Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010624962004
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3209]
MONDAY,, THE FIFTEENTH DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NINALA JAYASURYA
WRIT PETITION N
No: 5501 of 2004
Between:
1. RASHTRIYA ISPAT NIGAM LTD.
LTD., VISAKHAPATNAM STEEL PLANT,
REP.BY ITS DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER (DNW) MR.G.RAGHU,
VISAKHAPATNAM.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. CHAIRMAN EASTERN POWER DISTRIBUTION CO.,
CO., OF ANDHRA
PRADESH LTD. HAVING ITS CORPORATE OFFICE AT
VISAKHAPATNAM, REP.BY ITS CHAIRMAN & MANAGING
DIRECTOR, EASTERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF
ANDHRA PRADESH LTD.
LTD., CORPORATE OFFICE 30-14
14-9, SAI
SHAKTI BHAVAN, DABAGARDENS, VISAKHAPATNAM.
2. THE CHIEF GENERAL MANAGER O&N,
N, EASTERN POWER
DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF ANDHRA PRADESH LTD.,
LTD.
CORPORATE
OFFICE,
30-14-9,
9,
SAI
SHAKTI
BHAVAN,
DABAGARDENS, VISAKHAPATNAM.
3. THE SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER OPERATIONS CIRCLES,
EASTERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF ANDHRA
PRADESH LTD. VIDYUTH BHAVAN, OPP.HOTEL GREEN PARK,
VISAKHAPATNAM.
4. THE DIVISIONAL ELECTRICAL ENGINEER, OPERATIONS DIVISION,
ZONE-II,
II, EASTERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF ANDHRA
PRADESH LTD. KANCHARAPALEM, VISAKHAPATNAM.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1.Mr. VIVEK CHANDRA SEKHAR S
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
Mr.V V SATISH (SC for APEPDCL)
Orders Reserved on
: 18.02.2026
Orders Pronounced on
: 15.06.2026
Orders Uploaded on
: 16.06.2026
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
The Court made the following Order:
The present writ petition is filed seeking the following relief:
“………….to issue a writ of certiorari or any other appropriate writ calling for the
records
of
the
2nd
respondent
in
Proceedings
No.CGM/O&M/EPDCL/VSP/O&M/BB/D.No.2025/03 dated 23.09.2003 and quash the
same as being contrary to clause 22.3.3.3 of terms and conditions of supply, being
illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction in view of section 49 (1) of Indian Electricity
(A.P. Amendment) Act 2000 and Electricity Act 2003 and be pleased to pass such
other order or orders as this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and proper in the
circumstances of the case.”
2.
Heard Mr.Avula Akash, learned counsel representing Mr.S.Vivek
Chandra Sekhar, learned counsel for petitioner. Also heard Mr.V.V.Satish,
learned Standing Counsel for APEPDCL appearing for respondents. Perused
the material on record.
3.
Brief facts of the case are that Rashtriya Ispat Nigam Limited (for short
“RINL”), a Public Sector Undertaking established by Union of India for
production of steel requires continuous and reliable power supply, since
manufacturing involves handling of liquid metals at high temperatures and
highly poisonous and explosive gases. For continuous and reliable power
supply, RINL established three 60 MW (Mega Watts) generators.
It
established a fourth turbo generator with a capacity of 67.5 MW in the year
1995 and thereby total power generation capacity was enhanced to 247.5
MW. Power generated by petitioner’s Captive Power Plant including 2 x 7.5
MW and 2 x 12 MW auxiliary generators is adequate to meet its production
and ancillary activities. Therefore, excess power generated by RINL’s Captive
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
Power Plant is being exported to Transmission Corporation of Andhra
Pradesh (A.P.Transco) at a reduced price. In order to meet contingencies like
annual shut down of its generating stations and any other unexpected
generator / boiler tripping situation, RINL entered into an agreement with 1 st
respondent for supply of energy with a Contracted Maximum Demand (CMD)
of 150 Mega Volt Ampere (MVA) later revised to 100 MVA. For the purpose of
recording, import and export of power, 1st respondent-Distribution company
set up its meters at the main receiving station. RINL established a system
known as Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition System (SCADA) which
also measures import and export of power.
