Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:HHC:45825
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
CWP No.20737 of 2025
Decided on: 01.07.2026
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Rattan Sain
…..Petitioner
Versus
State of H.P.
.
.....Respondent
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Coram
Ms. Justice Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Whether approved for reporting? 1 Yes
For the Petitioner:
Mr. Chander Shekhar Chauhan,
Advocate.
For the Respondent:
Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General
with Mr. Sikandar Bhushan, Deputy
Advocate General.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Jyotsna Rewal Dua, Judge
Petitioner seeks direction to the respondentState Education Department to return him possession of
the land given by his grandfather about 50 years ago to the
respondent- State Education Department for the purpose of
running a Government school. Prayer has been made on
the factual assertion that school is not being run on the
land in question, therefore, the purpose for which the land
was given, has been abandoned by the State.
Whether reporters of print and electronic media may be allowed to see the order? Yes.
2025:HHC:45825
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and
considered the case file.
2(i)
The case set up by
the petitioner is that his
grandfather ‘gave’ his owned land comprised in Khewat No.
89/81, Khatauni No. 224/216 min, Khasra NoS. 913 and
914,
measuring
respectively,
00-01-20
&
00-00-94,
hectares
situated at Sub Tehsil Dhamwari, Kanungo
Circle Dhamwari, Patwar Circle Sindhasali,
District
Shimla. The land was given to the respondent- State
Education Department for running a Government Primary
School at the native village of the petitioner’s grandfather.
The State Education Department opened Government
Primary School Gokaswari over the aforesaid land, which
was later upgraded as Middle School, which continued in
old dilapidated two rooms building. During the year 2017,
aforesaid Middle School
State
was closed by the respondent-
Education Department there being nil student
enrolment. This was due to the fact that Government Senior
Secondary School had become operational at Dhamwari, at
walking distance from the closed Middle School. On
17.08.2024, respondent- State Education Department also
closed down the Primary School Gokaswari because of nonavailability of students. Teaching staff of the aforesaid
2025:HHC:45825
school was shifted to the Government school at Dhamwari.
A Government Primary School is running just adjacent to
the Government Senior Secondary School Dhamwari.
2(ii)
Petitioner’s case is that by the closure of the
Government
Primary
School
Gokaswari,
for
which
petitioner’s grandfather had parted with his land, the
purpose for giving the land to the Government was
defeated/abandoned; Petitioner’s grandfather had given his
land to the respondent-State Education Department only
for running the Government school in the
interest of
welfare of the villagers as at that time, no school was in
existence in the area for the villagers and students; The
Government Primary School Gokaswari functioned over this
land till 17.08.2024 In view of closure of school due to nonavailability of
students and
availability of Government
Primary School as also the Senior Secondary School in the
vicinity i.e. at Dhamwari, petitioner served legal notice to
the
respondent-
State
Education
Department
on
29.08.2025 for giving him back the possession of the land
in question. Failure of the respondent to do the needful
compelled the petitioner to institute this writ petition for
grant of following substantive relief:-
2025:HHC:45825
“1.
That the appropriate writ may kindly be issued, with
the Prayer that the Piece of the land which is given
by the owner of the land to the concerned government
Education department was only for the purpose of
running the government school at his native village.
Now
the
school
is
closed
by
the
concerned
Government Education department in year 2024
because of the non availability of the student. The
purpose
of
giving
the
land
to
the
Education
department by the owner of the land, is defeated, as
the government Education department ordered the
closure of the school. To see and take this fact into
the consideration may kindly passed an order to
giving the possession of the land to the owner of the
land and may also passed the order of the
appropriate disposal of the dilapidated two rooms
building of the school and as the Hon'ble High court
may thinks fit, in the interest of justice.”
2(iii)
(i)
Respondent in its reply has pleaded that:The land was donated/gifted by the petitioner’s
grandfather to the respondent- State Education Department
about
50 years ago for the purpose of
running a
Government Primary School. In view of the said objective
and in public interest, the respondent-State Education
Department
had
established
Government
Primary
School Gokaswari, which remained functional for a period
of
about
years;
(ii)
The
Government
took
administrative/ policy decision for merger of various
schools in the State having five or less than five students
2025:HHC:45825
enrolment, with the nearest schools.
