Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010631442025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3331]
TUESDAY, THE SEVENTH DAY OF APRIL
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBBA REDDY SATTI
WRIT PETITION NO: 33027/2025
Between:
1. RASAMSETTY JANAKI RAMANA, S/O RASAMSETTY ANJANEYA
DAS, AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS R/O, D/NO.20/516-28, PARASUPETA,
NGOS COLONY, MACHILIPATNAM, KRISHNA DISTRICT. 521001.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REPRESENTED BY ITS
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY,
PANCHAYAT RAJ
AND
RURAL
DEVELOPMENT DEPARTMENT,
SECRETARIAT BUILDINGS,
VELAGAPUDI, GUNTUR DISTRICT.
2. THE STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH, REPRESENTED BY ITS
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, FINANCE DEPARTMENT, SECRETARIAT
BUILDINGS VELAGAPUDI, GUNTUR DISTRICT.
3. THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
4. THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, P.R.I DIVISION, MACHILIPATNAM,
MACHILIPATNAM MANDAL, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
5. THE DEPUTY EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, P.R.I SUB-DIVISION,
MACHILIPATNAM MANDAL, MACHILIPATNAM, KRISHNA DISTRICT.
6. THE ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, P.R.I SUB-DIVISION,
MANDAL PARSHAD, MACHILIPATNAM MANDAL,
KRISHNA
DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature
of WRIT OF MANDAMUS declaring action of the respondents in nonpayment of amounts due even after finalizing the bills, payable to the
petitioner after the successful completion of the execution of 11 works under
Gadapa Gadapaku Mana Prabuthvam(GGMP) Funds for laying of C.C.Roads
in Thallapalem Panchayat 1 and 2, Thallapalem Village, Machilipatnam
Mandal, Krishna District the works are as follows (1) Construction of C.C.
Road from Adala Ramakrishna house to Evana Naga Raju house in
Jonnalavarimodi H/o Thallapalem Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal,
Krishna District, Vide Agreement No. 1106/ 2023-2024, dt. 15-02-2024, for
estimated cost of Rs.4,71,000/- after deduction of EMD and Seignorage
Charges the Net Amount comes under Rs.3,75,778/-, Construction of C.C.
Road from Bommidi Satyanarayana house to Bommidi Panduranga Rao
house in Satravapalem H/o Thallapalem Panchayat
of Machilipatnam
Mandal, vide Agreement No. 1108/2023-2024, dt. 15-02-2025, for estimate
cost of Rs.2,80,000/- after deduction of EMD and Seignorage Charges the
Net Amount comes under Rs.2,17,895/-, (2) Construction of C.C. Road from
Siddireddy Nagulu house to Evana Naga Raju house in Jonnalavarimodi H/o
Thallapalem Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal, Krishna District, Vide
Agreement No.1107/2023-2024, dt. 15-02-2024,
for estimated cost of
Rs.4,55,000/- after deduction of EMD and Seignorage Charges the Net
Amount comes under Rs.3,33,748/-, (3) Construction of C.C. Road from
parimi Krishna site to Burrial ground in Sattenapalem H/o Thallapalem
Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal, Krishna District, Vide Agreement No.
1109/ 2023-2024, dt. 15-02-2024, for estimated cost of Rs.3,87,000/- after
deduction of EMD and Seignorage Charges the Net Amount comes under
Rs.2,68,084/-, (4) (5) Construction of C.C. Road from Sattenapalem SC
Colony CC road to Parimi Krishna site in Thallapalem Panchayat of
Machilipatnam Mandal, Krishna District, Vide Agreement No ll 10/ 2023-2024,
dt. 15-02-2024, for estimated cost of Rs.4,07,000/- after deduction of EMD
and Seignorage Charges the Net Amount comes under Rs.3,04,140/-,
Construction of C.C. Road from Gangiredia Tataiah house to illuri
aggiramudu house in jonnalavaripalem village of Tallapalem panchayat of
Machilipatnam mandal, Krishna District, Vide Agreement No. 1105/ 20232024, dt. 15-02-2024, for estimate cost of Rs.4,09,000/- after deduction of
EMD and Seignorage Charges the Net Amount comes Rs.3,37,512/-, (6)
Construction of C.C. Road frorri Ganta Raju house to Ganta Surendra house
in Gantavaripalem of Tallapalem Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal,
Krishna District, Vide Agreement No. 1104/ 2023-2024, dt. 15-02-2024, for
estimate cost of Rs.3,45,000/- after deduction of EMD and Seignorage
Charges the Net Amount comes Rs.2,68,190/-, (7) (8) Construction of C.C.
