Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
$~16 & 17
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & CM APPLs. 13124/2017, 21686/2024,
21695/2024
ISHWAR SINGH
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Dharambir Singh, AR with
Petitioner (in-Person).
versus
THE NODAL OFFICER / ADM (NEW DELHI) & ORS
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Sanjay Kumar Pathak, SC with
Mrs. K.K. Kiran Pathak, Mr. Sunil
Kumar Jha, Mr. M.S. Akhtar and Ms.
Joohu Kumari, Advocates for R-1.
Ms. Anjana Gosain and Ms. Shreya
Manjaria, Advocates for R-2.
Mr. Digvijay Rai, SC with Mr. Archit
Mishra, Advocate for AAI with Mr.
Y.S. Chaudhary, Law Officer.
Mr. Arjun Pant, Advocate for DDA.
+
W.P.(C) 3015/2017 & CM APPLs. 13194/2017, 21688/2024,
21725/2024
RAN SINGH
Through:
.....Petitioner
Mr. Dharambir Singh, AR with
Petitioner (in-Person).
versus
NADAL OFFICER / ADM (NEW DELHI) & ORS
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Sanjay Kumar Pathak, SC with
Mrs. K.K. Kiran Pathak, Mr. Sunil
Kumar Jha, Mr. M.S. Akhtar and Ms.
Joohu Kumari, Advocates for R-1.
Ms. Anjana Gosain and Ms. Shreya
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
Manjaria, Advocates for R-2.
Mr. Digvijay Rai, SC with Mr. Archit
Mishra, Advocate for AAI with Mr.
Y.S. Chaudhary, Law Officer.
Mr. Arjun Pant, Advocate for DDA.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV NARULA
%
1.
ORDER
26.02.2026
These two writ petitions arise from the same acquisition, turn on the
same rehabilitation scheme, and challenge the same administrative
decisions. The record also shows substantial overlap in the submissions.
They are both, therefore, being disposed of by way of a common order.
Facts and Procedural Background
2.
On 28th April, 1972, a notification under Section 4 of the Land
Acquisition Act, 1894 was issued proposing acquisition of abadi land of
Village Nangal Dewat for the public purpose of expansion and development
of the IGI Airport. A declaration under Section 6 followed on 28 th August,
1979. The Land Acquisition Collector made Award No. 16/86-87 on 14th
August, 1986, determining the area under the acquisition as 263 bighas and
5 biswas.
3.
Village Nangal Dewat comprised the old abadi (popularly referred to
as “Lal Dora”) and an extended abadi. The old abadi did not have the usual
revenue record. The extended abadi did. In that setting, a survey was carried
out in 1972 to identify land and structures in the old abadi and structures in
the extended abadi.
4.
Residents challenged the execution of the acquisition proceedings by
way of W.P.(C) 481/1982. On 18th September, 1986, the implementation of
the award was stayed for three months, with the Court expecting
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
governmental decision-making on resettlement.
5.
When the matter came up on 2nd August, 2001, a statement was made
on behalf of Respondent No. 3/Airports Authority of India1 that persons
whose names appeared in the award would be allotted alternative land, and
categorisation of plots would be carried out on that basis. The challenge to
acquisition was, in consequence, given up and the writ petition was
dismissed. A review petition [R.P.9312/2001] was thereafter filed against
this order.
6.
Thereafter, representations were made at the level of the Lieutenant
Governor seeking modification of plot categorisation, on the footing that
village residents lived as joint families and required larger plots.
7.
As the process progressed, the Court noticed that several landowners
had died and that mutation applications by legal heirs were pending. On 29 th
October, 2003, directions were issued for expeditious decision of mutation
applications, and for inclusion of such names in the draw of lots, while
deferring actual allotment until mutation disputes were resolved.
8.
On 28th April, 2004, the Court appointed a Nodal Officer to
coordinate the rehabilitation exercise and to prepare the list of eligible
candidates after considering objections. The order also contemplated that if
the issue concerned eligibility of a category, the list would be prepared and
the category issue would be placed for consideration.
9.
Thereafter, lists were prepared and subsequently revised. In the
consolidated list that ultimately formed the basis of allotments, three
separate plots were allotted to Bhiku S/o Meda, Rizak Ram S/o Bhiku and
Munshi S/o Balle Ram S/o Bhiku at Serial Nos. 89, 91 and 92, respectively.
“AAI”
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
These allotments were later merged by order of the Nodal Officer dated 25 th
January, 2005. The Petitioner, Ishwar Singh S/o Sukhan S/o Bhiku, is
aggrieved thereby and has assailed the same in W.P.(C) 2997/2017.
Similarly, the names of the five sons of Ramji Lal, namely Lekhram,
Bhagwana, Puran, Harnath and Ratan Lal, were reflected collectively at
Serial No. 94, and a joint alternative plot was proposed on the basis of the
aggregate entry. Ran Singh S/o Lekh Ram is aggrieved by the said action
and challenges the same in W.P.(C) 3015/2017.