Additionally, some
schools with zero student enrolment have been de-notified.
Consequently, Government Primary School Gokaswari was
merged
on 17.08.2024 with nearby school namely GCPS
Dhamwari, District Shimla due to low student enrolment.
Vacant rooms of the Government Primary School Gokaswari
(GPS) have been handed over by the Directorate of
Education on 25.09.2025 to Anganwari Kendra Ambani on
temporary basis.
At this is stage, it will be relevant to notice
counter averments made by the petitioner in rejoinder that
Anganwari Center in question was previously being run in
a building just adjust adjacent to Government Primary
School Gokaswari; Anganwari Center has been
be shifted to GPS Gokaswari
ordered to
by the respondent on
25.09.2025 only after the respondent-State Education
Department received the legal notice dated 20.08.2025,
from the petitioner seeking possession of his land.
This
shifting was ordered in order to defeat petitioner’s rightful
claim.
3.
Consideration
3(i)
Respondent-State Education Department has
not disputed the land in question having been given to
2025:HHC:45825
them by petitioner’s grandfather. It is also not disputed by
the respondent that purpose for giving the land was to run
Government Primary School thereupon.
It is the pleaded
case of the respondent that Government Primary School
Gokaswari functioned over the land in question for about
50 years, but this school was closed on 17.08.2024 and
now stands merged with an adjoining school i.e. GCPS
Dhamwari, District Shimla. The record demonstrates that
respondent decided to utilize the land of the petitioner for
running Anganwari
Kendra Ambani after receipt of legal
notice from him, seeking possession of his land.
3(ii)
To retain possession of petitioner’s land, the
respondent has fallen back upon Section 126 of the
Transfer of Property Act, 1882, (the Act in short), that reads
as under:“126. When gift may be suspended or revoked.—
The donor and donee may agree that on the
happening of any specified event which does not
depend on the will of the donor a gift shall be
suspended or revoked; but a gift which the parties
agree shall be revocable wholly or in part, at the mere
will of the donor, is void wholly or in part, as the case
may be.
A gift may also be revoked in any of the cases
(save want or failure of consideration) in which, if it
were a contract, it might be rescinded.
Save as aforesaid, a gift cannot be revoked.
2025:HHC:45825
Nothing contained in this section shall
deemed
to
affect
the
rights
of
transferees
be
for
consideration without notice.”
Learned Deputy Advocate General submits that
petitioner’s
grandfather
had
gifted
the
land
to
the
respondent-State Education Department; Though there is
no record available with the respondent as to the kind of
deed that was made between the owner of the land and the
Education Department at the time of opening of the school,
however, in absence of any revocation or reversion clause in
the gift deed, the gift deed has become absolute and
irrevocable in terms of Section 126 of the Act.
The above submission cannot be accepted. This
is for the following reasons:Petitioner does not admit the land in question
having been ‘gifted’ by his grandfather to the respondentState Education Department. According to his pleaded case,
the land was ‘given’ by the petitioner’s grandfather to the
Education Department for running Government Primary
School. Petitioner’s assertions are to be believed to be
correct as the jamabandi for the year 2020-21, placed on
record as Annexure P-1, reflects that even as on date, the
land in question is being recorded though in possession of
2025:HHC:45825
respondent-State Education Department, but under the
ownership of petitioner’s father to the extent of shares
recorded
therein
alongwith
other
co-owners/family
members. Had the land been gifted in accordance with law
to
the
respondent-State
Education
Department,
the
ownership of the land in question would have been mutated
in favour of the respondent. Further the respondent-State
Education Department in its reply admits there being no
record available with them about the gift deed, which is
alleged to have been executed by the grandfather of the
petitioner.
At this juncture, it would be relevant to take
note of Section 123 of the Transfer of Property Act, which
mandates that for the purpose of making gift of immovable
property, the transfer must be effected by a registered
instrument signed by or on behalf of the donor and attested
by at least two witnesses. The provision is as under:“123. Transfer how effected.—
For the purpose of making a gift of immoveable
property, the transfer must be effected by a registered
instrument signed by or on behalf of the donor, and
attested by at least two witnesses.
For the purpose of making a gift of moveable
property, the transfer may be effected either by a
registered instrument signed as aforesaid or by
delivery. Such delivery may be made in the same way
as goods sold may be delivered.”
