Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:25623-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 2284 of 2025
1 - Smt. Rambai Choudhari W/o Ghursai Choudhari Aged About 50 Years R/o
Village- Dongariya, Police Station- Pendra, District- Gourela-Pendra-Marwahi
(C.G.)
2 - Smt. Rukhmani Choudhari W/o Dhane Choudhari Aged About 28 Years R/o
Bhalaur, District- Manendragarh At Present Resident Of Village- Dongariya,
Police Station- Pendra, District- Gourela-Pendra-Marwahi (C.G.)
3 - Bhimsen Choudhari S/o Rammilan Choudhari Aged About 19 Years R/o
Village- Dongariya, Police Station- Pendra, District- Gourela-Pendra-Marwahi
(C.G.)
4 - Fulchand Choudhari S/o Ghursai Choudhari Aged About 35 Years R/o
Village- Dongariya, Police Station- Pendra, District- Gourela-Pendra-Marwahi
(C.G.)
--- Appellants)
Versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through The Station House Officer, Police Station- Kota,
District- Bilaspur (C.G.)
--- Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Pritam Tiwari and Ms. Nirupama Bajpai,
Advocates.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Nitansh Jaiswal, Deputy Government Advocate.
CRA No. 6 of 2026
1 - Ravi Choudhari S/o Fulchand Choudhari, Aged About 45 Years R/o VillageKhairi, Singhpur Venkatnagar, Police Station- Jaithari, District Anuppur (M.P.)
At Present R/o Village- Dongariya, Police Station- Pendra, District GourelaPendra- Marwahi (C.G.)
2 - Ramprasad Choudhari S/o Besahan Choudhari, Aged About 43 Years R/o
Village- Khairi, Singhpur Venkatnagar, Police Station- Jaithari, District Anuppur
(M.P.) At Present R/o Village- Dongariya, Police Station- Pendra, District
Gourela- Pendra- Marwahi (C.G.)
---Appellant(s)
Versus
State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Station House Officer, Police Station Kota,
District Bilaspur (C.G.)
--- Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Sudhir Kumar Bajpai (Amicus Curiae)
For Respondent(s) : Mr. Nitansh Jaiswal, Deputy Government Advocate.
Hon’ble Mr. Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
23/06/2026
1. Heard Ms. Nirupama Bajpai as well as Mr. Pritam Tiwari, learned
counsel for the appellants {in Cr.A. No. 2284/2025} and Mr. Sudhir
Kumar Bajpai, learned Amicus Curiae for the appellants {in Cr.A. No.
6/2026} as well as Mr. Nitansh Jaiswal, learned Deputy Government
Advocate for the State/respondent.
2. Today, these matters are listed for hearing on application for suspension
of sentence and grant of bail, however, with the consent of learned
counsel appearing for the parties, we proceed to hear the matter finally.
IA No. 3/2025 is an application for permission to engage counsel for the
appellants. The application is ordered as prayed for and Mr. Pritam
Tiwari, Advocate is permitted to appear and argue on behalf of the
appellants in Cr.A. No. 2284/2025.
3. Challenge in these appeals is to the judgment of conviction and order of
sentence dated 29.09.2025 passed in Sessions Trial No. 197/2021 by
the Second Additional Sessions Judge, Bilaspur, by which each of the
appellants have been convicted and sentenced as under:
Conviction under
Section
Jail Sentence
Fine
Default
Sentence
(Rigorous)
(Rigorous)
147 of the Indian 2 years
Penal Code (for short,
the IPC)
-
-
148 IPC
3 years
-
-
302/149 IPC
Life
Rs. 1200/-
1 years
4. There were total 08 accused in this case out of which, one of the
accused namely Kanhaiya Choudhari expired during the trial. One of the
accused was a child in conflict with law, who has been tried separately.
The present appeals pertains to the accused Smt. Rambai Choudhari,
Smt. Rukhmani Choudhari, Bhimsen Choudhari, Fulchand Choudhari,
Ravi Choudhari and Ramprasad Choudhari.