10.
During the same period, another controversy arose relating to land
recorded not in the name of identified individuals but in the name of
communities. On 16th December, 2004, the explanation placed before this
Court in R.P. 9312/2001was that the record did not permit identification of
individuals where allotment was to a community and not to named persons.
The Court observed that, in terms of the total community land shown, the
community would be entitled to plots as a group, and the manner of internal
distribution would be for the community to resolve.
11.
The review petition ultimately came to be dismissed on 18th May,
2005, with the Court recording, in substance, that no enforceable right to an
alternative plot existed dehors the scheme as framed.
12.
On 4th January, 2007, in W.P.(C) 18324/2006 filed by one Surat
Singh, the Court declined to interfere with the criterion followed by the Noal
Officer, stipulating that landholdings reflected in the 1972 survey would be
merged and a single plot allotted, even where different family members
were shown separately. The appeal against the said decision [LPA
112/2007] was dismissed on 10th January, 2013.
13.
During the pendency of another petition filed by, inter alia, the
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
Harijan and Backward Jan Kalyan Samiti, the Ministry of Civil Aviation
considered further measures for backward communities in occupation of
community land. A committee process followed. A list of 122 persons
prepared in the year 1958, reflecting allotment of independent plots in their
respective individual names, was treated as the outer limit. Thereafter, a
further survey was conducted between June and July, 2007 to verify
possession over the community land. The committee recommended
eligibility for persons meeting the twin requirements of linkage to the 1958
list and possession at verification.
14.
As per the Committee’s report dated 17th July, 2007, and in terms of
the criteria stipulated by AAI on 24th December, 2002, consolidated
alternative plots admeasuring 450 sq. metres each were allotted in favour of
the legal representatives of Bhiku and of Ramji Lal.
15.
Challenges to the criteria and policy were litigated. The Single Judge
dismissed the challenge on 18th March, 2008. The Division Bench dismissed
connected appeals on 16th April, 2013.
16.
Against this background, an order was passed on 12 th March, 2013 by
ADM/LA (South-West), allotting individual plot in favour of the Petitioners.
AAI assailed that order in W.P.(C) 4200/2013 and 4280/2013. By a common
order dated 13th July, 2016, the Court held that the matter should be decided
by the ADM appointed as Nodal Officer, New Delhi, within three months,
on merits and uninfluenced by observations in the disposal order.
17.
Pursuant to that direction, the Nodal Officer passed separate
impugned orders, both dated 4th January, 2017 rejecting the claims for
separate individual alternative plots on similar grounds. The present writ
petitions challenge those decisions.
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
Petitioners’ Submissions
18.
The submissions advanced by Mr. Dharambir Singh, the authorised
representative on behalf of all the Petitioners, are summarised as follows:
18.1. The impugned orders dated 4th January, 2017 defeat the rehabilitation
scheme settled by this Court. The Petitioners do not seek a second plot, but
recognition of their fathers’ (Late Lekhram’s and Sukhan’s) independent
entitlement, to be computed on the basis of their separate holding and
eligibility. The rehabilitation benefit, though not a statutory right arising
from acquisition, became enforceable once the scheme was framed,
approved, and administered. The Nodal Officer was bound to apply the
scheme and not to dilute it by importing conditions not contemplated by the
scheme.
18.2. The names of Late Lekhram and Sukhan were separately recorded in
the source documents and they were treated as eligible persons in the
rehabilitation exercise. However, the Nodal Officer treated them as forming
part of a joint unit with the other legal representatives and made a
consolidated allotment of 450 sq. metre plots each. According to the
Petitioners, this amounts to a misapplication of the scheme, which does not
allow clubbing of separately eligible persons into a single allotment merely
on the ground of familial relationship.
18.3. Under the correct application of the scheme, Late Lekhram ought to
have been allotted an individual plot of 160 sq. metres, based on the
clubbing of his holdings in the old abadi and community land. Similarly,
Late Sukhan would be entitled to a separate allotment of 250 sq. metres.
18.4. The scheme provided two-fold gateway for eligibility, coupled with a
clubbing rule for plot size. The eligibility is established where the claimant’s
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
name appears either in the survey report (old abadi) or in the jamabandi as
on 28th April, 1972, and also appears in the naksha muntazamin. Where a
claimant’s name appears at more than one place, either in an individual
capacity or as a legal heir, the total holding is to be clubbed for determining
the plot size
18.5. The Petitioners contend that Late Lekhram and Late Sukhan satisfy
the eligibility criteria under two independent streams recognised by the
rehabilitation framework. They assert that their names appear in the 1972
survey relating to old abadi with quantified holdings as well as in the award
and the naksha muntazamin.
