Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SHAMURAILATPAM
SUSHIL SHARMA
SHAMURAILATPAM SUSHIL SHARMA
Date: 2026.06.04 17:58:51 +05'30'
Sl. No. 19
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
Cont.Cas(C) No. 26 of 2026
Ref:- WP(C) No. 802 of 2025
Mr. Rarry Mangsatabam, aged about 56 years, S/o (L)
Mangsatabam
Iboyaima
Singh,
resident
of
Thangmeiband Yumnam Leikai, P.O. Lamphel, P.S.
Imphal, Imphal West District, Pin – 795004.
… Petitioner
- Versus –
1. Dr. M. Basanta Kumar Sharma, Secretary, Bar Council
of Manipur, High Court of Manipur Complex,
Mantripukhri, Imphal - 795001 and 8 others.
… Respondents
B E FO R E
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
For the petitioner
:
For the respondents
:
Mr. Rarry Mangsatabam, senior
advocate/party-in-person
Mr. W. Sanatomba, Advocate for R1
to R9 led by Mr. S. Biswajit Meitei,
senior advocate
Date of hearing & order :
03.06.2026
O R D E R
[1]
Read this in conjunction with and in continuation of earlier
proceedings made in the previous listing on 25.05.2026 which reads as
follows :
‘Item No. 1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
CONT.CAS(C) No. 26 of 2026
Rarry Mangsatabam
Petitioner/s
Vrs.
M. Basanta Kumar Sharma & 8 ors.
Respondent/s
BEFORE
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR
(ORDER)
25.05.2026
[1]
In the captioned contempt case, Mr. Rarry Mangsatabam,
who is the contempt petitioner appearing party-in-person is before this Court
(physical Court).
[2]
Contempt petitioner appearing party-in-person is a learned
Member of this Bar, he is a designated Senior Advocate and he is a elected
member of ‘Bar Council of Manipur’ (‘BCM’ for the sake of brevity).
[3]
Learned contempt petitioner submits that he has filed
WP(C) No. 802 of 2025 on 06.10.2025 inter alia assailing resolutions and
notices of BCM which were made pursuant to/ acting on a complaint dated
22.07.2025 from one ‘Mr. Thongbam Mahipal Singh’ (‘complainant’ for the
sake of brevity).
[4]
Contempt petitioner submitted that his afore-referred writ
petition was entertained by this Court, notice was issued and an interim order
was made on 29.10.2025. Contempt petitioner draws the attention of this
Court to this 29.10.2025 order made in WP(Writ Petition) and
MC(Miscellaneous Case) thereat and the same is as follows:
‘29.10.2025
[1]
Writ petitioner in the captioned ‘main writ
petition’ (‘WP' for the sake of brevity) is a member of High
Court Bar Association of Manipur and is a designated
senior advocate. Writ petitioner is also an elected
member of Bar Council of Manipur. Writ petitioner is
appearing party-in-person.
[2]
Epicenter of the captioned WP is a
‘complaint dated 22.07.2025’ (‘said complaint’ for
convenience) from one Mr. Thongbam Mahipal Singh of
Imphal who is respondent No. 2 in the captioned WP and
captioned MC thereat.
[3]
In and vide said complaint, respondent No.
2 alleged unethical professional conduct qua writ
petitioner primarily on the ground that writ petitioner who
was a former Additional Advocate General of State of
Manipur and presently a State Special Counsel is
appearing in cases in the High Court of Manipur on behalf
of Manipur Lokayukta, in cases which are filed against
the State Government. The afore-referred said complaint
was received by respondent No. 1 (Bar Council of
Manipur) which shall hereinafter be referred to as ‘BCM’
for convenience, on the next date, i.e., 23.07.2025.
Acting on the said complaint, BCM made a ‘resolution
dated 26.07.2025’ (‘1st impugned resolution) inter alia
resolving to show cause writ petitioner, pursuant to
which a ‘Show Cause Notice dated 06.08.2025’ (‘1st
impugned SCN’ for convenience) was issued, this was
followed by another resolution of BCM being ‘Resolution
dated 30.08.2025’ (‘2nd impugned resolution’ for
convenience) inter alia resolving to request writ
petitioner to not to appear as counsel for Lokayukta (to
be noted, this is Agenda No. 3 in this resolution).
Pursuant to the second impugned resolution, another
‘Show Cause Notice dated 23.09.2025’ (2nd impugned
SCN for convenience) was issued inter alia calling upon
writ petitioner to rethink qua appearing for Lokayukta and
also calling upon writ petitioner to choose between
resigning from membership of Bar Council of Manipur or
resigning from the office of Senior Advisor of the High
Court Bar Association, Manipur.
[4]
Assailing the afore-referred complaint, 1st
and 2nd impugned Resolutions of BCM, 1st and 2nd
impugned SCNs, captioned WP has been filed.