Road from RCM Church to Maddala Rani House in Gantavaripalem of
Tallapalem Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal, Krishna District, Vide
Agreement No. 1112/ 2023-2024, dt. 15-02-2024, for estimate cost of
Rs.2,71,000/- after deduction of EMD and Seignorage Charges the Net
Amount comes Rs.2,17,669/-, (9) Construction of C.C. Road from Vempa
Kamala house to Ganta Arlappa house in Gantavaripalem of Tallapalem
Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal, Krishna District, Vide Agreement
No.1103/ 2023-2024, dt. 15-02-2024, for estimate cost of Rs.4,06,000/- after
deduction of EMD and Seignorage Charges the Net Amount comes
Rs.3,23,310/-,
(10) Construction of C.C. Road from Ramalayam to
Gangiredia Tataiah house
in Jonnalavaripalem Village of Tallapalem
Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal, Krishna District, Vide Agreement
No.1111/ 2023-2024, dt. 15-02-2024, for estimate cost of Rs.4,58,000/- after
deduction of EMD and Seignorage Charges the Net Amount comes
Rs.3,72,713/-, (11) Construction of C.C. Road from main road in RCM Church
in Gantavaripalem of Tallapalem Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal,
Krishna District, Vide D.R.No.233/ 2023-2024, dt. 11-03-2024, for estimate
cost of Rs.1,11,000/- after deduction of EMD and Seignorage Charges the
Net Amount comes Rs.90,322/-, the total amount of Rs.31,09,861/- excluding
from the EMD amounts and consequential direct the respondents to release
the final bill amount of Rs. Rs.31,09,861/- along with the EMD amounts and
interest payable to the petitioner on the principal amount and to pass such
IA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the respondents to pay the amount of Rs.31,09,861/- after the
successful completion of the execution of 11 works under Gadapa Gadapaku
Mana Prabuthvam(GGMP) Funds for laying of C.C.Roads in Thallapalem
Panchayat 1 & 2, Thallapalem Village, Machiliparnam Mandal, Krishna
District, the works are as follows, (1) Construction of C.C. Road from Adala
Ramakrishna house to Evana Naga Raju house in Jonnalavarimodi Fl/o
Thallapalem Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal, Krishna District, Vide
Agreement No. 1106/ 2023-2024, dt. 15-02-2024, for estimated cost of
Rs.4,71,000/- after deduction of EMD & Seignorage Charges the Net Amount
comes under Rs.3,75,778/-, (2) Construction of C.C. Road from Bommidi
Satyanarayana house to Bommidi Panduranga Rao house in Satravapalem
Fl/o Thallapalem Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal, vide Agreement No.
1108/2023-2024, dt. 15-02-2025, for estimate cost of Rs.2,80,000/- after
deduction of EMD & Seignorage Charges the Net Amount comes under
Rs.2,17,895/-, (3) Construction of C.C. Road from Siddireddy Nagulu house to
Evana Naga Raju house in Jonnalavarimodi Fl/o Thallapalem Panchayat of
Machilipatnam Mandal, Krishna District, Vide Agreement No. 1107/ 20232024, dt. 15-02-2024, for estimated cost of Ids.4,55,000/- after deduction of
EMD & Seignorage Charges the Net Amount ( omes under Rs.3,33,748/-, (4)
Construction of C.C. Raad from parimi krishna site to Burrial ground in
Sattenapalem H/o Thallapalem Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal, Krishna
District, Vide Agreement No.1109/ 2023-2024, dt. 15-02-2024, for estimated
cost of Rs.3,87,000/- after deduction of EMD & Seignorage Charges the Net
Amount comes under Rs.2,68,h84/-, (5) Construction of C.C. Road from
Sattenapalem SC Colony CC road to Farimi Krishna site in Thallapalem
Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal, Krishna District, Vide Agreement Nt
.1110/ 2023-2024, dt. 15-02-2024, for estimated cost of Rs.4,07,000/- after
deduction of EMD & Seignorage Charges the Net Amount comes under
Rs.3,04,140/-, Construction of C.C. Road from Gangiredia Tataiah house to
illuri aggiramudu house in jonnalavaripalem village of Tallapalem panchayat of
Machilipatnam mandal, Krishna District, Vide Agreement No. 1105/ 20232024, dt. 15-02-2024, for estimate cost of Rs.4,09,000/- after deduction of
EMD & Seignorage Charges the Net Amount comes Rs.3,37,512/-,
Construction of C.C. Road from Ganta Raju house to Ganta Surendra house
in Gantavaripalem of Tallapalem Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal,
Krishna District, Vide Agreement No. 1104/2023-2024, dt. 15-02-2024, for
estimate cost of Rs.3,45,000/- after deduction of EMD & Seignorage Charges
the Net Amount comes Rs.2,68,190/-, Construction of C.C. Road from RCM