18.6. The Petitioners also claim eligibility on the community land side.
They rely upon (i) inclusion of Late Lekhram and Late Sukhan or their
lineage in the 1958 consolidation list of 122 persons, and (ii) possession
during the physical verification exercise conducted in June to July 2007.
They contend that once such eligibility is recognised, the scheme requires
clubbing of holdings only for computing plot size; however, the
Respondents have instead used clubbing to merge distinct eligible persons
and subsume their entitlement within an earlier joint allotment.
18.7. The Petitioners dispute the Respondents’ insistence on mutation for
old abadi, contending that in Lal Dora areas possession is treated as
ownership. As old abadi lands lack regular revenue entries, requiring
mutation is impractical and contrary to the scheme, which accords the
survey report parity with the jamabandi.
18.8. Reliance is placed on an order dated 30th May, 2007 passed by this
Court in AAI v. Karan Singh,2 to contend that the role of the Nodal Officer
CM(M) 249/2007, (2007) 141 DLT 277.
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
is confined to applying the criteria approved by the Court and that he cannot
introduce fresh standards under the guise of implementation. According to
the Petitioners, the impugned order does precisely that by imposing a
mutation requirement despite separate mention in the source documents, and
by treating distinct eligible persons as joint allottees merely because their
names appear together in a consolidated list.
18.9. They further rely on the reasoning of the Division Bench in Bhoop
Singh versus DDA & Ors.,3 which, on their reading, recognises that in old
abadi, possession is treated as equivalent to ownership and that the scheme
does not sanction a preference for extended abadi merely because
conventional revenue records exist there.
18.10. The Petitioners term the impugned order perverse on three grounds:
(i) it proceeds on the incorrect premise that mutation was not effected and
hence a separate plot could not be granted; (ii) it misconstrues the decision
dated 4th January, 2007, in W.P.(C) 18324/2006, as mandating joint
allotment of family members shown separately, though it only contemplates
clubbing of landholdings for plot size; and (iii) the reliance on absence of
separate compensation for the superstructure is misplaced and cannot defeat
a claim where separate holding and distinct entries in the award and
apportionment are shown, particularly when earlier corrections and
administrative practice have recognised separate names as sufficient for
separate allotments.
18.11.
The Petitioners allege discriminatory treatment, contending that
other co-sharers reflected in the acquisition and apportionment record were
granted separate plots, whereas they alone have been subjected to a joint
LPA 260/2008.
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
allotment.
18.12.
They further allege that the Respondents, including the Nodal
Officer and AAI, have made incorrect statements in their counter affidavits
regarding mutation, the basis of clubbing, and compliance with the scheme,
and submit that such explanations ought not to be accepted in the face of
contrary source records and prior administrative corrections.
18.13. It is accordingly prayed that the impugned orders be set aside and
Late Lekhram and Late Sukhan be treated as individual eligible allottees,
with their old abadi and community land holdings clubbed only for
determining plot size, and separate allotments issued in accordance with
their entitlement.
Submissions on behalf of AAI and the Respondents
19.
AAI submits that the impugned order applies the settled framework
and does not depart from the scheme. Their contentions are summarised as
follows:
19.1. It is urged that the Petitioners are seeking, in substance, a reworking
of the 308 list and the earlier joint allotment entry. According to AAI, the
relevant record position as on 28th April, 1972 showed the land in the name
of the ancestor, and mutation in favour of the Petitioner’s predecessor was
not reflected in the revenue record on the cut-off date. Therefore, the joint
allotment to the legal heirs of the recorded holder was consistent with the
scheme and the long line of orders.
19.2. It is further submitted that, in any event, the impugned order draws
support from judicial directions to the effect that mere appearance of a name
in the survey report and naksha muntazamin does not entitle a person to an
individual alternative plot if that person was not awarded separate
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
compensation for the land underneath the superstructure. AAI contends that
Late Sukhan and Late Lekhram were not given separate compensation for
the land beneath the structure in the award and hence could not claim a
separate alternative plot on that basis.
19.3. AAI denies discrimination. It is submitted that the Petitioners have
not placed a true comparable instance where a person without separate
compensation for land beneath the structure, and without the cut-off record
being in that person’s name, has nonetheless been allotted a separate plot.
19.4. It is also urged that the Nodal Officer could not have entertained a
fresh representation as a review, and that the petition is an attempt to reopen
issues that have attained finality through multiple rounds of litigation.
19.4. AAI also points out that the joint plot admeasuring 450 sq. metres has
not merely been allotted on paper, but possession has been offered. This,
according to AAI, demonstrates that the Petitioners have received the benefit
flowing from the clubbed entitlement and cannot now seek to recast that
clubbed entitlement into a separate individual allotment.
Analysis and Findings
20.
The Court has considered the submissions advanced by both sides.