4.
On 25.10.2001, RINL authorities observed that there is an unusual
difference between the net import of power as calculated from SCADA and as
recorded by meters set up by the 1st respondent. To rule out the possibility of
any abnormal error in measurement power by SCADA, relevant transducers
were tested and found to be in order. Later, a precision meter was installed in
one of the incoming circuits at Main Receiving Station and it was observed
that meters setup by the 1 st respondent were recording 30% less than the
recording by precision meter. RINL through letter dated 09.11.2001 reported
about improper functioning of meters to the authorities of 1st respondent. On
10.11.2001, the Assistant Divisional Engineer (MRT) visited the main
receiving station and observed that current in the three phases i.e., red, yellow
and blue is not being recorded equally and having abnormal variations. After
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
thorough verification of the meters, current transformers and wiring on
19.11.2001, defect in the power consumption recording process was noticed
in the wiring between the secondary of 220 KV current transformers and
summation current transformers in R & Y in circuit-II. Ultimately, officials of 1 st
respondent-Distribution Company rectified defect on 21.11.2001 by replacing
defective wires.
5.
Basing on the inspection dated 19.11.2001, 4 th respondent / Divisional
Electrical Engineer invoking Clause 22.3.3.3 of Terms and Conditions of
Supply issued Assessment Notice dated 04.12.2001 and called upon the
petitioner / RINL to submit representation, if any to the same. In the said
notice, it was inter alia stated that the meter installed is not functioning
correctly, recording less energy consumption and the energy consumption
during the period of defect in the meter i.e., from July, 2001 to October, 2001
was assessed at Rs.5,27,66,471/-. In response to the said notice, RINL
sought some information / material and submitted representation dated
01.01.2002, inter alia stating that A.P.Transco has not followed required
maintenance practices and periodical checking to ensure healthiness of the
circuits and meters. 3rd respondent thereafter by affording an opportunity of
hearing confirmed the back billing for an amount of Rs.5,27,66,471/- vide
Proceedings dated 05.02.2002.
6.
RINL aggrieved by the said proceedings filed an appeal on 04.03.2002
before 2nd respondent with detailed comments on the order passed by 3rd
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
respondent. Appellate Authority without taking into account the annual test of
meters conducted on 30.08.2001 by ADE/HT meters, Visakhapatnam, by
making an observation that during the month of 06/01, the consumers
generator (TG2) had tripped, confirmed the order of assessment holding that
the billing meter is recording less due to melting of secondary leads in CircuitII from 07/01 onwards.
7.
Assailing
that
the
determination
of
back
billing
amount
of
Rs.5,27,66,471/- is illegal and without jurisdiction, present writ petition came to
be filed.
Contentions:
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner referring to material on record, made
elaborate submissions. He argues that the reason for improper recording of
power by the meter is due to melting and shorting of secondary circuit wires
and not due to malfunctioning of the meters.
He submits that in such
circumstances, invocation of Clause 22.3.3.3 of Terms and Conditions of
Supply is without jurisdiction, that as it is not a case of defective functioning of
meter, Clause 22.3.3.3 is not attracted and if at all, the dispute / difference as
to the energy supplied to the petitioner was to be determined by the Chief
Electrical Officer to Government (CEIG) as provided under Section 26 (6) of
Indian Electricity Act, 1910, but the said Act was repealed. He further
contends that the obligation to maintain meters, circuits, wiring etc., lies with
the Distribution
Company and
it
failed
to
ensure
maintenance
of
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
interconnecting circuit and proper recording of supply particulars. He submits
that any defect in the maintenance by the 1st respondent authorities and the
loss, if any, shall be borne by the 1st respondent, but cannot be fastened to
the writ petitioner.
9.