Church to Maddala Rani House in Gantavaripalem of Tallapalem Panchayat
of Machilipatnam Mandal, Krishna District, Vide Agreement No.1112/ 20232024, dt. 15-02-2024, for estimate cost of Rs.2,71,000/- after deduction of
EMD & Seignorage Charges the Net Amount comes Rs.2,17,669/-,
Construction of C.C. Road from Vempa Kamala house to Ganta Arlappa
house in Gantavaripalem of Tallapalem Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal,
Krishna District, Vide Agreement No. 1103/2023-2024, dt. 15-02-2024, for
estimate cost of Rs.4,06,000/- after deduction of EMD & Seignorage Charges
the Net Amount comes Rs.3,23,310/-, (10) Construction of C.C. Road from
Ramalayam to Gangiredia Tataiah house in Jonnalavaripalem Village of
Tallapalem Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal, Krishna District, Vide
Agreement No.1111/ 2023-2024, dt. 15-02-2024, for estimate cost of
Rs.4,58,000/- after deduction of EMD & Seignorage Charges the Net Amount
comes Rs.3,72,713/-, (11) Construction of C.C. Road from main road in RCM
Church in Gantavaripalem of Tallapalem Panchayat of Machilipatnam Mandal,
Krishna District, Vide D.R.No.233/ 2023-2024, dt. 11-03-2024, for estimate
cost of Rs.1,11,000/- after deduction of EMD & Seignorage Charges the Net
Amount (6) (7) (8) (9) comes Rs.90,822/-, the total amount of Rs.31,09,861/immediately, with an interest @24% per annum for the delayed amount to the
petitioner, pending disposal of the above writ petition and pass such
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. VARDHINEEDI SAI KIRAN
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR PANCHAYAT RAJ RURAL DEV
2. GP FOR FINANCE PLANNING
The Court made the following:
ORDER
Heard Sri V.Sai Kiran, learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri
P.Rajesh Kumar, learned Assistant Government Pleader for Panchayat Raj
and Rural Development & Finance and Planning Department, for the
respondents.
2.
The above writ petition was filed to declare the action of the
respondents in non-payment of amounts due to even after finalizing the bills
payable to the petitioner, to a tune of Rs.31,09,861/- in relation to above
mentioned 11 works, as illegal and arbitrary.
3.
Today, when the matter is taken up for consideration, learned Assistant
Government Pleader for Panchayat Raj, submitted the written instructions of
the 4th respondent.
4.
A perusal of the said instructions would disclose that the petitioner has
executed the aforementioned works and the total value of the work done by
the petitioner is Rs.38,43,025/- and after QC recovery of Rs.5,56,901/-, the
net amount payable to the petitioner comes to Rs.32,86,124/-. The written
instructions are made as part of the record.
5.
Thus, as seen from the instructions there is no dispute regarding the
execution of works and the petitioner’s entitlement for Rs.32,86,124/-. Since
the amount payable is admitted and undisputed, the writ petition is
maintainable. In M/s Utkal Highways Engineers and Contractors v. Chief
General Manager & Ors1, it was held at Para No.8 as under:
“Be that as it may, the High court has not dealt with the merits of the writ
petition. Moreover, it is not an inviolable rule that no money claim can be
adjudicated upon in exercise of writ jurisdiction. Non-payment of admitted dues,
inter alia, may be considered an arbitrary action on the part of respondents and
for claiming the same, a writ petition may lie.Further, throwing a writ petition on
ground of availability of alternative remedy after 10 years, particularly, when
parties have exchanged their affidavits, is not the correct course unless there
are disputed questions of fact which by their very nature cannot be adjudicated
upon without recording formal evidence.”.
6.
Given the instructions furnished by the 4th respondent, though there is a
small variation in the amount claimed by the petitioner and the amount
determined by the official, as payable to the petitioner, the Writ Petition is
disposed of directing the respondents to release an amount of Rs.32,86,124/(Rupees Thirty Two Lakhs Eighty Six Thousand One Hundred and Twenty
Four only) payable to the petitioner regarding execution of the aforementioned
work, within four (04) months from the date of receipt of the copy of this order.
No order as to costs.
As a sequel, pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand closed.
___________________________
JUSTICE SUBBA REDDY SATTI
PVD
2025 SCC online SC 1400
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review