The dispute herein is not about the legality of acquisition. It is about
rehabilitation. An allotment of alternative land in this matter is not a
statutory sequel to acquisition. It is a scheme-based benefit which evolved
through
judicial
supervision,
committee
recommendations,
and
administrative implementation over decades. That history fixes the
boundaries of enforceable entitlement. A claimant succeeds only by showing
that the scheme, as settled and applied, confers a right to the relief sought.
21.
The scheme is anchored to an organising discipline. The cut-off date
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
is 28th April, 1972. Eligibility and the size of the alternative plot are tested
by reference to the position as on that date, using the recognised source
documents. The scheme also guards against duplicity. Holdings may be
clubbed for determining plot size, but the scheme does not permit outcomes
which result in more than one plot being traced to the same holding or to the
same entitlement stream.
22.
The Petitioners are correct in pointing out that the Nodal Officer
cannot devise fresh criteria. That principle, explained in Karan Singh
confines the Nodal Officer to applying the framework already approved.
However, that limitation does not mean that every separate appearance of a
name in the survey report or in the naksha muntazamin automatically yields
a separate individual plot. The scheme still requires identification of the
“eligible unit” and, where necessary, the decision-maker must reconcile
occupation related entries with the award and apportionment record to
determine whether the claimant was treated as a separate landholding unit
for rehabilitation purposes.
23.
AAI’s explanation regarding the 1972 survey illuminates why this
reconciliation is necessary. The survey was undertaken to facilitate
apportionment of compensation for land and structures in the old abadi and,
in the extended abadi, essentially for structures since revenue records existed
for land. The survey, therefore, performs a descriptive and administrative
role. It is an input and not a final declaration of separate landholding status
for allotment. That is also why the naksha muntazamin and the award
remain decisive indicators when the claim is pitched as a demand for a
separate plot.
24.
This fits with the judicial direction relied upon by AAI and applied in
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
the impugned orders. The thrust of that direction is that a separate mention
of a name in the survey report and naksha muntazamin cannot, by itself,
compel allotment of an individual plot if the claimant was not awarded
separate compensation for the land beneath the superstructure. The scheme
thereby draws a workable distinction between occupation of a structure and
recognition as a separate landholding unit for allotment purposes. It prevents
the rehabilitation exercise from fragmenting into multiple independent
claims founded only on occupation entries.
25.
Once this principle is applied, the Petitioners’ case must answer a
narrow question. Do the source documents, read with the award and
apportionment, compel the conclusion that Late Lekhram or, as the case may
be, Late Sukhan, was treated as a separate landholding unit so as to warrant
a separate alternative plot. The impugned orders answer this against the
Petitioners by holding, inter alia, as follows:
In the case of Ishwar Singh, Petitioner in W.P.(C) 2997/2017:
“As per list of 316 persons prepared in the year 2004 at Sr. No. 89,
Bhiku S/o Meda was found in possession of 339.89 sq. yards
equivalent to 284.12 sq. Mtr, a joint plot was allotted in the name of
Bhiku S/o Meda as his name was mentioned in the revenue records
against Khasra No. 1236, for the land measuring 1008 sq. yards
situated in Extended lal dora of village Nangal Dewat. Also the LR's
of Bhiku were given entitlement in the list of 316 persons at Sr.
No.91 and 92 for the total land measuring 157 sq. yards or 131.28
sq. Mtr. Therefore, a total land measuring 496.89 sq. yards (339.89
+157) or 415.37 sq. Mtr. is found in possession of the LR's of Sh.
Bhiku. In lieu of this land i.e. 415.37 Sq. Mtr. and alternative plot
measuring 350 sq. Mtr was allotted in the names of Bhiku S/o Meda.
The name of Bhiku S/o Meda is mentioned at Sr. No. 89 in the list of
308 persons submitted by the then Nodal Officer before the Hon'ble
High Court on 25.01.2005.
Further, LR's of Sh. Bhiku i.e. Sukhan, Balle Ram, Deepa and
Rizak Ram have individual allotment in community land against
Khasra No. 1235/2 and 1241. In the list of 122 persons from Sr. No.
29 to 32. The verification team found 202 sq. yards in possession of
two LR's of Bhiku i.e. Sukhan and Balle Ram and the other two LR's
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
of Bhiku i.e. Deepa and Rizak Ram were not found in possession of
the community land. Therefore, as per criteria adopted by the
committee the holding of old abadi i.e. 308 list allotment and holding
of community land clubbed together i.e. 202+496.8=698.8 sq. yards
or 584.28 sq. Mtr. Accordingly, as per categorization list as
mentioned above, the applicant case falls in the category mentioned
at Sr. No. 10, therefore, a joint plot measuring 450 sq. Mtr. was
recommended in the name of LR's of Bhiku.