Drawing the attention of the Court to the relevant Terms and Conditions
of Supply and the provisions of Indian Electricity Act, 1910 as also decisions
of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Bombay Electricity Supply & Transport
Undertaking v. Laffans (India Pvt. Limited) & another1etc., learned counsel
submits that the impugned back billing order is liable to be set aside as the
same is without jurisdiction, unjust and arbitrary.
10.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents strenuously contended
that order of assessment as confirmed by the Appellate Authority is valid,
contains cogent reasons and does not suffer from any illegality. He submits
that the case on hand is not one of defective functioning of the meter, but
defect in the wires. He submits that during the course of inspection of meters /
equipment etc., it was found that the wires were burnt and it has resulted in
recording of less consumption. He submits that after rectification of the wires,
the meter recorded normal consumption and the authorities concerned after
taking into consideration all relevant aspects by co-relating with earlier
consumption pattern, had rightly determined back billing amount for the period
from July, 2001 to October, 2001. He contends that as it is a case of defect in
(2005) 4 SCC 327
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
the wires, the CEIG has no jurisdiction in the matter and the contention with
reference to Section 26 (6) is misconceived. He submits that in fact, petitioner
has not raised any objection with regard to invocation of Clause 22.3.3.3 of
Terms and Conditions of Supply much less, lack of jurisdiction at any point of
time before the concerned authorities.
He also submits that material on
record goes to show that grievance of the petitioner is only with regard to
period of assessment, but not the method adopted by DISCOM authorities in
arriving at the back billing amount. Making the said submissions and relying
on decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran
Nigam Limited & Another v. Adani Power (Mundra) Limited & Another 2
and Bihar State Electricity Board & Another v. Shree Plywoods (Pvt.)
Ltd., and others3 etc., learned counsel submits that there are no merits in the
writ petition and interference in a matter like this is not called for. Accordingly,
he seeks dismissal of the writ petition.
Consideration by Court:
11.
At the outset, it may be pertinent to mention that there is no dispute
about less recording of consumption by the meter at the time of inspection of
the petitioner’s premises by the concerned officer on 19.11.2001. It is also not
in dispute that the meter is not defective and in view of the same, it was not
changed after the inspection. The only issue is with regard to invocation of
Clause 22.3.3.3 of Terms and Conditions of Supply for arriving at the amount
(2023) 14 SCC 731
2001 SCC OnLine Pat 450
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
of back billing and period of back billing. To appreciate the contentions
advanced by the learned counsel with reference to the said aspects, it may be
appropriate to extract Clause 22.3.3 which deals with procedure for arriving at
consumption when the meter is defective and Section 26 (6) of the Indian
Electricity Act, 1910.
22.3.3. Procedure for arriving at consumption when the meter is defective:Where supply to the consumer has been given without a meter or where the
meter fixed is found defective or to have ceased to function and no pilferage of
energy or malpractice is suspected, the quantity of electricity supplied during the
period when meter was not installed or the meter installed was defective, shall be
assessed as mentioned hereunder:
22.3.3.1 The quantify of electricity supplied during the period in which the meter
ceased to function or became defective, shall be determined by taking average of
the electricity supplied during the preceding three months the month in which the
said meter ceased to function or became defective provided that condition in
regard to use of electricity during the said three months were not different from
those which prevailed during the period in which the meter ceased to function or
became defective.
22.3.3.2 If the conditions in regard to use of electricity during the periods as
mentioned above were different, assessment shall be made on the basis of any
consecutive three months during the preceding 12 months when the conditions of
working were not different.
22.3.3.3 Where it is not possible to select a set of three moths as indicated in
sub-clause 22.3.3.1 or 22.3.3.2 or if meter is not at all installed, quantity of
electricity supply shall be assessed by the Assistant Divisional Engineer /
Divisional Engineer of the area on the basis of connected load and hours of
usage of electricity by the consumers. However in the case of industrial
consumers due regard shall be given to the production figures and conditions of
working in the period under question.