[5]
In his campaign against the afore-referred
complaint, resolutions, SCNs, writ petitioner made the
following points:
(a) The 1st and 2nd impugned Show Cause Notices are
not traceable to any power either under ‘the
Advocates Act, 1961’ (‘said Act’ for convenience)
or the Rules made thereunder being ‘the Bar
Council of India Rules, 1975’ (‘said Rule’ for
convenience).
(b) Respondent No. 2 (complainant) does not have
locus as he has neither appeared for counsel
representing him nor is there any other form of
privity between the complainant and writ
petitioner.
(c) The language in which the impugned 1st and 2nd
SCNs are couched, come across as SCNs which
have pre-judged the issue as it call upon writ
petitioner to make an option rather than
explain/show cause.
(d) The Membership of respondent No. 1 (BCM) is by
way of election, writ petitioner is an electee and an
elected member of the Bar Council cannot be
dislodged by disciplinary proceedings inter alia
under Section 35 of the said Act.
[6]
Prima facie case for issue of notice made
out.
[7]
Issue notice
[8]
Ms. S. Nikita, learned counsel, accepts
notice for respondent No. 1 and Mr. S. Biswajit, learned
senior counsel, appears on her behalf. As regards
respondent No. 2, let notice returnable in four weeks, i.e.,
returnable by 26.11.2025 be issued. Private notice
permitted.
[9]
Mr. S. Biswajit, learned senior counsel, on
instructions submitted that learned counsel on record
requires time to ascertain the provision of law to which
the SCN is traceable. Learned counsel for respondent
No. 1 requested time to get instructions on other aspects
of the matter also.
[10]
Be that as it may, as regards captioned MC,
from the trajectory the matter has taken, it is clear that if
the proceedings continue, it can lead to irreversible legal
injury. This tilts balance of convenience in favour of grant
of interim order sought for. Interim order sought for in the
captioned MC is as follows:
‘PRAYER
It is therefore most respectfully prayed that this
Hon'ble Court may be pleased to pass an Order
staying all further proceeding before the
Respondent no.1/Bar Council of Manipur arising
out of the Complaint dated 22.07.2025 filed by the
Respondent no.2 against the Petitioner-Advocate,
including all consequential Impugned Misc.
Resolution no.2 dated 26.07.2025, Impugned
Resolution no.1 and 3 dated 30.08.2025,
Impugned Notice dated 23.09.2025 of the
Respondent no.1/ Bar Council of Manipur, during
the pendency of the present writ proceeding, for
meeting the ends of justice.’
[11]
As prima facie case has been made out
balance of convenience is in favour of grant of interim
order and as there is possibility of irreparable legal injury,
there shall be an order of interim stay as prayed for till the
next listing which will be on 26.11.2025.
[12]
In the interregnum, it is open to respondent
No. 1 to file an affidavit-in-opposition and bring it on
board, if so advised and if so desired.
[13]
List on 26.11.2025.’
[5]
Contempt petitioner, adverting to paragraph Nos. 10 & 11
of afore-referred order submits that an interim order was granted but when
the interim order was operating, in breach of the interim order, BCM in its
meeting on 22.11.2025 made resolutions inter alia pertaining to the
resolutions which are under challenge in WP as well as with regard to further
action pertaining to complaint dated 22.07.2025 from Mr. Thongbam
Mahipal Singh which has been described in 29.10.2025 order as epicenter.
Contempt petitioner, adverting to affidavits of BCM being affidavits dated
13.02.2026 & 30.03.2026 in WP, submitted that BCM has filed affidavits in
this Court clearly confirming the resolution made on 22.11.2025 inter alia
regarding further action qua 22.07.2025 complaint (epicenter) and therefore
it is a case of contempt/breach of 29.10.2025 order of this Court. Contempt
petitioner went on to submit that even on a demurer, even if the resolutions
are seen as a roll back, there is a clear resolution about further proceedings
to take forward the complaint dated 22.07.2025 whereas all further
proceedings inter alia further proceedings pursuant to complaint dated
22.07.2025 (epicenter) have been stayed by this Court.
[6]
It was also pointed out that the 29.10.2025 order had
thereafter been extended until further orders as both respondents in the WP
had entered appearance through counsel and complainant (R2) has sought
time to file affidavit in opposition. Though the contempt petition says that
the order has been made absolute, contempt petitioner fairly submits that the
interim order has not been made absolute but has been extended until further
orders.