That as per the list of eligible person LR's of Sukhan S/o
Bhiku, Balle Ram S/o Bhiku jointly were found entitled to a plot
against their holdings in the community land and as per the order
dated 31.05.2007, their holdings were clubbed with the holdings of
Bhiku S/o Meda, who had earlier allotted a joint plot 350 sq. Mtr. in
the list of 308 persons. It is clear from the guidelines that no two
person can be allotted alternative plot twice, therefore, the holding
of community land of both i.e. LR's of Sh. Sukhan and Balle Ram
were clubbed with the plot already allotted (350 sq. Mtr.) in the
name of Bhiku S/o Meda and a larger size of plot measuring 450 sq.
Meters was allotted in lieu of the total holdings of the LR’s of Bhiku
S/o Meda, Sukhan S/o Bhiku, Balle Ram S/o Bhiku i.e. 698.8 sq.
yards/584.28 sq. Mtr. Hence in view of the order dated 31.05.2007
and 17.07.2007, the committee rightly clubbed the land holding of
the claimant and jointly allotted a plot in favour of LR’s of Bhiku S/o
Meda, Sukhan S/o Bhiku, Balle Ram S/o Bhiku jointly.
It is clear from the above mentioned fact that allotment in
lieu of Lal Dora land and extended Lal Dora land (496.8 sq. yards)
has already been made in the year 2004 in favour of LR’s of Bhiku
and further allotment in the lieu of 202 sq. yards in lieu of
community land was made in the year 2007 was clubbed with the
earlier allotment in the year 2004-05 and a joint plot measuring 450
sq. Mtr. was allotted in the name of LR’s of Bhiku S/o Meda, Sukhan
S/o Bhiku, Balle Ram S/o Bhiku. The details of joint allotment is also
given at Sr. No. 29 of Annexure-A, prepared by the then Nodal
Officer for recommendation in respect of community land for
allotment of alternative plots in village Nangal Dewat.
In this case as per policy/guidelines framed by the committee
in its report dated 17.07.2007, which read as under:
“It was also noticed that in many cases, the previous nodal officer
has recommended plots in joint names. The committee was of the
view that in all cases where the allotment has been made either in
individual capacity or in joint names the land holding of the
person/persons should be clubbed. Therefore, if a plot has already
been allotted in individual capacity or in joint capacity then the land
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
of the claimant should be added at the respective place.”
In this case, the later allotment shall be clubbed in earlier
allotment and a joint allotment is made. The same has been done in
this case, as later allotment in lieu of community land is clubbed
with earlier allotment made in lieu of old lal dora land i.e.
496.8+202=698.8 sq. yards and the same has been allotted in favour
of LR’s of Sh. Bhiku.
Therefore, claimant request for clubbing of old lal dora land
and extended lal dora in community land does not make any sense as
the same is against the policy/guidelines framed by the committee for
allotment of alternative plot and the same is liable to be rejected.
13. Now I come to the guidelines framed by the Hon’ble High Court
on 18.05.2005. Guidelines No. 3 clearly states that:
“If a person died intestate after 28.04.1972, the legal heirs will be
jointly entitled for allotment of a plot only. However where one or
more of the legal heirs have their own separate holding of a plot
then the proportionate share in the persons plot shall be added to
histheir own holding for determining categorization and size of plot
to be allotted”.
14. The case of the claimant is that Bhiku S/o Meda died in the year
1961, it is further stated that mutation was not carried out in the
records in the name of his legal heirs. It is noticed that the claimant
has not produced any document in support of his claim that Bhiku
S/o Meda was expired in the year 1961. The claimant has not
enclosed death certificate or any other document which can establish
that Bhiku S/o Meda was expired in the year 1961. It is pertinent to
mention here that the claimant is not aware about the exact date of
death of Sh. Bhiku S/o Meda and only upon his speculations;
claimant comes to the conclusion that Bhiku died in the year 1961
i.e. much before 28.04.1972. Further, consolidation process was
carried out in the year 1953-54 in village Nangal Dewat and as a
result of which extended lal dora plots were allotted to Sh. Bhiku S/o
Meda. Even if it is presumed that Bhiku died in the year 1961,
claimant failed to explain the reason for not carrying out the
mutation in revenue records against the plot allotted to his
forefather i.e. Bhiku S/o Meda. It is also supplemented that claimant
has not produced any Will executed by Bhiku S/o meda before this
office with respect to his holding in village Nangal Dewat. Hence as
per the guidelines dated 18.05.2005, the claimant is not entitled to a
separate piece of plot. It is clear from perusal of record that land in
extended lal dora was still recorded in the name of Bhiku S/o Meda
in Khasra No. 1236. LR’s of Bhiku failed to mutate the land in their
favour after death of their father. The claimant also failed to mutate
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
the land even after passing of direction in this regard from the
Hon’ble High Court in this regard. In view of the above, claimant
request for the allotment of individual alternative plot is liable to be
rejected.
