the Petitioners’ contention cannot be accepted in
absolute terms. At the same time, officiation cannot be regarded as a wholly
fragile arrangement capable of being unsettled at any time without
justification. Where an employee has continued to officiate, has discharged
duties on the post, and vacancies are available, any order of reversion must
be supported by cogent administrative reasons. Beyond a general assertion
that other officials were promoted “in place of” the Petitioners, no such
justification is forthcoming.
43.
There is also no allegation that the Petitioners secured promotion by
fraud, misrepresentation, or any form of manipulation. Their promotions
were effected pursuant to a comprehensive promotion exercise, and the
subsequent withdrawals arose from the Respondent’s own reassessment of
sealed-cover cases, eligibility, and service records. The Petitioners cannot be
faulted for consequences flowing from such administrative processes.
44.
The Respondent’s submission that no recovery has been effected does
not render the issue academic. The Petitioners’ apprehension arises from the
withdrawal of promotions. The legal position is settled. In Rafiq Masih, the
Supreme Court held that recovery from employees in the lower rungs of
service, in the absence of fraud or misrepresentation, is impermissible where
it would operate harshly or inequitably. The Petitioners discharged duties of
the higher post under orders of the Respondent and received corresponding
remuneration. In the absence of any allegation of wrongdoing, recovery
would unjustly penalise them for compliance with official orders.
45.
In these circumstances, the impugned orders cannot be sustained to
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
the extent they withdraw the Petitioners’ promotions without consideration
of available vacancies and without a reasoned determination as to the
necessity of reversion. At the same time, a direction granting retrospective
regular promotion from the dates of officiation may disturb existing
seniority and affect the rights of third parties, and may also bypass the
statutory scheme governing promotions. The appropriate course, therefore,
is to set aside the impugned withdrawal orders, insofar as they affect the
Petitioners, and remit the matter to the competent Selection Committee for a
fresh and reasoned consideration in accordance with law.
46.
The fresh consideration must not be an empty formality. The
Committee shall specifically examine: (i) the vacancy position in the cadre
of Judicial Assistant on the relevant dates, including 20 th September, 2017,
6th December, 2017 and 13th February, 2019; (ii) whether the Petitioners
could have been accommodated against available vacancies without
disturbing the claims of senior or sealed-cover candidates later found
suitable; (iii) whether any Petitioner was otherwise ineligible, unfit or
outside the zone of consideration at the relevant time; and (iv) the effect of
the Petitioners having worked as Judicial Assistants pursuant to the earlier
promotion orders.
47.
For Sandeep (Petitioner No. 9), the Committee shall separately
consider his case. His promotion was withdrawn on 20 th September, 2017.
The Respondent has further stated that he was found unfit in the 2021
exercise due to non-fulfilment of the prescribed benchmark. While such
subsequent assessment may be relevant for the 2021 promotion exercise, it
cannot, by itself, determine the validity of the withdrawal effected in 2017.
The Committee shall therefore examine whether the withdrawal of his
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
promotion, in the context of the vacancies then available and the reasons
recorded, or not recorded, in the order dated 20th September, 2017, was
justified.
48.
In respect of Kavita Chugh, Ritu Tyagi and Kanchan Sachdeva
(Petitioner Nos. 5, 7 and 8), whose promotions were withdrawn by order
dated 6th December, 2017, their cases shall be reconsidered with reference to
the vacancy position prevailing at the relevant time and the reasons which
led to such withdrawal.
49.
As regards Ravi Kumar Tripathi, Rakesh Singh Rawat, Sarika,
Shobha and Mohit Anand (Petitioner Nos. 1, 2, 3, 4 and 6), whose
promotions were withdrawn by order dated 13th February, 2019, their cases
shall be examined with reference to the vacancy position as it then stood,
including the notification dated 18th February, 2019 recording 217 vacant
posts of Judicial Assistant as on 5th February, 2019, as well as the minutes of
the Grievances Redressal Committee dated 27th March, 2019.
Relief
50.
For the reasons stated above, the writ petition is disposed of in the
following terms:
The orders dated 20th September, 2017, 6th December, 2017 and 13th
(i)
February, 2019 are set aside to the limited extent they withdraw the
promotions of the Petitioners, subject to fresh consideration by the
competent Selection Committee in terms of this order.
(ii)
The competent Selection Committee shall reconsider the cases of the
Petitioners in the light of the observations made above and shall pass a
reasoned order within twelve weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order.
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
(iii)
While reconsidering the matter, the Committee shall specifically deal
with the vacancy position in the cadre of Judicial Assistant on the relevant
dates and shall record whether the Petitioners could or could not have been
accommodated against available vacancies without prejudice to the claims
of officials who were senior, eligible or later found fit.
(iv)
If, upon such reconsideration, the Committee finds that any Petitioner
could have been accommodated against an available vacancy, consequential
benefits shall be considered in accordance with law. Such benefits may
include continuity, notional fixation, seniority or monetary benefits, as may
be permissible under the 2012 Rules and without unsettling rights already
crystallised in favour of third parties, except in accordance with law.
(v)
No recovery shall be made from the Petitioners of the salary or arrears
paid to them for the period during which they actually worked as Judicial
Assistants pursuant to the orders dated 23rd August, 2017, 20th September,
2017 or 6th December, 2017. Any recovery already made, if any, shall be
refunded within eight weeks.
51.
The writ petition is disposed of in the above terms. Pending
applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
APRIL 25, 2026
as
Digitally Signed
By:AKANSHA SINGH
14:54:10
W.P.(C) 1349/2022
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review