2025:HHC:45825
The above is also to be co-related to Section 17
of the Registration of Act, 1908, which makes instruments
of gift of immovable property compulsorily registrable.
Relevant provision of this Section is as under:“17. Documents of which registration is compulsory.—
(1) The following documents shall be registered,
if the property to which they relate is situate in
a district in which, and if they have been
executed on or after the date on which, Act No.
XVI of 1864, or the Indian Registration Act,
1866, or the Indian Registration Act, 1871, or
the Indian Registration Act, 1877, or this Act
came or comes into force, namely:—
(a) instruments of gift of immovable property”
In view of above provisions of Transfer of
Property Act and the Registration Act, respondent’s defence
for opposing handing over the possession of property to the
petitioner on account of
there being no provision
for
revocation or reversion clause in the gift deed, falls flat.
There
being
no
gift
deed
on
record,
question
of
providing/existence of provision for revocation or reversion
clause therein does not arise.
Gomtibai
(Smt)
(Dead)
through
others Vs. Mattulala (Dead) through LRs 2
there can be no gift of
(1996)11 SCC 681
LRs
and
holds that
immovable property without a
2025:HHC:45825
written instrument which is also compulsory registrable. It
is only in such eventuality that donor would lose title to
the property
and valid transfer shall be effected. Portion
relevant from this decision reads as under:“4.
Thus, it is seen that the gift of immovable property
should be made only for transferring the right, title and
interest by the donor to the donee by a registered
instrument signed by or on behalf of the donor and must
be attested by at least two witnesses. The pre-existing
right, title and interest of donor thereby stand divested
in the done by operation of Section 17 of the
Registration Act only when the gift deed is duly
registered and thereafter the donor would lose title to
the property. It must also be proved that the done had
accepted the property gifted over under the instrument.
In this case, though the transfer of gift was acted upon
by Kusturibai as per the correspondence and evidence
on
record,
but,
admittedly,
there
is
no
written
instrument executed by the donor, namely, the plaintiff
and the defendant in favour of their cousin sister
Kusturibai and it was got attested by at least two
witnesses and registered in accordance with the
provisions of the Stamp Act and the Registration Act. In
the absence of compliance of these formalities, at best
what could be seen from the partition deed is that the
original plaintiff and the defendant have expressed their
intention to gift over the land to their cousin sister
Kusturibai. As held earlier, in the absence of any
registered instrument of gift and acceptance thereof by
the done, the said property could not be said to have
been legally transferred in favour of their cousin sister;
in other words, the gift is not complete in the eye of law.
Therefore, the District Court has rightly set aside the
decree of the trial court which was later confirmed by
2025:HHC:45825
the High Court. We do not find any error of law
warranting interference.”
It appears that respondent at best is projecting
the case of an oral gift allegedly made by petitioner’s
grandfather, however, in view of the provisions of Section
123 of the Transfer of Property Act, there can be no oral gift
of the immovable property. Further gift of immovable
property cannot confer any title to the beneficiary unless
and until the written gift deed is registered.
3(iii)
It will also be beneficial to refer to some relevant
provisions of the Indian Easements Act, 1882. Section 60 of
this Act provides for revocation of licence as under:“60. License when revocable:A license may be revoked by the grantor, unless—
(a) it is coupled with a transfer of property and
such transfer is in force;
(b) the licensee, acting upon the license, has
executed a work of a permanent character
and incurred expenses in the execution.”
Section 62 provides for deemed revocation of the
licence in given situations:62. License when deemed revoked.—A license is
deemed to be revoked—
(a)
when, from a cause preceding the grant of it,
the grantor ceases to have any interest in the
property affected by the license;
2025:HHC:45825
(b)
when the licensee releases it, expressly or
impliedly, to the grantor or his representative;
(c)
where it has been granted for a limited period,
or acquired on condition that it shall become
void on the performance or non-performance of
a specified act, and the period expires, or the
condition is fulfilled;
(d)
where the property affected by the license is
destroyed or by superior force so permanently
altered that the licensee can not longer exercise
his right;
(e)
where the licensee becomes entitled to the
absolute ownership of the property affected by
the license;
(f)
where the license is granted for a specified
purpose and the purpose is attained, or
abandoned, or becomes impracticable;
(g)
where the license is granted to the licensee as
holding a particular office, employment or
character, and such office, employment or
character ceases to exist; (h) where the license
totally ceases to be used as such for an
unbroken period of twenty years, and such
cessation is not in pursuance of a contract
between the grantor and the licensee;
(i)
in the case of an accessory license, when the
interest or right to which it is accessory ceases
to exist.”