15. The Hon’ble High Court in its judgment dated 04.01.2007 in
W.P. (C) No. 18324 of 2006 has held that:
“The Nodal Officer has considered this aspect that if the legal heirs
of those persons who died intestate after 28.04.1972 and in case
their names were not mutated separately, would also be entitled for
joint allotment of an alternative plot. No fault can be found with the
inference of the Nodal Officer that the benefit of mutation carried
out on 13.08.2004, be not extended at such a belated stage after the
decision of writ petition No. 481 of 1982 dated 18.05.2005, as the
cut off date of 28.04.1972 had to be kept in mind considering the
eligibility and entitlement. The alternative plots have to be allotted
on the basis of entry in the revenue record of the land in the old
abadi after being merged and, therefore there is no such illegality or
apparent mistake in the order of Nodal Officer in the facts and
circumstances which is being challenged by the petitioner.”
Since after the death of Bhiku S/o Meda, mutation has not been
carried out in the name of his Legal Heirs and the name of Bhiku S/o
Meda was recorded in 1/10 share against the Khasra No. 1236, land
measuring 01 Bigha, situated in village Nangal Dewat. It is well
established and settled procedure that entries in revenue records
were given priorities over any other entries for the sake that revenue
records are updated and corrected on regular interval of time. Also
revenue record gives more accuracy and gives more valuable data
for the identification of the correct person for the allotment of
alternative plots. In this case, name of Sh. Bhiku S/o Meda was
mentioned in the revenue records and therefore, priority was given
to the name mentioned in the revenue records and therefore, other
holdings related to Sh. Bhiku S/o Meda was rightly clubbed with the
holding/name mentioned in the revenue records. Therefore, joint
allotment to the LR’s of Bhiku S/o Meda is equitable and justified in
the light of above said judgment.
16. On the issue of separate compensation in the award, it is
appropriate to discuss the relevant para fo Hon’ble High Court
order dted 19.02.2013 in LPA No. 429/2007, titled as Nirmala Devi
& Ors. Versus AAI. Para 11 of the judgment read as under:
“We make it quite that if the name of a person appears separately in
the survey report and Naksha Muntazamin but he has not been
separate compensation in the award, in respect of the land
underneath the super-structure raised by him, he shall not be entitled
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
to allotment of an individual alternative plot merely on the strength
of his name appearing in the survey and Naksha Muntazamins.”
I have no hesitation in saying that claimant case falls in the same
situation as his name appears in the survey report in Naksha
Muntazamins but does not figure in the Award. The Claimant has not
been given separate compensation in the award, in respect of the
land underneath the super structure raised by him and hence the
claimant is not entitled for a separate plot of land. However,
claimant argued that Naksha Muntazamin is part and parcel of
Award by the argument is not in consonance with the judgment dated
19.02.2013 given by the Hon’ble High Court. Therefore, the same
cannot be accepted. It is further added that the above said judgment
dated 19.02.2013 is double bench judgement and till date it has not
been challenged. Therefore, as per para 11 of this judgment, the
claimant is not entitled for allotment of individual plot in his name
as his name does not figure in the Award in respect of the land
underneath the super-structure raised by him.”
In the case of Ran Singh, Petitioner in W.P.(C) 3015/2017:
“12. As per the list of 316 persons submitted by Nodal Officer on
16.12.2004, Sh. Ramji Lal has five sons namely Lekhram, Bhagwana,
Puran, Harnath and Rattan and all of them were found in possession of
land measuring 189 sq. yards or 158.03 sq. mtr given at Sr. No. 96.
Even in the list of 308 persons submitted by the Nodal Officer on
25.01.2005, all of them were found jointly in the possession of 158.03
sq. mtr of land and hence they were recommended a joint alternative
plot measuring 160 sq. mtr given at Serial No. 94.
13.
As per list of 308 persons, a joint plot measuring 160 sq. mtr.
was allotted in the name of Lekhram, Bhagwana, Puran, Harnath and
Rattan all sons of Ramji Lal jointly as they were found in possession of
land measuring 189 sq. yards or 158.03 sq. mtr situated in old Lal
Dora. In lieu of this land, an alternative plot measuring 160 sq. mtr was
allotted jointly in the names of Lekhram, Bhagwana, Puran, Harnath
and Rattan all sons of Sh. Ramji Lal. The same is mentioned at Sr. No
94 in the list of 308 persons submitted by the then Nodal Officer before
the Hon’ble High Court on 16.12.2004 and 25.01.2005. All these LR’s
of Sh. Ramji Lal have individual allotment in community land against
Khasra No. 1192/1 in the list of 122 persons from Sr. No. 101 to 105.
The verification team found 596 sq. yards or 498.33 sq. mtr in
possession of these LR’s in these five plots. Therefore, as per criteria
adopted by the committee the holding of old Abadi i.e. 308 list allotment
and holding of community land clubbed together i.e. 189+596=785 sq.
yards or 656.35 sq. mtr. Accordingly, as per categorization list, joint
plot measuring 450 sq. mtr. was recommended in the name of LR’s of
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
Ramji Lal.