5. The case of the prosecution, in brief is that on 21.02.2021, the
complainant Sarvesh Manhar (PW-8) lodged a report at Police Station
Kota stating that he and his family had gone on 21.02.2021 to visit the
Marhi Mata Temple situated at Bhanwartank. After offering prayers at
the temple, they cooked food there in the afternoon and at about 5:00
p.m. were sitting and eating food with their family members. During this
time, some persons who were eating food nearby were quarreling
amongst themselves. When the complainant's side objected and asked
them not to quarrel, 7–8 accused persons assaulted the complainant's
side with sticks and an iron cooking implement (Kevcha). Due to the
injuries sustained, Karan Ratre (hereinafter referred to as ‘the
deceased’) from the complainant's side died and other persons also
received injuries. On the basis of the complainant's report, an offence
was registered at Police Station Kota and investigation was undertaken.
During investigation, a spot map (Exhibit P-32) was prepared. Inquest
proceedings over the dead body were conducted. An application for
post-mortem examination was prepared and the post-mortem was
conducted at CHC Kota. On inspection of the place of occurrence and
on the basis of a seized receipt fragment, the temple committee receipt
book, photographs, etc., accused Ravi Choudhari, Kanhaiya Choudhari,
Ramprasad Choudhari were taken into custody and produced before the
Executive Magistrate, Belgahna. The complainant identified accused
Ravi Choudhari, Kanhaiya Choudhari and Ramprasad Choudhari.
Identification proceedings were conducted in the presence of the
complainant and witnesses. On the basis of the memorandam of Ravi
Choudhari and Kanhaiya Choudhari, it was found that Bhimsen
Choudhary, Phoolchand Choudhari, Smt. Rambai Choudhari and Smt.
Rukhmani Choudhari had also participated in the assault; therefore, their
memorandum statements were recorded. On the basis of the
memorandum statements of the accused persons, two wooden sticks
used in the incident were seized. Statements of the complainant and
other witnesses were recorded and examined. The accused persons
were arrested and witness statements were reduced into writing.
6. After completion of the entire investigation, a charge-sheet was filed
before the learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Kota, which was
registered as Criminal Case No. 232/2021. Thereafter, the case was
committed to the Court of Sessiosn where it was registered as S.T. No.
197/2021.
7. Charges were framed against the appellants for the offences under
Sections 147, 148, 294, 302, 302/149 and 506-B of the IPC. The
appellants denied the charges and prayed for trial.
8. In order to bring home the offence, the prosecution examined as many as
26 witnesses namely Santosh Kumar Rathore (PW-1), Dr. Sandeep
Dwivedi (PW-2), Harprasad (PW-3), Aman Khandekar (PW-4), Rekha
Samundre (PW-5), Harendra Kumar Manhar (PW-6), Jittu Kurre (PW-7),
Sarvesh Manhar (PW-8), Devdas Ratre (PW-9), Indrapal Divakar (PW10), Kedar Banjare (PW-11), Vijay Kumar Joshi (PW-12), Lal Ji Tandiya
(PW-15), Suraj Rajak (PW-16), Pitambar Porte (PW-17), Mulchand Soni
(PW-18), Virendra Bahadur Singh (PW-19), Kamleshwar Singh (PW20), Shivam Pandey (PW-21), Hemlal Prajapati (PW-22), Onkar Prasad
Banjare (PW-23), Dinesh Kumar chandra (PW-24), Ajay Ware (PW-25)
and Dr. Avdhesh Kumar Sahu (PW-26) and exhibited as many as 46
exhibits and three Articles. In support of their, the appellants got the
police statement of Rekha Samundre and Suraj Rajak, exhibited as
Exhibits D/1 and D/2.
9. The statement of the appellants under section 313 Cr.P.C was recorded
by the learned trial Court wherein they stated that they were innocent
and had been falsely implicated in this case. Either they expressed their
ignorance or denied the questions.
10.
The learned trial Judge, after considering the evidence on record, has
convicted the appellant as detailed in the opening paragraph. Hence,
these appeals.
11.
Mr. Sudhir Kumar Bajpai, learned Amicus Curiae and Mr. Pritam Tiwari
learned counsel appearing for the respective appellants submit that the
accused party and the complainant party had gone for a picnic and while
preparing food, a scuffle took place. There was no pre-planning and the
appellants were not even armed with any weapon. The learned trial
Court has failed to consider that the witness of test identification parade
has not supported the case of the prosecution and has turned hostile.