The concerned Asst. Divisional Engineer (Operation), of the area shall issue the
assessment notice to the consumer (Appendix – XII) with in a week from the date
of receipt of the inspection report from the Inspecting Officer. The Assistant
Divisional Engineer operation shall indicate the details based on which the
assessment was made, in the said notice. The consumer shall be advised to file
his representation if any to the concerned Divisional Engineer (operation) in the
case of LT services and Superintending Engineer (operation) in the case of HT
services within fifteen days from the date of receipt of the notice. The Divisional
Engineer(operation) / Superintending (operation) as the case may be, shall
permit the consumer to represent his case in person, if the consumer so desires.
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
After due consideration of the material furnished in the reply to the Assessment
notice, representation made available if any, during personal hearing and the
facts and material of the case on record, the Divisional Engineer (operation) /
Superintending Engineer (operation) as the case may be, shall then pass an
order in the case which shall be a speaking order. The amount payable by the
consumer towards short billing on account of defect in meter, pursuant to the
said order of the Divisional Engineer (operation) / Superintending Engineer
(operation), shall be payable by the consumer within 30 days from the date of
issue of the order, by cash or by D.D. drawn in favour of the concerned AAO
(ERO) in case of LT services and SAO of circle office in case of HT services.
(B.P.Ms.No.377 (Opn-Comml) Dated 23-12-93)
(B.P.Ms.No.110 (Opn-Comml) Dated 06-3-98)
Section 26(6) of the Indian Electricity Act, reads as follows:
26.Meters –( 1) In the absence of an agreement to the contrary, the amount of
energy supplied to a consumer or the electrical quantity contained in the supply shall be
ascertained by means of a correct meter, and the licensee shall, if required by the
consumer, cause the consumer to be supplied with such a meter:
Provided that the licensee may require the consumer to give him security for the
price of a meter and enter into an agreement for the hire thereof, unless the consumer elects
to purchase a meter.
(2)……….
(3)……….
(4)………..
(5)………..
[(6) Where any difference or dispute arises as to whether any meter referred to in
sub-section (1) is or is not correct, the matter shall be decided, upon the application of either
party, by an Electrical Inspector; and where the meter has, in the opinion of such Inspector
ceased to be correct, such Inspector shall estimate the amount of the energy supplied to the
consumer or the electrical quantity contained in the supply, during such time, not exceeding
six months, as the meter shall not, in the opinion of such Inspector, have been correct; but
save as aforesaid, the register of the mater shall, in the absence of fraud, be conclusive
proof of such amount or quantity;
Provided that before either a licenses or a consumer applies to the Electrical
Inspector under this sub-section, he shall give to the other party not less than seven days’
notice of his intention so to do.]
12.
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
Further, Rule 30 (1) of the Indian Electricity Rules, 1956, contemplates
that the supplier shall ensure that all electric supply lines, wires, fittings and
apparatus belonging to him are under his control, which are on a consumer
premises, are in a safe condition and in all respects fit for supplying energy
and the supplier shall take due precautions to avoid danger arising on such
premises from such supply lines, wires, fittings and apparatus.
13.
A perusal of the letter dated 24.11.2001 (Page 41), addressed by the
ADE/DPE/HT to the 4th respondent with regard to conduct of joint inspection
by him along with other officials of the Distribution Company, wherein it was
mentioned that “the meter box is completely rusted, rats and squirrels are
freely moving inside the meter box through the rusted roles(sic. wholes)”
would clearly indicate lack of maintenance and protection to metering
equipment by DISCOM authorities. Nowhere in the said communication /
report, was there any finding / observation that the meter is defective. Obvious
reasons for less recording even as per respondent-authorities is only ‘B’
phase CT secondary wires are intact and others are melted resulting in
unbalance of current in the meter. Thus, it is not a case where the meter
per se is defective, but a case where the meter is functioning and recording
less consumption due to melting of wires. In such circumstances, that too
when meter fixed is not found defective, invocation of Clause 22.3.3. and
assessment of quantity of electricity thereof as rightly contended by the
learned counsel for the petitioner is without jurisdiction. Any assessment
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
towards back billing on the basis of the procedure contemplated under the
said clause is illegal, not sustainable.