That as per list of eligible person Harnath, Lekhram, Puran,
Bhagwana and Rattan were found entitled to a plot against their
holding in the community land as per the order dated 31.05.2007, their
holdings were clubbed with the holdings of LR’s of Ramji lal and a
larger size of plot measuring 450 sq. Meters was allotted to Harnath,
Lekhram, Puran, Bhagwana and Rattan all sons of Late Ramji Lal
against the total holding of 785 sq. yards or 656.35 sq. mtr. Hence in
view of the order dated 31.05.2007 the Nodal Officer rightly clubbed
the land holding of the claimant and jointly recommended a plot in
favour of Harnath, Lekhram, Puran, Bhagwana and Rattan all sons of
Late Ramji Lal. In short all the five sons of Ramji Lal were entitled to
1/5th share in plot measuring 450 sq. meters i.e. 90 sq. meters each.
It is clear from the above mentioned fact that allotment in lieu of
Lal Dora land (189 sq. yards or 158.02 sq. mtr) has already been made
in the year 2004 in favour of LR’s of Ramji Lal and further allotment in
the lieu of community land was made in the year 2007 (596 sq. yards or
498.33 sq. mtr). Therefore, in this case as per policy/guidelines framed
by the committee in its report dated 17.07.2007, which read as under:xxx
xxx
xxx
As per above said guidelines, the later recommendation for alternative
plot shall be clubbed in earlier recommendation and thereafter a single
allotment of bigger size is made after clubbing both the holdings existed
in Lal Dora and community land. The same has been done in this case,
by merging or clubbing the holding of the claimants in Lal Dora land
with the community land i.e. 189+596=785 sq. yards or 656.36 sq. mtr.
and a single plot of larger size measuring 450 sq. mtr. was
recommended in the name of LR’s of the Ramji Lal.
Therefore, claimant request for clubbing of old Lal Dora land in
community land does not make any sense as the same is against the
policy/guideline framed by the committee for allotment of alternative
plot and the same is liable to be turned down.
14.
Now I come to the judgment dated 19.02.2013 in LPA No.
429/2007. The Hon’ble High Court has observed that:
“ We make it quite clear that if the name of a person appears separately
in the survey report and Naksha Muntazamin but he has not been given
separate compensation in the award, in respect of the land underneath
the super structure raised by him, he shall not be eligible to allotment of
an individual alternative plot merely on the strength of his name
appearing in the survey report and Naksha Muntazamin.”
15.
As per criteria adopted by the Hon’ble High Court in above
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
mentioned case, it is also found that the claimant name is not mentioned
separately/individually in the survey report at Sr. No. 1 of Khasra No.
1198 (Old Lal Dora) at page 32. The names are clubbed together with
their respective holding and share i.e. ½ (Half) share is mentioned
against Sh. Lekhram and ½ (half) share is mentioned against Sh.
Puran, Harnath and Rattan all sons of Late Ramji Lal. Even the name
of Sh. Bhagwana is not mentioned in the survey report against Khasra
No. 1198 in old Abadi. Therefore, the claimants are not found eligible
for individual alternative plot as the name of their father/forefather
does not appeared separately against a piece of land measuring 189 sq.
yards in Khasra No. 1198 situated in the old Abadi in village Nangal
Dewat. Sh. Lekhram, Puran, Harnath and Rattan all of them were
found in possession of single plot measuring 189 sq. yards or 158.02 sq.
mtr. in the survey report, it is clear that they do not owned any
individual holding but owned joint holding of size of 189 sq. yards or
158.02 sq. mtr. In lieu of their joint holding measuring 158.02 sq. mtr, a
joint alternative plot of size 160 sq. mtr. was recommended in the name
of LR’s of Sh. Ramji Lal. Therefore, joint allotment of the LR’s of Ramji
Lal is equitable and justified in the light of above said judgment.
16.
The claimants have not been given separate compensation in the
award, in respect of the land underneath the super structure raised by
them and hence as per order dated 19.02.2013, the claimants are not
entitled for a separate alternative plot. Even the compensation for the
structure is not assessed separately in the award and Naksha
Muntazamin for the structures. Claimants names have appeared in the
Naksha Muntazamin, against the compensation of land measuring 189
sq. yards but that too is not in individual capacity. Therefore, merely
appearing some names jointly and some names separately in the survey
report, Naksha Muntazamin and Award does not qualify the claimant
for the allotment of individual alternative plot and hence the claim of
the claimants is liable to be rejected.”
26.