[7]
Mr. W. Sanatomba, learned counsel who has filed
Vakalatnama for Bar Council of Manipur (respondent No. 1 in the WP) is
before this Court as WP and MC thereat are also listed today. This Court
gave the option to learned counsel Mr. W. Sanatomba to accept notice in this
contempt petition also and file a suitable affidavit in the contempt petition
but learned counsel submitted that he does not have instructions from the
respondents to accept notice and to be noted this is in spite of multiple earlier
listings where such option was given to learned counsel. This Court also
examined the possibility of mediation in the main WP and the MC thereat
but Section 6 of the Mediation Act, 2023 (32 of 2023) and serial No. 4 of
the First Schedule thereat appears to come in the way as the case at hand
may well fall under the category of disputes/matters not fit for mediation as
it is a case of complaint before a statutory authority pertaining to
practitioner/registered professional. To be noted, this Court is acutely
conscious that Mediation Act, 2023 is a conditional legislation, it consists of
65 Sections, it is dated 14.09.2023, it was published in the Official Gazette
on 15.09.2023 but only 21 out of the 65 Sections (excluding Section 6)
kicked in (came into force) on 09.10.2023 vide Notification being S.O.
4384(E). To put it differently, Section 6 and obviously the First Schedule
have not come into force but it has categorized complaints to a regulatory
body against a registered professional as a dispute/matter not fit for
mediation.
[8]
In the light of the narrative thus far, as 22.11.2025
resolution clearly talks about deliberation qua 22.07.2025 complaint and
authorizing the Secretary of the Bar Council of Manipur to verify veracity
of the documents submitted by the complainant and collect relevant judicial
orders, prima facie view is 22.07.2025 complaint is being proceeded with,
on the teeth of 29.10.2025 interim order which is operating. As contempt
petitioner has made out a prima facie case for issue of notice, this Court has
no option other than writing that prima facie case for issue of notice to
respondents has been made out and issue notice.
[9]
Issue notice to respondents, returnable by 03.06.2026.
[10]
Dasti notice is permitted.
[11]
List on 03.06.2026.
CHIEF JUSTICE
Indrajeet’
[2]
Today, in the hearing, Mr. Rarry Mangsatabam, contempt
petitioner appearing party-in-person is before this physical Court.
[3]
As regards the respondents, all 9 (nine) respondents have
been served, ‘respondent Nos. 1 to 3’ (‘R1 to R3’ for the sake of
convenience) and ‘respondent Nos. 5 to 9’ (‘R5 to R9’ for the sake of
convenience) are present in Court (physical Court). To be noted, with
the exception of R1, all other respondents are learned senior
members/members of this Bar and they are present before this Court
(physical Court). As regards R4, this Court is informed that he is
travelling (not in station) and Mr. W. Sanatomba, learned counsel is
representing him also and further to be noted, Mr. S. Biswajit Meitei,
learned senior counsel is appearing on behalf of Mr. W. Sanatomba. To
be noted, R1 to R3 and R5 to R9 are represented by Mr. W. Sanatomba,
learned counsel, and Mr. S. Biswajit Meitei, learned counsel appears on
his behalf. This means that all 9 (nine) respondents {8 (eight) of whom
are present in this Court (physical Court)} as well as R4 are represented
by counsel who in turn is led by a learned senior counsel.
[4]
Adverting to earlier proceedings dated 25.05.2026, Mr. S.
Biswajit Meitei, learned senior counsel, on instructions from Mr. W.
Sanatomba as well as the respondents who are present in Court (who
also represent R4) submitted that proceedings of ‘BCM’ (‘Bar Council of
Manipur’) made on 8th March, 2026 could not be brought to the notice
of this Court in the last listing owing to want of instructions and lapse
in communication. Today, learned senior counsel has placed before this
Court the proceedings of BCM dated 08.03.2026 and scanned
reproduction of the same is as follows :
[5]
Adverting to afore-referred proceedings, learned senior
counsel submitted that Agenda No. 3 is of relevance to the captioned
contempt case and drew the attention of this Court to the Resolution
on the same i.e., Resolution No. 3. Furthering his submissions in this
direction, on instructions, learned senior counsel submitted the
following :
i)
Afore-referred Resolution No. 3 of Agenda No. 3
continues to operate and will continue to operate i.e.,
BCM would await verdict of this Court in WP(C) No.
802 of 2025 and MCs thereat.
ii) Afore-referred 08.03.2026 Resolution as regards
Agenda No.3 supersedes all other Resolutions of BCM
pertaining to Agenda No. 3 and any matter pertaining
to subject matter of WP(C)No.802 of 2025. This
submission is recorded.
iii) Aforementioned Agenda No. 3 and/or any other issue
touching upon subject matter of WP(C) No. 802 of
2025 will not be tabled until Verdict is returned by this
Court in WP(C) No. 802 of 2025 and MCs thereat.
[6]
If only the afore-referred Resolution dated 08.03.2026
had been brought to the notice of this Court, this Court would have
been saved of the unpleasant task of issuing notice to respondents in
the captioned contempt case. On this note, recording the stated
position of the respondents, captioned contempt case is given a closure
by writing that the same is disposed of as closed discharging all
respondents from contempt case. There shall be no order as to costs.
CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
Sushil
P.S. I : Upload forthwith
P.S. II : All concerned will stand bound by web copy uploaded in High Court
website inter-alia as the same is QR coded.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review