Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:223
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
WP(S) No.16 of 2026
----1. Rani Singh, aged about 51 years, W/o Sanjay Kumar, R/o
Ratu Road, Near Ojha Market, Devi Mandap Road, P.O. Hehal,
P.S. Sukhdev Nagar & District Ranchi.
2. Kumari Champak Lata, aged about 45 years, W/o Mahesh
Kumar, R/o House No-180, Adarsh Nagar, Naya Toli, Pandra,
P.O. Hehal, P.S. Pandra & District- Ranchi.
3. Rajni Kumari, aged about 35 years, W/o Chandra Shekhar
Kumar, R/o Village Byonk, P.O. Ganwan, P.S. Ganwan &
District- Giridih.
4. Anjum Shahin, aged about 33 years, W/o Abdul Firoj Siddiki,
R/o Village Ahirpurwa, P.O. Barwadih, P.S. Barwadih & DistrictLatehar.
… Petitioner(s).
Versus
1. The Jharkhand Staff Selection Commission through its
Secretary, having its office at Kali Nagar, Chai Bagan, P.O., P.S.
Namkum & District - Ranchi.
2. The Chairman, Jharkhand Staff Selection Commission, having
its office at Kali Nagar, Chai Bagan, P.O., P.S. Namkum &
District Ranchi.
3. The Examination Controller, Jharkhand Staff Selection
Commission, having its office at Kali Nagar, Chai Bagan, P.O.,
P.S. Namkum & District - Ranchi.
… Respondent(s).
CORAM
SRI ANANDA SEN, J.
-----For the Petitioner(s) : Mr. Abhijeet Indra Guru, Advocate
Mr. Chanchal Jain, Advocate
For the JSSC
: Mr. Sanjoy Piprawall, Advocate
Mr. Rakesh Ranjan, Advocate
Mr. Prince Kumar, Advocate
Mr. Jay Prakash, Advocate
Mr. Tejo Mistry, Advocate
…......
02 /07.01.2026:
:
Heard, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioners, learned counsels appearing on behalf of the State and
learned counsels appearing on behalf of the JSSC.
2.
The issue involved and sought to be raised in this writ
petition has already been decided by Hon’ble Coordinate Single
Bench of this Court in W.P.(S) No. 582 of 2023 (Mina Kumari
Vs. The State of Jharkhand & Others along with Analogous
Cases) vide order dated 01.09.2025, wherein following directions
have been given, which are quoted herein below:1
2026:JHHC:223
“51. Accordingly, to maintain institutional integrity and
ensure an impartial enquiry a one-man commission headed
by a former judge of this Court is being constituted. Hon’ble
Dr. Justice S.N. Pathak (Retd.) is appointed as a One-Man
Fact-Finding Commission to look into the matter of
irregularities and illegalities, if any, committed in the matter
of preparation and publication of the revised merit list
pursuant to the judgment and orders passed by the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the matters referred to above. The One-Man
Fact-Finding Commission is requested to make an enquiry
and report, inter alia, on the following issues:
I. Whether the respondent JSSC has at all prepared the
revised merit list and other merit lists as per the
judgment and orders of the Hon’ble Apex Court before
making appointments after the judgment dated
02.08.2022?
II. Who are and how many numbers of ‘already
appointed and protected candidates’ having lesser
marks than the marks obtained by the petitioners have
been accommodated and whether their actual dates of
appointment and joining is prior to and as per the
judgment dated 02.08.2022 passed by the Hon’ble
Apex Court or not ?
III. Who are and how many numbers of ‘original writ
petitioners’ as indicated in the judgment of the Hon’ble
Apex Court having lesser marks than the petitioners in
their respective subjects have been appointed by the
respondents and whether they deserve to be included in
the said category ?
IV. Whether the vacancies indicated to be occupied by
the absentees or non-joining candidates in the year
2019 which is large in number and not surrendered
have been actually filled up by the respondents by less
meritorious candidates?
V. Further it shall also be required to be verified as to,
whether the candidates whose candidature was rejected
on valid reasons have been later on favoured with
appointments and the candidates who have lesser
marks than the petitioners have actually been
appointed prior to the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex
Court or after 02.08.2022 ?
VI. Any other aspect / issue which the One-Man FactFinding Commission may think fit and proper.
52. In view of the above, the One-Man Fact-Finding
Commission is requested to make an enquiry into the aspects
referred to in Paragraph No.50 of this Judgment within a
period of three months from the date of receipt of this
Judgment and submit its report to the State Government,
which may be placed before the Hon’ble Council of Ministers
for taking an informed decision on the report and
recommendations of the One-Man Fact-Finding Commission.
The Final decision of the State Government must be taken
within 6 weeks from the date of submission of the report by
the One-Man Fact-Finding Commission.
2026:JHHC:223
53. This Court further directs that the State Government shall
take final decision on the above referred report and the issue
involved as indicated herein below:
(i) How to appoint/adjust the genuine candidates?
(ii) To take appropriate actions to remove the noneligible candidates;
(iii) To take action against erring officials / staffs of the
concerned Department/JSSC; both departmentally
and/or criminally.
54. The One-Man Fact-Finding Commission is free to devise
the mechanism and procedure for making the enquiry as
directed by this Court and it shall be free to consider issuing a
general notice inviting objections/representations from the
writ petitioners only and after hearing all the concerned may
prepare the report so that the orders passed by the Hon’ble
Apex Court are complied with in its letters and spirit.