Writ review does not permit recasting that conclusion unless it is
shown to be plainly perverse or reached by ignoring decisive material. Even
on merits, the Petitioners’ case for allotment of individual plots is not made
out. The Petitioners rely on the proposition that possession in “Lal Dora” is
equivalent to ownership and that mutation is not applicable. Even if
possession carries weight in village practice, the scheme did not adopt an
open-ended notion of ownership. It adopted an administrable, record-based
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
approach which uses the survey as a substitute where revenue entries are
absent, but still tests separate allotment claims against the acquisition
compensation framework to avoid duplication and inconsistency. This is not
a title adjudication. It is distribution of a finite benefit under a scheme. The
Court cannot substitute a different model of entitlement while examining the
legality of the Nodal Officer’s decision.
27.
The community land policy, and the 2007 survey exercise, were
introduced to address a different problem. Lands recorded in the name of
communities required a distinct verification method. The committees and
later orders prescribed twin requirements and treated the 1958 list of 122
persons as the outer limit. However, even while opening this window, the
same no-duplication discipline remained central. If a person already featured
in the earlier allotment list, the task was to rework the plot categorisation by
accounting for the community land component, not to allot a second plot.
28.
That is the point where the Petitioners’ demand for a separate plot
runs into difficulty. AAI’s consistent position is that the committee found
the Petitioners eligible for community land, and that eligibility was
implemented by clubbing the community land holding with the existing
landholding unit already recognised in the list of 308 persons. 29.
The
counter affidavits supply the basis for the computation of the area. For
instance, Ishwar Singh was found eligible for 101 sq. yards of community
land. Another legal heir of Bhikhu was also found eligible for 101 sq. yards.
The total holding attached to the already recognised allotment unit rose
materially, and the alternative plot size correspondingly rose from 350 sq.
metres to 450 sq. metres. Likewise, in the case of Ran Singh s/o Lekh Ram,
all the legal representatives of Ramji Lal, including Late Lekh Ram, were
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
found eligible in respect of community land and in possession thereof. In
light of their clubbed holdings aggregating 656.35 sq. metres, and in terms
of the criteria stipulate by AAI, they were allotted of a plot measuring 450
sq. metres. This demonstrates that the scheme benefit arising from
community land eligibility was not denied. It was accounted for in the
manner the scheme contemplates, namely by enhancement of the plot size
within the existing allotment unit.
30.
The recommendation and subsequent allotment of the aforesaid plots
is not in dispute. In these circumstances, the Petitioners’ submission, in
substance, asks for the community land component to be used not only to
revise plot size, but also to rework the earlier allotment unit and to carve out
a separate individual plot. That is not a mere numerical correction. It is a
structural rewriting of the allotment unit itself, after the allotment list had
crystallised and after possession of the 450 sq. metres plot was offered. The
scheme, the committee approach, and the later judicial directions on
avoidance of duplication do not support that form of re-engineering.
31.
AAI’s reliance on Karan Singh also matters from the standpoint of
finality. That judgment records, in clear terms, that the litigation arising
from Village Nangal Dewat has spanned decades and that the process
required a stopping point. It cautions against entertaining belated challenges
to the Nodal Officer’s orders and against reopening claims after the scheme
has progressed through time-bound stages. On AAI’s case, the Petitioner did
not challenge the joint allotment entry at the stage when the list of 308
persons was finalised and acted upon. The present prayer, framed as a
demand for a separate plot, effectively seeks to reopen that joint entry. The
closure principle, on which Karan Singh rests, militates against such
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
reopening in writ jurisdiction unless a clear legal transgression is
demonstrated.
32.
The plea of discrimination also remains unproven. AAI’s answer is
that the comparators cited by the Petitioners are not similarly situated, since
those persons had separate holdings reflected in revenue records through
mutation and were recognised for allotment on that footing. This Court
cannot accept a discrimination argument without a true comparison on the
decisive features identified by the scheme and the binding directions,
namely separate landholding recognition for compensation and allotment
purposes.
33.
Allegations of false statements and mala fides have also been raised.
The question in writ review is whether the impugned decision suffers from
jurisdictional error, manifest arbitrariness, or perversity. The impugned
orders were passed by the authority directed by the order dated 13 th July,
2016. It addresses the Petitioners’ central claim and rejects separate
allotment on grounds the scheme, as applied through later directions,
permits. That suffices to repel interference.
34.
The case, therefore, does indeed centre on separate allotment. On the
record as presented and, on the scheme, logic reinforced by AAI’s counter, a
separate individual alternative plot is not made out. The scheme benefit has
been accounted for by clubbing and by enlargement of the joint allotment to
450 sq. metres. The Petitioners have not established a legal basis to compel
dismantling of the recognised allotment unit into a fresh separate allotment
at this stage.
35.
For these reasons, the Court is not persuaded that the impugned orders
dated 4th January, 2017 suffer from illegality, perversity, or arbitrariness
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
warranting interference under Article 226.
36.
The writ petitions are dismissed. Pending applications, if any, also
stand disposed of.
SANJEEV NARULA, J
FEBRUARY 26, 2026
as
W.P.(C) 2997/2017 & W.P.(C) 3015/2017
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 09/03/2026 at 13:15:11
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review