14.
At this juncture, it may be appropriate to point out that plea with regard
to jurisdiction / assessment of back billing amount under Clause 22.3.3.3 of
the Terms and Conditions was not specifically raised by the petitioner at the
time of submitting its representation / objections. However, it had objected to
the period of assessment from 7/2001 to 10/2001 i.e., for four months. Since
a dispute was raised with regard to the period during which less consumption
was recorded by the meter which is otherwise perfect in all respects, the
authorities of DISCOM ought to have referred the matter for resolution by
CEIG as provided under Section 26 (6) of the Indian Electricity Act, at the
relevant point of time.
15.
In similar circumstances, A Division Bench of High Court of Karnataka
in Karnataka Electricity Board v. Topasa 4 dealt with an issue whether a
dispute arising out of under recording of consumption of electricity by an
electrical meter, it is for the Board or it is for the consumer, to have the matter
decided by the Electrical Inspector under sub-section (6) of Section 26 of the
Indian Electricity Act, 1910?. In the said case, at the time of a surprise
inspection of the premises of the respondent-consumer it was found that the
power meter was under-recording to the extent of 23% and the lighting meter
was under-recording to the extent of 11.2%. Division Bench answered the
ILR 1991 KAR 909
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
Issue at Para No.7 and dismissed the appeal. For ready reference, relevant
portion is extracted hereunder:
7. Now the precise question before us is as to whether it is for the
consumer to raise a dispute before the Electrical Inspector or for the Electricity
Board to raise a dispute. In our opinion, when sub-section (6) of Section 26 of the
Act says that either of the party is at liberty to raise a dispute before the Electrical
Inspector it means the party aggrieved is entitled to raise a dispute. Naturally in
the case of under-recording, it would be the Board which is the aggrieved party
and therefore in such cases, it is for the Board to raise a dispute before the
Electrical Inspector and have the matter decided if it wants to make back billing
to the extent the Board’s income was reduced on account of fault in the meter. In
cases where the complaint is that the meter is over-recording naturally consumer
would be the adversely affected party and therefore it is for him to raise a dispute
before the Electrical Inspector under sub-section (6) of Section 26 of the Act, in
order to have the amount of the bill reduced.”
16.
In Bombay Electricity Supply case referred to supra, a Three Judge
Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court was dealing with an appeal filed against
the judgment of a Division Bench of Bombay High Court. The dispute relates
to two meters, one which was burnt and another which was found running
slow. After replacing the burnt meter, on the premise that the meter had
recorded incorrect readings, revised bills were raised. Challenging the same,
the consumer M/s.Laffans (India) Pvt. Ltd., filed a writ petition. A learned
Single Judge dismissed the same holding that it was for the consumer to raise
a dispute before the Electrical Inspector under Section 26 (6) of the Electricity
Act, in case he challenged or disputed the assertion of the supplier and that
the meter was not recording correctly and was running slow. Further, that as
the consumer did not raise any such dispute, supplier was entitled to replace
the meter if the same was defective and to raise a demand on the basis of
average consumption in the past period.
17.
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
Hon’ble Division Bench reversed the said view and held that if the
supplier disputed the correctness of the meter, it should have referred the
dispute to the Electrical Inspector as provided in Section 26 (6) of the Act and
it was for the Electrical Inspector to estimate the amount of energy supplied to
the consumer. It was also held that the appellant / supplier having not referred
any such dispute to the Electrical Inspector and consequently no estimate of
the energy supplied by it to the first respondent (consumer) having been
made, it was not open to the appellant / supplier to raise a bill on the basis of
average of the past one year’s consumption.