In the instant case, though it is not the case of
the respondent, yet even if it is assumed for argument’s
sake that respondent had the licence over the property,
then also in view of Section 62 (f) of the Indian Easements
Act, the licence having
admittedly been granted for a
2025:HHC:45825
specific purpose i.e. for running Government Primary
School Gokaswari, the purpose having been abandoned,
becomes revocable. It is not even the case of the respondent
that any work of permanent nature was executed over the
land. No such plea at all has been taken in the reply.
Reference in this regard can be made to following para of
M.I. Builders Pvt. Ltd Vs. Radhey Shyam Sahu and
others3 :“67. Section 128 of the Act confers powers on the Mahapalika
to sell, let out, hire, lease, exchange, mortgage, grant
otherwise dispose of any property or any interest therein
acquired by or vested in the Mahapalika. The appellant
and the intervenors said that there was no disposal of
any property and no interest in the land had been
transferred by the Mahapalika to the builder. The
respondent, as noted above, contended to the contrary.
Under Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882
agreement to sell does not create any interest in land. We
are not concerned with this provision. Reterence may,
however, be made to Sections 60(b) and 62(f) of the
Easements Act, 1882. Though the licence under Section
60(b) is irrevocable but it can be revoked after the
happening of a certain event which is when the builder
has recovered the whole of his investment plus 10% of
the profit. Reference may be made to a decision of this
Court in Chevalier I.I. Iyyappan v. Dharmodayam Co4. In
this case an argument was raised by the appellant that
he had been granted a licence and acting upon the
licence he had executed a work of permanent character
(1999) 6 SCC 464
AIR 1996 SC 1017 : (1963) 1 SCR 85
2025:HHC:45825
and incurred expenses in the execution thereof and,
thereafter, under Section 60(b) of the Easements Act,
1882 the licence was irrevocable. This Court said:
"In our opinion no case of licence really arises but if
it does what is the licence which the appellant
obtained and what is the licence which he is seeking
to plead as a bar. The licence, if it was a licence,
was to construct the building and hand it over to the
respondent Company as trust property. There was
no licence to create another kind of trust which the
appellant has sought to create. It cannot be said
therefore that there was an irrevocable licence which
falls under Section 60(b) of the Act. Even such a
licence is deemed to be revoked under Section 62(f)
of that Act where the licence is granted for a specific
purpose and the purpose is attained or abandoned
or becomes impracticable. In the present case the
purpose for which the licence was granted has either
been abandoned or has become impracticable
because of the action of the appellant."
"52. Where one person grants to another, or to a definite
number of other persons, a right to do, or continue to
do, in or upon the immovable property of the grantor,
something which would, in the absence of such
right, be unlawful, and such right does not amount to
an easement or an interest in the property, the right
is called a licence.
53. A licence may be granted by anyone in the
circumstances and to the extent in and to which he
may transfer his interests in the property affected by
the licence.
…………………………………..
60. A licence may be revoked by the grantor, unless—
(a)…………………
(b)
the licensee, acting upon the licence, has
executed a work of a permanent character and
incurred expenses in the execution.
62.
4.
A licence is deemed to be revoked—
(a) to (e) ……………………
f) where the licence is granted for a specified
purpose and the purpose is attained or
abandoned, or becomes impracticable.”
The respondent-State Education Department
having abandoned the purpose for which the petitioner’s
grandfather had parted his land in its favour, cannot be
permitted to retain the land. The claim of the petitioner for
getting back possession of the land in question is justified.
2025:HHC:45825
Accordingly, this writ petition is allowed. Respondent is
directed to give the possession of the land in question back
to the owners of the land. This exercise be carried within
four weeks from today.
Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any,
also to stand disposed of.
July 1, 2026
R.Atal
Jyotsna Rewal Dua
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review