Most of the prosecution witnesses have turned hostile. Based on the
memorandum statement, the appellants have been implicated in this
case. It is next submitted by the learned counsel for the appellants that
the FIR was lodged against unknown persons and only one witness,
Rekha Samudre (PW-5), identified the accused persons for the first time
in Court and stated that they had committed the offence. The remaining
witnesses refused to identify the accused persons. Even Sarvesh
Manhar (PW-8) and Lalji Tandiya (PW-15), through whom the police
had conducted the test identification proceedings, did not identify the
accused persons before the Court. The prosecution had not conducted
any identification proceedings through witness Rekha Samudre (PW-1).
Therefore, when for the first time in Court she identified the accused
persons, such identification cannot be relied upon for connecting the
accused with the crime. The place where the incident took place was a
picnic spot and there was a large gathering of people and among those
large number, the prosecution witness could not have properly identified
the real assailants.
There are omissions and contradictions in the
statement of the prosecution witnesses and there is no material on
record to connect the appellants with the offence in question and as
such, the order passed by the learned trial Court convicting and
sentencing the appellants deserves to be set aside and the appellants
be acquitted of the charges.
12.
On the other hand, Mr.Nitansh Jaiswal, learned Deputy Government
Advocate appearing for the State/respondents submits that the learned
trial Court has passed the judgment of conviction and order of sentence
after proper appreciation of the materials available on record which
deserves no interference and as such, these appeals be dismissed.
Minor contradictions in the statement of witnesses cannot be termed as
fatal for the prosecution so as to grant acquittal to the appellants.
13.
We have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties, perused the
pleadings and materials available on record with utmost circumspection.
14.
The first question for consideration would be whether the death of the
deceased was homicidal in nature, which has been answered in
affirmative by the learned trial Court, based on the postmortem report
and the deposition of the Doctor who had conducted the postmortem.
15.
Dr. Sandeep Dwivedi (PW-02) who had conducted the postmortem,
stated that on 22.02.2021, Police Constable Anil of Police Station Kota
produced
the
dead
body
for
post-mortem
examination.
Upon
examination, vide his report (Exhibit P/1), he found that externally, the
body was in a state of rigor mortis. Both hands and legs were straight
and parallel to each other. Blood was coming out from both nostrils. Both
eyes and mouth were partially open. There was a raised and swollen
injury over the occipital bone of the skull. No fecal matter or semen was
found on the undergarments. On examination of skull and spine, the
meninges of the brain were swollen and compressed. Internal subdural
and subarachnoid hemorrhage was present in the brain. Clotted blood
was present in both chambers of the heart. Undigested food material
was present in the stomach. The nature of death appeared to be
homicidal and the cause of death was excessive internal bleeding
resulting from severe injuries to the internal organs of the brain. The time
of death was approximately 18 to 24 hours prior to the post-mortem
examination. This aspect has not been disputed even by the learned
counsel appearing for the appellants and as such, we affirm the finding
arrived at by the learned trial Court that the nature of death of the
deceased was homicidal.
16.
Now the question remains for consideration for this Court is whether the
appellants are the assailants who committed murder of the deceased?
17.
Even as per the prosecution story, on the date of incident, a large
number of people gathered in the area where the incident took place, for
visiting the temple and for picnic purpose. There were different groups of
people preparing food at various places. The case of the prosecution is
that the accused/appellants were quarelling among each other and
hurling abuses which was objected to by the complainant party stating
that there were ladies and they should not hurl abuses upon which
verbal duel took place. Later, it escalated into a fight using wooden
sticks and and iron Kevcha.
18.
According to the identification memo (Exhibit P/10 and P/11), the test
identification parade was conducted in presence of Executive Magistrate
Belgahna,
and
Sarvesh
Manhar
(PW-8)
identified
Ramprasad
Choudhari, Kanhaiya Choudhari and Ravi Choudhari in presence of
witnesses Lalji Tandiya (PW-15) and Hemlal Prajapati (PW-22).
Similarly, Sarvesh Manhar (PW-8) also identified Fulchand Choudhari.
However, this fact has been denied by Sarvesh Manhar (PW-8) in his
deposition before the learned trial Court.