It is further clarified that the One-Man Fact Finding
Commission would be empowered to summon any person/(s)
/Official/(s) of the Respondents and/or call for any documents
in original from them for proper enquiry as aforesaid.
55.
It is worth mentioning here that the Learned Advocate
General has, during course of his arguments, made a
proposal that the Petitioners may approach the Secretary of
the JSSC raising their individual claims and their grievances
can be redressed at that level subject to the available
vacancies. Though this Court appreciates the
proposal made by Ld. A.G.; however, in the attending facts
and circumstances, this Court is declining to accept such
proposal of sending the Petitioners to JSSC itself for the
purpose of enquiry into the issues mentioned in Paragraph 50
of this Judgment, for which purpose a One-Man Fact Finding
Commission is being appointed and the Petitioners would be
at liberty to place their claims in the form of Representations
and supporting documents before the One Man Fact-Finding
Commission, as already observed earlier.
56. This Court also directs that the already appointed
candidates shall not be disturbed until final outcome of the
enquiry and if any appointment or appointments are found to
be wrongful or in breach of the directions of the Hon’ble Apex
Court; the concerned candidate will be afforded due
opportunity before any final action is taken with respect to
their services.
57. The State Government is directed to make all necessary
arrangements to effective functioning of the One-Man FactFinding Commission including providing of Secretarial Staff
and other support staff. The State Government must ensure
that the sittings of the Commission are held at a venue that
the One-Man Commission may decide. The One-Man FactFinding Commission must be paid a sum of Rs. 6,00,000/(Rupees Six Lakh Only) as renumeration. The same must be
paid within three equated monthly instalments.
58. Inspite of the above controversies and issues which
may be enquired into by the One-Man Fact-Finding
Commission; yet another important aspect which requires
consideration/determination, inasmuch as, if as against the
total advertised vacancies i.e. 17784; the Respondents have
2026:JHHC:223
appointed only 12046 candidates and 3704 vacancies are
claimed to have been surrendered on account of nonavailability of S.C. & S.T. candidates; then the remaining
2034 vacancies needs to be offered to the eligible Petitioners
strictly on the basis of their respective merits. In other words,
there are good number of vacancies which have not being
filled up at all. Thus, the Respondents are also directed to fillup the remaining 2034 vacancies within a period of six
months and the Petitioners would be at liberty to approach
the Respondent JSSC/Secretary by way of filing their detailed
representation within a period eight weeks from the date of
this Judgment and upon receipt of such representation/(s);
the JSSC shall make due recommendation to the concerned
department for the needful after thorough verification. It is
made clear that the aforesaid direction shall only be
applicable w.e.f. the remaining vacancies i.e. 2034.
59. Further, the vacancies which may be carved out on the
basis of the One-Man Fact-Finding Commission Report and
the informed decision of the State Government, shall be
offered to the other deserving candidates in due course.
60.
Registry is directed to send the copy this order to the
Hon’ble Mr. Justice S. N. Pathak (Retd.). Copy of this order
shall also be handed over to the Ld. Advocate General & Mr.
Sanjoy Piprewal for onward transmission to all the concerned
authorities.
61. Before parting, it is pertinent to observe that after
every examination for selection by JSSC or JPSC, this Court is
flooded with the writ petitions complaining about nonconsideration or rejection or non-discloser of marks of
selected or non-selected candidates and thereby violation of
Article 14 & 16 of the Constitution.
Often this Court has to call for original records to verify
the facts and claims of the candidates, which becomes clumsy
and time taking; thus, this Court proposes the State
Government to constitute an authority within JPSC/JSSC as a
“Fact-Finding Body” to receive the grievances of the
candidates and pass reasoned and speaking orders based on
the verification of the original records which are maintained
by these organisations. This authority, if constituted, shall act
as a primary fact-finding authority to give its view only on the
factual claims of the candidates; which will naturally filter out
the genuine claims and it would also lessen the burden of this
Court.”
3.
The parties submit that this case is similar to “Mina
Kumari’s” (supra) case.
4.
Learned counsel for the State and the JSSC submit that
they have already challenged the aforesaid order in Letters Patent
Appeal being L.P.A. No.764 of 2025, titled as “The Chairman,
JPSC & Others Vs. Mina Kumari & Others”.
5.
Considering the fact that since the issue has already
2026:JHHC:223
been decided by the Hon’ble Coordinate Bench of this Court in the
case of “Mina Kumari” (supra) vide order dated 01.09.2025,
wherein some directions have been issued and this Court in similar
batch of writ petitions i.e. W.P.(S) No. 5040 of 2025 (Avishek
Kumar Gupta Vs. The State of Jharkhand & Ors.) and other
Analogues cases, while taking into consideration the order
passed in the case of “Mina Kumari” (supra), disposed of the said
writ petitions in terms of the order passed in the case of “Mina
Kumari” (supra), and admittedly this case is covered by the said
order, I am disposing of this writ petition in terms of the final
order passed by the Hon’ble Coordinate Single Bench of this Court
in W.P.(S) No. 582 of 2023 (Mina Kumari & Others Vs. The
State of Jharkhand & Others along with Analogous Cases).
6.
The order passed by the Hon’ble Coordinate Bench of
this Court will be made applicable in this case also.
7.
Be it noted that if in the Letters Patent Appeal preferred
thereagainst, any order is passed or direction is given, the same
will also be applicable in this writ petition.
8.
With the aforesaid observations, this writ petition
stands disposed of.
9.
Pending interlocutory application, if any, also stands
disposed of.
(ANANDA SEN, J.)
07.01.2026
Tanuj/CP-2
Uploaded on 09.01.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review