18.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court examined the matter with reference to
Section 26 (6) of the Electricity Act, 1910 and Rule 57 of the Electricity Rules
as also the earlier precedents viz., M.P.Electricity Board v. Basantibai 5 ,
Belwal Spinning Mills Limited v. U.P.SEB6 and J.M.D.Alloys Ltd., v. Bihar
SEB7. Expressing its view, as to what is a correct meter, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court at Para No.8 and 9 held as follows:
“8. As to what would be a “correct” meter, there is sufficient indication in
the Act and the Electricity Rules, 1956 in the Explanation given at the end of subsection (7) of Section 26 of the Act and sub-rules (1) and (2) of Rule 57, quoted
hereinabove. Where the meter is completely non-functional on account of any
fault or having been burnt, it will not register the supply of energy at all. Since a
burnt meter does not record any supply of energy, it virtually means “no meter”.
9.What is contemplated by Section 26 (6) is a running meter, but which
on account of some technical defect registers the amount of energy supply or the
electrical quantity contained in the supply beyond the prescribed limits of error. It
contemplates a meter which is either running slow or fast with the result that it
does not register the correct amount of energy supplied. There is an additional
(1988) 1 SCC 23
(1997) 6 SCC 740
2003 (5) SCC 226
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
reason for coming to such a conclusion. Section 26 (6) confers power upon the
Electrical Inspector to estimate the amount of energy supplied to the consumer or
the electrical quantity contained in the supply, during such time, not exceeding
six months, as the meter shall not, in the opinion of such Inspector, have been
correct. Where the meter is running slow or fast, it will be possible for the
Electrical Inspector to estimate the amount of energy supplied to the consumer
by determining the extent or percentage of error in recording the supply, whether
plus or minus. However, where the meter is burnt or is completely non-functional,
such an exercise is not at all possible. Therefore, Section 26 (6) can have no
application in a case where a meter has become completely non-functional on
account of any reason whatsoever.”
19.
In Para No.10, specific reference to decision of Belwal Spinning Mills
case was made, wherein it was inter alia held that “any difference or dispute
arising between the licensee and consumer, as to whether any meter has
recorded or is recording correct reading or not, can be raised by either party
and referred, upon the application of either party, for decision by an Electrical
Inspector.”
20.
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the facts of the said case, while noting that
for the period for which, according to the appellant / supplier, the meter was
not correct, none of the parties has referred the dispute to the Electrical
Inspector disposed of the appeal clarifying that the demand raised by the
appellant / supplier based on the average consumption during the similar
period in the last year is justified, for the period for which the reading was lost
on account of the meter having been found burnt. Further, so far as the period
for which the meter is said to be incorrect, the demand has not been revised
by basing it on the finding arrived at by the Electrical Inspector and hence is
not available to be revised. (Para 14)
21.
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
In the light of the expression of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the above
said decision, this Court is of the opinion that the issue with regard to less
recording of readings by a meter which is not otherwise defective and the
assessment towards back billing amount falls within the purview of Chief
Electrical Inspector to Government under Section 26 (6) of the Indian
Electricity Act. Therefore, the very issuance of notice under Clause 22.3.3.3 of
Terms and Conditions of Supply and the impugned orders pursuant thereto
are not sustainable for want of jurisdiction. There is no dispute with regard to
the proposition that scope of judicial review of decisions of expert bodies is
limited and Courts would be loathe to interfere with the same. But the decision
in Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Limited relied on by learned counsel for
respondents is not applicable to the facts of the case and contentions raised
by him merits no acceptance.
22.
For the aforegoing reasons, the order dated 23.09.2003 of the second
respondent confirming the order of the third respondent dated 05.02.2002 is
quashed and the writ petition is allowed.
23.
Before parting with the order, it may be pertinent to mention that as per
the instructions of learned counsel for petitioner, back billing amount was
adjusted / collected from the petitioner. In view of setting aside of the
impugned order, back billing amount collected or adjusted, if any by the
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
respondents shall either be refunded or given credit to in the monthly
consumption bills of the petitioner. No costs.
Consequently, all pending applications, if any, shall stand closed.
__________________________
JUSTICE NINALA JAYASURYA
BLV
Dt. 15.06.2026
NJS,J
WP_5501_2004
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NINALA JAYASURYA
W.P. No: 5501 of 2004
Date: 15.06.2026
BLV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review