19.
According to the prosecution, there are three injured witnesses namely
Rekha Samundre (PW-5), Harendra Kumar Manhar (PW-6) and Jittu
Kurre (PW-7). The injuries sustained by Rekha Samundre and Harendra
Kumar Manhar are reported to be simple in nature as is evident from
Exhibit P/44 and P/45. However, the injury sustained (Exhibit P/46) by
Jittu Kurrey (PW-7) is stated to be grievous.
20.
Only Rekha Samundre (PW-5) has deposed in support of the
prosecution whereas the other two witnesses, namely Harendra Kumar
Manhar (PW-6) and Sarvesh Manhar (PW-7) have turned hostile.
Rekha Samundre has identified the accused persons for the first time
before the learned trial Court and she was not the part of the test
identification parade. Harendar Kumar Manhar (PW-6) stated before the
learned trial Court that he cannot identify the accused present in the
Court and even on showing the arrest memo in which the photographs of
the accused were pasted, denied to identify them. He is one of the
injured eye witness. Similar is the case with other injured eye witness
namely Jittu Kurre (PW-6). He has also been declared hostile as he
could not identify the accused persons.
21.
The allegation against the appellants/convicts are that the deceased was
done to death after a scuffle between the two parties and the deceased
was assaulted by stick and a Kevcha, which is an article used for
cooking and is made up of iron. There is no specific allegation against
any appellant as to who assaulted the deceased or the injured person
with which weapon. Even the injured eye witnesses namely Harendra
Kumar Manhar (PW-6) and Jittu Kurre (PW-7) have turned hostile and
not supported the prosecution case and have even denied that any test
identification parade was conducted. Rekha Samundre (PW-5), though
has tried to state that she could identify the accused persons, but she
was not the part of the test identification parade and has identified the
accused/appellants for the first time before the learned trial Court.
However, she could not tell the name of any of the appellant or that
which appellant caused injuries to which person.
22.
Ajay Ware, Inspector (PW-25) has deposed that he had seized an iron
Kevcha measuring 77 cms. In length which was seized from one of the
accused, a child in conflict with law, and the seizure memo was annexed
with the documents of the trial of the said child. There is no FSL report
so as to indicate the presence of human blood on the Kevcha or the
wooden sticks seized by the police. There is even no query report of the
Doctor which could have thrown some light on the aspect whether the
said weapon could have been used to cause injuries to the deceased.
23.
On careful consideration of the materials available on record, we are of
the considered opinion that the prosecution has failed to prove its case
beyond reasonable doubt for the offences with which the appellants had
been charged. There is no incriminating material available in this case
which could connect the appellants with the crime in question. The
alleged identification made by the witness Rekha Samundre (PW-5) also
appears to be doubtful as when two of the injured witnesses have
denied to identify the assailants, especially when one of the witness
sustained grievous injury. The absence of FSL report also goes against
the prosecution case.
24.
In view of the above discussion, this Court is of the considered opinion
that the prosecution has failed to establish its case beyond reasonable
doubt and the judgment passed by the learned trial Court needs
interference and as such, the judgment of conviction and order of
sentence dated 29.09.2025 is hereby set aside and the above
appellants/convicts are acquitted of the charges.
25.
Resultantly, these appeal stand allowed. Pending interlocutory
applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
26.
The appellants/convict are reported to be in jail. They are directed to be
released forthwith unless wanted in any other case. However, keeping in
view the provision of Section 437-A of the Cr.P.C. {Section 481 of the
BNSS}, the accused-appellants are directed to furnish a personal bond
for a sum of Rs. 25,000/- with two sureties each in the like amount
before the court concerned which shall be effective for a period of six
months along with an undertaking that in the event of filing of Special
Leave Petition against the instant judgment or for grant of leave, the
aforesaid appellants, on receipt of notice thereof, shall appear before the
Supreme Court.
27.
Registry is directed to transmit the trial court record along with a copy of
this order to the trial court concerned forthwith for necessary information
and compliance.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
JUDGE
Amit
AMIT
KUMAR
DUBEY
Digitally signed
by AMIT KUMAR
DUBEY
Date: 2026.06.29
17:54:40 +0530
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
CHIEF JUSTICE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review